Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Uncategorized

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • CHAPTER 1

    CHAPTER 1

    Nature’s Coded Messages

    The processes by which Nature creates the fundamental particles which combine to form atomic matter and so our whole universe determine certain numerical factors which are precisely the same whenever and wherever measured. These are known as the fundamental dimensionless constants. They are merely numbers but yet those numbers are encoded expressions which tell us that Mother Nature has, for some special reason, determined a definite relationship between certain physical quantities.

    There are three such numbers that, collectively, can reveal to us the secrets of Creation, if only we can discover their physical formulation.

    One is the numerical factor which relates the mass of the proton to that of the electron, an important ratio, given that the partnership of these two fundamental particles constitutes the hydrogen atom. This is the primary atomic element from which all matter evolves. The numerical factor here is 1836.152.

    Another, equally important numerical factor, is that having the measured value of 137.0359. This relates the speed of light c in vacuo with the electric charge e of the electron and Planck’s constant h. Planck’s constant is the factor by which the frequency of an electromagnetic wave is determined as a function of the energy quanta involved. That number 137.0359 is Nature’s message which says:

    “Decipher me and you will understand what governs the phenomena of quantum physics as evidenced by matter at the sub-atomic level.”

    Thirdly, there is the numerical quantity that relates the constant of gravitation G and the charge to mass ratio, e/me, of the electron. Unlike the first two numbers, this does not appear in the tables of physical constants. It is not one that is measured directly, but has to be inferred from separate measurements of G as the force of attraction between two bodies of known mass, and e/me as by measurements using a cathode ray tube. One simply cannot hope to fathom the mysteries of Creation without an understanding of the physical processes that govern the value of G. The measurement data applicable to G and e/me depend upon the units physicists have chosen to use.

    Concerning units, it is intended in this work, to use the system of units that prevailed during the period in history when our knowledge of physics at the fundamental level expanded by the discovery of the electron. This system, the cgs system, regards the force between two unit electric charges separated in vacuo at unit distance as being itself unity, whereas the practical system of units as used in modern physics complicates the force formulation by ascribing properties to the vacuum medium itself, properties which need expression in their own units. To use the practical system of units for the purpose of this work would over-complicate the mathematical equations and add unnecessary complexity to the project at hand, that of understanding the creative forces at work in our universe.

    So, to summarize, the task ahead is to examine the factors which govern the physical actions that determine the three numerical quantities introduced above. Our object is simply to unravel, so far as we can, the secrets of Creation and, at the very least, decipher the three numbers introduced above, by which is meant the discovery of the mathematical formulae which they signify as relations between the physical quantities involved.

    Historical Foundations

    An appropriate starting point is provided by Newton’s Law of Gravitation as seen in the context of Coulomb’s Law concerning the force acting between two electric charges. Although Isaac Newton established that gravitation was governed by an inverse-square-of-distance law of force which implied the constant of gravitation G, it was not until a century later in 1797/8 that Henry Cavendish, using a delicate torsion balance for measuring the attraction of two small bodies, could quantify its value.

    Joseph Priestley in 1767 proposed that the electric force acting between two charged objects was also subject to an inverse-square-of-distance law. Having been advised by his friend Benjamin Franklin that when a small charged body is placed anywhere inside a hollow charged conducting sphere, no electric force is exerted on that body, Priestley recalled that Newton had shown mathematically that the gravitational force attributable to the mass of a hollow spherical shell is zero everywhere inside that shell. This is only true if the gravitational force is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the two interacting bodies. Therefore, Priestley reasoned that the electric interaction force must itself be of the inverse-square-of-distance form.

    In 1750 an Englishman Michell had devised an instrument in which the known torsion of a thread balances an unknown force acting at the ends of a bar magnet and had used this to show that an inverse square law acts between magnetic poles. Coulomb reinvented the torsion balance and with it, in 1785, verified the law for both magnetic pole interaction and electric charge interaction.

    So we see that, by the end of the 18th century, physicists were able to formulate the magnitude of the force acting between bodies as a function of their mass, their electric charge and, indeed, their magnetic pole strength, but, still two centuries later, there remains the need to decipher the messages implied by those measured quantities to understand how Nature determines their values.

    In this pursuit we should find inspiration in the account above by which Priestley deduced that the electric force had to be of the inverse square form. The mathematics involved is of the kind we shall be using in this work as we explore the same force laws to probe the mysteries of Creation and this will include an account of the small but very significant modifications affecting the law of gravitation to cater for the planetary perihelion anomaly. This is a question of how energy travels between interacting bodies when their separation distance is changing.

    Just as Newton was able to prove mathematically that there is no gravitational force acting on a body within a spherical shell of uniform mass density per unit area of the spherical surface, so we shall prove, on the same assumption, that the interaction component of the field energy of two electric charges separated by a distance R sums to zero within a sphere of radius R centred on either charge [See Appendix I]. It is analysis of this kind that can point to the connecting links between electric, magnetic and gravitational laws of force and provide the elements of a unified theory by which to comprehend how Nature regulates the values of those dimensionless constants already mentioned.

    As to the historical picture, take note that the electron did not present itself as something whose electric charge and mass could be measured until another hundred years or so had passed. J. J. Thomson in 1897 made progress in his cathode ray tube measurements by which the charge to mass ratio of the electron was measured and by 1911 Millikan, by his falling-drop technique of measurement had discovered how we can measure electron charge and so separate it from the mass of the electron.

    Early in the 20th century, therefore, and especially after the introduction of wave mechanical theory with the advent of the photon, physicists had all that was needed to decipher Nature’s messages, the subject of this work. Yet, the task has, it seems, been left to this author, whose interest was aroused when engaged on Ph.D. research in 1950-3 on the subject of anomalous energy losses found in electrical steels when reacting to oscillating magnetization. The reaction phenomena associated with magnetization of electrical conductors has an analogy with the reaction which must of necessity exist when a magnetic field acts across space devoid of matter. It was the study of that reaction that opened the door leading to the pathways we are to explore in this work.

    So how shall we proceed? Well, it seems appropriate to present at the outset a glimpse of what lies on the far horizon, the answers to our deciphering exercise. Hopefully, this will allow the reader to anticipate some of the onward steps as the theory develops and so share some of the excitement which this task arouses. There is, however, one preliminary historical feature that must be presented first. This concerns the ‘Thomson electron’.

    The Thomson Electron

    There has to be a starting point from which one can build a picture of the electrical structure of the space medium and matter which sits in that medium. The electron is the embodiment of the unit of electric charge in physical theory. It is the appropriate foundation for our exploration of the electrical properties of the medium that pervades all space, it being well established that the vacuum medium has properties by which it can store electrical energy.

    The reader well versed in modern physics will now wonder how one can possibly justify the need to refer to this space medium in terms which seek to revive what amounts to the old-fashioned notion of the aether. After all, every physicist today is indoctrinated in the belief that space is a four-dimensional medium referred to as ‘space-time’ and subject to the relativistic principles which Albert Einstein introduced between 1905 and 1916. E=Mc² is taken as a sufficient testimonial in proof of Einstein’s theory and no one can argue with the experimental evidence which gave birth to the atomic bomb.

    “With Einstein’s work, the old substantial aether vanished from higher physics. In spite of the internal difficulties which had dogged it, it was long mourned by the older school of physicists, who found the reasoning of Einstein perilous – and hard to follow.”

    — from p. 287 of ‘Science since 1500′ by H. T. Pledge, a 1939 Ministry of Education publication then available from the U.K. Stationery Office

    Well, it is this author’s submission that it is due time for the younger physicists of today to visit the graveyard where the aether was put to rest and consider its reincarnation. That visit takes us back to the year 1904, one year before Einstein launched his theory. In that year 1904 a book entitled ‘The Recent Development of Physical Science’ was published in its second edition. Its author was W. C. D. Whetham, a Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge and so a close associate of J. J. Thomson, the discoverer of the electron, who had entered Trinity College in 1876 at the age of 20 and who remained there for another sixty-four years, becoming Master of Trinity College from 1919 to his death in 1940.

    In now quoting a section of text from that 1904 book, one can see that it gives basis for one to wonder why our modern generation is so impressed by Einstein’s E=Mc² contribution. This is a quotation from pages 283-284 of Whetham’s book, which include the table below:

    “The property of mass, the most fundamental property of matter for dynamical science, is explained by the electron theory as an effect of electricity in motion. Forasmuch as a moving charge carries its lines of electric force with it, it possesses something analogous to inertia in virtue of its motion. The quantitative value of this effect has been calculated by Thomson, Heaviside and Searle. Definite experimental evidence has been given by Kaufmann, who finds that the ratio e/m of the charge to mass of the corpuscles ejected by radium diminishes as their velocity increases. The charge is almost certainly constant, and thus the mass must increase with velocity. Theory shows that, for a slowly moving corpuscle, the electric inertia outside a small sphere of radius a, surrounding the electrified particle, does not depend upon the velocity, and is measured by 2e²/3a where e is the electric charge on the particle. But when the velocity of light is approached, the electric mass grows very rapidly; and, on the assumption that the whole of the mass is electrical, Thomson has calculated the ratio of the mass of the corpuscle moving with different speeds to the mass of a slowly moving corpuscle, and compared with the results of Kaufmann’s experiments.

    In this remarkable manner has it been possible to obtain experimental confirmation of the theory that mass is an electrical phenomenon.”

    velocity in cm/s calculated mass ratio observed mass ratio
    2.36 x 1010 1.65 1.5
    2.48 x 1010 1.83 1.66
    2.59 x 1010 2.04 2.0
    2.72 x 1010 2.43 2.42
    2.85 x 1010 3.09 3.1

    That is a commentary on the state of knowledge of the electron in the year 1904 but that knowledge seems not to have been heeded by future generations of physicists. Today, if you refer to the tables of physical constants, you will find that the electron radius is not formulated according to the above formula, but rather as something that is 50% greater, a notional parameter that has no physical meaning as justified by theory that explains why the radius expressed in relation to mass, electric charge and the speed of light should have that particular value.

