Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • KEYNOTE ADDRESS: CONTINUATION

    KEYNOTE ADDRESS: CONTINUATION

    On ‘The Repression of Inventions’

    REPRESSION OF THE SECOND KIND: PATENT OFFICE HOSTILITY

    The next act of ‘repression’ also concerns an invention in the energy field and this time I shall point my finger at the U.S. Patent Office. The subject is ‘cold fusion’. Some of you will recall that in 1989 two professors, Martin Fleischmann of Southampton University and Stanley Pons of the University of Utah, hit the news headlines by declaring that they had found that an electrolytic cell filled with heavy water had shown some spurious effects by generating heat apparently from nowhere, unless perhaps, that heat came from a nuclear fusion reaction.

    Scientists have been trying for close on 50 years to build an operable nuclear fusion reactor that runs on the hydrogen isotope found in heavy water. They have not succeeded by their method of producing very high temperatures to trigger the reaction and yet here was a test-tube experiment that was said to deliver that success by operating at room temperature.

    It needs little imagination to guess the feelings of those who were spending vast sums of government money on trying to produce controlled nuclear fusion in the laboratory when they heard that two professors of electrochemistry had found that heat, seemingly coming from a fusion reaction, can be generated at water temperatures using simple chemical apparatus.

    The object is to generate heat which we can turn into electricity, but those nuclear scientists expect a nuclear reaction to produce vast quantities of radiation in the form of neutrons or gamma radiation. On that reasoning, Professors Fleischmann and Pons should have killed themselves or at least signed their own eventual death warrants by doing the experiment. Yet they found very little evidence, indeed negligible evidence, of such radiation products in their tests on the heavy water cells.

    Now, instead of waiting to see the new technology develop in the hands of these electrochemists and the sponsors who rushed in to assist, the scientific community, particularly those who lived only in a world of theory, went on the rampage. It came to be described as ‘The scientific fiasco of the century’.

    In retrospect it seems that Fleischmann and Pons announced their discovery before they knew enough about the process to understand why it worked. There was more heat being generated than could be explained in chemical terms and this is why fusion came into the picture, but the process was elusive and could not, at the time, be replicated on demand, at least by the many who then tried their hand at building the Fleischmann and Pons cell. Now, my interest in all this arose because I had, for many years, been developing a theory which assured me that atomic nuclei of the hydrogen isotopes in heavy water do not contain neutrons. There being three isotopes of hydrogen in a 1, 2, 3 series, this meant that, assuming a fusion reaction where two heavy water (2+2) nuclei combine to form one heavier atomic nucleus (3) and one lighter atomic nucleus (1), there is no need for a neutron to be emitted.

    To my way of thinking there was a way in which to improve the operation of the cell used by Fleischmann and Pons and within three weeks of their initial announcement back in 1989 I had filed a patent application on that ‘invention’ of mine at the British Patent Office. It was not something I had tested experimentally. It was simply a ‘paper proposal’ but I well knew the need to file a patent before one made a general disclosure of an invention and I wanted to set the scene for airing my views on the subject and draw attention to my earlier theoretical work. That British patent was eventually granted without any problem, but the corresponding United States patent application that I filed ran into an incredible barrage of ‘repression’ staged by the Patent Examiner.

    My background in the patent profession, some 37 or so years on from that encounter with my German visitor, meant that I knew what was normal, abnormal and outright incredible when it came to dealings with a Patent Office. I had never, in my whole career encountered the latter situation until I filed that ‘cold fusion’ patent application in the U.S. Patent Office in the wake of Fleischmann and Pons.

    I have heard that over 200 patent applications on the subject of cold fusion have been rejected by the U.S. Patent Office. Included in these is the original application by Fleischmann and Pons, even though their corresponding European patent application has been granted. At this time [APRIL, 1996] my own U.S. patent application is still in contention.

    I have had no less than 14 patents cited against my application together with 37 articles from newspapers and scientific periodicals. Most of these are dated after my priority filing date but they have been cited to support the Examiner’s case that there is no reputable evidence to show that excess energy can be generated in a device working at water temperatures.

