Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Overview

Overview and introductory articles

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • THE HERESY OF THE AETHER

    DISCOURSE NO. 4

    THE HERESY OF THE AETHER

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998


    ‘Ether’ (also Aether): a substance formerly believed to fill all space and to be responsible for trasmitting electromagnetic waves.


    INTRODUCTION

    The above is the definition of the word ‘ether’ to be found in a Chambers dictionary, 1998. A 1934 Edition of the Concise Oxford Dictionary defines the ether as ‘the subtle elastic fluid permeating space and filling the interstices between particles of air and other matter, a medium through which light-waves are propagated.’ In these web pages I use the spelling ‘aether’ to distinguish it from the chemical (anaesthetic) meaning of the word ‘ether’.

    These dictionary meanings are ambiguous. The aether is best defined as ‘that which fills space devoid of matter’. If you say there is ‘nothing’ in that space, meaning that space itself is ‘nothingness’, then ‘space’, which the dictionary defines as ‘a continuous extension viewed with or without reference to the existence of objects in it’, is something you view when there is nothing there to see. With its other meaning you are viewing something that is not there by looking at what is there. ‘Nothingness’ means ‘non-existent’. The word ‘aether’ has to mean something and the physicist should accept it as meaning ‘that which fills space devoid of matter’, even though he or she may try then to prove that what does fill that space is so subtle as to be ignored for all practical purposes.

    There are then three scientific perspectives that one can consider. Firstly, it can be declared by way of assumption that the aether has a specific property of determining the constant speed of light relative to an absolute universal frame of reference. Alternatively, one can say that the aether is a ‘subtle elastic fluid permeating space’, a medium so subtle that it can adapt to ensure that the finite speed of light as measured in the presence of matter takes its reference on a frame determined by the matter present. The third perspective is to say that the aether is ‘that which fills space devoid of matter’, ‘that’ being a sea of energy, the deployment and reorganization of which accounts for the creation of matter and then go on to supplement that with the second definition.

    The history which led to the conflict between the Chambers 1998 dictionary definition of ‘aether’ as a ‘former belief’ and the 1934 Oxford dictionary definition as a ‘subtle elastic fluid’ is that of Einstein’s theory in assuming, quite falsely, that, if the aether exists it defines the light propagation frame as an absolute single frame of reference. Such history has meant that scientists have turned their thoughts away from the study of the properties of aether proper, a study which nevertheless can lead us to the prospect of harnessing its energy and understanding its true regulating effect on light propagation, particularly the scaled frequency loss implicit in the Hubble constant, which has been misinterpreted as an orderly progressive expansion of the universe in a sea of nothingness.

    If you really wish to follow the path of the heretic then read on. You will learn all about the aether and see that I must be right in making these statements.

    DOES THE AETHER HAVE A TEMPERATURE?

    At this point you may wonder how I can jump from Maxwell’s demon and the practical world of thermodynamics and move into the depths of the hidden underworld I have chosen to call the ‘aether’. Well, Maxwell himself did that when he addressed the mysteries of that Second Law of Thermodynamics and evolved a theory for the manner in which the aether transports electromagnetic waves.

    However, I will go directly to the question I have just posed. Does the aether have a temperature? Well, if you are a conformist and believe Einstein then you must say that, since the aether does not exist in any tangible form, and has been replaced by the mathematics of space-time, it cannot have a temperature any more than a mathematical equation can have a temperature.

    Given that verdict, suppose I now say that I accept that energy has mass and that mass can gravitate and, furthermore, that there is a sea of energy filling space, then you will conclude that if I am right the aether is subject to gravitational forces. You may conclude that I have to be wrong as I have gone far beyond the notion that the aether has a temperature. Indeed, what value could that temperature be?

    I ask now if you have heard of the ‘cosmic background temperature’, a quantity measured in the locality of Earth as being 2.7 K? Orthodox scientists cannot explain that other than by declaring it to be the heat residue of the Big Bang, implying that it is the temperature of whatever residue of matter there is out there in so-called empty space.

    I say that that temperature is the temperature of the aether. It is determined by the gravitational properties of the aether and it is a temperature which the aether shares with matter dispersed in space.

    Now I do not want here to get involved in too much physics, because I shall cover the details of this subject in the specialist PHYSICS section of these web pages. So, for the immediate purpose I will just say that, though the aether has a mass density, that density is kept uniform, but we can still say that there is what is called a ‘gravitational potential’ acting between aether and material bodies such as the sun. This potential implies that energy has been released, as energy of motion, typically heat. The reason is that gravitational potential is negative as it implies release of energy by the coming together of two masses.

    Suppose I say that the aether owes its gravitational mass to the presence of a system of aether particles each having a specific mass, then the gravitational potential as between the sun and one such particle will be a measure of the heat shed to the particle and retained by the particle, inasmuch as the aether itself does not radiate energy from itself. It follows that I can then be guided by the way heat energy is shared by particles in a gas or in solid matter. There is a constant in physics known as Boltzmann’s constant. It connects the particle’s heat energy and temperature and so, if say that the energy shed by the gravitational potential of the aether is retained by it as heat, using that 2.7 K temperature we measure as the cosmic background temperature, I can work out the mass of each such aether particle.