    However, that energy quantity 2e²/3a is the true measure of the electric energy of an electron of radius a and students of physics should see it as important and know how to derive this formula themselves. Just assume that the charge e is confined within a sphere of radius a. Take note that the speed of light c is also the ratio of electrostatic to electromagnetic units in the cgs system. Then assume the charge is moving in a straight line at velocity v so that it defines a current circuit element of strength ev/c and formulate the strength of the magnetic field produced by that circuit element at points distant from the charge. From that work out the magnetic field energy density at such a point and then integrate that energy over all space external to that charge sphere. You will obtain the formula (ev/c)²/3a. Now equate that to kinetic energy mv²/2 and the result will be that mc² is 2e²/3a.

    This was, no doubt, the manner in which this result was obtained in that 1904 report, but there is another quite simple derivation that has more merit. Take note that the electric energy of a sphere of charge e and radius a, having all of its charge at the surface of that sphere, as if it were of conductive material, is e²/2a, but if we do not make that assumption and simply declare that the charge e is actually distributed within that sphere of radius a so as to have uniform electric energy density or pressure inside that sphere that equals the energy density just outside the boundary radius a, then it is easily proved that the component of electric energy inside the sphere is e²/6a. Add that to the energy outside the radius a and one obtains 2e²/3a.

    This is surely the energy of the electron that accounts for its inertial property. It is the formula referred to in this work by reference to the ‘Thomson electron’. It is equal to the mass of the electron as multiplied by the square of the speed of light, as you have just seen, and yet physicists see E=Mc² as something we owe to Albert Einstein’s theory of relativity that came along after 1904.

    As to the so-called ‘relativistic mass increase’ that one also attributes to Einstein’s philosophy, was this not explained in that 1904 text in deriving the data for that table presented above? The gain in energy with speed adds inertial mass and, if whoever computed that data did not use the formula E=Mc², it becomes an interesting exercise to discover how, given the measured electron speeds, the increase of mass factor could have been calculated.

    The known speed of light in 1904 was much the same as it is today, very nearly 3×1010 cm/s, and using the formula for mass increase that one derives from electron theory, the same as that later obtained by Einstein’s methods, one sees, using this speed of light value, that an observed mass increase by the factor 3.1 corresponds to an electron speed of 2.84×1010 cm/s. The difference between this and 2.85×1010 cm/s as listed in the above table is only marginal and probably attributable to approximations in the calculation.

    In any event, the point made here is that the Thomson electron formula can be relied upon in our onward theoretical investigation. It is, however, noted that the formal derivation of E=Mc² as an expression relating the electrical energy E of a charge with its inertial mass M is possible, as this author has shown. See discussion in Appendix II. One has merely to accept that the charge, when subjected to acceleration by an electric field, will move in just such a way as to conserve its intrinsic electric field energy from being radiated.

    Based on the physics of 1904, with its aether, we can now confront those messages that pertain to Creation and we do so by using the Thomson electron formula in a quite fascinating way, as will emerge in chapter 4 when we show how the proton is created.

    Concerning a Theorem and the Aether

    19th century physicists went adrift by assuming that the aether had certain properties, notably that of providing a universal and absolute frame of reference for the constant speed of light in vacuo. They should, instead, have studied the aether with an open mind, allowing its properties to be revealed by their experiments. First and foremost is the fact that the aether can and does store energy, electrical energy, and so it must have an electrical composition.

    19th century physicists were obsessed by its properties as a medium in which electromagnetic waves propagated. They were baffled because it seemed, in one sense, to exhibit the properties of a solid medium and, in another sense, the properties of a fluid. Considered as an electrical system having structure as if it comprises electric particles formed into a kind of crystal pattern, the problem was one of stability, as was pointed out by Samuel Earnshaw, a Cambridge scientist, by presenting his famous mathematical theorem. In 1839 he read a paper before the Cambridge Philosophical Society, which was later published in their Transactions at pp. 97-114 of volume 7 of 1842. That paper was entitled: ‘On the Nature of the Molecular Forces which regulate the Constitution of the Luminiferous Ether’. Quoting from that paper one reads:

    “It is therefore certain that the medium in which luminiferous waves are transmitted to our eyes is not constituted of such particles (acted upon by purely inverse-square forces). The coincidence of numerical results, derived from a medium of such particles, with experiment, only shows that numerical results are no certain test of a theory, when limited to a few cases only.”

    So, at the very outset of the project undertaken in this work, one has it on the authority of an eminent scientist, speaking some 164 years ago, that an aether constituted by electric particles conforming with the inverse-square-of-distance force law is an impossibility on mathematical grounds, whatever our number deciphering exercise might prove.

    Earnshaw’s Theorem was a basis for rejection of early attempts by this author to secure publication in the mainstream science publications and, indeed, this was how the author first came to know that there was such a theorem.

    Why then are we proceeding with our quest? Well, there was something about this author’s perception of the aether that made that theorem helpful rather than obstructive. Earnshaw had overstated his case. If the medium contains electric charges of like polarity governed by the inverse-square law then they can arrange themselves in a stable configuration, provided they are immersed in a uniform continuum of charge of opposite polarity. Conversely, one might say, if the evidence supports an aether having a structured form composed of electric charges governed by the inverse-square law, then, with certainty, that aether must incorporate a background continuum of electric charge which envelops those charges.

    So, you see, dating from 1839, physicists seeking to understand the aether were wandering in the dark as they confronted problems of this kind and confronted an aether that had to exhibit the properties of both a fluid and a solid. The fluid crystal of modern physics with its state dependent upon electric field excitation had not been discovered and, almost as soon as the electron had been discovered and its charge and mass measured, Einstein came onto the scene and gone was all hope of salvaging the aether from the wreckage.

    This author, however, having committed so much effort into the project of understanding the aether, aether of a form that overcame Earnshaw’s theorem, could but soldier on without support from the physics community. By 1966 the author had published two works based on aether theory, both entitled ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, the first, dating from 1960, being only 48 pages in length and the second, dating from 1966, being an enlarged 170 page second edition.

    Coincidentally, in that year 1966, as the author discovered later, a book by an author named W.T. Scott appeared with the title: ‘The Physics of Electricity and Magnetism’, published by Wiley, and this included a commentary on Earnshaw’s theorem. It is relevant to mention it because Scott had also seen where the theorem fails. A passage in his book reads:

    “In a region of continuous charge distribution, a maximum or minimum could exist, but a continuous distribution is an idealization. We have to consider each electron or proton as an isolated charge, so that pure electrostatic equilibrium is impossible.”

    Earnshaw’s theorem sought to prove stability by showing how a differential equation could have a maximum or minimum but the analysis denied that possibility for the interaction of discrete electrical charges immersed in a true void. Scott had seen what this author had seen, namely that the presence of a uniformly charged background could provide that stability. However, Scott says that involves ‘an idealization’. One may answer that by saying that the aether could well be an idealization, meaning a physical medium of such ideal and simplified form that it has rather special properties not shared by matter. One may also say, given the evidence to be presented in this work, that the aether has to have that uniform background continuum of charge as a kind of sea in which the other charged particle forms are immersed and in which a stable array of such charges can exist.

    This brings us to the stage where we can begin to introduce the formulae which emerge from the deciphering of what is implied by those numerical constants and so we move on to chapter 2 and begin by exploring the factors that determine the force of gravity.

  • APPENDIX VII

    APPENDIX VII

    Einstein and 100 Years of Wisdom

    Physicists will soon be celebrating the centenary of the birth of Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity and as news of such an event reaches the general public via the media, there may be those who ask what is meant by its underlying ‘principle of relativity’.

    In Einstein’s own words it is: ‘A generalisation when we express the tenet thus: If, relative to one Galilean co-ordinate reference system, another Galilean co-ordinate reference system is a uniformly moving co-ordinate system devoid of rotation, then natural phenomena run their course with respect to the second co-ordinate system according to exactly the same general laws as with respect to the first co-ordinate system. This statement is called the principle of relativity.’

    I think I know what this means but I doubt if there are many, even of the physics community, who really care as to its meaning. After all, it adds up to saying that whatever happens in the scientific and technological arena today will, if we repeat whatever we did to make that happen, have the same result tomorrow, even though we and our Earth have moved on through the cosmic background. However, I know that there will be those of you who question this because our frame of reference, Earth, is itself rotating. So it really is impossible here on Earth to test what Einstein claims as a ‘principle’ unless we can stop the Earth from rotating. Alternatively, we could go off in a spacecraft equipped with sensors and controls that preclude any rotation. However, Einstein did not do that, nor could he 100 years ago.

    There is also scope for misunderstanding because, in a sense, Einstein’s wording is somewhat ambiguous. He refers to two frames of reference and natural phenomena, but there is doubt here as to whether the principle refers to a specific phenomenon or, rather, physical event or whether what is implied is physical phenomena in general. As an example of what I mean, consider the mechanics of a ball bouncing from a surface. The principles of motion governing that bouncing ball are, by one interpretation, the same if studied from the perspective of either reference frame. But if we think of two observers one in each of those two frames are we to understand that from their individual perspectives, looking at the same ball, their assessment of the physics governing the motion will be exactly the same?

    On this latter interpretation the principle of relativity would fail because, should the ball bounce from a surface in that second reference frame with a certain velocity relative to that surface and that frame be moving at the same velocity relative to the first reference frame, one observer would see the ball bounce and the other would see it stop on impact.