    Now, in this talk, I cannot go into the details of all this. I just want to make the point that I have known for a very long time that the scientific community can be very repressive in resisting those who intrude into their fields of specialty. Scientific papers are sent off for the peer review of experts in the relevant field. These are those with the most to lose if what is on offer is new and runs counter to their own beliefs. If the papers support the ‘party line’ and particularly the prior work of the referee, then they are accepted. Otherwise they are rejected, because no one wants to rock the boat by showing that there is dissent that can raise doubts amongst those on committees who have charge of research funding.
    I have, however, never before seen a situation where the ‘party line’ of a group of scientists could penetrate the ranks of an examining patent office. It is legitimate for patent examiners to argue that something is not new or may be obvious and so unpatentable. It is legitimate for patent examiners in U.S. practice to invite evidence and testimony as to operability of an invention. It is legitimate also to contend that what is claimed is ‘perpetual motion’, which is said to be contrary to natural law (meaning the established laws of physics), but the rejection of which I am speaking is not put in such simple terms. Rather than declaring, as by some kind of administrative edict, that what can be classed as a ‘cold fusion’ application should be deemed unpatentable, as being akin to claims for perpetual motion, it is as if the U.S. Patent Office, or their examiners as their agents, decided to grind the applicant down. I was first asked to decide which aspect of my application was to be selected for examination, the implication being that there were numerous different inventions involved. Yet in the U.K. the British examiner saw the same patent specification as relating to one single invention. When I made my selection, then came the 51 items of cited art, whereas 6 would have been a reasonable number of cited documents.

    It may interest you if I refer to just one item. After the cold fusion announcement, Harwell scientists mounted a crash programme to verify what was claimed by Fleischmann and Pons. A U.S. Government representative from Oak Ridge National Laboratory named J.F. Cooke visited Harwell to check their progress. His report was cited by the examiner including a verbatim quotation from it. The report made a point of saying that Prime Minister Thatcher had telephoned Harwell to see how things were progressing. Some 13 lines of Examiner remarks later in that report one reads the words: “Calorimetric cells, which took into account and eliminated temperature gradient problems, were also used.”

    Now my patent application involves injecting power into the cell which would actually inject heat into the cathode and one of my arguments is that, to get the action started that might cause excess heat to be generated, it requires some such influence in the metal electrode to set up electric fields which can stimulate the onset of the activity. I know that the combination of a temperature gradient in an electrode and the passage of electric current can work together to produce electric fields even inside a metal conductor. Such fields can involve residual charge which neutralizes the repulsive action between two hydrogen nuclei and may allow them to come together close enough to trigger fusion. So I see the need to make special provision for that activity as by introducing heat into the electrode in the cell to set up the needed temperature gradient. Now when Harwell set out to verify or discredit the cold fusion claim they decided that, to measure any heat generated, their apparatus should be put in a cocoon so as to keep it at a uniform temperature and so ease the task of measuring any change of that temperature. Measuring increase of heat generated depends upon accurate measurement of temperature change. That is fairly obvious, but what is equally obvious to me, though not to the U.S. Patent Examiner, is that, if a temperature differential within the hydrated metal is the essential ‘cold fusion’ trigger, so the Harwell experiment killed the goose before it could lay the golden egg!

    However, in killing the goose they gave basis for a U.S. Government report which the U.S. Patent Examiner relies upon as a citation against my invention to prove, in effect, that the goose that had been killed had never existed!

    What is so outrageous is that none of this was prior art concerning the scope of the invention that I was claiming in my U.S. patent application. It concerned the Fleischmann and Pons process, which had become prior art which could be cited in its own right had my patent claims not distinguished my invention from what they had disclosed.

    On this whole subject we shall have to wait and see how the dust finally settles on this question of cold fusion, but certainly, if it is found that we can eventually generate electric power from the excess heat of a cold fusion reactor, then history will show that here was a technology, the many inventions on which were subjected to deliberate repression by the U.S. Patent Office. What I do find hard to understand is the reason behind that repression, because I have always seen Patent Offices as referees functioning as passive filters which allow patents to be granted solely on their merits in the fair contest between what is old and what is new and better technology for the world at large.

    REPRESSION OF THE THIRD KIND: THE EMPLOYED INVENTOR

    The third form of repression is one which affects numerous inventors and, short of changing the whole philosophy of the patent system internationally, I cannot see any remedy. The problem is a fact of life. Imagine you are employed in a technical capacity by a high-tech multinational company. You have contracted that your inventions belong to your employer. You make an invention that your employer does not want to develop. What do you do? Contractually it belongs to your employer. Now I can assure you that, if you press to get possession of the rights so that you can offer them to other companies, then you will have an interesting experience. Your request will be rebuffed if the invention is in your employer’s technical field. One reason is that there may be cross license arrangements with those other companies and, should you offer your invention to those other companies, they may wonder why they should pay you money to use the invention when they should have free use had it been patented by your employer. Also, your employer would be concerned to find you sniping at his competitors in an uncontrolled way, especially as the accepted playing field for competition is in the customer market place and there is nothing to stop you from trying to enforce your patent against customer and competitor alike.
    So, if the invention lies within your employer’s technical field, then, in trying to promote your invention independently, you run risks with your career that you would rather avoid. On the other hand, if your invention lies outside your employer’s field, then there are also similar risks. Why should an employer be enamored by you if you use your creative technical faculties for private purposes when that skill should be concentrated on the employer’s technology and for your employer’s benefit?

