1975a
The following is a paper jointly authored by H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles and published in Il Nuovo Cimento, v. 30A, pp. 235-238 (1975).
CALCULATION OF THE PROTON MASS IN A LATTICE MODEL FOR THE AETHER
Abstract: A lattice model for the aether is shown to give indications of a fundamental charged particle of mass M such that: M/me is equal to:
a value very close to the observed proton-electron mass ratio of 1836.15152(70).
Commentary: As for reference [1972a], this paper was co-authored with Dr. D. M. Eagles of the then-named National Measurement Laboratory in Sydney, Australia. The author had, by reference [1974a], reported an advance which had substituted a dimuon mass quantum for the pion in a correlation function involving the proton, the latter being in the author’s 1969 book ‘Physics without Einstein’. This led to discussion with Dr. Eagles and the appreciation that the muon might be the standard building block from which protons are formed. Dr. Eagles took the initiative of writing the paper, again including the emotive word ‘aether’ in the title and again securing support from his Laboratory Director for its submission to a reputable scientific journal. Il Nuovo Cimento is published by the Italian Institute of Physics. It was 10 years later, in 1985, that Van Dyck, Moore, Farnham and Schwinberg, reporting on their measurement of the proton-electron mass ratio in the International Journal of Mass Spectroscopy and Ion Processes, vol. 66, pp. 327-337 (1985), had occasion to refer to our paper, using the words:
“Finally, as a point of interest, Aspden and Eagles have computed a theoretical value (1836.152320) for this mass ratio by apparent classical arguments. The value that they calculate is remarkably close to our experimentally measured value (i.e. within two standard deviations) This is even more curious when one notes that they published this result several years before direct precision measurements of this ratio had begun.”
To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1975a]
Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)
Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.
[p. 235]
IL NUOVO CIMENTO Vol. 30 A, N. 2 21 Novembre 1975
Calculation of the Proton Mass in a Lattice Model for the Aether.
European Patent Operations, I.B.M. United Kingdom Limited
Hursley Laboratories – Winchester
CSIRO National Measurement Laboratory – Sydney
(ricevuto il 24 Febbraio 1975; manoscritto revisionato ricevuto il 3 Settembre 1975)
Summary. — A lattice model for the aether is shown to give indications of a fundamental charged particle of mass M such that M/me = (3/4)(108)3π2(1843)−4/3[(3/2)1/2 − 1]−1 = 1836.152 32, a value very close to the observed proton-electron mass ratio of 1836.151 52(70).
A model for the aether involving a simple cubic lattice structure of negatively charged particles embedded in a continuum of positive charge has been shown by Aspden (1) to be capable of giving alternative explanations of many of the experimental supports for relativity theory (*), and to permit calculations of some of the fundamental constants of physics which are treated as empirical parameters in more conventional approaches. Recently a slight development of part of Aspden’s original work was shown to permit an exact formula to be obtained for the calculation of the fine-structure constant (2) α. It was found that
α−1 = 108π(8/1843)1/6 = 137.035 915 .(1)
(1) H. Aspden: Physics without Einstein (Southampton, 1969).
(*) Relativity has good support experimentally from the increased lifetimes of fast-moving mesons which give direct evidence of time dilation. A nonrelativistic explanation based upon the aether concept has yet to be developed but may perhaps be found in the contraction of electric charge in storing energy due to increase in speed.
(2) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Phys. Lett., 41 A, 423 (1972).
[p. 236]
This value lies within 0.9 p.p.m. of the latest estimate from experimental results (3). In the present paper we give arguments to indicate how a particle of mass equal to that of the proton can appear in the lattice aether theory, and we find a precise expression for the ratio of the mass of this particle to that of the electron.
The aether lattice shares the motion and rotation of the Earth locally, and also moves in such a way that each lattice point rotates in a small circle of radius r = ħ/2mec = 1.93·10−11 cm about its position of equilibrium at an angular speed Ω = c/2r = 7.76·1020 s−1. The ratio of r to the lattice constant d satisfies (1,2)
r/d = (3/2)(a/2b)1/2 = 0.302 916 ,(2)
where
a/b = (1843)−1/3(3)
is the ratio of the radii a and b of the electron and lattice particle respectively, with (1,4)
a = (2/3)e2/mec2 ≈ 1.88·10−13 cm .(4)
The ratio of the lattice constant to the electron radius is given by (1)
d/a = 108π .(5)
A fruitful postulate in ref. (1) was that creation of matter is likely to be concerned with changes in lattice cells near boundaries between normal regions of the lattice aether and regions in which the signs of the charges of lattice particles and the continuum are reversed. Such a reversal was assumed to occur in the interiors of stars. The creation is envisaged as proceeding from the lighter to the heavier particles. If we suppose that as a first stage a number of lattice particles and a corresponding number of cells of the continuum mutually annihilate, and that the equivalent volume is replaced by an appropriate number of positively or negatively charged particles of the same type as those forming the lattice, then an energy quantum Q0 associated with the number of these particles per lattice cell will be given by (*)
Q0 = (2/3)(e2/b)(3d3)(4πb3)−1 .(6)
(3) E. R. Cohen and B. N. Taylor: J. Phys. Chem. Reference Data, 2, 663 (1973).
(4) M. Born: Einstein’s Theory of Relativity (New York, N. Y., 1965), p. 211.
(*) An alternative way of viewing the quantum Q0 is to regard it as equal to the energy contained within two lattice cells (one of each polarity) associated with the pressure of magnitude P = e2/4πb4 required to keep lattice particles from disintegrating. Reasons are given in ref. (1) for thinking that such a pressure pervades all space.
[p. 237]
From eqs. (3) to (6) we find that Q0/mec2 = 412.665 816. This quantum does not appear to have been observed in experiments performed to date, but it may be of significance that (1/2)[Q0/mec2 + 1] = 206.8 is close to the muon-electron mass ratio.
In order to progress from this quantum to the mass of the proton we need to make the postulate that for calculations of the ground-state energy of elementary particles and of some composites it is not appropriate to use quantum theory, and that a classical consideration of spheres with charges ± e in contact is a valid approach. The relation between the masses and radii of the particles concerned is assumed to be similar to that given by eq. (4) for the electron. Then, if positive- and negative-charged particles associated with energy quanta P and Q are allowed to come into contact with each other, it is easy to show that the energy E of the composite system satisfies
E = P + Q − (3/2)PQ/(P + Q) .(7)
Minimizing this energy with respect to Q we find that
Q/P = (3/2)1/2 − 1 .(8)
Thus it appears plausible that, if heavy particles of mass P/c2 form one of the main types of building block for matter, then the environment will be such as to involve energy quanta Q given by eq. (8); but we have already indicated how quanta of energy Q0 given by eqs. (3) to (6) are associated with matter creation in the lattice aether theory. Hence, identifying Q and Q0, we calculate that
P/mec2 = (3/4)(108)3π2(1843)−4/3[(3/2)1/2 − 1]−1 = 1836.152 32 .(9)
A recent reassessment of experimental data (3) gives the proton-electron mass ratio as 1836.151 52(70). Thus, although there is no a priori reason for the identification of Q rather than, e.g., P with Q0, the numerical result which follows from such an identification is persuasive.
The present note and ref. (2) have demonstrated that lattice aether theory can be used to find expressions that give close agreement with experiment for two very accurately determined fundamental constants of physics. The agreement with the most probable experimental value is to within 0.91 p.p.m. for the fine-structure constant and within 0.44 p.p.m. for the proton-electron mass ratio. Thus the calculated values lie only just outside the estimated standard deviation errors of 0.82 p.p.m. and 0.38 p.p.m. given for the two experimental figures (3). An extension of the ideas presented in ref. (1,2) and the present note can be used to give an exact expression for the gravitational [p. 238] constant G in terms of the charge-mass ratio of the electron. Agreement with a recent experimental value (5) is obtained. The constant G is only known to an uncertainty of about 90 p.p.m., so this agreement does not provide a very strict test of the significance of the model on its own. However, in combination with the two accurate results for the fine-structure constant and for mp/me, it provides additional support for thinking that the lattice aether model merits thorough study and further development. Details about the calculation of G have been published recently (6).
(5) C. Pontikis: Compt. Rend., 274, B 437 (1972).
(6) H. Aspden: Gravitation (Southampton, 1975).
● RIASSUNTO (*)
Si mostra che un modello reticolare dell’etere dà indicazioni di una particella fondamentale carica di massa M tale che M/me = (3/4)(108)2π2(1843)−3/4[(3/2)1/2 − 1]−1 = 1836.152 32, un valore molto prossimo al rapporto osservato fra la massa del protone e quella dell’elettrone che è 1836.151 52(70).
(*) Traduzione a cura della Redazione.
Резюме не получено.
H. Aspden, et al.
21 Novembre 1975
Il Nuovo Cimento
Serie 11, Vol. 30 A, pag. 235-238
