Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Overview

Overview and introductory articles

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • ASPDEN PHYSICS WEB SITE

    PHYSICS WITH ASPDEN





    • Hello….My Name is HAROLD ASPDEN and I live in SOUTHAMPTON, HAMPSHIRE, ENGLAND. I have now removed my E-Mail address from this web page owing to it having attracted too many spam messages and so persons wishing to communicate with me on matters arising from what I here present should do so by mail addressed to me c/o Sabberton, P.O. Box 35, Chilworth, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.

    Welcome to my Physics WEB SITE

    • I am a RETIRED CORPORATE PATENT DIRECTOR having a long-standing interest in fundamental physics, the subject of many papers of published record. My English university background is: Manchester (B.Sc., 1945-1948), Cambridge (Ph.D., 1950-1953) and Southampton (Visiting Senior Research Fellow, 1983-1992). This Web page is headed ‘Physics with Aspden’ because in 1969 I published a book entitled ‘Physics without Einstein’. I sought then, and still seek now, to show how much further we can progress if we follow a course not depending upon Einstein’s philosophy. The book left little impression on the scientific community, probably owing to its title. However, with the passage of time its 2,000 copies were all sold long ago. It is now out-of-print and, as these Web pages grow, I shall be incorporating a copy of that work and my other books and many of my papers as PDF files. These can be read using the Abobe Acrobat Reader which is freely available from Adobe on their Web site

      In developing this Web site I have been compiling my concluding work, which revises and builds on the theme of ‘Physics without Einstein’, its title being ‘The Physics of Creation’.

    • Its first ‘draft edition’ was completed on 28th March 2003 and was duly recorded in these Web pages. Its revised version was completed on 23rd October 2003 and replaced that first draft version. In it you will discover some of the truths of physical science that have eluded mention in standard textbooks on physics. I believe there are two intermeshing worlds, both having three space dimensions, the material world that we can see and the unseen ghost-like underworld that we can sense by phenomena which the orthodox physicist cannot explain, notably gravitation. My subject is ‘Creation’ and the related quest of ‘Unification’, that Holy Grail of the theoretical physicist, which can only be found by those willing to wander in the darkness, probing the fluid-crystal-like structure of the aether, the oscillatory jitter of which accounts for its quantum electrodynamic properties and, arising from its need for dynamic balance, the force of gravitation.

    • With the dawn of the Einstein Year: 2005, I recorded an easily readable introductory work entitled ‘Physics without Einstein: A Centenary Review’, in which I show why Einstein’s Theory of Relativity does not warrant the praise it has received, it having blocked the way forward for better understanding of matter creation and gravitation.

    • The scientific community was, however, in no way ready to heed what I had to say, given that 2005 was seen as a year when physics students should be encouraged to take interest in Einstein’s theory. However, ever conscious that as every day passes we are heading closer to the day when the energy resources we rely on will fail to meet demand and any hope of success based on the prospect of nuclear fusion fades away, the time has come in 2006 to face up to the truth. Accordingly I decided to supplement what I shall be reporting on this website by a more popular and easily readable separately-published book. The book is entitled Creation: The Physical Truth (ISBN 1-84624- 050-6) and was published on October 26, 2006. Details of this new book, together with a message of considerable importance having bearing upon our energy future are now of record on my new and separate website:

      • I now hope to attract feedback which can assist in further clarifying and, if necessary, correcting, my message in this major work. I request such feedback and expect it will guide me in cooperating with those interested in the onward development of understanding the physics of Creation and, by its promulgation, enhancing the education of physics students everywhere.

      • My physics has deeper roots than those of currently-accepted theory and the fruits of my endeavour have yet to blossom above ground, as it were, as they climb from the obscurity of that aether underworld and come to be seen in their full glory by those who live above ground, and not in the far-off imaginary underworld of the Big Bang, the Black Hole and Four-Space.

      • To see the 2005 item ‘Centenary Review’ press:

      • To see the text of the book as presented in its earlier revised version on this website press:

      • To see a listing of the author’s published papers and have access to many of these in PDF (Portable Document Format) using your Acrobat reader facility press:

      • To see a listing of the author’s published books and have PDF access to these as they are eventually entered on this web site press:

      • For those interested in the onward development this website and the author’s quest in developing interest in the physics that can help to solve our future energy resource problems press:

      • For those interested in the background history of the author’s quest in developing the physics recorded in these books and papers press:

      • To escape from this WEB SITE and visit the author’s related technology site, press:


      Harold Aspden

      *****


      The URL of these Internet Web pages is:
      www.aspden.org


  • BIOGRAPHY-2003

    BIOGRAPHICAL NOTES

    THE STRUGGLE FOR ACCEPTANCE

    Having now completed what I intend to be my final book updating my efforts on fundamental physics, I intend to add here a chronological commentary on my perception of onward developments and reactions to what my work has contributed to the field of science.

    Harold Aspden


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    16 April, 2003

    I appreciate being notified on 8 April, 2003 by Patrick Bailey’s E-Mail message, of a new experimental discovery concerning ‘Electrostatic Rotation’ and feel the subject deserves the special comment which opens this new section of my website.

    Electrostatic Rotation

    A news release issued on April 8, 2003 by the University of California, Riverside claimed the discovery of a new physical phenomenon – electrostatic spin. An electric charge sitting stationary on conducting metal spheres can cause rotation of the spheres.

    “The scientists who have discovered electrostatic rotation are Anders Wilstrom, Ph.D. and Armik Khachatourian, Ph.D. Their work has been published in both the Journal of Mathematical Physics and Applied Physics Letters and shows that when a direct current voltage is applied to three metal spheres suspended without friction, the spheres begin to rotate. This newly documented phenomenon has been named ‘electrostatic rotation’.
    This was a surprise and could not be explained by available theory.”

    Yet, as to theory, I can quote the following words from a lecture paper entitled ‘Space, Energy and Creation’ that I delivered to the Physics Department at Cardiff Universty in Wales, some 26 years ago, in 1977.

    “We know that when an astronomical body is first created it has an electric charge given by G1/2 times its mass, where G is the constant of gravitation. As explained already, this charge will then develop a vacuum spin and we can formulate a mathematical relationship between this speed of rotation and the mass density of the body, involving only the value of G and a density parameter of the vacuum.”

    Preceding these words, on the same page 8 of the printed version of the Lecture paper, one reads:

    “One way of developing a charge distribution is by a strong electric discharge. The fast moving electrons will be drawn together by the pinch effect, so generating a radial electric field centred on the axis of the discharge. If the vacuum medium reacts to develop a compensating effect then it will absorb the field energy to sustain a vacuum spin about the discharge axis. This spin may be shared by the air surrounding the discharge with the result that the tornado angular momentum becomes explicable.”

    I had introduced the subject by reference to how the tornado owes its existence to the repeated lightning discharges which find an easy flow path through the funnel of the tornado and the opinion of experts that, somehow, that lightning might induce the enormous speed of rotation of air in that funnel. I was here explaining how a radial electric field might be created, regarding the electrostatic field, rather than any magnetic field, as the factor relevant to inducing the spin.

    Now, 17 years prior to this 1977 Lecture, I had, in my 1960 printed booklet: The Theory of Gravitation, presented the mathematical basis of vacuum spin, or rather, aether spin and shown how it accounts for the Earth’s magnetic field, both qualitatively and quantitatively, given an aether coextensive with body Earth and sharing the Earth’s rotation, but subject, as my later work explains, to a relative precession which accounts for the movement of the geomagnetic poles relative to the Earth’s N and S poles.

    In these circumstances I can but suggest that ‘Electrostatic Rotation’ or ‘electrostatic spin’ should really be seen as aether spin induced by electrostatic charge – a phenomenon I termed ‘aether spin’ or ‘vacuum spin’ long ago.

    Hopefully the experimental breakthrough that has emerged from U.C., Riverside will endorse and lead to acceptance of my theory on this subject, which in its latest updated version appeared on my website www.aspden.org on April 12th, 2003 in the form of a new book entitled The Physics of Creation. Chapter 8 pertains to the electrostatic spin phenomenon but the last part of Chapter 9, under the title Our Future Energy Source: The Vacuum shows how the phenomenon may contribute something of real importance in the world of technology. In a sense, I am merely reviving the research findings of Dr. Henry Moray, who needed an electrostatic atmospheric input of high voltage to prime the operation of his apparatus, but I am suggesting that his apparatus set up a radial electrostatic field which, owing to charge oscillation developing between two concentric-plate capacitors, generated ‘aether spin’ in a pulsating mode which imports energy steadily from the aether itself.

    I can but hope that this timely discovery by Winstrom and Khachatourian will receive the credit it deserves and that it may help my cause as well in my own struggle for acceptance.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    15 May, 2003

    Having completed the draft version of my book ‘The Physics of Creation’, I have begun to scan through my earlier work as I begin to consolidate what is presented in these web pages. My Energy Science Report No. 5 entitled ‘Power from Water: Cold Fusion’, published in 1994, deserves special attention. It warrants close review by anyone interested in what I have said about proton creation in my new book. It is now included amongst the papers section on this web site 1994d. I mention it now because reading it aroused my creative spirit and set me wondering about a theme that I have not previously considered. I do not intend to put in the effort needed to take the idea forward but here I will introduce it in the hope that physics students having research ambitions in fundamental theory might be attracted to the problem.

    The Composition of the Air we Breathe

    There will be many theoretical physicists who read what I have said in my book about proton creation and about my way of deriving the Hubble constant who, in spite of that common factor of nine simultaneous or sequential target ‘hits’ of the quon by muons, still need more proof to find my theory convincing. The energy of nine muons is enough to create a proton and we have seen in chapter 4 of that book how the heavy lepton, the taon, which has a mass-energy of the order of that of two protons, is also created by the same process.
    I will not try further to influence the minds of those who might be disposed to decipher the mystery I now introduce. Instead I will simply present the problem which I address to young students of physics, a problem that might even be of interest to a 17 year old still at school.
    I merely quote from a typical school level physics book, one published in 1950. Its reference data are of no relevance as the quotation I now present is a matter of general knowledge anyway:

    “In the case of atmospheric air, the chief constituents (apart from variable amounts of water vapour and carbon dioxide) are nitrogen (78 per cent by volume), oxygen (21 per cent by volume), argon (1 per cent by volume), and small amounts of other inert gases neon, helium, krypton and xenon.”

    So there you are – a fact of science – the air we breathe, for some reason determined by Mother Nature, is primarily composed of nitrogen and oxygen – something every young student learns as general knowledge in science. Ask the question “What determines the ratio of nitrogen and oxygen?” and the wisdom of your physics teacher in responding to that question would suggest the ratio comes about by chance and is not something one can calculate by theory.

    All I ask is that you weigh the odds of your teacher being right or wrong, in the light of what I now describe.

    I draw attention to a relevant mathematical relationship. Given that the Earth’s atmosphere has existed for many hundreds of millions of years, might it not be that some kind of equilibrium has been established as between oxygen and nitrogen? For the nuclear charge of an atom of oxygen to turn into an atom of nitrogen, one of its eight protons must be shed, whereas, for an atom of nitrogen to turn into oxygen, its seven protons must be joined by influx of an eighth proton. The scenario concerns proton decay and proton creation and chapter 4 in my book The Physics of Creation has explained how protons are created from muons by a statistical factor that involved the ninth power.

    I must also mention that my Energy Science Report No. 5 included a discussion as to how the third isotope of hydrogen is created, tritium, the nucleus of which is termed the triton, and this concerned the creation of a nucleon which added the extra unit of mass to the deuteron as needed to increase its mass from 2 to 3 in nucleon terms. That process, however, involved creation from muons by a statistical factor that involved the eighth power.

    If I now formulate the expression (7/8)n and suggest that this is the atomic ratio as between oxygen and nitrogen of the equilibrium state of our atmosphere, what, for an appropriate integer value of n, would then be the ratio by volume of oxygen to nitrogen and how would this compare with that of our atmosphere?

    You may verify that the answer, for a composition that is 99% nitrogen plus oxygen, is that 78.38 per cent by volume would be nitrogen and 20.62 percent would be oxygen, a quite remarkable result, given that our Earth’s atmosphere has, to a nearest integer percentage approximation, 78 per cent nitrogen and 21 per cent oxygen. Can this be coincidence or are we looking here at an algorithm in physics that has real physical significance? Decide for yourself and, if sufficiently interested, ponder on the question of how to decipher the message as to the true physics which that algorithm conveys. I leave that task to others, as it is now time for others to advance the theory based on the foundations I have laid.

    To verify my mathematical analysis, note that (7/8)10 has the value 0.263075576 and this is taken as the ratio of oxygen atoms to nitrogen atoms. Owing to the molecular forms of oxygen and nitrogen being similar and the implications of the Avodgadro Hypothesis this ratio is the relevant gas composition volume ratio of oxygen and nitrogen for the equilibrium state under consideration.

    Add 0.263075576 to unity and evaluate the reciprical and then multiply by 0.99 and 0.263075576 and so obtain the 20.62 oxygen percentage, which then, allowing for that one percent component of inert gas, gives a 78.38 nitrogen percentage.

    Why n should be 10 for this particular nuclear transition process, but 8 for the nuclear transmutation of the deuteron into a triton and 9 for the basic process of proton creation in the aether is, I submit a fascinating problem. I have justified the 8 and 9 factors in my published work and now wonder if someone, somewhere, can find an answer to this puzzle, assuming it is not merely a matter of numerical coincidence. If so, I would be delighted as it would surely aid me in my struggle for acceptance.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    21 May, 2003

    My book ‘The Physics of Creation’ does reveal how the proton is created, but does not expand on that theme to explain how Mother Nature contrives the build the spectrum of the many atoms that constitute matter. I have, however, stated in the foregoing note, by reference to Energy Science Report No. 5, that my theory does explain how the hydrogen isotopes deuterium and tritium are formed. Thus the first three members by atomic weight in the periodic table of atoms have theoretical justification. Also in the foregoing note I have, I hope, given students of physics a little food for thought, but, owing to a question posed by E. R. Margis in an E-Mail communication accompanying a book order I have just received, another challenging topic concerning the creation of atoms has emerged.

    Why is Uranium the Heaviest Stable Atom?

    Readers might be interested in my reply to this question. It was that, essentially, one needs to accept that the structure of an atomic nucleus is inter-locked with the cubic structure of the aether itself, meaning that the aether is like a fluid crystal which assumes structural form owing to the field effects of electrical charge components of the atom, but which can dissolve as needed so as not to preclude free motion of the atom through space.