    So, without there being any repressive act, as such, the system operates in silence with the same result. If you have a research mind and half of your ideas have application outside your employer’s field of activity then half of your inventive power is suppressed. It is an inevitable fact of life, so long as the patent system remains as it is now.

    What you can expect, therefore, is that the real break-through on the new energy front is more likely to come from someone well qualified technically but not tied to a corporation or an institutional body.

    The Fleischmann and Pons cold fusion work was initiated at their own expense and not as a formally funded project. I can also say that there was a time in my career with IBM when I decided, at my own expense, to file a patent application on an invention that I felt simply had to go on public record. I took that initiative and then told IBM it was theirs if they wanted it, but otherwise I would abandon the rights upon publication, which is what happened. IBM did not repress that invention. I was senior enough in IBM’s patent organization to act responsibly and not let that invention cause any problem, but I made sure that it was not ‘repressed’ by having been thought of but not documented on public record owing to inaction stemming from the employee-inventor syndrome. I sought, as back-up, to get a scientific paper published on the invention, but knew that the ‘peer review’ system involved in that could have its own kind of ‘repression’, which is why I made sure of publication by applying for the patent. Unlike the situation in U.S.A. application for a patent in U.K. offers initial publication before grant, which means that it is scrutinized for its form and for search purposes but does not have to overcome the main Examiner hurdles before being published.

    Now, what was my invention? It was nothing less than a proposed method of extracting energy from the aether, as revolutionary an idea as one can possibly conceive – energy from a medium which most physicists say does not exist, but which I say is everywhere in and around us. You may think that I had lost my mental faculties or that I had, like the German U-boat engineer mentioned earlier, gone adrift in my scientific reasoning, but I can assure you that I was ready to defend my case.

    That was in 1977. My invention required the use of an electrical discharge in a rarified gas, what is known as a cold-cathode discharge, but involved a technique which had the object of gaining power over and above the electrical input. The patent specification was published in 1978 and assigned the number GB 2,002,953. My technical paper on the subject, overcame referee scrutiny and was published in 1977 in the IEEE Proceedings on Plasma Science, PS-2, pp. 159-163 under the title ‘Electrodynamic Anomalies in Arc Discharge Phenomena’. Both were duly ignored by the scientific community. That is as you might expect, but I had satisfied my desire to put my contribution on record.

    Not surprisingly, however, at least to me some nine years later in 1986, a British scientist named Geoffrey Spence, acting also on his own behalf, succeeded in demonstrating a somewhat similar plasma discharge device operating and delivering kilowatt output power substantially in excess of input power. Indeed, his invention would, in my opinion, have infringed claim 4 of my patent had I pressed onward to the grant stage and kept it alive. However, the academic world, being what it is, though partially successful in replicating the Spence device, lacked that something needed to take the project forward. Spence had his problems because the device suffered from electrode failure because too much heat was eroding the electrode where the energy was collected. The Spence invention, surprisingly, was duly patented in the U.S.A. Unlike the fiasco over cold fusion, the United States Patent Office allowed a patent on something that, on the face of it, did cover the electrical equivalent of perpetual motion. It was U.S. Patent No. 4,772,816.

    Now, has the Spence invention been ‘repressed’? Well, has it or hasn’t it? You tell me! The scenario is that Spence built something that worked. It delivered excess power, but the durability of the device posed problems. Its operation did attract sponsors. When I heard about it I was told that a university project had verified operability, but that the device failed after 14 hours or so owing to electrode erosion. Spence lived as a recluse but he had set up a trust to cope with the potential exploitation of his invention rights. This was a glimpse of a new technology that could deliver power in breach of the laws of physics. It had the necessary patent cover, but to get it to work commercially it needed development of the kind available to major corporations in the electronics industry.
    Has the invention been ‘repressed’ or simply neglected because the wisdom of the technology world rules that such inventions are impossible? Was this another version of something similar to the Hans Coler saga, where the invention most assuredly did work to deliver excess power, but the wise men in authority who had not seen it working felt they knew better and diverted their attentions elsewhere?

