1977e
The following is a paper by H. Aspden (using an alias name J. N. Kidman) published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 18, pp. 181-182 (1977).
QUANTUM GRAVITATION AND THE PERIHELION ANOMALY
This paper shows a way of deriving the theoretical formula for the anomalous perihelion motion of a planet, exactly the same as that developed from Einstein’s four-space theory, but based on an extremely simple proposition founded in classical physics. The paper is a mere two pages in length and should be read in its full non-abstracted form as a PDF file 1977e
The reason why this paper was authored by an alias is that I wondered whether my many submissions of papers for publication, inevitably followed by referee rejection, had classified me as someone whose ideas were not to be encouraged. I wanted to test the water, as it were, by writing from a different personal (not business and non-academic) address and using a different name. This paper was promptly accepted and so I drew the conclusion that at least it was not the use of my home address that was obstructing acceptance, though my experience later, as well in my early university days, was that an address that implied a scientific environment was, indeed, as important as the merit of the paper itself.
Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)
Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.
[p. 181]
LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO VOL. 18, N. 6 5 Febbraio 1977
Quantum Gravitation and the Perihelion Anomaly.
10 Birch House, Lingwood Close – Bassett, Southampton, England
(ricevuto il 13 Settembre 1976)
Consider the following hypothesis: If a particle of relatively small mass m is acted upon by a particle of relatively large mass M so as to be accelerated towards M at a rate f, then the force which M exerts on m is that applicable when m is a distance s further away from M, s being the distance (1/2)ft2 corresponding to the acceleration f in the time t, where t is the time taken for a photon to travel from m to M and back to m.
This involves a retarded action of the force which M exerts on m, in as much as it takes time for the field system the adjust to the motion of m.
On the basis of this hypothesis we find that when m is in orbit about M and subject to mutual gravitational attraction then m describes an ellipse whose major axis advances about a focus in the direction of motion of m. This corresponds to the advance of perihelion for planetary motion. The equation of motion is identical to that deduced using the general theory of relativity.
Since the hypothesis could have quantum features, by virtue of its dependence upon a propagation mechanism similar to that of photons for establishing the interaction force, it may be that a link can be established between general relativity and quantum gravitation. The need for a new physics to account for such a link has recently been discussed by Ginzberg (1), who has, however, expressed the view that quantization of general relativity is unimportant under normal astronomical conditions. Nevertheless it may be that phenomena evident only in the astronomical situation, such as the anomalous motion of planetary perihelia, can lead us to the connection between the quantum world and the world of gravitation.
This paper serves solely to present the argument that the above hypothesis gives the same equation for the advance of perihelion of a planet as does that derived from general relativity. It is left to the reader to assess the relevance of this to the physical interpretation of the natural phenomena involved. The identity of the result with that obtained by Einstein is possibly significant in itself, because there are several theories of gravitation from which perihelion formulations are derived. A comparison of such theories has been presented by Whitrow and Morduch (2).
(1) V. L. Ginzberg: Quart. Journ. Roy. Astron. Soc., 16, 265 (1975).
(2) G. J. Whitrow and G. E. Morduch: Nature, 188, 790 (1960).
[p. 182]
To calculate the perihelion motion we apply Kepler’s third law of planetary motion: the squares of the periodic times are proportional to the cubes of the mean distances of the planets from the Sun. An orbit period T is related to the distance R separating the two masses by the relation:
T ∝ R3/2 .(1)
There is no perihelion advance in the Newton-Kepler system due to two-body interaction. A radial perturbation has the same harmonic frequency as the orbital motion. There is perihelion advance if the radial perturbation has an oscillation period which is slower than the orbital period. Thus if (1) represents the orbital period and is modified due to the change of R to R + s for radial oscillations, as results from the above hypothesis, we will expect a perihelion motion. The radial-oscillation period is T(1 + s/R)3/2, a fractional increase over T of 3s/2R, if s is small relative to R. Now to find s we put t = 2R/c, where c is the speed of light. The acceleration f is v2/R, where v is the orbital-speed component. T is then 2πR/v. Since s = (1/2)ft2, these data give 3s/2R = 3(v/c)2, which is the proportional rate of advance of perihelion. The advance in radians per revolution is 2π-times this quantity or, in terms of T,
(24π3/T2)(R2/c2) .(2)
For elliptical motion in which eccentricity e is significant, the above retardation effect modifies Newton’s law of gravitation:
m(d2u/dθ2) + mu = GMm/h2(3)
to the Einstein law of gravitation:
m(d2u/dθ2) + mu = (GMm/h2)(1 + 3h2u2/c2)(4)
and leads to a perihelion advance of
(24π3/T2)(a2/(c2(1 − e2)))(5)
in radians per revolution, presented here in the form used by Einstein (3) in his 1916 paper.
In these expressions u = 1/R, h = vR, G is the constant of gravitation, θ is the angular position of m in its elliptical orbit of major semi-axis a.
(3) A. Einstein: The Principle of Relativity (New York, N. Y., 1952), p. 109. (This is collection of papers including Einstein’s paper on The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity, in Ann. der Phys., 49 (1916).)
