Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Papers & Publications

Peer-reviewed papers and publications by Harold Aspden

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • 1958a

    1958a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Proceedings of I.E.E., C, p. 359 (1958).

    ‘Discussion on Electromagnetic Energy Transfer’

    Commentary: This was the author’s first published utterance on the subject of E = Mc2 and its derivation as a consequence of the non-radiation of energy by an accelerated electron.

    It was many years later when the author eventually read a book by Cornelius Lanczos published in 1974. The title of this book is ‘The Einstein Decade (1905-1915)’ and on page 96 one reads, under the heading E = Mc2:

    “In 1906 Einstein proved that radiating energy must have a mass value of the magnitude E/c2, otherwise the centre of mass of a body, on which no external forces are acting, could come into motion all by itself.”

    This does, indeed, show the parlous state of physics, when we read that Einstein commands respect for saying that it needs a certain amount of energy radiation, the amount prescribed by his E = Mc2 formula to stop an electron from accelerating when no external forces are applied.

    This author will no doubt be deemed to be somewhat naive for thinking in a Newtonian sense that an action must have a cause and that an electron will not accelerate unless a suitable field acting on the electron charge is present. All the author then asks the reader to accept is that one just cannot rely on the derivation of the Larmor radiation formula:

    dW/dt = 2e2f2/3c2

    based only on the mathematical proposition: ‘Let there be acceleration!”

    In the subject item of correspondence, the author pointed out that, if an electric field of intensity E is the cause of that acceleration f, the Larmor radiation formula requires modification to read:

    (dW/dt)x = 2e2f2/3c2 – 4Efex/3c

    where (dW/dt)x is the rate at which energy crosses a boundary at radius x from the electron charge e. It was then noted that if M is the mass of the electron effective at that radius x, the radiation expression becomes:

    (dW/dt)x = (4E2e2x/3M2c2)(e2/2x-Mc2)

    because Mf = eE.

    The author then remarked that: “If the equation holds at a radius x equal to e2/2Mc2 there is no radiation of energy” and that, as we well know, the electric field energy of a charge outside a sphere of radius x is e2/2x. Accordingly, if M represents the component of electron field mass that is to be accelerated with the electron, that acceleration occurs only in accord with the normal inertial mass property if there is no radiation of energy by the accelerated electron.

    Here, in 1958, the author was pointing to the very causal basis of the inertial property of matter. Matter comprises discrete particles of electric charge and every single one of those charges will only experience acceleration determined according to the accelerating field condition, but in every case the inertial mass will ensure that no energy is radiated by any discrete charge. If there is electromagnetic energy radiation when charges are oscillated that is solely attributable to the collective mutual actions and is not sourced in the individual response of any charge component.

    It is a question of accepting that if n identical charges e share the same acceleration in the same electric field, the Larmor radiation formula will not involve a factor n2 but rather a factor n(n-l), because n electrons are not radiating on their own account.

    How Einstein could develop a theory based on the contrary proposition is quite astounding, especially as one knew from the electron activity in atoms that electrons were subject to acceleration but had an energy conservative property which later was seen as its quantized state.

    Over the years, every time the author pointed to this non-radiation property of the electron as being the basis for E = Mc2 he was told that he should not challenge Einstein’s theory and that the radiation formula stood proved and verified.

    Accordingly, we still find that physics teachers continue to show how to derive the Larmor formula for the energy radiation of an accelerated electron, without describing what it is that is accelerated, where the accelerated mass of the electron is seated and how accelerating field does its work in the close proximity of the electron charge. Their teaching expands into the ‘wave zone’ where they are developing theory that approximates the physics of collective charge actions and no longer the physics of the individual electron.

    If only they would pause to heed what this author said in 1958, they would understand the causal basis of inertia and of the formula E = Mc2 and see that they can do better by turning away from the Einstein doctrine.

    Amongst the many items of published correspondence listed in this bibliographical collection of the author’s contributions there is one entitled “Signals from the Future” [1971a]. It refers to Paul Dirac’s difficulty with the electron energy radiation theme, and includes the following words: ‘the equations showed that electron acceleration was possible when there was no incident field, and, as Dirac put it, “the electron seems to know about the pulse before it arrives”.’


  • 1957a

    1957a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published by the Institution of Electrical Engineers as Monograph No. 187M (July 1956) and later in Proc. I.E.E. vol. 104C at pp. 2-7 (1957).

    AN INVESTIGATION OF THE EDDY-CURRENT ANOMALY IN A LOW-SILICON SHEET STEEL

    Abstract: The eddy-current anomaly effects in a 0.019 in thick low-silicon sheet steel are investigated and analysed on the basis of magnetic inhomogeneity arising from ferromagnetic domain structure. This particular steel was chosen because previous experimental work had shown that inherent time-lag effects in the magnetization process were small. However, in such steel, flux waveform distortion arising from hysteresis phenomena adds to the anomaly effect, and a special experimental technique by which such distortion effects could be eliminated from the analysis was developed. This made it possible to test the magnetic inhomogeneity. The results obtained were interpreted in terms of a hypothetical domain configuration, and it is concluded that the magnetic inhomogeneity arising from ferromagnetic domain structure does account for the eddy-current anomaly, distortion and time-lag effects being of minor importance.

    Commentary: The advance reported in this paper was the step of measuring the eddy-current loss anomaly factor, not as an averaged effect taken over a full cycle of magnetization, but rather as an incremental effect confined to the rising portion of the flux density range. The effective permeability over the relevant range of magnetization is linear and it was found that the anomaly effect was concentrated over this range of magnetization, rather than the region at the top and falling portion of the B-H loop. What this meant was that one could see how quite large anomaly factors at levels hardly justified by magnetic domain inhomogeneities were in evidence.