    A HOPE CONCERNING A NEW ENERGY INVENTION

    The description of the Spence invention sits there on record in Patent Offices and anyone can buy a copy of the patent specification, but we are not enjoying that bonanza that can come from the generation of electrical power from the bountiful aether. You see, if the scientific community believe something is not possible, they do not try to make it happen. On the contrary, they go out of their way to make sure that no one in their own ranks strays by beginning to think that the ‘impossible’ has become the ‘possible’.

    If you believe in God then you can say that God can achieve the impossible. Otherwise how could the forms of energy we see around us have been created, given that everything is in decline as energy is dissipated as heat.

    If you do not believe in God or can accept that God, like us, is governed by the laws of physics, then the creation of matter from a lesser form of energy has to be scientific possibility.

    I could not indulge in such reasoning when my work required me to evaluate inventions. Though there is repression by scientists and technologists in their cursory evaluation of those dubious inventions, it was part of my duty in a corporate patent department to be attentive to the ‘crackpot’ ideas of inventors, just in case one comes along which wins the ‘jackpot’. Sadly, institutional research funding is no gambling game. There is no jackpot to be won, because funded research has to stay on secure territory and aim at modest objectives which succeed only by building very slowly on well established foundations, even though those foundations are unable to support the fabric of the new energy world.

    So much for the invention of Geoffrey Spence, but that is not all. Moving on another three years to 1989, there was a press release issued by the Novosti Press Agency telling us about an energy breakthrough in Moscow. Energy was being tapped from the vacuum using a plasma discharge! This was the work of a team led by Professor Chernetskii. You may have heard mention of this briefly during a recent T.V. programme in the EQUINOX series. [U.K. television]. That particular programme was named ‘IT RUNS ON WATER’ and its documentary background was mainly of U.S. origin. The Chernetskii invention was mentioned because it gave back-up to the developing scene where U.S. inventors are claiming to have discovered various ways of getting energy apparently from nowhere, and in the process are attracting scorn and derision from those who believe that just cannot be.

    So, why have the Russians not swept the field with that new technology? Can it be that they have so much oil that they see no need to invest in plasma generators? I have no answer to offer. It is just one of those facts that we, or rather they, live with. There is a kind of mental inertia that builds up in experts to the point where they cannot change their ways, whereas those who have not acquired much inertia lack the driving force to break through those barriers that one encounters in this field of new energy.

    Yet the seeds of a new energy technology are there waiting to be nurtured, but it seems the energy scientists would rather try to harness the hot fusion power of the hydrogen atom bomb or go off into space to try to tap into the electron power of the ionosphere.
    I mention that because the news we heard about six weeks ago, on 26th February [1996], was that a satellite costing hundreds of millions of dollars had been lost because of an unexpected electrical discharge which fused the tether connecting the satellite to the Columbia space shuttle.

    Now, what have I been talking about in referring to my 1977 invention, the 1986 invention of Geoffrey Spence and the 1989 news about the Chernetskii invention is the enormous excess power delivery to a cold-cathode subjected to a plasma discharge in an evacuated tube containing gas at very low pressure. That experiment in space did not use a discharge tube. It had a 12.8 mile cable sweeping through the Earth’s magnetic field to set up a voltage of several kilovolts between the satellite and the space shuttle. This was intended to deliver electrons to the shuttle which were then to be fired back into space to close the circuit loop. Here we have a situation where the ‘discharge’ is through a plasma out in space rather than inside an evacuated tube in the laboratory. The secret of those three plasma inventions is that the action which brings in the energy bonanza is not carried by the electrons, but rather by the positive ions, the protons that sit with the electrons if the plasma involves hydrogen. Those protons pick up energy mysteriously at a rate that is several thousand times greater than they should according to accepted theory!

    So what happened to that space experiment? The space shuttle itself was the cathode and the satellite was the anode in the discharge and the inevitable energy bonanza converged onto the cathode, not carried by the electrons coming down through that cable, but rather carried by positive ions moving in through the space plasma to join up with those electrons at the cathode, namely at the point of connection with Columbia. The seven-man crew were indeed lucky to survive such a close encounter with a release of excess energy from the aether. Once the connection had fused, the cable with its satellite took that power source away. It was lost.