    On the first interpretation Einstein was on safe ground in postulating the so-called ‘principle’, subject to limiting conditions, because, relying on the teachings of classical mechanics and Isaac Newton, it is a direct consequence of the physical laws governing what happens in the mechanical world. Einstein was aware of this limitation, but claimed his notoriety by venturing beyond that boundary and asking us to accept the ‘principle’ without such a restriction.

    On this he declared, after saying that in regard to classical mechanics ‘there was no need to doubt the validity of this principle of relativity’: ‘in view of the more recent development of electrodynamics and optics it became more evident that classical mechanics affords an insufficient foundation for the physical interpretation of all natural phenomena. At this juncture the question of the validity of the principle of relativity became ripe for discussion, and it did not appear impossible that the answer to this question might be in the negative.’

    So, you see, here was Einstein himself weighing the validity of his ‘principle’ as a matter of probability, another word for ‘uncertainty’, owing to the physical phenomena that we encounter in electrodynamics, the motion and interaction of electric charges, rather than the physical phenomena that pertain to electrically neutral matter. A point of interest here is that electrodynamics and electromagnetic waves (light) require an electromagnetic frame of reference, whereas mechanics requires an inertial frame of reference and there is an implicit distinction between these akin to the distinction between v and dv/dt, velocity and acceleration.

    Indeed, one might ask what Einstein had in mind as a basis for that qualifying remark in the last sentence of the above quotation. He does not reveal that. Instead he moves on by declaring that ‘there are two general facts which favour the validity of the principle of relativity’. Here that word ‘favour’ has its implication, given that, in physics, one is expected to prove a proposition rather than judge its merits by speculating on chance.

    As to the first of these ‘facts’, judge for yourself whether what he declares can be regarded as fact: ‘The principle of relativity must apply with great accuracy in the domain of mechanics. But that a principle of such broad generality should hold with such exactness in one domain of phenomena, and yet should be invalid for another, is a priori not very probable.’

    That is a factual statement in a semantic sense but far from logical in a scientific context.

    As to his other ‘fact’, this is one he develops by reference to observations made from railway carriages moving relative to an embankment, a mechanical scenario, but one he sums up by saying that: ‘In virtue of its motion round the sun, our Earth is comparable with a railway carriage travelling with a velocity of about 30 kilometres per second. If the principle of relativity were not valid we should therefore expect that the direction of motion of the Earth at any moment would enter into the laws of nature.’

    Even though the theme so far was based essentially on what one could describe as mechanics, Einstein then rests his case by declaring that our observations on body Earth have never ‘revealed such anisotropic properties of terrestrial physical space’ and that ‘This is a very powerful argument in favour of the principle of relativity.’

    Now, of course, if aware of the famous experiment performed by Michelson and Morley one cannot fail to see that Einstein invented his ‘principle of relativity’ expressly as a way of justifying the observation that the speed of light reflected by mirrors is the same as the speed of light incident upon those mirrors, notwithstanding our Earth’s motion through space. However, there are amongst us those, including myself, who cannot accept the way in which Einstein brushes aside that reference to electrodynamics. The reason is very simple.

    It amounts to saying that we do not belong to a non-rotating world to which that principle enunciated by Einstein applies but recognizing that, as with that space craft or even in an Earth laboratory for the brief period needed for the test, we could create a non-rotating test laboratory in which to prove or disprove Einstein’s principle of relativity.

    On such a basis, that of electrodynamic interaction between electric charge in motion, one surely needs to challenge Einstein’s doctrine. I tried some 50 years ago, half a century after the birth of Einstein’s theory, only to be ignored but yet emerge from the fray with the knowledge on which this work is based. The physics community is not open to persuasion on this issue, possibly because no one is willing to pass judgement on a subject that they do not understand but assume is understood by their peers and so they stay aloof in their ignorance.

    That said, I will now explain why I have been motivated to write this Appendix to ‘The Physics of Creation’. Its first draft edition was completed in April 2003. It was shortly thereafter that I received a letter dated 15 May 2003 from a stranger to me, a person named S. I. Wells having an address in California, who explained that he had referenced a paper of mine in his own paper entitled ‘Magnetic Interaction Reconsidered’, that he had submitted to the American Journal of Physics for publication. It was rejected but the referee comments had implied that the latter portion of the paper posed a ‘puzzle’ that warranted publication and so resubmission was encouraged. In the event this latter submission was then rejected without consideration on the grounds that ‘we no longer have a Questions & Answers section and thus will not be accepting your manuscript for publication’.

    Now, to me, this is, as they say, ‘par for the course’ – thou shalt not challenge Einstein! So, what was it that Wells had offered for publication? It was brief but concise. After pointing out that special relativity was developed to preserve the equations of electrodynamics in all inertial frames, which makes it imperative that the principle of relativity applies in all possible situations, Wells draws attention to a ‘seeming paradox’. He refers to two equal and like polarity electric charges separated by a straight, rigid and insulated rod, when viewed (a) in the rest frame of the rod and (b) in and relative to a laboratory frame which is in uniform relative motion in any direction neither parallel nor perpendicular to the rod. Every physicist should be sufficiently familiar with standard theory governing how charge in motion produces a magnetic field and how that field exerts force on another moving charge, which means that he or she can easily verify that an observer in that rest frame will see that rod at rest, whereas an observer in that moving laboratory frame will see the same rod as subject to a torque which will cause it to turn to alter its orientation in space.

    So, Einstein says that the rod cannot turn, but standard physics as taught universally says it will turn. Yet the American Journal of Physics, the major U.S. periodical for those who teach physics, decline to publish this observation.

    One does not have to be a genius to stumble across this crack in the theory of relativity, a system which some refer to as ‘The Einstein Myth’, but one must wonder about the integrity of our scientific world, given this situation.

    I was well aware of this paradox during my university research years over half a century ago, but my research discipline was the electrodynamics that govern the magnetic properties and energy anomalies found in steel as used in electrical power transformers. Challenging Einstein’s philosophy was not on my career agenda as a research student. Philosophy is for those who are already established and secure in their way of life.

    Yet I was intrigued in 1965 when I saw and purchased a newly published book by R. A. R. Tricker entitled ‘Early Electrodynamics’ (Published by Pergamon Press). A topic similar to that raised by Wells is mentioned in the chapter entitled ‘The Critics’ by reference to the opinions of H. G. Grassmann (1809-1877). The debate concerned Ampere’s electrodynamic force law, a law which is never used today but which, curiously enough, would still not survive the test imposed by Einstein’s principle of relativity.

    Grassmann pointed out that Ampere’s law would require the force acting between the two charges to be zero when their motion as shared by the rod was inclined at a certain angle to the rod but change from an attraction to a repulsion as the rod turns around whilst having the same translational motion in the electromagnetic frame of reference. Concerning this Tricker states: ‘For Grassmann this is too improbable to be acceptable. Grassmann can bring no experimental evidence whatever to support his view and there is not the slightest reason to suppose that nature was designed to satisfy the particular tastes of anybody.’

    So you see, here is an author who expects proof by experiment, rather than argument based on taste and probability, but somehow Einstein’s principle of relativity, which I see as unproven and as a mere philosophical notion, a matter of ‘taste’ in the sense used above, has governed the progress of energy science (retarding it!) for a century.

    How can we emerge from this dilemma? The answer amounts to saying that all verifiable and proven electrodynamic technology as harnesses in our power industry is founded on electrodynamic action by electric charges flowing around closed circuits. The electrodynamic law used involves integration of action around such closed paths. Any differences in assumptions concerning those laws can only be tested by experiments involving interaction of electric charges that exhibit properties characteristic of an isolated state that is not smeared into the action of a uniform current flow around a closed circuit.

    The dipole rod experiment implicit in the argument posed by Wells, if performed, would be such a test, but other such tests are those based on plasma discharges where the charge carriers have different charge/mass ratios and opposite charge polarity. This is the realm of energy anomalies that promise to tap energy from the space environment, as touched upon at the end of chapter 9 of this work.

    Einstein’s theory has obstructed progress in this field of technology by making it appear that all was well with our understanding of electrodynamics, whereas there are unanswered questions such as that posed by the paradox raised by Wells here in this 21st century, by me in the 20th century, as chapter 9 has shown, and by Grassmann in the 19th century. If only Einstein had conceived his principle in more general physical terms, as opposed to its restricted form! After all, a Galilean system of co-ordinates is an inertial system and one is thereby locked into the physical constraints that accompany inertia. By ‘general’ here I do not mean the extension adopted by Einstein in moving from his ‘Special Theory of Relativity’ to his ‘General Theory of Relativity’. I will reword Einstein’s statement as to the principle of relativity to show you what I mean: ‘Space is a co-ordinate reference system having the electrical properties of a fluid medium in which a kind of crystal structure can form to define such a frame of reference. That crystal structure adapts to the presence of material bodies, locking onto atomic structure, and so shares the motion of such bodies but can dissolve as necessary to merge with the fluid before re-emerging as new structure. If, relative to one such co-ordinate reference system, another such co-ordinate reference system is a uniformly moving co-ordinate system devoid of rotation, then natural phenomena run their course with respect to the second co-ordinate system according to exactly the same general laws as with respect to the first co-ordinate system, but such phenomena are governed only by the local co-ordinate system, a constraint particularly evident in electromagnetic action which takes the local co-ordinate system as its sole frame of reference.’

    My message here is that Einstein relied on the Galilean co-ordinate reference system as an inertial frame of reference but should have based his theory on a system of reference that itself had the necessary physical properties to adapt to the local presence of matter. The notion of a universal aether medium gave a physical foundation but provided only one frame of reference, whereas an aether that provides multiple frames of reference nucleated locally by the presence of matter but not overlapping is what is needed.

    After a century of stubborn adherence to Einstein’s doctrine it is unlikely that I shall, in my lifetime, see the physics community changing direction. I can but hope that what I now see as an ongoing quest to tap energy from the aether itself will trigger the reversal of opinion. As it is, however, I can but repeat the quotation that I presented on page 1 of my first publication on this subject, ‘The Theory Gravitation’, 1960. It was from pages 387–388 of a 1913 book by N. R. Campbell entitled: ‘Modern Electrical Theory’ (Cambridge University Press): “If we speak of ‘aethers’ and not ‘the aether’ all our experiments prove is that the particular aether with which we are concerned in any case is that which is at rest relatively to the source and may be regarded as forming part of it. This is the simple way out of the difficulties posed by the Michelson-Morley experiment. If from the beginning we had used a plural instead of a singular word to denote the (aether) system …. those difficulties would never have appeared. There has never been a better example of the danger of being deceived by an arbitrary choice of terminology. However, physicists, not recognizing the gratuitous assumptions made in the use of the words ‘the aether’, adopted the second alternative; they introduced new assumptions.”

    Having read these words, back in the year 1945, as a young university student, I was in no mood to be persuaded in Einstein’s favour and, from then on could but study Einstein’s theory with a critical eye and a desire to search for the truth as there to be found in the omnipresent aether. I was lucky to see a picture of the aether emerge as secondary spin-off from my theoretical efforts to understand the ferromagnetic properties of the atomic structure of iron. This book and its forerunners duly emerged and now, save for the point I make below, there is little more I can add. I hope a few readers will share my thoughts as we live through the Einstein centenary.

    That ‘point’ is a reference to Einstein’s technique of ‘transformation’, his theory not being one involving a simple and direct logical interpretation of his so-called ‘principle of relativity’. It seems that when looking at physical phenomena occurring in one Galilean co-ordinate frame whilst sitting in another such frame, albeit moving uniformly and without rotation relative to the first, one must put on a pair of spectacles having a special prescription. This is necessary in order to distort what one sees to make it conform by looking the same as it would in that first frame whereas in fact it is actually different. That prescription is expressed in mathematical four-dimensional terms, obliging one to perceive the time dimension as a fourth space dimension, a curious notion and best avoided, given that we seek the truths of the real world and not a fantasy world that is mere illusion. Reverting to that problem posed by Wells, as mentioned above, it could well be that a ‘relativist’ wearing those spectacles formulated according to the mathematics of the Lorentz transformation might be able to avoid thinking there is any torque effect upon that electric dipole, but after close to 100 years one can but gasp and ask: “Oh Lord, why have we allowed Einstein to distort our vision of the aether of your Creation?’

  • Appendix VI: The Hypotheses of Fechner and Einstein

    Appendix VI: The Hypotheses of Fechner and Einstein

    Readers will not be surprised to hear that upon reading through what I have written in this book about Creation, there are a couple of after-thoughts that warrant mention. Those who believe Einstein’s theory will, no doubt, assume that my theory cannot explain the evidence of record deemed to support Einstein’s hypothesis concerning ‘time dilation’. Then there will be those who are a little bewildered by my reliance on Fechner’s hypothesis to explain the electrodynamic action of electric current flow as arising from pairs of oppositely charged particles created in spaced relationship and then annihilating one another upon coming together by moving in opposite directions.

    Surprising though it may seem, there is scope for challenging Fechner’s hypothesis constructively and thereby overcoming a problem that it poses, but in so doing one finds that the experimental evidence relied upon as proving ‘time dilation’ may become instead proof that supports the theory presented in this work.

    There is only one reported type of experiment which purports to support Einstein’s ‘time dilation’ hypothesis. This is that indicating the enhanced lifetime of the muon as a function of its speed. I discount the idea that time dilation is inherent in Einstein’s conception of distorted space as a valid means for explaining the null result of the Michelson-Morley experiment as already discussed in chapter 9. Also one can dismiss the evidence arising from an experiment which involves transporting an atomic clock in an aircraft flying around the world to see if it loses time or gains time relative to an atomic clock sitting at the base location. Here the question one faces is whether speed or acceleration or both, being different for the flying clock and that at rest on body Earth, will affect the clock rate. You see, we are not here discussing time as such but are discussing an atom, meaning the change of energy states of electrons in motion around the atomic nucleus and this involves photons, the frequency of which depends upon energy, not time. The atomic clock rate is affected by change of gravitational potential and so altitude. It confuses the issue to imagine atomic clock rates as changing owing to so-called ‘time dilation’. See the Section IV, ‘Times Rates of Moving Clocks’ of my paper: ‘Synchronous Lattice Electrodynamics as an Alternative to Time Dilation, (Hadronic Journal, 10, 185–192; 1987). It is included as the fifth paper of the Appendix in my book Aether Science Papers.

    Now I must digress just a little before coming to the detail of the theory of dilated muon lifetime, as I now perceive it in the light of the derivation of the muon rest-mass lifetime, as presented in chapter 3 of this work.

    Imagine a lamp that runs on electricity from an electrically charged cell, a battery. It has a certain illumination lifetime, its light going out once the electric charge from that battery is all shed. Now imagine that the lamp is taken on a long journey accompanied by lots of charged cells. The lamp will glow for a longer period proportional to the number of cells and their total electric charge. Now, if you assembled such a device and observed the enhanced illumination lifetime of that travelling lamp, I believe you would think it a joke if someone said to you: “Ah yes, here is the evidence I have been seeking concerning Einstein’s theory. You have proved that Einstein was right when he conceived the notion of ‘time dilation’. Time itself really does alter its rhythm and extend itself, the faster the speed of the object under observation.”

    However, the comment may not seem quite so ridiculous if what you were observing was something rather elusive as seen in the microcosmic world within a high energy particle accelerator at CERN in Geneva, Switzerland. Physicists probing the darkness of the unknown by getting fundamental particles to move at very high speeds are more closely tuned to think in terms of Einstein’s theory than theory at the basic electrician level, and so, upon seeing something that lives longer, as its speed approaches that of light, Einstein’s time dilation formula comes immediately to mind.

    What they saw in that accelerator was a system comprising many muons, a muon being a charged electric particle that, apart from its much greater mass, has features resembling the electron, but those physicists had no idea why those muons had a fleeting existence as, once created, they survive for a brief period only and then all that is left is electrons, albeit moving at high speed owing to the energy shed by the parent muon. It is a great mystery as to how the muon comes into existence and the best reason I can offer is that it already exists everywhere in space and reveals itself as matter only when it (a) takes up position in the dynamic aether lattice and shares the rhythmic motion of that lattice rather than having the random motion in the aether underworld and (b) somehow attracts and becomes attached to two electrons or positrons and adjusts its resonant state in the manner I have described in my paper: The Muon g-Factor by Cavity Resonance Theory, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 39, 271 (1984). In saying it exists everywhere I am merely echoing the message of chapter 3 entitled ‘The Ubiquitous Muon’. However, as to the electron itself, you may wonder how that is created. We have seen in chapter 4 the theory explaining how the proton is created from muons and we know from experiment that muons in matter form can decay into electrons or positrons, but surely that might only mean that the muon has shed its hangers-on. We are left with the puzzle of how, in theory, electrons are created. Well, I cannot answer that, except for noting that our theory in chapter 6 has explained how the photon is created in a space medium that has a characteristic frequency, that universal rhythm of space that leads us to the dynamics of gravitation by connecting the mass of matter with the gravitons. Surely the fact that a photon having that characteristic frequency defines an energy quantum which is precisely that of the electron rest-mass, is the clue by which to solve the puzzle. One is merely left with a chicken-and-egg type of problem, as to whether the electrons are created ab initio and somehow then regulate the oscillations of the underworld of space or whether the universal oscillations and ordered structure of space set in first and so determine the form of the electron.

    Here we will confine our attention to the question of the muon and its extended lifetime at speed as determined by those experiments at CERN. Yes, indeed, particle physicists could measure the lifetime of the muon just as an electrician can time the illumination of that lamp mentioned above, and they even found that, the faster the muon travelled, the greater its lifetime in proportion to its overall energy, including its rest-mass energy. Yet somehow they missed seeing how, just as for that lamp, the muon in motion needs an entourage of energy cells which is greater in number, the greater that speed.

    They were well aware that Einstein had, some 65 years earlier, supposed that the dimension of time is woven into the fabric of space, a fabric which can be stretched and twisted, with the result that space can be curved (whatever that means in non-mathematical terms) and time can be dilated (whatever that means in non-mathematical terms). So, when the muon at speed was found by experiment to have a longer lifetime, one proportional to its increase in energy, that was said to be ‘proof’ that Einstein’s theory was right. Quoting the very words used at page 62 in the paper by Bailey and Picasso (Progress in Nuclear Physics, v. 12, Part 1, pp. 43–75; 1970):

    ‘To conclude, the CERN Muon Storage Ring group has proved that the “clock paradox” is established as an experimental fact (at the level of approximately 1.2%).’

    Well, enough of this, the task here, after some further 33 years from the publication of that paper, is to explain the extension of muon lifetime to those of you who prefer to live in the same three-space dimensional world as those of pre-Einstein times.

    The Muon Lifetime at Rest and in Motion

    Firstly, you must understand what governs the lifetime of the muon at rest. As we saw in the latter part of chapter 3 it was determined by the simultaneous hit of the two electrons or positrons (those hangers-on to the muon in its matter form) by two virtual muons from the aether background medium. Secondly, you must understand that when that muon moves it acquires kinetic energy which takes the form of an accompaniment of muon charge pairs borrowed as needed from that aether background medium. Their presence is transient and regulated by statistical factors subject to the overriding control parameter, the energy momentum of the system. In a sense the muon, being a lepton, can be part of a charge system in which pairs of opposite charges are constantly being created in the forward field followed by their decay, but ever subject to the need to preserve energy. Inevitably, however, the ultimate decay event occurs and the muon suffers demise as its energy disperses with the creation of a residual electron or positron.