    See the related papers: [1956a] and [1956b].



  • 1956b

    1956b

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published by the Institution of Electrical Engineers as Monograph No. 164M (January 1956) and later in Proc. I.E.E. vol. 103C at pp. 279-285 (1956).

    THE EDDY-CURRENT ANOMALY IN ELECTRICAL SHEET STEEL

    Abstract: A theory which accounts for the well-known discrepancy between eddy-current losses in electrical sheet steels and the experimentally observed values is presented. The anomaly is shown to be due partly to the magnetic inhomogeneity arising from ferromagnetic domain structure and partly to a time-lag effect caused by the finite speed of domain boundary movements. A new experimental approach to the study of the eddy-current anomaly is described. This involves the use of a method of measuring the anomaly factor as it applies instantaneously at a point in the magnetization cycle.

    Commentary: The advance reported in this paper was the step of measuring the eddy-current loss anomaly factor, not as an averaged effect taken over a full cycle of magnetization, but rather as an incremental effect over selected portions of the B-H loop. It was found that the main anomaly effect was occurring over the low flux density range. Indeed, over such a range it could be far in excess of the mean value normally attributed to the phenomenon.

    In an extreme case one can show that magnetic domain inhomogeneities could account for a loss anomaly factor as high as 3 in thin sheet steel, but the research reported here revealed loss factors appreciably higher than 3. It followed that a time-lag effect enhancing the hysteresis loss could not be ruled out.

    In retrospect, these notes being written some 43 years on from the date of the subject paper, the author now admits that the research suffered from a rather grave omission in that no account had been taken of the effect of the heat generated by eddy-current and hysteresis loss. This heat would flow from the magnetized core in the plane of the laminations and so in a direction at right angles to the magnetic polarization within the magnetic domains.

    By the Nernst Effect this is a recipe for the induction of mutually orthogonal electric fields powered by tapping that heat and it is now realized that this would, in fact, add to the induced EMF driving currents around the eddy-current loop, enhancing eddy-current flow and so escalating into an anomalous loss effect.

    The only excuse which the author can offer for this oversight is that there seemed at the time no reason to even think about thermoelectric effects affecting electric current flow in a single metal, steel, and even had that been contemplated the limited temperature range involved would hardly have suggested scope for efficient conversion of heat into electricity on the scale needed to explain the anomaly. Now, also seeing all this in retrospect, there is good reason for questioning the validity of what one had been taught concerning the second law of thermodynamics, or at least the applicability of this law to specific conditions prevalent inside a metal conductor where absolute temperature has no significance and only the temperature differential contributes to the effect considered.

    This aspect of the eddy-current anomaly can be far more important than the direct implications of the actual power loss. Indeed, one can begin to see scope for a new method of electrical power generation drawing on the ambient heat of our environment. This prospect gains strength from the discovery that eddy-current anomaly factors much higher than 3 were observed, particularly over the low flux density range where the maximum action attributable to the Nernst Effect will occur. The reason for this is that the domain magnetization is then equally shared by the two polarization directions, so that the augmenting EMFs induced will see flow paths of least resistance.

    See also the related papers: [1956a] and [1957a].



  • 1956a

    1956a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published by the Institution of Electrical Engineers as Monograph No. 165M (January 1956) and later in Proc. I.E.E. vol. 103C at pp. 272-278 (1956).

    MAGNETIC TIME-LAG EFFECTS IN SOLID STEEL CORES

    Abstract: The discrepancy between the theoretical eddy-current effects and the actual eddy-current effects in thick steel cores is investigated. By using thick cores the magnetic inhomogeneity arising from ferromagnetic domain configuration is of little consequence and the discrepancy may be attributed to an intrinsic time-lag effect in the magnetization process. The time-lag is measured and explained in terms of a localized eddy-current action associated with the dissipation of hysteresis loss. It was found that the time-lag depended upon frequency and was less important at high frequencies.

    Commentary: The experimental research reported in this paper aimed at explaining the mysterious extra loss that occurs in steel when subjected to alternating magnetization. This particular paper concerned the problem in solid steel rods magnetized at kilocycle frequencies as distinct from that in laminated steels at power frequencies. One important distinction between these two cases is that the physical size of magnetic domains and consequent magnetic inhomoheneity should be of lesser relevance in the magnetization of solid cores, thereby allowing one to see if the eddy-current loss anomaly could be eliminated in the latter situation and confined to the sheet steel laminations where magnetic domain inhomogeneity is prevalent.

    In the event it was found that in the solid steel cores there is indeed an anomalous loss resembling an eddy-current effect, but it is attributable to what one might term the dynamic component of the hysteresis loss. It corresponds to a time-lag effect of the order of 10 microseconds and arises from the increase in magnetizing field during the period taken by the jumps in the movement of the magnetic domain walls. However, this degree of time-lag cannot explain the eddy-current loss anomaly that occurs at the lower power frequency of 50 Hz, where time-lags of the order of 100 microseconds and more are needed to match the eddy-current loss observed.

    Accordingly, this paper, though establishing a case for added loss attributable to magnetic time-lag effects has to be considered in the context of the separate reports which were based on the same Ph.D. research programme.

    Press [1956b] and [1957a] for further information.



  • 1952d

    1952d

    The following is a U.K. Patent Application filed by Harold Aspden on February 15, 1951 with a first publication date of July 23, 1952.

    U.K. PATENT NO. 676,088

    ‘A FERROMAGNETIC HYSTERESIS POTENTIOMETER’

    Commentary: This is a patent describing and claiming the same device that is the subject of the published paper in The Review of Scientific Instruments. See [1951a]



  • 1952c

    1952c

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in The Journal of Scientific Instruments, vol. 29, pp. 371-374, (1952).

    A METHOD OF MEASURING THE MAGNETIC PERMEABILITY OF ROD SPECIMENS

    Abstract: A method is described by which the permeability of open-ended rod specimens is measured by detecting changes in flux density and field strength by search coil and fluxmeter means. A feature is introduced whereby a repeated reversal of magnetizing field results in the field-indicating fluxmeter adding all the field changes in the same sense so that the customary compromise between accuracy and sensitivity involved in direct measurements of field strength is avoided. The method is extended by connecting in opposition the field search coil and the flux search coil so that the above arrangement can be used as a sensitive flux-balance indicator and the accuracy of a permeability measurement rendered substantially independent of fluxmeter errors.

    Commentary: This paper was written during a period when the author was working for a Ph.D. degree which involved experimental research on the eddy-current anomaly. See the related paper: [1956a]. However, this method was not used in the eventual experiments which were the basis of that Ph.D. This paper was awarded a prize by the U.K. Institute of Physics.



  • 1952b

    1952b

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in The Journal of Scientific Instruments, vol. 29, pp. 2-7, (1952).

    A TWO FLUXMETER METHOD OF MEASURING FERROMAGNETIC HYSTERESIS LOSS

    Abstract: Ferromagnetic hysteresis loss is usually measured by the method of reversals or the step-by-step method, both of which involve the use of a ballistic galvanometer or a fluxmeter. The necessity for recording observations and measuring the area of the hysteresis loop can be eliminated by using a second fluxmeter to integrate successive electrical discharges, which are initiated by a chosen change in flux density and are proportional in magnitude to the magnetizing field. The total deflexion of this second fluxmter over one complete cycle of magnetization is a direct measure of the hysteresis loss. By this means it is possible, without sacrificing accuracy, to reduce the time of measurement to a small fraction of that usually required by conventional methods.

    Commentary: This paper was written during a period when the author was working for a Ph.D. degree which involved experimental research on the eddy-current anomaly. See the related paper: [1956a]. However, this method was not used in the eventual experiments which were the basis of that Ph.D.



  • 1952a

    1952a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in the Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 23, pp. 523-528 (1951).

    EDDY-CURRENTS IN SOLID CYLINDRICAL CORES HAVING NON-UNIFORM PERMEABILITY

    Abstract: A method of estimating magnetization losses in solid cylindrical cores of ferromagnetic material is given. The conception of complex permeability is introduced to show the effects which hysteresis has upon the degree of flux penetration. A formula is given for the effective permeability which should be used in the classical treatment in which non-linearities have been ignored. An arbitrary case in which the permeability changes across the core section is considered and the solution is extended to a core which is homogeneous, but whose permeability changes with the degree of magnetization. In this way errors due to a non-linear B-H curve are reduced and the complex permeability notation is shown to lead to a more reasonable Steinmetz relationship. The eddy-current anomaly is mentioned and it is noted that the theory developed is suited to a consideration of the anomaly as explained in terms of time-lag effects.

    Commentary: This paper was written during a period when the author was working for a Ph.D. degree which involved experimental research on the eddy-current anomaly. See the related paper: [1956a]. However, the detailed analysis based on complex magnetic permeability as covered by the mathematics in this paper in relation to a non-linear B-H magnetization curve was not included nor involved in the research thesis which was submitted in support of that Ph.D. degree.



  • 1951a

    1951a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden was published in The Review of Scientific Instruments, vol. 22, pp. 869-871 (1951).

    A FERROMAGNETIC HYSTERESIS POTENTIOMETER

    Abstract: The potentiometer embodies the principle of the normal fluxmeter method of measuring hysteresis loss but, while retaining the accuracy, enables the measurement to be made in a fraction of a minute. The potentiometer incorporates a number of tappings which are connected to individual contact studs so that by rotating a contact arm the current applied to a magnetizing circuit can be varied in a cyclical manner between two limiting values. There are intermediate positions of the arm which correspond to intermediate values of current and these values differ by fixed amounts from one cycle to the next. The contact arm also forms part of a stud switch so that a search coil can be disconnected from a fluxmeter over the part in each cycle over which the current changes between the intermediate and one of the limiting values. In this way a complete rotation of the arm is made to take a specimen through twelve cycles of magnetization and since the intermediate current values are evenly distributed over the complete cycle the fluxmeter registers a deflection which can be related to the hysteresis loss.

    Commentary: This paper was written during a period when the author was working for a Ph.D. degree which involved experimental research on the eddy-current anomaly. See the related paper: [1956a]. However, this potentiometer was not used in the eventual experiments which were the basis of that Ph.D.



  • Aspden Www Aspden Org Papers P2002A Notes

    NOTES ON BERLIN LECTURE

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 2002

    This set of six Notes was compiled as an aide memoire for use in the author’s onward discussions following the presentation of the Lecture at the 2nd Berlin Conference for Innovative Energy Technologies organized by BINNOTEC e.V., Berlin and held the location of SolarEnergy 2002, Messe Berlin, Messedamm 22, D-14055 in Berlin, Germany on June 13th-15th 2002.

    I

    EINSTEIN: ENERGY AND THE VACUUM

    When reading about energy as a property of the medium we call the ‘vacuum’, there will
    be those who wonder about the role which Einstein played in clarifying our picture of things.
    Well, much as you may wonder, you will find that Einstein had very little to say about energy, as
    such, and far less, if anything, about the vacuum as a source of energy. Do not be deceived by
    what you think may be implied by the formula E = Mc2. This equation is easily derived by
    investigating how an electric charge accelerated by an electric field can respond to avoid radiating
    its energy E and, indeed, its very charge. Its response has to be such that it exhibits inertia
    according to a mass property M as given by the above formula, c being the speed at which electric
    field disturbance propagates through the vacuum from the seat of action, the electric charge.
    However, that was not how Einstein came to formulate that equation. His approach was
    somewhat philosophical, albeit guided by a fact known from experiment in the latter part of the
    19th century that, the faster an electric particle moves, the greater its mass, subject to a limiting
    threshold set by the speed of light c. The correct interpretation, however, is the simple fact that
    energy has to be conserved and, as an electric charge has an associated amount of energy, energy
    which increases by augmenting the electric field energy of the particle with a retinue of kinetic
    energy, that energy is not dispersed by radiation and so accumulates and enhances the mass.

    As you can see, under that heading of the Berlin Lecture ‘Capacitor Magic or a Mere
    Dream’, I began by asking you to ‘imagine’ a capacitor as having a rather unexpected property
    and followed this by asking how you would turn this into a ‘practical’ device. Imagination of
    what might be possible in our world of reality, coupled with practical skill are characteristic of the
    engineer and inventor and energy is the realm of the engineer. In contrast, noting that that Berlin
    Lecture, though prepared in draft form in January 2002 before I accepted the invitation to speak
    at the Berlin meeting and completed on 8th March after returning from a four week absence on
    vacation, it struck a chord in the author’s mind to read, on 14th March 2002 in the English
    newspaper THE TIMES, that that day was the anniversary of the birth of Albert Einstein and that:

    While at secondary school, Albert Einstein – who was born on this day in Ulm,
    Germany in 1879 – wrote an essay in which he proposed becoming a teacher of
    theoretical science, because of his “disposition for abstract and mathematical
    thought, and my lack of imagination and practical ability”.

    It is no wonder, therefore, that Einstein came to see the aether, or rather space-time, as an
    abstraction definable in terms of mathematical equations but could not imagine its real form and
    see its potential as a practical energy source!

    Admittedly, this author is here giving vent to his feelings, having in mind the hostility he
    encountered when trying to advance his insights into the nature of the aether and encountering
    shocked reaction expressed by the words “Have you never heard of Einstein?”. To have one’s
    scientific papers during a 14 year period up to 1969 rejected on sight for non-conformity with
    Einstein’s teaching did leave its scars. This accounts for the unusual choice of title of the author’s
    first major printed work, namely Physics without Einstein, a 224 page book which, incidentally,
    at pp. 8-14, presents the full mathematical analysis proving that an accelerated electrical charge
    that seeks to preserve itself from loss of energy must exhibit an inertial property according to a
    formula E = Mc2 where M is the mass defining that inertial property, E is the energy of the particle
    and c is the speed at which disturbances produced by accelerating electric field action propagate
    by displacing the electric charge system of the aether.

    [H. Aspden: 15th March 2002]

    II

    AN UNEXPLAINED ANOMALY

    It was only as I finalised the text of the BERLIN LECTURE that I recalled that, some 19
    years before, in 1983, I had been given a copy of a Ph.D. thesis by someone I knew as a Research
    Manager at IBM’s development laboratories in U.K., Dr. Bruce P. Piggin. I and Dr. Piggin had
    just retired from IBM and I had become a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the University of
    Southampton in England. Dr. Piggin’s Ph.D. research had been in the Chemistry Department of
    that university and his thesis entitled ‘Pulse Studies on an Electrochemical System’ was dated July
    1967.

    I remembered that he had some particular views about capacitors and an aspect that he
    saw as warranting attention, but what he had said at the time did not stir my interest, even though
    I was then intent on experimenting with a torsionally suspended capacitor system excited by high
    voltage pulsations to repeat my own version of the Trouton-Noble Experiment, which had in 1904
    been an attempt to detect the Earth’s motion through space. Indirectly that experiment is
    concerned with the law of electrodynamics because the detection of motion through the aether
    depends upon a certain interpretation of that law, as it concerns the notion of two spaced
    capacitor charges moving with body Earth through space and an experiment aimed at detecting
    the effects of electrodynamic interaction forces as between the moving charges.

    So my copy of that thesis has lain dormant in my files for those 19 intervening years, and
    it is only now, having been inspired by new ideas to write the BERLIN LECTURE, that I have
    seen reason to browse through it once more. My reason is that the test capacitor of Bruce
    Piggin’s thesis is a cell of concentric cylindrical electrode construction and it is pulse-charged.
    I also note that, as I now read this 1967 Southampton University thesis, it has occurred to me that
    the cold fusion theme that captured our headlines in the 1989 era, had involved a cell of somewhat
    similar construction and that Professor Fleischmann, of cold fusion fame, had his professorial seat
    in the Department of Electrochemistry at Southampton University.

    Now, in this brief note, which I admit I present as possibly only of passing interest, I only
    wish to draw attention to a feature of the Piggin thesis that I find curious as it may have some
    bearing upon the claim I am making in presenting that BERLIN LECTURE. Remember that in
    that Lecture I am suggesting that the aether can import energy anomalously into a concentric
    cylindrical capacitor. Critics will ask for evidence in support, so I feel obliged to point to anything
    that can help in this quest.

    So all I intend to present here is a copy of page 105 from Dr. Piggin’s thesis, which
    introduces his Fig. 49, and couple this with a quotation concerning that Fig. 49 that appears on
    page 100 of the thesis. I leave others who may read this to infer what they may, but say further
    that in his experiment Piggin applies an electrical pulse to charge the capacitor and follows this
    by an opposite polarity pulse to force its rapid discharge, after which, for some mysterious reason,
    that capacitor begins to recharge of its own accord. Can the inertial energy of the aether that I
    discuss in the BERLIN LECTURE be feeding in by a sub-microsecond delay?

    That quotation reads:

    ” An interesting observation is shown in Fig. 49. In this case, decay of the stored
    charge is assisted by the search pulse of opposite polarity. It is observed that the
    voltage decays at an accelerated rate during the search pulse as expected. The
    interesting question posed is why should the decay voltage rise of its own accord,
    after the search pulse has finished? Similar observations will be reported in later
    chapters.”

    Readers do need to be mindful of the fact that Dr. Piggin’s thesis concerned tests on cells
    using a chemical dielectric in the capacitor system, platinum electrode in iodine-iodide solutions
    and so chemical factors may account for the observed anomaly, but equally the chemical factor
    would not preclude aether-energy inflow and that phenomenon could well have been in evidence.
    Without there being test data for cells not loaded with a chemical dielectric this remains an open
    question.

    The following is a copy of page 105 from the thesis.

    Footnote

    As a point of interest I recall from my school education (some 60 years ago) that my
    physics master introduced us to the properties of a Leyden jar by demonstrating an experiment
    with two concentric electrodes and a removable cylindrical dielectric spacer element. He charged
    the assembly as a capacitor and then removed the dielectric element before (I believe – if my
    memory serves me well) then connecting the electrodes to discharge any energy they might have.
    Then he reassembled the capacitor with its dielectric spacer element and showed us that the
    capacitor did, indeed, still have some electric charge. His message was that there was energy
    stored in that dielectric spacer element, which I now can imagine as attributable to an inertial
    aether spin action within its cylindrical form, an action which can shed energy immediately on
    demand only if the electrode system is present and its electrodes are short-circuited so as to permit
    a discharge current to flow.

    [H. ASPDEN : 16th March 2002]

    III

    THE ASYMMETRICAL CAPACITOR ACTION

    In the BERLIN LECTURE it was suggested that a capacitor, particularly one of
    concentric cylindrical electrode construction, might deliver as output, when discharging, an
    amount of energy that could be as much as double that supplied as input when charging. This
    might seem to pose a problem with regard to the conventional mathematical analysis of capacitor
    properties, bearing in mind that we assume that the charge input Q is equal to the capacitance C
    multiplied by voltage V.

    I will, therefore, examine this problem from two points of view. I will begin by making
    a strong assertion, expressing an opinion that I feel sure 99% of the academic community versed
    in electrical theory will support, but I will then contradict what this implies by reference to
    experimental data. After that I will engage in a measure of theoretical speculation in presenting
    the only alternative point of view available, an approach which not even 1% of that academic
    community would support, and then I will endorse what this implies by pointing to experimental
    data that has been drawn to my attention but which I cannot vouch for as verified by independent
    researchers.



    The First Point of View

    One can be sure that the charge displaced around a circuit from one electrode to the other
    cannot suddenly double in value merely because of the transition which occurs as the charge-discharge cycle peaks at its maximum value. The action, therefore, must occur in the state of the
    aether between the two electrodes of the capacitor as the energy stored in that region of aether
    seeks release as the aether there senses a transition from the input to the output state.

    In short, it has to be the effective permittivity of the dielectric properties of the capacitor
    that changes to deliver the extra energy as output. In mathematical terms, it would seem that the
    permittivity during discharge must be half that applicable during the charging period, even though
    we are referring essentially to the properties of what we understand as the vacuum state. This
    implies a capacitance during discharge that is half that during the charging period, so that the
    charge Q, which equals CV, remains the same at the instant of transition, whilst the voltage V
    doubles. C, which is proportional to that permittivity value, is halved. In energy terms, bearing
    in mind that energy E = CV2/2, this results in a doubling of the energy E, meaning that the
    discharge will release twice the amount of energy that was fed in as input during charging.

    Now, the problem here is that I am not aware of any experimental evidence that reveals
    a doubling of output voltage when a capacitor begins to discharge. Even if the case is restricted
    to capacitors having concentric electrodes I still think that, if such a phenomenon were to occur,
    it would have been mentioned in our textbooks on the subject. Indeed, to the contrary, as
    reference to the Ph.D. thesis of Bruce Piggin just discussed in the preceding note shows, the
    capacitor voltage of the concentric cylindrical electrode capacitor merely follows the normal path,
    but yet, if then abruptly fully discharged by a negative input pulse, there is some kind of after
    effect which does show a mysterious voltage build-up.

    Accordingly, adopting this first point of view, has still left us with the problem of
    understanding how a capacitor can shed energy electrically if in truth it has acquired an excess of
    energy from aether input.



    The Second Point of View

    Here I need to outline a feature of the aether that my rigorous theoretical analysis of that
    structured vacuum medium has revealed. The aether has a cubic cell structure with an aether
    particle seated in each cell. It sits in a uniform continuum of electric charge which fills the space
    in that cell not occupied by the particle form and this continuum charge has a polarity opposite
    to that of the aether particle, so that the aether overall is electrically neutral. The aether particle
    would itself expand under its internal electrostatic repulsion forces were it not for there being a
    an energy presence in the cell pervading that continuum, the energy concentration matching that
    of the aether particle form so as to have equilibrium and balance of pressure. That energy
    presence is provided by a virtual pair of leptons, the heavy electrons that particle physicists refer
    to as mu-mesons or muons. They perform no known role in the physical constitution of the
    universe, because that role is primarily the one they serve in assuring pressure equilibrium within
    the aether itself and because the aether, as such, is ‘unknown’ to the theoretical physicist of today.

    I know this fact about the aether virtual muon system because my theory has allowed the
    evaluation of the unit cell energy in terms of the rest mass energy of the electron and the analysis
    suggests that a virtual muon can be either a positive or negative electron unit of charge with an
    associated energy quantum that is either 205 or 207 times the value of the electron rest mass
    energy. The theory indicates that the 207 units outnumber the 205 units by a two to one ratio.

    Indeed, by assuming that these virtual muon quanta migrate through space and suffer
    mutual annihilation and recreation at the same cyclic frequency as the quantum jitter motion of
    those aether particles, one can recognize their secondary role which accounts for the process of
    proton creation and so derive a theoretical value for the proton/electron mass ratio that is
    1836.152, in good accord with the measured value.

    This is all of record in this author’s published work, as summarized in ‘Aether Science
    Papers
    ‘ (1996), but I make particular reference to the ninth of the fourteen appended papers in
    that book, which is ‘A Theory of Proton Creation‘, Physics Essays, v. 1, pp. 72-76 (1988). It
    discusses the role of the virtual muon in creating the proton from the energy underworld of the
    aether, the energy equilibrium of that medium being maintained as it absorbs energy dissipated by
    matter, reorganizes it into a quantized virtual muon form and then sheds it as surplus by creating
    protons with an accompanying electron to keep the electrical charge balance.

    Now, why is this relevant to our capacitor problem? The simple answer here is that, if the
    capacitor is to deliver twice the amount of energy on discharge as it receives during the charge
    period, and do this without doubling its voltage for the discharge period, then it must somehow
    be able to double its charge so as to deliver twice as much output charge as it received as input.
    That is impossible unless the vacuum medium within the capacitor plates can itself produce a flow
    of charge through what is normally seen as a non-conductor of electricity.

    My proposition, therefore, is that, given that the aether has energy it seeks to release and
    given that it is alive with a virtual muon activity that passes unnoticed normally, we can look to
    that muon activity to find a way of shedding that energy as a flow of current from that capacitor.

    The action is probably one where a negative muon of 207 electron mass units sheds two
    electrons at the negative capacitor electrode and converts into a positive virtual muon of 205
    electron mass units, whilst the reciprocal action occurs at the positive electrode as two electrons
    are drawn from that electrode and absorbed into a positive virtual muon 205 to convert it into a
    negative virtual muon 207. As the virtual muons deploy in their equilibrium activity this will
    amount to a flow of electrons through the space between the electrodes.

    It means that the capacitor can, without doubling its voltage, deliver the double energy
    output by delivering double the input charge as output.

    It may all sound highly speculative and that I do not deny, but at least I offer a possible
    answer to the problem. Furthermore, though it is indeed quite fortuitous, I find that, after a lapse
    of 14 years since a previous contact, a U.S. researcher named Alexis Guy Obolensky mailed me
    a letter dated February 28, 2002 in which he reminds me of a supporting opinion I expressed back
    in 1988 concerning his discovery of faster-than-light-speed action in an experiment involving
    transmission via coaxial cables. It is quite astounding to find that, as I write this commentary as
    a Note to back up the text of the BERLIN LECTURE that I compiled in January, I can quote a
    paragraph from Obolensky’s February letter that seems to endorse my speculation. It reads:

    “I was the first to employ matched coaxial cable time delays and phase matched
    current sensors to demonstrate the existence of electromagnetic (faster than light)
    shock waves. This substantiated Tesla’s magnifying transmitter patent
    application’s superluminal claim. His technique to extract fuelless coherent-energy, from the incoherent-heat of the ambient medium, was suggested but not
    proven back in 1988. This, notwithstanding the numerous superluminal shock
    wave experiments that revealed an approximate doubling of the remote receiver’s
    integrated-current output compared to a simultaneous measurement of the local
    transmitter’s integrated-current input. To my knowledge, electronic research has
    still not investigated electromagnetic shock waves by using equal-time-delay,
    simultaneous measurements, to circumvent the Einstein clock problem.”

    That reference to the electric charge output from a pulse-excited coaxial transmission line
    being double the charge input has attracted my attention. It implies an energy gain which
    Obolensky, in the next paragraph of his letter attributes to ‘the incoherent heat in our planet’s
    atmosphere’ as the source. However, my opinion, as is evident from my BERLIN LECTURE is
    that the aether is the energy source and I can but point out that a voltage pulse travelling along
    a coaxial cable is the sequential charging and discharging of a capacitative component which has
    a conductor as central electrode and an earthed electrode formed by a concentric conducting
    sleeve, that is a concentric cylindrical electrode capacitor in which one can develop aether spin.

    Accordingly, I can but regard what Obolensky describes as supporting this second point
    of view and endorsing my conductive aether notion based on those virtual muons.

    [H. ASPDEN: 16th March 2002]

    IV

    CAPACITOR ENERGY ESCALATION ANALYSIS

    Here we calculate the condition for the circuit shown in Fig. 7 of the BERLIN LECTURE
    to tap aether energy based on the capacitor property there discussed, namely the feature that for
    a cyclic change of capacitor energy the capacitor energy doubles during the discharge. It seems
    appropriate to assume that the development of aether spin in a system which is to be governed
    by a phase-lock between a space region in spin and a non-spinning enveloping space region will
    require that a small but finite threshold of radial electric field intensity between the capacitor
    electrodes has to be exceeded.

    Let C be the value of each capacitor. Let V be the d.c. capacitor priming potential in
    volts. Let v denote the voltage of a transient potential drop across each of the two sections of the
    inductor system. Let R here denote the resistance of each such inductor section, this resistance
    including that of a load which is connected to the secondary winding of a transformer of which
    the primary winding is the inductor system just mentioned.

    At any instant the voltage across one capacitor will be V-v when that across the other
    capacitor is V+v. This is because capacitor charge can oscillate between the two capacitors as
    current flow through the inductors changes cyclically, the corresponding induced EMFs of
    strength v across each inductor section being in anti-phase and so of opposite polarity relative to
    the central earth terminal.

    By standard electrical theory the energy stored by the two capacitors is given by:

    C(V+v)2/2 + C(V-v)2/2

    which is:

    C(V2 + v2)

    and so as v changes there is no energy gain but merely a loss owing to the flow of current through
    the overall inductor resistance 2R.

    However, we are considering a situation where the discharging capacitor is shedding twice
    as much energy as it gained during charging. Therefore, allowing for the presence of the aether
    energy acquired during the charging stage, in discharging to the V-v condition, a capacitor will
    shed an excess of energy drawn from the aether amounting to:

    C(V+v)2 – C(V-v)2

    which is:

    4CVv

    This excess energy is deemed to flow in as input from the aether owing to the quantum
    synchronisation of the zero-point vacuum energy of that aether medium. This latter energy is
    replenished in each half cycle of oscillation only to the extent needed by the fluctuation of the
    voltage v across the inductors.

    Suppose now that v, which is zero initially, is induced by some internal fluctuation or
    external field stimulus and so begins a natural oscillation at the resonant frequency of the circuit.
    Let v now denote the amplitude of a sinusoidal variation so that as this passes through its zero
    value the energy 4CVv which has come from the aether has been shed in half a cycle.

    This energy has to do more than overcome resistance loss if there is to be a build up of
    the oscillations as needed to render the system useful as a power generator. Note then that the
    resistance loss plus power delivery will be proportional to v2, because v is the amplitude of the
    voltage acting across the inductors and so, with inductance fixed, the current magnitude is
    proportional to v and the resistance loss plus power delivery is proportional to the current
    squared. Accordingly, the crucial factor is whether kv2, with k determined by that inductance and
    resistance, is less than 4CVv when multiplied by twice the frequency of oscillation. If so, and
    provided that threshold condition mentioned above is exceeded, then the oscillations will escalate
    in strength and provide a source of ‘free’ energy. It is then clear why the priming voltage V is
    important.

    The factor k will also depend upon the capacitance of the capacitor as this limits the
    current. Indeed the current amplitude is 2πvC times the frequency of oscillation and if 2R is the
    circuit resistance the overall condition for an escalating energy action becomes one for which
    2V/v is greater than π2CR times the frequency. This is a simple numerical ratio because CR has
    the dimension of time. It is a condition that, at least in theory, is easily satisfied but that unknown
    threshold value of electric field intensity has to be exceeded, a factor which makes that priming
    voltage V extremely important.

    It must be high and, being high, this means that v will increase more and more until it rivals
    V in value, which in turn means that a high rate of energy output can be achieved if V+v is of the
    order of 25,000 volts and the resonant frequency is of the order of 100 kHz. Indeed, potentially,
    a pair of capacitors each of only 1 nanofarad capacitance could, on this theoretical basis, deliver
    aether energy at a power rating of the order of 50 kW, 62.5 kW being applicable if v were to
    climb to a limiting value V.

    To put this in perspective, if this capacitor energy escalation theme is a valid proposition,
    one can begin to contemplate a practical application based on the above 50 kW power output
    from a pair of 1 nanofarad capacitors. Such a capacitor using air as dielectric would need an
    electrode separation of the order of 1 cm to withstand the 25,000 volt charge. If it were to
    comprise two concentric cylinders, one having an internal diameter of 20 cm and the other an
    external diameter of 19 cm, and an overall length of 50 cm, then its capacitance would be 2.2
    nanofarad and two such capacitors would only take up a fraction of the space assigned to the
    engine compartment of an ordinary automobile. Yet the potential power rating, based on that 2.2
    nanofarad value would be in excess of 100 kW, which is an acceptable level for such an
    application. The equipment needed to generate a 25 kV capacitor priming voltage, taken together
    with a standard electrical car battery to feed in the initial charge of the capacitors plus the
    inductor/transformer units which form the resonant circuit and provide a lower voltage
    transformer output need be no larger in volume than the capacitors. One is then left with the need
    for an electric motor that can provide the mechanical drive for the automobile, this being standard
    technology but the greater weight factor in terms of drive power generated and so the primary
    design criterion that could limit vehicle performance.

    One can, however, be sure that if the new technology implied can meet the requirements
    of powering an automobile, it can be even more advantageous in large scale electric power
    generation for domestic and industrial use as well as in ship propulsion.

    Accordingly, the scientific principle involved warrants the necessary research to verify or
    disprove what is suggested and, if viable, ascertain such criteria as may impose limitations on
    performance.

    [H. ASPDEN: 17th March 2002]

    V

    POWER FROM CONCENTRIC CAPACITOR PAIRING:

    A GENERAL OBSERVATION

    The inevitable question concerning my BERLIN LECTURE is: “Why what is suggested
    has not been discovered already in the electrical laboratories of our many universities?” To
    suggest that energy outputs of some 100 kW could be delivered as if from nowhere by connecting
    two capacitors of a few nanofarads capacitance by inductors to form a resonant circuit is an awe
    inspiring proposition.

    My simple answer has to be to ask where I can look up the record of such an experiment
    having been performed and its negative result recorded. Clearly, had such an experiment been
    performed and had it delivered a ‘free’ energy output, then that would inevitably have been
    newsworthy besides being documented in a scientific periodical.

    Has the experiment ever been performed? Until someone can say: “Yes” to this question
    and quote the reference for my inspection, then I must assume the answer is: “No” and adhere to
    my argument that the issue must be clarified in view of its potential importance.

    However, just ask yourself why anyone in a university electrical laboratory would be
    interested in setting up an oscillation in an inductor-capacitor circuit as between two series-connected capacitors and an inductor and how they would proceed. I suggest that if they did they
    would obtain the capacitors commercially and that those capacitors would not be of concentric
    electrode construction. I suggest that they would not see much point in using a series connection
    of the capacitors, given that one normally connects capacitors in parallel if one seeks to augment
    the capacitance in circuit. I suggest that the series connection, if adopted, might be deemed to
    serve only as means for using capacitors of lower voltage rating in a higher voltage application,
    perhaps in a high voltage laboratory for delivering high voltage d.c. pulse discharges for test
    purposes, but not as part of a resonant inductor-capacitor circuit.

    Then consider the chance that someone would deem it worthwhile to build themselves two
    large concentric cylindrical electrode capacitors for coupling with an inductor in a resonant circuit
    and then connecting a high d.c. voltage source to the junction between the two capacitors when
    standard circuit theory says that, once connected, no steady current would flow from that d.c.
    source. Yes, were the capacitors to be of electrolytic form and have the necessary polarized
    medium as the dielectric element, one might contemplate such an assembly but then consider the
    point I now make. The ‘free’ energy theme we are discussing requires a high priming voltage V
    and a resonance that involves the capacitance attributable to the aether alone. A high dielectric
    permittivity merely means a higher loss-generating current oscillation, whereas the maximum
    ‘free’ energy gain arises from the base permittivity value of the vacuum medium and the
    capacitors with vacuum or an air-cored dielectric medium offer that maximum gain. Any spurious
    power gain in a circuit using electrolytic capacitors, even if their assembly were to be a simple
    single-pair electrode form (which is extremely unlikely) would easily be overlooked in an
    application aimed at some other objective than power generation.

    Then there is the factor of operating voltage level. I have used 25,000 V as a nominal
    voltage in estimating the ‘free’ energy potential output of the order of 50 kW based on operating
    a pair of 1 nanofarad capacitors at 100 kHz. However, an experiment on a laboratory test bench
    not in a high voltage electrostatic test laboratory environment is more likely to be performed at
    a voltage of the order of 250 V. This would lower the anomalous output power to a mere 5
    watts, which could easily pass unnoticed unless one was expressly looking for such a power
    discrepancy.

    The chance of building a circuit of the kind required and then discovering that it generates
    power in a manner contrary to expectation as founded on conventional theory is, therefore,
    extremely improbable. Yet, given that this has happened in history, what chance is there that the
    discoverer of the new ‘free’ energy source can stir interest by those in authority who are
    committed to their belief that what amounts to a ‘perpetual motion’ device is impossible because
    it defies the established laws of physics?

    There is the greater chance of what seems to be a ludicrous scientific claim being given
    attention for its general interest as a story worthy of the telling. So it is the authors of books on
    fringe-science topics that we must applaud for bringing such ‘free’ energy claims to our attention.
    There is entertainment value in the subject and, as ever, the excitement that the underdog may yet
    be proved right and turn the world of energy science around just in time to save us from the
    impending disaster that is getting ever nearer owing to the demise of our oil reserves. In saying
    this I am mindful of the reference I made in my BERLIN LECTURE to the book by Keith Tutt.

    I can but conclude that the formal academic task of pursuing the necessary experiments
    is there as a challenge for our learned brethren of the physics and electrical engineering sectors
    to undertake. Disprove by experiment what I have suggested in that lecture and find comfort in
    the ongoing belief that all is well with the prevailing laws of energy conservation which exclude
    energy inflow from the aether. Alternatively, prove that such inflow can occur and ease our
    concern about future energy resources, besides opening the door for the entry of a new
    cosmological belief, namely that our Sun and Earth were created by energy shed by an overactive
    aether.

    [H. ASPDEN: 12 April 2002]

    VI

    THE PARALLEL PLATE CAPACITOR

    The key factor pointing to how energy is extracted from the vacuum medium by the cyclic
    charging and discharging of a capacitor, the subject of my BERLIN LECTURE, is the need for
    synchronisation as between the orbital motion of charge forming the quantum underworld even
    though the charges sit in different regions subjected to different extraneous field effects. The
    presence of an electric field between the electrodes of a capacitor displaces the charge orbits there
    located and this means that, to hold that synchronism with charges elsewhere throughout the
    orbital cycle, the system of that charge between the capacitor plates must move in a direction at
    right angles to the electric field direction.

    This is possible in the cylindrical electrode capacitor configuration of Fig. 6 but this poses
    problems for the action in the parallel plate capacitor configuration of Fig. 5. I have suggested
    that the linear motion of the charge system in this latter case does deploy energy from the vacuum
    medium to keep that state of synchrony but that as the capacitor discharges the collapse of that
    linear motion would dissipate the energy within the aether itself and so not be available as a useful
    excess power output.

    Here, on reflection, I find that I may have been in error in suggesting that holding to strict
    synchrony throughout the orbital period without lateral motion might lead to an impossible
    process of continuous very high frequency oscillation of energy exchange. If that linear lateral
    displacement of charge were to be precluded by the fact that charges would be driven into one
    another and so set up an electric field opposing that motion, then the charge orbits between the
    capacitor electrodes could not be displaced in that lateral direction.

    Then what I at first deemed to be impossible may indeed be possible. The quantum
    underworld may well be able to cope with extremely rapid exchanges of energy as between its
    constituent vacuum charges and the ruling factor has to be the facts of experiment that prevail in
    the different circumstances. The phenomenon under consideration appears not to manifest itself
    in experiments involving parallel plate capacitors, where we see no anomalous behaviour, but the
    evidence, as discussed in that BERLIN LECTURE, does reveal itself when the capacitors have
    cylindrical concentric electrodes. In other words, in order for us to gain access to energy that can
    be shed by the vacuum medium by setting up a pulsating electric field between two capacitor
    electrodes, those electrodes must have a configuration which provides a passageway for free flow
    of the charges in the direction lateral to the field direction.

    [H. ASPDEN, 28th April 2002]

    ***************************