    Now you may think that I am merely speculating imaginatively in rambling on like this, and I cannot deny that is partly true, because I am human and this talk of ‘free energy’ inspires one to dream. Someone like myself has to think about these matters, given that those paid to do that thinking have to stay in line with what has become orthodox (non-imaginative) opinion.

    I will therefore now end by telling you that three U.S. patents have issued recently and they read like university doctorate theses in showing, by data referenced to numerous experiments, that plasma discharge devices can generate electrical power many times greater than is supplied as input power. They were granted to Canadian inventors, a man and wife team also acting on their own private funding. Dr. Paulo Correa and his wife Alexandra drew this research to my attention, which is why I know about it first-hand. Indeed, I find that my earlier writings in this field are referenced in those patents. It seems that Dr. Correa has conquered the problem of electrode over-heating and, after long duration running of the many devices he has built using different electrode configurations, shapes and materials, his development is now at the point where predictably 40 megawatt-hours of energy can be delivered from something of light weight construction that one can hold in one hand. Imagine holding something that can deliver 2 kilowatts of electrical power output and keep going for 20,000 hours. Then ask yourself when we can expect to see electrical vehicles on our roads using somewhat larger versions of those tubes.

    So here is the invention that must not be repressed and that is why I have accepted this invitation to speak to you here about ‘repressed inventions’. It was not to tell a sorry tale and bring bad news from the past, but rather to inspire you with hope, the kind of hope which I now see as good news for the world’s energy future.

    Next week at this time I plan to be in Denver, Colorado, attending the Third International Symposium on New Energy, where Dr. Paulo Correa will disclose details of the invention I have just mentioned. An invention by Win Lambertson will also be discussed, which could prove to be the solid-state equivalent of the plasma discharge device. We may well now be facing a future that repeats in the power generating industry what we have seen in the electronic communication industry.

    Finally, I say that if there are forces of repression where inventions are concerned then those forces now have plenty of work to keep them fully employed!

    The above is the full text of the notes I used as preparation and for reference in delivering my talk to the very large audience that attended my session at the Fortean meeting in London on Saturday 20th April, 1996. I now invite you to read my onward ‘Discussion’ of these matters, by pressing the following link button:

    


  • KEYNOTE ADDRESS

    KEYNOTE ADDRESS

    THE REPRESSION OF INVENTIONS

    Copyright, HAROLD ASPDEN, 1997

    This is the full text of the author’s notes for a talk delivered to the
    very large audience that attended the session on ‘Repression of Inventions’ at UNCONVENTION ’96, as organized by FORTEAN TIMES and held in London, England on Saturday 20th April, 1996.

    The reason this is chosen as the ‘KEYNOTE ADDRESS’ to open these Web pages will be explained in a Discussion Note at the end of this discourse. Our subject is ‘ENERGY SCIENCE’ in the context of generating useful power from the thermodynamic condition of our space environment. However, these Web pages reveal far more than a glimpse at the prospect of a new technology which can solve the world’s energy problems and avoid pollution. In penetrating the barriers of energy science we expose the secrets of creation on a universal and a microscopic scale. Those processes of creation are powered by the same action that delivers the excess power in the electrodynamic and ferromagnetic devices that will be at the very heart of our power generators in the years ahead. The source of that energy is the aether, ‘AETHER SCIENCE’ being the theoretical discipline which gives foundation for the technological discipline of ‘ENERGY SCIENCE’. The subject is vast in scope and the theme I was asked to speak about when invited to give the following talk, though chosen for me by the organizers is as good a place as any from which to start. I hope it will prove interesting.

    ABOUT THE TITLE

    I was rather surprised to be invited to come here today and speak to you about ‘The Repression of Inventions’. I have not expressed views on the subject before. The topic concerns the deliberate restriction on the use of an invention. This implies exercise of restrictive powers, as by the Government, but I think there is a more popular belief that major corporations sometimes buy inventions which might threaten their business and keep them from being used to the public good.

    In my retirement from gainful employment with a major corporation I am not at all interested in the politics of these matters but I have become interested in inventions which can help to solve the world’s energy problems and the need to reduce pollution. I therefore realize that a revolutionary discovery in the energy field can have such impact that one could wonder whether an oil company, for example, might contrive to suppress such an invention and deprive us from its benefit. My guess is that their initial reaction on hearing about such an invention would be more an exercise in curiosity and that, by the time that turned into fear about business outlook, the news about the invention would have spread and it would be too late to keep the discovery secret.