    There was a time in physics when the research based on Moseley’s law led to Moseley diagrams which were the first indication that elements were missing from the periodic system at Z values of 43, 61, 72, 75, 85 and 87. That was back in 1922, but over the following years the atoms at 72, 75 and 87 put in an appearance, but a book by Shankland on Atomic and Nuclear Physics dated 1955 tells me that Z = 43, 61 and 85 do not occur naturally, as they are radioactive and have relatively short lives. They were, Shankland states, not identified until they were artificially produced in the cyclotron and nuclear reactor, thereby filling the last gaps below Z = 92 in Moseley’s scheme. However, in the meantime the Z = 85 did reveal itself in normal form as the relative abundance of its isotopes is presented in a 1967 Handbook of Physics that I have.

    As to technetium (Z = 43) and promethium (Z = 61), I pointed out that the fourth paper of mine in the Appendix of Aether Science Papers, (one of the books ordered by E.R Margis), explained why these atoms are so scarce. It is owing to excessive dynamic interference between the aether structure and the innermost electrons moving around the atomic nucleus.

    Regarding that as a kind of ‘proof’ that the aether plays a role in regulating the existence of atoms, the question about what limits the size of an atom reminds me of something I wrote at page 142 in my 1972 book Modern Aether Science, (also ordered). If one thinks of Z charges +e merging to form a sphere of charge Ze and assume the volume of that charge sphere is Z times the charge volume of the electron or positron, one will, by the use of the Thomson formula discussed in Physics Unified, (also ordered), see that the mass of this Ze charge should, in electron rest mass terms, be Z raised to the power 5/3. Now, I have built my aether theory on the notion that the vacuum medium has structure owing to there being charges sitting in a crystal-like array, those charges having a volume which I find by rigorous analysis is 1843 times the volume of the electron charge. So I find it intriguing that Z charges +e which merge to occupy that particular volume of space would, by that formula, be limited to Z = 91. 91 raised to the power 5/3 is 1841.05. So if the aether lattice charge is -e and it is obliterated to make way for an atomic nucleus this would leave a balancing aether charge of +e owing to the charge of the continuum background and by adding that critical number of +e charges to take up the space vacated one arrives at a limiting value of Z of 92 for stable atom existence. This identifies uranium as the largest stable element.

    As to atomic mass, this arises I believe from antiprotons replacing the charges at the enveloping sites in the aether, to create an electrically-neutral unit centred on the Ze charge. Pages 140 and 141 of Modern Aether Science are then relevant in explaining how atomic mass is related to Z.

    In replying to E. R. Margis, I admitted that I had not thought about this for years and years, having taken the view that the story of the aether is only made more confusing if one tries to explain everything and ventures too far into the territory of the nuclear physicist. I added that it seems best to concentrate on the theory as now described in my work ‘The Physics of Creation’ that I have just put on my website www.aspden.org in PDF form. I also mentioned that that takes a while to download and noted that at this time I am revising it in a form which needs far fewer bytes, meaning far less download time.

    Having just referred to the my 1987 Hadronic Journal paper concerning the missing atoms technetium and promethium, the fourth paper of the Appendix in Aether Science Papers, this is an appropriate place to make an important comment. Until I came to write The Physics of Creation I had complete faith in the standard belief that the force of gravity is somehow a force set up by electrodynamic interaction. I had identified the graviton system of the aether and all the right numbers emerged to give what seemed to be a very convincing derivation of G, the constant of gravitation. It was natural then, at the time I wrote that Hadronic Journal paper, to ponder on the possibility that setting up an electromagnetic oscillation at a high frequency that could resonate in some way with that of the graviton motion in the aether might lead to anomalous supergravitational or anti-gravitational effects, possibly leading to discovery of practical importance. With the new interpretation of the physics of the graviton, still giving that same theoretical derivation of G, but as what I may term a ‘pseudo-negative electrostatic interaction’, that prospect seems to vanish. One is still left with the prospect of gravitational anomalies arising from severance of the dynamic coupling between the mass of a body and its graviton accompaniment, and possibly some weak effects where electric field effects intrude, but any thought that future generations might find a way of harnessing gravity for long range space travel by devising some future electrodynamic machine has, it seems, now to be dismissed.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    29 May, 2003

    It is quite fortuitous, but after having compiled the above note several days ago I received on May 26 an E-Mail from a person named ‘Jameske’ which declared: “after enjoying a very technical and involved set of chapters on your aether theory I was intrigued to read something about neodymium in relation to gravity”. This was a reference to my book ‘Aether Science Papers’ and specifically its Epilogue on pp. 60-62. The message went on to quote what I had said there in the context of anti-gravity or super-gravity, by reference to technetium and promethium, which, though in the middle regions of the periodic table of atomic elements, are completely missing from the spectrum of stable atoms. The question was then posed “How is neodymium wrapped up with gravity and how do I envisage its use?” This biographical note is my answer to this enquiry by Jameske.

    The Missing Atoms and the Gravity Question

    In my earlier writings I have suggested that the fact that certain atomic elements, notably technetium (Z = 43) and promethium (Z = 61) are missing from the list of stable elements is attributable to a kind of resonance associated with the phenomenon of gravitation. Those atoms could be subject to an enormous gravitational effect which, depending upon the phase of that resonance, might even be anti-gravitational. Either way, any such atoms if existing in a stable state on Earth would either have been pulled down into the Earth’s core or expelled into outer space and so are not seen in the normal abundance data for the Earth’s surface composition.

    When I wrote about this I was convinced that here was evidence supporting my theory of gravity, which, as an electrodynamic force action was attributable to the parallel flow of current seated in graviton motion, the latter providing dynamic balance for matter owing to its motion at the Heisenberg jitter frequency, the Compton electron frequency, relative to matter sitting in the electromagnetic frame of reference.

    So now my revised theory as presented in my book The Physics of Creation, in changing the G-determining gravitational action from being electrodynamic to become ‘negative’ electrostatic, seems to have upset that argument.

    Now, I say ‘seems to’ because I wish now to defend the case for electrodynamic action still being of relevance.

    The precise theoretical determination of G, the constant of gravitation, requires those gravitons and the physical form of an aether which the author has pointed to for half a century. The electrodynamic interaction of gravitons at a frequency equal to the rhythmic frequency of that aether would give gravitational attraction were it not for the fact, now realised, that the absence of relative velocity, essential to the derivation of the Neumann Potential, nullifies the case. However, one can still have the rare situation, where, if only one can generate, by electrodynamic action, frequencies that equal and so resonate with the Compton electron frequency of the aether, then there is prospect of generating an enormous anomalous gravitational action independent of the normal G-determined constraints.

    The only place we can look for such action is within the atom, where electrons move at ultra high frequencies and could be subject to harmonics which enhance those frequencies by integer factors. Here it is not a question of graviton-to-graviton interaction, but graviton-to-electron interaction.

    So the missing atom scenario still applies and I face that question posed by Jameske as to: “How is neodymium wrapped up with gravity and how do I envisage its use?”.

    The answer here is that in my published work, notably in my book Aether Science Papers, which is posted for access via this website, both in that Epilogue chapter and in the fourth paper in its Appendix, I explained how promethium (Z = 61) resonates electrodynamically with the gravitons of the aether and so has gone ‘missing’. Now one can hardly contemplate building a practical flying device which harnesses this substance if phase-controlled for anti-gravitational operation, unless one has a supply source for promethium and that does not exist because the element has already either flown away on its own or dug deep into the Earth and buried itself beyond recovery. One can, however, at least contemplate taking the two adjacent atoms in the periodic table, namely neodymium and samarium, and, perhaps by alloying them in some way, hope that the resulting composition might, albeit with external electrical control, be modulated in such a way as to set up a controlled electrodynamic interaction with those gravitons.

    Incidentally, in saying that ultra-high frequency electrical oscillations might play a role in setting up gravitational forces and suggesting that those oscillations originate within a metal alloy, there will be those who would say this cannot be owing to eddy-current screening. Rather than digressing to answer this in terms of electrical induction theory, it seems sufficient here to point out that the holy grail of physicists is the unification of electromagnetism and gravity. That being the case, how can it be that so many physicists look to electromagnetism in some special characteristic form as a prospective gravitational action, if electromagnetism as such, albeit having that special characteristic, cannot penetrate metal as does the action of gravity?

    Now, as to having a substance amenable to control of its gravitational properties, it would need far more insight than I can offer at this stage in my life to say whether or not such a notion could ever offer promise technologically. All I can say is that, given the insight my theory does provide into the true nature of gravity, then at least that is a start on the potential pathway to harnessing that force. Before my theory one had no direction in which one could even look. If gravity arises because space is curved, as Einstein implies, then, O.K. find someone who can tell you how to alter the curvature of space. Otherwise, if I am right, at least I can point future physicists in a direction that has some bedrock as a foundation.

    As to technetium, here I am now less sure that gravity is a factor in its abundance. It may simply be that its K-shell electron has a cavity resonance, which I know has an orbital radius slightly greater than half the Compton electron wavelength and that boundary radius, in clashing with the nucleus, might make its electron presence in the technetium atom unstable. The theory of this is bound up with the electron g-factor.

    I mention this because the E-Mail from Jameske also posed the question as to whether the two elements either side of technetium, molybdenum and ruthenium, might have some use with regard to gravity. That I see as a less likely possibility than the neodymium-samarium partnership centred on promethium, but, please note, there is really no point in speculating too far along those lines pending general acceptance of the underlying theory. Yes, I realise that physicists in general are not impressed by theories which require backtracking by challenging what has been accepted, but I also realise that there can be a way forward if, on the horizon, there is something of practical technological importance that might emerge. An understanding of gravity will, hopefully, be followed by technology to harness gravity. It is mere hope but hope having a foundation that did not exist before.

    This note, therefore, is simply a message I offer in my ongoing struggle for acceptance.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.


    12 June, 2003

    Bearing in mind the reference to Hyperons at the end of chapter 4 of my book ‘The Physics of Creation’, I cannot, after just reading an item in Physics World, resist entering the following Note on my website

    A CHARMING PUZZLE?

    The June 2003 issue of Physics World, the U.K. Institute of Physics member’s monthly journal, in its ‘Post-Deadline’ section on page 3 included an item headed ‘Charmed particle puzzles theorists’. The ‘puzzle’ arises from the discovery of a new sub-atomic particle named Ds(2317) which, it is said, ‘could force researchers to rethink their theories about quark interactions’. This discovery of an unexpected energy resonance peak at 2.32 GeV emerges from the BaBar experiment at Stanford in U.S. Also mentioned in this account is the confirmation of that discovery by researchers at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring in New York State along with their discovery of a new peak at about 2.46 GeV. In conclusion it is said that ‘these findings could provide insights into the force that binds quarks, indeed gluons, together.’

    It seems highly relevant to note that at the end of chapter 4 of my book ‘The Physics of Creation’, I presented the theoretical basis and included a tabulation showing how the particle resonances of record at 1.381 GeV and 1.527 GeV emerged as short-lived by-products from the processes governing proton creation. Given that the proton itself has a rest-mass energy of 0.938 GeV, it is indeed interesting to note that 1.381 GeV plus 0.938 GeV is 2.319 GeV, whereas 1.527 GeV plus 0.938 GeV is 2.465 GeV.

    Surely this suggests that there is nothing to ‘puzzle’ over concerning those observed resonance peaks at 2.32 GeV and 2.46 GeV. Their existence, in being brought to attention at this time, merely adds weight to my theory as presented in ‘The Physics of Creation’. Hopefully this will serve as one more step forward in my struggle for acceptance, but only if those physicists who are allured by the ‘charm’ and ‘colour’ of these exotic particle forms are willing to risk entrancement by referring to what I have already published on the subject.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    3 October, 2003

    On October 1st 2003 I was sent an E-Mail by Derek Gerlach, from a Stanford University Alumni E-Mail address, which raised a very pertinent question concerning my derivation of the law of electrodynamics in my book ‘Physics Unified’. I wish here to record my appreciation for this communication, because it raises the kind of question that one needs if our understanding of the physics which governs our universe is to progress. I admit that had I received two years ago such a communication dealing with this specific aspect of my theory it would have been difficult to decide how to reply. The points raised warrant attention and my answer below will, I hope, prove of interest to those who may read this and perhaps add strength to my theory.

    Concerning the Law of Electrodynamics

    Derek Gerlach’s comments concerned my derivation of the law of electrodynamics at the beginning of my book ‘Physics Unified’. Before considering the points he raises I think it appropriate to explain that when I first recognized that the accepted law of electrodynamics had to be incorrect owing to its failure to account for the multiplicity of interactions between charges in motion, a limitation which rendered it valid only for actions stemming from a closed circuit current, my thoughts turned to gravity. By reinterpreting the experimental evidence and admitting energy exchanges involving the aether but precluding interactions that generate out-of-balance couples, i.e. the self-induction of rotation, I had seen how to formulate a law of electrodynamics which could give a basis for the force of gravity.

    This law was based on the Neumann potential, according to which two parallel electrical current elements will mutually attract one another in conformity with the inverse square of distance law. It meant that by regarding matter as sharing a rhythmic motion as part of the quantum underworld of the aether, a motion accounting for the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, there was need for dynamic balance by graviton mass having its own rhythmic motion and the mutually parallel motion of those gravitons implied the electrodynamic action that we see as gravitation.

    I must admit that what emerged from my theory, in allowing me to derive the constant of gravitation G by pure theory, plus the fact that physicists have taken it for granted that gravitation and electrodynamics would one day be connected by a unified field theory, seemed conclusive. Yet, quite recently, I began to see a problem. Originally I had accepted the Neumann potential as an empirical fact and developed my theory relying on that formulation. However, the day came eventually when I saw how to derive the Neumann potential starting from Coulomb’s Law and that involved a step which I now see as destroying the case for the force of gravity being electrodynamic in origin.

    One can see by reference to my paper: ‘Instantaneous Electrodynamic Potential with Retarded Energy Transfer’ (Hadronic Journal, 11, pp. 307-313, 1988, Paper No. 6 in the Appendix to my book: Aether Science Papers), that the step from equation (3) to equation (5) is critical so far as concerns an electrodynamic theory of gravity. The force corresponding to the Neumann potential, as defined by equation (5), though showing that two parallel current elements have the correct interaction, stems from equation (3) which says the force is proportional to the square of relative velocity of the electric charge. The synchronized motion of gravitons in the aether means no relative motion and so no force according to equation (3). Hence one cannot apply the Neumann potential to account for the force of gravity. However, the electrodynamic interaction of electrons, even if sharing parallel motion, is not so affected because the electron current is seen as arising from the quantum-electrodynamic countermotion of positive and negative electron-sized charges. The latter implies relative motion, whereas this quantum-electrodynamic feature is not deemed applicable to graviton motion in the aether.

    It was this problem that caused me to treat graviton interaction as an action between electrostatic charge by regarding the gravitons as leptons which, in respect of positive and negative charge polarity, are equal in numbers, so that the residual force is one of mutual attraction owing to the charge they displace from the enveloping charge continuum. This is now explained in detail in my new book ‘The Physics of Creation of record in these web pages.

    So now I must address the problem raised by Derek Gerlach, bearing in mind that the physics involved relates specifically to electrodynamic interactions of the familiar kind as evident in experiments involving electric circuits and electric discharge apparatus.

    Derek Gerlach’s Questions

    Question 1: On page 3 of ‘Physics Unified’ why is Force F directed along the vector r, and why is it mutual on q and Q?

    My answer: I am seeking to determine the electromagnetic force acting between two charges q and Q separated by a vector distance r, which means that am taking the applicable electromagnetic reference frame as that in which the velocities v and V of q and Q, respectively, are measured. I assume, by hypothesis, that any electromagnetic action set up in that frame arises from a balanced primary interaction force directed along the line of charge separation, but intend to explore the dynamic factors which might involve secondary force components owing to inertial reaction.

    Question 2: On page 4, before the last paragraph, if P points along V, should not equation (1) read (F.V)+(Z.V)+(P.V)=0 ?

    My answer: I have in mind the charge Q moving to convey current in a situation where V is constant, corresponding to a steady flow of electric current. Collectively, Z and F, being attributable to the electromagnetic action must not do any work that can alter V. Indeed this is why Z is introduced by way of a secondary reaction induced by the effect of that force F. Hence the equation (F.V)+(Z.V)=0. However, owing to symmetry in the actions on q and Q one can infer the presence of a third reaction force P which must be cancelled by a counterpart force to the extent that it has a component directed along V. This ‘counterpart force’ can be assumed to be the force attributable to an EMF in the equivalent circuit of just the value needed to keep V, and so the current, constant. Note that this EMF is that of the electric field action local to the point where Q sits. To declare that (F.V)+(Z.V)+(P.V)=0 would be tantamount to assuming a priori that the net force acting on Q has to be at right angles to V, the standard assumption for interaction involving a closed current circuit, which I emphasize is not the two-charge case we are considering.

    Question 3: On page 5, last paragraph, why must force P point along V and have zero perpendicular component?

    My answer: Given that I recognize the existence of two reaction force components Z and P acting on Q, having in mind that P is compensated by an EMF, as in a wire conductor circuit, it is appropriate to say that P lies along a line defined by vector V. However, I did, in that referenced paragraph, point out that, whereas we are familiar with electrostatic potential tending to minimize, the corollary is that the energy shed tends to maximize and, since the latter feeds the kinetic energy we associate with inertia, I think it logical to infer that this is consistent with the reaction force acting along the line of motion of Q. However, one could argue that this is arbitrary, because I could equally say that Z and P combined are such that P is so directed along that line of motion, which leaves Z to represent any force on P lateral to that motion whilst both Z and P each have components directed in the line of that motion. In other words the analysis in chapter 1 of my book ‘Physics Unified’ would have been better presented had I begun by introducing P, as directed in the line of motion of Q, explaining that, together with any force on Q attributable to extraneous electric field induced or applied as circuit EMF, it amounted to zero net force, consistent with V being constant. The argument leading to the presence of the force Z would then proceed, as before, by contending that collectively the forces on Q and the counterpart forces on q can produce no turning couple attributable to the electromagnetic interaction force F.

    Question 4: Referring to pages 4 to 6, is it true that forces Z and P would not be present if the experiment under consideration were performed in free space, rather than in the context of a material conducting wire? I am led to believe ‘yes’, based on paragraph 2 of page 6, which states Z and P are reaction forces.

    My answer: Here I do have a problem. The constraint on Q set by the argument concerning the balance of P against a force arising from an electric field means that the analysis applies to circuit theory, where current in one wire circuit act on currents in another wire circuit. Then there is the case where q is part of a closed circuital current in wire but Q is a freely moving charge, as for example, an electron traversing the length of a cathode ray tube under the control of a magnetic field produced by that circuital current. Here we still find, from experiment, that the forces acting on Q conform with the form of electrodynamic law derived in my book. However, that closed circuit condition operates, upon integration for action where both q and Q charges are electrons, to eliminate any net force component acting along the path of Q, and so implies that P is zero. The fascinating practical question which then emerges concerns the effect of a closed circuital current involving electrons as the q charges but acting on freely moving Q charges that are heavy ions not themselves flowing all the way around that same closed circuit and so sharing the same current flow. This is the realm of plasma discharge devices, which do manifest force anomalies of a form which supports the theory I have presented. Keep in mind the fact that current flow in a copper conductor involves electrons in motion through positive ions that do not share that motion. Here there is no direct electrostatic force between two such systems and the electrodynamic action attributable to the Neumann potential then governs. If then one considers interaction by charges all of which move freely in space that force F is swamped by the normal electrostatic interaction force and the law of electrodynamics as I have formulated will not then apply. However, I am not aware of any experimental evidence that casts light on this situation. The atom as a charged nucleus surrounded by moving electrons qualifies as such a system but we do not see electrodynamic theory as such used in atomic theory to explain the atom’s self-interaction. I tend, therefore, to think that, in such free space situations, the electrostatic interaction directed in the line of charge separation, as supplemented by the interaction according to the Neumann potential, acting also in that line, will be the sole force to set in balance with the mass-related inertial forces of the charge acted upon. I believe that much of the difficulty experienced by effort to fathom the mysteries of unified field theory by linking gravitation and electromagnetism arises from trying to make the empirical physics of electrodynamics, as founded on charge motion under constraint, fit the situation of free charge interaction in free space.

    Question 5: Page 11, text following equation (14): If the answer to question No. 4 is ‘yes’, then why is it that equation (14) (which includes the effects of Z and P) is a general law of electrodynamics presumably valid in free space?

    My answer: Here Derek Gerlach refers to a paragraph following equation (14) which reads:

    ‘This is the complete and general law of electrodynamics to which we have been led by straightforward analysis. It will form the basis of the unified field approach presented in this work.’

    I agree that in the light of the answers I have given above it is misleading to imply that the general law presented applies to free charge interaction in otherwise empty space. However, the case I developed was based on first formulating a general law that applies to the empirical evidence we have from experiments and then moving on to the situation in free space where graviton interaction is in issue. It just so happens that the mutually parallel motion of those gravitons means that two of the three component terms in the general law cancel to leave only the bare Neumann potential component. It now seems on reflection that one could justify this argument in favour of the Neumann potential as the sole governing factor for the free space electrodynamic interaction.

    Question No. 6: On pages 7-10 why is the analysis of the interaction of q and Q indicative only of F? Since the net force on Q is Z+P+F, it seems as though the analysis should indicate the latter, since the text states that FQ is the general law of electrodynamics.

    My answer: Here I think there is some confusion because I used the symbol F to signify a component only of the total force FQ which acts on Q. My object in pages 7 to 10 was to use an argument based on symmetry to derive the formula for the force F as attributable Neumann potential, rather than merely declaring I was using the Neumann potential formula of historical record. It was some years later that I made the onward step of proving that the Neumann potential arises from the Coulomb potential, assuming instantaneous action in the Coulomb gauge but retarded energy transfer in a zero-point energy background, the subject of the 1988 Hadronic Journal paper referenced above.

    Conclusion

    The above is my reply to Derek Gerlach’s comments, but this is an appropriate place to mention an erroneous statement I made concerning the general law of electrodynamics I have derived in my book ‘Physics Unified’.

    The general form of law has three force components, two of which combine to give what physicists recognize as the Lorentz law and a third component which cancels to zero where the law is integrated to cater for one of the charges being part of a closed current circuit. This third component includes, in the case of my law, a mass ratio and is preceded by a minus sign. The general law, with the third component, was derived, subject to an assumption, by Clerk Maxwell, as I mention in my book. However, that version of the law contained no mass ratio factor. Maxwell used quarternions rather than vector notation and his terminology was different from that I have used, mine being based on the vector formulations of Sir Edmund Whittaker, whose book ‘A History of Theories of Aether and Electricity’, 1951 Edition, published by Thomas Nelson and Sons, discusses the subject at pp. 83 to 87 of the its first volume.

    Both the Whittaker and the Maxwell versions of the general law opted for the assumption that action must balance reaction in a linear sense, but allowed imbalance of force in the rotational sense. I adopt the alternative assumption that one must preclude an out-of-balance couple owing to the interaction of the two charges but permit linear imbalance of action and reaction force, given that the two-charge system could never have acquired charge motion not directed along the line of their separation vector were it not for the presence of extraneous forces due to interaction of charges q and Q with other charges in the close environment. For the vector notation both Whittaker and Maxwell formulations require that third force component to be preceded by a plus sign, whereas my formulation requires a minus sign. Yet for the quarternion formulation of Maxwell with the different notation and style of expression a minus sign is used. In being guided erroneously by that minus sign in Maxwell’s treatise, and in quoting from his treatise, I wrongly stated in ‘Physics Unified’, that my derived version of the general law of electrodynamics was the same as Maxwell’s third version of the law. This was, of course, for actions between charges of equal mass.

    One can but wonder how this subject of electrodynamic action might have developed during the 20th century had Maxwell realized that the assumption governing that third force component was crucial and that there was an alternative which implied out-of-balance linear force. Indeed, it is such out-of-balance that implies energy transfer to and from the two-charge system under study, a good starting point if one is confronted with anomalous energy conditions in experimental work. Do keep in mind that the Lorentz version of the force law denies electrodynamic force directed in the line of motion of the charge on which it acts, which means that the accepted law cannot account for energy transfer electrodynamically. This has obliged us to use empirical rules when considering electromagnetic induction and deprived us of the necessary insight into the true energy transfer processes involved.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    October 26, 2003

    Three days ago I received an E-Mail from a scientist I will refer to as Ed. G. which included the comment “In checking your website I see you are still alive and well (which is my first consideration, of course)… ” but then went on to remind me that I had not responded to an E-mail dated 1st May, 2003 which, he stated, was based on his “incomplete reading of The Physics of Creation“, but which posed certain questions. The points raised are important and I cannot understand how I failed to reply at the time, but better late than never, and since I am still alive and in good health, considering my 75 years of age, here is my reply.

    The Anisotropy of Space

    The Question: In your model of the aether the cubic lattice moves as a unit at the speed of light with respect to the charge continuum, which I presume defines absolute rest. Is the foregoing statement basically accurate as a description of what you’ve postulated? Secondly, if so, how do you have any compelling theoretical justification for anisotropy other than the possible need of a moving lattice for reasons of stability? Why exactly can’t you model the lattice as completely stationary (which from my point of view, would be preferable because of symmetry considerations)?

    Now it so happens that I have just updated this website www.aspden.org by replacing the first draft edition of my book The Physics of Creation with an updated version, including an index, some minor corrections, but also a major addition concerning neutron stars at the end of chapter 8. I think what I have added there will add strength to what I have to say in reply to the above question and I see this as an opportune moment to put my response here on record.

    First, I note that in his E-Mail of 23 October Ed. G. ended by saying:

    What I seek is a succinct statement of your latest model of the aether. If you could direct me to your best article on this topic, I will give it high priority.

    Here my answer is that I do not like the notion that my vision of the aether is a ‘model’, or that it has evolved in different ‘versions’. The aether is a reality. It exists and my efforts have been to decipher its structure and form based on the facts confronting us in our knowledge of physics. The analysis of the aether, as presented in chapter 7 of The Physics of Creation, is, in its fundamentals, identical to that disclosed on pages 16-19 in chapter 2 of my 1960 book The Theory of Gravitation.

    As to a ‘succinct’ statement, here I can but begin by quoting a few words from p. 11 of The Physics of Creation, after referring to Earnshaw’s theorem:

    There was something about this author’s perception of the aether that made that theorem helpful rather than obstructive. Earnshaw had overstated his case. If the medium contains electric charges of like polarity governed by the inverse-square law then they can arrange themselves in a stable configuration, provided they are immersed in a uniform continuum of charge of opposite polarity. Conversely, one might say, if the evidence supports an aether having a structured form composed of electric charges governed by the inverse-square law, then with certainty, that aether must incorporate a background continuum of electric charge which envelops those charges.

    Given the aether as a charge continuum permeated by a system of like charges of opposite polarity one can surely see that those charges form into a structured array, the lattice, and, given that electrostatic interaction energy as between those charges and the continuum cannot be a negative quantity for the aether, it is a mathematical exercise to evaluate their displacement and the dynamical criteria that govern stability. That is what chapter 7 in The Physics of Creation is about.

    The result confirms what I saw as implied, albeit succinctly, but seemingly never onwardly developed at the time, by the words of Paul Dirac, as quoted on p. 80 of chapter 6 in my book The Physics of Creation. He declared in his Nobel prize lecture:

    It is found that an electron which seems to us to be moving slowly must actually have a very high frequency oscillatory motion of small amplitude superimposed on the regular motion wich appears to us. As a result of this oscillatory motion, the velocity of the electron at any time equals the speed of light. This is a prediction which cannot be directly verified by experiment, since the frequency is so high and the amplitude so small.

    On that same page 80 of my book I quoted a paragraph from page 87 of my 1980 book Physics Unified which reads:

    Similar proposals had been made earlier by both Einstein and Schroedinger. Einstein imagined the electron as belonging to a Galilean reference frame oscillating at a frequency determined from the electron rest mass and the Planck relationship, and being everywhere synchronous.

    So, you see, all I did, rather than ‘postulating that the aether had a cubic lattice which moves as a unit at the speed of light with respect to the charge continuum’, was to suggest that the aether provided that frame of reference, though I admit it was no easy task to undertake the mathematical analysis needed to probe the physics that governed this aether underworld. The breakthrough step was my decision that the aether could not be a system having negative electrostatic interaction energy, a step which, to me, means that energy rules, rather that ideal notions expressed as ‘symmetry’ or ‘curvature of space’.

    Now, as to that primary question: “Why exactly can’t you model the lattice as completely stationary?”, my answer is that if I did I would have no way of recognizing how the aether governs quantum theory by determining Planck’s constant h and the related angular momentum quantum. The whole foundation of my theory is the discovery of the structured 3x3x3 aether lattice particle unit as having the quantum of angular momentum h/2π when spinning to set up electrical pulsations at the Compton electron frequency. Paul Dirac could see the need for that motion; a static aether devoid of that oscillatory jitter of the lattice particles relative to the continuum would have nothing to tell us about quantum theory and would lack the dimension of time.

    Ed. G asks if I am saying that in my model of the aether the cubic lattice moves as a unit at the speed of light with respect to the charge continuum, which presumably defines absolute rest.

    My answer here is “No!” because I see both the continuum and the aether charge lattice as separate systems displaced from one another about centres seated in an inertial frame of reference. That inertial frame can have translational motion, just as the inertial frame of the solar system has a cosmic motion through enveloping space. The two systems rotate in synchronism about those centres and at the frequency we refer to as the Compton electron frequency. The speed of light, as such, is not relevant here. The separate systems move in circular orbit at a speed s and so have relative motion at the speed 2s. It just so happens that, when we come to understand how electromagnetic disturbances propagate through the aether, the propagation speed is determined as a function of the structural properties of the lattice and those speeds s. It just happens to equal 2s.

    How then do I account for the implied anisotropy of space? Well, I just do not regard space as being anisotropic. There is anisotropy evident in the cosmic radiation background, but that arises from observation made from a moving Earth, matter moving through the enveloping aether. That radiation comes from aether external to the Earth’s ionosphere, from aether regions that can be said to be stationary, meaning that the centres of those circular orbits are stationary. So the question really concerns aether entrained by moving matter, as with body Earth.

    Looking at aether within body Earth, I do not know whether or not the continuum charge shares the Earth’s motion, but I believe the aether lattice within the Earth’s matter will share the motion of that matter. That said, if the continuum moves as well, then where it crashes into the enveloping aether continuum of outer space it will need to dissolve, as by mutual charge annihilation including the lattice particles, whereby the energy released is deployed perhaps by creating virtual muon pairs which migrate through Earth from the forward aether boundaries to the rearward aether boundaries, where new continuum and lattice charges can appear to keep the balance of things and conserve inertia. If the continuum does not share the Earth’s motion then we face the problem of lattice charge build-up at the forward aether boundaries, and since there is no evidence of this, then, quite logically, one has to accept that continuum and aether lattice charge move together with body Earth, meaning that their only relative motion is that quantum jitter at the Compton electron frequency.

    Now, if this is too challenging a concept, let me now pose a question. What would happen if atoms other than hydrogen, meaning those supposedly containing neutrons, that is almost all the atomic content of body Earth, were really microcosmic aether structures in which antiprotons have replaced the lattice charges and some other lower-mass charge form became the centre of charge in the atomic nucleus? It then seems probable that the Earth’s steady motion around the Sun combined with the cosmic motion of our solar system would entrain and so drag the Earth’s aether along with body Earth. Would that not mean that we can forget the notion of an atom containing neutrons, as such, in that the neutron property of the atom was only invented to balance the charge books, given that the aether has been ignored?

    How can it be that the free neutron, the particle that incorporates a proton together with an electron, judging by how it breaks up upon decay, only has a short lifetime, whereas the proton seemingly is stable? Surely the question is based on fiction, the fiction that the neutron, as something other than a proton or antiproton, can exist at all within the atom. The aether surely plays a role by virtue of an aether lattice particle vacating a lattice site and being replaced by an antiproton.

    This then helps us to understand how the Earth drags its aether along with it, but I have more now to add. I did in chapter 9 in the first draft edition of The Physics of Creation indicate that maybe neutron stars were regions of aether in which the lattice charges had been replaced in the manner just suggested. Since that work was first presented on this web site, astrophysicists have actually, and for the first time, measured the magnetic field of a neutron star. Now, given that my aether theory explains the magnetic properties of astronomical bodies, it has been a tremendous step forward to find that what has been measured fits well with that theory. Accordingly I have hastened the update and revision of The Physics of Creation and I thereby invite Ed. G. to take note of the new pages concerning neutron stars now added to chapter 8 of the revised version.

    I conclude by emphasizing that, whereas the notion of symmetry has appeal when dealing with physical models, one needs to be guided by the evidence telling us that there is a physical underworld we cannot see, the aether, that does have an inherent symmetry, symmetry retained even when matter is present, but which, owing to motion of that matter, can appear to lack symmetry if viewed from within an aether that does not share that motion.


    Press ‘The Physics of Creation’ to go to its index page.

    Press to return to the main site index.
  • ASPDEN PHYSICS WEB SITE: PHYSICS WITH ASPDEN

    PHYSICS WITH ASPDEN





    If you have been introduced to this website www.aspden.org by the referenced items in my book CREATION: The Physical Truth then you are very welcome. You will, I am sure, find the commentary below helpful in understanding the importance of what has been disclosed in that book. It is the product of a more-than-50-year endeavour to solve the primary mysteries that give foundation for the physics which governs our existence. Though this pursuit was not intended to be a search for an energy source that we can harness, I now believe that the research involved points the way forward in such a quest and so I urge physicists who have the necessary resources to be guided accordingly. Much of this effort to understand the physics concerning the energy source that accounts for the creation of what we see in the space around us is of past record on this and my related websites. Therefore, this summary account will be restricted to comment that is specifically related to what is said about the energy theme in that book, primarily concerning nuclear fusion, nuclear fission and the energy shed by a process that accounts for quantum theory. Should the reader not have a copy of CREATION: The Physical Truth and wish to buy a copy then reference to the opening page on my website

    provides the necessary order information. Should the reader have returned to this website having already read the Commentary below but with a view to seeing the opening index page that existed before my book CREATION: The Physical Truth was published then the link connection is:

    a title chosen because I authored a book entitled Physics without Einstein that was published 38 years ago in 1969.

    COMMENTARY

    Introduction
    The primary purpose of CREATION: The Physical Truth is to show how the physical underworld of space determines the value of Planck’s constant h, or rather the dimensionless quantity, the fine-structure constant, that incorporates h by linking it with the electron charge e and the factor c which relates the electrostatic and electromagnetic forms of that charge. Its further purpose is then to show how the energetic underworld of space which accounts for that fine-structure constant evaluation has a meson, heavy-electron, feature that allows that underworld to create protons. The proton-electron mass ratio is then derived theoretically and found to be 1836.152. Inevitably, based on consideration of the dynamical balance in the quantum underworld of space as required by the Heisenberg jitter motion and the Principle of Uncertainty, this introduces the action accounting for gravity and so the theory presented discloses how G, the constant of gravitation, is determined.

    Such theory was presented by the author in his earlier works and the effort should have been recognized many years ago. Sadly, however, that was not to be, because (one must presume) the analysis was based on recognizing the need to revive belief in an aether medium. Most physicists accept the Einstein doctrine that merely seeks to relate by mathematical formulation what we can see and measure in the universe to which we belong. However, the modern physicist is baffled when it comes to explaining the energy source from which the universe was created. Given an aether that is alive with energy and interacts with our atomic world one can answer that problem but it has to be an aether that can account for the null result of the Michelson-Morley experiment in physical terms.

    Given such an aether, the problem then is how to overcome other errors in our physical picture of things and construct a power generating system that can replicate our sun’s energy source, falsely deemed to be attributable to nuclear fusion of its hydrogen atoms. With this in mind I refer the reader to pages 150-153 of CREATION:The Physical Truth in the chapter entitled Nuclear Fusion. I there state that my theory can explain the magnetic moment of the deuteron and then discuss how the theory explains the relative abundance of protons and deuterons. Where, I ask, in the teaching of physics, is there an explanation of what it is that governs the relative abundance of deuterium and hydrogen atoms? The nuclear fusion of two protons is a very important topic in physics, because, in the context of hot fusion, it is deemed to be the energy source that powers the sun and because, in the context of cold fusion, certain experiments offer promise in the quest for a new pollution-free energy source.

    Nuclear Fusion
    I am writing these words on April 15, 2007 and have before me the March 2007 issue of PHYSICS WORLD , the monthly journal sent to members of the U.K. Institute of Physics. The Institute’s News Editor, Edwin Cartlidge, there presents on pages 10 and 11 a very interesting news report entitled The secret world of amateur fusion, which I found rather astounding. After telling us that ten billion euros are being spent building the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER), which is due to switch on in 2016, as a test to see if we can replicate on Earth the sun’s nuclear fusion process, he writes:

    ‘Contrast this with the device (a so-called fusor) that sits on a bench in the corner of a quiet laboratory at Cambridge University. Like the reactors built by professional scientists, this machine can be used to create fusion reactions – tens of thousands of deuterium-deuterium reactions per second…..’

    He goes on to explain how this device was put together by two school students, Henry Hallam who had become a second year engineering undergraduate at Cambridge, and Fergus Noble who would start his natural-sciences degree course later in the year. This is followed by an expression of doubt that the energy generated by such devices will ever exceed the amount of energy they consume, but it tells us that ‘there are those who believe that a variation on the fusor could one day be used to produce useful amounts of energy, and do so far more cheaply than conventional reactors’. However, Edwin Cartlidge enlightens us further by referring to several others who expect success in this pursuit based on Farnsworth’s fusor that was upgraded in the 1960s by Robert Hirsch to become the model now used by those continuing this research. This comment was followed with the words: ‘It consists of two concentric spherical steel grids – with the outer acting as positive electrode and the inner a negative electrode – contained within an outer steel sphere filled with a dilute fuel gas’.

    I mention that because, though I can see a future prospect for development of cold fusion reactors, I suspect that the use of electrical devices having concentric cylindrical electrodes will prove to be the foremost candidates for the ultimate power generating technology that will serve as the world’s energy resource by tapping energy from the quantum underworld that pervades all space. My thoughts on that are now of published record in a U.K. patent application GB2432463. What I there describe is the kind of device that I see as linked by the physics that caused the sun to spin, whereas gravity force by acting primarily between the protons accounts for the sun having within it a radial electric field such as applies between concentric electrodes in an electrically powered structure. The latter field acting on the quantum powered underworld of space induces spin owing to a phase lock arising from the dynamic activity that accounts for gravitation.

    Now, in referring to specific sections of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth, I will, owing to the above reference to cold fusion, first highlight what is disclosed on pages 150-152. You will see that on page 150 I refer to the fact that more than twenty years ago my theory of published record allowed me to derive a value for the magnetic moment of the deuteron that was in wonderful part per million accord with the measured value. That is quite an accomplishment and I find it disappointing that the effort has not be recognized by the scientific community.

    Here explaining my position I stress that the experimental value for this quantity (0.857438 nuclear magnetons) is certainly known to part per million accuracy because it is based on a combination of four quantities, each measured to a precision better than one in ten million. These are (i) the deuteron/proton spin magnetic moment ratio, (ii) the electron/proton spin magnetic moment ratio, (iii) the electron anomalous g/2 factor and (iv) the proton/electron mass ratio. The theoretical value that I derived from my theory is 0.857439 nuclear magnetons and, should anyone think that this result was a contrived manipulation of data aimed at achieving such close agreement, then I invite such a critic to check my analysis.

    The formula involved is:

    (6/7) times 2 divided by [2 – (71/56)/1836)] = 0.857439

    and this arises from analysis of the three-state quark-like structure of the deuteron as discussed in the referenced Hadronic Journal, 9, 129-136 (1986) paper, which I claim as being of outstanding merit and importance in physics, even though it has been ignored for so long. I there give reason for the deuteron experiencing a change of state as between three forms, a state A in which it constitutes three positrons separated by two antiprotons, a state B in which it constitutes an electron-positron pair separating a proton from an antiproton with a positron as a satellite and a state C in which it comprises two protons separated by a single electron with an electron and positron as satellite particles. The time spent in these respective states is in the ratio 2: 1: 4, meaning that the core deuteron is neutral for one seventh of the time. The deuteron core reacts to motion in a magnetic field as if it has unit charge for (6/7) of the time.

    As to the mass of the core deuteron, this is essentially that of two protons offset by the energy of its electron-positron composition, allowing for the electrostatic interaction energy that is negative in value. This mass is slightly different for the three states but it is calculable and, as that paper shows, is found to be lower than that of two protons by the amount 11/8 times electron mass for state A. State B has a core mass less than that of two protons by 9/8 times electron mass, whereas state C has a core mass less than that of two protons by 10/8 times electron mass. You can therefore see how that factor 71/56 is derived. The 2: 1: 4 ratio of A: B: C states gives 2(11) + (9) + 4(10) divided by 7 and by 8 which is 71/56. The 1836 factor is the proton/electron mass ratio.

    However, what then is so very impressive, is that this finding of the 2: 1: 4 ratio of deuteron states is the governing factor which determines the chance of deuteron fission to create free protons and the chance of proton fusion to create a deuteron. Here we need to accept that the quark behaviour of the proton as comprising three components requires it to alternate between a state in which it is a proton combined with an electron and a positron and a state in which it is an antiproton sitting between two positrons. Here the negative interaction energies are those of 7/4 and 9/4 times electron mass, respectively, the average being that of 2 electron mass units and so balancing the mass added by the electron-positron presence. This does not preclude the transient existence of the bare proton as a single charge form when created or released from electron-positron bondage by a nuclear reaction.

    The deuteron creation from proton fusion occurs by creating the ground state A deuterons plus residual electrons, positrons and protons, a process subject to three conservation criteria. Conservation of energy, charge form and space are essential, the latter meaning the net volume of space occupied by whatever form the charges have. Given the three equations required by these three conservation conditions the conversion of the three-charge proton form into the least energy deuteron form involves sets of 35 such protons. Of these 32 fuse together to become 16 deuterons shedding electrons and positrons as necessary to comply with the conservation requirements and 3 such protons shed their electron-positron components to become bare proton charges at least transiently. The trigger event for such an action is when all 35 protons are in their least energy state, meaning, a one in two chance raised to the power 35.

    As to the reverse process, the fission of deuterons to create protons, the chance of this occurring can be calculated by applying the same conservation principles. Deuterons, as noted above, exist in a mix of three states, of which state B has the highest energy and at any instant 1 in 7 of the deuterons exist in that state. The energy needed to trigger fission is simply the energy quantum needed to create a single electron or positron. Analysis shows that 8 B-state deuterons experience fission in the same trigger event, but that the conservation of energy, space occupied by charge and charge parity require also the transformation of 11 C-state deuterons into 10 A-state deuterons as part of the same event. This produces 18 protons. The trigger event for such an action is when a group of 8 deuterons are all in the same highest energy B-state, meaning a one in seven chance raised to the power 8.

    From these data we can compute the relative abundance of protons and deuterons that must exist in a stable atomic mixture, as in water. The resulting ratio of protons and deuterons is:

    (2)35(18)/(7)8(16)

    which is simply:

    9(16/7)8

    or:

    6705

    which means that there are 1491 deuterons for every ten million protons. This is a quite remarkable result considering that the abundance data for nuclear masses of record show a figure of 1492 in ten million for the A = 2 isotope of hydrogen. I give the relevant Handbook of Physics reference on page 152 of CREATION: The Physical Truth.

    To derive with such accuracy both this hydrogen/deuteron abundance ratio and the magnetic moment of the deuteron from the same physical account of the structure of the deuteron is quite remarkable. It is also all the more important owing to the relevance of such knowledge in the quest to generate our power needs by harnessing cold fusion. Just imagine the consequences if those involved in nuclear research were to build a nuclear reactor containing a large volume of water from which the deuterons have been extracted. There would be an inherent tendency for the protons of the hydrogen atoms to combine in order to restore the equilibrium state of balance required by that 6705 proton/deuteron ratio. That would mean nuclear fusion subject to a controlling factor, the need for an outflow of positive electric charge or an inflow of negative charge. All that is needed is for that body of ‘light’ water to be subjected to electric field action that promotes electron inflow.

    On page 184 of CREATION: The Physical Truth I refer to the fact that research scientists had borrowed for their experiments a very large quantity of heavy water from Ontario Hydro where such water has a function in its nuclear reactor plant. Heavy water would need an outflow of electrons in order to acquire the positive charge needed for deuterons to experience fission by conversion into normal water but this hardly involves any risk of catastrophe because such nuclear transmutation needs energy inflow. On the other hand such experimental pursuits, if relying on water purified by extraction of deuterium which will then seek to recover the equilibrium proton/deuteron ratio by nuclear fusion, merely require inflow of electrons and must generate heat, hopefully without explosion consequences.

    It is for those involved in well-funded cold fusion research to deliberate on such issues, whereas all I can do is to outline the theoretical factors that govern the relevant physics. The proton is not a point charge or a combination of three point charges (quarks) that are fractions of the proton’s unit charge. I have stressed the need to develop theory using the formula known to J. J. Thomson, as mentioned on page 50 of CREATION: The Physical Truth.

    As a further interesting note pertaining to the nuclear transformation between protons and deuterons I now draw attention to a footnote on page 263 in a book I purchased when I began my university education (1945). It was the second edition of a book by H. A. Wilson entitled Modern Physics, published in U.K. in a Student’s Physics series by Blackie & Son Ltd.

    In discussing the relationship between H1 and 1H2, the proton and the deuteron, Wilson gives the equation:

    n1 + H1 = 1H2 + 5q

    where n1 signifies the neutron. This is in Wilson’s chapter on Atomic Nuclei in which there is an account of several nuclear reactions and their energy releases. By reference to a table listing these he states: ‘The energies are nearly all approximately multiples of q = 0.387 MeV and so may be conveniently expressed in terms of this quantity as unit.’

    So, in now considering these words that I first read more than 60 years ago, I am tempted to see if my account of the proton and deuteron relationship agrees or disagrees with Wilson’s equation. I refer again to that Hadronic Journal paper referenced above. In it I calculated the mass of the neutron in relation to the proton and found it to be greater, in mass-energy terms, by 1.2933214 MeV, which I noted as being remarkable, given that the Particle Data Group in a 1984 report had stated the measured difference as being 1.293323 ± 0.000016 MeV. As to the deuteron core mass that value as derived by my theory is less than the mass of two protons by that above-presented factor of (71/56)/1836 in proton mass units. This is 71/56 electron mass units or 0.6479 MeV and, according to that Wilson equation, this plus 1.2933 MeV should equal 5q. It is therefore quite fascinating to find that the theory gives the energy quantity as 1.9412 MeV, which, divided by 5, is 0.388 MeV. That compares with Wilson’s approximate value for q of 0.387 MeV.

    The Mass of the Deuterium Atom
    A question that now arises is whether the above analysis can account for the measured mass of the deuterium atom and to answer this I need to suggest one minor change affecting the picture of the changing states of the deuteron. I believe that for one sixth of the time that the deuteron spends in one of its four state-C conditions during a cycle of change, it will have its satellite electron and positron coupled together in charge surface contact, which will increase the magnitude of the overall negative charge interaction energy of the deuteron. It will amount to 1/7 times 1/6 times 3/4 electron mass-energy units, which is 1/56. In contrast the negative interaction energies applicable to the core deuteron A, B and C states sum to [2(35) + 25 + 4(18)]/56, which is 167/56 electron mass units. Adding 1/56 makes the total negative interaction energy equal to that of 3 electron mass units, meaning that the total negative interaction energy of the deuteron states exactly compensates for the mass energy of the 3 electron-positron components present in each of those states. In summary this means that the deuteron mass energy is exactly that of two protons. This may seem rather surprising but it makes sense if one is seeking to explain how the deuteron is created based on the fusion of two protons, especially having regard to involvement of the aether background in absorbing one unit of positive electrical charge. Also it seems logical for the total energy of the deuteron to remain constant in spite of its fluctuations in form as between the A, B and C states. How, then, can one explain the measured mass of the deuterium atom, bearing in mind that it is not precisely the mass of two protons?

    Well, here I can but offer one way of looking at this problem. The deuterium atom supposedly consists of an orbital electron with a deuteron as the atomic nucleus. Reference data indicate that its mass in atomic mass units is 2.014102 which is 3671.366 electron mass units. Subtracting the mass of two protons 2(1836.152) implies that the mass of the deuterium atom is lower than the mass of two protons by the amount 0.938 electron mass units. Allowing for the orbital electron in the atom this means that the deuteron effective in contributing to the deuterium atomic mass exhibits a mass lower by 1.938 electron mass units. One must therefore ask how that atomic mass has been measured. If by mass spectrograph can it be that the measured reading applies essentially to the C-state form of the deuteron nucleus with the electron-positron pair not registering as part of the C-state core owing to its separate existence in independent charge form?
    The answer to this depends upon how the deuteron reacts when subjected to mass measurement within a mass spectrograph. Owing to the separate charge and much lower mass of the electron-positron pair it is possible that its cyclic changes of state will be affected under such measurement conditions, as by its electron and positron satellite in the deuteron nucleus of the dominant C-state not revealing their presence as a deuteron component. This would account for that discrepancy of very nearly two electron mass units, bearing in mind the negative energy interaction of the opposite polarity charges involved and a spacing that can be subject to uncertainty factor associated with quantum jitter motion. On such a basis one cannot expect to obtain a precise theoretical picture matching the results obtained earlier for the deuteron magnetic moment and the proton-electron abundance ratio.

    Given the exceptional nature of those results for the physical theory under discussion, there can surely be no doubt that the basis on which the theory is developed is correct and warrants attention in the onward quest to generate power by harnessing cold fusion technology. Readers will therefore understand why I see what I have written as ENERGY AND OUR FUTURE in part III of CREATION: The Physical Truth as warranting consideration by those who fund research in the energy field.

    As to the other important message concerning energy generation that I intend that book to convey, namely replicating in the laboratory, if we can, the very process by which our sun acquired its spin energy, I will just summarize a little on that theme in the last of the following three observations and at the end of this Commentary by further reference to that patent application mentioned above.

    The Sun’s Energy Source
    Firstly, though the sun is almost wholly composed of hydrogen atoms which no doubt have the relevant equilibrium mix of protons and deuterons, I do not see ‘cold fusion’ as a process that heats the sun. My book makes it clear that hot fusion requiring a core temperature of a hundred million degrees is out of the question. It is impossible because the sun is ionized which means that its gravitation, almost wholly that between protons which account for most of the sun’s mass, must set up a positive electric charge in the sun that precludes its compaction. I was pleased, after my book was published, to be informed by the U.S. publishers of a book by Donald E. Scott entitled The Electric Sky bearing the caption A Challenge to the Myths of Modern Astronomy that I was not alone in having recognized this fact. However, I was somewhat perplexed when finalizing this account on 3rd May 2007 upon reading in the U.K. newpaper, The Times an obituary of Professor Carl Friedrich Weizsacher, which declared that:

    ‘He was best known for his solution to the fundamental problem of astrophysics: how stars can radiate immense amounts of energy for billions of years. In 1938 he suggested that the energy comes from a chain of nuclear fusion reactions that is possible because of the high temperatures and pressures found in the dense central cores of stars.’

    One can but wonder how Weizsacher had measured the pressure and temperature at the centre of a star, if he was not just basing such presumption concerning pressure and temperature on the assumption that they were necessary to trigger a fusion reaction. Surely here is a ‘myth’ of modern astronomy, given the fact mentioned on page 148 of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth, the reference to the suggestion by J. H. Jeans in the journal Nature at page 101 of 2 June, 1904, as later elaborated in his book EOS: Or the Wider Aspects of Cosmogony published by Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co, Ltd. in 1928. Jeans declared that it was the mutual annihilation of protons and electrons that accounted for the sun’s energy and the whole of that 1929 book was devoted to that subject. I will just quote here a passage from page 28 of that book:

    ‘The temperatures in the interior of stars are higher still, and although we cannot measure them directly we can calculate them with very fair precision. The temperature at the centre of the sun is found to be in the neighbourhood of 50,000,000 degrees, and this is a fairly average temperature for the stars in general.’

    It was only one page later that Jeans declared that ‘at the centres of most of the stars nearly all, or perhaps quite all, of the electrons must have broken loose from their parent atoms, leaving the stellar matter almost or quite pulverized into its constituent nuclei and electrons’. So, why did Jeans not then realise that those positively charged nuclei carried the mass that accounted for most of the sun’s gravity force and so must have caused those atomic nuclei to set up a mutually repulsive electric field that would preclude further compaction and so then implied a uniform pressure and temperature within the sun? It is, indeed, quite shocking that physics has got itself in so confused a state concerning the sun’s energy and what could become our future energy resource. It is especially shocking when we consider that the book by Jeans was in its third reprint in January 1929 and was an account of the Trueman Wood Lecture delivered in U.K. before the Royal Society of Arts on 7th March, 1928. Yet we are told in 2007 that Weizsacher in 1938 ‘is best known for his solution to the fundamental problem of astrophysics, how stars, like the sun, radiate immense amounts of energy’ thanks to nuclear fusion of its atoms.

    Secondly, concerning the sun and the fact that it spins about an axis in space, my theory from which I derive in my book the value of the fine-structure constant assures me that the existence of a radial electric field with respect to an axis will develop rotation of a coextensive volume of the space medium about that axis drawing on the energy activity of the quantum underworld. Here is a pointer to a source of energy available everywhere in space owing to a phase-lock governing motion of its hidden electrical charge, that of a structured array of particles that I call quons. Potentially that is a source of energy, but it is not the primary energy source that sustains the sun’s radiation. It is the fact that its hydrogen atoms are pulled by gravity so closely together that their orbiting electrons collide and shed energy which heats the sun. The result is ionization but, as we well know, an ionized atom does not stay long in that state, because it recovers by somehow capturing a roving electron and locking again onto the ‘merry-go-round’ of the quantum underworld, meaning it taps the vast energy resource that accounts for quantum theory in physics. We cannot exploit that possibility without contriving to squeeze atoms so closely together by asserting adequate pressure on hydrogen gas and that is not within our engineering capability.

    So, thirdly, we must look to the possibility of replicating the sun’s spin on a pulsating basis. Whereas the sun was set spinning upon its creation, it keeps spinning at the same speed and so the energy imported by the quantum phase-lock was a one-off event. However, if we can replicate the action in a concentric electrode capacitor system that sets up a pulsating radial electric field, then a steady inflow of space energy seems a possibility. That is why I mention Tesla on page 170 of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth. Tesla developed high voltage transformers of which the primary and secondary windings were of concentric cylindrical form well spaced to allow for the high voltage between primary and secondary windings. Being for use with alternating current here was a structure having a pulsating radial electric field. He encountered anomalous activity as if energy was being fed into his apparatus from the environment and attributed this to atmospheric electricity, leading to a belief that electric energy could be propagated atmospherically and our energy needs supplied by using antenna to tap into that energy source. At the time this was hardly technology that could encourage investment given the ‘free-for-all’ implications involved and so this aspect of Tesla’s research has become mere scientific folklore.

    How can the scientific community justify ignoring what Tesla had discovered, given that the onward interest by others, such as Moray, as described in that book by Keith Tutt mentioned on page 167 of CREATION: The Physical Truth, supported the discovery that energy could be tapped from the electrical state of our space environment? The justification for such ignorance could only be the satisfaction at the time that our oil resources were adequate to meet our needs and so, nearly a century on from there, it is time for a ‘wake-up’ call, given that those oil resources are running out and will not be available when the youth of today reach old age.

    The Aether Factor in Atomic Structure

    Before concluding this Commentary I wish now to outline a physical concept that could justify effort by young would-be researchers who are interested in contributing to the advance of physical theory. It is briefly touched upon on page 41 of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth, where I refer to the discovery that silicon atoms having a nuclear charge Z of 14 have been produced by experiment in a form in which they have a nuclear mass 42, rather than the normal value of 28. I here quote the paragraph in the middle of page 41:

    ‘The clear significance of this is the involvement of aether structure in the sub-structure of the atomic nucleus of atoms other than hydrogen and the implication this has for aether drag ……’

    What, you may wonder, is meant by ‘involvement of aether structure in the sub-structure of the atomic nucleus’? I really feel I have done enough in my theoretical physics efforts without struggling to prove my case and going even further but here are a few thoughts that warrant some attention.

    Physics as presently taught requires acceptance that atoms comprise a combination of Z protons and A-Z neutrons. Suppose, however, that there are no neutrons in atomic structure and all we have is a combination of the isotopes 1H1 and 1H2, meaning protons and deuterons. This might imply that A-Z cannot exceed Z, but it can if we say that some of these charged nucleons can form into a structural lattice array that locks onto aether structure, replacing some of the quons, enough to equal A-2Z, these then serving as what might seem to be neutral particles having zero electric charge.

    What, if any, support can we find for this hypothesis. Well, just scan through the well-established data for the atomic structure of the whole list of known atoms. There is only the 1H1 hydrogen form that has a Z value less than twice A and none record A/Z values as high as 3, which is why that discovery of 14Si42 is so exceptional. To proceed, and with the physics of the atomic bomb and nuclear fission in mind, let us look at the case for uranium. It has an abundance that is quite high given its position in the atomic spectrum. It is therefore stable or effectively so, given that its half-life is estimated at 4.5 billion years. It has the isotopic formula 92U238, whereas the isotopic form 92U235, the extracted form that features in the atomic bomb is unstable. What then is so special about 92U238? Well, just assume it comprises nothing but deuterons, of which 27 have taken up positions in the aether replacing quons. The mass of 27 deuterons will be seen as contributing no charge to the nuclear properties of the uranium atom. It will have a Z value that is half of 238 minus twice 27, which is 92. Why then is 27 so special? The answer is the 3 by 3 by 3 cube configuration of aether structure within the nucleus, a symmetrical structure, symmetry being conducive to stability. Such stability does not exist for the 92U235 atomic nucleus.

    Then ask if stability is enhanced where the charge components, 92 in the case of 92U238, sit outside that 3 by 3 by 3 nuclear core component. Symmetry indicates a 5 by 5 by 5 structure enclosing that 3 by 3 by 3 core meaning that there are 125 minus 27 or 98 possible sites for the 92 deuteron charges that attach themselves to the aether sub-structure but do not replace the quons. A cube has six side faces and so if the central position on each side face of the 5 by 5 by 5 structure is not occupied by a deuteron we do have a symmetrical configuration and 98 minus 6 is 92.

    If one now draws attention to the fact that 90Th232 sits close to 92U238 in the periodic table and has a similar stable form, one can say that symmetry is still preserved for this case because there need be no deuteron at the very centre of the 3 by 3 by 3 structure and, instead of 6 sites at face-centres in the sites of the enveloping cubic structure being unoccupied, the 8 corner sites are unoccupied. The result is that A is reduced by 3(2) and Z by 8 minus 6, as is the case.

    Also relevant to this same line of enquiry is the reported ‘unexpected’ appearance of barium and lanthanum as products of neutron bombardment of uranium, as reported in 1939 by Hahn and Strassmann (Naturwiss., 27, pages 11 and 89). The uranium nucleus is said to divide into at least two nuclei of lighter weight when fission is triggered. What is so special about 56Ba138 and 57La139?

    Well, just suppose that the 3 by 3 by 3 aether lattice core sites within the nuclei of these two atoms are occupied by protons, 26 having replaced the quons, the central site being unoccupied in 56Ba138 but being occupied by a proton that has not replaced a quon in 57La139. Note that 138 minus 26 is 112, which can be the atomic mass of 56 deuterons and 139 minus 27 is 112, which can also be the atomic mass of 56 deuterons. Note then that 125 minus 27 is 98, which indicates the number of sites in the outer aether lattice group. So if each of the 8 corner regions has 7, corresponding to the number of sites in a 2 by 2 by 2 cube corner of the 125 group less the corner site of the 27 group, we have perfect cubic symmetry.

    As to that silicon topic raised on page 41 of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth, the 3 by 3 by 3 configuration has 8 corner sites plus 6 face-centre sites on the cube faces, 14 sites, that can be occupied by protons that do not replace quons, leaving 13 sites which involve quon replacent, 12 by protons and one central site by a deuteron. Overall this accounts for the A 28 value and the Z 14 value. Concerning that special case where silicon could have Z of 14 and A of 42, this would apply if the 14 sites occupied by protons were occupied instead by deuterons.

    For the simple case where A does equal 2Z, as for oxygen atomic nuclei, attachment to aether structure need not have quon replacement if the nucleus comprises nothing other than deuterons and for the more complex situation posed, for example, by 20Cd40, which does have A equal to 2Z there can be a need for quon charge replacement. 13 deuterons plus 14 protons could account for a value of A of 40. Based on a 3 by 3 by 3 structure, cubic symmetry might not be possible but stability could depend upon two diagonally opposite corner sites having similar composition. There are 20 sites on the cube edges, meaning 27 less one centre site and 6 face-centred sites. These 20 sites do not involve quon replacement and contain 14 protons and 6 deuterons. There is quon replacement by deuterons at the 7 other sites. At two diagonally opposite corner sites the three adjacent edge centre sites are occupied by deuterons, the other 14 edge sites being occupied by protons. This configuration satisfies the A of 40 and Z of 20 requirement.

    What I am suggesting here is that the understanding of the nuclear fission of uranium atoms involves physics which must take account of the aethereal cubic lattice structure in space. I see this as explaining why, based on proton and deuteron content alone, the atomic nuclei can have A greater than 2Z without neutrons being an essential component of the atomic nucleus. This is important because, by this brief analysis above, we see that there is good reason to believe that the electrical vacuum medium suggested as the basis for understanding quantum theory has a role that governs atomic fission as well as atomic fusion evidenced by the proton-deuteron transformation.

    Introducing the Duon
    I should now note that, though I have developed the above picture of an atomic nucleus, other than that of the hydrogen atom, as being governed by a deuteron composition and interaction with the underlying lattice-structured vacuum medium, there is the possibility that a fundamental particle form other than the deuteron is involved. I say this because, on pages 122-123 of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth I show that a positive muon and a negative muon might merge to pool their energy, without loss, by being in surface contact with one contracting to half its original charge radius, thereby creating a particle form that has a mass twice that of the muon. That gave basis for the existence of the dimuon which was the needed nucleus for proton creation. By a similar argument one could infer the existence of a particle having the charge of the proton or antiproton but double the proton mass. Such a particle, which I could name as the duon, though not having the structure of a deuteron, might exist within an atomic nucleus but be short-lived and evade detection distinguishing it from a deuteron if separated from that atomic nucleus. So my suggestion is that it might be that reference to a deuteron as a component of an atomic nucleus in the above account could instead be reference to such a duon as a nuclear component. In making this suggestion concerning duons I am encouraged by the thought that the case for the existence of a dimuon is so strong, given its role in proton creation as portrayed by this theory, and yet the dimuon has defied detection, presumably by its rapid decay. The same could apply to the duon, especially as its detection would be even more difficult, given that it could be mistaken for a deuteron.

    Conclusion

    To conclude this Commentary concerning my book, I can but say that it does not surprise me that most of those who may read it will have little interest in what I see as of special interest in physics, namely the understanding of the physical underworld that regulates the values of Planck’s constant, the constant of gravity and the proton/electron mass ratio. After all, that is of mere educational interest and it seems our student population is attracted to subjects other than pure physics. Though I would like to be recognized during my lifetime for the contributions I have made by deciphering what governs the values of those constants, I now see us headed for a catastrophic future if we cannot devise the technology needed to tap into the omnipresent energy underworld of space. That is why I have written my book CREATION: The Physical Truth. It was, in 2004, why, given my professional background in the patent field, I sought and was duly granted U.K. Patent No. GB2390941, hoping that the world might pay attention and seek to exploit the ideas involved. It is why, giving that subject further consideration, I have seen the need to suggest an essential modification concerning that technological idea, this being the subject of U.K. patent application GB2432463, as mentioned above. The technical details can be seen by referring to the Energy Exploitation Message on my web pages at:

    As I will be 80 years of age later this year (2007) I cannot engage in the necessary experimental research myself so I have to be content to publish and just hope that the world benefits from the information I present.

    Below, referenced to the relevant pages of my book CREATION: The Physical Truth, are a few errata and comments concerning the links to the items of record in my web pages.

    Errata
    Page 92: The reference to the item entitled The Exclusion Principle is not on this website www.aspden.org but is instead to be found in the Essay section on website:

    Page 111: The mass ratio term as cubed and then equated to the odd integer 1843 should be reformulated in reciprocal form to become a cube root term.

    Page 126: The formulation of 2μ in the equation at the middle of the page should be changed to 2 times (2μ).

    Page 143: The book title on the first line of this page should read Our Final Century.

    Links to References
    Pages 53, 108, 119 and 150: The full text of the Hadronic Journal pages referenced can be seen by looking at Part 2 of my book Aether Science Papers:

    Page 131: The link to the published papers is:

    Pages 152, 155, 157, 163 and 171: The Energy Science Reports are of record in:

  • To escape from this WEB SITE and visit the author’s related technology site, press:


    Harold Aspden

    *****


    The URL of these Internet Web pages is:
    www.aspden.org


  • DISCOURSE INDEX

    OVERVIEW DISCOURSE TOPICS


    Other topics will be added as this website is developed.


  • OVERVIEW DISCOURSE TOPICS

    OVERVIEW DISCOURSE TOPICS




  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Ov Ov008

    DISCOURSE NO. 8

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2001

    WORLD IN PERIL: IMPENDING DOOM

    The U.K. newspaper, THE TIMES, has today, August 29, 2001, alerted readers to the prospect of impending doom.

    The report occupied most of page 7 of this broad sheet publication. Its first words declared:

    “Britain is facing devastation from the largest wave in recorded history if a predicted catastrophic volcanic eruption in the Canary Islands occurs, according to scientific study.”

    One goes on to read:

    “The scale of destruction, however, will be nothing compared with that in the United States, the Caribbean and Brazil. Here, a series of waves measuring up to 165 ft will pound into densely populated regions, virtually wiping out cities such as New York and Miami and inundating an area up to six miles inland. The natural disaster is predicted to be amongst the worst in history, with the total cost running to many trillions of pounds.”

    “A new prediction of the likely effects, by Simon Day of the Benfield Greig Hazard Research Centre at University College London, suggests that this would create a giant tsunami, much larger than those begun by earthquakes, that would sweep the Atlantic with huge destructive power. Details of his research, conducted with Steven Ward of the University of California, are published next month in the journal Geophysical Review Letters“.

    “Within five minutes of the landslide, a dome of water about a mile high would form and then collapse, before the mega-tsunami fans out in every direction, travelling at speeds of up to 500 mph. A 330 ft. wave would strike the western Sahara in less than an hour.”

    Well, now, after reading all this along with the extensive accompanying text, even taking note of the attempt to reassure and avoid arousing panic, by the last paragraph which says: “It is unlikely to happen in the next century”, I see the need to bring this series of OVERVIEW discourses to an end. I will, therefore, in this concluding Discourse No. 8, add a further prophecy of doom by pointing to a phenomenon connected with the aether itself, one that is rooted also in the geological history of past catastrophic events.

    The theory of the aether which I have presented in these web pages and which I urge should be studied by energy-minded physicists, along with geophysicists concerned with hazards on the grand scale, involves what I have called ‘space domains’. These are vast regions of space bounded by planar boundaries which separate what one might term regions of space and regions of anti-space. In physical terminology, the electrical polarities of whatever constitutes the aether and accounts for the Maxwell-type electrical displacement that accompanies electromagnetic wave propagation, are interchanged as between two sides of a domain boundary, meaning that positive charge becomes negative charge and vice versa. If mankind, along with body Earth, moves through space at our cosmic speed of several hundred km/s, then, once in a while these domain boundaries will need to be crossed, as the Earth takes of the order of a minute or so, depending upon the angle of approach, to traverse a boundary.

    What, then, will happen? Well, I believe there will be a reversal of the Earth’s magnetic field, hardly a traumatic event. But you may say that I am merely speculating about the existence of an aether of this domain-structured form and so doubt whether this warrants further interest. However, if you, the reader, are a geologist then perhaps you will be aware that reversals of the geomagnetic field feature as part of the history of record in rock formations at different strata levels. Along with that data there is evidence of upheaval and destruction, with occasional elimination of species of plant and life forms, seemingly coinciding with the geomagnetic reversals. One wonders if the Earth, in its long period galactic orbit, sometimes traverses a space domain boundary at such an acute angle that it takes several minutes to make the crossing. Consider then the consequences, given that the aether-based theory of gravitation that we discuss in these web pages, tells us that the force of gravity has a range confined to interaction between matter sharing the same space domain. You will then see that that geomagnetic reversal is accompanied by gravity between earthly matter switching-off, as it were, for a quite short period. Imagine the earthquakes and immense dust clouds that then result as the Earth’s surface lifts up owing to the consequential loss-of-gravity expansion effects and centrifugal forces produced by Earth rotation.

    The combination of earthquakes and tidal waves will be of indescribable magnitude and no part of the Earth will remain unaffected. One can only pray that the Earth’s path will happen to be square-on (i.e. at right-angles) with respect to the planar form of the domain boundary, so that the transit period is not prolonged, as it will be if the crossing occurs at a low angle of incidence.

    This, I fear, is the sad side of understanding the physics of the aether. It is as if Nature imposes a price for the intellectual enlightenment as to what constitutes the medium we call ‘space’.

    That insight into the future is something the hazard-risk-evaluating geophysicist needs to consider along with the prospect of volcanic disturbance. Exploring the doomsday scenario from this viewpoint has, incidentally, a spin-off benefit in the interim in that it could redeem the physicist’s lost belief in the existence of a real aether. It opens the door on explaining gravity in terms of aether theory along with discovering how the aether with its domain structure built around a kind of fluid-crystal underworld can determine the most basic dimensionless constants of physics. That door, once open, will surely serve us well for some time yet by leading us to a new energy resource, the aether itself, given that its energy is used by Mother Nature to create all matter.

    In ending, I suggest the reader, might like to know a little more about those geomagnetic field reversals and so I invite inspection of pages 168-174 of Chapter 8 of my book Physics Unified.

    This ends this OVERVIEW section of these web pages. I have tried to present these eight DISCOURSES in an easily readable form, avoiding any specialized knowledge or mathematics and hope the reader has found them interesting.


    H. Aspden
    August 29, 2001




    Full text (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed pages. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 168] considers energy deployment. The basic energy is still in the kinetic form of the rotating space medium. The polarity reversal of the space medium in crossing the boundary is not an actual reversal. It is an apparent reversal. The body has moved from one region to another. The synchronizing constraints in each region will assure that energy is available if needed to sustain a transient condition. Thus the 2Q charge can exist and will disappear as the space region slows down and enough electrons can move in to assure a balance. Bear in mind that the initial crossing of the boundary would destroy the gravitational field momentarily causing the negative charge in the surface regions to be displaced from the surface of the body. It takes a little time to react to the attraction of the central charge and the centrifugal motion seemingly is established in this interval.

    Geomagnetism

    Our next question is that of the effects on the Earth of crossing a space domain boundary. We must, even after the many eons since our Earth was created, be crossing these space domain boundaries as the whole solar system progresses on its course through space. It travels at about 390 km/s, as we saw from the opening words in Chapter 3. At this speed it takes 770 years to travel one light year. It would take about 700,000 years to traverse the space domain calculated in the above example. Therefore, every 700,000 or so years we should suddenly experience a violent upset as gravitation relaxes in effect for the few seconds of transit. Also we should find that the polarity reversal of σ′ causes a magnetic reversal of the Earth’s field.

    In this connection we can calculate the magnetic moment produced by the residual charge Q of the Earth today. This charge is positive at the present time. Its polarity is set opposite to that of σ′ as induced by the rotation of the space frame with the Earth. Magnetic effects are evidenced by disturbances of the lattice particle system. The charge σ′ cannot itself induce a magnetic field because it arises from a displacement of the lattice. Thus it is only the compensating charge Q associated with matter rotating with the frame that can generate a magnetic effect. There is of course a balance charge −Q at the boundary which is part of the system of matter present and this also has to be taken into account. Indeed, it may be shown that the latter charge develops twice the magnetic moment of the distributed core charge. The difference is the same in magnitude as that due to the
    [p. 169] distributed charge but has the direction we associate with negative charge. It is this double action which causes the field to be similar to that of a dipole at the centre of the Earth.

    The earth’s magnetic moment is simply 1/2c times the electric charge velocity moment, or:

    (1/2c)(2/5)(4πσ′/3)R5w(227)

    From (218) and the fact that σ is e/d3:

    σ′ = 2ew/Ωd3(228)

    Then, since Ω is c/2r, we put (228) in (227) to find a magnetic moment of:

    16πerR5w2/15d3c2(229)

    In this expression er is the Bohr Magneton, known from experiment to be 9·27 10−21 cgs units. d was shown above to be 6·37 10−11 cm. For the Earth today w is 7·26 10−5 rad/s. c is 3 1010 cm/s.

    The resulting value of the geomagnetic moment is very critically dependent upon R, the radius of the space medium rotating with the Earth. Thus, if R is 6·45 108 cm the magnetic moment is 7·86 1025 cgs units. If R is 6·50 108 cm the magnetic moment is 8·17 1025 cgs units. In fact, the radius of the Earth is 6·38 108 cm and the geomagnetic moment measured is 8·06 1025 cgs units.

    These are very significant results, which bear out the essential validity of the theory presented. Evidently the Earth’s space boundary is about 100 km above the Earth’s surface on this theory. There is the question of the direction of the geomagnetic moment and the precession of the poles needs explanation, but we do have here the essential foundations for an understanding of the nature of the geomagnetic field.

    It is feasible to think of the Earth’s magnetic field reversing at times when the Earth is carried across a space domain boundary. By studying the evidence of the Earth’s magnetic field reversals some indication of the existence, the size, and the form of the space domains should become available. We have inferred their approximate size from the theory of the space medium and the hypothesis that the known mass of the sun is typical of stellar mass generally. It remains a mystery as to why space domains of this particular size should form. To probe that question is to seek to understand why the stars have a particular mass and such questions must be deferred at this time. However, we can picture the reversal pattern of the
    [p. 170] geomagnetic field for a simple domain structure. As each domain has about the same size a simple cubic domain structure seems an appropriate choice. The results will be an approximation only, inasmuch as all stars do not have the same mass/radius parameter. To estimate the degree of approximation let us consider the extreme example of a red giant star in comparison with the sun. Betelgeux is said by Jeans* to be about 40 times as massive as the sun and to occupy 25,000,000 times as much volume. The mass/radius parameter is 0·137 compared with the sun. The value of D given by (226) is 0·37 for this red giant star, compared with the sun’s domain radius D at creation. However, a red giant is believed to be the decaying form of a star, rather than the form it may have upon initial creation. Since the majority of stars are similar to the sun we can, therefore, expect a reasonably-representative pattern of magnetic field reversals to emerge from a choice of a simple cubic structured domain system. A reversal period of the order of 700,000 years is to be expected for motion parallel with a main axis of the cubic domain structure. In general, however, a motion will be inclined to such an axis and the planes separating domain boundaries will be crossed more frequently than this.

    In Fig. 40 the hypothetical pattern of reversals due to motion through cubic domain space is shown in a time scale measured in millions of years before the present time. The solar system is imagined to move in a straight line through domain space over this period of time, though it does move in a slight arc owing to the galactic motion. The inclination of the line with the domain cube axes is chosen deliberately to give results which resemble the observed reversal sequence and the time scale has been matched accordingly. The names assigned to the reversals are those used conventionally to designate these events. There is a reasonably close correlation. The interesting result, however, is that such an erratic pattern of events lends itself to decoding in this way. The author believes that this is affirmative support for the domain theory suggested, especially as the size of the domains derived from the empirical data fit is in close accord with that calculated for the sun. Note that the analysis leading to (226) required D to be the radius of a spherical domain. The corresponding cube dimension would be smaller than this. The data in Fig. 40 suggest a domain cube size of about 400,000 years at the [p. 171] [p. 172] Earth’s speed through the space system. At 390 km/s this gives a domain cube size of about 500 light years.

    * J. H. Jeans, The Stars in their Courses, Cambridge University Press, p. 92 (1931).

    Fig. 40: Earth path in galactic orbit crossing cubic space domain boundaries, with the named geomagnetic reversals and a scale in millions of years
    Fig. 40

    A textbook showing the Earth’s magnetic field reversal pattern over the past four million years is one by Tarling and Tarling.* They also comment on the rather perplexing evidence which shows that fossil species have disappeared at times of reversal and new species have appeared shortly thereafter. This implies that the geomagnetic field reversal was accompanied by a rather more traumatic event. Reporting on the documentary evidence of data gleaned from the deep-sea floor of the Indian Ocean, the Science Correspondent of The Times wrote in 1972:†

    . . . tiny metallic and glass beads that originated from outer space . . . were fragments from some great cosmic catastrophe that caused molten particles to splash into the atmosphere some 700,000 years ago. The shower of debris coincided with the last reversal of the earth’s magnetic field.

    The reader will notice that Fig. 40 shows a recent reversal of the geomagnetic field. The above report and the Tarling book both suggest that the last reversal was 700,000 years ago. If this were true then another reversal would be imminent on the time scale used in Fig. 40. However, since these reports were written evidence of a reversal about 12,000 years ago, a very short-lived reversal, has emerged. This fits very well with the empirical evidence in Fig. 40, which shows a near crossing of a cube domain edge, meaning two reversals in rapid succession. The author was unaware of the latest discovery of the reversal when outlining this domain theory at the end of his book Modern Aether Science, published early in 1972. The fact that we have had a magnetic reversal in relatively recent times is reassuring if such events are accompanied by cosmic upheavals. One may well wonder whether catastrophic geological events can be traced to this recent period.

    On a longer time scale it is interesting to consider the circuital motion of the solar system in its galactic cycle and contemplate the fact that the Earth would cross the domain boundaries at different angles of incidence with a four-fold periodicity per galactic cycle. If
    [p. 173] the gravitational field between matter in the Earth is disturbed when the domain boundaries are traversed, the faster the crossing, the less the disturbance. The crossing will be most rapid when the Earth approaches the boundary in the normal direction. If it approaches a boundary at a low angle it will take much longer to traverse it. Indeed, it seems statistically possible for an approach to be at such a low angle that the Earth could disintegrate on reaching the domain boundary. The probability is very small but it is a consequence of this theory and one might wonder whether the asteroids really originated in a planet broken up in this way.

    * D. H. Tarling and M. P. Tarling, Continental Drift, Bell, London, pp. 52 and 66 (1971).

    † P. Wright, ‘A Mine of Knowledge from the Sea’, The Times, London, August 17 (1972).

    These ideas are highly speculative but take encouragement from the researches of Steiner.* He has made an extensive study of the possible correlation between geological events and the galactic motion and concluded that the constant of gravitation G may, in some way, depend upon the period in the galactic cycle. The theoretical interpretation of such data is difficult in view of the uncertainties in the present state of cosmological theory, particularly so far as concerns the variation of G. The problem is further confused by the expanding Earth hypothesis which is dependent upon a slowly varying G. Yet Einstein’s theory hardly permits G to vary and the author’s theory presented in this work requires G to be as constant as the charge-mass ratio of the electron. One feels that if the latter were to change then all other parameters, such as the speed of light and the dimensions of the space lattice and even energy, would change as well. The author therefore favours the supposition that G is constant but only acts between matter within specific domains of space. This renders G effectively dependent upon the position of our planet as far as geological events are concerned and seems to offer scope for relating geological events and galactic motion. However, far more research is needed before these ideas can leave the realm of speculation. Meanwhile, reverting to the statement above that there would be a four-fold periodicity of gravitational upset in the galactic cycle if the space domain ideas hold, the author draws attention to another paper by Steiner† in which he writes:

    If Phanerozoic geological history incorporates any periodicities, they are of the order of 60 or perhaps 70 million years. . . . The galactic periodicity of the solar system is, however, approximately [p. 174] 274 million years, representing the length of the cosmic year, or one revolution around the galactic centre.

    * J. Steiner, Jour. Geol. Soc. Australia, 14, 99 (1967).

    † J. Steiner, ‘Geology’, p. 89 (1973).

    The author’s ideas on space domains and their correlation with geomagnetic field reversals and geological disturbances are also presented in a paper in Catastrophist Geology, 2, 42 (1977).

  • NUCLEAR FUSION: HOT AND COLD

    DISCOURSE NO. 7

    NUCLEAR FUSION: HOT AND COLD

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2001


    Although our scientific fraternity believes that the sun derives its power from the process of nuclear fusion and many billions of dollars have been spent trying to tame the process here on Earth in fusion reactors, the story to date is one of failure. The time has come when we should at least consider what heresy is telling us, namely that maybe the sun’s energy is not sustained by thermonuclear reactions which demand temperatures of 100,000,000 or so degrees.


    INTRODUCTION

    Contemporary with my heretical prophecies, back in the 1950s and 1960s, saying that there is an aether containing a vast sea of energy and that Einstein’s philosophy was wrong, there was a scientist named Charles E R Bruce at the laboratories of E.R.A. (Electrical Research Association) in U.K. who was trying to convince us that cosmic phenomena evolve from enormous electrical discharges. His mind was on the induction of electrical fields in space, of sufficient strength to promote plasma discharges that could account for much of what we see in the activity of stars.

    As can be seen from scrutiny of these Web pages my interest has been the possible analogy between the aether and the formation of magnetic domains in iron, owing to energy deployment in a structured background and the development of the Bohr-quantized states of motion that go with the ferromagnetic state. My thinking is that the aether has a hidden structure and develops its own Bohr-quantized states of motion, so providing the governing quantum-based influence that regulates action in matter. Part of this picture involves the induction of strong electric fields in the aether as transitions occur which bring about order from a state of disorder, the onset of gravitation in the aether being analogous with the onset of ferromagnetism in iron cooled through its Curie temperature. The formation of stars with attendant presence of very strong electric fields has something in common with Bruce’s ideas on cosmological electric discharges.

    So, I was not spellbound at the thought that the power of the sun has to be primarily that of a nuclear fusion reaction. On the other hand, when the electrical manufacturing company I was working for back in the 1950s took an interest in fusion reactor research, I was absorbed by the problem encountered, namely that of stabilizing the electrical discharge that was to trigger fusion in the reactor. This seemed to be a straightforward problem of confining a high current discharge by its self-pinch action.

    My interest was enhanced by my own private research pursuit of connecting the gravity force with its electrodynamic origin, a pursuit which by 1958 had made me realize something rather important about the true form of the Law of Electrodynamics, meaning the law of force governing how one isolated electron in motion acts on another such electron. It was to lead me soon thereafter into publishing a book in 196o entitled The Theory of Gravitation in which I presented what I believe is the correct form of the Law of Electrodynamics.

    However, gravitation aside, I could not ignore the challenge of applying my mind to the problem posed by the electrodynamic discharge instability encountered in hot fusion reactor research. Indeed, that interest led to the filing of a patent on a reactor design that aimed to improve the stability of the plasma discharge. See [1958b].

    Now, in retrospect, looking back to the 1958-59 period, I was enough of a scientific ‘conformist’ to accept basic teachings concerning electrical theory. The electrodynamic force between two discrete electric charges in motion was something that had never been measured in the laboratory. All the tests had been performed on interactions involving action of electrons attributable to closed circuit current flow. I exploited this distinction in formulating my own Law of Electrodynamics. However, the problem with the discharge in the fusion reactor was not one that needed my modified version of this law, or so I thought at the time!

    By 1966, however, with the reactor control problems still persisting, it was evident that something quite unusual was affecting the electrodynamic interaction in the high current plasma discharge. I saw my chance early in 1965 and, though then working for IBM and no longer having a job interest in power engineering, I thought it worth commenting on this electrodynamic law topic in a Letter to the Editor of the IEE journal ‘Electronics and Power’. See: [1965a].

    An experiment using current flow in a falling column of mercury had replicated the discharge instability, even with a stabilizing axial magnetic field, and the lateral wriggle, snaking of the discharge, was shared by that column of mercury. Now, Ampere had based his formulation of electrodynamic force on four empirical facts plus one assumption. That assumption was crucial to determining the choice of law. I saw that experiment with the falling column of mercury as providing the fifth empirical fact needed to determine the law without making any assumption. My finding was that this supported the form of law that I had presented in my 1960 book, The Theory of Gravitation..

    I was striving to justify my development of a Unified Field Theory, meaning the ultimate objective of presenting the unifying link between gravitation and electrodynamics, the pursuit which had defied Einstein’s efforts.

    That Electronic and Power Letter was published in April 1965 and the Editor had invited comment by Dr. A A Ware, the author of the paper in the January 1965 issue that had discussed the status of hot fusion reactor design and shown the falling mercury column experiment Dr. Ware put the case that no isolated charge in motion is truly independent of a closed circuit current path, inasmuch as displacement currents in the vacuum assure current loop action. Accordingly, rigorous mathematics denied me the scope for incorporating a modifying term in the formulation of that law of electrodynamics.

    There you see the crux of my problem in contending, not with the physics of the subject, but with the attitude of the orthodox scientist. Once you say that a moving charge in isolation has to have its action as a current closed by displacement currents along a path through the vacuum medium, then you invite me to say that the net electrodynamic force action is shared between forces acting on the charge and forces acting on the displacement current. You invite me to say that the real part of the current circuit, the seat of the charge in motion, can interact with the aether to set up forces between charge and aether. In my efforts to get my message across all I am trying to do is to get the scientific community to understand that forces can be exerted electrodynamically between charge in motion and the aether. This means that the aether can act on the charge to speed it up or slow it down, energy being exchanged between charge and aether, and it means that the force need not act at right angles to charge motion as conventional theory requires. I saw the instabilities in the falling mercury discharge as being attributable to the tendency of the discharge to extend along its flow path.

    I did react by submitting another Letter to the Editor of Electronics and Power, published in the June 1965 issue. See [1965b] and proceeded to show why that experiment with the falling column of mercury had more to tell us concerning how there really are electrodynamic forces acting axially along the path of current flow. This is contrary to standard teaching based on the Lorentz force law.

    Slowly but surely, given that such axial forces exist in that falling column of mercury to cause it to wriggle and defy all attempts to stabilize it, I came to realize that there was no way a thermonuclear reactor could ever succeed if its designers relied on electrodynamic pinch in the discharge.

    However, there was hope on the horizon. I had in my 1960 book The Theory of Gravitation shown that the rotation of a sphere of aether within a plenum of enveloping aether can induce a radial electric field about the axis of spin, albeit a field that is compensated by charge displacement in coextensive matter. I was later to discover from the experimental research of R. T. Ryan and B. Vonnegut (‘Formation of a Vortex by an Elevated Electrical Heat Source’, Nature Physical Science, 233 142, 1971), who sought to understand the secret of how tornadoes are formed, that they could stabilize an electric arc discharge, confining it to its axis, merely by quite slowly spinning about that axis a cylindrical metal cage. Here was the indication that the aether within that cage might be rotating about the axis of the arc discharge and producing a radial electric field which the arc plasma neutralized, but in so doing was constrained by radial forces which could overpower the radial electrodynamic effects.

    Had I been working in the thermonuclear research field I would have urged investigations of the potential implied by Vonnegut’s findings. In the event, however, I had in my sights a hope that there could be an entirely different prospect of generating power from a electrical plasma discharge. Arising from my curiosity about that falling mercury column developing instabilities when carrying a current, I began to ponder on the question whether the law governing electrodynamic force, as set up between two moving electrons, is also governing in the case where, say, a moving proton acts on a moving electron. That mercury column experiment involved a closed circuital current, which usually means that electrons, and electrons alone, carry the current around the circuit. However, in that mercury, it being a liquid metal conductor, there are free electrons that can act as carriers of the current, but also there are positive heavy ions that are not locked into a crystal lattice and so are mobile and must, therefore, as part of a flow of mercury, share in the electric charge transport. The current might flow around a closed loop, but in one part of that loop the flow is all-electron in composition and in the remaining part it is part-electron and part-heavy-ion.

    This, plus something I could glean from the science references to anomalous force effects in cold-cathode (non-electron) arc discharges, caused me to do some analysis on how two moving charges of different mass might react in an inertial sense to a mutual interaction force, assuming that energy is conserved. The result was fascinating. The analysis of this problem featured in the second edition [1966a] of The Theory of Gravitation and later in a peer-reviewed paper of mine that appeared in the Journal of the Franklin Institute [1969a].

    There just had to be a force term in the law of electrodynamics giving an action along the line of current flow, but the finding that impressed me was that the force acting on the heavy ion would be enhanced by a factor equal to the mass ratio as between that ion and the electron. This could mean a thousand-fold increase of the force and it would imply energy transfer from electrons to heavy ions in a manner that, by standard physics, would seem anomalous. So I was, at this stage in my research, beginning to see that what I was exploring was potentially not just an academic pursuit aimed at the problem of gravitation and the Unified Field Theory. There could be technological consequences.

    The key step in my analysis in deriving this law of electrodynamics was that of deciding whether I would assume that the interaction force set up between the two moving charges could induce reaction forces on the charges that would mean overall an imbalance of angular momentum or of linear momentum. There just had to be one or the other in the general case. I opted for the imbalance of linear momentum, knowing that the resulting form of the law of electrodynamics would include a specific situation for which there is no imbalance in either sense, meaning full compliance with Newton’s Third Law that action balances reaction. That was the only way I could see scope for electrodynamics embracing gravitation. The specific condition meant that gravitation would have to involve action between charges moving mutually parallel at all times.

    Furthermore the gravitating charges, the ones setting up the gravity forces, would have the same mass or, as I later established, be part of a group of charges which, collectively, could cooperate in a compatible form, having regard to their charge effects.

    To discuss that would divert us to the gravitational aspects of my theoretical work, whereas here I wish to pursue the anomalous energy topic.

    The breach of the law that inertial action balances reaction means, simply, that energy is being exchanged between the interacting charges and the local aether underworld which determines the electromagnetic reference frame. In short, I could see scope for beginning to believe that electrical plasma discharges involving ions much heavier than electrons might be able to tap energy from the aether itself.

    This would be something far more exciting than the generation of power by nuclear transmutation, whether fission or fusion. However, I was busy earning my living in a corporate environment not concerned with power generation. All I could do was pursue my theoretical investigations as a hobby and see where that pursuit took me.

    My interest in the cold-cathode arc discharge energy prospects spilled over in 1977 when I declared my position in a paper published by the IEEE [1977a] and, to be sure of publication, I had even recorded my disclosure in a patent specification filed at the British Patent Office and duly published (Patent No. 2,002,953) [1979b].


    Harold Aspden
    August 20, 2001



  • THE PARLOUS STATE OF PHYSICS

    DISCOURSE NO. 6

    THE PARLOUS STATE OF PHYSICS

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1999


    The title of this Discourse is a phrase I used in an item of correspondence published in the Proceedings of the IEE in U.K. in 1958. See [1958a].


    INTRODUCTION

    I will begin this account by taking note of the Concise Oxford Dictionary (1934 edition) definition of the word ‘parlous’.

    So, you will understand that I was saying 41 years ago, back in the year 1958, that Physics was in a ‘perilous’ state which renders it ‘hard to deal with’, even though it is ‘surprisingly clever’. I may say that my opinion has not changed, nor will it so long as physicists choose to believe Einstein’s theory and the way it excludes interest in the aether that fills all space. You may wonder why I was so concerned and wonder further what right I had to voice such an opinion, given that I was putting my views forward in the forum of an Engineering society and not one dedicated to the subject of Physics.

    Well, first of all, I point out that if the Physics which is applied to problems in electrical science is leading us in the wrong direction, then the discipline of Electrical Engineering is also being thwarted. Engineers are concerned with making progress in the real world, whereas physicists, the ones building theories about space and time are living in an imaginary world and undermining the foundations on which engineers have to build.

    In my school years, Physics, with Mathematics closely behind, was my best subject. I won the school Physics Prize in the year I left school to migrate to university, but opted to study for a science degree in Electrical Engineering. This was the world of electric power generation, electric motors, magnetic energy storage in the inductance of a circuit, electrical power transmission and, of course, the problems of working with high frequency and high voltages, and learning how to make electrical measurements. That was all ground work for my later research pursuits for a Ph.D. where I addressed the problem of why the accepted electrical theory concerning the induced currents which flow in steel, as used in electrical machines and power transformers, when subjected to an alternating magnetic field simply gives the wrong answer by a significant factor of error.

    Here was a problem, one that stood on the engineer’s platform with the physicist being an onlooker, but here was a scientific problem which, once solved, could, indeed can, revolutionize our electrical power industry. I was not destined to decipher its secret during my Ph.D. years but did my best and duly recorded my findings in I.E.E. papers published two or three years later. See [1956a], [1956b], [1957a].

    Now the point of this introduction is to explain why I became interested in the action of a magnetic field in developing reaction effects inside a metal, in this case steel. I knew from my physics training that one can store energy by setting up a magnetic field within a vacuum. Moreover, I knew that one can recover that energy by switching off the action producing the field. Common sense was sufficient to say that there is something in that vacuum that can house that energy and keep it safe so that it is still there when we want to recover it. However, I knew that physicists avoided explaining all this in simple language of the kind an engineer might use. They hid behind their formulae and the ‘laws’ they had devised based on certain empirical facts. They got the right answers but did not understand the processes of energy storage involved.

    Ignoring the vacuum, or aether, for a moment, the question of how that magnetic energy is stored in solid metal warrants comment. Physics told me that metal, as an electrical conductor, contains free electrons, all moving about at random amongst a background of atoms having a residual positive charge, charge which was locked in place by the crystal structure of those atoms. Overall the metal is electrically neutral. However, if a magnetic field is applied to that metal, something I was doing daily in my experiments, then those electrons are, according to our physics teaching, duly deflected in their paths so that they describe helical orbits and react to produce a magnetic field opposing the one applied.

    My research involved alternating magnetic fields, but this reaction occurs even with a steady field. However, in practice one sees no such reaction on the scale indicated by the accepted theory. When I searched to find how this was explained by physicists I found several attempts at explanations, itself enough to show that physicists were baffled. The problem was left in limbo by the expedient of suggesting that statistical factors were self-compensating. The empirical facts were thereby obscured by an ‘unwritten’ law of physics, which said that ‘what is, has to be, whether you can understand it or not!’

    I was amused by one explanation which appealed to my engineering instincts. It amounted to saying, “Yes, the thermal motion of those electrons did produce an enormous back-reaction field that could overwhelm and virtually cancel the applied field, but that happily there were electrons just inside the boundaries of the metal surface and these always provide the necessary compensating effect”. The argument was that they bounced from the inside of that metal surface so as to be forced to migrate in a closed loop path embracing the body of the metal, thereby producing a strong magnetic field in the forward field direction of just enough strength to cancel the whole of the back-reaction field. Why was this amusing? Well, just ask yourself how an electron can bounce from the notional boundary surface separating the crystal structure formed by the atoms of the metal from the enveloping empty space. What were those electrons supposed to hit before bouncing back? If they collided with other electrons then the electron momentum would be conserved, meaning no bounce that could change the field action. If they collided with an atom they would not hit the positive nucleus because that is secluded behind a screen of electrons. So one has to suppose that they might escape into free space and so cause the metal body to acquire a positive residual charge that would itself bring the electron back into the metal, but surely without it having changed its lateral momentum. It just cannot be part of a net electron migration around the inside boundary of the metal.

    This to me was simple common sense. It was just an onward step from this to realize that there has to be a significant magnetic field reaction in metal when subjected to a steady magnetic field and the textbook teaching which denied such an effect just had to be wrong.

    When I considered this I realized that one should not rely on the ‘laws’ taught by physics teachers. Here was something that defied those laws. My approach was to say that energy was being deployed into that metal and drawn from the source applying that magnetization. I knew that potential energy, the kind we associate with electrical voltages, tends to reduce as dynamic energy, the kind we associate with motion and magnetism, tends to increase, keeping overall energy balance, but subject to some conduction loss by conversion into heat energy. So I said that the system would adopt a condition for which the maximum amount of energy had been deployed into the back-field reaction for a given applied field. Analysis of this assured me that the back-reaction field would be of precisely half the strength of the applied field.

    This seemed an odd result until I considered what it really meant. We pretend the back reaction effect does not exist and so work out the relationship between the magnetic field produced and the current in a magnetizing winding producing that field. This we incorporate into out units in physics. Suppose, however, that the actual relationship between the field produced and the current is twice that we assume. Then, given that the system subjected to that magnetic field will always react to half-cancel the field, then we are back to what we really observe. It is just that we get by by ignoring the fact that there really is a back-reaction field produced.

    We get by, knowing what we know, but miss the opportunities that lie before us of discovering what we do not know if only we could just see things in that deeper perspective and come to accept that half-field reaction. What this then means is that if we mount a ferromagnetic rod on spigots and reverse its magnetic polarization suddenly, then the angular momentum change will only be half that we expect from our knowledge of the charge-to-mass ratio of the electron. So we can test what I am saying, and confirm what common sense says about the physics of the back-reaction.

    I knew that such an experiment had been done and so I knew I was right in what I was proposing. However, I also knew that the back-reaction theory, by which all magnetic fields calculated from their current source values had to be doubled before being halved by back-reaction, had to extend outside solid metal and into free space, the vacuum.

    Accordingly, I knew that here was the clear evidence of the existence of a real aether in which electric charge is in a state of motion. Yes, I had then my answer as to how magnetic energy is stored and then recovered from the vacuum medium. The setting up of the field generates heat and disperses energy in space, but the persistence of the field acting on the omnipresent moving aether charge orientates the field reaction set up by the aether itself. Then, when the current is switched off, the aether becomes the primary field source and feeds its energy into the winding that provided that current. The aether cools a little as a result but overall, in coping with the problem of our inductive magnetization cycle, the aether keeps its energy balance.

    So here I was, in the mid 1950s, now committed to belief in a real aether, having a simple ‘engineer’s’ insight into the reason for the gyromagnetic spin anomaly of the ferromagnetic rod, and having solved the mystery of the problem known as ‘the absence of free electron diamagnetism’.

    However, how could I, a young Cambridge Ph.D. needing to earn my living, stand up and challenge what Einstein had said about there being no need for an aether and, more to the point, challenge Nobel Laureate Paul Dirac by saying that his interpretation of the factor 2 of the gyromagnetic ratio was wrong? Dirac had confounded the physics world by distilling from Einstein’s equations a formula which gave the electron a half-quantum spin factor. Here was Dirac, originally a graduate in Electrical Engineering, having become a theoretical physicist by propounding an abstruse mathematical case that came to be accepted by his brother physicists but yet did not tell me how to solve my problem of field reaction in steel.

    So, in saying that physics is in a ‘parlous’ state, I say that with some considerable feeling. Dirac’s theory is surprisingly clever. It is ‘hard to deal with’ and by its general acceptance our world of theoretical physics has been left in a ‘perilous’ state.

    So do read that message of mine that found its way into the Proceedings of the Institution of Electrical Engineers back in the year 1958. Press: [1958a]. After that, when you have digested how easy it is to derive the formula E=Mc2 by saying that an accelerated electron does not radiate itself and so can survive life in an atom without depending upon the quantum ruling of the physicist, then do look at something of mine published years later in 1971. It also appeared in a publication of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, but in their journal Electronics and Power. Press: [1971a] and you will see that Paul Dirac did eventually try to use ‘engineer’s’ language when describing his view of the electron. His insight into the notion of an electron that extends physically throughout all space with no defining boundary, but yet requires that the laws of physics break down inside the electron, is quite interesting. That alone tells me that physics is in a ‘parlous state’.

    Hopefully, this Discourse No. 6 will serve as an explanation of what motivated my interest in the subject of these Web pages, besides helping the reader to understand why what I am saying has not been assimilated into the standard teachings of Physics. There is just too much for physicists to undertake, as they would have to unscramble so much of the nonsense woven into their picture of the fabric of space. The way forward lies in tapping useful energy from the aether which physicists say does not exist.

    Harold Aspden
    February 15, 1999



  • THE AETHER IN DETAIL

    ADDENDUM TO DISCOURSE NO. 5

    THE AETHER IN DETAIL

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2001, 2003


    Having, as it were, seemingly immersed you in a sea of aether, but in a pictorial sense, I now seek to introduce the aether in detail, not within these web pages, which I now want to confine to the technological aspects of ENERGY SCIENCE, but by pointing the way forward via my related web site, www.aspden.org, to locations where the theory of the aether is to be found.


    INTRODUCTION

    I wrote the 2001 version of this web page some three years after entering DISCOURSE No. 5 on the web site and at a time when I had begun to bring my publications into PDF (Portable Document Format) form which can be read by Acrobat Reader. Accordingly, I can now rely on easy reference to the original published forms of what I have written over the years since I began my investigations into the detailed form of the aether.

    An appropriate starting point, by reference to that separate web site where I address the physics theme, is to draw attention to the book I wrote in 1996 entitled ‘Aether Science Papers’, pointing out that my aether theory was the subject of an evolving sequence of publications, namely ‘The Theory of Gravitation’ (1960), ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, 2nd Edition (1966), ‘Physics without Einstein’ (1969), ‘Modern Aether Science’ (1972), ‘Gravitation’ (1975), and ‘Physics Unified’ (1980).

    It was in the years following that 1980 period that I found my scientific papers on the subject were less likely to be rejected for publication by so-called ‘peer review’ and so my published work of the 1980s is in the regular scientific periodical paper form. Evenso, lost as those papers are in the academic jungle of science on record in university libraries, it seems worthwhile to provide this Internet information.

    ‘Aether Science Papers’ was published in 1996, essentially because I had declared the intention to provide that sequel on the back cover of my 1972 book ‘Modern Aether Science’. I think it appropriate, therefore, to refer now to what I said on the last page of that work and refer also to its back cover summary.

    I invite you to browse through these items, taking note of what I say about the ‘supergraviton’. In reading that again in this year 2001, I see that in 1996 I promised a ‘technological sequel’ to that work (‘Aether Science Papers’). These web pages will evolve into that ‘sequel’. Meanwhile, I urge you to delve into that book and build an understanding of the aether by following the reference leads. Hopefully you will then share my enthusiasm for the science that this insight into the aether affords and, possibly, come to share in the onward effort to seek out the best way of tapping into the vast energy resources of that aether.

    I will aim to compile that ‘technological sequel’ by building on the nucleus of Energy Science Reports that I will incorporate into my TECHNOLOGY section of these web pages, as well as in the Bibliographic section of my site www.aspden.org. It will evolve in stages as I compile, possibly in book form, an updated account of what is discussed in the existing Reports.

    Use this link to see the text of the last page and back cover of ‘Aether Science Papers’.


    Harold Aspden
    September 1, 2001
    & July 10, 2003