    Core Mass and Virtual Muons

    A point of importance here is that the muon that we see as matter has somehow been conditioned to have a core mass that is an odd integer multiple, 207, times that of the electron, whereas by its coupling with two electrons or positrons it adds a mass of two electron units as offset by approximately 2.25 such units owing to the negative electrostatic interaction energy of this combination. [See the author’s paper: ‘The Nature of the Muon’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 37, 210 (1983)]. In contrast the virtual muons that become associated in pairs and add kinetic energy to the muon when it moves at speed have a mass-energy that is 206.3329 units of electron rest-mass energy. So, there are two kinds of core muons present, the primary µ−207 form and the virtual µ−206.33 form.

    Decay Mechanism and Virtual Muon Hits

    The muon lifetime is determined by virtual muon hits arising from the quantum electrodynamic fluctuations of the energy represented by the ‘ubiquitous’ muon field. A single virtual muon hit of a target electron or positron, which occurs some 107 more often than a dual muon hit, will merely rupture the composite three-charge muon in a transient sense and cause the electron or positron pair to resettle with a muon. However, there can be charge inversion in this process, by which it is meant that a positive muon and an electron in contact can exchange energy to become a negative muon and a positron. In any event there is an equal chance of the resettling electrons or positrons adopting any one of the residual muons as the core muon, whether it be a muon of the 207 form or one of the 206.33 form.

    Decay and Recycle

    The result of this is that when the eventual dual hit occurs, if that event is for a composite muon form having the 207 muon as a core then that means muon decay, but, if that dual hit has as target the composite muon with a 206.33 muon core, then that merely frees a virtual muon which can find a partner in the virtual muon field and recycle its existence as part of the quantum-electrodynamic activity. The 207 muon is the misfit and it cannot survive this event and so combines with one of its associated electrons or positrons to decay and shed energy to the aether, the neutrino process, whilst freeing the other electron or positron which takes with it its substantial share of the energy released as the decay product of the muon.

    Statistical Inverse Proportionality and Lifetime Extension

    One can then understand why it is that the chance of muon decay in relation to the decay lifetime of its rest-mass state is diminished in inverse proportion to the ratio of overall energy to muon rest-mass energy. This latter ratio is the total statistical number of those muons, virtual plus primary, to the primary muon component. This is why the CERN experiment involving many thousands of muons moving at speeds which increased their mass more than twenty fold did reveal evidence of the so-called time dilation of the muon. All that the experiment proved was that the ‘genie in the lamp’ was spreading its influence equally amongst all the energy components of the system, thereby sustaining their energy state for a longer period in proportion to the energy present.

    Relativistic Mass and Electron Analogy

    The above discussion has concerned the muon and attributed its kinetic energy to its accompaniment in motion by the statistical presence of virtual muon pairs. The so-called relativistic mass increase of the muon arises from the mass added by the presence of those virtual muons. The electron, therefore, ought to conform in the same way, by having an induced electron-positron accompaniment and one can assume that it too would have an extended lifetime at high speed, matching its increased energy, if such a lifetime were to be recognized as something we can measure. Apart from the inference to be drawn from electron tunnelling through potential barriers, however, the electron’s lifetime is elusive, because the decay does nothing other than recreate the lowest form of matter, the electron.

    Current Flow and Fechner’s Hypothesis

    The question of interest then is whether the electron moving as a carrier of electric current is accompanied solely by other electrons or whether they share the task of conveying current with a flow of positrons moving in the opposite direction. This brings us to that problem posed by Fechner’s hypothesis. I know it is easy to say that the electrons will annihilate the positrons but it is equally easy to say that, if the current circuit element they represent is suddenly switched off, so electromagnetic inductance will respond to set up a pulse of EMF which creates another such current element by a quantum-electrodynamic process involving electron-positron creation. Such a debate can lead nowhere, but there is an interesting history pertaining to this problem, albeit going back many years before the electron was discovered by J. J. Thomson.

    One may refer to pages 201 to 208 of volume 1 of a book written by Sir Edmund Whittaker entitled: History of the Theories of aether and Electricity, published by Thomas Nelson and Son Ltd in 1951. After referring to Fechner (1845) and a similar hypothesis posed by Weber (1846) and then discussing these in some depth, Whittaker on page 206 states:

    “It has been shown (reference to H. Lorberg, Journal f. Math. lxxiv, p. 305; 1878), indeed, that the assumption of opposite electricities moving with equal and opposite velocities in a circuit is almost inevitable in any theory of the type of Weber’s, so long as the mutual action of two charges is assumed to depend only upon their relative (as opposed to their absolute) motion.”

    Revisiting Fechner’s Hypothesis

    Now, here I must confess that, even up to the stage where I had written chapter 9 of this book, being well satisfied at having derived the relative velocity formula from first principle analysis by starting from time differentiation of energy according to Coulomb’s law [equation (9.2)], I was content to move on by relying on the assumption just mentioned (Fechner’s hypothesis) to come to the derivation of the Neumann Potential. This was a logical step given my knowledge of what Sir Edmund Whittaker had written. Also I can see that I may have brushed over an important issue by talking about electron-positron pairs or muon pairs having a ‘statistical’ presence in accounting for kinetic energy. For some reason, however, while relaxing on vacation after having compiled the first draft of this book The Physics of Creation, I began to wonder about the Fechner hypothesis and what the analysis would reveal if those two ‘opposite electricities’ moved with opposite velocities at different speeds.

    To my great surprise, the analysis now to be presented at the end of this Appendix proved that the same result would be obtained whatever the difference in speed magnitude of the two oppositely-charged electric particles. Indeed, one of those particles could be at rest. The essential point, however, is that, for every unit charge of one polarity in motion there has to be another unit charge of opposite polarity at rest, which assures us that the flow of electrons in a conductor can suffice to set up the Neumann Potential, provided there is an atom somewhere in that conductor that is left positively ionized by having shed that electron. Such a result challenges that conclusion above quoted by Whittaker. However, it puts in issue the very basis on which I have just explained the enhanced lifetime of the muon, given the well-known analogy between the physical properties of muons and electrons. My theory seems to require kinetic energy to be that of a neutral presence of a statistical population of leptons which share the motion of a particle. Subject to statistical constraint, a moving electron must then have its kinetic energy linked to the presence of electrons and positrons. The electrodynamic action arising from an electron discharge across a gap between an anode and an earthed cathode cannot have kinetic energy solely represented by the rest-mass energy of induced electrons as that would mean kinetic energy itself has electric charge separate from the primary charge. Enlightenment on this issue comes, however, from that derivation of the formula E = Mc2 in Appendix II. In conserving energy as it is accelerated the primary charge will necessarily contract in radius because the Thomson formula for the electron requires energy to be inversely proportional to charge radius. Collectively with the presence of numerous other such moving electrons this contraction will make space available for occupancy by electron-positron pairs created by absorbing some of that energy. However, when the energy of the electron reaches the threshold value of three times the rest-mass value, the electron can revert to its original form by creation of an electron-positron pair. Such a transition does not involve a major energy fluctuation and the notion of a ‘statistical’ presence of such charge pairs merely implies that energy is used, as it were, in climbing a staircase, two units at a time with the energy intermediate the steps being stored by contraction of the primary electron. For energy to increase with speed with net electric charge constant, such a scenario apportioning energy as between the contracted state of the primary electron and the transient presence of induced lepton charge pairs, seems essential if the muon analogy is to hold up and muon lifetime enhancement at speed is to conform with the theory already presented. This will, however, pose a question as to whether that lifetime might exhibit a pattern of change in steps corresponding to each stage of charge pair creation or decay. On the other hand one can be confident that electrons carrying current in wire conductors and having kinetic energies far below those needed to trigger electron-positron pair creation will perform as required by the Neumann Potential but the equal presence of their counterpart opposite charges, albeit non-moving, is essential.

    Experimental Conditions and Energy Distribution

    In any ongoing debate of this subject one needs to keep in mind that experimental data concerning lepton mass increase at high speed invariably concerns numerous such particles all moving together at the same speed. Under such conditions the lepton-pair created in measure related to kinetic energy can share that function amongst many primary particles, thereby reducing overall energy fluctuation to a minimum.

    Conclusion: Rejection of Time Dilation and Support for Aether Theory

    The essential point I do wish to stress is that, if muon lifetimes exhibit what has been assumed to be ‘time dilation’ and conform with the mass-increase formula, as by my theory based on the kinetic energy being vested in the existence of muon charges paired by opposite polarity, then the analogy between electrons and muons suggests that electron-positron charge pairs must feature in electron current activity. Accordingly, notwithstanding Fechner’s hypothesis having been put in doubt, I see that in exploring that problem I have strengthened my case for the derivation of the Neumann Potential based on Coulomb’s Law, not to mention the other consequence, the dismissal of Einstein’s notion of ‘time dilation’ as being irrelevant to the physics governing muon lifetime.

    Mathematical Derivation of the Neumann Potential

    The analysis mentioned above now follows. The Fechner hypothesis requires electrodynamically-interacting charges Q and q moving at velocities V and v, respectively, to be that of charges +Q and −Q, moving at velocities V/2 and −V/2, respectively, interacting with charges +q and −q, moving at velocities v/2 and −v/2, respectively. We now adopt the more general hypothesis that the interaction is between such opposite pairs of charges, moving respectively at +V1 and −V2 and at +v1 and −v2, where:

    V = V1 + V2

    v = v1 + v2

    The four components, based on the energy potential formula (9.6), now have a U2 term which has the value:

    (V1 − v1)2 − (V1 + v2)2 − (−V2 − v1)2 + (−V2 + v1)2

    which reduces, in magnitude, to:

    2[(V1.v1) + (V1.v2) + (V2.v1) + (V2.v1)]

    which, in turn, contracts to:

    2(V1 + V2).(v1 + v2) = 2(V.v)

    This is precisely the expression obtained by analysis based on the Fechner hypothesis, leading to the force term (9.8):

    2Qq(V.v)/R2c2

    which, as a negative quantity, becomes a positive energy potential when integrated with respect to R from R to infinity. This energy potential is:

    2Qq(V.v)/Rc2

    which, as before, is double the Neumann Potential, again bringing into focus the need to accept that the field medium of the aether reacts diamagnetically to halve magnetic action, thereby giving physical foundation for the gyromagnetic anomaly factor of 2.

  • Appendix V

    Appendix V

    The Angular Momentum of the Solar System

    In the following table the parameters from which the angular momenta of the planets can be estimated are listed. To simplify the data the planetary orbits are deemed to be circular. The data are in Earth units, the mass, orbital radius and annual rate of revolution in orbit being taken as reference. The sun, with an estimated angular momentum, is included to facilitate summation. All the angular momenta are in the same direction as all planets rotate on the same sense as the sun rotates about its axis.

    Body Mass Orbit Years per Angular
    Sun 332800 —— —– 20 approx.
    Mercury 0.05 0.387 0.24 0.03
    Venus 0.82 0.723 0.62 0.69
    Earth 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
    Mars 0.11 1.52 1.88 0.135
    Jupiter 317.8 5.20 11.86 724.6
    Saturn 95.2 9.54 29.46 294.1
    Uranus 14.5 19.18 84.01 63.5
    Neptune 17.2 30.07 165 94.3
    Pluto 0.11 39.44 248 0.69

    The total angular momentum of the solar system may be estimated by summing the last column. It is found to be about 1200 Earth units. The Earth mass is approximately 6.0×1027 gm and the Earth’s orbital radius is approximately 1.5×1013 cm. The Earth rotates in orbit through 2π radians in a year comprising 3.15×107 seconds. Thus one Earth unit of angular momentum is 2.7×1047 gm cm2/s. 1200 such units makes the total angular momentum (AM) of the solar system some 3.2×1050 gm cm2/s.

    If ω denotes the angular velocity of the sun at creation when its mass M was no doubt very much the same as its present value of 1.989×1033 gm and its radius R little different from its present value of 6.96×1010 cm, then based on its mass density being uniform, as has been deduced by reference to Appendix IV, then:

    (AM) = 2MR²ω/5

    and:

    ω = 8.3×10-5 rad/s

    This is an empirical value based on data found by observation and measurement of our solar system. The fascinating achievement of the theory discussed in this work by reference to aether spin and Appendix IV is the value of ω indicated by equation (8.13) in chapter 8:

    ω = ρm (4πG/ρo)½

    which, since the term in brackets is known to be 5.39×10-5 rad/sec per gm/cc and since the mass density of the sun is 1.41 gm/cc, tells us, by theory alone, that the angular velocity of the sun’s aether at creation was 7.6×10-5 rad/s. This differs by less than 10% as a comparison between theory as applied to an event billions of years ago when the sun was created and the evidence before us today from the data we have about the solar system. A little speculation might then suggest that, since we have shown in chapter 8 why the sun’s aether has to have a greater radius than the sun itself, the sun’s aether at creation was locked into sharing the angular spin velocity of the sun itself, but this came about before the sun had acquired its full inflow of mass and angular momentum. In then spinning faster than the G1/2 factor times 1.41 gm/cc allowed, the sun ceased to share its aether spin angular velocity and, lost all chance of recovering that spin-lock, once it traversed a space domain boundary and shed its planets. I am, of course, in these final words indulging here in speculation, but my object is to tempt readers to find better answers, all in the onward pursuit for truth in our research into Mother Nature’s realm of Creation.

    Aspiring students of cosmology might be interested in working out how stars cluster over time so that there can be several sharing a space domain, whereas over large expanses of space between galaxies there will be many space domains unoccupied by stars. One could conceive of two stars created with much the same mass as the sun, but yet are not created as a binary pair, moving under gravity in a common space domain and so being drawn together, either to form a new star of double the sun’s mass or settling into a stable dynamic system and forming such a binary star combination. With that and the fact that the above equation for ω does not depend upon stellar mass in mind, such a student might have his or her curiosity aroused upon reading the passage I now quote from P. M. S. Blackett’s article in Nature, 159, 658-688 (1947):

    “From statistical evidence on stars of similar type the probable values of these quantities (stellar mass, radius and angular velocity of rotation) in terms of the values for the sun are found to be: M = 2.3 R = 2.0 ω = 25.”

    The message I read in that ω factor 25 is that most stars have escaped the experience of giving birth to planets. Maybe at creation they acquired more linear motion than did our sun and so they traversed their first and subsequent space boundary encounters at a much higher speed, so that gravitational upheaval during transit had insufficient effect.

    That figure of 25, as referenced on our sun, clearly says that most stars of the same type as our sun exhibit a rotational speed of approximately once per day, given that the sun rotates once every 25 days. Our Earth’s once per day rate of rotation corresponds to an angular velocity of 7.27×10-5 rad/s.

    Is it not then quite fascinating to find that our theory for the creation of a star, as based only on our analysis of aether structure plus what we know about the hydrogen atom, tells us that stars at creation spin at 7.6×10-5 rad/s? Such analysis does not depend upon space domain size, though the latter, given that speed of rotation, does determine the mass of the star.

  • Appendix IV

    Appendix IV

    Hydrogen as a Star

    Stars are ionized. They comprise hydrogen atoms. They have sufficient mass for the force of gravity to squeeze those atoms close together. Their K-level electrons then crash into the electrons of adjacent atoms and so sustain the ionization. As a result the nucleus of the hydrogen atom, the proton, the seat of most of the mass present, can come free and be pulled inwards towards the centre of the star owing to gravity. The result is equilibrium when the electrostatic repulsion of the many protons involved balances the mutual gravitational attraction, not of those protons, but of the full atomic composition of the star that lies within the pressure threshold set by the critical contact between those electrons in the K-level of the atomic structure.

    The radius of the K-level electron orbits in hydrogen is known to be 5.292×10-9 cm and so, once the pressure reduces the distance between the nuclei of the adjacent hydrogen atoms to 1.0584×10-9 cm, then one can expect the ionization state, as produced by gravitational action and so the dynamic activity of the aether which accounts for that action, to develop in such a way as to give basis for the following formula relating charge density σs and mass density ρm in the star:

    σs = ρm (G)½

    This is equation (8.12) in chapter 8. Our object here in this Appendix IV is to determine that mass density for hydrogen atoms having contact between their K-level electron orbits. For a simple cubic array of such atoms there is one hydrogen atom in every unit volume defined by the cube of that distance 1.0584×10-9 cm and, since a hydrogen atom has a mass of 1.67×10-24 gm, this corresponds to a mass density of 1.41 gm/cc. This happens to be the mean mass density of the Sun.

    However, we need to justify that simple cubic structure, because most physicists will suggest that some close packing of the kind known to crystallographers will be more likely. To answer this I draw attention to the fact that our analysis of aether structure has already relied on a simple cubic structure of those quons that form the E frame of the aether. The reason there was that the quons repelled one another and sought to be as far apart as possible. The same could apply to hydrogen atoms squeezed close together, because each of those protons sitting at the atom’s centre is screened by a single electron. This means that the protons, though 100% screened electrostatically, on average, will sporadically be exposed in the sense that they will, as it were, see the charge of the adjacent protons. In finding the optimum ‘crystal’ structure they will, like the quons in the aether, then opt for the simple cubic array.

    That is my case in support of the argument that hydrogen stars will have a mean mass density of 1.41 gm/cc and the one star we can be sure about in determining its mass density is our sun, which has exactly that mass density of 1.41 gm/cc.

  • Appendix III

    Appendix III

    The Electron’s Anomalous Magnetic Moment

    This Appendix is a slightly edited version of a chapter entitled ‘An Excursion in Quantum Electrodynamics’ which appears in my book: ‘Aether Science Papers’ published in 1996.

    The starting point in the whole of my research has been the subject of electrodynamics and its energy anomalies, by which I mean the experimental anomalies and not the paradoxical notions that beset the theory of the subject.

    I have found repeatedly, from my attempts to write about such matters, that referees of physics journals delight in pointing to the success of quantum electrodynamics in explaining the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron. They claim such precision in their calculations that is so overwhelming that surely only a fool would dare to think that, by contemplating an aether, there may be a better and easier way of going about that task.

    So, having discovered the easy alternative, I delved into that wonderful world of QED to see how its magic derived a theoretical value for the g/2 factor of the electron which measurement shows as being 1.001159652193(10). This is the value adopted in consultation with the CODATA Task Group in 1986 and as made available to scientists in U.K. by a pocket chart published by The Royal Society jointly with other learned bodies. The numerical value just quoted is stated to be the magnetic moment of the electron in terms of the Bohr magneton.

    The Spectacular Success of QED

    I saw that a book entitled ‘Introduction to Gauge Field Theory’ had been authored by Bailin and Love and published in 1986 under the auspices of the Institute of Physics in U.K. and that the promotion literature specifically declared that it provided ‘a detailed treatment of quantum electrodynamics’. I bought that book with the express purpose of seeing exactly how those who really understand QED actually obtain the wonderfully precise number that one understands fits so well with the value measured.

    In a browsing mood, I first opened the book on page 214 and was pleased to see that chapter 14 began with the words: “The spectacular success of quantum electrodynamics (QED) in calculating the Lamb shift and the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron and the muon …”. Yes, that statement meant that what I was looking for would be found in the earlier chapters of the book. After all, here was a book on that very subject.

    I found the relevant section heading on page 140: ‘The electron anomalous magnetic moment’. The opening words were: “In this section, we specialise to the case of QED (Abelian gauge theory) and derive the electron anomalous magnetic moment. For convenience we shall work in the Feynman gauge…” I was expecting then to see the analysis develop to the derivation of something very close to that 1.001159652193(10) number recited above, but, to my horror, the derivation ended on page 142 with the words:

    “Thus the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron µAMM is: µAMM = (α/2π)(e/2m).”

    Alpha, α, is a fundamental constant in atomic physics, the fine-structure constant. I knew that this was only the first-order determination, being the reciprocal of α/2π(137.036), which is 0.0011614. Evidently the ‘spectacular success’ was not something I could verify by guidance from that book. I was expected to accept that QED was a ‘spectacular success’ but it was something I had to take on trust without knowing what assumptions were made in the onward iterations of the calculation.

    QED and the Engineer’s Perspective

    The book was, of course, full of equations, each one following the other and so conveying the impression of being ‘a tight logical structure’ but when the crunch came and a numerical result should have emerged I had to be satisfied with the above first-order approximation formula.

    From my academic background in engineering I had always judged the result of a ‘tight logical structure’ on the end result, by comparing the numerical value derived with that observed as an actual experimental result.

    I am now going to make the outrageous statement that QED is so powerful a technique that it is like taking a power-driven sledgehammer to crack a nut. There just has to be an easier way to explain how Nature determines that anomalous magnetic moment!

    Back-of-the-Envelope Analysis

    A back-of-an-envelope type of calculation can do better than that QED result presented in the book by Bailin and Love. All that is meant by the anomaly of the electron magnetic moment is that the antics of an electron in motion cannot bring to bear the electric energy in the far field zone fast enough to affect its inertia when in orbit having a very restricted radius. There is a cut-off range connected with the electron’s Compton wavelength and only the electric field energy within that range contributes to the electron’s inertia in its state of minor orbital motion.

    This may be an engineer’s way of looking at the problem, but it is a realistic approach.

    If what I have said above about the moving atom and its problems in collecting energy spread over its electromagnetic field is ‘phantasy’, then so the world of QED is phantasy of an extreme kind, because that goes even further by involving us in the problems of photon-electron interactions and something called ‘normalization’ to avoid infinities but which amounts to the ‘cut-off’ range just mentioned.

    My Alternative Formula

    So, I sit, in my aging years, watching the world of physics evolve its ‘tight logical structure’ and wonder if that world will ever look up my paper, ‘Fundamental Constants derived from Two-Dimensional Harmonic Oscillations in an Electrically-Structured Vacuum’, Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 9, 315–323 (1986). That paper shows, in a few pages, how the electron’s g/2-factor can be explained with at least the same precision that is claimed for QED.

    The formula is:

    g/2 = 1 + α / [2π (1+31/2/Ν) − α]

    Here, N is determined as the nearest prime number to the value 3π/2α. Since α-1 is just a little above 137, N is 647. The table below is reproduced from that referenced paper to show how g/2 depends upon the value of α-1.

    (alpha)-1 (g/2) factor
    137.03597 1.001159652365
    137.03598 1.001159652280
    137.03599 1.001159652195

    Now, that paper of mine was received by the publishing journal in November 1985 and at that time I, the author, was completely unaware of the prospect that the CODATA values to be adopted later in 1986 would establish 1.001159652193(10) as the g/2-factor of the electron. Nor did I imagine that the α-1 value adopted would be 137.0359895(61).

    What must then be absolutely clear to anyone reading this is the fact that if QED is a ‘spectacularly successful’ theory because it provides something very close to this relationship between the fine-structure constant and the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, then it cannot be any closer than the value derived above using my very simple formula with N as 647.

    Comparison with QED

    What I offer, however, is a ‘back-of-the-envelope’ type of analysis for deducing that formula, whereas the eighth-order calculation based on numerous, indeed thousands of, Feynman diagrams as well as arbitrary hadronic involvements, as needed to get a close QED value, is a task that could well keep the reader fully occupied for several years. That assumes the reader has very advanced skills in the relevant mathematics, skills far in excess of the school-level training which suffices to understand my method.

    The Compton Frequency and Electron Resonance

    As is well known, the electron exhibits a characteristic wave frequency, νc, which is the Compton electron frequency. This is the frequency of the photon corresponding to the mass-energy of an electron at rest. Now, although Einstein may have said that the idea that something can be at ‘rest’ is meaningless, I do not accept that. You see, it is a question of deciding whether each electron in the universe is a law unto itself so far as external governing influences are concerned, or whether it is regulated by external influence. I can assure you that that Compton electron frequency is a universal regulating rhythm that beats the time and all electrons have to dance to that time. They are not free to wander, each having its own proper time, much as Einstein might have wished that to be the case! If you have read in books about ‘time’ that there is no such thing as ‘universal time’ then you have exposed yourself to a ‘brainwashing’ exercise conducted by devil authors who preach the Einstein doctrine but contribute nothing to the science which sustains technological progress.

    Field Cavity Resonance and Energy Cut-Off

    My method involves an energy cut-off range determined by a wave resonance in the near-field zone of the electron as shown in the figure below. The length of the radial lines in the outer cavity is half the Compton wavelength of the electron, because the field oscillations are phase-locked by the charge polarity condition. The length of the radial lines in the inner core of the electron charge is approximately the electron charge radius a and represents a standing wave condition of much higher frequency.

    Pattern of electron field cavity wave resonance

    Now, the electron itself is a form of energy compressed into a field and we can calculate how that energy is distributed. J. J. Thomson did that calculation in the 19th century to find that, in electrostatic units, the energy e2/2α was seated outside the charge radius α. However, he discovered from the study of how electron mass increased with speed, even tending to become infinite as the speed of light was approached, that the effective rest mass of the electron was 2e2/3αc2.

    This meant that, if the electron were hollow within the radius a, then we could write the energy E as being 3Mc2/4. However, even before Einstein came into the picture in 1905, the Cambridge cosmologist, Sir James Jeans had, in his early years before being knighted, explained that mass and energy are equivalent and had argued that matter could be annihilated to produce radiant energy. He saw this as being the energy source feeding the sun and all other stars.

    It is a simple exercise to work out that if the pressure of the electron field at the radius a is the same within the body of the electron, meaning that the charge e has an appropriate distribution conforming with this condition, then the speed of propagation of wave disturbances in the electron charge itself has the value c and that the electric energy inside that radius is e2/6a. So, you see, the net result is an electron of energy 2e2/3a giving a relationship between energy and mass that we can write as E=Mc2.

    Much of this was accepted physics before Einstein appeared on the scene and was known as ‘electron theory’, so it is very hard to understand how modern physicists can write that history off as if it never happened!

    Resonance and Degrees of Freedom

    For our immediate purpose, we have now the basis for studying the coordinated wave interaction as between that external influence at the Compton electron frequency and the wavelengths associated with that radius parameter a of the electron.

    Looking now at the figure showing the pattern of the electron’s field cavity resonance, ask yourself how the world outside the electron might interface with the world inside the core charge of the electron. If you think of pressure from the viewpoint of a gas then the interface is just a pressure interface and there is not much to say. However, a gas comprises numerous particles all moving in different directions. There are three degrees of freedom. However, inside that electron it may be that there are not numerous component particles behaving as a gas and moving with those three degrees of freedom. There could be an oscillation that has only one degree of freedom, amounting in its overall effect to a radial oscillation within the radius a. I emphasize here that I have no special insight into what goes on inside an electron. I can only make tentative assumptions and reason on that basis to see how what develops compares with what we see and measure in our experiments. So, I trust you are following the gist of my argument, because I am coming to the point that between the sphere of radius a and the sphere interfacing with those Compton frequency oscillations there is an adjustment at constant pressure in going from one degree of freedom to three degrees of freedom.

    What this amounts to is that the surface area of that intermediate interface will be three times the surface area of the inner interface. In short, the outer interface radius will be 31/2a, subject, however, to a little ‘tuning’.

    Geometric and Phase Constraints

    Now, if this seems a little speculative, there is an alternative approach giving the equivalent result. Look again at the figure and imagine both the radial oscillations within the core charge of the electron and in the cavity excited at the Compton electron frequency as setting up standing wave antinodes needing to balance those of travelling waves progressing by reflection around a circuit within the middle cavity. You will see that the three-wave interface at the charge surface requires a 120° angular separation. The geometry of this system also requires the outer radius to be 31/2a.

    A vital consideration is what it is that tells an electron that it is a negative charge or a positive charge. I do not want to dwell too long on this point so I will simply explain that it is all a question of how those the two frequency modes of oscillation beat together. Undoubtedly, as those who may study the history of aether theory may discover, the answer lies in developing the concepts of C. A. Bjerknes of the period 1877 to 1910. Positive and negative are states involving oscillations in antiphase, all positive charges sharing a common phase and all negative charges sharing a common phase, but I leave that research to others. Suffice it here to say that the phase of oscillation is important. The Compton electron wavelength has to blend with the wavelength 2a, as the reader can work out from that pattern shown in the figure.

    The ratio of these wavelengths has to be an odd integer that cannot be factorized as that would allow the phase of the electron oscillations to have optional values in relation to the regulating universal rhythm of the Compton frequency oscillations. All positive electron charges have the same phase and all negative electron charges have the same phase but positive and negative charges are different because they are in antiphase.

    This is the secret of the meaning of electrical charge polarity. It is just a question of phase, but there is phase-lock ensuring that there are no maverick charges in the electron family. There are only electrons or their positive versions, the positrons.

    Derivation of the g/2 Factor

    It is on this basis that there is a constraint on the adoption of the distance parameter a as a wavelength. The wavelength (λc) assumed by the resonant oscillation within the electron has to ensure that:

    (λc)/2 = Na

    where N is a prime number.

    Now, from what has been said above, it can be seen that, since a without this constraint is given by 2e2/3hνc, hνc being the rest-mass energy of the electron and the Compton wavelength λc being c/νc, we can write as an approximation:

    a = (2πe2/hc)λc/3π

    From these two equations we find that N becomes the nearest prime integer to 3π(137)/2, bearing in mind that α, which is 2πe2/hc, is approximately 1/137. This gives N, uniquely, as 647.

    The formula for g/2 is then easily explained because the field energy of the electron disposed outside the cut-off radius R is simply e2/2R and R is simply (λc/2)(1+31/2/647). Using the formula:

    (g/2)(mc2 – e2/2R) = mc2

    where m is the normal rest mass of the electron, and also the fact that λc is h/mc, it then needs a little algebra to find the residual electron energy thereby effective in confined orbital states of motion. This allows us to determine its ratio to the normal energy applicable for translational motion but one then arrives at the result presented in table above.

  • Appendix II

    Appendix II

    Inertia and E = Mc²

    The physical basis of inertia and so of the well-known formula E = Mc² resides in the Principle of Conservation of Energy and, contrary to what many physicists believe, the unwillingness of an electron to radiate and so shed the only attribute that accounts for its existence, its electric charge and the energy intrinsic to that charge.

    Electron acceleration in company with other electrons accelerated by the same electric field will engender a collective action by which energy can be said to be dispersed by setting up electromagnetic wave propagation. If N electrons are involved then the rate of energy radiation is, by Larmor theory, said to be proportional to N². Physicists who see this as applying to radio transmission from antenna in which numerous electrons are caused to oscillate in synchronism with one another must, however, ask themselves whether the radiation might be proportional, not to N² but to (N² – N), whereby we exclude radiation of the very energy that keeps the electrons alive.

    Why, I ask, should physicists just declare that an electron is accelerated without, as they do, factoring into their analysis the external electric field that causes that acceleration?

    Now I could write many, many pages in support of my concern, but see no reason for replicating and developing what I have already published elsewhere. My book: ‘Physics Unified’ includes a discussion in chapter 4 where I refer to 17 authors who seem to be troubled by this problem. These authors include Dirac and Einstein.

    If you think Einstein’s theory is rigorous, ask yourself how we measure relativistic mass increase of a fast-moving electron unless it is rapidly accelerated. Then note Einstein’s words in a famous paper of his entitled: ‘On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies’ : “As the electron is to be slowly accelerated, and consequently may not give off any energy in the form of radiation, the energy withdrawn from the electrostatic field must be put down as equal to the energy of motion of the electron.”

    The reference is Annalen der Physik, 17, 891 (1905).

    If you respect the work of Nobel Laureate Paul Dirac, just look up the paper in which, in discussing the classical theory of energy radiation by accelerated charge to accommodate relativistic principles, he stated: “It would appear that we have a contradiction with elementary ideas of causality”

    Here the reference is Proc. Roy. Soc., A167, 148 (1938).

    So my case is simple. Just go back to see how the formula for electron energy radiation was derived in the first place. I will not repeat the analysis here but will present the mathematical integral on which it is based:

    π
    2 ∫ [ (1/8π)(efsinΘ/c³t)²2π(ct)²sinΘ cdt] dΘ = 2e²f²/3c³

    This is derived at p. 81 in my book: ‘Physics Unified’. There are two important points to notice about this formulation. Firstly, it contains no symbol which represents the intensity of the electric field which must be present in order to set up the acceleration f. Secondly, that factor of 2 before the integral sign is put there because it is assumed that the electric field disturbance that is propagated must, by virtue of our understanding of Maxwell’s theory of wave propagation, be matched by the propagation of an equal magnetic field disturbance.

    Now I can declare quite categorically that once the accelerating electric field of strength V is included that integral above becomes zero, provided we have: Ve/f = e²/2c²(ct) and since e²/2(ct) is a measure of the electric field energy outside the radius ct, t being time, that remains to be accelerated as the disturbance progresses at speed c, it is evident that here we have a formula that tells us that an electron will accelerate in just such a way as to avoid shedding its electric energy, the condition being that the inertial mass is the electric field energy involved divided by c². So we have E = Mc² derived by classical electron theory and a physical insight into the nature of inertia.

    The reason I am delving into this subject here is my concern about the theory of the Hubble constant in relation to the classical formula for the Thomson scattering cross-section of the electron. The theory for this depends upon the above formula for the rate of energy radiation by the electron deemed to be accelerated by the passage of an electromagnetic wave intercepted by the electron. If there can be no radiation of electric field energy by the isolated electron accelerated by such a wave then, in that respect, the scattering cross-section of the electron must be zero. However, I can see the case for the magnetic disturbance, or rather the kinetic energy disturbance implied, to still ripple through as part of the resulting wave propagation. To that extent, and bearing in mind that there is a measure of qualitative evidence supporting the Thomson scattering attributed to electrons, I tend to the opinion that an electromagnetic wave encountering isolated electrons in space does confront an obstructing cross-section that is half that indicated by the classical Thomson formula.

    In this case there is logic in looking to the transient creation of electrons by the aether’s failed attempts to create protons as a reason accounting for the attenuation of intensity and frequency of waves coming from distant stars. It is just that the theoretical determination (chapter 8) of the magnitude of the Hubble constant is affected, but surely we do have here a profound insight into some fascinating aspects of the physics that underpin our universe and I just hope that physicists will see enough reason to revise their opinions in the light of these comments.

    As to revising one’s opinions, readers may find it of interest to read what I have recorded ahead in Appendix VI concerning Einstein’s notion of time dilation and also concerning the significance of what I have said in Chapter 9 about Fechner’s hypothesis and its bearing upon electrodynamic interaction. Our understanding of the physics of Creation is, to be sure, an evolving theme, but one can be equally sure that what is reported here in this work is closer to the truth than a physics based on Einstein’s theory.

  • APPENDIX I

    APPENDIX I

    The Exclusion Zone of Interaction Energy

    When two particles interact owing to the interaction of their mutual electrostatic or gravitational fields, the fact that field energy density is proportional to field intensity squared means that there is a cross-product component of energy density separate from the self-energy components of either particle. This cross-product component is what is meant here by ‘interaction energy’. Our task now is to prove the following theorem:

    Given two particles separated by a distance r and subject to an inverse square of distance law of force, prove that their interaction energy sums to zero within a sphere of radius r centred on either charge.

    Why is this important? It is important because in physics we face the problem of working out how fast that energy can transfer from its distribution over the whole of the field enveloping the particles to satisfy the Principle of Conservation of Energy by moving to or from the kinetic energy state which is seated with and shares the motion at the particle location.

    For the electrostatic case, consider a charge Q in the figure above as developing a radial electric field VQ at radius x. Imagine then a charge q distant r from Q developing a radial electric field Vq at the radius x from Q. Let y denote the distance from q and a point P under consideration at radius x from Q. Then, with φ as the angle between VQ and Vq, we know that the interaction energy density component at P is:

    $$
    \frac{V_Q V_q \cos\phi}{4\pi}
    $$

    Also, VQ is Q/x² and Vq is q/y². Now consider the volume of an elemental section of a spherical shell of thickness dx at the radius x, as subtended at P by a small solid angle from q. The elemental volume is y²/cosφ times this angle per unit thickness of the shell. If this is multiplied by the above expression after replacing VQ and Vq by the above terms in x and y, we find that the cosφ term is eliminated as is the y² term, to leave us with an expression for the energy attributable to that elemental section dx of shell is Qq(dx)/4πx² times the solid angle mentioned. Since this does not depend upon y, we can evaluate the total energy component dE for the full solid angle of 4π to obtain:

    $$
    dE = \frac{Qq}{x^2} dx
    $$

    Provided x is greater than r, the fields VQ and Vq are in the same direction. With x less than r the two regions of the spherical shell intercepted by the same solid angle have opposite and cancelling interaction energies owing to the change of direction of VQ relative to Vq. Thus within the radius r the interaction field energy sums to zero and so the proposition is proved.

    Now we could have replaced Q and q by masses M and m and, by introducing G, the constant of gravitation, as a coefficient, reached exactly the same conclusion, namely that there is no net interaction energy within a sphere centred on M or, by the logic of symmetry, centred on m.

    Accordingly, whether we have in mind the electrostatic interaction or the gravitational interaction, the energy transfer for change of separation distance involves energy having to traverse the distance r in going to or from the kinetic energy state in the process of transfer with field energy.

    A separate mathematical analysis based on the use of MacClaurin’s Theorem can show that the interaction field energy distribution at radii beyond r is inversely proportional to the square of x. From that one concludes that the precise distance energy travels in its transfer between field and kinetic energy is the distance r. The latter analysis is of record in chapter 1 of my book: ‘Physics Unified’ and also in a paper of mine published by the U.K. Institute of Physics [‘The Inverse Square Law of Force’, J. Phys. A: Math Gen., 13, 3649–3655 (1980)].

    The importance of the theorem here presented is evident from the analysis in chapter (9) where we derived the equation (9.6) which led us to a physical foundation for the Neumann potential in terms of the Coulomb interaction. An equally important result, however, is that afforded by the clear analogy with the gravitational interaction, because equation (9.6) has a gravitational counterpart that is the basis of the point made in chapter 5 by reference to the expression (5.1). Physicists whose minds are entrenched in relativistic doctrine would do well to take stock of what has just been stated here, because one can see, from the argument that follows expression (5.1) in chapter 5, that the perihelion motion of planet Mercury can be explained by the simple classical logic of classical field theory, once the theorem presented in this Appendix I is given due attention.