    The repression I fear, on the energy front, is that which has other roots well planted in the fertile soil of what I can best describe as ‘human nature’.

    It is a human reaction of experts in the energy field to pour scorn on anyone who dares to challenge the conventional threshold which limits what is deemed possible in energy terms. There is a line that must not be crossed. Whoever dares to mount such a challenge can risk being seen as a Don Quixote tilting at a windmill and attempting the impossible.

    So what I have to say will be focused on that theme and I would ask that you take note that I am not here talking about my problems or the problems of the individual inventors, but your problems, the problems ahead that we all face together if there is no breakthrough invention on the horizon that can ease our energy worries and allow us to stop the use of nuclear power.

    Now, I have to mention patents, because the way to get business people interested in an invention, besides demonstrating it working is to secure some patent protection. Neither inventors nor those in authority who can take inventions forward can expect to benefit from their efforts and their investment without securing some patent protection.

    Here I do urge you not to see patents as ‘repressive’. I did not choose the title of this talk! They are the very opposite of that because they involve a contract with the Government, one respected on an international scale, by which a monopoly limited to a period of years is conferred in return for the open publication of details sufficient to implement the invention. So, if a patented invention is ‘repressed’, you, the public, could easily inspect the public records, see what it is that we are losing out on and ask the necessary questions. I could, of course, wish that the patent system was more effective, but one needs to keep in mind that it really does work, and it has held its ground for a century in the treaty arrangements of international politics.

    So I suggest that an invention is not to be endorsed as such until the inventor secures a patent and ‘repression’ has to be seen more as a lack of action than a withholding of something from the public. However, there can, on occasion, be deliberate obstruction with the public standing by and watching something they cannot understand. Almost always, the inventor has trouble getting anyone to take an interest in his invention.

    REMINISCENCE AS A PATENT MANAGER

    To put things in perspective, I will begin by indulging in a little reminiscence and tell you about the way some inventors try to project their ideas.

    36 years ago I was hired as the new Patent Manager at IBM’s Head Office in London. We were busy enough working on the hundreds of inventions in process through the Patent Office without having to worry about the inventions offered by outsiders, but we were attentive and polite to any would-be inventor who knocked on our doors. My first visitor in that capacity popped in off the street, Wigmore Street. In those early days IBM had its Head Office just behind Selfridges, a principal department store in Oxford Street. He introduced himself as being a member of MENSA and as having a very high intelligence quota. Then he digressed to ask me how I was getting on in my new job. Eventually he got to the point. Yes, he had made an invention. Yes, he understood that our company policy was not to accept the confidential disclosure of inventions offered by strangers. Yes, he knew he ought to file a patent application before talking to us, but he really had something so wonderful to offer that would revolutionize IBM’s typewriter business. Then he said that he would not disclose his invention to us there and then and that all he wanted was to borrow my secretary for two weeks and she would come back and be able to vouch for the merit of his invention.

    When I then rose to accelerate his departure he explained that he had devised a new language which would require a new keyboard lay out which would be more efficient because it only had ten keys. In saying this, he looked attentively at his eight fingers and two thumbs. I thought he had in mind some kind of stenographic machine. But, no, what he had ‘invented’ was a new language based on ten characters! We were all expected to learn a new language. That sort of idea is not patentable and I could not imagine IBM succeeding in an effort to sponsor the elimination of the English language.

    When I terminated the meeting he departed with the comment that I had only said what my predecessor had said four years previously and that he had only popped in to see me to kill time while his wife was shopping in Selfridges.

    I dare say that I could be accused of suppressing his invention, but only in the sense that I decided that IBM was not interested and if I did wrong I hope I will be forgiven!

    Every Patent Manager can tell many such stories. I will very briefly mention three from my prior employment in the London Patent Department of a major Engineering Company.

    One Friday afternoon the company received a two-line telegram which read “If you do not send 5,000 pounds by return, I will not tell you my invention”. It was from Ireland, but a little while later there was a communication just as humorous from Australia about an idea for electrocuting rabbits. I remember it because it had no proper address. It was mailed to England addressed to ‘The Company that made the Canberra’. That was the name of a bomber aircraft back in those days. The gist of the invention was the idea that when a rabbit popped up from a rabbit hole it would interrupt a light beam, causing a photocell to sense the presence of the rabbit and thereby cause a bell to ring. That would frighten the rabbit which would then withdraw and seek to escape by running to another exit hole. The electrocution device located at that hole was then to be triggered with a delay set according to the distance to the other hole and the known speed of travel of the rabbit, so that the rabbit would be duly killed. It was asserted that our engineers would have the technical skills needed to design such a device. Now, on the face of it, this communication was not intended as a joke, but you will agree that it ranks as one of the many inventions that does warrant ‘repression’.