    I have done such calculations. Indeed, I derived the mass of the aether particle in the 1950s and reported it in a book I published in 1960. The book, or rather booklet as it was only 48 printed pages, was entitled The Theory of Gravitation. It was some 30 years later that I did those aether temperature calculations using the theoretical aether particle mass I had derived in that 1960 publication and I obtained a temperature that did, indeed, confirm the value measured as the temperature of the cosmic background. See [1993d]. There was no Big Bang argument in my theory!

    CONCERNING MAXWELL’S THEORY

    I must now just mention one feature of the aether, one overlooked by Clerk Maxwell and all those who did pursue their 19th century models of aether. The aether conveys electromagnetic waves. Those waves have a lateral oscillation, meaning that they wriggle sideways in their forward progress as does a snake. To sustain such waves the aether had to behave as if it were a solid and yet we move through it as if it were a fluid devoid of mass. The 1934 dictionary said it was ‘a subtle elastic fluid’. That was before the 1998 dictionary got around to saying it was nothing other than something ‘formerly believed to fill all space’. Well, how can the aether be fluid and solid at the same time and sustain the passage those lateral electromagnetic oscillations?

    The answer is that it has the form of a fluid crystal and, further, that those lateral waves need something other than the structure of the fluid crystal to provide a lateral dynamic balance. In a fluid crystal the local presence of electric fields can cause the fluid to develop its crystal form in the locality of those fields. A material system such as body Earth which comprises, at its ultra microscopic atomic level, electric charges and their attendant fields can move through the aetherial fluid crystal and carry a kind of aether crystal with it, whilst surrounding aether has its own separate crystal form. The structure can dissolve at the foward boundaries, dispersing into the background fluid, only to reappear as new crystal structures forms behind the aether structure that is ‘dragged’ along by body Earth.

    Why, one may well wonder, has the fluid crystal not been adopted by aether theorists as their model for the aether? Am I really alone in seeing this as the answer? What is wrong with physics if it cannot see the good sense of at least examining the possibilities opened up by the knowledge that there are liquid crystal displays in our pocket calculators. If you read the 19th century history of ideas concerning the aether, as being something impossible, both a fluid and a solid, and you have such a calculator before you, then you have under your control something that can exhibit the properties of both a liquid or a solid. You cannot then say there is no aether because there is a unresolved conflict as between its liquid and solid properties. You might as well say that the liquid crystal display of your calculator is an illusion, rather than a technological reality.

    Just understand that the aether has properties akin to those of a fluid crystal! Or are you so sure that Einstein is right in turning away from the aether notion, that you accept his viewpoint, rather than respecting the memory of so many great 19th century physicists by reviewing their efforts constructively and taken account of today’s knowledge of the fluid crystal?

    Let us get back to the question of that lateral vibration of propagating electromagnetic waves. Believe it or not, there is a kind of unseen ‘snake’ wriggling along side-by-side with the wave we eventually sense. It is an electrical component of the aether, a dual displacement feature, and it not only keeps the aether in balance dynamically, but it preserves the continuity of the wave oscillations when minor impediments are encountered in its transit through space. Those impediments, however, take their toll on energy and, as my theoretical analysis shows, the effect is that the wave energy can be depleted in transit and with that the frequency. This accounts for what cosmologists call the redshift and interpret as the mutual recession of all stars in the universe, the phenomenon they say is the expansion of the universe.

    I can derive from this argument and pure theory based on detailed analysis of aether structure, the observed value of what is termed the Hubble constant and that is why I am certain about what I have just said. It is all reported elsewhere in these Web pages and in my scientific papers of public record. See, for example, [1984e]

    At this point, however, since these are just words, I think I should share with you a picture of what the aether looks like, if you really could see it. My insight into that and its portrayal will emerge when you press the link to the ‘NEXT PAGE’. I certainly do not regard the aether as ‘nothingness’ and my task ahead is to educate you, the reader, on the aether topic, whilst applying my heresy also to more important topics, such as how we can extract energy from that aether as well as from new kinds of heat engine that tap ambient source of low grade heat. First, however, I must try to guide you along the channels of thought that led me to my aether belief. Foremost in this quest is the need to understand something your textbooks cannot begin to address, which is how energy fed into a solenoid, a wound coil of wire, can store energy in that ‘nothingness’ I call aether and then allow us to recover that energy when we switch the current off. Yes, your physics textbooks will tell you about Faraday’s discovery of induction and about magnetic fields and lines of force, but though they tell you how to calculate the energy stored in unit volume of space, they will not tell you how a magnetic field actually stores that energy and holds it ready for our recovery. To be sure, no textbook can ever explain that without coming to terms with the reality of the aether.


    Harold Aspden
    September 10, 1998



  • GALLIO OR THE TYRANNY OF SCIENCE

    DISCOURSE NO. 3

    GALLIO OR THE TYRANNY OF SCIENCE

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998


    The above is the title of a 1927 paper by J.W.N. Sullivan in the style of the one quoted in Discourse No. 2 which J.B.S. Haldane read to the heretics in Cambridge, England, having the same publisher, Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner and Co. Ltd.


