Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Papers & Publications

Peer-reviewed papers and publications by Harold Aspden

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • ARP 1 (2004): Energy Science — A Brief Review and a Conclusion


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    ENERGY SCIENCE: A BRIEF REVIEW AND A CONCLUSION

    © H. Aspden, 2004

    Introduction

    Exploring the scope for tapping energy from a new and non-conventional source is a research pursuit of a few worthy individuals, very few, in comparison with the many, very many, highly qualified scientists who work in the power industry. We need that new source of energy because our oil and gas reserves are being rapidly depleted, because reverting to burning coal, which also cannot last for ever, creates pollution and because nuclear power involves other dangers.

    In a perfect world we would have come to understand how what we see around us was created, meaning finding the answer to the question: “Where did the energy needed come from?” and then discovering how we can harness that mystery energy resource. Understanding Creation is not just an act of faith based on religious doctrine, nor can we rely 100% on the doctrinaire principles of science of modern physics. Something else is needed. Fortunately, there is now enough evidence of record to justify enquiry which probes into the secret world of energy science.

    What follows is a brief review, a summary, of my own efforts in recent years, followed by a culminating conclusion which may inspire others to undertake further work of their own. If future generations are to survive by relying on power from windmills, then let us just hope that there are those who, in the spirit of Don Quixote, find the energy needed to meet the challenge.

    Concerning Nuclear Energy

    Our ability to harness atomic power, a by-product of atomic weapon research, does not mean, as most physicists accept, that the heat generated within the sun and which, by its radiation, keeps the Earth warm is the product of a nuclear reaction at the sun’s centre. Gravitation pulls the sun’s hydrogen atoms so close together that their electrons collide and cause ionization. Protons are freed along with electrons. Then, because two protons interact gravitationally to set up an acceleration rate that is 1836 times that applicable between two electrons, the ionized plasma we see as the body of our sun contains more protons than electrons, leaving a surplus of electrons at its boundary surface. There is therefore a balance of gravitational compression pressure and electrostatic expansion pressure throughout the body of the sun, meaning it has a uniform mass density, and there is no reason to think that its temperature at its centre is any different from that at its surface. Its core temperature is not sufficient to account for nuclear reaction. Instead, the quantum interplay between the hydrogen atom and the underworld medium that fills all space sustains the atom’s electron motion, thereby having supplied the energy needed to ionize when gravity brings hydrogen atoms into collision, but duly replenishing energy that might be lost by radiation, once free electrons are captured by free protons to restore the atomic hydrogen form.

    [p. 2]

    The quantum underworld, the space medium, the aether is the energy source, not nuclear power! We are therefore being misled. It is one thing to build more and more nuclear power plants to meet future needs but quite another to do so thinking that we are merely replicating Nature’s processes at work in the sun and so be blind as to the true source of energy.

    Indeed, one might say that it is the energy of the quantum underworld that, in sustaining the sun’s energy radiation, controls the weather on Earth and so empowers those windmills that provide the alternative to nuclear power. On such a foundation one must see sense in looking for ways to tap energy directly from that all-pervading quantum underworld energy source, confident that it must be possible. Then, guided by certain reports of historical record, there is a path to follow, but it is not an easy path as there are sidetracks than can lead nowhere and so frustrate one’s efforts.

    The Governing Rules

    There are two governing rules or ‘principles’ that dominate energy science. One is the Principle of Conservation of Energy and the other is the Principle that Action and Reaction are equal and opposite. Teachers of physics expect us to accept these without question, as they form the bedrock on which they build, sure in the knowledge that experience over time has proved their validity.

    Yet when they discuss energy deployment as it applies to the real world of technology they do not even contemplate the quantum underworld of space and ask whether energy balance and so its conservation can include the latter. Energy conservation does not mean that we cannot transfer energy from that quantum underworld and bring it into the apparatus of our real world. The notions of the high energy particle physicist concerning the interplay between electron-positron creation and decay and photons do imply energy conservation as between matter and the space medium but, for some mysterious reason, such physicists are not open minded when it comes to tapping energy from that vacuum medium.

    As to the action and reaction theme, this happens to be enshrined in Newton’s Third Law of Motion and so is taken as beyond question, but yet physics is taught also by reference to the Lorentz force law which, as applied generally between two electrons in motion, breaches Newton’s Third Law, unless the force acting on one of those electrons is calculated as the average force on the basis of the other electron describing a closed circuital path.

    So, you see, when it comes to convincing those who govern opinion on what is possible and what is not possible there is uncharted energy territory to be explored in an effort to tap energy from space, but yet we confront unwarranted hostility and ridicule for aiming at the impossible.

    My Research

    My Ph.D. research addressed the problem of anomalous excess energy loss in the magnetization processes at work in transformer cores. That was back in the years 1950-1953 and I was destined to pursue a professional career peripheral to the research field, one concerned with evaluating and protecting inventions stemming from research in the electrical power industry and electronics. However, as early as 1956, I privately researched a few theoretical ideas of my own, one being an attempt to understand how energy is stored in the vacuum medium. I concluded that the medium reacts to the presence of a magnetic

    [p. 3]

    field as if it is the seat of electric charge in motion that can act in opposition to the applied field. Energy criteria, meaning maximum amount of energy transferred to the medium, indicated that the reaction would be one that is exactly half the strength of the applied field. I saw this as resolving an anomaly in physics, one which had mistakenly given birth to the notion of so-called ‘spin’, the half-quantum state that supposedly explained the primary factor-of-two implicit in what is known as the gyromagnetic ratio.

    This was theoretical physics. It caused me to see the need to understand how the aether was structured, taking account of all the problems that had beset belief in the aether and caused its demise from the physics curriculum and its replacement by Einstein’s notion of space-time. Apart from my onward theory leading to an insight into the cause of gravity and how protons are created an early conclusion was that the creation of an electric field radially directed from an axis would induce aether spin about that axis. The energy inflow from the aether needed to account for that state of spin was found to equal the energy supplied in creating that electric field.

    This all being a theoretical and not a technological interest, I soon found that I could explain how stars are created and why they spin, apparently in breach of the physicist’s rule that angular momentum must be conserved. To say a star spins poses the question of how it acquires its angular momentum, but that was answered by my theory as all I had to explain is how the star acquires the electric core charge within a balancing surface charge, and the explanation of that is presented above under that heading ‘Concerning Nuclear Energy’. The aether provides the angular momentum, it having a vast store of angular momentum by virtue of its quantum activity in the form of its electric charge having a jitter motion, the basis of Heisenberg’s Zitter-bewegung and so his Principle of Uncertainty.

    When I did, after some 30 years in industry, move to a ‘retirement’ position for 9 years as a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the university local to my home town, my research was aimed at advancing my theory rather than efforts to tap energy from the aether. Interest in the latter theme was aroused, however, during the latter part of that 9-year period and has prevailed ever since.

    I became involved with motor experiments based on rotating an electrically conductive rotor magnetized parallel to the axis of rotation, this involving induction of an electric field radially directed with respect to the axis of spin. The object, by analogy with the action that imports energy and angular momentum from the aether when a star is formed, was to see if the motor behaved anomalously. The experiments proved positive and confirmed the speculation involved, but were not extended, there being an impractical feature in that, to import energy steadily from the quantum underworld, the action had to be pulsed. To have a pulsating magnetic field acting through the plane of a conductive rotor disc implies eddy current loss and limits possible speed of operation. That meant that there was little, if any, scope for any practical application leading to technology that could serve as a future power source. Other ideas involving motors did emerge but proved equally disappointing. Accordingly, it seemed best to switch interest to devices that are essentially solid-state and static in operation.

    Then the day came when, after pondering over the reports of the findings of Dr. Henry Moray back in the 1930 period said to tap energy from the atmosphere by the use of an overhead wire connection to a capacitor apparatus as well as the information concerning the modern day Methernitha apparatus, which incorporates large capacitors in the form of Leyden jars, I concluded that here were devices that set up a pulsating radially

    [p. 4]

    directed electric field and import energy by aether spin. I saw this as analogous to my efforts on motors and my interpretation of how a star develops its state of spin. That was in the early months of 2002 and it seemed an appropriate topic to address as an invited speaker at a conference held in Berlin in June of that year. Not having verified operability but yet being about to disclose this at that conference, I deemed it prudent to file a patent application in U.K. before speaking at that event and so my Patent Application GB 2390941A was duly filed and then eventually published on 21st January, 2004.

    Not surprisingly, this has raised questions by those who saw this printed publication almost immediately after it appeared and so I submitted an article on the subject which has appeared in at pp. 19-25 of Issue 55, v. 10, 2004 of ‘Infinite Energy’. Meanwhile experimental work has been undertaken and the bad news is that there is no energy excess developed, at least on a practical scale which needs the apparatus to operate at high voltage of the order of 10 kV and fairly high frequency of the order of 100 kHz.

    This means that the angular momentum of the aether spin developed by successive pulsations, at a frequency far exceeding the pulsation rate of a hundred cycles per second as used in my motor research, cannot slow down and convert its spin energy into electrical form fast enough to be captured as output upon capacitor discharge and so deliver useful power output.

    Hence that capacitor theme is not the answer to the riddle posed by the Moray and Methernitha route to generation of what has come to be known as ‘free energy’.

    The Conclusion

    This brings my efforts to a conclusion, but a conclusion that still offers hope. Being forced to look once again at the common factors evident in the Moray and Methernitha projects there is the possibility that what Dr. Moray meant by the reference to his dependence upon the availability of Swedish stone implies magnetically polarized magnetite, otherwise known as lodestone. The Methernitha apparatus used horsehoe magnets and had coils of wire conductor wound around the legs of the horseshoe form. Moray could have had coils wrapped around a lodestone core. Then there is what has been reported concerning the findings of Hans Coler in Germany in the years preceding and during World War II.. Coler had coils wrapped around bar magnets and generated electrical power output with no other input power connections.

    So, in asking myself how it can make sense to take a material already magnetized and then pulse it magnetically by developing electric current oscillations in an enveloping winding, I was surprised to find that I was led to ask myself another question. We know that oscillating current in a solenoid enclosing a magnetic core will produce an oscillating magnetic flux over the whole cross-section of the core. A back EMF is produced which means that we feed energy into the solenoid as current strength increases and a forward EMF is induced which returns that energy as current strength decreases. This is the phenomenon of inductance.

    Now, within that core, it having ferromagnetic properties, there are atoms containing electrons in orbit, the 3d-state electrons in iron, for example, and as these turn to augment the magnetic flux when the solenoid current increases so whatever it is that powers the motion of those electrons will also experience a back EMF and so involve inflow of energy. Then, of course, one might expect as the current subsides so there will be a return of energy to those 3d-state electrons in their orbital motion. That makes sense

    [p. 5]

    and is a natural assumption once that aspect of the magnetization process is considered. However, here now is that other question.

    How does the energy shed by the 3d-state electrons and stored pending its return force its way back by passage through the limited area of those electron orbits? EMFs are induced as a function of flux linkage by the current loops involved. Yes, I certainly knew how the magnetic field energy is stored. That is the basis of aether charge reaction theme by which I explained that gyromagnetic ratio factor-of-2. But here one has a reacting field system that is uniform across the area of the magnetic core. Logically, therefore, since only a fraction of that area is accounted for by the 3d-state electron orbits, two per atom for iron, then only of fraction of energy shed by the quantum underworld that powers the electron motion can be returned to that medium as the magnetic field subsides in strength. This has to be the case unless one is to accept the belief that there is no field reaction such as I suggested years ago and that instead there are merely lines of magnetic flux having a physical reality that somehow store energy. Such flux lines would need to be rigid in their spatial fixation in relation to the source current orbits with the degree of their numerical concentration being a measure of the energy density involved. To me, lines of magnetic flux are merely notional, a way of portraying how energy in a magnetic field spreads itself in surrounding space but not of themselves having any real physical form.

    So you can see how I am led to believe that a magnet might be caused to shed energy drawn from the quantum underworld of space and have no direct way for its atoms to recapture that energy. Here I am treading more familiar ground, three years of experimental Ph.D. research being concerned with magnetic hysteresis loss and associated eddy current loss.

    Once I had this idea of a magnetic core shedding energy that it could not recover, I asked myself what we really know about the process producing hysteresis loss. In my Ph.D. years it was something one could dismiss as being due to sudden erratic movements of magnetic domain walls as inclusions are encountered by those walls as the domains they bound grow and shrink with reorientation of magnetic direction in the ferromagnetic crystals involved. Hysteresis loss was accepted as a fact, an unavoidable phenomenon that one finds in magnetic cores, though one that is of less importance in well annealed cores of high purity that have a high magnetic permeability property. My research concerned measurement of loss aimed at studying how it changed under different conditions, including internal mechanical stress as well as stress applied externally as well, of course, with variation in frequency and superimposed states of magnetic polarization.

    With this new thought in mind, I enquired into the energy process involved in a cycle of magnetization around the whole of an imaginary truly-rectangular form of B-H loop, a close approximation to the actual form applicable to closed magnetic cores having no air gaps. The magnetizing solenoid inputs energy in proportion to HB, because H is a measure the current in the solenoid and the rate of change of B is a measure of the back EMF resisting current flow. That applies to the right-hand side of the loop. The left-hand side represents further input from the solenoid in proportion to (-H)(-B) and because this equals BH, the overall energy input from the solenoid is 2BH. With B in gauss and H in oersteds this, divided by 8π, is a measure of hysteresis loss measured in ergs per cc. per cycle. The top side represents outflow of energy because, ignoring the small H component of B, B is effectively the notional current action of the 3d-state electron orbits in the core, and the rate of change of H, which is negative, is the effective flux density change that accounts for an induced EMF. So, in theory, for 100% flux coupling with those orbits, the

    [p. 6]

    quantity B(-H) is the measure of energy change involved, suggesting that the energy BH fed in during loop passage up the right-hand side and also along the top side is transferred as input to the quantum underworld of space. Similarly the energy represented by (-B)H applies to energy transfer along the bottom line of the loop, meaning it drains away the energy supplied during the left-hand side downward step.

    All this amounts to the whole loss defined by the area of the hysteresis loop being supplied by the solenoid and fed into the quantum underworld of space, the very reverse of what we aim to achieve. However, though experiment confirms that loss, we know that it does, at least for its major part, stay with us in the real world by appearing as heat in the core. So here then is the proof that, as atomic theory tells us anyway, those 3d-state electron orbits are too small to capture the full measure of energy shed by the magnetization process.

    Now the symmetrical B-H loop is characteristic of a ferromagnetic core that is not polarized as one finds in magnets. Once a certain H value is reached by increasing magnetizing current the domain wall movement that accounts for the width of the hysteresis loop, the so-called coercive force, no longer occurs and any onward magnetization arises from those 3d-state electron orbits turning towards the direction of magnetization, virtually a loss-free process apart from eddy current effects. This takes us to a roughly linear range of magnetization where B and H increase or decrease in proportion. Over this range increase of B involves energy input from the solenoid proportional to HδB, where δB is the change of B over that range. However, here we now also have energy input from the quantum underworld in measure given by BδH, where δH is the change of H over that same range. Given that B is proportional to H over this range these energy quantities are equal. So we expect the inflow of energy from the quantum underworld to match that supplied via the solenoid.

    Furthermore, during the downward half of a cycle of magnetization over that limited range although energy is returned to the solenoid as expected owing to the inductance property, most of that energy tapped from space cannot, from the evidence we have of hysteresis loss phenomena, go back into the quantum underworld. Here then we see a glimmer of a possibility in our search for a free energy source. Either that energy is shed as heat or it is amenable to capture in its electrical form.

    So now consider why it is that it has eluded notice in laboratory experiments in university laboratories. Where is the evidence of tests on the rapid oscillatory excitation of a ferromagnetic core over a range above the territory of hysteresis loss, that being at a flux density level in the region of 70% of saturation? No one would undertake such an experiment ever expecting to gain energy especially as the obvious expectation is increased loss of energy.

    However, the Cambridge professor who was head of the Department of Electrical Engineering during my Ph.D. years at Cambridge did report an experiment magnetizing an iron core including a variable air gap which purported to measure leakage inductance as a function of the gap width. What his experiment proved was that as the gap width increased, for a given level of magnetic flux linking the magnetizing winding, it needed less current than expected to sustain that level of flux. In other words, either there was flux leakage, meaning flux that somehow avoided the gap, as the professor assumed, or there was more magnetic energy fed into the air gap than was supplied by the magnetizing winding. When I eventually did repeat the experiment under conditions which assured flux passage around the whole core, including air gap, I proved that the latter interpretation was

    [p. 7]

    correct. The experimental data I proved that the energy in a gap of 2.25 mm width in a small 100 VA transformer core is as much as 180% of the input energy, which is supporting proof for what is suggested above. This experiment is described under the heading ‘Mystery Energy Source: The Energy Balance Sheet’ in my Energy Science Report No. 1 of record on the web site www.aspden.org where I then examined the prospect of generating ‘free energy’ based on motor technology which exploits the excess energy fed into magnetic pole gaps by reference to the Adams motor.

    You see, here I was thinking that to tap that excess energy, the ‘free energy’ supplied by the aether, we would need to harness motor technology, whereas, now that I realise that the extra inductance energy cannot all by drawn back into the aether as the current drops, a new horizon appears. Solid-state aether power generation now becomes a possibility, shedding light helpful in our onward energy quest. Ferromagnetism becomes the doorway for energy inflow.

    Moray’s experiments seem to have been motivated by attempts to tap energy from the atmospheric electric field, inspired perhaps by Tesla’s pioneer efforts, whereas Coler might have been dabbling with efforts to sense radio signals based on coils wound around a bar magnet as an antenna and the Methernitha experiments may well have arisen from hearsay about the prior claims of both Moray and Coler. All three incorporated capacitors and certainly two, if not also Moray’s apparatus, had provision for two magnet systems to operate in a push-pull fashion with one generating power it its forward current half-cycle as the other resets in its reverse current half cycle. All three had some means for triggering the active state, be it Moray’s aerial wire, the Wimshurst machine of the Methernitha project, or, as in the case of Coler, patience in an environment active in long wave radiation, patience being needed to get the tuning right at an appropriate time of transmission, given that his coil-wound magnets were, in effect, antennae and his apparatus was known to operate at a frequency above 100 kHz. These signal triggering components could not have been the real energy source powering the apparatus once it had become operative.

    Now, reverting to that B-H loop theme, with permanent magnet cores in mind, the cycle of magnetization has to centre about the working point at which BH is a maximum in the upper left-hand sector of the loop. Small field oscillations of H about this point will produce variation of B and H around a thin minor hysteresis loop angled upwards from left to right and corresponding to a substantial increase of B for a small increase of H but with a very substantial base value of B. From the above discussion of energy deployment in cores that are ferromagnetic but not magnets operated over that linear range of magnetism at the B-H loop extremity one can then see how such a situation for a magnet implies the energy inflow from the quantum underworld of space. The hysteresis loss would be quite low in relation to the power gain.

    Such, therefore, is my verdict, my final verdict, I expect, as to how I believe the three free energy devices under discussion function. Knowing where and how the inflow energy enters the apparatus then leaves open the question as to how to extract that energy as useful electrical power output, followed by the key question as to how the process can be scaled up to prove viable as a major commercial power source.

    The latter question is not too difficult to answer, bearing in mind that on a large scale magnets as such are not essential as one can replicate the effects by polarizing large iron cores using superconductive excitation coils that absorb little energy. Operation at kHz frequencies may be needed and this involves eddy-current losses but the flux density

    [p. 8]

    range of oscillation can be commensurately small to contain that to the normal level of loss in laminated steel cores we see in power transformers.

    The former question is the challenge and Coler’s apparatus affords guidance as to the coil connections required, though I feel sure his provision for current in the coils flowing also through the body of the bar magnets used is not necessary.

    A Final Note

    I have decided to publish this at this time because I am obliged to record that the capacitor experiments have proved abortive. I expect now to abandon the patent application mentioned in my article on that subject in ‘Infinite Energy’. Furthermore, I shall not be filing a patent application covering what I have disclosed here concerning magnetic cores as a new source of power, bearing in mind the relevance of the disclosure concerning Coler’s apparatus that became public when Official Secrecy on the related British Intelligence Report ended.

    Whether or not my onward efforts, including experiments on the subject of this Note, will bear fruit remains to be seen, but I can say that, from now on, I am concentrating on revising and consolidating my position on ‘The Physics of Creation’ that features prominently on this web site www.aspden.org .

    For detailed information on the Coler Report just referenced see Lecture No. 7 in the Energy Science sector of this web site.

    H. Aspden

  • ARP 2 (2004): The Foo Fighter Mystery


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    THE FOO FIGHTER MYSTERY

    © H. Aspden, 2004

    Introduction

    On May 18th 2004 THE TIMES newspaper published in U.K. included in its Weather section an intriguing commentary entitled ‘Weather Eye’ by Paul Simons. It began by noting:

    “The Mexican Air Force disclosed last week that one of its planes had seen a swarm of bright lights hovering and darting around it. The lights remain a mystery, but UFO enthusiasts claimed that they were extraterrestrial.”

    Paul Simons then explained how this reminded him of strange lights seen towards the end of the Second World War, when many pilots reported seeing balls of light chasing their aircraft during flights in Europe and over the Pacific. He then noted that the lights, which were also reported by German pilots, were nicknamed “foo fighters” and looked like small balls of fire, usually orange, sometimes translucent. He ended with the words:

    “The foo fighters are a mystery to this day. There is still no technology in the world that can perform their spectacular feats, and if the lights were a natural electrical phenomenon, such as ball lightning, it is difficult to explain why they were seen in all weathers.”

    When I read this I recalled that in 1983 a paper of mine entitled ‘The Thunderball – an Electrostatic Phenomenon’ was published here in U.K. by the Institute of Physics. It appears at pp. 179-184 in their Conference Series No. 66 record of a conference held in Oxford.

    Until reading that account a few days ago I had never before heard of that “foo fighter” nickname or understood that the phenomenon was so prevalent. I was aware of an account by Professor R. C. Jennison, himself having been a fighter pilot in the Second World War, who told me that in more recent years as a passenger on a commercial flight homeward bound for England he had an encounter with a thunderball within an aircraft. He said that there were very few passengers in the cabin and he was sitting well back and in an aisle seat. To his surprise a young stewardess looking distressed suddenly came rushing aft towards him. She threw herself over him to get into a window seat and then he saw the reason for her concern. A glowing spherical object was floating along the aisle moving towards the rear of the plane. He did not move and it floated past him and vanished through a closed door at the rear. Professor Jennison’s speciality, being electronics and the physics of electromagnetic wave propagation, led him then to say that he wished he had had the foresight to look away from that glowing object to see if he could sense its presence visually, a possibility he thought, if it was emitting radiation other than that of its optical glow.

    [p. 2]

    The Mystery Explained

    The point I made in my paper concerning the thunderball is that the phenomenon is the result of setting up an electric field directed radially to or from a central axis. Lightning is not the essential trigger that creates the quasi-stable state of spin which consolidates into spherical form and glows until the energy stored in its field spin is dissipated. My paper delves into the quantitative aspects of the physics involved and shows how the theory predicts the energy density levels which have been established from the available observational data. The spheres of field spin created can be portrayed as spheres of uniform electric charge density of one polarity with a compensating electric charge of opposite polarity sitting at the boundary surface of sphere. This accounts for the energy content, it being that of the field of the displaced charge.

    The theory is then supported by an associated energy state arising from its spin as the sphere rotates about an axis through its centre and such theory involves a coupling with the quantum jitter of the underlying field medium. This is governed by a synchronization factor effective between the spin quanta within the charge sphere and those of the quantum underworld of enveloping space.

    Such theory is a matter of record elsewhere, not only in the above referenced conference paper but in books and in many published papers. See this author’s web site www.aspden.org. However, a point that is rather obvious from what has just been described, is the fact that such a sphere, electrically-neutral overall, but rotating about its axis, will produce a magnetic field directed along that axis. So, you see, we are considering here a phenomenon of energy contained by a spherical form which, as mere electric field displacement, can float in space but yet, owing to its magnetization, be subject to the influence of magnetic fields. Note that ‘mere electric displacement’ is something we can achieve within the vacuum, as by storing energy in a capacitor formed by two plate electrodes spaced apart in vacuo.

    As to whether a thunderball may have a magnetic field, just take note that history records that thunderballs floating in the vicinity of gun barrels have been seen to be attracted to them, presumably because the iron gun barrel has itself acquired some magnetism, but otherwise because, as we well know, magnets that come into close proximity with iron are pulled in by the induced field.

    Why, you may ask, is the thunderball the product of a lightning discharge? Well, we know that lightning arises from atmospheric electricity, clouds acquiring electric charge and then their sudden discharge. This produces ionization of air along the discharge track, meaning that the air molecules shed electrons. The electric current of the lightning discharge is therefore carried by those electrons and, as is well-known in electrical engineering theory, a sudden very high current discharge produces a ‘pinch’ effect. The electrons are pulled together, being drawn radially towards the axis of the discharge. This, therefore, establishes a radial electric field between the inner electron population and the outer positive ion population. This sets up the field spin state mentioned above, which persists after the lightning discharge has subsided, and what results can be a consolidation into spherical form bearing in mind the magnetic attraction as between the field spins created along the length of the discharge path.

    Now, concerning the question of the “foo fighters” and why, if they are the same phenomenon as the thunderball, they appear without the presence of a thunderstorm, just consider a fighter aircraft as it changes altitude at very high speed in its manoeuvres in an atmosphere we know is charged with electricity. The Earth has a vertical electric field, as

    [p. 3]

    if it is negatively charged, that is measured in hundreds of volts per metre. It is not enough for us to harness for electric power generating purposes but it is enough, subject to fluctuations, changing sunlight and cloud movement, to set the stage for a thunderstorm or, should a fighter plane make a sudden change of altitude cause its metal skin to acquire an electric charge of one or other polarity.

    Then, taking account of the fact that the aircraft fuselage is somewhat cylindrical in shape, one can see that here we have a longitudinal axis with an external electric field directed radially from that axis. This is a recipe for setting up field spin in the underlying vacuum medium, the medium through which the plane is travelling at high speed. This means that a trail of field spin is created behind the aircraft and there is then the possibility of that magnetic field attraction consolidating that field-spin into spherical forms which glow in shedding the energy acquired. Such spheres might then be held captive by the magnetic field set up by the field spin that envelopes the fuselage and so be seen as “foo fighters”.

    Such, at least, is my explanation of the “foo fighter” mystery that puzzles Paul Simons.

    A Concluding Note

    As to the thunderball that was witnessed by Professor Jennison inside an aircraft, that could have been produced by a lightning discharge well ahead of the aircraft and flown into so as to enter the body of the fuselage. Just as thunderballs can pass through solid objects, they being aethereal-like objects characterized by energy and a state of field spin, so they could well find their way into a passenger compartment.

    A more important note on which to conclude is the need for concern as to the attitude of the physics community, given that such a mystery has been left unanswered. There are indeed many mysteries that need to be addressed by today’s physicists, mysteries that pertain to the reality of Nature here and now on body Earth. They should take precedence over highly expensive experimental pursuits that supposedly delve into the mysteries such as “Is there life on Mars?”, “How long ago was the Big Bang, assuming there was a Big Bang?” and “What happens if two protons are caused to collide at an ultra-high level of energy?”

    At least, there is enormous scope for exploration of alternative ideas concerning basic physics, rather than merely building block by block on an existing framework without a care as to whether or not it might collapse owing to having relied on the wrong assumptions. The aether is pushed aside by Einstein’s theory, but yet whatever there is in space devoid of matter can somehow store energy, electric and magnetic field energy. Physicists think that electromagnetic wave energy is conveyed by photons moving like bullets at the speed of light but still use wave theory to explain optical interference phenomena and wave theory demands an aether.

    When they did believe in the aether in the 19th century, physicists did not know how to escape from their dilemma, that of the aether seeming to be a solid for some reasons but yet a fluid for other reasons. You would think they would re-evaluate their position, once the properties we associate with fluid crystals became better known. Another example is their belief that the Sun owes its energy radiation to a nuclear fusion reaction occurring at its centre where they believe the temperature exceeds 100,000,000 degrees Celsius. Yet any student of physics who has been introduced to Bohr’s theory of the hydrogen atom can work out that when hydrogen atoms come as close as they need to to account for the mass

    [p. 4]

    density of the Sun, the electrons of adjacent atoms collide. This produces ionization, meaning that some protons become free, which in turns means that enough protons will be pulled by gravity to set up a positive charge in the body of the Sun of just such an amount as to cancel further compression under gravity. There can then be no inner temperature that can promote nuclear fusion. Ionized atomic hydrogen at about 6,000 degrees Celsius will prevail throughout the body of the Sun.

    The key factor governing what has just been said is our knowledge that, by the law of gravity, the mutual rate of gravitational acceleration of free protons is 1836 times greater than that which applies between free electrons. In spite of the mixture of positive and negative charges in the Sun’s ionized plasma, the higher mass of the proton by a factor of 1836 compared with electron mass results in an equilibrium state in which statistically there are more protons within the body and core of the Sun than there are electrons. The electron deficit is made up by an excess of electrons in the Sun’s surface regions.

    So, if we rule out nuclear fusion, how does the Sun get its energy input to sustain its radiation? Well, surely, that same physics student might reason that the electrons that are recaptured by the protons will adopt the identical quantized state that they had before their original separation. This is because they are governed by interplay with the quantum underworld, meaning the aether, and that requires inflow of energy from that underworld. So the Sun is kept alive by the aether which physicists say does not exist and, daring to answer the problem of another mystery, that of where energy goes when it is radiated into outer space, I suggest that such energy is eventually absorbed back into that unrecognized aether. In short, my message is that we exist in a state of low temperature energy equilibrium as between us and the aether but the Sun, owing gravity attributable to its massive form, has energy equilibrium with the aether at a level set by ionization of its hydrogen atoms and that is at 6000 degrees Celsius.

    My further message is that, given that the aether can be induced to shed energy, there is the ever-present challenge of our contriving to tap energy from the aether. Ask yourself what it is that sustains the properties of a permanent magnet. Physicists will tell you that ferromagnetism depends upon the quantized orbital motion and spin states of electrons which happen in some substances to work collectively in an energy condition that favours the magnetized state. Then ask, if it were possible to draw energy from a permanent magnet, whether that magnet might recover that energy from the quantum underworld, the aether. I certainly would be inclined to answer that question in the affirmative, meaning there could well be scope for tapping energy from the aether by a motor using permanent magnets in some way. Such a topic featured in a recent issue of the magazine NEXUS (June-July, 2004) and I saw it contained on pp. 41-44 an account of “Kohei Minato’s Amazing Magnetic Motor”, which proves what has just been suggested. There is indeed much the physicists have yet to learn and my message is that when facing a mystery in the field of physics one should be realistic enough to keep the aether in mind.

  • ARP 3 (2005): Can Gravity Be an Electrostatic Force?


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    CAN GRAVITY BE AN ELECTROSTATIC FORCE?

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    Introduction

    Unlike electromagnetic force, which acts at right angles to charge motion, gravity is a simple direct inverse-square of distance force, as is electrostatic action. Yet we struggle and fail to forge a link between gravitation and electromagnetism. Can it be that what is seemingly impossible, mutual electrostatic action between matter that is uncharged electrically, is the true answer to the mystery of gravitation? Here we see that there is a strong case in favour of this proposition.

    A Quantum Theory of Gravitation

    The Schuster-Wilson hypothesis is of relevance here, as is the related research of Nobel Laureate, Blackett [1], it being evident that the charge only reveals itself indirectly in setting up a magnetic moment and only then in a form not concentrated locally as a function of mass density of matter present.

    In-depth research on this topic has led the author to believe that rotation of the omnipresent space medium, our quantum underworld, can induce electric charge displacement which can set up a magnetic moment, as in the Sun or body Earth. This research indicates the existence of a charge continuum in space which is neutralized by a structured array of charges of opposite polarity and which governs quantum phenomena and determines basic physical constants. One then finds that continuum charge is displaced by the presence of a graviton population associated with matter present and here one discovers the physical basis of gravitation. The gravitons, which share with matter the Heisenberg jitter motion of quantum theory, provide the mass-related dynamic balance essential to cope with the motion imparted by the quantum underworld of space. This means that the force of gravitation really acts between those gravitons and is, via them, dynamically-coupled with matter that is itself electrically neutral.

    Note now a key point at issue. Electrostatic force between two like polarity charges is repulsive but here we are concerned with charge displaced by the presence of gravitons and that implies the effect of voids in a background charge continuum and so mutual attraction between the gravitons creating those voids as the enveloping charge seeks to spread by pushing the gravitons together.

    Another key point which needs consideration is the question of how a quantum theory of gravitation which implies a graviton form as a unit of gravitational action can account for weak gravitation forces that still depend upon G but arise from mass or its energy equivalent that is much smaller than the graviton mass. The answer to this is found by recognizing that gravitons, being leptons, can exist in charge pairs and can exchange energy as between themselves and another associated particle form. On a steady gravitational basis the taon form dominates the action according to the charge continuum volume displaced but on a transient basis minor fluctuations in volume of a heavier graviton form cater for the balance.

    [p. 2]

    How then do those gravitons feature in the spectrum of particle physics? Research shows that they mainly comprise the taon – the mystery lepton particle that sits alongside the muon and the electron in the bottom line of the standard quark picture of the particle grid. As to that heavier graviton form it is somewhat elusive but has been detected at around 2.587 GeV in the particle spectrum and is best referred to as the ‘Japanese H-quantum’ [2]. It exists in anti-particle pairs alongside two anti-particle taon pairs, meaning that there is one such heavy graviton for every two taon-gravitons.

    How is all this justified? Simply by derivation of G, the gravitation constant, in terms of the taon mass. Where is the proof of all this? Now, seriously, how can the Gravity Research Foundation expect that in an Essay of 1500 words or less? The proof is of record elsewhere [3] but, this being written solely to meet the concise requirements of the Foundation’s Essay competition, it can best be summarized by the following commentary and equations which show how G depends upon the taon/electron mass ratio.

    Step 1: Determine σ, the charge density of the space continuum. Do this by delving into the quantum properties of space, as evidenced by the Bohr Magneton er, e being the charge of the electron. With r having the value h/4πmec we then account for the photon in terms of spin of a 3x3x3 component of that structured charge array mentioned above. This gives us the equation:

    hc/2πe2 = 144πr/d where r is the orbital radius of charge motion, h is Planck’s constant, c is the speed of light and d is the cubic spacing of those charges. Accordingly:

    σ = e/d3

    We now know the value of σ because we can eliminate h/r and deduce that:

    mec2 = 72πe2/d me being the rest mass of the electron.

    Step 2: For encouragement at this stage note that we could digress to find the ratio r/d simply by analysis of electrostatic interaction energy density of the space medium and arguing that it cannot be negative, thereby accounting for charge being displaced from sites at which they would be at rest and so determining r and telling us that the quantum underworld must have that jitter motion postulated by Heisenberg. The analysis is of early record elsewhere [4]. It allows precise determination of the fine-structure constant, a quantity explained by no other theory.

    Step 3: We now formulate the link with G in terms of the taon and the heavier graviton form, of masses mτ and mg and volumes Vτ and Vg, respectively:

    %G(2mτ + mg) = σ(2Vτ + Vg) Next we need to use a formula dating back to the pre-Einstein era of J. J. Thomson:

    mc2 = 2e2/3a which applies to the electron and also relates the mass m of our two particles with their charge radius a and so their volume. This assumes that the charge e is distributed within the sphere of radius a so as to have uniform pressure or energy density.

    The volume to mass ratio of the two-taon and heavy graviton combination must match the corresponding volume to mass ratio for transient fluctuations in which a pair of heavy gravitons annihilate one another to share the volume of three such gravitons in a single charge. The same condition arises for the case where energy is exchanged between the field system of matter and the heavy graviton with, for such minor fluctuations, the preservation of gravitational potential overriding the need for perfect dynamic balance. In the latter case the slight expansion of graviton volume increases just enough to match the

    [p. 3]

    mass-energy added to the system of matter, thereby keeping gravitational potential unchanged. The relevant volume to mass ratio which has to equal:

    (2Vτ + Vg)/(2mτ + mg) is then:

    3Vg/mg Since charge volume is inversely proportional to the cube of the related mass one finds from the above equality that:

    (mg/mτ)3 – 3(mτ/mg) -1 = 0 which, upon solution, gives:

    (mg/mτ) = 1.452627 This allows us then to write:

    %G = σ(3Vg/mg) Step 4: One can now evaluate G based on the measured value of the taon mass-energy, which is 1.781 GeV or 3485 electron mass units, to find that the heavy graviton becomes 2.587 Gev or 5063 electron mass units.

    Note that d is 72πe2/mec2 and so is 108π times the electron charge radius, the latter being 5063 times the charge radius of the heavy graviton. Given that σ is e/d3 we then find that:

    %G = 4π(e/me)/(108π)3(5063)4

    and, e/me being 5.272 esu/gm, this tells us that G has the value 6.67×10-8 dynes.cm2.gm-2.

    Conclusion

    Physicists, and notably Weisskopf [5], have been puzzled as to the role played by both the muon and the taon, the heavy electrons of particle physics. Separately [6] the author has shown how the muon governs the creation of the proton and here we have seen that the taon governs in the field of gravitation. The case put here is that gravitation is an electrostatic phenomenon and this is deemed to justify the above use of the electrostatic units of the c.g.s system. We have derived G, the constant of gravitation, in good accord with its measured value. However, the author has gone further in this quest and is of record in showing how to derive by the same theory the masses of both the muon [3] and the taon [7] in terms of electron mass. Hopefully, therefore, this case that gravitation is an electrostatic phenomenon will come to be accepted in the future spectrum of physics.

    References

    [1] P. A. M. Blackett, Nature, 159, 658 (1947). [2] S. Hasagawa et al, Prog. Theor. Physics, 47, 126 (1971). [3] H. Aspden, The Physics of Creation, www.aspden.org (2004). [4] H. Aspden & D. M. Eagles, Physics Letters, 41A, 423 (1972). [5] V. F. Weisskopf, Physics Today, 69-85 (Nov. 1981). [6] H. Aspden, Aspden Research Papers, 4 www.aspden.org (2005) [7] H. Aspden, Hadronic Journal, 9, 153 (1986).

    [1489 words]

  • ARP 4 (2005): The Creation of the Proton


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    THE CREATION OF THE PROTON

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    Introduction

    Although particle physicists think they can probe the mysteries of creation by building mammoth accelerators costing billions of dollars to produce high speed impact of protons they do not have any theory giving insight into how those protons themselves are created. So they proceed in wild attempts to create other forms of matter thinking that will tell them how the universe itself was created. It is just the same for the problem of gravitation, given that cosmologists can justify vast expenditure in probing the depths of remote space based on their unproven notion that gravitation applies without moderation within very dense matter deemed to exist in so-called neutron stars. Yet they still have no theory showing how G, the constant of gravitation, is determined here on Earth in terms of electrical interaction as between particles. This author’s insight into the latter problem, his efforts in the past being unheeded, was the subject of the previous paper No. 3 in this series. Here in this paper we shall address once again the former problem, that of proton creation, the author’s findings on this theme, now dating back some 30 years. This having also been ignored by the scientific community notwithstanding its vital importance is now restated in a more advanced form in the hope that, in accounting for matter creation, it will serve to provide answers sought by unguided research and so serve to spare unwarranted waste of money on futile and ill-founded experimental effort.

    The Basic Question

    Concerning the proton, which, being the heavy nucleus of the hydrogen atom, accounts for 99.95% of its mass, the basic question we face is “Why is it stable, whereas other particles are short-lived and decay after only a transient existence?” The secondary question is: “Why does it have a mass that is slightly greater than 1836 times that of its hydrogen atom partner, the electron?”

    Here I note that the electron, though assumed by physicists to be stable and have no decay lifetime, does contrive to tunnel through obstructing electric potential barriers as if it suffers demise on one side of such a barrier and is reincarnated on the other side 10-13

    or so seconds latter. It seems so logical then to accept that protons and electrons are special in the sense that they may, indeed, have a finite lifetime, but there are forces at work which require the energy shed by their decay to recreate them virtually immediately in the same energy form and close to where they decay. This is merely saying that surplus energy that exists in the space environment of our quantum underworld contrives to create matter by appearing as protons and electrons.

    Physicists, by quantum theory, can picture action in that quantum underworld, much as it is disguised by their mathematical equations, but they still lack the insight to see how energy unable to be absorbed by that underworld has to take material form by creating those electrons and protons. The reason, of course, is that they have been brainwashed into believing the theory advocated by Albert Einstein which makes probing that underworld based on aether theory a taboo subject. So, unless they change their belief, they are not

    [p. 2]

    destined to understand how the proton is actually created and, in particular, why it has a mass some 1836 times that of the electron.

    They should however realise that there is intermediate ground to be explored that is truly in the realm of quantum theory, namely what determines the actual value of Planck’s constant h and what is known as the fine-structure constant which relates h with the speed of light and the charge of the electron. Yes, here we see the importance of the electron, that partner to the proton. Surely the message is: “Fathom what it is that determines the value of fine-structure constant and you will be on track in the quest to understand how matter is created.” Yet, physicists, in spite of knowing how to spend vast sums of money to fund construction of their high energy particle colliders and space probes, do not know how to go about even looking for the answer to the mystery of the fine-structure constant. The ghost of Einstein stands in their way!

    The Bottom Line in Particle Physics

    As you can see I intend to put my case rather firmly and I admit that, as I write this, I am motivated by a rejection, having offered to tell the physics community how protons are created by presenting a poster on the occasion of the ‘Physics 2005' conference to be held in April 2005 under the auspices of the Institute of Physics in U.K. of which I am a member. One must, you see, be seen to conform with the current beliefs of those who act as scrutineers for such occasions. New ideas that may cast doubt on certain theoretical notions that are currently in fashion cannot be entertained.

    That conference aims to celebrate Einstein’s centenary and so concerns cosmology and quantum physics. It is an appropriate occasion to hear new views on matter creation and, in particular, what I refer to as ‘the bottom line in particle physics’. This is a reference to the role played by the three particles that feature alongside one another below the quarks in the standard particle grid used by particle physicists. These particles are the electron, the muon and the taon, the fundamental leptons that play a major role in quantum electrodynamics.

    In the previous paper [1], the subject of which was also offered as a poster session presentation at the above conference but duly rejected, I have shown how G, the constant of gravitation is determined in terms of the role played by the taon. This leaves us to answer the question: “What role, if any, is served by the muon?” As to the electron, we see it everywhere, so much so that it is appropriate to take it as a reference by which to relate the properties of other particles, but there is still the question of how the electron itself is created. Can that be answered?

    Well, here I admit that I have no clear answer but I will at the end of this paper float an idea that others may find interest in exploring.

    Here, my object is to account for the creation of the proton and, indeed, you will see that my answer is clear and precise in deriving a theoretical value for the proton/electron mass ratio that conforms with experiment. The virtual muon population that pervades all space is the agency that performs this creative act.

    Before proceeding, and in order to gain the reader’s attention, I will again, as I did in my 1986 paper [2], repeat a quotation from an authoritative scientific source dated 1985.

    I note with some pride, pride I share with a colleague in advancing this theory, that when the leading experts, R. S. Van Dyck, Jr., F. L. Moore, D. L. Farnham and P. B. Schwinberg, involved in making such measurements reported in 1985 their findings in Int. J. Mass Spectrometry and Ion Processes, 66, p. 327 they stated:

    [p. 3]

    The value that they [Aspden and Eagles] calculate is remarkably close to our experimentally measured value (i.e. within two standard deviations) This is even more curious when one notes that they published this result several years before direct precision measurements of this ratio had begun. They had measured the proton-electron mass ratio to within a precision of 41 parts in a billion and this measurement was reported some 10 years after we had presented the theoretical value derived from aether theory.

    You see, it was 30 years ago in 1975 that this major step in understanding how matter is created was put on scientific record, but I still face the task of gaining its acceptance. The passage of time has, however, clarified some of the factors involved and so much of this paper is new and original, particularly the focus I shall be placing on the links between protons, taons and dimuons, the dimuon being a charged particle having double the mass of the virtual muon, and the virtual muon being the form the muon takes in its virgin state as part of the quantum electrodynamic underworld of space.

    A Pre-Einstein Principle

    The physics governing proton creation is that founded in electron theory dating back to the pre-Einstein years, before 1905. In particular I shall be using a classic formula once used in many student textbooks and one I see in a 1904 book by reference to J. J. Thomson, the scientist who discovered the electron. I have presented the relevant quotation from that book in Chapter 2 of a work I have put on record in January 2005 [3]. It would be best for reader to read that chapter before delving into what follows. The point I there make is that E = Mc2 owes nothing to Einstein for its derivation. Indeed, as I there explain, the simple truth is that this fundamental formula arises from the fact that a charged particle reacts to an accelerating electric field so as to conserve its intrinsic energy and has nothing whatsoever to do with mathematical gymnastics performed in so-called ‘four-space’.

    The ‘principle’ I refer to in this section concerns the form of the electric charge we symbolize as e, whether this be the charge of the electron, the proton or any other fundamental particle. J. J. Thomson’s formula for the energy of this charge is:

    E = 2e2/3a (1) where a is the radius of a sphere in which the charge is confined and in which the charge is so distributed that a uniform pressure prevails within that sphere and is balanced by the external pressure asserted at its surface by its self-field. One can easily verify that three quarters of this energy sits in the field outside the radius a whereas one sixth lies within the charge sphere.

    As we now proceed you will see that there is liberal use of this equation and that it applies to separate charge components of a charge pair, comprising opposite polarity charges of magnitude e in surface contact. Thus the sum of two such terms as in (1) offset by a term e2 divided by the sum of their radii would represent the energy of the combination.

    [p. 4]

    A System of Notation

    We will refer to the proton as P, the virtual muon as µ, the dimuon as Q, the taon as τ and the electron as e. The dimuon is a charge confined with a radius of half that of the virtual muon and so the energy of the dimuon is twice that of the muon.

    Why do I introduce the dimuon? My answer simply is that this is the quantum of energy that my theory tells me exists in each cubic cell unit of the quantum underworld of space. As I noted in my previous paper [1], where I derived G, such cubic cell units have a cube side distance d which is equal to 108π times the electron radius a. We are, you see, going to show how protons are created from energy shed by the quantum underworld, the aether, and the units of energy Q or the units of the energy of a virtual muon µ are the source of the energy needed to create the proton.

    As to notation, if I write:

    (A:B) this represents the energy of two charged particles A and B in surface contact and if I write:

    (A:B)* this represents the energy applicable if B happens to be the necessary charge form corresponding to the combination having shed energy to adopt an overall minimum energy state subject to the first charge A being of constant form.

    Thanks to that Thomson formula above it is a simple task to take the sum of the energies of the two particles as offset by their electrostatic interaction energy and by differentiation with respect to a variable radius of the second charge evaluate the minimum energy and that radius and thereby the value of B.

    One finds that B is equal to (%(3/2) – 1) times A or 0.22474A whereas the energy shed has the value (%(3/2) – 1)2 times A or 0.0505102A and so we are ready to delve into the secrets of proton creation.

    The Proton Creation Process

    We begin by supposing that somehow the proton as a single charge form P has been created. Why then is it so stable as to be the primary component of all matter? Can it somehow be associated with another particle form that has led to a minimum energy situation? If so then what is that particle form? It would, from the above analysis, have an energy that is 0.22474 times P which happens to be the combined energy of two virtual muons or the dimuon Q.

    Surely that is not a coincidence. Our proton must somehow be able to exist, even if only transiently, in the form:

    (P:Q)* but if so it has shed energy that has itself a particle form, whether as a single particle or particle combination, that has a net charge e.

    The latter energy is, in fact, the quantity ∆ of the expression:

    (Q:∆)* So, our empirical enquiry, given that P has been created, tells us that it might exist in an overall stable net energy state given by:

    (P:Q)* + ∆ WP even though it may be switching form, oscillating as it were, between its single form P and a three-particle state. This is consistent with the experimental observation that the proton exhibits a three-quark composition.

    [p. 5]

    Now, though this accounts the stability of the proton or next task is to explain how it is actually created and, a most important consideration, why it is a unique form of stable matter. That link with the dimuon energy quantum may seem a sufficient answer and, indeed, that was the status of my research back in 1975 when the theory of the proton/electron mass ratio was first recorded [4]. However, some 11 years on from there, in 1986, I advanced the theory when I saw how shedding that energy ∆ was the clue to proton creation from a virtual muon source [5].

    I asked what would happen if n virtual muons were to transfer their energy and a charge e to the particle combination (Q:∆)* and cause ∆ to be separated whilst Q merged with the muon inflow to create the combination (P:Q)*. I realised that n would have to be odd, meaning inflow of one more positively charged virtual muon than the inflow of negatively charged virtual muons. Also, to be sure, one might expect a mismatch of energy and so some further energy shedding than occurs in forming (Q:∆)*.

    To my genuine surprise however, and intense satisfaction, it became evident from the mathematics involved that n not only had to be odd but that it could only have a unique value to keep energy in balance with no loss by radiation.

    To find n, note that:

    nµ + (1 – 0.0505102)Q = Q/(0.22474487) (2) and that Q is 2µ. One can see that n has to equal 7.

    The result is that the proton must have a mass that is 8.898979486 times the mass of the virtual muon, the mass energy of the latter being half that of a cubic cell of the quantum underworld of space, found by pure theory to be equal to the mass energy of 206.3329 electrons.

    Therefore the proton/electron mass ratio obtained by this theoretical pursuit is slightly above 1836.152 as recorded in that 1975 paper [4].

    In the light of this I cannot see how anyone can doubt the role played by the virtual muon in creating the proton and so creating matter generally. If one seeks to question the derivation of that factor 206.3329 then that requires reference to my book ‘Physics Unified’ [6] published in 1980. It is fully of record on my website www.aspden.org and on page 112 you will see an equation (160) which is the result of a full derivation of that figure above. The equation actually is:

    Eo = 412.665816 mec2

    where Eo is the energy Q or 2µ of the above analysis.

    Particle Creation and the Electron

    I said above that I would ‘float an idea’ concerning the electron whilst on this subject of matter creation. I have, in my research so far, taken the electron’s existence for granted and I have, for some 15 years now, been more concerned with energy issues of our real world than the underlying physics theory that preoccupied me as a private interest from 1955 to 1980. So in coming back to the subject of matter creation, I can point to a clue pertaining the electron and positron forms of matter.

    First note that, in deriving that Eo energy quantum above, the vital step was that of determining the mass and energy of a fundamental particle that pervades all space and accounts for the Heisenberg jitter motion of quantum theory. The energy density of that particle is identical to the energy density of Eo divided by the volume of the cubic cells of the quantum underworld, each of side distance 108π times the charge radius of the electron. The volume of the charge occupied by that fundamental particle was deemed to be an odd

    [p. 6]

    multiple of the volume of the electron. This step was need to refine the calculation of the fine-structure constant determined by my theory, as discussed in reference [7]. The electron came into the act in that context and also in regard to its quantum angular momentum of h/2π as used in formulating the theory of that quantum underworld of space.

    Now, in regard to the creation of matter in the form of atoms of higher order than hydrogen, my theory of early record did contemplate the proton becoming associated with a meson in a two particle charge combination of the kind noted above with the energy thereby shed being absorbed in the main by creating what I referred to as electron-positron chains. These comprised a line of electrons interposed between positrons in adjacent charge surface contact and I noted that about 166 or so electrons and positrons in a chain might form a discrete link between two adjacent particle sites in the quantum underworld, as one can see by halving that 108π factor.

    As early as 1974, in reference [8], I recorded my ideas on the subject of heavier atoms and their structure but at that stage I had settled on the belief that the meson linked to the proton component in the atomic nucleus had to be that charge form Q introduced above. Furthermore, since we are here considering atoms of atomic number greater than unity, we confront the neutron as a component in the atomic nucleus. Here I declare quite categorically that the neutron as such has no presence in an atomic nucleus. When created as a free particle form it exists as a combination of electrons and/or positrons with a proton or antiproton and survives for several minutes before decaying. The so-called neutron of the atomic nucleus is an antiproton form that happens to have replaced a charge occupying a lattice site in the space medium.

    The thought I now float concerns the form that energy might take when shed by the union of the P and Q particle forms and a pointer to the electron-positron pairing.

    I have stressed in the previous paper [1], No. 3 in this series, that the taon has a role as a graviton in accounting for gravitation and that gravitons provide dynamic balance for an equal mass of matter sharing the quantum jitter motion. Note therefore the approximate energy equality between:

    e + (P:Q) + (P:Q) and:

    τ + (e:e) + (e:e) In terms of electron mass (P:Q) has an energy of [1 – (%(3/2) – 1)2]P or, with P as a little over 1836.152, some 1743.4 electron mass units and so the combined energy of the three components is 3487.8. The (e:e) electron-positron components may be shown to have an energy of 1.25 electron units, this being 2 minus their interaction energy. So if we deduct 2.5 from 3487.8 to get 3485.3 we might expect the taon τ to have a mass energy equivalent to 3485.3 electron units.

    The reader may verify by reference to the previous paper [1] that the value of the taon mass in electron units which gave us the precise value of G as measured was 3485 electron units.

    The suggestion therefore is that the proton creation process has features which indicate electron-positron pair creation forming components that can combine to create links between components in the atomic nucleus, especially as the (P:Q) forms sit at one end of such links. The ∆ energy component of the three-state proton form has enough energy to create such links with a little energy to spare.

    The energy quantum involved has presumably not been detected as a meson owing to the transient quark nature of existence of the ∆ form.

    [p. 7]

    A question which then should be raised is that of why I take two (P:Q) combinations as the basis of taon creation. Why not six or seven? The answer has to be that Nature plays a statistical game of trial and error and will create numerous particle forms, as will the high energy particle colliders at CERN and elsewhere. However, the particles that will take control will be those having a higher creation rate at specific energy values and which have energy determined by two factors. We see that in the case of the proton because its energy was determined first without that factor n of 7 being assumed but then we found that only the factor 7 could give the right energy input. So where is that other factor for the taon? Well it is presented on page 156 of reference [9], as published in 1986. There, also taking the energy of the proton as the base reference, I indicated how a series of hyperons developed by processes involving charge-pair annihilation and consolidation of charge with conservation of charge energy and charge volume and all based on the proton, dimuon and taon forms. Indeed, the clear message from that analysis of six hyperons, all of which were found to have theoretical energy values in conformity with observation, was that the energy of the taon was greater than that of the proton by the factor 3 raised to the power 7/12. The latter has the value 1.898107 and, the proton/electron mass ratio being 1836.152, this gives the taon/electron mass ratio as 3485.2

    Conclusion

    One can but conclude that the quest to understand how matter is created is best pursued by such analysis rather that trying to create freak forms of matter using high energy particle colliders. I do stress the need to rethink adherence to Einstein philosophy given what I have said in my four chapters in my recent work ‘Physics without Einstein: A Centenary Review’ [3]. Until the scientific world recovers its good sense and takes another look at the mysteries of our cosmos with the aether in mind and Einstein ignored we really have no hope of inspiring future science students and gaining a better understanding of the phenomena which dominate, indeed constitute, our very existence.

    References

    [1] H. Aspden, Aspden Research Papers, 3 www.aspden.org (2005). [2] R. S. Van Dyck, Jr., F. L. Moore, D. L. Farnham & P. B. Schwinberg, J. Mass Spectrometry and Ion Processes, 66, 327 (1985). [3] H. Aspden, ‘Physics without Einstein: A Centenary Review”, www.aspden.org (2005). [4] H. Aspden & D. M. Eagles, Il Nuovo Cimento, 30A, 235 (1975). [5] H. Aspden, Hadronic Journal, 9, 129 (1986). [6] H. Aspden, ‘Physics without Einstein’, Sabberton Publications, www.aspden.org (1969). [7] H. Aspden & D. M. Eagles, Physics Letters, 41A, 423 (1972). [8] H. Aspden, ‘The Chain Structure of the Atomic Nucleus’, Sabberton Publications, (paper reference 1974a, www.aspden.org ). [9] H. Aspden, Hadronic Journal, 9, 153 (1986).

    21 February, 2005

  • ARP 5 (2005): Tesla versus Einstein


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    TESLA VERSUS EINSTEIN

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    Introduction

    As we celebrate Einstein in the centenary year since he introduced his Theory of Relativity there are those of us who see little to celebrate because we believe that Einstein blocked the way forward in our quest to tap energy from the aether. The aether is the energy source accounting for the creation of our universe but Einstein’s theory caused scientists to replace the aether by abstract mathematical notions. Hence there has been no acceptance of the aether as a possible new energy source, needed as our oil reserves are eroded. It is timely, therefore, to review the claim made by Nikola Tesla that he had devised and constructed an automobile that was powered on aether energy.

    Some Quotations

    Whereas the general public, including almost all of the scientific community, accept Einstein’s theory without question, essentially because that has become the popular opinion in the light of E = Mc2 having significance connected with the atomic bomb, that formula relating energy E and mass M by the speed of light in vacuum is easily derived without any use of Einstein’s doctrines. See my monograph entitled ‘Physics without Einstein: A Centenary Review’ which is of record on my website www.aspden.org

    However, I am not the only one who regards Einstein’s theory as an obstruction rather than an aid in our understanding of fundamental energy science. The following quotations therefore seem appropriate as an introduction to what follows.

    ‘Tesla maintained his belief in the aether as the source of all substance. This, he thought, was the fundamental, unifying theory of physical things. He was quite unable to accept Einstein’s theory of relativity and curved space.’ ‘The Secret of the Creative Vacuum’ by John Davidson [1]

    ‘There is incontrovertible evidence, for example, from a number of sources, that neither the gravitational ‘constant’ nor the speed of light in a vacuum are constant after all. Since Einstein’s theory of relativity is founded upon these two assumptions, if either one of them is shown to be incorrect, then Einstein’s theory is seen to be more relative than he thought! In short, like Newton’s observations, it would be wrong, as a fundamental model.’ ‘The Secret of the Creative Vacuum’ by John Davidson [2]

    ‘It may come as a shock, but Einstein’s theory of relativity is not part of the design of nuclear weapons! …… High school science students are conditioned to ridicule the concept of a nineteenth-century luminiferous aether with eye-rolling and giggling. But is this a contemptible idea when

    [p. 2]

    compared with the “new and improved” terminology of gravitational masses “warping” the fabric of “space-time”? ‘A Dissident View of Relativity Theory’ by W.H.Cantrell [3]

    ‘Einstein plagiarized the work of several notable scientists in his 1905 papers on special relativity and E = Mc2, yet the physics community has never bothered to set the record straight in the past century.’ ‘Albert Einstein: Plagiarist of the Century’ by Richard Moody, Jr. [4]

    ‘Insofar as the theory is thought to explain the result of the Michelson Morley experiment, I am inclined to agree with Soddy that it is a swindle; and I do not think Rutherford would have regarded it as a joke had he realized how it would retard the rational development of science’.

    ‘Relativity – Joke or Swindle?’ by L. Essen [5]

    Einstein: 1902-1909

    During these years Einstein was employed by the Swiss Patent Office as a ‘technical expert (third class)’ until 1906 and then ‘technical expert (second class)’. So his famous scientific papers of 1905 were written midway during that period of his life before, in 1909, he became an associate professor at the University of Zurich.

    Bearing in mind that the Swiss Patent Office registered patents without rigorous examination for novelty or merit, except for those concerned with clocks and watches, one must wonder if that was the work which kept Einstein busy in those years. If so, and since he is acclaimed for the scientific achievement of upsetting our understanding of time itself, it is an interesting observation that the 20th century gave birth to one of the greatest inventions ever made concerning clocks. It was that of Dr. Essen, the Director of the Time and Frequency Division of Britain’s National Physical Laboratory. He invented the atomic clock and so ought to be an authority on the measurement of time. That last quotation was by Dr. Essen. Somehow scientists say they can verify Einstein’s theory by conveying atomic clocks around the Earth in aircraft but nowhere in their analysis of their experimental findings do they show in truly physical terms how acceleration affects the rhythm of electron motion in the atom. It is no wonder therefore that Dr. Essen was outspoken concerning his disbelief in Einstein’s doctrines.

    Now, of course, it is not the distortion of our understanding on the nature of time that has obstructed scientific progress. Rather it is the effect Einstein’s theory has had on our understanding of how energy is stored in what we see as empty space. Somehow we can inject energy into the vacuum and then recover it on demand, this being the property of electromagnetic inductors. The major question scientists face is whether that energy we feed into space is the same energy that is returned to us on demand. Or could it be that we feed energy into an existing universal pool of energy and are allowed to withdraw only the amount we have put on deposit. Should that universal energy pool exist in reality then it is logical to suppose that somehow it accounts for the creation of matter and so our universe, in which case the challenge is to try to tap energy from that pool.

    With Tesla in mind that is the subject of this paper, but at this point, merely as an aside remark since I have just mentioned clocks, it is of interest to note that I was, not long ago, asked to contribute some input on my interest in the energy theme as a participant in a television presentation being directed and filmed by an Australian group who, having

    [p. 3]

    travelled around USA and Europe interviewing several others, had arrived in London in U.K. I arranged for my interview to be at the Institution of Electrical Engineers, where, outside the entrance, they could film a statue of Michael Faraday to whom we owe the discovery of energy storage by magnetic induction. However, after that interview, and to my complete surprise, I was asked to accompany the film crew to the archives of the British Museum, where I would be shown a ‘perpetual motion’ machine that was several centuries old. It was a large clock, some six or seven feet high, that never needed winding up. I had never heard of it but soon got the message that they expected me, on camera, to stand in front of the clock and explain how it worked.

    At this point I should explain that, whereas Einstein had experience examining patents, my career after my early research years at Cambridge, was spent in the patent profession explaining in detail how inventions worked and defining the legal patent claims that are the basis of protecting and so convincing Patent Office examiners as to the merits of those inventions. I was a Patent Attorney and my employers were the English Electric Company until the end of 1959, followed by IBM thereafter. Even so, with no prior brief from the inventor of that clock or any technical description, having had a glimpse of the clock, I heard myself explaining how it worked.

    It was a grandfather-type clock having a pendulum and was operated by a weight that, by falling very slowly under gravity, powered the mechanism that operated the hour and minute hands. There were two such weights. As one was discharging its energy over a period of weeks and months, so the other was being lifted by a device that was sensitive to changes in atmospheric pressure. That device comprised an enclosed glass chamber partially filled with mercury and coupled to a vertical displacement tube sealed at one end, there being a vacuum cavity above the mercury in that tube but a vent at the top of the main chamber which exposed the surface of the mercury to atmospheric pressure. With ongoing change of air pressure, barometric pressure, the displacement of the mercury shifted weight from one side of a balance to the other side, thereby exerting force through an arm which, by its motion, effectively wound up the clock in respect of one of its two weights, pending interchange of roles.

    Had the mercury not been removed by the Museum for preservation reasons, it would be, as it had been, a machine in perpetual motion powered only by the energy of our environment, but hardly a method which offers practical prospect for solving the world’s developing energy problems. A machine before Einstein’s time, but a message also that says: “Energy is available for exploitation if we probe into the depths of our environment and can visualize that deeper physical underworld of space, the aether.” Thanks to Einstein, scientists have lost interest in that aether, but, thanks to Tesla, there are some of us who are still interested!

    Tesla’s Pierce-Arrow Car

    Those who have written about Tesla’s research have told us about his deep interest in atmospheric electricity, extending even to the possibility of transmitting real electrical power by natural propagation through the atmosphere. He was a genius and an inventor who has left his imprint on the electrical power industry, especially by his invention of the a.c. induction motor.

    On November 17th, 2004, I was sent a letter by Don Kelly of the Space Energy Association in USA. He tells me there is now hope that there will soon be a ‘final resolution of Nikola Tesla’s excellent Pierce-Arrow car project of 1931, at Buffalo, N.Y.’,

    [p. 4]

    meaning how it worked. This car I, understand, was demonstrated and tested back in 1931 and shown to operate at high speed not with a normal fuel supply, but by power drawn from a mysterious source, which Tesla implied was aethereal atmospheric electricity. Tesla did not reveal its design details and so its secrets.

    Don Kelly suggests that the clue to its operation may be found in Tesla’s two 1901 U.S. patents, Nos. 685,957 and 685,958. They portray two radiant energy input sources, one from an X-ray tube as an example of power input to the patented device. Don Kelly notes in his letter:

    “We have now slowly come to the conclusion that Tesla used both of these methods, i.e. the natural ‘antenna’ method, and the artificial way, via multiple (12) vacuum (X-ray) tubes within the car. At some point Tesla must have decided to use only one 6 foot high antenna, and use the collector radiant energy as the input to his 12 X-ray tubes.”

    Now, from my point of view, it is a very formidable task to try to decipher how Tesla’s car really did function, based on little or no information other than that outlined above.

    However, frustrated, as I am, by the seemingly universal dedication to belief in Einstein’s theory, notwithstanding its blocking action on the aether energy front, I will try to build a picture of the kind that one sees in a patent specification, even though I have no input from the inventor (Tesla) and no sight of the working embodiment (the Pierce-Arrow car).

    The focus of attention, as I see it, is (a) a large inductor (what Don Kelly refers to as the 6 foot high antenna which I understand was mounted at the rear of the car), (b) 12 vacuum tubes, though whether they were X-ray tubes is speculation in the light of patents dated 30 years earlier, and (c) a multiple set of large capacitors.

    Don Kelly’s letter indicated that a 60 kw level of power output would be needed and that he had information that ‘a substantial large capacitor, or multiple smaller capacitors’ needed to be in place as well as means for converting d.c. to a.c. to power the ‘engine’, which I presume was a three-phase induction motor, this being Tesla’s brainchild.

    Speculation by Deduction

    Take a large inductor and assume a steady d.c. current flow through it. Ignore for the moment the possible energy source. Using capacitors how can one generate three-phase a.c. power output? We need to switch the d.c. current to feed current into each of three capacitors sequentially during a complete cycle of the a.c. generated. During periods when a capacitor is not receiving current we need to discharge it through the input winding of one phase of the motor. Each capacitor needs therefore two switches and that suggests a role for the vacuum tubes.

    So here we see the need for six tubes, not twelve, Why did Tesla need twelve? I will presume that the tubes were of a type commercially available and that their rating may only have been half that needed to power his car at speed. So six tubes would suffice to explain the design principle but twelve were used, six sets of two in parallel, to get the required power output. The alternative interpretation is that Tesla’s motor was a six-phase machine.

    That said, where is the source of energy? We can presume, as Tesla may have done, that the inductor, being a large coil having many turns and mounted vertically at the

    [p. 5]

    rear of his car, air-cored or possibly iron-cored to enhance inductance, was somehow tapping electrical power from atmospheric electricity. Note that the Earth has an electric field extending high into our atmosphere and known to be of the order of hundreds of volts per metre. This has not been seen as a source of useful power or harmful. After all we surely would find current flow in lightning conductors even in the absence of thunder and lightning were this the case. One can wonder if, by setting up a vertical field oscillation at 2 or 4 kHz, or so, we might develop a resonance effect owing to oscillations between the Earth’s surface and the ionosphere, which somehow causes possible energy output to escalate to useful levels, but I am sceptical as to that possibility.

    So where else can we look for that energy source. Don Kelly suggests it might be those 12 tubes. Might they have really been gas discharge tubes? In that case I am mindful of the research findings of Paulo and Alexandra Correa [6], but here again I am sceptical because the Correas use tubes of special fabrication and had such a property been evident from a tube commercially available back in 1931 then its excess energy property would surely have been discovered long ago.

    I am then left to consider the capacitors as the seat of the power input and this is something that really arouses my interest. The reason is that, in 2002, with some considerable confidence, I spoke openly at a conference suggesting that I had reason to believe that, by pulsating the energization of a capacitor of concentric electrode design, we could tap energy from the aether [7]. I saw this as replicating a phenomenon involved in the creation of our sun, whereby setting up a radial electric field induces aether spin and taps energy from the aether that is retained in the spin of the sun before much of it is shed in imparting angular momentum to the planets. Unfortunately, tests using a.c. excitation of such a capacitor failed to verify what I had predicted.

    So I now wonder if Tesla’s electrical circuit in that car had a feature that makes this capacitor theme viable, a feature I had missed in my own research efforts?

    Well, further speculation and analysis now points to a possible answer and revives my hopes in the capacitor theme, as I now explain.

    Induction of Aether Spin

    There are two essential factors that must apply if I am right in thinking Tesla’s power source was those capacitors in his Pierce-Arrow car.

    The first is that the capacitance has to be much higher than seems possible for the air dielectric capacitor that I had in mind and the second is that the there must be a retardation effect involved in setting up the aether spin within the capacitor. The reason for this is that the induction of the spin is not spontaneous in response to the setting up of the radial electric field, as I had assumed, but involves delay and this precludes operation at 100 kHz which was the basis of the tests made. Operation at much lower frequency means the need for much higher capacitance to achieve the required power output. Note that my theory indicated that energy could be tapped from the aether owing to that radial field displacing the quantum orbital motion of aether charge and the need for phase lock as between that charge within the capacitor and the charge in enveloping aether. This meant either a vibratory effect that had to be contained with no spin or the development of aether spin giving a vibration-free and smooth deployment of energy. The spin condition implied import of kinetic energy from the aether to augment the electric energy priming the capacitor, with that kinetic energy being non-recoverable by the aether external to the

    [p. 6]

    capacitor during electric discharge and so being shed by augmenting the output voltage to deliver more energy than was supplied as input.

    I now suspect, in the light of further theoretical analysis and the inferences I draw from hearing about Tesla’s Pierce-Arrow car, that the onset of the radial electric field creates a torque action within the capacitor dielectric, which stems from the aether it contains but is restrained by the fixed structural form of the capacitor. This torque, however, could be effective in initiating an aether spin that develops progressively from the spin axis and spreads outwards until it extends throughout the whole concentric form of the dielectric. The reason is that energy is needed to ‘notch’ the aether particles cell by cell at the slip boundary between the aether in spin and aether within the dielectric but still not spinning. The energy is returned in each ‘notching’ cycle but to set up spin spontaneously for all the aether contained within the dielectric demands too much energy and so the required result emerges only from a stage-by-stage progression.

    From such considerations I can see it was a mistake to hope to achieve aether energy output operating at 100 kHz. This whole theory is based on the creation processes and spin induction associated with the creation of stars and planets which is a one-off half-cycle operation as compared with operating at a.c. power frequencies in electrical apparatus. So what frequency is possible with aether energy delivery? I cannot estimate this until I delve into the theory of that ‘notching’ effect, but for the time being I will assume, with hope, that the 60 Hz frequency that dates from Tesla’s time is an operable frequency. That may have been the frequency of his car motor corresponding to top speed.

    This leads now to the problem of capacitance. Whereas capacitance of the order of a nanofarad was what I had in mind with 100 kHz operation, it seems that I now must think in terms of hundreds of microfarads, given also that I doubt if Tesla’s circuit was operating at the high a.c. voltage of 10 kV.

    Here there has been revision of my thoughts on the use of a dielectric medium between the capacitor electrodes as opposed to mere air. The electric field that governs aether spin could well be very much higher than is evident from the capacitor voltage because the charge polarization of the dielectric offsets the primary field and what we measure is the difference. This would have a very substantial effect on the amount of energy tapped from the aether and so points to the need to use a capacitor insulator of high dielectric constant.

    As a further thought I see there is much to be gained by pulsing the capacitor with unidirectional current rather than the normal sinusoidal current we associate with a.c. operation. This would keep the aether spin ongoing in the same direction but oscillating about a mean level. Accordingly, my interpretation of Tesla’s Pierce-Arrow car has this feature. Finally, and concerning how a capacitor can deliver more output energy on discharge than during the charging stage, given the inherent power source, I can but suggest that, whereas charge input occurs in the normal way, it is desirable for the input voltage to be switched off before discharge begins and also desirable to force the current out in a controlled manner during discharge. Excess energy delivery can only be by virtue of an excess voltage in the output phase. All this points to the need for an inductor of high inductance which keeps the level of current flow constant and can absorb voltage pulsations but, by switching, diverts the current between input periods and output periods as between the several capacitors. What Tesla may have done to produce his three-phase output power, even though thinking he was exploiting aether energy input to his inductor, may, fortuitously and without him knowing it, have been the ideal way of operating those

    [p. 7]

    capacitors in their aether energy-tapping role. I am, of course, assuming that he used large capacitors having concentric electrode construction such as are normally associated with high voltage operation. Maybe they incorporated a special kind of dielectric and here, I recall reading somewhere in connection with more recent over-unity energy claims, about experiments using barium titanate as dielectric, it having a very high dielectric constant. Also one sees, I believe, the use Leyden jars in the circuits used by the Swiss Methernitha community in their over-unity energy activities, an encouraging sign [8]. As to the stress now placed on d.c. operation I can further add that, after publishing my first proposals concerning a concentric capacitor having potential for anomalous energy effects, I heard from a German engineer experienced in d.c. power supply via coaxial cables, as used by underground railways, that he had observed that in servicing such power lines it was not sufficient merely to short-circuit the cable to discharge it once power had been switched off. Experience had shown that the cable could surprise one by recovering its voltage and it took quite a while for the energy stored in the cable capacitance to discharge fully, far longer than one might expect. A coaxial cable operating at high voltage d.c. is, of course, a concentric capacitor and so, if I am right in what I outline above, it should exhibit such an anomaly.

    Conclusion

    I have been prompted to write this by Don Kelly’s communication concerning Tesla and this is my answer. Whether this inspires those with the resources to research the subject further, only time will tell, but, to be sure, there is so much money being spent building high energy particle colliders to probe the secrets of creation on Big Bang theory, that one might hope that a little governmental funding could be spared to explore this ‘free energy’ theme. It is founded on aether spin which itself already accounts for many features pertaining to the creation of the solar system. Big Bang research can only lead to taking risks that bring about destruction and take us no nearer to the technology that can one day tap aether energy. Tesla, it seems, achieved that objective, but we prefer in this year 2005 to celebrate Einstein, who blocked the way forward on the aether energy front, whereas Tesla is more deserving. Hopefully, by 2031, the centenary anniversary of his Pierce-Arrow car, our scientists will be wiser on this question of the aether and its energy resource.

    References

    [1] J.Davidson, ‘The Secret of the Creative Vacuum’, C. W. Daniel Co. Ltd., pp. 171-172 (1989). [2] J.Davidson, ‘The Secret of the Creative Vacuum’, C. W. Daniel Co. Ltd., p. 177 (1989). [3] W H Cantrell, ‘A Dissident view of the Theory of Relativity’, ‘Infinite Energy’, 10, Issue 58, pp. 6 & 8 (2005). [4] R M Moody, Jr., ‘The Secret of the Creative Vacuum’, ‘Infinite Energy’, 10, Issue 58, p. 34 (2005). [5] L. Essen, ‘Relativity – Joke or Swindle?’ (1988) reprinted in ‘Infinite Energy’, 10, Issue 58, p. 23 (2005). [6] P. Correa & A. Correa, ‘The Search for Free Energy’, Simon & Schuster, pp. 218-222

    [p. 8]

    [7] H. Aspden, ‘The Physics of Perpetual Motion’, ‘Infinite Energy’, 10, Issue 55, p. 19

    [8] K. Tutt, ‘The Search for free Energy’, Simon & Schuster, pp. 92-93 & pp. 285-292

    H. Aspden February 28th, 2005

  • ARP 6 (2005): A Problem in Plasma Science


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    A PROBLEM IN PLASMA SCIENCE

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    Introduction

    There is a quite serious problem that pervades the scientific theory relied upon in connection with research involving plasma discharges and so having bearing upon nuclear fusion experiments and even the interpretation of certain astrophysical phenomena. It arises from leaving unresolved an issue raised by Clerk Maxwell in his Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism and so dating back to the 19th century.

    Equally serious is the problem of scientific academia today by which physicists publish their ideas in numerous papers and in measure aimed solely at building their prowess and justifying their position, but papers most of which add nothing of significance to our knowledge base. Accordingly, university libraries tend to become poorly charted jungles in which genuine contributions of worthy research are hidden and so pass unheeded.

    That 'issue' raised by Clerk Maxwell was in fact resolved and recorded in that 'jungle' some 37 years ago and, thanks to the author, myself, being still alive to point to its location, this item is now being remembered here on my website. I will below explain its importance.

    The Sun and a Problem

    We are told that the sun has a temperature of about 6000 degrees and can verify that this is a reasonable statement because we know the amount of solar heat radiation per square centimeter per second that reaches us here on Earth and we have Stefan's radiation law as determined from our laboratory experiments on radiation from hot bodies.

    We are told that the sun's core has a temperature of over 100,000,000 degrees but that cannot be verified because it is founded solely on the assumption that the sun is powered by nuclear fusion and that is said to require such a high temperature. The evidence gleaned from the form of radiation said to comprise neutrinos is not a measure of temperature.

    Yet we are also told that surrounding the sun there is a region we call the corona which is said to have a temperature of 1,000,000 degrees, inasmuch as the spectral lines of radiation sourced in that region were found in 1942 to exhibit energy properties akin to those arising from certain levels of electron transitions applicable to highly ionized iron atoms.

    So the sun has three temperatures, none of which has actually been measured and all of which are inferred, one from an actual measurement of energy radiation, one from analysis of an energy spread in a spectral image and one from the mere imagination that the sun owes its energy source to the process we associate with the hydrogen bomb.

    The problem I have is in wondering how the sun's corona can be at 1,000,000 degrees if the sun within that corona has a surface temperature of 6,000 degrees.

    I think most readers will agree that understanding the deployment of energy in a plasma composed of heavy ions and electrons, such as we have in the sun, is important and

    [p. 2]

    yet here we have a blatant example of something accepted by the physics community that really does not make sense. Are we to suppose that we are looking at tiny specks of sunlight emitted from single atoms of iron that have a temperature of 1,000,000 degrees, mixed in the background of the sun's surface at 6,000 degrees? Or might it be that we cannot just use Boltzmann's constant to convert energy to temperature, assuming equipartition of energy between all ions of whatever size, and thereby stay with common sense and assign the same temperature to all components of that plasma but admit there is some process at work that deploys energy unevenly? Why should we use gas laws formulated on the basis of there being no ionization when interpretating phenomena exhibited by ionized plasma?

    The case I now put is that the problem confronted by Clerk Maxwell, had it been resolved, would have enlightened us on this important issue, one which has significant bearing upon the current research in the field of nuclear fusion.

    Plasma Electrodynamics

    Maxwell was concerned that Ampere's law of electrodynamics might not be a valid interpretation of experimental fact because it relied partly on empirical data and partly on assumption. He addressed the options available. The key point was that it was known how electric currents interact where one of the currents flows though wire around a closed circuit but it was not known how two discrete electric charges in motion might interact as a function of their motion. To define the law of force there had to be an assumption. Ampere had assumed total balance of action and reaction but one can have total balance of action and reaction for that closed circuit current condition without satisfying the precise formulation specified by Ampere.

    In today's terminology the Lorentz force law suffices and meets the necessary balance criteria for such closed current circuit conditions, but an additional term, as formulated by Maxwell, is needed to cover the general case and that still depends upon an assumption. That additional term, expressed in vector form is simply:

    (v.r)v' times ee'/r3, where a charge e in motion at velocity v acts on a charge e' distant r from e and moving at velocity v'. The effect of this term integrates to zero for the closed circuit current condition

    Maxwell realized that this additional term could have any factor, positive or negative, large or small, and still comply with the empirical conditions. He opted for the factor being +1 because he knew that this would give an overall formulation for which the two charges in motion could interact without giving rise to an anomalous unidirectional net linear force that might suggest the interaction induced a linear push on something.

    Instead, though it was not mentioned, that would lead to the two-charge interaction itself developing a turning couple as if it were exerting a twist action on that same something. Ampere's law had avoided both of these possibilities.

    Given the belief in the existence of an aether in Maxwell's time and the fact that the motion of those charges is referenced on a frame of reference signifying a property of the aether, that 'something' did have a basis, one that could provide the balancing force along with the associated energy.

    Maxwell, in being concerned with formulating force action, was addressing a problem that had important energy implications, but that seemingly escaped notice.

    [p. 3]

    What I realized when I came onto the scene was that it would have been preferable for Maxwell to opt for the version with the minus sign preceding that (v.r)v' term, simply because that would avoid the twisting problem. Also, though introducing that out-of-balance net linear force, I could see that such a formulation, for v parallel with v', would, in combination with the Lorentz component, result in a law for which mutual force action between the charges was of the simple inverse square of distance form acting along the line joining the charges.

    Such a law made more sense especially as, at the time I discovered this, my thoughts were on linking electromagnetism and gravity.

    The formal analysis, however, then had to take account of the possible interaction of charges of different mass, such as heavy ions interacting with electrons, and that added the factor (m'/m), where m' is the mass of charge e' and m is the mass of charge e, these charges being, of course, expressed in electromagnetic units.

    My paper on this duly appeared in the library archives of universities in Journal of the Franklin Institute, 287, 179 (1969) and there it sits gathering dust and serving no purpose unless whoever reads this decides to check what I am saying in this web item.

    Given that, just as Clerk Maxwell saw reason to question the law of electrodynamics proposed by Ampere, I had good reason for going one step further and completing that task, I cannot understand why physicists interested in plasma experiments have not embraced what is surely the correct law.

    Why is it that relevant? Well, just consider that term:

    !(ee'/r3)(m'/m)(v.r)v' and imagine m' is the mass of a heavy positive ion and m is the mass of an electron sitting in an ionized plasma, be it that of the sun or that of a nuclear fusion reactor.

    Consider the collective results of four types of interaction. (1) Slow moving ion with electron moving closer: Ion gains speed slightly because ee' negative, v' small and v.r positive. (2) Slow moving ion with electron moving away: Ion slows to even lower speed because ee' negative, v' small and v.r negative. (3) Fast moving ion with electron moving closer: Ion speed escalates because ee' negative, v' large and v.r positive. (4) Fast moving ion with electron moving away: Ion loses speed rapidly because ee' negative, v' large and v.r negative.

    The net effect of such charge interaction electrodynamically in a plasma must therefore be to cause each positive heavy ion on average to have kinetic energy far in excess of that of the average electron. It would be an interesting, though quite complicated mathematical task to evaluate statistically the mean energy apportionment between ions and electrons, one which I trust some enthusiastic mathematician might undertake. For my part it suffices to point to the experimental evidence that supports what I am saying.

    The Supporting Experimental Evidence

    In my 1969 paper I drew attention to the fact that it had long been recognized that energy was being acquired anomalously by positive ions subjected to acceleration in a cold cathode gas discharge. The cathode reaction forces measured were high and inexplicable. I referred to a paper by E. Kobel in Physical Review, 36, 1636 (1930). Clearly the effect of electrons flowing in the return path outside the tube and acting on ion flow within the

    [p. 4]

    tube accounted for that phenomenon, based on the law of electrodynamics as revised to replace the +(v.r)v' term in Maxwell's equation by that -(m'/m)(v.r)v' term. I note that Maxwell used cartesian formulation, whereas I am using the vector notation that Sir Edmund Whittaker used in discussing this subject in his 1951 book History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity.

    In saying that the action of electron currents exerts anomalous electrodynamic forces that accelerate heavy ions to higher than expected speeds, I am challenging orthodox theory which sees no basis for electrodynamic forces existing along the line of the ion current flow path, but the experimental evidence supports what I say. I refer to the subject of explosive arc discharges in liquids and wire rupture in experiments reported by P. Graneau and P. N. Graneau in Physics Letters, 97A, 253 (1983) and Applied Physics Letters, 46, 468 (1985). These were discussed in the context of the revised law of electrodynamics in my paper in Physics Letters, 111A, 22 (1985) but see also my paper in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-14, 282 (1986).

    I also refer to my earlier paper on the subject of anomalous acceleration forces exerted by electrons on ions in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-5, 159 (1977).

    This latter paper was published just one year before the two fusion research papers that I next mention, whereas my original 1969 paper antedates these by nine years. I refer to the anomalous gain of energy by heavy ions found in plasma experiments and reported without mention of the theory that I had shown to be relevant.

    J. Reece Roth, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-6, No. 2, June 1978, studied the effect of radial electric fields in stabilizing a plasma discharge, but found that something was causing the heavy ions in the plasma to have a much higher temperature than the free electrons. The paper is entitled: ‘Effects of Applied DC Radial Electric Fields on Particle Transport in a Bumpy Torus Plasma’. Note that notion of 'temperature' as a sufficient measure of energy. What was meant was that the heavy ions have acquired a much greater energy than the electrons, whereas, seen as a kind of gas, they were supposed to have the same mean energy and so the same temperature. This was a report arising from reasearch aimed at nuclear fusion and here was energy gain by the heavy ions that are supposedly going to fuse and so deliver energy once containment and higher temperatures are reached. That observed energy gain surely warranted full investigation.

    In that same year I saw a paper by J. D. Sethian, D. A. Hammer and C. B. Wharton in Physical Review Letters, 40, 451 (1978) and quote the following words from that paper saying that they have found:

    “Experimental evidence for an anomalous electron-ion energy transfer in a relativistic-electron-beam-heated plasma that is 1,000 times faster than can be predicted by classical processes.” At the end of their paper they suggest ‘without particular justification’ that the anomalous factor might be the hydrogen ion to electron mass ratio.

    Here is another example of anomalous energy acquisition by heavy ions in a plasma, the energy per ion being quite enormous compared with the energy of electrons in that plasma, even though standard theory assumes they should have equal mean values.

    Such research is aimed at replicating in a fusion reactor a process believed to be occurring in the sun and, for some reason, ignoring what my earlier papers have offered as explanation, those involved have not seen the common link, the fact that the sun's corona contains heavy ions that have energies far in excess (by a factor of the order of 160 greater) of that of the electrons that are seen as having the sun's temperature of 6000 degrees.

    [p. 5]

    Surely there is a natural physical process occurring by which apportionment of energy in a heavy ion-electron plasma favours the heavy ions in a very substantial way.

    Assuming that I am right in declaring that an out-of-balance linear force action is asserted by the electromagnetic reference frame intrinsic to the medium I call the aether but which otherwise can be referred to as the quantum underworld, that medium may well be supplying that excess energy. Otherwise, it surely is interfering with the interaction between electrons and heavy ions in a way which promotes energy transfer from electrons to those ions.

    Now I have stated that my writings on this matter, and particularly my 1969 paper in the Journal of the Franklin Institute, have not been heeded. I must correct that statement. There is just one instance, a quite important instance, where a researcher in Canada, Dr. Paulo Correa, somehow discovered that paper and saw its relevance to what he had discovered experimentally in his plasma discharge research. He and his wife, Alexandra Correa, in their laboratory research had discovered an anomalous inflow of energy that justified seeking patent protection for their project. My paper was a supporting reference mentioned by the Corrrea's in the patent description of their appatratus. The relevant U.S. patents are numbered 5,416,391 (issued May 16, 1995), 5,449,989 (issued September 12, 1995) and 5,502,354 (issued March 26, 1996).

    Indeed, owing to the significance of that research, I did myself in 1996 write and publish a 35 page Report entitled Power from Space: The Correa Invention, which is now of record in the Report section of my website www.aspden.org.

    Conclusion

    As a conclusion I submit that there is something wrong with a highly academic scientific community funded to a large extent by governments concerned with our future energy resource problems, when research discoveries of this kind can be ignored. It seems that there can only be advances which conform strictly with scientific doctrines that are of textbook record without heeding discoveries which happen to emerge from free-lance research that trespasses outside textbook territory.

    Electrodynamics was founded upon experiments confined to the interaction involving an electron current carried around a closed wire circuit and experiment shows that textbook doctrine cannot cope with strange energy phenomena seen in plasma research where heavy ions are involved.

    Is there an aether medium permeating all space or not? Textbook knowledge assures students that the aether has been eradicated, thanks to the doctrines proposed by Albert Einstein. So, if the aether is feeding energy into those plasma discharges studied by the Correas, that cannot be accepted and it is deemed appropriate to look elsewhere for our future energy resources. Where to look? Our fusion reactor research, of course, a seemingly never-ending quest, that even reveals its own anomalies. Energy seems to be creeping into the heavy ions from some mysterious source, but that has yet to warrant special study in its own right without us having to wait for the breakthrough that might come when a 100,000,000 degree temperature can be sustained for a long enough period without triggering our extinction.

    I say we cannot be sure the sun is powered by nuclear fusion. Indeed I am sure it is not. However, we can be sure that energy is finding its way into heavy ions in a plasma contrary to accepted scientific principles and those in authority having concern for our energy future should heed the message here presented.

    [p. 6]

    H. Aspden 30 October 2005

  • ARP 7 (2005): Our Physics World and Its Problems


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    OUR PHYSICS WORLD AND ITS PROBLEMS

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    This paper was offered for publication to the Editor of Physics World, the member’s journal of the U.K. Institute of Physics. This was shortly after reading the September 2005 issue of that journal. However, the response received was that the suggestion in the paper that the sun might not be powered by a nuclear reaction was deemed too risky for publication to be accepted and so he well understood, as I had indicated with my submission, that I would be publishing the paper on my website.

    ****************

    Here an Engineer cum European Patent Attorney who became a member of the Institute of Physics in 1983 at the age of 55 comments on our physics world and, with hindsight and a lifelong interest in physical science, draws attention to our problems.

    I decided to write these words after reading through the September 2005 issue of Physics World. In the News and Analysis section on page 13 there is the title ‘Hydrogen results cause controversy’ telling us that Mills and coworkers in USA ‘have observed a range of phenomena that cannot be explained by standard atomic and plasma physics’. It would appear that a new unconventional source of energy is on the horizon, with findings confirmed by independent researchers in Netherlands, but with its discoverer claiming that the hydrogen atom can exist in a state involving what are said to be hitherto unheard of ‘hydrinos’.

    As a mere reader interested in both physics and new energy technology this reminded me of a book written by Keith Tutt, a graduate of Bristol University, who in 1993 won a prestigious Science Journalism of the Year Award for his documentary ‘Killing us Softly’ about Sizewell ‘B’ nuclear power station. That book ‘The Search for Free Energy’, published in 2001, devoted a whole 19 page chapter to the subject of the saga of what Randell Mills claims to have discovered.

    So here is a news item that tells us of a discovery of some years standing that might impact our energy future but, as is so often the case, the inventor has a theory as to how it works, one that physicists justifiably question, but yet there are still questions to be answered in the light of experimental findings. The problem is not whether the hydrino theory is right, but rather whether the supporting experimental evidence will be heeded, assuming the theory is incorrect.

    Page 12 of Physics World opposite to this item, there is ‘A physicist’s view of energy supply’, which tells us that nuclear power should be expanded, though the author, a British physicist, ends by saying “Whether fusion could solve the world’s energy needs in the long term remains to be seen, but it’s certainly imaginable.” That is indeed a

    [p. 2]

    problem, given 50 years of past effort and an outlook that contemplates success only in a matter of decades from now.

    Given that the folklore of physics assures us that the sun, which comprises hydrogen, is powered by heat generated by nuclear fusion, one can hardly look ahead to the future feeling confident that what we might ‘imagine’ will solve our future energy problems, especially as doubts are being raised as to the very structure and composition of the hydrogen atom. I use the word ‘folklore’ because I have never seen an answer to the puzzle of how it is that some of the sun’s hydrogen atoms can be ionized without their protons, then free and having a mass 1836 times that of the electron and so being subject to a very much stronger mutual gravitational interaction than applies between electrons, not thereby causing the sun to have a positively charged core. That surely should mean setting up repulsive electrostatic forces which preclude compression and mean that the sun has a uniform pressure and so a uniform mass density of 1.41 times that of water throughout its entire body, hardly a recipe for inducing a fusion reaction in its central core.

    Such are the problems with which we contend. The primary focus for research interest is driven by the need for funding on a large scale to pursue research interests in space probes, high energy particle colliders, nuclear fusion and the like and the, albeit doubtful, claims of discovery of anomalous energy effects by outsiders are treated as mere noise in a background of primary effort governed by that funding need.

    By page 15, the Editor invites readers to wonder if we are ‘Living in a dodecahedral universe’ as we address the mysteries of “dark” energy in a flat universe which a French astrophysicist discusses on pages 22-28 under the title ‘A cosmic hall of mirrors’. Research on that subject is aimed at choosing between alternative cosmological models and depends on the outcome of space probes in the years ahead but one can hardly think that that will lead us to the energy source that can sustain our needs.

    Then we come to pages 29-31 where a U.S. scientist now tells us about ‘Strange events in the proton’, where we are looking into the composition of the hydrogen atomic nucleus, the proton. We are told that there is a ‘spin’crisis owing to strange quarks inside the proton. One reads: ‘Once the contribution of the strange quark is known with better precision, theorists should be able to build a consistent mathematical picture of the structure of the proton by including strange quarks in computer simulations of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong force.’

    Now, at risk here of seeming cynical, there was a time in the history of physics when, in 1920, Rutherford here in Britain coined the name proton for the hydrogen nucleus and when it was then believed that the nuclei of heavier atoms were composed of a combination of protons and electrons, but a problem arose from what was referred to as ‘nuclear spin’. Physicists could not understand what determined the magnetic moment of the proton. They had a proton ‘spin’ crisis then but that was before the ‘quark’ era. Rutherford, also by 1920, had coined the name neutron to describe the electrically neutral combination of a proton and an electron as a single particle. It was only later in 1932 that Chadwick, a longtime associate of Rutherford, discovered the neutron we speak of today. Thereafter, our picture of the atomic nuclei of atoms other than hydrogen ceased to be a mere combination of protons and electrons and instead became a combination of neutrons and protons, the electron having been banished from the nucleus owing to the problem posed by combination of spin magnetic moment moments.

    [p. 3]

    So the proton has been on our minds for 85 or so years and we are still trying to figure out what it is. This is in spite of the fact that its mass in terms of the mass of the electron has been measured to a precision well below one part in ten million and its magnetic moment to well within one part in a million. Such numbers are coded messages that need to be deciphered, but one needs to visualize the right structural basis that can account for those numbers in physical terms. What I find difficult to understand is why it is that we now say there are no electrons in the atomic nuclei, relying on it being impossible because electrons have a property not exhibited by such nuclei, namely too high a spin magnetic moment, whereas we say atomic nuclei contain neutrons without heeding the very important fact that neutrons have the property of a lifetime measured in minutes, whereas most atomic nuclei are stable particles. Where is the theory that accounts for the lifetime of the neutron, telling us why it decays in its free state and does not decay if part of the atomic nucleus?

    In my opinion, until we have accepted a viable theory that can explain the proton-electron mass ratio, the magnetic moment of the proton, along with the magnetic moment of the neutron as well as proton and neutron structure plus neutron lifetime, we cannot be sure of anything on this subject. That is the real problem facing the world of physics, whether we are interested in the creation of the universe or the energy source which created it and which might come to our aid if we fathom its mysteries.

    As to that effort to probe proton structure in terms of QCD theory, I recall reading in 1985 the following item in SCIENCE NEWS, v. 128, p. 88:

    “So far, IBM has been conspicuously absent from the supercomputer market, now dominated by Cray Research, Inc., and Control Data Corp., both based in Minneapolis. However, news of at least one IBM research effort in high-speed computing surfaced in last month’s National Computer Conference in Chicago. A team of physicists will soon take over a specially built computer designed to solve a single physics problem. According to an IBM official, this computer is supposed to take less than a year to solve a problem that would take a Cray-1 supercomputer more than 300 years to do. The IBM machine consists of an array of 576 processors, each one capable of 20 million ‘floating point’ operations per second. The machine will be used to calculate the mass of a proton from ‘first principles’, applying quantum chromodynamics theory. This year-long exercise should give physicists some clues as to the validity of their concepts about quarks and gluons.” That was in 1985 and yet, twenty years on, in 2005 we are now told by an article in Physics World that ‘Once the contribution of the strange quark is known with better precision, theorists should be able to build a consistent mathematical picture of the structure of the proton by including strange quarks in computer simulations of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong force.’

    Computer technology may have improved in that time but I, for one, am not excited by the prospect of success in this venture, given that I never did hear the outcome of that colossal IBM attempt to test the QCD theory as applied to proton structure some twenty years ago.

    On pages 33-38 of that September 2005 issue of Physics World one reads what Matthew Stanley of the Department of History at Iowa State University has to say about

    [p. 4]

    our Cambridge Professor Arthur Eddington, famous for his solar eclipse expedition which confirmed a feature of Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity. Stanley tells us how Eddington explained the energy source that causes stars to shine basing his argument on compliance with the gas laws. In reading that I found it enlightening but remain puzzled as to the answer to my problem above concerning that question of ionization and the alternative belief that nuclear fusion is involved. My interest in Eddington arises more from his attempts to decipher the numerical significance of the basic dimensionless constants of physics, notably the proton-electron mass ratio, solution of which problem, as stated above, would give us insight into the structure and form of the proton itself. Thereafter on pages 40-44, preceding two book reviews, there is an article on silicon microelectronics by Japanese and Hong Kong authors, a subject that was of considerable interest to me in earlier times when I was IBM’s Director of European Patent Operations, but having retired in 1983 to indulge in my interest, our energy future and more fundamental physics topics, one on which I will not comment.

    As to book reviews, the first was entitled ‘The future of nuclear power’, indeed a subject warranting concern, and the second ‘The life of the brightest star’, a subject in which I was also interested. The first review concerned a book by William J Nuttall and entitled: ‘Nuclear Renaissance: Technologies and Policies for the Future of Nuclear Power’ and the second referred to two books: ‘Fred Hoyle: A Life of Science’ by Simon Mitton and ‘Fred Hoyle’s Universe’ by Jane Gregory.

    I fully agree with the concept advocated by Hoyle that we live in a steady-state universe in which matter in continuously being created. However, to justify my belief, two important points need clarification. Firstly, one must explain why the Hubble time constant is not a measure of a Doppler effect indicating an expanding universe. Secondly, one needs to emphasize that protons and electrons appear to have an infinite lifetime, solely because, if they decay, they are the favoured particle form which Mother Nature immediately recreates with the energy so released. Since we cannot tell one proton from another or one electron from another, they appear as stable particles in a steady-state universe that, as Hoyle believed, is one in which matter is continuously created. It is just that it can only feed on energy being shed either by radiation or particle decay.

    So, as a reader of Physics World interested in the fundamentals of physical science, the September 2005 issue warranted my full attention. I add that, my university education and Ph.D. research years being in the Electrical Engineering field, hence my interest in the energy theme, I cannot help, as an engineer by training, posing another puzzle, that of why physicists accept Maxwell’s equations for electromagnetic wave propagation without concern for dynamic balance. A wave has something physical in motion lateral to its direction of propagation and lateral motion can only occur if there are two components, one in dynamic balance with the other with their energy ratio being a function of wave frequency. So, if physicists need to understand how light from distant stars can propagate without frequency dispersion but with loss of frequency, as needed to avoid the Doppler interpretation of stellar red shift, and if matter is being created throughout space, then one needs to see one such wave component shedding energy in greater measure than the other. Keep in mind that waves traversing one another in opposite directions somehow know their frequency. Here lies the alternative answer that explains the Hubble time constant, but I have yet to see the story of this mentioned in Physics World. Here is another problem for

    [p. 5]

    the physics world, a belief in the Big Bang theory and an expanding universe, that is based on wave theory that defies engineering common sense.

    To be sure physics is a subject that challenges our creative faculties on a worldwide scale and the authors of what we read in Physics World will, as for this issue, include many of overseas location. However, given a personal interest in the proton, the most basic particle form that accounts for our universe, I do wonder what is currently emerging in Britain on the subject of the proton.

    Can it be that the readers of Physics World would be interested in a British initiative on this proton question that dates back to1975, one which was recognized ten years later, by the foremost experts on measuring its value (R. S. Van Dyck, Jr., F. L. Moore, D. L. Farnham and P. B. Schwinberg, Int. J. Mass Spectroscopy and Ion Processes, 66, 327; 1985)? They had measured its value to within a precision of 41 parts in a billion and included the following comment in their paper:

    “The value that they [Aspden and Eagles] calculate is remarkably close to our experimentally measured value (i.e. within two standard deviations). This is even more curious when one notes that they published this result several years before direct precision measurements of this ratio had begun.” Yes, that surely is a remarkable result, a severe test for any theory. It was later, in 1988, that this same theory of the proton developed sufficiently to afford a theoretical evaluation of the proton magnetic moment as being 2.792847367 in nuclear magnetons, which, as can be seen, compared quite well with the CODATA measurement value of 2.792847386(63). I reported this in Hadronic Journal, 11, 169-176, (1988) and it certainly did not involve anything remotely resembling QCD theory, being founded on a simple physical concept that the spin properties of a particle are those exhibited by its charge and mass-energy as confined within a radius defined by an enveloping wave-defined boundary. That paper is entitled ‘The Theory of the Proton Constants’ and it is appropriate here to mention my earlier paper of equal importance entitled ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Neutron and the Deuteron’ that appeared in Hadronic Journal, 9, 129-136 (1986). Should this be of interest, both of these papers are fully recorded on the website www.aspden.org.

    I add one final comment aroused by reading through the September 2005 issue of Physics World, which concerns the page 64 commentary under Lateral Thoughts by Simon Singh who refers to the ‘unutterable beauty’ of the equation E = Mc2 and, of course, refers to this as ‘Einstein’s equation’. Physicists in Britain in the early years of the 20th

    century would, I am sure, have agreed as to the importance of this equation, but have seen it more in the context of their knowledge even back in the late 19th century of the formulation of the mass of the electron as being equal to 2e2/3a, where e is the charge of the electron in electromagnetic units and a is the assumed radius of that electron charge. A 1904 textbook on Physical Science authored by a Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, told us about J. J. Thomson’s use of that relationship in showing how its variation with electron speed ranging up to 95% of the speed of light could explain the threefold mass increase observed. Every physics student surely knows that, if electron charge e is expressed in electrostatic units, that formulation would represent energy, so the ratio of electrostatic units to electromagnetic units, being c, that student can surely see that the energy of the electron is equal to c2 times its mass.

    [p. 6]

    So, to my way of ‘lateral thinking’, our student community should not be expected to believe that the great British physicists of the pre-Einstein era, needed Einstein to tell them that energy is equivalent to mass times c2. Is this a problem? Yes it is, because of that ‘folklore’ theme I mentioned above. Who, I wonder, will challenge my comment that the sun is not powered by hot nuclear fusion?

    Harold Aspden

    20th October, 2005

  • ASPDEN RESEARCH PAPERS

    ASPDEN RESEARCH PAPERS

    This sequence of papers dates from 19th July 2004, the author having decided that from then on the subject of this website should be advanced by providing a series of papers under the above title ‘Aspden Research Papers’. Some of these papers will appear here as soon as they are completed. The first paper, No. 1 of 2004, is one such paper. Of the others, as the are written, some few will be offered to scientific journals for publication in the scientific peer-reviewed literature and, if rejected, will then appear here in due course, whereas those accepted will be duly recorded elsewhere on this website. Otherwise they will be posted directly here on this website.

    Harold Aspden




    Press to return to the main site index.
  • ARP 8 (2005): Solar Energy and Three Questions


    Converted from the text of the PDF above; superscripts, italics and the author’s layout are kept, figures and tables are cut from its pages. [p. N] marks where each PDF page begins.

    [p. 1]

    SOLAR ENERGY AND THREE QUESTIONS

    © H. Aspden, 2005

    Introduction

    The universe could not exist in the absence of a source of energy and there is good reason to believe that what we observe in our experiments as electron-positron particle pair creation is the ongoing interplay between matter and a hidden source of energy that pervades all space. Therefore, since our technology has made us dependent upon the Earth's hydrocarbon decay products which are now dwindling away, we really need to know the answers to certain fundamental questions pertaining to energy science. One must surely wonder if there is scope for tapping into the primary energy source that created our universe and so we need answers to three questions. These are:

    Question No. 1: Is the Sun really powered by the energy of nuclear fusion or can it be that the energy it radiates is drawn directly from the energy source that governs the underworld of space that physicists portray, unknowingly, by their formulations of quantum theory?

    Question No. 2: When the Sun was created how did it acquire its angular momentum, meaning why did it begin to spin, given that material objects do not turn of their own accord but need something external to apply the necessary torque?

    Question No. 3: When the Sun was created how did it acquire its cosmic motion, meaning its motion of 390±60 km/s relative to the cosmic radiation background, as measured in 1977 by G. F. Smoot, M. V. Gorenstein and R. A. Muller, Physical Review Letters, 39, 898, that quite possibly being motion relative to that underworld source of energy?

    The Answers?

    What, you may wonder, are the answers to these three questions? Physicists in general will assure you that the Sun, most definitely, is powered by the nuclear fusion of its hydrogen atoms as they combine to form deuterium and helium and so, guided by that belief, they urge costly research aimed at developing nuclear fusion reactors, hoping to succeed in that quest before our oil and gas reserves are wholly exhausted. This is in spite of the fact that half a century of such research has led nowhere. It is in spite of the fact that the Sun has a surface temperature of about 6000 degrees, whereas nuclear physicists declare that it needs a temperature of 100,000,000 degrees to trigger nuclear fusion. This they say exists in the centre of the Sun but then one must wonder why that has not initiated a chain reaction resulting in the total annihilation of the Sun and us with it in one mighty explosion, given that this is the technology of the hydrogen bomb.

    My own answer to Question No. 1 is different but it relies on the answers to Questions Nos 2 and 3 of which physicists are less confident. Yes, as to Question No. 2, you might be told that the Sun acquired its spin thanks to the very rare event of a very close encounter with another star that happened to pass close by in its transit through space. Alternatively you will be assured that, since all stars were created at the same time in what is described as a Big Bang birth of the whole universe, the close interaction and collision

    [p. 2]

    of stars when born would cause some stars to spin in one sense and others to spin in the opposite sense. On such argument the Big Bang can also be said to account also for the answer to Question No. 3 but the simple truth is that this is all a matter of speculation, speculation that has no relevance to a possible solution of our emerging energy problems. Only their belief that the Sun is powered by nuclear fusion and their hope that we can replicate the physical process involved in a nuclear reactor remains. It is a hope that always seems to promise success on the far horizon when those in charge of the project know they are due to retire.

    So, as humanity struggles to eliminate conflict and build a better world for future generations, those who guide in the search for power, meaning real power, that which needs an energy source, are wandering in the dark and losing confidence. Why else would their thoughts be concerned with the possible dangers ahead, as envisaged in the unpredictable outcome of their costly government-funded experiments? Here I have in mind the recent book entitled 'Our Last Century' by Martin Rees, now Lord Rees, the Master of Trinity College, Cambridge who tells us of the need to weigh the risk that certain experimental projects might have deadly consequences, not just for those closely involved but for everyone on Earth.

    For me this becomes a message which says that physicists have to change their ideas as to the fundamental theory that accounts for the creation of matter and pay attention when someone claims to have discovered something that does not quite conform with what they have come to believe. Maybe our Sun is not powered by nuclear fusion. Maybe it spins because that invisible source of energy has supplied the necessary angular momentum. Maybe it moves through the cosmic radiation background because it has been pushed by a force asserted by that same invisible source of energy. Maybe even there are of record reports that hint at anomalous phenomena associated with release or gain of energy and a state of spin. Maybe also there are of record experiments involving electrical discharges in which anomalous reaction forces are asserted on the electrodes of the discharge apparatus. Maybe the latter phenomenon has already been encountered in those experiments aimed at discovering a route to power by nuclear fusion but discarded as being unimportant, though still interesting enough to warrant mention in the vast archives of scientific literature that define and measure the academic prowess of members of the scientific community.

    In what follows I will enlighten you as to the reality of this 'maybe' scenario since all the necessary answers have emerged from a private research interest that I have pursued for more than half a century and all I seek by this web site is to share my findings with fellow scientists in the hope that they will see a better way forward in their search for a new energy source.

    Proton Creation

    One such finding, the most important, is the explanation of how the proton is created, the proton being the nucleus of the hydrogen atom which accounts for 99.95% of its total mass and so, hydrogen being the primary constituent of the Sun, is highly relevant to our discussion above.

    I mention this first in order to present, as it were, my credentials, before getting too involved in the onward discussion.

    My Ph.D. research at Trinity College, Cambridge, dates from 1950-53 and concerned an anomalous energy phenomenon associated with ferromagnetism. Sadly, the

    [p. 3]

    anomaly concerned an excess loss of energy, whereas what we now wish to see is an anomalous energy gain. I was interested in how the loss was affected by mechanical stress and why iron, nickel and cobalt are ferromagnetic. This led me to picture a structured system of electric charges (certain electron states of adjacent atoms) sharing, in synchronism, an orderly orbital motion that could relate energy and angular momentum. I then came to realise that I could translate that 'picture' into a form representing the hidden energy source of the quantum underworld, but knew that if I spoke of this I would then be seeking to revive a belief in something that had been pronounced dead by the physics community, namely the aether, and so prudence prevailed and my thesis was restricted to the energy anomaly research.

    I then left Cambridge to enter the corporate world of industry, seven years with English Electric Co. Ltd and then twenty-three years with IBM before taking early retirement and, with IBM's initial sponsorship, resuming my own research interests at Southampton University close to where I live. That absorbed the next nine years following which I now pursue this interest from my home in my retirement years.

    However, half a century ago, within a year or so of leaving Cambridge, my thoughts reverted to that picture I had formed of synchronous electron orbital motion within the atoms of a structured ferromagnetic crystal as being analogous to the properties of what was possibly the quantum underworld energy source that regulates our universe and accounts for its creation. So it was back in the 1950s that I first began to indulge in this research interest in my own time with no work connection and, amongst other research findings, came to see how a state of spin could be set up by interaction between matter and that quantum energy underworld. Eventually this led to an insight into how protons are created. It emerged in stages and it was not until 1975 that the scientific paper showing how to calculate the proton-electron mass ratio was published. It was entitled: 'Calculation of the Proton Mass in a Lattice Model for the Aether', and its reference is Il Nuovo Cimento, 30A, 235-238 (1975). The paper, though of fundamental importance, was duly ignored by the scientific community, no doubt because it relied on the existence of that all-pervading energy medium in space, one that could impart rotation to matter when created, but a medium which physicists prefer to ignore because they wish to rely on the empirical concepts that they refer to as 'quantum theory' and dislike mention of the word 'aether'.

    I found this surprising because I was not the sole author of that paper. Dr. D. M. Eagles, a well-recognized English physicist, a Ph.D. of London University, who had worked in USA for NASA and by then had moved to The National Measurement Laboratory in Australia, had taken an interest in my research findings and our collaboration resulted in that paper on proton creation theory. Physics, it seems, is not simply a search for the fundamental scientific truth but rather, given the need for recognition and research funding, a contest for popularity of ideas, with intruding proposals ignored if that means backtracking and a change of direction.

    This did not worry me, inasmuch as I had a very busy and responsible activity in my work with IBM as head of their European Patent Operations as well as involvements internationally with the professional activity of the patent scene but the time came when I decided that my scientific interest was more than enough to deal with without having the constant burden of travel abroad on company business.

    It was in 1983 that I retired from IBM to concentrate fully on my research interest and document my findings in scientific papers once again bearing a university affiliation

    [p. 4]

    address and so having an enhanced chance of acceptance. Then, one day in 1985 I received a letter which drew my attention to the remarkable fact that IBM had embarked on a mammoth computer task, that of calculating the proton-electron mass ratio, based on what had come to be known as QCD (Quantum Chromodynamics). The task was seen as so formidable that it was expressed in the following words:

    "So far, IBM has been conspicuously absent from the supercomputer market, now dominated by Cray Research, Inc., and Control Data Corp., both based in Minneapolis. However, news of at least one IBM research effort in high-speed computing surfaced at last month's National Computer Conference in Chicago. A team of physicists will soon take over a specially built computer designed to solve a single physics problem. According to an IBM official, this computer is supposed to take less than a year to solve a problem that would take a Cray-1 supercomputer more than 300 years to do. The IBM machine consists of an array of 576 processors, each one capable of 20 million 'floating point' operations per second. The machine will be used to calculate the mass of a proton from 'first principles', applying quantum chromodynamics theory. This year-long exercise should give physicists some clues as to the validity of their concepts about quarks and gluons."

    SCIENCE NEWS, v. 128, p. 88.

    Until I read this I had no idea that IBM had the slightest interest in the problem of determining the theoretical value of the proton-electron mass ratio. With my 1975 paper in mind and since IBM was sponsoring provision of my research facilities at Southampton University in England, I then wrote to the Director of Research of IBM in USA merely to draw his attention to that paper, which had indicated my IBM affiliation.

    This was the reply I received, dated October 2, 1985: "Dear Dr. Aspden:

    As you correctly surmise, the object of the IBM effort in this area is to test, quantitatively, QCD. In order to do so, we want to calculate the proton mass, the masses of a variety of other hadrons, as well as other testable predictions of that theory. These calculations therefore are completely unrelated to any other calculations of the proton mass that may have been performed previously using other approaches.

    In general, our writings on this subject have clearly emphasized that the testing of QCD is the object, and we will continue to emphasize this point.

    We appreciate your taking the time to communicate to us your concerns about the Science News item. Sincerely yours, Ralph E. Gomory Senior Vice President and Director of Research"

    So you see, IBM's interest was merely in proving the prowess of their computer capability, which I could well understand, but I confess that I never saw anything reported as to the result obtained from that QCD effort. Later I bought a book published in 1986 entitled 'Introduction to Gauge Field Theory' by D. Bailin and A. Love, thinking that this,

    [p. 5]

    in dealing with QCD, would mention what might be involved in the proton-electron mass ratio calculation, but it did not. QCD, quantum chromodynamics, as these authors state, is based on the colour SU(3) group. It concerns what are referred to as quarks and their 'colour indices' and what seems to be a never-ending sequence of mathematical formulations. It is implied that quarks exist as individual entities having an electric charge that is a one-third or two-third fraction of the proton charge or electron charge, whereas common sense might suggest that the real scenario concerns groups of unitary charges which, by exchange of energy, with charge pairs being annihilated and then being recreated and existing for different fractions of time might only seem to exist as fractional charge.

    If our understanding of the creation of matter depends upon such ideas as we see in QCD then we may as well give up any hope of onward progress. As to that 1975 paper of mine it was in that very same year 1985, in which the IBM QCD initiative to calculate the proton-electron mass ratio was announced that the foremost experts on measuring its value (R. S. Van Dyck, Jr., F. L. Moore, D. L. Farnham and P. B. Schwinberg, Int. J. Mass Spectroscopy and Ion Processes, 66, 327, 1985 ) were able to report on the most precise measurement of that quantity ever made. They had measured it to within a precision of 41 parts in a billion. That is an almost incredible degree of precision, my theoretical calculation of that quantity resulting in the value 1836.15232, but that was not intended to be precise to the last two digits.

    I therefore felt somewhat gratified when this paper was drawn to my attention by Dr. Eagles and I read the words:

    "The value that they [Aspden and Eagles] calculate is remarkably close to our experimentally measured value (i.e. within two standard deviations). This is even more curious when one notes that they published this result several years before direct precision measurements of this ratio had begun."

    Even that, however, has not aroused any real academic interest in what I am now discussing on this web site, namely our understanding on how the Sun, the mass of which is almost wholly that of protons, was created and the energy source involved. Accordingly, in writing these words in October 2005, I mention that I have spent the last few months writing a book of modest size entitled 'Creation: The Physical Truth' which I expect to appear in print early in 2006. Henceforth, apart from periodically updating this web site and my related web site www.aspden.org, I now intend that to be my final effort to bring some enlightenment as to the mysteries of solar creation, with its spin-off implications for our future energy resource.

    The Preferred Answers

    The book in its Part I provides the detailed answer to Question No. 2 above and I urge anyone interested in the subject to read that work and in turn urge others to engage in onward research aimed at exploiting that supply of energy that accounts for the spin action and is active everywhere throughout space. The way forward in that pursuit, as regards the issue covered by Question No. 2, involves establishing within a dielectric medium an electrostatic field radially directed from a central axis and somehow inducing pulsations that are associated with energy inflow. As to the Sun, it being ionized and thanks to the effect of gravity asserting a stronger pull between protons than between electrons, that is what accounts for it having an internal radial electric field and, as a one-off initial event, the energy inflow accompanied by angular momentum that causes it to spin.

    [p. 6]

    I leave it to that new book to brief the reader on that subject, but just mention here that my case is founded in part on my discovery of a serious error in classical physical theory and its correction. The error concerns what is referred to as 'Earnshaw's Theorem', which, as can be seen from a paper by J. Reece Roth, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-6, No. 2, June 1978, is part of the folk lore of plasma research connected with nuclear fusion. Radial electric fields supposedly cannot help to stabilize a plasma discharge, but that quantum underworld energy resource that fed angular momentum to the Sun defies Earnshaw's Theorem, and radial electric fields do, as reported by that 1978 paper, have a way of causing the heavy ions in a plasma to have a much higher temperature than the free electrons. The paper is entitled: 'Effects of Applied DC Radial Electric Fields on Particle Transport in a Bumpy Torus Plasma'.

    As to what sustains the energy inflow needed to feed solar radiation, the subject of Question No. 1, I can but point to the activity we see as solar flares, which focusses attention on the relatively quite small amount of electrostatic ionization energy enveloping the body of the Sun. I suggest that ions, whether electrons or protons, are oscillating sporadically in a radial sense with respect to the centre of the Sun and so effectively inducing pulsations in a radial electric field in the Sun's photosphere. A pulsating radial field will cause energy inflow owing to the phase-lock that exists as between regions of the energy medium that are within the body of the Sun and those that are external to that body. The point here is that the external energy system of the quantum underworld is so powerful that it overpowers the internal energy system by keeping its quantum activity in synchronism and so in step with the quantum activity within that photosphere region but in so doing causes small superimposed angular momentum oscillations in the body of the Sun to draw in kinetic energy which can only be returned to the enveloping energy system as thermal radiation. I am leaving it to others to develop the necessary theory. My guess is that the Sun's temperature is regulated by two criteria. If the temperature is too high the ejected ions will range over a further distance from the Sun's surface and so take longer before collapsing back to that surface, which means an excess rate of cooling. Upon cooling to a lower temperature ejected ions will have lower speeds but with less range before collapsing inwards the time cycle will be faster and so the heat generated by the angular momentum fluctuation will then be greater than the rate of energy radiation and so the Sun will find a level of temperature equilibrium.

    Question No. 3 is not dealt with in that new book of mine. It finds its answer, not in electrostatic action, as does Question No. 2, but rather in electrodynamic action owing to the interaction between electrons and protons as a function of their motion relative to the structure of the quantum underworld, the omnipresent energy system. The latter provides the frame of electromagnetic reference and we are concerned here with a process involving interaction forces that have a rather special property, one that precludes the setting up of a turning couple but can assert linear force action as between matter and that quantum underworld, force action that involves also energy transfer as between matter and the energy of that underworld.

    I did not discuss electrodynamic interaction forces in 'Creation: The Physical Truth' because it involves mathematics in vector form and I sought to concentrate on the easier analysis essential to the primary issue, namely gravitation, the creation of protons and stars, and the physical form of that quantum energy medium. As explained in my book 'Physics Unified' published in 1980, I did, by a paper published in the Journal of the Franklin Institute, 287, 179, (1969), show how avoidance of turning couple reaction could avoid

    [p. 7]

    reliance on an empirical aspect of the law of electrodynamic interaction between two moving charges and thereby reveal the correct formulation of that law. It was found that if the interaction involved charges of opposite charge polarity and different mass then the particle of heavier mass could be subject to a dominant force component in its line of forward motion in proportion to its mass ratio in relation to the other charge. So where we have protons sharing a forward motion with an entourage of electrons flowing towards those protons owing to their mutual electrostatic interaction there will be a quite strong out-of-balance linear force acting on the protons and accelerating them to higher speed in the forward direction. This will seem to be an anomalous effect but it has firm physical foundation and is surely an indicator that the quantum underworld that defines the electromagnetic frame of reference is asserting force on the proton system and that means supplying energy as necessary.

    If you find this hard to believe then take note that historical record includes reports of experiments in which anomalous cathode reaction forces have been measured in electrical discharge tubes classified as 'cold cathode' devices, meaning that heavy ions and not electrons are flowing through the tubes with electron current closing the current loop. This is a system in which the electrons in motion external to the tube interact electrodynamically with heavy positive ions in motion inside the tube. Where, you may well wonder has this been explained? Only by me, so far as I know!

    Why, with all the money spent on high energy heavy ion discharges in nuclear fusion research, has this phenomenon not revealed itself? The answer is that it has, but the finding has been ignored – left without explanation – in spite of my own earlier published work on this classical electrodynamic problem. I refer here to the paper in Physical Review Letters, 40, 451 (1978) by J. D. Sethian, D. A. Hammer and C. B. Wharton and quote the following words from that paper saying that they have found:

    "Experimental evidence for an anomalous electron-ion energy transfer in a relativistic-electron-beam-heated plasma that is 1,000 times faster than can be predicted by classical processes."

    At the end of their paper they suggest 'without particular justification' that the anomalous factor might be the hydrogen ion to electron mass ratio.

    So there you are. With all the money being spent on nuclear fusion research, here is an energy anomaly encountered but left unexplained in spite of that paper of mine published in USA back in 1969, a paper which showed why that anomalous force exists in proportion to that ion-electron mass ratio.

    Perhaps you are now ready for the answer to that Question No. 3. The Sun was formed by hydrogen atoms coming together owing to the pull of gravity. So much hydrogen was involved that the gravitational pressure compressed the hydrogen to the point at which electrons in adjacent atoms could collide and so be set free. That means ionization and, yes, we know the Sun is ionized. However, it only takes a very limited amount of ionization to free just enough protons for the Sun to acquire a positive net electrical charge density, the self-repulsion of which is exactly balanced by the mutual gravitational attraction effective between matter forming the whole body of the Sun. So here we have the message that the Sun has a uniform mass density over the whole volume enclosed by its radiating surface. That means that we can calculate its energy content.

    That balance of gravitational action and electrostatic action tells us that the net core charge is a positive charge of amount Q equal to the Sun's mass M times G, where G is the

    [p. 8]

    constant of gravitation. If R is the Sun's radius then school textbook physics tells us that the gravitational energy potential of the Sun is 3GM2/5R. This is negative energy in the sense that it is energy released by the action of gravity in forming the Sun but, owing to that equality of pressure and that relationship between Q and M times G, it is exactly balanced by the electrostatic potential energy of that positive charge Q. So let us now consider the remaining electrostatic energy components, namely the self-energy of the balancing negative electron charge Q that is held in place at the surface of the body of the Sun by electrostatic attraction and the separate electrostatic energy of that interaction of that negative charge Q and the Sun's positive charge Q. The former is a positive energy quantity, which is Q2/2R, and the latter is a negative energy quantity, which is Q2/R, the difference being the measure of energy released in creating the Sun, energy amounting to Q2/2R.

    What then happened to this energy? Did it convert into heat, as was once believed, enough to sustain the Sun's radiation for a few million years, but not enough to explain a four billion year estimate of the Sun's existence or was it that, in forming as an ionized system of protons and electrons, with protons leaping ahead as they converged to nucleate the body of the Sun, that electrodynamic force action just mentioned imparted linear motion to those protons. In this latter case we can calculate how fast the Sun would then need to move relative to the enveloping cosmic background to absorb that energy. All we have to do is equate MV2/2 and Q2/2R, V being the speed acquired by the Sun, and, since Q2 is GM2, this tells us that GM/R is equal to V2.

    Now as we well know the Sun's mass is very nearly 2×1030 kg, its radius is very nearly 7×108 m and G, the constant of gravitation, is 6.67×10-11 N-m2-kg-2, which means that V in metres per second is approximately the square root of 1.905×1011. This is 436 km/s. Is it not then a curious circumstance to find, as was noted in the introduction above, that our Sun is actually moving through the cosmic background at a speed estimated as 390±60 km/s. Can this be mere coincidence, another physical discovery to be brushed aside and forgotten, or is it that the theoretical case just presented is a true account of the energy that set the Sun in motion, bearing in mind that 436 km/s is within that measured speed range? I leave that issue open for discussion, but for my part I say it is highly relevant and I go one step further by drawing attention to the research findings of Alexandra and Paulo Correa who, by reference to that paper of mine in the Journal of the Franklin Institute have opened the door on tapping aether energy by their PAGD (Pulsed Abnormal Glow Discharge) research findings as reported in their U.S Patents Nos. 5,416,391, 5,449,989 issued in 1995 and No. 5,502,354 issued in 1996.

    Conclusion

    I have sought by this brief introduction to the problem of Solar Energy to arouse interest in a research path that I have followed to satisfy my curiosity as to what it is that determines the values of certain physical constants which are the very foundation for understanding of what we see and experience as the physical world we inhabit. To focus reader's attention I have spoken here solely of the Sun as the topic of interest, inasmuch as the Sun poses the greatest mystery, and we are probably on the wrong track in trying to replicate its energy source by nuclear fusion research. My findings concerning other physical phenomena, as presented in full detail elsewhere, www.aspden.org, relate to the way in which Nature determines the values of those fundamental constants, including

    [p. 9]

    particularly the constant of gravitation, Planck's constant and the detailed derivation of the proton-electron mass ratio.

    Other than clarifying, as necessary, what I have recorded by my past efforts, there is little more that I can contribute in this quest and I just hope that there will be those who read what I have said in my book 'Creation: The Physical Truth' and who periodically refer to this web site where I will duly comment on the feedback I receive from those readers.

    As a final note here it seems appropriate to mention that it was reading that book by Lord Rees entitled 'Our Final Century' that prompted me to try, once again, to get my message across in book form, rather than by merely writing scientific papers or publishing on Internet.

    I will announce on this web site when my book is to be published. It is expected to be in the early part of 2006.

    Harold Aspden 14 November 2005

  • 2004a

    2004a

    The following is a U.K. Patent Application filed by Harold Aspden on March 9, 2002 with a first publication date of January 21, 2004.

    U.K. PATENT NO. 2,390,941

    ‘ELECTRICITY GENERATING APPARATUS’

    Abstract: The apparatus comprises two capacitors having concentric cylindrical electrodes with their central axes aligned mutually parallel. They are connected so that charge can oscillate between them and through an inductor circuit but two electrodes, corresponding electrodes of each capacitor, are connected to a high voltage d.c. source. This delivers no input energy except for the initial priming of the capacitors. By inducing an onset of an oscillation of charge as between the two capacitors such oscillations build up owing to aether spin set up between the capacitor electrodes which imports energy. Power can be drawn from the circuit by a secondary winding that is part of the inductor circuit.