    The last inventor encounter that I will mention here was more serious. It dates from 1955. An elderly German gentleman was shown into my office. He explained that he was very senior, having been a chief engineering designer of U-boats during World War II, and, though what he had to offer needed the attention of the company’s Managing Director, he said he was willing to speak to me in spite of my lowly position, just to secure introduction to the Company’s top management. Then he produced three letters by way of displaying his credentials and he folded each in turn as he presented them, one by one, across my field of view so that I could only read the signature on the letter. “You know Albert Einstein?”, he said, as my gaze saw Einstein’s signature. Then followed one signed by Max Planck and after that one signed by Heisenberg, both renowned physicists. That was enough to tell me that if they concerned something he had invented, his invention had been disclosed several years earlier. When I did a check later I found that, though Max Planck had lived well into is 80s, he had died in 1947.

    Next, fully knowing the answer to his question, he said: “You make diesel engines? Telephone the factory right away. Tell them to stop production. My invention will replace all such machines.”

    Eventually he produced a copious set of design drawings backed by calculations of thrust forces and reaction forces on turbine blades. He was talking about a gas turbine but he said it was one that could operate on a closed cycle, meaning that the gas was circulated around inside the engine and there was no exhaust. Now a gas turbine works by turbine blades which operate to compress the gas before it is heated further by combustion in a middle chamber and then it harnesses the power of the expanded gas to drive the main turbine blades. (In my engineering upbringing a ‘gas turbine’ was a developing technology distinct from that of the ‘steam turbine’.) My German visitor said he had designed a machine which developed a thrust force without needing any exhaust. If used on an aircraft it would have been a jet engine with no jet! On the face of it this was impossible and here I was confronted by extensive calculations by an expert who well understood thermodynamics and he was saying that there would be a thrust force if the engine was built. (As an aside here I note that I was not being blinded by scientific technicalities. I had graduated with high honours in my engineering studies and the thermodynamics of heat engines had been one of my final test subjects. But, equally, I was well versed in the physical principles which are embodied in Newton’s laws of mechanics. I also knew from my then-recent professional qualification in patents that there was a class of ‘invention’ that was denied patent protection – that which purports to offer prospect of ‘perpetual motion’.)

    My reaction to all this was to appear passive but yet sufficiently interested to be sure I understood exactly what he was saying about his design, intimating that we would consider his proposal and advise him of our interest.

    He left his data with me ‘to pass on for consideration by our engineering management’, but there was no need for that. When I later scanned through his analysis, looking for the fatal flaw that had to be there, somewhere, I could see that he had introduced flow channels for recirculating gas and omitted to allow for the fact that, besides the axial thrusts on the turbine blades, there are reaction forces set up when gas goes around a U-bend and is involved in pressure changes in those feedback flow channels. Those reaction forces would cancel any forward thrust. His invention would not work but, in line with usual practice, it was our company policy not to engage in argument about the merits of an outsider’s invention. He was duly informed by letter that our production facilities were so committed that the company just could not undertake any involvement with his invention. (I could add here that there had been an earlier encounter with an inventor by one member of our patent staff who had rejected an inventor’s proposal by letter telling him why it would not work. The response had been an invitation to a duel, albeit one which, on closer reading, meant a willingness to engage in a public debate on the merits of the invention. However, that had been enough to confirm the policy to which I was adhering.)

    In having taken no action to have our visitor’s invention proposal reviewed by engineers of our gas turbine section, it could be assumed that I had acted in a repressive way and perhaps unfairly. Yet I was doing my job to the best of my ability and, indeed, there are certain legal dangers in passing on outside inventor’s ideas to technical departments within a company without having in place certain contractual understandings. Yet I assure you that, had a meritorious invention crossed my desk in this way, it would have been looked at with more positive interest.

    REPRESSION OF THE FIRST KIND: GOVERNMENT SECRECY

    Based on that background, what I now come to is the invention of another German, someone I never did meet but would have been glad to meet. His name was Hans Coler. I do not know whether he had a patent but I can say that it was unlikely as I expect the German Patent Office would have thrown it out as being a claim for perpetual motion. It concerned the generation of electrical energy using magnets and I really do wish that knowledge of that invention had come to my attention in those early days of my career. I had a Ph.D. for research on an energy anomaly connected with electromagnetism so I would have been particularly interested. That invention is one that did work and yet it does seem to have been ‘repressed’ by Government intervention.