    INTRODUCTION

    The introduction of Einstein’s relativistic notions and quantum mechanics into the theoretical physics of the early 20th century must have aroused concerns amongst those of the academic community who could see science claiming more ground in the intellectual field. As more heresy crept into science it claimed a following and the boundary between the conformist and the heretic moved forward, but there were those who saw tyranny in what was so evidently too rapid an advance.

    Now, whereas Haldane had suggested that the something akin to fourth and fifth dimensions might show themselves in ethics, just as the fourth space dimension had intruded into physics, so there were those who saw science as going beyond its rightful place in the spectrum of knowledge.

    On p. 69 of the Sullivan paper one reads:

    “Many people, including some scientific men, take science too seriously. They think that science gives a far more comprehensive picture of reality than it really does. There have been philosophers who have gone so far as to suppose that those factors of experience that science does not find it necessary to talk about do not really exist. ….. The scientific concepts have by no means proved themselves adequate to account for the whole of experience. Nearly everything of real importance to man lies outside science. The fact is that science was undertaken as an intellectual adventure: it was an attempt to find out how far nature could be described in mathematical terms. Certain primary conceptions – time, space, mass, force and so on – all of which can be defined mathematically, were adopted, and it became a highly absorbing game to find out how much of what goes on around us could be described, mathematically, in terms of these conceptions. The success of this effort has been so astonishing that some scientific men have forgotten to be astonished. They have come to take it for granted that a complete mathematical description of the world should be possible. This assumption is not a rational one: it is a pure act of faith. The great founders of the scheme made no such mistake: they were quite aware of the precarious nature of their enterprise. Thus, Newton, the greatest and most successful of them all, says that, if they find the mathematical method does not work, they must try a different method. The mathematical method, which is the very essence of modern science, has, however, worked splendidly.”

    Now I see in these words an argument which casts suspicion on the way science, or rather theoretical physics, was developing in the early decades of the 20th century. Surely no one can imagine that mathematics as a scientific tool can do more than help to decode the pattern and structured form of what constitutes the universal fabric of our existence, if, that is, there is an underlying web having such form.

    My own suspicions concerning quantum mechanics and Einstein’s vision of space do not concern the tools used to unpick what is woven into that web, but rather the ‘principles’ enunciated by the father figures in the world of science. I refer to the Principle of Uncertainty and the Principle of Relativity, neither of which has a causal physical explanation in orthodox scientific teaching. They are applied by using the tool of mathematics, just as a paintbrush is a tool used to paint a picture on a canvas. However, in science, we see the picture first and we never see the canvas. Pre-20th century science regarded the aether as the invisible canvas that gave structural support to the picture we see as the universe. Those principles I have just mentioned sought to interpret the art work of that picture, but mathematics, as such, is no substitute for that paintbrush and that canvas. Mathematics merely allows us to scan the picture in an effort to form algorithms in search of the truth as to how the painter wielded that paintbrush, but we must never forget that underlying it all there has to be that canvas, the aether. The teachings of quantum mechanics and relativity do not recognize the need for that aether, not to mention the paintbrush or the painter!

    So, reverting to the title of this discourse, what is meant by ‘Gallio’? It has a dictionary definition:

    Used in conjunction with the expression ‘or The Tyranny of Science’, I have a little difficulty in thinking it is tyrannical for a scientist to refuse to meddle outside his province. In my experience it is fairly standard for specialists in matters scientific to be very wary about giving opinions on something outside their specific scientific discipline. Evenso, that does not preclude scientists in general and especially those who teach physics, from smiling and duly ridiculing those who dare to imply the possibility of what might seem to be a claim to have devised a perpetual motion machine. Equally, physicists in general insist that one must not challenge the Second Law of Thermodynamics, but in our quest to learn more about heresy we shall now move on to that topic.

    MATHEMATICS, INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND MAXWELL’S DEMON

    In the above quotation from Sullivan’s 1927 writings it was implied that mathematics had over-reached itself as scientists sought to reduce everything to mathematical formulations. 1927 happens to be the year in which I was born and so it might seem there remained little scope for me to add much to the scientific fiasco. However, going back to earlier times:

    “A man born about 1800, wanting a serious view of the whole of science, could no longer be a dilettante. The activities of science had become multifarious and specialized, its literature voluminous. That literature, too, was more difficult as well as more copious. In particular, much of it demanded a deep grasp of mathematics.”

    This is a quotation from page 149 of ‘Science since 1900’ published in London by ‘His Majesty’s Stationery Office’ in 1939. Its author was H.T. Pledge of the Science Museum, a branch of the Ministry of Education in U.K.

    So here an expert in science history was telling us that in 1800 the onward march of science required a deep grasp of mathematics, whereas, by 1927, there was a feeling in some sectors of the community that mathematics had claimed too much ground in that scientific arena.

    It is no wonder that science today lacks a measure of coherence owing to its extreme diversity and the specialization involved. Too many scientific papers exist on university library shelves, the vast majority written only to bolster the qualifications of those involved in the contest for advancement in academia and adding nothing of value to the store of knowledge.

    Physical science progressed on three fronts as it drove us forward through the years of the industrial revolution. From a technological base that offered little more that the magnetic compass and time keeping instruments, Newton’s mechanics was to lead us into a mechanical age, supplemented by the progress of the science of electricity and the science of thermodynamics. The age of steam and then on into the era of electrical power generation took us to the time when mathematics had served us well enough, but mankind should not now be seduced by the virtual realities of an age of mathematics. We must draw the line and take stock.

    One of the worst case examples of mathematical notions interfering with technological prospects is the time waster of imputing a connection between information technology, entropy and Maxwell’s Demon, an issue bearing upon the validity of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

    The announcement of the birth of Maxwell’s Demon dates from 1871. Its conception was an act of heresy aimed at contravening the Second Law of Thermodynamics. That law was an edict of mankind, based on the rather obvious assertion that one must do work to get heat energy to flow up a temperature gradient from a cold to a hot zone. Everyone knows that to lift something or climb up a gradient one must do some work, but we have not seen it necessary to declare that as a specific law of gravity. Heresy creeps in when it is suggested that what we all know on these matters can be put in doubt.

    I can suggest the prospect of devising experiments to demonstrate antigravity by the expedient of declaring that the gravitational force acting on an element of mass is really a force acting on something normally partnered with that mass, and then suggesting how that partnership can be broken.

    Maxwell did much the same for the thermodynamic situation. He pointed out that the heat energy in a gas is shared by fast moving and slow moving molecules. Together they formed a partnership as they exchange energy in collisions and endow the gas with a mean temperature. That temperature governs the performance of a heat engine running on that gas by taking energy from all its molecules and exhausting it at a lower temperature. Maxwell (1867), in a letter to Peter Guthrie Tait, suggested that the gas should be enclosed in a housing having two compartments A and B separated by an aperture. The wall between A and B contains an aperture which may be opened and closed by a frictionless slide. He discussed the situation if someone (later nicknamed ‘Maxwell’s intelligent demon’ by William Thomson) sat besides that aperture and operated the slide to allow only fast moving gas molecules to go from B to A and allow only slow moving gas molecules to go from A to B, keeping the slide shut for all other molecules.

    “Then the number of molecules in A and B are the same as at first, but the energy in A has increased and that in B diminished, that is, the hot system has got hotter and the cold system colder and yet no work has been done, only the intelligence of a very observant well-fingered being has been employed.”

    Now here was a statement by the renowned Clerk Maxwell that told us how we might go about discovering a method of taking heat at ambient temperature and, consistent with the Principle of Conservation of Energy, converting it into hot and cold forms, a resource which we well know allows us to do useful work. If we, with the necessary heat engine, could then sit in that enclosure and harness that temperature differential we could spend that energy resource usefully and, as is normal, let the spent energy, then degrade back into heat at lower temperature as it merges into the gas in the enclosure. Energy has been conserved but useful work has been done by the intelligent manipulation of that frictionless slide, an act involving no effort.

    Curiously, instead of accepting that this is possible in theory but rather impractical, scientists made it an academic exercise to argue their way out of their dilemma of trying to preserve their so-called ‘Second Law of Thermodynamics’. Incidentally, the so-called ‘First Law of Thermodynamics’ is nothing other than the Principle of Conservation of Energy dressed in thermal underwear.

    So how does all this relate to information technology? Well, maybe it stemmed from that word ‘intelligence’ in the above quotation of Maxwell’s words. Somehow those looking for loopholes by which to leave Maxwell’s demon unemployed, decided that work had to be expended in making decisions and they started to say that intelligence and information, as such, involves entropy. The word ‘entropy’ is itself a peculiar concept. It is a word which assigns a kind of quality to an amount of heat. If Q is the energy signified by that word ‘heat’, and the prevailing temperature condition of that heat is T, then Q/T is its entropy. This expression is not of much use as it only gives basis for scientists to say that the Second Law of Thermodynamics requires that entropy always increases. In other words, heat degrades by cooling down. As T decreases, so Q/T increases. On from there we find that scientists wonder if computers have entropy related to the information they store. In short, the subject seems to have gone rampant with wild ideas.

    Leo Szilard in a paper published in German in Zeitschrift fur Physik, v. 53, pp. 840-856 (1929) wrote:

    “A perpetual motion machine is possible if – according to the general method of physics – we view the experimenting man as a sort of deus ex machina, one who is continuously and exactly informed of the existing state of nature and who is able to start or interrupt the macroscopic course of nature at any moment without expenditure of work.”

    He then went on to say that the nervous system of the intelligent being that might serve as Maxwell’s demon would expend energy, eventually concluding that:

    “We have examined the biological phenomena of a nonliving device and have seen that it generates exactly that quantity of entropy which is required by thermodynamics.”

    All this was, of course, well before the age of the modern computer, but once computers appeared on the general scene, thoughts concerning the Maxwell demon then turned to the scope for discharging the demon function by computer.

    Numerous scientific papers have been written on the subject, many reproduced in the book by Harvey S Leff and Andrew F Rex: ‘Maxwell’s Demon: Entropy, Information, Computing’, published in 1990 by Adam Hilger (the publishing house operated by the Institute of Physics in U.K.).

    That book makes several references to Rolf Landauer of IBM who, as one reads from a report in New Scientist dated 14 July, 1990, showed in 1988 that, although a Szilard engine gains energy, this is cancelled out because the demon loses an equivalent amount of energy in its decision making process. However, the article in New Scientist drew attention to the findings of Carlton Caves of the University of Southern California, Los Angeles, who ‘believes that Maxwell’s demon can, in certain circumstances, do the impossible: transfer energy from a cool body to a warmer one.’ Caves (‘Physical Review Letters, vol. 64, p. 2111) took Landauer’s argument a step further by describing how a group of 10 Szilard engines could be operated in tandem by the demon, but with information coded to require less than 10 times that needed to control the single engine.

    Now is not all this an incredible scenario? More than 100 years after Maxwell’s death we are still arguing whether that Second Law of Thermodynamics is or is not valid and resorting to some very weird reasoning in that process.

    INTRODUCING A NEW DEMON

    By now you will understand that I have sympathy with Maxwell’s proposition and believe that, with a little ingenuity, we can find a way of doing the task assigned to Maxwell’s demon.

    Before I outline the secret of how that may be accomplished, I will just present one other quotation which helps to put our task in perspective. We are tracking heresy in search of a new source of energy. We attract ridicule from our scientific peers who wish to conform. We make no sense to the non-scientist and so our venture is a lonely one.

    I take the quotation from that book referenced above, which on page 37 introduced a chapter authored by Edward D. Daub and entitled: ‘Maxwell’s Demon’:

    “In his presentation of the ‘two cultures’ issue, C.P. Snow relates that he occasionally became so provoked at literary colleagues who scorned the restricted reading habits of scientists that he would challenge them to explain the second law of thermodynamics. The response was invariably a cold negative silence.”

    Daub then noted:

    “The test was too hard. Even a scientist would be hard-pressed to explain Carnot engines and refrigerators, reversibility and irreversibility, energy dissipation and entropy increase, Gibbs free energy and the Gibbs rule of phase, all in the span of a cocktail party.”

    My own problems of that kind have arisen when, in a social situation, the fact that I had written a book challenging Einstein’s theory had come to light. ‘So you do not believe that E=Mc2?’ was the question I faced, obviously posed by someone with very little knowledge of the detail of Einstein’s theory, because no expert on that subject would open such a discussion, especially in that way. My heresy on that subject amounts to saying that I can derive that formula merely by arguing that all matter comprises electric particles and all electric particles exhibit inertia in just the amount needed to conserve the energy stored by their electric charge. In short, inertia and so E=Mc2 is a manifestation of the Principle of Conservation of Energy and owes nothing to Einstein’s philosophy. I explain all that in detail in the physics pages of this web site.

    The C. P. Snow book referenced above was published in 1961 and is entitled ‘The Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution’, the quotation being from pp. 15-16. I recall being interviewed by C.P. Snow in his capacity as a Director of English Electric Co. Ltd, that being early in the 1950s when I was employed by that company. I may now wonder how I would have answered if he had asked me to explain the Second Law of Thermodynamics. I trust I would have survived the test. Thermodynamics had been one of the examination papers of my final examination for an honours degree at university. However, then I was a conformist and now I am a heretic!

    So, to conclude this Discourse No. 3, I will introduce my own demon. Instead of using a normal gas as the heat medium in the enclosure with its separating wall and aperture, I will assume I have a plasma, meaning gas molecules that are ionized. They are electric particles, half bearing positive charge and half bearing negative charge, all jostled around in a gaseous system and having therefore a spread of kinetic energy as applies to Maxwell’s case.

    Instead of that wall with its single aperture, I will introduce two apertures, one on each opposite side of the bounding housing, as shown in Fig. 1. Instead of the intelligent demon I will use a non-intelligent magnet to set up a magnetic field in a direction mutually orthogonal with a line drawn between those two apertures and the longitudinal axis of the housing.

    Fig. 1

    Now, considering first the ions which move from left to right, those that are positively charged will be deflected laterally to aperture A upon passage though the magnetized region, whereas those that are negatively charged will be deflected to aperture B. In contrast, for ions moving from right to left, it will be the negative ions which find their way into aperture A, whilst the positive ions will be guided into aperture B by that magnet.

    So, you can say, rightly, that there is no separation of the electric charge able to promote an electric current flow which taps energy from the heat of the gas in that housing. You may realize that we could block the gas flow through the apertures by positioning electrodes which take off the electricity into a load L without allowing passage of gas, leaving the neutralized molecules to become reionized by their onward collisions. However, in this case the actions have cancelled. This would not be the case if all the flow were one way, but then we would have to do work to keep the ionized gas moving in that direction.

    That would lead us into MHD technology, magnetohydrodynamics, the technology that might have taken hold in the post-1960 era if nuclear power had not come along. Evenso, suppose, for example, that we can somehow ensure that more faster-moving positively charged ions travel one way than travel in the reverse direction, then may not we then have scope for devising a system serving Maxwell’s purpose?

    Indeed, suppose we put those apertures adjacent one end of that housing shown in Fig. 1. Electrodes extracting charge will leave the molecules neutralized and they will not immediately become reionized, so they will migrate as neutral molecules for some distance as they move towards the other end of the housing. In theory this means that we have electricity output tapping energy from heat in the housing but no escape of the gas involved.

    Has anyone experimented on such a basis? Surely the idea would be thrown out because it implies heating a gas to a temperature high enough to develop ionization and keeping the gas trapped as that temperature is sustained. If the device did produce electricity it would be at the expense of heat input. So where is the gain and how does this relate to Maxwell’s demon? Well, the answer to this is that, if one can merely top up the heat energy in a gas to keep it at a steady temperature as electricity is bled off then we have virtually a 100% energy conversion of heat to electricity. Furthermore, without input of heat as indicated, we have here a system which allows a heat sink not shedding heat energy to a heat sink at a lower temperature to convert heat directly into electricity and that implies that, if only that ionization could occur at ambient temperature, we could generate electrical power by cooling our atmosphere. That would turn global warming to our advantage whilst proving as spin-off the accompanying air cooling needed by our air conditioning systems.

    That is the reverse of using electricity in an electric fire, 100% conversion from one energy form to another, all consistent with the Principle of Conservation of Energy. However, there is no gain in entropy here. There is no exhaust gas at a lower temperature which carries off energy as waste and has that high measure of entropy.

    The Maxwell demon has been replaced by a magnet, and the magnet can ‘think’ in that it can act selectively in diverting electrically charged gas molecules but not electrically neutral gas molecules. If the charged molecules are those that move faster and so engage in more energetic collisions, then that selection is analogous to the role played by the demon. If the positively charged molecules are heavier than the negatively charged molecules the latter will have the higher speed, another feature which helps in that selection. So may I ask, why is it that so much has been written about Maxwell’s demon in connection with neutral gas and so little concerning the ionized gas where magnetic fields are used to serve the demon role?

    Hot fusion research which tries to contain ionized gas by use of magnetic fields should have spin-off bearing upon this Maxwell demon topic. Where is that spin-off? All I have seen is the discovery that energy transfers anomalously from electrons to heavy ions, something I suspect that could be exploited in harnessing the principles of the Maxwell demon.

    However, such heresy opens the path to technologies better than those implied by the Maxwell demon, the latter conserving energy but merely separating it into low entropy and high entropy forms to set up a temperature difference. It is so much better if we can convert heat energy directly into electricity with that near-to-100% conversion rate. The reason is that we can pump heat from the abundant form at ambient temperature and raise it to a higher temperature by expending energy at a rate that is only a fraction of that pumped into the higher temperature zone. If then we can generate electricity to operate that heat pump with close to 100% conversion efficiency, there can be a large surplus of electrical output, all drawn from the ambient temperature energy of our environment.

    In these web pages I still have more to say about the Maxwell demon as we bring our heresy on this subject into the lower temperature realm which applies to Maxwell’s demon, rather than having to contemplate the use of hot ionized gas.

    The research I shall describe in the TECHNOLOGY section of these web pages will include a room temperature implementation of the principles suggested above by reference to Fig. 1. The ionized gas molecules moving inside a housing will be replaced by the motion of electrons driven by heat through a ferromagnetic conductor, the intrinsic magnetism of which provides the magnetic field.

    Indeed, I was surprised to find that my conversion from a conformist to a heretic led me to do a rethink on what my Ph.D. thesis was all about, written when I was a ‘conformist’ but now, in retrospect, looked at, some 30 years on, from the stance of a ‘heretic’. That story will unfold in these Web pages, as interested readers may see by inspecting the bibliographic reference [1956b]

    In developing this general overview of Energy Science by delving into heresy, I will next address the question of ‘Aether’. Does it exist or not? If so, what is its role? Why do we need it? Some may think we have mathematical formulae which satisfy the relevant facts and that they are all we need. Well, that is the conformist opinion, but the aether still exists and I intend to show that it does not conform with the orthodox mathematical scheme. It will bring us in the Discourse of the next page to another and more important facet of Clerk Maxwell’s contributions to science.


    Harold Aspden
    September 8, 1998



  • DAEDALUS OR SCIENCE AND THE FUTURE

    DISCOURSE NO. 2

    DAEDALUS OR SCIENCE AND THE FUTURE

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998


    The above is the title of a paper read to the heretics in Cambridge, England on February 4th, 1923 by J.B.S. Haldane.


    INTRODUCTION

    In advancing on the theme of scientific heresy in this year 1998, it seems appropriate to begin by jumping back some 75 years and quoting three excerpts from Haldane’s paper as presented to what I presume was a meeting of a student body – the Society of Heretics.

    When I discovered this paper, I had to refer to my dictionary, a 1934 edition of the Concise Oxford Dictionary, to see what ‘Daedalus’ meant:

    Is not that a wonderful combination of words – skilful, inventive, mazy, manifold, complex, mysterious, intricate, labyrinthine?

    Haldane chose to wrap up his insight into the science of the future in that title word ‘Daedalus’ and, indeed, in the event, the picture we have of physical science today is just what is implied by that dictionary definition. Haldane, no doubt, had in mind the influence which Einstein’s theory was to have on the academics working in theoretical physics and its associated mathematics.

    So, again, I ask you to decide on the question of ‘heresy’. Was Haldane preaching heresy when he delivered that paper? Make your judgment in the usual way, the way of so many who have little patience with the ideas of others, that is by cursory inspection of but a few lines of the paper in question, as quoted from its page 17, in the fourth impression (1924) as published by Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner and Co. Ltd, London:

    “The Condorcets, Benthams, and Marxs of the future … They will recognize that perhaps in ethics as in physics, there are, so to speak, fourth and fifth dimensions that show themselves by effects which, like the perturbations of the planet Mercury, are hard to detect even in one generation, but yet perhaps in the course of ages are quite as important as the three-dimensional phenomena.”

    So here we see the influence of Einstein’s philosophy, by then (1923) deemed to be an accepted feature in the fabric of physics, being declared as a potential intruding influence in the ‘ethos’ of academia. It is but a short step in the dictionary to progress forward from the word ‘ether’ to the word ‘ethic’ and on to the word ‘ethos’ and it seems that, just as Einstein tried to move academic thought on from the belief in the existence of the ether, so Haldane would have that same effort trespass into ethics and, as I see it, that can lead to upset of the ethos of things in general.

    I would say that Haldane’s perception of the importance of Einstein philosophy was heresy best not heeded, but, again, you, the reader, must judge for yourself and, if interested, move forward in your own way to see if you can find a pathway to the ultimate truth.

    DAEDALUS AND FUTURE ENERGY TECHNOLOGY

    As one reads on through Haldane’s paper one comes to a more practical vision of things to come, as judged from that 1923 perspective. Here Haldane had sufficient insight to realise that our energy demands were at such a rate that they could not be sustained by natural replenishment. The time would come when our oil wells and coal fields would become barren.

    Now, surprisingly, at this point Haldane did not have the vision to persist with the Einstein indoctrination, as well he may, given the E = Mc2 facet of Einstein’s theory. Instead, he drew attention to the prospective role of, believe it or not, the windmill.

    Long before we came to use electrical fans as part of an air-conditioning system, indeed long before electric motors were invented, the power of the windmill was serving much the same purpose. A drawing in the British Museum illustrates ‘Hales’s Ventilator for Newgate’ and it bears in the illustration the title: ‘The Windmill fixed on Newgate to work the Ventilators, erected there April 17, 1752’. Newgate was the name of a prison in London, England.

    On page 24 of Haldane’s paper we read:

    “Personally, I think that four hundred years hence the power question in England may be resolved somewhat as follows: The country will be covered by rows of metallic windmills working electric motors which in their turn supply current at a very high voltage to great electric mains. At suitable distances, there will be great power stations where, during windy weather, huge reservoirs of liquified gases will enable wind energy to be stored, so that it can be expended for industry, transportation, heating and lighting, as desired …… no smoke or ash will be produced.”

    That 1923 perspective may well prove to be true but the future will be somewhat bleak if we in England have to rely on wind power for our electricity supply. Haldane was certainly not expressing heresy in that prophecy! I trust he will be proved wrong and that invention and discovery in true Daedalus style will come to our rescue.

    Note here that conservation of resources, which is the theme of many proponents who try to influence the way things are in the energy world, will not solve the problems ahead. At best it will defer the problems and stave off the unpleasantness of an over-polluted environment.

    DAEDALUS AND THE IMMINENT THAT NEVER HAPPENED

    My next and final quotation from Haldane’s 1923 paper is, when seen in retrospect, as entertaining as it is of serious concern. It was evident in 1923 that agriculture in England could not sustain the food demands of its population.

    On page 57 of his paper Haldane forecasted what he termed ‘an imaginary essay that might be written by a student of science history in the future’:

    ” … it was not until 1940 that Selkovki invented the purple alga porphyrococcus fixator which was to have so great an effect on the world’s history …. Porphyrococcus is an enormously efficient nitrogen-fixer and will grow in almost any climate where there are water and traces of potash and phosphates in the soil, obtaining its nitrogen from the air …. the enormous fall in food prices and the ruin of purely agricultural states was, of course, one of the chief causes of the disastrous events of 1943 and 1944. The food glut was also greatly accentuated when in 1942 the Q strain of Porphyrococcus escaped into the sea and multiplied with enormous rapidity. Indeed for two months the surface of the tropical Atlantic set to jelly, with disastrous results to the weather of Europe. When certain of the plankton organisms developed ferments capable of digesting it the increase of the fish population of the seas was so great as to make fish the universal food that it is now, and to render even England self-supporting in respect of food.”

    One can but think that there would be many young students amongst Haldane’s audience at Cambridge in that year 1923 when he predicted this 1940-1944 scenario who would not survive the disastrous events of what became the World War II years. Surely the world faces enough problems, problems which only scientific ingenuity can overcome, without political greed and warring factions adding to the miseries of life. Evenso, greed, stubborness and intolerance of reasonable heresy in the scientific community can also have their consequences and deprive the future world of so much that it justly deserves.

    There are some basic truths in science still to be discovered and there is no time to waste. In my opinion progress will be all the faster, the sooner we revert to the belief that we inhabit three-dimensional space and avoid what amounts to the drug-like addiction to notions of existence in multi-dimensional space.

    If that is heresy, then please join me in my heretical beliefs.


    Harold Aspden
    September 2, 1998



  • SCIENTIFIC HERESY

    DISCOURSE NO. 1

    SCIENTIFIC HERESY

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998


    Concerning science, are you an ignoramus, a conformist or a heretic?


    INTRODUCTION

    These are progressive stages in one’s scientific education, because to preach heresy and challenge conformist doctrines you need first to understand those doctrines, understanding which comes only from orthodox teachings at a time when you must accept what you are taught, whereas you are still an ignoramus if you lack the insights afforded by such teaching.

    What follows is a discourse for those who aspire to advance into the territory of scientific heresy. This involves research which does not build on the well-explored ground of the conformist, but has its foundations seated in the fertile soil of the unknown. We must explore the unknown if we are to discover the solutions to the many mysteries of science. However, once you tread off the straight and narrow path of the conformist and see scope for breaking the rule of law which prevails in orthodox scientific doctrine, then you are treading the path of the heretic. It can lead you into the desert, where you can be deceived by the occasional mirage, but there are coded messages in the sand and they are your guide to the ultimate truth.

    I can say with pride that I am a heretic. I could see one of those coded messages from a safe distance while still on conformist terra firma. So I wandered off track to follow that lead. It led me initially through a desert region and then on to a jungle, a new but fruitful jungle, something which grew amongst the debris left behind by those who deserted what one may describe as ‘three-space’ to indulge in flights of fancy in their imagined world of ‘four-space’. They carried with them those willing to assume the new orthodox relativistic faith. It is a faith in which one moves with time, and the faster one travels, the younger one becomes.

    Not surprisingly, Einstein’s theory gave impetus to the notion of space travel, but though that notion has captured the minds of many would-be scientists, its fascination is not linked to reality, and the subject lacks the fascination of heretical pathways which can lead one to the real truths of Nature, once those coded messages have been deciphered.

    TEST YOUR JUDGMENT

    Before our discourse embarks on that journey into heresy, I ask you to test your judgment by deciding whether, in your opinion, the following quotations are the words of a ‘conformist’ or a ‘heretic’:

    “While the gravimetric system is likely to be the first field-dependent propulsion system developed, the field resonance effect will bring stellar and galactic travel out of the realm of science fiction. The field resonance system artificially generates an energy pattern which precisely matches or resonates with a virtual pattern associated with a distant space-time point. ….. At the same time, through the virtual many-dimensional structure of space-time, a very strong attraction with the virtual pattern of a distant space-time point will exist. …. However, the result, a space-time ‘jump’, already appears to be supported by astrophysical research. Several analogies can be used to clarify the effect. It can be described as the temporary formation of an Einstein-Rosen bridge, a tunnel through space-time which connects two different regions in space-time in a way similar to that which has been proposed for a black/white hole (quasar) connection. The resonance effect can be considered to be analogous to the nuclear particle tunneling phenomena. Following this analogy, the spacecraft’s wave characteristics are increased dramatically by the artificially generated energy pattern, allowing it to tunnel through the space-time barrier without having the energy normally required to traverse the space between the two space-time points. ….. The travel times of such trips are expected to be short (seconds to weeks) …. Time does not have an independent existence in the General Theory of Relativity. …. Since the gravitational forces acting on the propulsion system can be quickly altered to achieve the desired motion, the spacecraft/aircraft experiences can be nearly instantaneously reoriented at a 90o angle, resulting in smooth continuous motion as far as the occupants are concerned. …. In order to explore a star system midway from the center of the Andromeda galaxy, several intermediate space-time jumps would likely be required for safety purposes.”

    Well, what is your verdict? Are these the words of a conformist or a heretic? Einstein’s theory is an accepted doctrine in conformist physics as taught in academic institutions. So you may tend to see the author of those words as a conformist. On the other hand one can suspect that some wishful thinking has been exercised and see the author’s words as verging on heresy. Before you answer, now take note that I have quoted from a paper AIAA-80-1233 delivered at the AIAA/SAE/ASME 16th Joint Propulsion Conference, held June 30-July 2, 1980 in Hartford, Connecticut, USA. Its title: ‘Prospects for a Breakthrough in Field Dependent Propulsion’. Its author: A.C. Holt of the NASA Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center.

    So, does that help? Conformist or heretic? Before you answer, now take note that the ‘thrust’ of the paper was not wholly concerned with propulsion of spacecraft, but an assertion of what might be possible given the funding necessary to carry this project forward at high speed. A concluding comment was:

    “If the field physics laboratory can be completed by the end of 1982 or early 1983, extensive confirmation of a breakthrough and the quantification of associated field and space-time relationships should be achievable within 3 years (1986).”

    So, there you are! I am writing this in 1998 and, although I am a scientific heretic, I have not strayed from the pathway of knowledge that tells me, intuitively, that travel through the wormholes of multi-dimensional space-time is anything other than science fiction. You must judge for yourself whether or not that NASA researcher can be classed as a heretic. Whatever you decide, do read on in these web pages to learn how heresy can be of service to mankind, not so much in promising future interstellar travel but in promising us the means to tap into the space medium to extract an abundant non-polluting energy resource.


    Harold Aspden
    September 1, 1998