    Curiously, by a quirk of bad fortune, Mother Nature has done a little repression herself, because some months ago I had a tidy-up of my papers at home and now I cannot lay my hands on the Coler documentation when I need to in order to prepare these notes. I am therefore speaking from memory, but, because of a separate record I kept, which included a drawing, I can quote the reference of the official document should anyone like to check it. It is the subject of a British Intelligence Committee Report: B.I.O.S. Final Report No. 1043: Item No. 31, entitled: ‘THE INVENTION OF HANS COLER, RELATING TO AN ALLEGED NEW SOURCE OF POWER’. It was eventually, after declassification, available from the Department of Scientific and Industrial research, but presumably it is in quiet repose somewhere in the Government’s public archival records.

    The report is that of two experts, one U.K. Government scientist and one Norwegian army scientist, sent to Germany to see Hans Coler demonstrate the very substantial excess energy that he could generate from magnets when subjected to special current excitation conditions. The report explained how testimony from German professors confirmed that the invention did work and did generate power in a mysterious way. Evidence on that was part of the report, but the really fascinating aspect of this was that Hans Coler had, owing to the War (World War II), lost access to the equipment needed to give a demonstration. The necessary components were therefore brought in from England by those visiting scientists. Then, closely watched by the scientists, Coler wound coils around the magnets, made connections and assembled an array of six magnets in a loop with a small spacing between their poles and, lo and behold, the apparatus began to deliver power to light bulbs used as a load.

    The two scientists were there for several days making repeated observations and making detailed drawings and notes about the set-up, all of which are reported in that official report. The Coler invention had been seen as warranting promotion to help to sustain Germany’s energy needs during the war-time adversity. The report was put under British Government official secrecy and, having eventually surfaced, one can now read that the report recommended onward development and expert investigation of the device because it did perform to generate electricity with no evident input source of power. The problem, of course, was that neither those scientists, nor the German professors who had seen Coler’s earlier devices working, could understand the principles involved. One might even wonder whether Coler himself understood what he had discovered!

    [HERE MY LECTURE NOTES REQUIRED THAT I SHOW SOME FIGURES ON AN OVERHEAD VIEWER AND TALK ABOUT HOW THE WINDINGS CONNECT THROUGH THE MAGNETS. AS I WILL BE INCLUDING ELSEWHERE IN THESE WEB PAGES, A FULL LECTURE ON WHY THE COLER INVENTION REALLY WORKS, I WILL JUST PRESENT HERE THE FIGURE 2 WHICH APPEARS AT PAGE 31 OF BRITISH INTELLIGENCE OBJECTIVES SUB-COMMITTEE TRIP REPORT NO. 2394 (BIOS TARGET NUMBER: C31/4799.]

    I see the Coler invention as a mystery still needing solution. I only heard about it after I had myself addressed an energy conference in Canada in 1988 by declaring that I was beginning to see a way of tapping energy from the aether by exciting magnetic cores in an electric motor in a certain way. Someone who had heard about my talk was kind enough to send me a copy of that Hans Coler report which by then had found its way into the network of individuals interested in this emerging new energy field.
    So, I leave the Coler question as an open issue, by saying that I do see this as a ‘repressed invention’, at least until someone assures me that an organ of the British Government or some other such authority did probe deeper into the technology indicated in that secret report and reached a definitive conclusion on the Coler mystery. Possibly, with nuclear power on the horizon, the attentions of those looking for new energy sources in the aftermath of the war were diverted away from the Hans Coler situation. More likely, however, any committee which looked into the subject would adopt a consensus view that what was claimed could not be viable as it was contrary to long standing experience, so concluding that the file ought to be closed with the mystery unsolved.

    [Note, not part of the Fortean presentation: When eventually I did acquire access to another copy of the Coler report I found a reference to patents in a sentence at the bottom of its page 2, under the heading The “Stromerzeuger”:

    In 1925 Coler showed a small (10 watt) version to Prof. Kloss (Berlin), who asked the Government to give it a thorough investigation, but this was refused, as was also a patent, on the grounds that it was a “perpetual motion machine&quot. ]

    Press the link below to continue and move on to ‘REPRESSION OF THE SECOND KIND: PATENT OFFICE HOSTILITY’: