Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • THE PROPAGATION MEDIUM AND MAXWELL ANTENNA

    A MESSAGE FROM DAVE GIESKIENG

    I was sent this text by Dave Gieskieng in December 1998 coupled with a message which included the words: &quotI am counting on you to put the enclosed paper on Internet http:\\www.energyscience.co.uk” and I am here complying with that request as a token of respect for Dave, who has just reached his 80th birthday and is not in good health. I wish him well in this last year of the Millennium.

    Harold Aspden

    Dave is now deceased but his memory lives on, this webpage having been transferred to this website www.energyscience.org.uk which now replaces the www.energyscience.co.uk website.


    THE PROPAGATION MEDIUM AND MAXWELL ANTENNA

    Copyright, D. H. Gieskieng, 1999

    Logic suggests that there must be a propagation medium as a Maxwell carrier of radio waves, photons and other rays, and the make-up of electrons and other particles. The universality of such a medium and the long ranging of gravitational fields may indicate that anomalies in this medium, as caused by partial exclusion of it in the space occupied by particles or clumps or bodies of them, tend to gravitate or draw together. The familiar experiment of iron filings on a paper on a magnet does not illustrate a field that the magnet is exuding, but rather a strain that the magnet places on the adjacent medium. strain of the medium can also be caused by flow of electrons in a conductor, permitting rapid magnetic polarity reversal, inductors, transformers, and resonent antenna excitation. James Clerk Maxwell (1831-79) predicted radio waves having equal electric and magnetic components, or an impedance of 1 ohm.

    It is well known that the center of a resonant half wave dipole antenna has maximum current and little or no voltage, whereas as a condition of resonance the ends experience maximum voltage and little or no current. The fact that this high current or magnetic middle has been very successfully used in countless inverted-vee antennas by placing that portion of them as high as possible on a single mast and draping the ends, suggests that the propagation medium is a universally large neutral magnetic field. In such antennas it makes little difference that the high voltage ends are nearer the ground where increased absorption is probable, since the electric fields radiated from there are rather quickly lost anyway, being in excess of the long ranging Maxwellian radio wave requirement.

    The so called Maxwell antenna keeps the dipole center portion straight for a length corresponding to an average impedance of one ohm, or matching the impedance of waves in space that Maxwell predicted, and the two ends of the remaining half wave length required for resonance are brought away at right angles and parallel to each other, which in the manner of open transmission lines prevents radiation from the higher impedance portion of the excitation. Containing this excess portion prevents its waste in the amount of half the power, making it available to help drive the middle, or shorting bar, as well as significantly affecting the pattern of radiation, making it somewhat spherical.

    Within a distance of about 15 miles, most of the excess electric fields of a conventional dipole antenna or beams consisting of them are dissipated, but their closer presence has apparently led to an averaging of 377 ohms wave impedance, which is grossly greater than Maxwell’s prediction. As of 1994, authoritarian references on far out wave impedance is non-existent. Perhaps that a half wave dipole can be center fed with a 75 ohm line led to some mistrust of any concept that it could be as low as 1 ohm, but it must be remembered that a conventional dipole is also involved with excess electric field.

    The presence of the excess electric fields below a conventional dipole antenna greatly affects wave reflection and the lobe angle of the radiation, whereas this is absent with the Maxwell antenna. The conventional dipole antenna has very pronounced end-nulls because the high electric fields there are refractory to the passage of the Maxwellian waves. By keeping these electric fields out of the way the Maxwell antenna is omnidirectional in both the horizontal and vertical modes. It was its horizontal omnidirectivity that first aroused my interest. Many field tests with differently proportioned Maxwell antennas indicates that the radiation impedance of the shorting bar rises to 1 ohm from its center to its ends, regardless of a variety of transmission line spacings or conductor diameters.

    Fluorescent bulb surveys about the Maxwell antenna indicate that the electric fields swirl cylindrically around each leg of the transmission line portion, with the like charge repulsion effect keeping the swirls from touching, expanding and radiating. The indicated field at the open end of the line stops there very abruptly, and at the other end the 90o bends cause a distinction between the line and shorting bar fields. There is an electric null at the very center of the shorting bar, corresponding to the alternating current change of polarity, or that the field there is purely magnetic or zero impedance. The two antenna halves seem to image each other. If the shorting bar is vertical the radiated wave is vertically polarized, and if horizontal it is horizontally polarized. When the horizontal and vertical monitor antennas on Squaw Mountain were averaged the Maxwell antenna was omndirectionally one or two db stronger than the favored direction of six Denver area beams when plotted to the same height and distance.

    Photons, or elements of light, are generated by the orbit change of electrons in an atom, giving off a single electric pulse amounting to only a partial wavelength. It would seem that it inherits its initial speed of light velocity from the spin of the electron, and maintains it by electromagnetic oscillation with the propagation medium. Photons are thus both an electromagnetic wave and particle, and subject to gravitational pull, as Einstein discovered in the early 1900’s during an eclipse of the sun by variation of the normal star pattern near the sun.

    Also, within about the last decade, mechanical navigational gyros have been superseded by laser driven optical fiberglass coils, thus utilizing photon inertia. Since photons can escape from an electron, or be absorbed into it, it seems that an electron may be made up of a circular chain of photons. This means that an electron losing a photon would have a smaller more energetic circle, somewhat moderating its energy change characteristics. It also means that parts of an electron are dependent on some propagation medium about them to participate in their spinning, and that stable condition relates to the Compton Effect, providing a spatial distribution of electrons.

    Dr. Harold Aspden has calculated that there are 1760 such spatial charges per cubic meter. It appears that these hold themselves at bay equidistantly with some strength, and there arises the question if the excess electric fields from conventional dipole antennas result in wave straining of that spatial pattern, which close in is powerful, but dissipates within about 15 miles, as distinguished from the Maxwellian propagation medium wave, which like photons continues indefinitely.

    Michelson and Morley were disappointed in their experiments to try to Doppler photons by the motion of the earth through space, yet they might have been successful in finding that photons don’t Doppler, unlike continuous wave train whistles which deal with air having significant mass. The propagation medium is massless, with the exception of the spatial electron lattice, gravitational and magnetic strains, and in a traveling transition magnetically reacts with the electric component of the photon. This means that a photon leaving a distant celestial body will assume its free spectra and velocity as it leaves the influence of that body, and we should look for an explanation of the red-shift other than a Doppler causing Big Bang. Dr. Aspden has calculated that while a photon maintains its speed of light velocity, the tired light causing effect of the spatial electron lattice absorbs enough energy to explain it in terms of frequency decay with distance.

    NASA’s fairly recent experience with a tethered satellite provides an additional insight to spatial electrons. A small satellite was connected to an insulated wire, which was payed out from a shuttle for a distance of nearly 20 miles, when a defect in the insulation permitted an arc from the wire to the shuttle, severing the wire. It is suggested that like a person walking in dry slippers on a carpet causing sparks, that the small satellite picked up fewer spatial electrons than the much larger shuttle, and that the arc was an electron flow to equalize that disparity.

    Similarly both the earth and moon have swept up very sizeable electron charges, and the like charge repulsion effect keeps the moon from crashing into the earth, while the gravitational effect keeps it from sailing out into space. A notch effect, probably otherwise exhibited in planetary ring material. The original publication on the new antenna was in the Colorado School of Mines Alumnai Magazine, January 1981. In this it was surmized that its radiation was essentially magnetic, however, further testing revealed that as above there is an electric component making the wave impedance 1 ohm, or that its name is more than justified as being “Maxwell Antenna”. The antenna began as a need for a station device, but gradually its value as an evaluating tool became evident. Dr. Aspden has collected much of my test work and made it available on Internet at http:\\www.energyscience.co.uk\le\le10app.htm and I would appreciate his rewriting it using the name Maxwell Antenna instead of Gieskieng antenna, and as much of the foregoing as he sees fit. Since it treads some new ground, perhaps he should ask Nature’s think tank to carefully review it because of its potential importance. Its long ranging power economy is an integrated solid 3db, or 50%, and has given interesting initial beam results for further gain. I have just reached the age of 80 years, and must leave it to others.

    Postscript No. 1: In Einstein’s admirable work on the theory of relativity the matter of the propagation medium at his time would have been mostly a unity factor, and may have been left out to conserve space in his equations. However, as above, its inclusion is necessary to enable the Maxwellian electromagnetic cooperation required in the composition of photons and other rays, elements, radio waves, and gravity – including black hole anomalies.

    Postscript No. 2: Colorado School of Mines Professor John Klein, even while suffering from terminal colon cancer, favored me with a two hour meeting in which he assured me that Maxwell’s work was sacrosanct. While he was obviously in physical discomfort, he was still lucid and glad for the opportunity to share his knowledge.

    D. H. Gieskieng, W0FK (1st amateur license 1935. CSM EM ’41)
    9653 Rensselaer Dr.,
    Arvada, Colorado 80004,
    USA
    December 1, 1998


    The background to the above is the subject of LECTURE NO. 10: APPENDIX in these web pages, but see also ANTENNA FEEDBACK FROM DAVE GIESKIENG where the antenna form discussed above is illustrated.

    Harold Aspden
    January 1, 1999

  • COLD FUSION INDEX

    COLD FUSION INDEX

    Cold Fusion Items in These Web Pages

    Copyright © 1998 Harold Aspden

    The following is a contents list affording access to the Lectures and Essays in these Web pages that pertain to what is now known as ‘Cold Fusion’.

    LECTURE NO. 9 Supergravitons and Cold Fusion
    LECTURE NO. 13 What is Nuclear Fusion?
    LECTURE NO. 14 Cold Fusion: A War Story
    LECTURE NO. 15 The Opinion of a Patent Attorney
    ESSAY NO. 8 Cold Fusion: My Story: Part I
    ESSAY NO. 8A Cold Fusion: My Story: Part II
    ESSAY NO. 9 Cold Fusion appears in a U.S. Patent
    ESSAY NO. 9A A Breakthrough: U.S. Patent No. 5,734,122
    ESSAY NO. 10 Protons, Deuterons and Neutrons


    Harold Aspden
  • LECTURE NO. 32

    LECTURE NO. 32

    PIONEER 10/11 GRAVITATIONAL ANOMALY

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2002


    INTRODUCTION

    Towards the end of the previous Lecture No. 31 reference was made to the anomalous gravitational acceleration of the space craft Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11. Having written about the theory of gravitation in several of my published works and claimed for many years to have an insight into the true nature of the force of gravity in terms of electrodynamic theory, I was inevitably interested in that discovery. Within days of first reading about it at pp. 28-32 of the 20 July 2002 issue of the U.K. weekly periodical New Scientist, (article by Marcus Brown entitled ‘Strange Attraction’), I could see how this discovery gave support to my theory of published record and, on 15 August 2002, I duly sent a brief paper on the subject to the Editor of Physics Letters B who deals with cosmological topics, hoping that it might be accepted for peer review publication. His answer, dated 27 August, was simple and gave no substantive reason for rejection. The only words were:

    “I’m afraid I cannot accept your manuscript for publication in Physics Letters B.”

    This is an example of the attitude of those who judge the earnest efforts of an individual, efforts aimed solely at helping the scientific establishment to make sense of Nature’s mysteries and so improve our knowledge and, indirectly, lead to enhancement of our technological resources. Such is my introduction to this Lecture which I will now begin by presenting the full text of the paper I submitted.

    *************

    A NEW INSIGHT INTO THE PIONEER 10/11 GRAVITATION ANOMALY

    Harold Aspden

    Energy Science Ltd
    P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England
    h.aspden@physics.org
    Keywords: Pioneer 10/11, gravitation, anomalous acceleration, general relativity

    ABSTRACT

    The mysterious component of gravitational acceleration of 8.7 x 10-8 cm/s2 towards the sun experienced by Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11 is here explained as an effect attributable to retarded energy deployment in the gravitational field. The physical principles involved are well documented with regard to the gravitational interaction of Sun and planet but an essential modification seems to have been overlooked for the case of a space craft moving steadily away from the Sun.

    R. Foot and R.R. Volkas [1] have drawn attention to the anomalous acceleration of Pioneer 10 and 11 experienced in their outward travel away from the Sun. They have suggested that this may be due to the presence of ‘mirror matter’ in the solar system which would need of have a density of about 4×10-19 g/cm3. Such a suggestion seems rather speculative and is not mentioned in the detailed report of the anomaly recently presented by J.D. Anderson et al [2], where the conclusion is that: “The effect is clearly significant and remains to be explained”.

    It is noted that the latter report affirms that Pioneer 11 was at a distance of some 22 AU from the Sun on 1st January 1987 and the data relied upon was that from 5 January 1987 to 1st October 1990, but that the last communication from Pioneer 11 was received in November 1995 when it was approximately 40 AU from the Sun. It is said now to be moving off into outer space towards the constellation Sagittarius at a velocity of 11.6 km/s. However, the key factor of interest is the anomalous acceleration directed towards the Sun of (8.74 +/- 1.33)x10-8 cm/s2 that was measured and that poses the problem.

    This anomaly is quite small, being referenced on the expected gravitational pull of the Sun, which is presumably based on the GM/R2 factor as measured at a distance R of 1 AU from our knowledge of the Earth’s angular speed in orbit and our knowledge of that distance. Here G is the constant of gravitation and M is the mass of the Sun. Indeed, at 22 AU, this would mean an expected retardation acting on the space craft of 1.225×10-3 cm/s2. Though only discrepant by one part in 14,000, one does here face a mystery that has to be resolved, owing to its potential significance to our understanding of the nature of gravitation.

    The explanation may be found by heeding an assertion by Heaviside which dates from 1893: “To form any notion at all of the flux of gravitational energy, we must first localise the energy. Whether the notion will turn out to be a useful one is a matter for subsequent discovery”. This opinion was further endorsed by Brillouin [3] in his book ‘Relativity Reexamined’, which included this quotation as an intial preface to the work. The point is that, if it takes time for gravitational field energy to adjust to change of relative position of two interacting bodies, then, as a function of their motion, one might find that G, in effect, has a slightly different value in governing that motion. Note here that there is, indeed, a difference between the motion of our Earth in near circular orbit around the Sun and the motion of a spacecraft moving radially away from the Sun.

    The mention in the above abstract that the background to this is ‘well documented’ is a reference, for example, to a paper entitled ‘The inverse-square law of force and its spatial energy distribution’ [4], where it is shown that G as it applies between two masses M and m has a higher value given by GMm/R2 times the increment of R if there were no gravity force for the retardation period involved.

    For a planet in orbit around the Sun this is found to modify Newton’s law of gravitation and bring it into conformity with Einstein’s law of gravitation by which the anomalous perihelion motion of planet Mercury is explained, provided the effective speed at which energy traverses the distance R is 0.707 times the speed of light. The retardation time T is such that:

    T2 = 2(R/c)2 ………. (1)

    It was the subject of that paper to show how, in acting on Heaviside’s suggestion, this equation (1) is derived, it being self-evident that any energy transfer at the speed of light can hardly be confined to a narrow pathway drawn between the Sun and the planet. The analysis had regard to the deployment of gravitational potential energy in the whole of the field affected by the interaction and indicated that the mean route for energy travel between Sun and planet via the field had to be longer by the factor (2)1/2 than their separation distance. The implicit assumption was that adjustment of gravitational energy occurs by energy quanta moving at the same speed as the photon, the speed c of light.

    Thus one finds that the relevant increment of R is fT2/2, f being the acceleration v2/R, and this gives a change of gravitational energy potential by the factor (v/c)2 in the case of Sun and planet interaction, v being the speed of the planet in its orbit.

    For the case under consideration, a spacecraft moving away from the Sun at a relative speed v, this energy retardation factor has the effect of increasing the gravitational potential by the factor vT/R or (2)1/2(v/c). Being a linear term instead of one of second order, this is far more significant than the term in (v/c)2 that applies to the planetary case.

    Note that a speed of Pioneer 11 of 15 km/s would then be needed to imply an enhanced pull of gravity amounting to 7.07×10-5 times 1.225×10-3 at 22 AU, which is 8.7×10-8 gm/s2, the median value measured. Although the relevant speed may have then been a little lower than 15 km/s, the loss of energy in escaping from the Sun’s gravitational field is in reasonable accord with that reduction to onward travel through space at 11.6 km/s and the argument here does point to the fact that observed anomaly is in some substantial measure explained by the energy retardation effect under discussion.

    It is submitted that in considering anomalies such as that posed by the Pioneer 10/11 observations, cosmologists, in applying the theory of gravity, should put more emphasis on the analysis of energy deployment and not just concentrate attention on the gravitation as a law of force defined by the standard formulation. The Appendix below, which summarizes in a reversed order the analysis of record in reference [4], warrants attention in this regard.

    APPENDIX

    Given Einstein’s law of gravitation:

    d2u/dφ2 + u = GM/h2 + 3GM(u/c)2 …… (2)

    which is an equation expressed in polar co-ordinates (u,φ), where u is 1/R and h is vR, we will deduce how the latter term, which is the addition to the corresponding formulation of Newton’s law of gravitation, relates to an energy factor.

    Note that h is constant, since angular momentum of unit mass acted upon in accordance with this law is conserved. It becomes a force equation if we multiply throughout by v2, the force being on unit mass.

    Writing u as 1/R that latter term is seen to be:

    3(GM/h2)(v/c)2 …………… (3)

    which implies that the force acting on unit mass is greater than Newton’s instantaneous action-at-a-distance law by the small factor 3(v/c)2.

    Now we are interested in the significance of this in energy terms and so we must integrate force with respect to R. This means multiplying by v2 and then replacing v by h/R before integrating 3(GM/h2)(1/R)4(h/c)2 to obtain an energy quantity per unit mass of magnitude GM/R times (v/c)2. Thus (v/c)2 is the factor by which the magnitude of the effective gravitational energy potential is increased owing to the retardation associated with the flow of gravitational field energy associated with the motion of a planet around the Sun.

    REFERENCES

    [1] R. Foot & R.R. Volkes, Physics Letters B, 517, 13-17 (2001).
    [2] J.D. Anderson, P.A. Laing, E.L. Lau, A.S.Liu, M.M. Nieto & S.G.Turyshev, Physical Review D, 65, 082004-39 (2002).
    [3] L. Brillouin, Relativity Reexamined (New York: Academic Press) 1970.
    [4] H. Aspden, J. Phys. A:Math. Gen, 13, 3649-3655 (1980).

    ********

    DISCUSSION

    Now, of course, one cannot argue with an Editor under these circumstances. One might, however, wonder why one’s submission is rejected in such an off-hand way and think that it could not be owing to the paper being too long or lacking in professional style and content. Nor can one really believe it was sent to the wrong periodical, bearing in mind that its first reference dated 2001 was a speculative contribution on the same subject that appeared in Physics Letters B. Accordingly, one inevitably tends to the view that the paper does not convey confidence owing to the author not declaring an appropriate affiliation as implied by a university address or an address of a laboratory of repute primarily concerning with space projects.

    Therefore, it is natural to suspect that the system which now governs progress on matters scientific is less democratic than those in government who fund scientific research on space probes and the like and research projects in the realm of cosmology might assume. Hopefully, however, the truths that underlie our scientific principles will surface in due course and, meanwhile, in spite of vast wastage of our resources, those of us who try to enhance the state of knowledge will just have to soldier on and accept the facts of life as they really are on the frontiers of science.

    I intend in this Lecture to delve rather deeply into the physics which governs the phenomenon of gravitation and its link with electromagnetism but I will argue from a new starting point on the basis that unification of ‘field’ theory can evolve from any part of the spectrum covered by that theory.

    Whereas, in my previous writings, I have sought to build my case without reliance on any of Einstein’s doctrinaire teaching but have begun from a standpoint that accepts the existence of the aether, I will instead begin here from the standpoint of an astronomical observation of recognized significance. This is the anomalous component of the perihelion precession of the planet Mercury, which is known to be 43 seconds of arc per century and cannot be explained by strict adherence to Newton’s basic law of gravitation.

    This gravitational anomaly was recognized in the latter part of the 19th century long before Einstein emerged on the scene and was attributed to a retardation of gravitational action by a German school teacher, Paul Gerber, who formulated the orbital motion of planet Mercury and showed how that 43 second of arc per century measured emerged from that formulation. [P. Gerber, Zeitschrift f. Math. u. Phys., 43, 93 (1898)].

    Now, calculation of field retardation effects, however rigorous the mathematics and however impressive the analysis might appear, seldom seem to give answers that fit what is actually observed and so, by 1916 when Einstein’s general theory of relativity did confront that perihelion anomaly, it is not surprising that fault was found with Gerber’s theory. Gerber was no longer alive to defend his work. However, both Gerber and Einstein relied on the facts of observation, that 43 second of arc per century anomaly, and, rather than beginning by taking sides as between the Gerber or Einstein methods, I will begin here by accepting as an empirical starting point the equation of planetary motion that matches that anomalous advance of perihelion.

    The relevant equation is equation (2) above. Note that it is a simple equation expressed in two space dimensions defined by the orbital plane of the planet about the Sun. It is not a four-space formulation, but one that portrays what can be seen through an astronomical telescope and by plotting the motion of the planet. It is, as noted above, an equation that merely relates to position and motion, albeit becoming a force equation once multiplied by velocity squared, the action of gravity usually being considered as a force rather than an action that concerns deployment of energy.

    Now, at this stage one cannot say much about the nature and origin of that force without looking into the question of how energy gets into the act. As seen above, it needs a mathematical step of integration to assess the energy factors involved. The conclusion is simple. The anomaly evidenced by the planet Mercury, noticed owing to its extremely elliptical orbit, is simply attributable to its gravitational potential being affected by a factor (v/c)2, where v is its velocity and c is the speed of light. That, therefore, is a fact of observation in no way affected by the choice of one’s underlying theoretical assumptions. So far we need not chose between the Gerber or Einstein hypotheses, namely ‘retardation’ versus ‘curvature of space by four-dimensional criteria’.

    The factor c comes into play in both of these hypothetical situations. For Gerber there is his assumption that energy needed to cater for the change of speed of the planet travels between Sun and planet at the speed of light along a path drawn directly between the two bodies. For Einstein the factor c creeps into the analysis by invoking a fourth space dimension where distance is expressed as ct, t being ‘time’.

    The way forward then is for those who accept Einstein’s theory of gravitation to see how best they can explain the new gravitational anomaly problem posed by Pioneer 10/11, which is quite a formidable task, and, for those who favour the retardation theme, to see where that leads. Alternatively, short of imagining the existence of gravitating matter dispersed in what we deem to be empty space, one cannot see much scope for solving the mystery, though that factor c might seem to apply if radiation pressure is involved. That radiation would, however, have to act towards the Sun, rather than be directed away from the Sun. Accordingly, I favour the retardation theme.

    In discussing the effect of retardation I am going to assume that one must focus on the amount of energy that is in transit as part of the gravitational interaction. I am guided in this by insight into the processes at work that account for the electromagnetic interaction between moving electric charges, a subject I shall discuss later in this Lecture. In a sense, I see the force of gravity as depending upon energy transfer akin to that involved in electromagnetic radiation with its attendant reaction forces, a process which brings into play that speed factor c.

    The transit energy involved in the gravitational energy flows either from an interacting body or to an interacting body and the amount of transit energy is a governing quantity. Being a depletion of gravitational energy potential, itself a negative quantity, its presence must be accompanied by a corresponding increase in the magnitude of that potential. This enhances the value of G, the constant of gravitation, in corresponding proportion.

    One may then reason that, if the action of gravity were to become instantaneous, that transit energy would become zero and G would have a slightly smaller value. This would allow the interacting bodies, if Sun and planet, to separate as the planet moves to an orbit of larger radius. The work done in so separating will, therefore, be equal to the transit energy released.

    With R now being the radius of the planet’s orbit and so approximating the separation distance between Sun and planet, the standard basic equation of planetary motion tells us that GR is constant, given that the planet’s velocity moment is conserved as is its angular momentum in orbit. If GR is constant a proportional increase of G by a small factor δ will be matched by a corresponding decrease of R and vice versa. The energy change for G so increased is then given by:

    -2δGMm/R + 2δ(mv2/2) ….. (4)

    because v2 is inversely proportional to R2 owing to that conservation of velocity moment. So a decrease in R by the factor δ will become a two-fold increase in v2, by the factor 2δ, whereas G/R will also increase by the factor 2δ.

    Since GMm/R2 is equal to mv2/R, the change of energy is, therefore, a reduction by the amount (GMm/R)δ. Accordingly, this is the amount of energy that is shed and transferred into transit energy upon G increasing by that factor δ. Conversely, the decrease of G, if retardation action ceased and instantaneous gravitational action resumed, implies an increment of R by that same factor, which would absorb that amount of energy by transferring it from its transit state to expand the planet’s orbit against the opposition of the gravity force.

    In effect, retardation causes the planet to fall into a lower orbit. In so falling it is in free fall for a period T under the gravitational force GMm/R2 which we write as mf. Accordingly, it will fall through a distance fT2/2, which is δR, f being GM/R2 or v2/R. One therefore can write the equation:

    δ = (vT/R)2/2 …… (5)

    Now, as was shown above from empirical evidence of planetary motion, the factor δ is simply (v/c)2 and so one finds from equation (5) that T has a value given by:

    T2 = 2(R/c)2 …… (6)

    The paper above concerning Pioneer 10/11 applied this same retardation time factor to the gravitational anomaly observed, the δ factor applicable there being related to the distance of the space craft from the Sun, according to distance travelled at the speed of the space craft in the retardation time T indicated by equation (6). The result does confirm the retardation theory here presented. However, the point of interest now to be addressed concerns the physics which determines that time factor T, as this tells us a great deal about the nature of the force of gravity and particularly about its connection with electromagnetism.

    Here I stress the point that in justifying the formulation of equation (6) by physics not dependent upon the empirical evidence of the anomalous advancing motion of the planet’s perihelion, I offer an explanation for that phenomenon which in no way depends upon Einstein’s theory of general relativity. Of itself that may not impress a scientific community content to rely on the Einstein interpretation. However, unless Einstein’s theory can somehow embrace the problem of the Pioneer 10/11 anomaly, in a way which matches the success of the above method, that scientific community is left wandering in the wilderness on this gravitational issue. Furthermore, such wanderers still await the coming of Unified Field Theory and enlightenment on how electromagnetism can account for the force of gravity.

    With that objective in mind I will now address the problem of retardation in the context of the electromagnetic interaction.

    ANOMALY IN ELECTRODYNAMICS

    The most incredible anomaly of all in physics is one which persists in the field of electrodynamics. It is ignored by the theoretical physicist simply because everyone seems to think that the basics of electrical science are so well established that there is nothing that can now be questioned. It is no wonder, therefore, that the unifying link between gravitation and electromagnetism remains a mystery.

    Every physicist well knows that the key law of electrodynamic action is that bearing the name of Lorentz. It simply has to be correct because it conforms with Einstein’s theory! Yet all it tells you is that the magnetic force acting on a moving electric charge is directed at right angles to that motion. We calculate the strength of the magnetic field and know that it acts on moving charge, electric current in a conductor for example, and merely pushes it in a direction lateral to that motion.

    Every physicist also knows that there is another law bearing the name of Lenz. This states that when a conductor moves with respect to a magnetic field, the currents induced in the conductor are in such a direction that the reaction between them and the magnetic field opposes the motion. So somehow, the secret being hidden in the meaning of that word ‘induced’, that magnetic field can push on the current in such a way that it causes the current to increase or decrease, meaning that forces act on it in its direction of motion, hardly something one might expect, given the unquestioned validity of the Lorentz force law.

    However, laws are laws and facts are facts and physics is based on emprical evidence, so we find a way of choosing which laws we apply, according to the nature of the problem at hand, and we get by, in testimony of which one can point to the remarkable success of our technology concerning matters electrical.

    Still, the problem of understanding the force of gravity remains and so I will now be more specific in pointing to the anomaly in question.

    It concerns the seat of magnetic field energy and the deployment of that energy given relative motion between two interacting electric charges that move in what we refer to as the electromagnetic reference frame.

    I am aiming to account for gravitation in terms of electromagnetic action and, guided by that empirical retardation equation (6) above, I intend to see how magnetic field energy distributes itself in the space enveloping two interacting electric charges in motion. We know the formula for the strength and direction of a magnetic field set up by charge in motion and so can work out how two superimposed fields will combine and from that, looking solely at the interaction components, we can determine the magnetic field energy density at all points in space. That is a logical thing to do and no new physics is involved. It is an extremely easy undertaking for the very simple case of two such charges moving along a common straight line, spaced apart, one behind the other. It could be a student task, a mere mathematical exercise, and surely one that many a physicist has already undertaken. But one really must wonder, given the result which emerges, and the fact that no one has screamed at those who teach electrical science, pointing to the result which refutes what is taught.

    Based on Fig. 1, which depicts two charges separated by a distance z and deemed to move in the same direction and so in a mutually parallel sense along a straight line drawn between them, we will now calculate the magnetic energy of their mutual interaction.

    At the point P the combined magnetic fields of both charges is:

    qvsinθ/x2 + q’v’sinφ/y2 ….. (7)

    and, if we square this and divide by 8π, considering only the interacting components, we obtain an field energy density at P for the interaction of:

    (qq’vv’/4π)sinθsinφ/x2y2 ……. (8)

    To integrate this over a region of space we need to define an elemental volume. This we take as the volume bounded by rotating the area defined by the sectors dθ and dφ around the axis of z, which is:

    (2πxsinθ)(xdθ)(ydφ)/sin(θ+φ) …. (9)

    This simplifies by using the trigonometrical relationship:

    ysin(θ+φ) = zsinθ ……. (10)

    to become:

    2π(xy)2dθdφ/z …….. (11)

    Upon multiplying (8) and (11) one finds the elemental energy term to be integrated. It is:

    (qq’vv’/2z)sinθsinφdθdφ ……. (12)

    Integrating over all space, first with respect to φ from 0 to π-θ, and then with respect to θ from 0 to π, one obtains:

    qq’vv’/z …….. (13)

    This is the total magnetic field energy associated with the interaction of the two electric charges moving, one behind the other, along a straight line, given their spacing z. The magnetic field of one acts on the moving charge of the other and vice versa but, by the Lorentz force law, there is no electromagnetic force component acting on either along that common line. So one should be able to have a change of z without there being any force resisting that change, other than that of their electrostatic interaction, which for flow of electron charge as current along a wire is cancelled out by the presence of positive charge which does not move inside the wire.

    Keep in mind that standard theory tells you that there is no magnetic field at any point along the z axis and so a rate of change of magnetic field cannot be said to induce an EMF which applies a force on the charges.

    So, our hypothetical student, has then every right to ask his teacher how equation (13) can avoid implying the existence of forces acting on the charges in their line of motion, given that the associated energy must change with change of z. Clearly, there is conflict in what we have been taught at school and university concerning electromagnetic action. This is a serious anomaly and one which is surely bewildering in its magnitude, surviving as it has for many generations of those seeking to find that Holy Grail of physics, the Unified Field Theory.

    THE WAY FORWARD

    Let us now ask how that interaction component of magnetic field energy in the example just considered is deployed in space. How much of it exists, for example, within a range z of either moving charge? In this case the range of integration for φ is from 0 to π/2-θ/2. The first integration stage gives the expression:

    – (qq’vv’/2z)sinθ[sin(θ/2) – 1]dθ

    which can be written in the form:

    – (qq’vv’/2z)[2sin(θ/2)cos(θ/2)][sin(θ/2) – 1]dθ

    or:

    (qq’vv’/2z)[4][sin2(θ/2) – sin(θ/2)]dsin(θ/2]

    whereupon the second integration stage gives:

    (qq’vv’/2z)[4][1/3 – 1/2]

    which is a final result for the magnetic interaction energy within the range z of either charge of:

    qq’vv’/3z ……….. (14)

    I have presented this analysis to show the reader that, at least for one specific type of interaction between two electric charges in motion, the magnetic field energy is deployed in such a way as to involve forces between the two charges that are contrary to what is specified by the Lorentz force law. Furthermore, of the total magnetic energy involved in that interaction, one third exists within a range of either charge equal to their separation distance. One has therefore to wonder how this energy deployment in space affects forces as a function of retardation effects attributable to energy taking time to distribute itself in the field when the charges change position.

    Our empirical analysis of the gravity problems, Pioneer 10/11 and the anomalous perihelion motion of planet Mercury, suggest a retardation by a mean time factor formulated in equation (6). The question we now face is whether what we have just investigated concerning deployment of magnetic field energy has anything in common with that gravitational problem.

    To proceed within the framework of standard physics one can seek to plot the distribution of that field energy in terms of distance from either charge, assuming different component actions which can be combined for any situation. The components are (i) the case where v, v’ and z are all mutually parallel, the case just considered, (ii) the case where v and z are mutually parallel but v’ is orthogonal to both and (iii) the case where v and v’ are mutually parallel but z is orthogonal to both. This involves tedious calculation which will not be pursued here. The interested reader can refer to the published paper on the subject. It was entitled:

    ‘The Spatial Distribution of the interaction Contribution to the Magnetic-Field Energy associated with Two Moving Charges’

    and appeared in Acta Physica Polonica Vol. A 57 pp. 473-482 (1980). Although I am a co-author, the main effort involved in performing the necessary calculations was that of Dr. D. M. Eagles of the National Measurement Laboratory, CSIRO, Sydney, Australia, as assisted on computer programming by P. Lalousis of that laboratory. The analysis reported is formal and rooted in accepted physics and so is beyond debate as to its validity.

    For the three component situations, each indicated that beyond a radius z drawn from either interacting charge, the interaction component of magnetic energy diminished as a function of distance in inverse square proportion but the relationship was linear within the range to z. For the specific case of our above example the energy distribution was as shown in Fig. 2. However, for the other two cases, the linear section was negative, meaning that there was a discontinuity at radius z, a very curious circumstance indeed.

    Fig. 2

    For my part, I was led to conclude that the energy distribution of Fig. 2, for which one can verify that one third of the total energy lies within the range z, has a ring of truth about it, whereas the other two cases seem illogical, in spite of being rigorously founded in our standard teaching concerning magnetic field theory. One must suspect that all is not well with our understanding of electromagnetic theory and that glaring example posed by the anomaly discussed above tells us just that!

    Nevertheless, looking solely at that Fig. 2 energy distribution, I invite the reader to examine what it implies concerning the retardation theme.

    Keep in mind that inertial, as opposed to frictional, retardation involves actions that tend to be governed by the square of the time involved. This means that, in working out a mean retardation time for the action by which energy change occurs in that range up to the separation distance z, we must evaluate the root mean square of the elemental time components. So, given that all the action occurs over that limited range z, if the energy distribution within that range is linear, being proportional to x at radius x, with x as the distance to travel from charge to field, the root mean square of the integral of x3dx divided by the square root of the integral of xdx over the range 0 to x gives the effective distance of travel. Upon evaluation, this is r/(2)1/2. The retardation time then could be the time taken to travel this distance from one charge to the field at speed c plus the time to make a similar return journey between the field and the other charge. This gives a retardation time T for which:

    T2 = 2 (r/c)2

    exactly, as we found empirically for the gravitational action in derving equation (6).

    An alternative giving the same result is for the action to involve one-way energy transit as between the field and either of the interacting elements, in which case the transit energy speed would be c/2. This could well be possible, for two reasons which I shall discuss in the next Lecture.

    We can therefore conclude from this that we have here a link connecting gravitation and electromagnetism, one that has experimental foundation, if we can classify the Pioneer 10/11 measurements and the Mercury perihelion observations as experimental.

    The way forward, in delving into the problem of gravitation and its unification with electromagnetic theory, now depends on our coming to terms with the problems inherent in our standard teaching concerning electrodynamics. Physicists do not have a clear insight into the way in which two electric charges in motion interact electrodynamically. All their experiments giving empricial foundation for their physical laws on the subject concern actions based on situations where at least one component of the interaction is an electric current carried around a closed circuit.

    Accordingly, in the next Lecture No. 33, I shall deal with the question of how energy is actually fed into a magnetic field, something that is not discussed in our textbooks on physics. Yes, I do know that if one has a coil of wire linked by an alternating magnetic field and forming a closed circuit through a resistor, then energy will transfer into the activation of current flow in that coil of wire and that resistor, the circuit controlling that alternating field supplying that energy. The question, however, is not: “What happens?” but: “How does it happen?” How can a magnetic force which always acts at right angles to the motion of electric charge impart momentum that drives that charge at a higher speed? How can our concept of rate of magnetic flux change linking a closed loop circuit, as a means for inducing an EMF in that circuit, be relevant to action on an isolated moving electric charge?

    I submit that until we know enough about electrodynamic action to answer such questions we have no hope of discovering how to embrace the gravitational action and electromagnetic action within one unified field theory. We must probe deeper into the basic foundations of electrical science. Indeed, having shown elsewhere how one can derive the constant of gravitation G in terms of the charge-mass ratio of the electron, it may seem that I have lost confidence in my methods, but that is not so. It is just that, in retracing my steps, I can occasionally see in retrospect a better way in which to clarify what is involved, whilst pointing the finger at the cracks in standard theory that physicists have glossed over or ignored. Rather than saying: “Eureka, I have discovered something”, I am now saying: “See where you have gone wrong and listen to a voice which can help you out of your dilemma.”

    This Lecture should make you wonder about the notion that space is curved and cause you to accept instead the effects of retardation, not of so-called vector potentials but of energy flow, given that energy is moving and that it cannot move faster than the speed of light. Yet, to be sure, there is a feature of the fabric of space that does imply instantaneous action at a distance in electric field theory, but that does not mean action involving energy transfer at infinite speed. It means instead that Nature has a way of keeping in step, holding to a strict (universal) time schedule, even where the separation distance is enormous, because it would need a too great a change of energy to alter the state of things.

    ******************

    H. Aspden
    August 30, 2002


  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le31 Perpetual

    LECTURE No. 31

    THE ENGINEER’S ANATHEMA: PERPETUAL MOTION
    © H. Aspden, 2002

    Professional engineers well know that there is no such thing as ‘perpetual motion’, but we do,
    from time to time, even in this 21st century, hear of those who claim to be able to produce
    motive power as if from nowhere, seemingly in defiance of the Principle of Energy
    Conservation. It surely implies a lack of education in physics and Newton’s laws which
    govern mechanics. Even so, the professional engineer cannot rely too much on physics,
    especially the kind of physics that has evolved from Einstein’s efforts, because there are those
    who see that as pointing a way forward to the day when we can travel through time by
    tunnelling through ‘worm holes’ in the fabric of ‘space-time’ having more than the three space
    dimensions one sees in the engineer’s field of view.

    When Newton devised his laws of mechanics his field of view looking across the surface of
    body Earth may have included the occasional windmill, something that could be seen as
    perpetual motion if one were secluded in a room with a window and had never been outside
    and sensed the power of moving air. One needs to understand the source of the energy input
    to avoid being deceived by the semblance of a device that runs with no power input.

    One may then wonder if we have moved far enough on from Newton’s time, given that we are
    now led to understand that those windmills are seen as our hope for salvation. It is stated on
    page 40 of the July 2002 issue of Physics World, the monthly journal of the Institute of
    Physics, that:

    “The total wind-power resources available offshore are vast – easily enough to
    supply all of Europe’s electricity. Several studies have shown that wind power
    could supply at least one-fifth of our electricity needs by 2010.”

    2010 is not that far into the future, bearing in mind that on February 4th,1923 J.B.S. Haldane
    read a paper to the Society of Heretics in Cambridge which included the passage:

    “Personally, I think that 400 years hence the power question in England may be
    resolved somewhat as follows: The country will be covered by rows of metallic
    windmills working electric motors which in their turn supply current at very
    high voltage to great electric mains. At suitable distances, there will be great
    power stations where, during windy weather, huge reservoirs of liquified gases
    will enable wind energy to be stored, so that it can be expended for industry,
    transportation, heating and lighting, as desired … no smoke or ash will be
    produced.”

    Now, it is not intended here to decry the future prospect of meeting our energy needs by
    harnessing wind-power, nor is it intended to support the bland notion of ‘perpetual motion’,
    but there is something that we engineers should understand concerning Newton’s Laws of
    Motion. There are three such laws, the third law being the one which assures us that Action
    and Reaction are equal and opposite, meaning that there is no way of generating a propulsive
    force without having something external to push against, be it the exhaust gas of a jet engine
    or whatever. There is, however, also a fourth consideration which we know as ‘Newton’s
    Rule’. It is a proposition proved by derivation based on that third law plus the Principle of
    Conservation of Energy. That ‘rule’ asserts that two colliding bodies will separate with a
    relative velocity that has the same magnitude as the relative velocity upon collision but has its
    direction reversed. What this means is that if one squares the relative velocities the result is
    the same before and after impact, meaning that something that is a function of the relative
    velocity squared is itself conserved upon impact. That ‘something’ is energy, but energy of a
    form that was not known in physics in Newton’s time.

    A little consideration will then show that, had Newton asserted his ‘rule’ as a law, then by
    appealing to the Principle of Conservation of Energy he could have deduced instead the ‘rule’
    that action equals reaction. The point one can now make is that Newton’s Third Law need
    not be sacrosanct and can be broken if one has a situation where energy can be deployed, not
    at the moment of collision and immediate separation, but by an interaction across space
    separating the two bodies. This puts us in the realm of electrodynamics, where one
    encounter’s the Neumann Potential and can trace its association to a 19th century proposition
    known as Fechner’s Hypothesis by which one can derive the energy potential of two
    interacting electric charges in motion as being a function of the square of their relative
    velocities. Furthermore, electrodynamics involves so-called ‘field energy’ which is energy
    seated in whatever it is that we refer to as the ‘vacuum’, but which used to be called the
    ‘aether’. Can one ever hope to find a way of pushing against that aether and, in so doing,
    tapping some of its energy?

    The mechanical engineer has, therefore, to yield a little ground to the electrical engineer who
    should struggle to understand the blatant breach of Newton’s Third Law evident from the
    daily use of the Lorentz force law, a law of electrodynamics that tells you that the
    electromagnetic force acting on a moving charge is always directed at right angles to the
    charge motion. You have only to consider two charges spaced apart laterally but moving along
    sharing a mutually parallel motion at the same speed, but one being somewhat ahead of the
    other, and you will see that action cannot equal reaction. There will be a turning couple set up
    by the interaction of the two charges.

    The electrical engineer is not aware of this because he deals with current flow in closed
    circuits where this anomaly has a way of cancelling itself out and the physicist has avoided all
    debate on this issue, which puts the Lorentz force law in question, because the Lorentz
    formulation is supported by Einstein’s theory. However, might one not begin to wonder about
    purported claims concerning ‘perpetual motion’ if they concern apparatus which has unusual
    electrodynamic features? Might one not wonder, just a little, given the search for that Holy
    Grail, the theoretical physicist’s desire to unify the theory of gravitation and the theory of
    electrodynamics, whether there can be anomalies akin to ‘perpetual motion’ claims that
    concern levitation and unorthodox methods of propulsion?

    Accordingly, much as ‘perpetual motion’ can be seen by the professional engineer as
    warranting ridicule, an accursed thing and so an anathema, there is the glimmer of a possibility
    that we may have missed something. Whether our future will come to depend upon windmills
    or whether it will offer us travel forward and back through time as we penetrate those ‘worm
    holes’ in the warps of Einstein’s space-time metric remains to be seen, as may the advent of
    machines which run on a supply of energy drawn from the aether.

    So let us take stock and just listen to the voices that speak of ‘free energy’ or, if that does not
    appeal to the reader, let us simply drift along and be satisfied by what we read in the monthly
    magazines sent to us by our professional institutions. These words are written in August
    2002, the month in which ‘Professional Engineering’ told us on page 3 that various articles in
    that issue “confirm what most people know, but few people want to talk about, that Britain,
    like may other nations, is facing long-term energy crisis …. but, despite the enormity of this
    issue, there seems to be little intelligent debate as to how we will replace these energy sources
    … so it is easier to let the issue drift for another day.”

    An illustration of three windmills was adjacent those words, as was the following statement:
    “Only last month plans to build some of Britain’s biggest wind farms were halted after a court
    upheld Ministry of Defence objections that the turbines affected radar systems. As a result, up
    to two-thirds of the country and vast areas of the sea could be off limits to what is seen as one
    of the most hopeful sources of renewable energy.” So you see, Haldane’s 1923 vision of
    windmill power as the ultimate answer has been thwarted by our need to preserve the later
    discovery of wave power, electromagnetic wave power, that gave us the power to look ahead
    just a few minutes into the future to the see approach of a hostile intruder.

    The alternative scenario, the theme of ‘free energy’ has its own history, dating back to the
    days of Nikola Tesla early in the 20th century, when he tried to convince those in authority in
    USA concerned with power generation that we should tap energy from the aether by setting
    up towers used for electromagnetic wave transmission, meaning real power and not just
    enough for radio communication. Later he was reputed as having demonstrated a car, his
    ‘Pierce Arrow’ car project of 1931 which ran, allegedly, on energy supplied via the aether,
    though history has not bequeathed to us the secret of the technology as to how he did this,
    except that he may have incorporated some electronic components to generate a high voltage.

    Dating from that time there are the well documented records of demonstrations by Dr Henry
    Moray who showed, quite convincingly, that his electric apparatus, as transported by
    automobile to a remote desert location well removed from power lines, could, with the help of
    an antenna mounted a few metres above ground draw enough electric power to illuminate
    many light bulbs and even operate an electric iron. Again, notwithstanding his openness in
    making many such demonstrations, we have not inherited the detail that underlies that
    technology.

    Accordingly, there are amongst us those who, even as qualified engineers, dabble in this area
    of research, seeking for clues that can open the flood gates on a new energy source. The task
    is a daunting one, partly because it is a field which attracts interest only from those who do not
    earn their living as experts on power technology. To put it bluntly, given that anyone who
    might even pay attention to, or give voice to, the idea that one can get a sustainable source of
    energy from the aether or our ambient surroundings, is deemed a crackpot lacking education
    on the basic principles of physics and so would be seen as an outcast by his peers, there is no
    hope. No one in authority will listen to such ideas and be willing to fund research in this field.
    Given also that investors who are themselves scientifically unqualified need proof of viability,
    as endorsed by experts who in turn need to sustain their reputation and credibility, one cannot
    look in that direction for funding nor is it proper for this important but ill-defined research
    field to be left at the mercy of ad hoc ventures of this kind.

    However, so far as our United Kingdom interests are concerned, it is not money and
    investment that afford the means for moving ahead. There is, instead, as Lee Hibbert states on
    that page 3 of the August 2002 issue of ‘Professional Engineering’, simply a need to
    “provoke some serious, wider debate on the issue of Britain’s future energy supplies” but “at
    the centre of that debate must be engineers – the only people capable of delivering the
    solutions.” The proviso, however, must also be that, in widening the debate, provision is
    made for the voices of those who are professionally qualified engineers but happen to have
    views on ‘unconventional’ alternative sources of energy, as guided by the influence of factors
    not embraced by the strict rule of law that dominates our formal indoctrination concerning
    energy.

    That reference above to Newton’s rule and Newton’s Third Law of Motion is an example of
    the kind of nuance in the background to our formal training that could be important. It has a
    counterpart in electrodynamics, as already mentioned, but which emerges technologically as
    the anomaly observed by electric discharges in ionized gas, where there is an unaccountable
    back-reaction force on the cathode of the cold arc discharge – the technology of the mercury
    arc rectifier of the early years of the 20th century. One needs therefore to be attentive to those
    who claim excess power generation from electrical apparatus that incorporates discharge tubes
    containing gas at quite low pressure. Two such devices, one claimed by an inventor in U.K.
    [1] and one by inventors in Canada [2], have been demonstrated and been granted U.S.
    patents, but the world has yet to benefit from their onward development, seemingly suppressed
    by lack of interest in the right quarters. At least the debate should welcome those with
    technical opinions on the factors at work in such devices.

    There is also of record an example of a case involving thermodynamic principles, one
    demonstrated here in U.K., in Edinburgh, Scotland, some 12 years ago, but now buried in
    history [3]. It was something discovered as spin-off from some piezoelectric research
    concerned with a device helpful in a clinical application. The slightest heat input made an
    electrical circuit unexpectedly responsive. Eventually, what emerged from a little ingenuity in
    probing that phenomenon was a component little greater in size than a stack of three 50p coins
    mounted on a heat sink base, which, when a small ice cube was placed on it, delivered from
    that component a small amount of electric power, but an amount sufficient to run an electric
    model motor driving a model aircraft propellor. The ice melted much more quickly than for
    the case where the motor was disconnected, but for several minutes, and here the small
    temperature difference of 20o C was converting the latent heat of ice into electrical power.
    Research effort on this was abandoned owing to lack of investment interest and, after several
    months of testing, the evident deterioration of the component, the reason for the latter never
    being resolved.

    However, one had to wonder how the laws of thermodynamics could explain
    what was observed. The energy input was heat energy drawn into the ice from the heat sink
    and so the room temperature environment, much of that heat energy being merely conducted
    through the component, but some of which was converted into electrical energy as a low
    voltage direct current. Here, however, one had an example of something involving energy
    conversion that seemed to break the rules governing thermodynamics. There had to be loss owing to thermal conduction through the electrically non-conductive interface between the metal surfaces used as electrodes and the component as well as electrical ohmic resistance losses in what was a self-oscillating a.c. current device and the rectifier components used to convert the generated current into d.c. output. Yet these were ignored in judging overall performance. Certainly, one suspected that here there was energy conversion with a higher efficiency than theory implied.

    On the same subject, though not recognized when the research was performed in the 1950 era,
    several university projects have addressed the problem of the anomalous power loss in electrical
    steels as used in power transformers. Eddy-current losses can be several times greater than
    they should be according to established theory. What no one at the time even contemplated
    was that the heat generated and conducted away through the steel laminations could, en route,
    be, in some measure, converted back into electrical form, thereby inducing EMFs which could
    enhance the circulating eddy-currents and so cause the loss to escalate. An anomaly factor of
    6 was measured in one research project [4] and a loss factor of 10 later reported for a specific
    situation [5], though a factor of 1.5 was the norm in standard situations. An expert in
    thermodynamic theory should ponder on the question of how, in a power transformer where
    the temperature differential between sections of the core can be no greater than, say, 40o C, it
    is possible for heat to be regenerated as electricity on the scale required to explain the
    phenomenon observed. Indeed, unless the second law of thermodynamics with its Carnot
    limitations is contravened, that eddy-current anomaly phenomenon remains an unsolved
    mystery facing future generations of would-be power engineers.

    One should wonder why what is known as the ‘Nernst Effect’ or the ‘Nernst-Ettinghausen
    Effect’ has been shelved as history, rather that explored further in the context of
    thermodynamics. It concerns heat flow in metal subjected to the action of a transverse
    magnetic field and the generation of an EMF in the mutually orthogonal direction as a
    function, not of absolute temperature, but of temperature gradient. That gradient is a measure
    of rate of heat flow and that EMF arises from some of that heat converting into electricity but
    so converting without being governed by the actual temperature locally, as applies where
    Carnot principles hold. There can therefore be 100% efficient energy conversion between heat
    and electricity under certain circumstances, simply because any energy not so converted can
    only revert to heat but certainly not at a lower temperature. This occurs at one position
    without the sting in the entropy tail, as it were, of having to pay the price for a round trip
    where, confined within the converter itself, that electricity has to traverse a junction at a
    different temperature. The latter scenario is the one where the second law of thermodynamics
    prevails. Note that the phenomenon of the Nernst-Ettinghausen Effect is particularly strong in nickel and that much of the heat conducted through Strachan’s device was through nickel, a ferromagnetic material in which there are domains within its crystal composition that are intrinsically fully magnetized.

    Imagine then a future where, guided by debate and a good measure of effort and ingenuity, we
    can one day combine standard heat pump technology to convert electricity into heat with a
    coefficient of performance of 5, say, and then deploy that heat back into electricity with, say, a
    75% conversion efficiency using apparatus in which nickel or steel is fabricated into an
    assembly specifically designed to exploit the Nernst Effect. That would amount to a kind of
    perpetual motion device by which we could generate electricity as if from nowhere, but really
    by tapping the ambient heat energy of our environment and cooling that in the process. Such a
    dream seems impossible, something bordering on the absurd, but can we really be sure? Are
    our laws of thermodynamics sacrosanct?

    Indeed, are our laws of mechanics and our laws of electrodynamics also sacrosanct? If so,
    then why do we encounter the occasional anomaly and, unable to spot the mistake if such
    there is, allow it to pass by as a nine-day wonder? Surely, we need to address the subject, not
    as judges awaiting the presentation of clear evidence by contending parties, but rather as
    humble, albeit professional, engineers, fully mindful of the established facts of physics, fearful
    of a destiny that deprives us of our energy needs and open to genuine debate in a constructive
    atmosphere, giving those few who do have the necessary ideas and inspiration a fair chance to
    get their message across. That debate can only begin when those who have been active in the
    forum of ‘free energy’ are identified and duly invited to contribute to the research agenda, the
    emphasis being, not on lecturing, but on opening and pursuing meaningful discussion amongst
    workshop groups of limited size.

    Remember the point that if one can develop an out-of-balance thrust force in contravention of
    Newton’s Third Law of Motion then one is on the doorstep giving access to a new source of
    energy drawn from the aether itself. We are told it is impossible. If that is the case then why
    is it that we now read about the anomalous acceleration force experienced by spacecraft
    Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11? It is as if the G, the constant of gravitation, has changed its value
    during the flight. Of even more significance is the fact that NASA scientists are able to claim
    the discovery that the use of a capacitor of asymmetrical structure charged to a high voltage
    develops linear thrust force that (quoting from Patent 6,317,310 recently granted to United
    States of America by its own Patent and Trademark Office) features in:

    “A linear accelerator which can be used to launch payloads or other similar
    applications.”

    Unfortunately, there is no reference to experimental proof of this in the specification of that U.S. Patent and so one suspects that it is based more on wishful thinking that fact.

    Evens so, if it were to be possible, to use a capacitor and a high voltage priming source, the latter not delivering energy except
    as a one-off initial priming charge, to generate a propulsive force asserted on the vacuum
    medium (the aether), then that implies energy transfer to or from that aether, a continuous flow of
    energy. The secret of the ‘free energy’ power generation by Dr. Henry Moray, whose
    apparatus was known to involve, essentially, large capacitors, is surely linked to drawing that
    capacitor priming charge from atmospheric electricity via that antenna he used, but there was also something special about those capacitors that allowed them to interact force-wise with the
    vacuum medium to tap its energy resource and so deliver power continuously. This is a subject which the author has discussed in detail elsewhere [6].

    Should we therefore wait for those windmills or can one hope that the Institution of
    Mechanical Engineers and also the Institution of Electrical Engineers, if not the Institute of
    Physics, will initiate action to bring the these fringe elements of the unorthodox energy
    spectrum into the ongoing debate concerning sustainable energy in our future.

    REFERENCES

    [1] G. M. Spence, US Patent No. 4,772,816, ‘Energy Conversion System’, 1986.

    [2] P. N. Correa and A. N. Correa, US Patent No. 5,416,391,‘Electromechanical
    Transduction of Plasma Pulses’
    , 1995.

    [3] H. Aspden and J. S. Strachan, Electricity without Magnetism, Electronics + Wireless World, vol. 98, pp. 540-542 (July 1992).

    [4] H. Aspden, Proc. I.E.E., vol. 103C, pp. 279-285 (1956) and vol. 104C, pp. 2-7 (1957).

    [5] F. Brailsford, ‘The Principles of Magnetism’, D. Van Nostrand, London, Fig. 10.11(c), p.
    239 (1966).

    [6] H. Aspden, Conference Paper: Our Future Energy Source – The Vacuum!, 2nd Berlin Congress for Innovative Energy Technologies, Binnotec e.V., Berlin, June 13-15, 2002. LECTURE 27.

    ***************

    H. Aspden
    August 28, 2002

  • LECTURE NO. 30

    LECTURE NO. 30

    The Aspden Effect

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2002


    The basis of this Lecture is the text quoted below of an item published in February 1995 in New Energy News, which was followed by a commentary by the Editor who stressed its significance and assigned it the name ‘ASPDEN EFFECT‘. he followed his remarks by an item headed ‘A CHALLENGE TO OUR READERS’ in which he stated “Many of you have asked for something that you could replicate. Here is a good one. …..” He ended by saying: “We also ask any of you theorists …. to give us some help to begin to understand the Aspden Effect.” After the passage of more than seven years, I have decided here to return to this topic and see how far I can go in clarifying the issues raised.

    INTRODUCTION

    I have seen the need for this after receiving an E-Mail enquiry in June 2002 from someone who had heard mention of the ‘Aspden Effect’ but was in search of the information source as he had in mind seeking to replicate the experiment involved. Also, it was on June 15th, 2002, after delivering my presentation at a conference in BERLIN in the presence of Dr. Hal Fox, the Editor of New Energy News, that during the question session he said I had not mentioned the Aspden Effect. The subject of my talk in Berlin did have a related underlying theme and I will explain that in what I have to say below. First, however, one needs to read what follows next as the item I wrote for that February 1995 issue of New Energy News.

    DISCOVERY OF ‘VIRTUAL INERTIA’

    I report an anomalous energy phenomenon found in my motor experiments.

    Imagine an electric machine having no electrical input itself and which, when started on no load by a drive motor and brought up to speed (3250 rpm), thereafter runs steadily at that speed with the motor drawing a little extra input power with a time delay rate of about two minutes. The machine rotor has a mass of 800 gm and at that speed its kinetic energy together with that of the drive motor is no more than 15 joules, contrasting with the excess energy of 300 joules needed to satisfy the anomalous power surge [to spin up from rest].

    Imagine further that when the motor, after running five minutes or more, is switched off and the machine is stopped, you can restart it in the same or opposite direction and find that it now has a memory in the sense that it will not now ask for that 300 joules of excess input. 30 joules will suffice provided that the time lapse between starting and restarting is no more than a minute or so.

    This is not a transient heating phenomenon. At all times the bearing housings feel cool and any heating in the drive motor would imply an increase of resistance and a build-up of power to a higher steady state condition.

    The experimental evidence is that there is something spinning of an ethereal nature coextensive with the machine rotor. That ‘something’ has an effective mass density 20 times that of the rotor, but it is something that can spin independently and take several minutes to decay, whereas the motor comes to rest in a few seconds.

    Two machines of different rotor size and composition reveal the phenomenon and tests indicate variations with time of day and compass orientation of the spin axis. One machine, the one incorporating weaker magnets, showed evidence of gaining strength magnetically, as the test were repeated over several days.

    I will soon be reporting in detail on these findings, after further work and evaluation of the implications. The phenomenon was something I should have been prepared for, having regard to my years of theorizing, but this discovery was unexpected as it has crept in loud and clear in a project aimed at testing a motor principle totally unrelated to ‘vacuum spin’. It has appeared obtrusively and I do not yet know whether, in adapting to its presence, it can serve in improving machine performance or become detrimental.

    Readers who are curious about my more general research endeavors may find interest in the specification of U.S. Patent No. 5,376,184 granted to me on December 27th 1994. In connection with the subject of this particular communication I quote from lines 3 to 28 of column 21 of that patent:

    “Now, in a practical device, one can similarly set up electric fields in a metal rotor by displacing those charge carriers, either by inertial action or the action of a magnetic field directed along the spin axis. However, even here physicists have problems understanding the phenomena they observe, as one may see from the scientific paper by James F. Woodward: Electrogravitational Induction and Rotation, Foundations of Physics, 12, pp. 467-478 (1982). On page 472 one reads, after a statement that machine operation produced induced charge in evidence from a voltage:

    Plainly, an effect of some sort is present. Since a negative charge appears during spindown, we may infer either that (1) an initially present positive charge disappears during spindown, or (2) some process drives the sample case to negative potentials during spin-down. The genuine disappearance of charge from the sample/sample-case assembly would be, of course, prima facia evidence for the existence of electrogravitational reduction.

    What this means is that electric charge can be held displaced within a metal to set up electric field gradients in that metal. Woodward did this by inertial spin action, possibly affected by the earth’s field, but a similar result can be obtained by building a series-connected capacitor stack.”

    

    BACKGROUND OF THE PROJECT

    The research giving the above spin-off was a project funded by the Department of Trade and Industry of the U.K. owing to my having competed successfully in 1994 for what was termed a ‘SMART’ award, a ‘Small Firms Merit Award for Research and Technology’. It provided funding for one year to engage in preliminary research on the subject offered for the competition, which was, in my case, a motor project involving magnets mounted to spin about their axes of magnetization. I was fully retired (being already 66 years of age) and no longer had use of the laboratory facilities where I had spent 9 years as a Visiting Senior Research Fellow after retiring early from my career employment with IBM.

    Since I was building the motors myself and was anxious to progress as rapidly as possible, I had to shelve, as it were, the fascinating side-line research avenue that opened up with the above discovery, owing to the time pressure and the limited period of funding for the objective that had been set. I may also say that I encountered another phenomenon that still baffles me concerning a later motor built as part of that effort. That motor was a d.c. motor able to run in either of its two directions, but, if set running in a clockwise sense, it would run for two or three minutes drawing its necessary drive power from the supply, but then it would start to slow down and come to rest just transiently as it switched itself over to anti-clockwise rotation, before rapidly gaining speed in that preferred sense. This did not make sense, given that it had started to run well in the clockwise direction and had received no impulse giving it an initial inertial motion in that direction.

    The early background relevant to the topic here discussed is that, at the time when I left IBM, where I had for many years held a senior position as Director of IBM European Patent Operations, to revert to my academic scientific interests, and with IBM’s generosity had secured university facilities for my research, I had then engaged in one experiment aimed at testing my ideas concerning ‘vacuum spin’. The idea behind this is that if one can set up a radial electric field, meaning one emanating from a spin axis, and that axis happens to be in-line with an axis in the vacuum medium about which there is the quantum jitter of a very high speed circular motion of very small radius shared by all matter, then that radial electric field might induce spin by that vacuum medium itself. That quantum jitter, by the way, is the so-called ‘Zitterbewegung’ that underlies Heisenberg’s Principle of Uncertainty in quantum theory, by which neither position nor momentum are certain, but multiply the two together and you get a definite quantum of angular momentum h/2π, where h is Planck’s constant of action. I have good reason to believe that matter acquires that jitter property by sharing it with a universal activity in the aether itself, or the ‘vacuum medium’ should the word ‘aether’ seem inappopriate terminology to a physicist who may read this.

    Unfortunately, at the time (the 1985 period), I used a non-conductive rotor which I subjected to a voltage gradient of 12,000 V/cm between the spin axis and an copper cylinder, in my efforts to sense a possible inertial anomaly evident from spin-up and spin-down tests. This assumes a possible modest exchange of angular momentum between the vacuum medium and the rotor. Although some spurious effects were noticed that effort was somewhat futile. It was only some eight or so years later that I came to realize that I ought to have used an electrically conductive rotor subjected to an axially–directed magnetic field, the so-called homopolar construction or Faraday disk construction, looking, not for power output by drawing current through the disk, but rather the inertial anomaly I had sought earlier in my experiments.

    Having by that time heard of certain ‘over-unity’ energy claims based on electric motors incorporating magnets spinning about their axes of magnetization, I could but then wonder if my interest in the ‘vacuum spin’ concept as aroused by my theoretical physics research could advance by engaging myself in motor experimentation. Hence, my application for that ‘SMART’ award.

    However, in pursuing that research, my prime object was that goal of ‘over-unity’ performance and this may account for much of what I have reported on separately in my ‘ENERGY SCIENCE REPORTS’. Now, however, I face the facts, the passage of time and the unfulfilled resolve, as stated in that New Energy News item above, that I would later be reporting in detail on the findings there outlined. The question at issue also is: “How does a reader of that account know what to build to replicate the findings, given that no details are provided?”

    Well, I intend here to remedy this as this preliminary draft of this Lecture develops. I can say that the main motor that revealed the anomaly mentioned in the New Energy News account is the one illustrated and described in my ENERGY SCIENCE REPORT No. 9, which I will soon be making available on this website. Meanwhile, I am putting this partial draft on record now, owing to having just included that New Energy News item in the bibliographic reference collection that appears now on my separate website www.aspden.org in the ‘papers’ section.


    H. Aspden
    21 July, 2002

  • LECTURE NO. 29

    LECTURE NO. 29

    Energy Challenges for the 21st Century

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2002


    This Lecture is my impromptu reaction to having today (July 4th, 2002) received in my mail two items, (1) being the monthly periodical Physics World (July, 2002) sent to members by the U.K. Institute of Physics and (2) the other being the Space Energy Journal (June, 2002) published quarterly by the Space Energy Association of P.O. Box 1136, Clearwater, Florida, USA, 33757-1136. The latter was accompanied by a handwritten letter from Don Kelly who reminded me of our past meetings at U.S. energy conferences and drew my attention to something pertaining to the energy research of Dr. Henry Moray. Having, as recently as 15th June, 2002 delivered, as an invited keynote speaker, a lecture in Berlin at the Binnotec 2nd Berlin Congress for Innovative Energy Technologies, a lecture which hinged on the findings of Dr. Henry Moray, I see reason to put some of my thoughts on record in these web pages.

    INTRODUCTION
    I have to confess that I find it extremely depressing when I see the contrasting attitudes concerning our future energy problems as revealed by these two publications referenced above, especially in the light of my contribution to that conference in Berlin. The title I have assigned to this Lecture No. 29 is the same as the one which dominates the front cover page of that July 2002 issue of Physics World, where it is followed, in small block capitals, by a sub-title: ‘CAN WATER, WIND AND FIRE SAVE THE EARTH?’. In contrast, the title of the theme I see as the subject of that June, 2002 Quarterly issue of The Space Energy Journal is: ‘Cosmic Energy – The Legacy of Nikola Tesla and T. Henry Moray’. I can also say that the title of my Berlin Lecture was: ‘Our Future Energy Source – the Vacuum!’

    You may wonder why I find this depressing. My answer to this is that I find it reprehensible on the part of our physics establishment that, in spite of the growing concern about our depleting energy sources and the pollution effects of hydrocarbon fuels, it does not include in its spectrum of enquiry at least some reference to the claims of record pertaining to certain unconventional sources of energy. Can it be that the physics community at large has to be deterred from exploring avenues of research that are somewhat controversial? Should one fear witchcraft, when in fact, as that sub-title suggests, we must anyway expect to suffer the ordeals of water, wind and fire if we are to save the Earth?

    As to one such unconventional energy claim of record, I wish here to acknowledge the fact that it was the Space Energy Journal which, in its September 2001 issue, drew to my attention to what may well be the first U.S. Patent to cover an invention that offered access to a source of energy which can solve all our future energy resource problems. It was an invention ‘before its time’, as we may say, but one we should not ignore and so I made a point of mentioning it in that Berlin Lecture of mine, as you may see by reading Lecture No. 27 on this website: http://www.energyscience.co.uk. That U.S. Patent No. 119,825 was granted in 1871 to Daniel MacFarland Cook of Mansfield, Ohio. It described a way of making an electrical device which, without any obvious power input source, could replace a voltaic cell and so deliver electrical energy as if from nowhere.

    I therefore ask you, the reader, to weigh the implications of what I say below by contrasting two scenarios (1) a scenario in which we drift along the pathways outlined in that July 2002 issue of Physics World and (2) the alternative scenario that is open for exploration if only physicists are willing to pay attention and learn something new, even though it is reminiscent of the past. The message is important. It concerns us all and is not akin to a philosophical enquiry into black holes in far off galaxies which has no bearing whatsoever on the future of humanity. Physics which concerns energy of the kind we harness here on body Earth is what matters and there is much to learn in that endeavour.

    THE FIRST SCENARIO: That of Physics World: July 2002 issue
    Under the heading: ‘Energy Challenges’, the opening paragraph declared:

    “Satisfying the world’s insatiable appetite for fuel without destroying the environment is the biggest challenge facing the energy industry.”

    That, however, is surely not the biggest challenge the industry faces, given that our main concern should be the dwindling reserves of the fuel that is available. After all, our environment has survived so far in spite of our own need to survive by the burning of coal and the consumption of oil and gas and though a pollution-free environment might mean a longer lifespan it can hardly have priority over the concern about the ultimate energy resource needed to give us mobility and keep us warm, and so alive, in winter.

    So let us look at the topics which that Physics World issue then addressed.

    First, however, take note of a few of Valerie Jamieson’s other comments. They include:

    “World energy consumption is expected to soar by 50% to a staggering 180,000 GWh per year by 2020, with the developing world demanding an ever-increasing share.”

    “Renewable technologies still make up less than 1% of the world’s commercial energy.”

    “Supporters of renewable energy are fighting claims that the environmental credentials of solar, wind and wave power are less than impeccable.”

    “A longer-term possibility is nuclear fusion. Despite the enormous progress in the performance of experiments over the past 30 years, nuclear fusion is still decades away from generating electricity.”

    The summary verdict by Valerie Jamieson on her theme Energy Challenges is:

    “Advances in physics and engineering are making energy from renewable sources increasingly affordable. But political will- as well as scientific progress – is just as crucial for safeguarding the environment for generations to come.”

    I see in this the message that physicists and engineers are doing a good job in improving orthodox technology as used in alternative energy generation, in spite of the added expense warranted as the price for reducing pollution, but, as ever, the finger is pointed at politicians telling them to do better, presumably by funding more research. I do not see the message that physicists must leave no stone unturned in their efforts to stimulate new ideas and follow every possible line of enquiry that may open the door on a new source of energy. Nor do I see the all-important message that physicists must pay attention to those, past and present, who claim or have claimed insight into new avenues leading to such new sources of energy.

    Taking stock now of the orthodox technology seen as warranting attention, as discussed in this Special Issue of Physics World covering the energy theme, one finds they are itemised by separate articles under the following headings.

    Green cars move into top gear
    Highlighting a few comments here one learns that:

    “By 2020 more than 1 billion cars (automobiles) will vie for space on the world’s roads, compared with the 400 million cars that exist today.”

    “Fuel cells represent the most futuristic method of propulsion as well as the cleanest; they mix oxygen with hydrogen – a potential fuel of the future – from a pure source or a hydrogen-rich compound such as methanol, and they emit only water vapour.”

    “Electric cars have a long research history; but until recently they had little to show for the work in terms of commercially viable cars for the mass market.”

    The hydrogen economy blasts off
    The same theme is pursued by a different author under this heading by reference to fuel-cell technology. Under the sub-heading ‘American Power’, one is informed that:

    “The DOE aims to realize the “meaningful introduction” of fuel cells for energy generation by 2005, replacing 12 trillion kilowatt-hours of conventional energy with hydrogen by 2010. Each year the US consumes 2500 times as much energy, but the plans do not stop there. By 2030 the DOE intends to replace at least one-tenth of its current annual energy consumption with hydrogen power.”

    Fuel cells eye up the mainstream market
    Here an author at the University of Birmingham tells us something about fuel cells. His comments include:

    “The fuel cell is the cleanest and most efficient power-generating device invented so far. It converts the chemical energy of molecules such as hydrogen, methane and alcohol into electrons at a potential close to 1 V. A stack of such cells can supply DC power at any desired voltage.”

    “Cryostatic tanks in the boot of the car store the liquid hydrogen and are topped up at robotic filling stations. However, the practicality of storing energy in this way is still in doubt.”

    “Indeed, the hydrogen storage issue is one of the most challenging problems for fuel cells. Currently the pressurized bottles used to store hydrogen are 20 times heavier than the liquid they contain. In other words, the storage density – the mass of hydrogen divided by the total mass of the container – is only 5% for hydrogen compared with 20% for petrol (gasolene).”

    As I interpret this it does not sound promising for those US DOE predictions above, but, then again, I do tend to be a little suspicious when faced with numerical assertions in media publications for the general reader. However, Physics World is read by physicists and not the ‘general reader’. Thinking about the automobile that I drive, a full tank of petrol can be nearly as heavy as a passenger and I would indeed be surprised if the weight of my petrol tank when empty were to be anywhere near the weight of five passengers, which is what is implied by that latter statement! Evenso, I can accept that fuel cell technology, with the dangers and difficulties of storing hydrogen, is going to involve a trade off between the benefits of reducing pollution and the price paid for loss of life owing to the danger involved.

    Energy savings go through the roof
    Here, under this heading, Physics World surveys the benefits of designing buildings in such a way that they consume less energy to keep them warm in winter and cool in summer. No one can argue with this objective.

    Bright future for efficient lights
    Lamp efficiency is the subject discussed under this heading, but one can not get particularly excited about the likely energy savings here, though any saving is, of course, desirable.

    Solar power to the people
    The subject of the article having this heading is photovoltaic cells. A few comments included are:

    “Solar energy is the power source that people love to love. Photovoltaic solar cells transform sunlight into electricity with no atmospheric emissions, no moving parts, no sound, and can provide a virtually endless supply of free power.”

    “To overcome the obvious drawback of photovoltaic cells – that they only work when the sun shines – many systems incorporate lead-acid batteries to store energy.”

    “By any account, as the price of photovoltaic cells approaches that of retail grid power in the coming years, more individuals and companies will consider the benefits of generating their own environmentally friendly energy and help to make solar power a major contributor to the world’s energy supply.”

    If this cost convergence proves to be true, who can argue with the sentiment expressed here?

    Surge of interest in wave energy
    The opening and closing comments of this article by an author from the University of Edinburgh are:

    “The challenge of generating energy from the sea has led to many different approaches to harnessing the power of the North Atlantic waves.”

    “Harnessing the power of the sea economically is difficult and requires the best engineering skills. The conditions at sea are very different from those onshore and every aspect of wave behaviour and device performance has to be understood. With rising concerns about environment – and such an abundant source of natural energy on our doorstep – wave power demands a closer look.”

    Wind power moves out to sea
    Here an author from Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands assures us that windmills located offshore can make a real contribution to our energy needs. He concludes by saying:

    “Offshore wind energy could become a major source of power in Europe – and elsewhere – by the end of the decade. The technical challenges are being faced by a willing industry, with many players keen to play a part. Their efforts will no doubt lead to innovative and cost-effective solutions, just as in the onshore wind-energy and off-shore fossil-fuel sectors. One day it may even be possible to combine offshore wind farms with wave and tidal plants. It is clear that offshore wind power is an energy source with huge potential.”

    I do not find this convincing. Wave power has been there for a very long time and if it has such potential then why do we still have a problem?

    New designs on nuclear energy
    Here, by the article under this heading, the pros and cons of conventional nuclear power generation are discussed. The industry claims to be confident that nuclear generation has a viable future. The opening and closing remarks are:

    “The nuclear industry and environmental campaigners have battled long and hard over the benefits of nuclear power. One side argues that nuclear plants emit almost no greenhouse gases and use a plentiful source of fuel. The other claims that nuclear power is expensive and produces radioactive waste that is fiendishly hard to store. But the nuclear industry is starting to think it has turned the corner in the battle for public acceptance of this form of energy.”

    “People realize that nuclear waste is not nice, but it is not the end of the universe. It is our weakest point, but it is not our Achilles’ heel.”

    One gets the feeling from this that those in charge of nuclear power plants know their power, the strength of their position, and see pollution as something we have to live with regardless of its problems.

    Waiting for the power of the sun
    Here in this final article one is confronted with the ongoing saga of the hope of an energy source that I first heard about in the 1950s, as a young man having a Ph.D. degree in Electrical Engineering and employed by a major energy corporation in U.K. Over the years since that time it has always been something that needs just a little more research, a matter of just two or so more decades to bring to fruition, just enough, I came to realize, for those making that judgement to reach their years of pensioned retirement.

    The caption under the title of the article includes the words “fusion energy is still decades away”. I quote the following passages:

    “Nuclear fusion – the energy source that powers the Sun and the stars – requires patience. Over the past 30 years the performance of fusion devices has improved by five orders of magnitude, but of all the energy sources discussed in this special issue, nuclear fusion is still the furthest from generating electricity. Even if the ‘fast-track’ approach to fusion is adopted, it will not generate electricity until 30 years from now.”

    “A major milestone on the route to fusion power will be breakeven – that is when the energy produced by the fusion reactions exceeds the energy used to heat the plasma. The record performance for a fusion experiment so far is 65% of breakeven by the Joint European Torus (JET) at Culham in the UK.”

    “Fusion is not an easy technology to master but it has enormous potential if it is successful.”

    “Fusion reactors will be able to generate the levels of power needed for the production of large volumes of hydrogen fuel, which is the only practical way to supply the energy needed for transport without contributing to the greenhouse effect.”

    “There is something either appealingly circular or worryingly roundabout going to great lengths to achieve the fusion of deuterium and tritium to ultimately produce large volumes of hydrogen. As with so much in fusion, only time will tell.”

    So, there you are, just hold your breath for another thirty years or so and, if all goes well, we will see nuclear fusion reactors generating the heat which drives our turbines to power electrical generators and so produce the electricity needed to generate hydrogen from water by electrolysis, which hydrogen can then be used in a fuel cell to power our automobiles. We shall then be mobile using power which man has tapped from a process which replicates that which, in theory, sustains the energy radiated by the sun. In the meantime we can find comfort in the technological development of solar panels and the extended use of windmills. Or, perhaps, we should heed a few voices which speak about over-unity and free-energy, and the breakeven factor in that pursuit, but that means giving a little attention to the heretic fraternity, those who respect the efforts of Dr. Henry Moray.

    After reading through the detailed reports covered by the headings just summarized, one can therefore hardly be surprised if a politician’s private reaction to all this is “So what?”, as there is nothing here to stir one’s hope or imagination and one can but feel that the energy problems of the future are best left for the future generations of the political community.

    But now let us examine the alternative scenario, one which at least should have been given a heading of its own in the above discourse.

    THE SECOND SCENARIO: That of so-called ‘Free Energy’

    What is ‘Free Energy’?
    This is a reference to a form of energy that is tapped somehow from our immediate environment in defiance of our accepted interpretation of physical law and by being guided by anomalies which are revealed by experiment, even though the latter might be seen as the work of cranks in our scientific community.

    The guiding spirit here is one which says that matter itself, indeed our Earth, Sun and the whole universe all had to be created from an omnipresent source of energy and so, maybe, there is a way of tapping a little more energy from that source. It is a source that some physicists refer to as ‘the zero-point energy background’, the quantum underworld that pervades all space and is the seat of quantum electrodynamic activity such as the transient materialisation of electron-positron pairs one can read about when studying theoretical physics.

    It was on this basis that I presented my Lecture in Berlin by concentrating attention on the physical principles that could explain the common features of certain remarkable energy generating devices such as were demonstrated by that Dr. Henry Moray many years ago and by others including present day researchers.

    Now the research I have pursued indicated how protons are created from the activity of that medium which forms the quantum underworld and so the creation of matter in the form of the hydrogen which clusters, by gravity, to form stars is explained. It is mere hypothesis to say that nuclear fusion has to be the source of the sun’s energy brought about by enormous temperatures assumed to exist in its central core. No one knows how to measure the temperature in the sun. All we know is the temperature of the surface that we all can see and that is found to be about 6,000 K. Even the evidence afforded by neutrino output falls short of proving that solar energy radiation is attributable to nuclear fusion and so the sun may well not be a good model on which to build in guiding one’s efforts at hot nuclear fusion and one might well be on a better track in adopting the route to cold nuclear fusion pioneered by Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons.

    There is, however, one aspect concerning the creation of the sun which warrants our attention. It is the need to explain how the primordial sun acquired its angular momentum, enough to shed the planets and impart to them their orbital motion while leaving a small residue of spin angular momentum without reversing the direction of that spin. My early research on this question revealed why that medium of the quantum underworld, the aether, could impart spin angular momentum as a function of the radial electric field set up by the protons that formed the sun. The theory indicated that, for every unit of electric field energy in that field, the aether would import from its own store of energy an exactly equal amount of dynamic energy. In short, I was destined eventually to realize that it could well be possible, by pulsing a radial electric field in suitable electrical apparatus, to import aether energy at a continuous rate, energy that one could then deliver as an electrical power output. The creation of the sun was my source of enlightenment.

    I could then see that the necessary apparatus for implementing such a free-energy objective would be a pair of concentric cylindrical capacitors primed by a charge at high voltage, but not drawing power steadily from that high voltage source. The energy would come from the aether directly. The operation would depend upon setting up an oscillation of the charge as between the two capacitors and so the pulsing of the radial electric field between the electrodes would import aether energy at a steady rate.

    Once I saw that U.S. Patent No. 119,825 in the September, 2001 issue of Space Energy Journal, of which Don Kelly was a founder, I was triggered into writing the Lecture I delivered in Berlin on June 15th, 2002. I could then see why Dr. Henry Moray needed an antenna to feed the D.C. voltage necessary to prime the capacitor charge and raise the output power from that of a simple voltaic cell to one of kilowatt proportions. Moray, some 70 years ago, could generate those kilowatts of energy as if from nowhere using apparatus transported to a remote location in the luggage trunk of his automobile. Furthermore I could then understand why the Methernitha community in Switzerland can generate free energy in their apparatus. They also use cylindrical electrode capacitors, in the form of a pair of two large Leyden jars, and have a large electrical influence machine (Wimshurst machine) connected to provide the D.C. voltage priming.

    I leave it to the reader to refer to the earlier LECTURE No. 27 to see the scope of that Berlin Lecture and its accompanying NOTES which augment the argument. I further remind the reader that any claim to have an electrical device which purports to operate as a ‘free-energy’ system, must, of necessity, imply a negative resistance property and that, according to standard electrical theory, must imply the onset of electrical current oscillations. Pulsing therefore occurs naturally and it is the pulsing of the radial electric field that imports dynamic energy from the aether.

    So, in summary, I owe it to Space Energy Journal for providing the extra input I needed to add emphasis to what I had to say in my Berlin Lecture. However, there is a further observation I now wish to add and this is on a point raised by Don Kelly in his letter to me dated June 27, 2002. It concerns the story that Nikola Tesla, by his Pierce Arrow car demonstration in Buffalo, N.Y. in 1931, actually had a free-energy system which powered that vehicle. This is mentioned on page 1 of the June 2002 issue of Space Energy Journal, where Don Kelly notes that somehow Tesla had found a way of importing cosmic energy without using an antenna in conjunction with a ground connection. This contrasted with Dr. Henry Moray’s device, but it is explained if Tesla had seen what I have now seen, namely that one could use any D.C. high voltage priming method to get the capacitor system operating. Instead of tapping into the atmospheric voltage gradient with hardly any current draw, Tesla could have used the ignition coil otherwise needed for activitating spark plugs in the car. The vertical tubes he used to start his engine by pushing rods within them could have been transformer cores which provided an inductive coupling that stepped up the voltage to a higher level needed to really enhance the action of those capacitors, their charge priming being proportional to the square of their voltage. However, what I do not know and still lack such information is the detail of the electrical circuit that Tesla may have used, though I see the following statement in Don Kelly’s note on ‘Cosmic Energy’ in the June, 2002 issue of Space Energy Journal:

    “The common approach to both of these cosmic energy systems (those of Tesla and Moray) was the use of three basic stages, i.e. (1) cosmic energy collection, (2) storage or capacitance and (3) the conversion of transformation or cosmic energy into useful EMF.”

    I would classify these stages by using the wording:

    “(1) A D.C. voltage source to prime the capacitor charge, (2) at least a pair of capacitors having concentric cylindrical electrodes, whereby to facilitate charge oscillations between the capacitors which, owing to their radial electric fields, import cosmic energy and (3) a transformer coupling which provides inductance to define with the capacitors a suitable oscillation frequency and to serve as the means for feeding power output at a useful level of EMF.”

    Finally, as one can see from the text of my Berlin Lecture and the related Notes, it seems manifestly feasible to contemplate powering a motor vehicle at the normal levels of power, by using a capacitor system no larger than one that would fit neatly into the luggage trunk of the vehicle.

    The logical message, in conclusion, is that maybe we are now in a position to understand the principles of operation of Nikola Tesla’s and Henry Moray’s free-energy devices and harness them in our future technology. Maybe we do not have to be patient and await the creeping advance of hot fusion research before we can have automobiles that run on an abundant source of energy without pollution. Only time will tell, but one must wonder how long it will really take before the physics establishment is willing to listen and willing to support our efforts, as guided by the pioneering work of scientists and inventors such as Nikola Tesla and Henry Moray.

    


    Harold Aspden
    July 4th 2002

  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le28 Le28

    LECTURE NO. 28

    SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1977

    The printed version of this paper was issued on the occasion when the author, Dr. Harold Aspden, delivered an invited lecture to the students and staff of the Physics Department at the University of Cardiff in Wales in 1977. It is appropriate here, some 25 years on from that date, to draw attention to some aspects of it that warrant special comment in the light of onward developments. The paper itself is in PDF format and can be accessed by pressing the link to it at the end of the text which follows.

    The paper highlights new scientific evidence that should help in our understanding of the creation of the solar system. As there stated, it was based on the author’s theoretical investigations into the structure of the vacuum (the aether) and it pointed to a quite simple experimental approach which could possibly verify the effect of the aether in controlling the stability of an electrical discharge by inducing aether rotation about the discharge axis.

    So far as the author knows this suggestion of what could prove to be a very important experiment has not aroused interest and has not, as yet, been performed by our academic fraternity.

    The paper drew attention to three unexplained phenomena evident in laboratory bench testing and related these to the major unexplained phenomena that confront cosmologists. These are (1) the mystery source of energy and angular momentum fed into the solar system at its creation, (2) the mystery of the expected but unresolved unification of the action of gravity and electrodynamic interaction, and (3) and the mysteries posed by the creation of thunderballs.

    Admittedly, the paper had a limited distribution, being a hand-out at that Cardiff event and thereafter given away to those who corresponded with the author on scientific matters of mutual interest. The author was not a active researcher seated in a university and there was hardly any chance of getting a peer-reviewed paper published on the taboo subject of the aether. The aether had been well and truly outlawed by theoretical physicists who were addicted to the Einstein doctrines concerning space-time and its abstract formulations of virtual reality in an imaginary world which depends more on the observer than the underworld of a real aether medium.

    However, the author’s private research efforts were progressing and, gradually, the theme of that paper on “Space, Energy and Creation” did gain in strength. Publication in scientific periodicals became easier, thanks to the open-mindedness of the editorial staff of Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, of the Italian Institute of Physics, a research periodical that was published in the English language before its demise in 1986. It was a peer-reviewed periodical offering rapid publication and, though several of the author’s papers were found acceptable, there were others which were rejected, an indication that not all of the referees used were of like-minded opinion.

    Now, in the author’s writings, certain anomalies in electric arc discharges in ionized plasma having bearing upon the basic law of electrodynamics had been stressed and these eventually attracted the attentions of a Canadian man and wife research team, namely Paulo and Alexandra Correa. They had made a rather breathtaking discovery that, by a method of discharge pulsing using a suitable circuit and a specially configured electrode system in a discharge tube, it is actually possible to generate electrical power by tapping energy from the aether itself.

    Arising from this and our mutual contact at conferences in USA the author wrote ENERGY SCIENCE REPORT No. 8 which was entitled “Power from Space: The Correa Invention”, which was published in 1996. By inspecting that Report it will be seen that its final reference [85] is the subject paper “Space, Energy and Creation”. That Report No. 8 includes material which, apart from the Correa breakthrough, shows how there has been further development having bearing on the author’s observations in “Space, Energy and Creation”.

    Now, at the time of writing these words in May 2002, we are on the eve of a conference event in Berlin in which the author will have opportunity to update his further contribution to the insight we have into the scope for tapping energy from the aether and hear also of the onward research of the Correas. It is for this reason that Space, Energy and Creation” is now being added to this web site, as Lecture No. 28, even though it is 25 years on since it was delivered to that university audience in Cardiff.

    Also added at this time is the author’s BERLIN LECTURE “Our Future Energy Source – The Vacuum!”.

    It is hoped the reader will find these of interest.

    Harold Aspden
    [May 28, 2002]


    Full text (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed lecture. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 1]

    SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION

    © H. Aspden, 1977

    INTRODUCTION

    This lecture presents some new scientific evidence which may help our understanding of the creation of the solar system. It suggests an experimental approach for exploring the phenomena involved. It results from theoretical enquiry into the structure of the vacuum medium, a pursuit which is somewhat controversial. It is hoped, however, that the evidence to be presented will speak for itself and encourage those with the resources to undertake the necessary experimental research.

    SOLAR ENERGY AT CREATION

    We believe the sun to be a nuclear inferno and that it was formed by matter in space condensing under gravitational force. This resulted in a build-up of temperature until eventually the primordial matter in the form of hydrogen began to be steadily converted into helium by nuclear processes. The radiation from this nuclear core then prevented the sun fron contracting further and we have a stable but slowly dying sun which could well feed us with solar energy for another 10,000,000,000 years.

    We no longer worry about what happened to the energy released by the gravitational field when the sun was first formed. There was enough energy from this source to sustain the present level of solar radiation for about 20,000,000 years. We suppose that it was all radiated away long ago. However, it must have performed some role during the early stages of the sun’s creation and it is this which I find of interest.

    [p. 1]

    The solar system: the spinning sun at the centre and the planets Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune and Pluto, each drawn on an arc of its orbit, all orbits turning in the same sense as the sun's spin
    THE SOLAR SYSTEM
    ANGULAR MOMENTUM IN EARTH UNITS
    SUN 332800 ≈ 20
    MERCURY 0.05 0.387 0.24 0.03
    VENUS 0.82 0.723 0.62 0.69
    EARTH 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
    MARS 0.11 1.52 1.88 0.135
    JUPITER 317.8 5.20 11.86 724.6
    SATURN 95.2 9.54 29.46 294.1
    URANUS 14.5 19.18 84.01 63.5
    NEPTUNE 17.2 30.07 165 94.3
    PLUTO 0.11 39.44 248 0.69
    ≈ 1200
    mass orbit radius revolutions per year

    1 Earth unit = (2π(1.496 1013)25.977 1027)/((365) (24) (3600)) gm cm2/sec

    = 2.665 1047 gm cm2/sec

    Therefore the angular momentum of the solar system is

    (1200) (2.665 1047)

    or 3.2 1050 gm cm2/sec

    [p. 2]

    For example, if the energy released was somehow all stored by the sun as kinetic energy, the sun would have to move at about 500 km/s. Curiously, measurements of the Earth’s motion through space by reference to the supposed-isotropic cosmic background radiation do indicate speeds of this general order (Conklin, 1969)*. This then leads one to ask whether the gravitational energy released is perhaps conserved in the local cosmic environment as a state of motion.

    Speculation such as this raises problems of momentum balance. We know that interactions between matter must satisfy the action and reaction law of Newton. Angular momentum is conserved in any complete system subject to central laws of force such as the law of gravitation. This follows from energy conservation principles.

    However, the source of the angular momentum of the solar system poses a very perplexing problem. We would like to think that the planets were formed from the sun, but the planets revolve in their orbits in exactly the same sense as the rotating sun. Somehow the sun must have acquired a substantial angular momentum when it was first formed and somehow it shed most of this in giving birth to the planets.

    So difficult is this problem that philosophers have resorted to the unlikely hypothesis that another star once passed close to our sun, imparting angular momentum and inducing planetary creation. Such an event, they recognized, is so improbable that the solar system could be perhaps unique in the universe, assuring man a rather special place in the cosmic scene.

    I prefer to regard the problem of the source of the sun’s angular momentum as a clue linked with the storage of gravitational energy released when it was formed.

    * E.K. Conklin, ‘Velocity of the Earth with respect to the Cosmic Background Radiation’, Nature, 222, p.971, 1969.

    [p. 2]

    Features of a tornado: a tilted funnel hanging from a rotating storm cloud, its lower end about 20 feet above the ground beside a house, with 'incessant lightning' and 'brilliant cloud' within the funnel
    Features of a tornado as described by Vonnegut in Journal of Geophysical Research, 65, 203, 1960

    [p. 3]

    ENIGMA INVOLVING ROTATION

    There is other evidence of phenomena which involve unusual angular momentum properties or raise difficulties with the principle that action balances reaction.

    One example is the mysterious energy source of tornadoes. It has been argued very persuasively by Vonnegut (1960)* that this energy really comes from the electrical discharges we associate with thunderstorms but the very substantial angular momentum of the tornado is also a problem. It may be that the energy somehow concentrates the angular momentum of an ordinary whirlwind or, as Vonnegut writes,

    ‘it is possible that the vortex is initiated directly by electrical energy.’

    Vonnegut also remarked that:

    ‘an understanding of ball lightning may very well be necessary if the tornado puzzle is to be solved.’

    Thus ball lightning becomes the second enigma. It is the problem of the glowing spheres which are regularly seen to float about in the air following a thunderstorm. They have an aethereal character because they can pass through walls, get inside aircraft and vanish suddenly, sometimes explosively with release of substantial energy. They are so peculiar and the subject of such strange reports that they evoke a great deal of scepticism. However, the fact remains that they are a mysterious scientific phenomenon produced by lightning. They contain energy of some 109 joules per cubic metre and apparently form as spinning spherical objects. The implication is that they have an associated angular momentum.

    * B. Vonnegut, ‘Electrical Theory of Tornadoes’, Journal of Geophysical Research, 65, p.203, 1960.

    [p. 3]

    The apparatus: a torsion balance hung on fine suspension wires, a horizontal rod through a central block carrying a weight at one end and resting at the other end across a block energised through a capacitor; curved arrows show the turning of the system
    THE APPARATUS DESCRIBED IN UMSHAU ARTICLE
    (vol. 5, p. 152, 1975)

    The system senses a very-slowly decaying uni-directional torque once the capacitor excitation is switched off

    [p. 4]

    In the laboratory environment there are two reports of anomalous behaviour known to the speaker and seemingly relevant. In 1972 a demonstration at a meeting of the Institution of Electrical Engineers in U.K. surprised its author. A rotor in a machine speeded up when the power was switched off. It happened and yet could not be reproduced in later efforts to study the phenomenon (Laithwaite, 1972)* It is as if, by some very special circumstance, energy was stored as rotational kinetic energy in the environment of the machine and was fed back to the machine when it was switched off.

    The other report appeared in the German publication Umshau in 1975**. Experiments are here reported as consistently verifying a phenomenon which defies explanation. An energy pulse communicated at high frequency across a capacitative coupling is absorbed by a specimen suspended in a torsion balance. After the pulse has subsided, a unidirectional torque prevails in the system for up to two hours for no apparent reason. It is as if energy is stored by some kind of unseen flywheel that feeds energy back to the apparatus slowly once the power is switched off in the system.

    It is clear from these examples that there is a case to answer and we can rightly examine the source of the sun’s angular momentum in relation to electrical action and the rotation of an unseen medium. I am therefore suggesting that the vacuum medium itself may exhibit properties attributable to its rotation. Before developing this thought, however, I wish to give one more example of the problem we have with the balance of action and reaction if we choose to ignore the role of the vacuum medium in interactions between matter.

    * E. Laithwaite, ‘Unexplained Phenomenon’, Electronics & Power, 18, p.360, 1972

    ** R.G. Zinsser, ‘Kinetobarische Effekte – ein neues Phänomen?’, Umshau, 5, p.152, 1975.

    [p. 4]

    Two pairs of opposite charges, + and −, both moving with velocity v. Left: the line joining them is inclined and the forces on them are unequal in direction, so they would turn. Right: the charges are one above the other and the forces are equal and opposite
    Electrodynamic interaction between two opposite charges in parallel motion, as expected from conventional theory
    Charge q moving with velocity v and charge q′ moving with velocity v′, separated by the displacement r from q to q′

    F = (qq′/r3)[(v′·r)v − (v·r)v′ − (v·v′)r]

    Electrodynamic force F on q′ due to q, according to Maxwell’s Third Law of Electrodynamics

    [p. 5]

    THE LAW OF ELECTRODYNAMICS

    Theoretically there is good reason to suppose that the electrodynamic action between two charges in parallel motion can produce forces which develop rotation.

    By suspending a charged capacitor any transverse motion should result in a turning effect until the line joining the effective centres of charge is at right-angles to the motion. Only then will action balance reaction in a steady uniformly-moving system.

    The experiment was performed by Trouton and Noble in 1903*. They sought to detect the Earth’s linear motion through space, but a null result was reported. It gave stimulus to relativistic doctrine but equally it demonstrated the inapplicability of Lorentz’s electrodynamic formula. The law is inadequate to deal with actions between isolated electric charges in motion.

    All the empirical evidence before that time had involved the interaction of effectively closed circuital charge motion with individual charges. This did not give enough empirical data to formulate a unique law of electrodynamics. It was a point well appreciated by Maxwell because he wrote about this in his great treatise**. He presented four alternative laws of electrodynamics, all equally valid for the closed circuit application but all different when applied to action between discrete electric charges in motion.

    * F.T. Trouton & H.R. Noble, ‘The Mechanical Forces acting on a Charged Electric Condenser moving through Space’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London., 202A, p.165, 1903.

    ** J.C. Maxwell, ‘A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism’, Section 526 of 3rd Edition, 1891. See p.173 of reprint vol. II by Dover Publications, New York, 1954.

    [p. 5]

    If v and v′ are parallel Maxwell’s Third Law of Electrodynamics:

    F = (qq′/r3)[(v′·r)v − (v·r)v′ − (v·v′)r]

    becomes:

    F = − ((qv)(q′v′)r)/r3

    Compare with Newton’s Law of Gravitation:

    F = − G(mm′/r3)r

    Where G is constant and the interacting masses are m, m′.

    Masses m and m′ joined by the displacement r pointing from m to m′

    Aspden’s Law of Electrodynamics is:

    F = (qq′/r3)[(v′·r)v − (m′/m)(v·r)v′ − (v·v′)r]

    Particle of mass m and charge q moving with velocity v, and particle of mass m′ and charge q′ moving with velocity v′, joined by a straight line

    [p. 6]

    This problem attracted my attention because there is an interesting choice available in the formulation of the likely general law. Either one has to admit inequality of action and reaction in the linear sense or one has to accept it from the point of view of rotation. This, bear in mind, applies to a system which may not be complete because we ignore the presence of charge in motion in the vacuum medium itself. We seek a law of electrodynamics applicable solely to interaction between two charges.

    Faced with the choice and guided by the null result of the Trouton-Noble experiment it seemed that the mutual electrodynamic action of two charges cannot develop a torque. This favoured the third law of electrodynamics in Maxwell’s work. Also, independently of this hypothesis, there is theoretical justification for the assumption made by Maxwell in deducing this law empirically. This comes from an analysis of the magnetic field energy deployment and its change when the two charges separate.

    The law has two very interesting consequences. When applied to charge of like polarity moving with the same velocity we obtain an inverse square law of attraction exactly of the form needed to correlate with Newton’s law of gravitation. This gives basis for unifying field theory. Secondly, there is the curious problem of the linear imbalance of action and reaction, which arises for generally-directed charge motion or, as analysis has shown*, for parallel motion if the interacting charges have different mass.

    Experimentally, there should be interesting anomalies in the forces exerted by electrons on ions in arc discharges and plasma. This is now appearing in the literature, though the anomalous behaviour of cold-cathode discharges (those involving ions rather than electrons) has been of record for many years. More recently it has been recognized that

    * H. Aspden, ‘The Law of Electrodynamics’, Jour.Franklin Inst., 287, p.179, 1969.

    [p. 6]

    A spinning sphere of vacuum, angular velocity ω, with negative charge density σ inside and positive charges round its boundary
    ANALYSIS OF VACUUM SPIN
    (Density Property)
    Dimensions
    Charge density σ M½ L−3/2T−1 k½
    Angular velocity ω T−1
    Mass density ρ ML−3
    (σ2/ω2ρ) k

    k is dielectric constant, a known property of vacuum.

    Hence if σ ∝ ω vacuum must have mass density ρ.

    [p. 7]there is a high anomalous acceleration of ions by electrons in plasma.* The new law which I have been urging is Maxwell’s third law of electrodynamics but adapted to cover interactions between charges of different mass. It is a law which is different from that derived using relativity theory. Indeed it has recently been said that the acceptance of relativity as a faith and the refusal to consider criticism of relativistic doctrine has hindered the rational development of electrodynamic theory. I am quoting here from a paper dated June 1977 circulated by Prof. McCausland of the University of Toronto in which he makes reference to some words by Dr. Essen**:

    There is some evidence that a new theoretical approach could break the stalemate in the development of nuclear fusion, which appears to offer the only source of energy that could prolong our civilisation far into the future.’

    Such is the possible importance of resolving the problems which are addressed here.

    CHARGE INDUCTION BY VACUUM SPIN

    Reverting now to the problem of anomalous angular momentum effects, we consider the hypothesis of vacuum spin. If rotation of the vacuum medium induces an electric charge displacement we can show from dimensional analysis that the induced charge density will be proportional to the speed of rotation and proportional to the square root of a mass density. In short, the vacuum medium has a mass density property which must be manifested when spinning. Now it is known from Maxwell’s work that charge is displaced linearly in the vacuum. It is the basis of his displacement currents. Therefore we must be open to

    * H. Aspden, ‘Electrodynamic Anomalies in Arc Discharge Phenomena’, IEEE Trans. Plasma Science, PS-5, p.159, 1977.

    ** L. Essen, ‘Einstein’, The Economist, March 19, 1977, p.4.

    [p. 7]

    GRAVITATION: two small masses m and two larger masses m′ with forces F and F′ between them; F′/m′ > F/m if m′ > m
    A cluster of heavy particles forming a core among scattered light particles: core = Σ m′, other mass = Σ m
    A core filled with positive charges surrounded by negative charges: If Σm are electrons the core must be positively charged
    A core of mass M carrying charge + Q amid negative charges, Q = √G M: for stable core
    A spinning sphere with charge − Q inside and + Q around its boundary: charge induction by vacuum spin
    A spinning sphere with + Q around its boundary and − Q in the surrounding space: vacuum spin charge plus matter charge

    [p. 8]the possibility that charge can be displaced in a radial sense. Put another way, we can expect that a charge density within a volume of matter might induce a reaction by the vacuum medium to cancel the matter charge. Such a reaction should involve vacuum spin.

    One way of developing a charge distribution is by a strong electric discharge. The fast moving electrons will be drawn together by the pinch effect, so generating a radial electric field centred on the axis of the discharge. If the vacuum medium reacts to develop a compensating effect then it will absorb the field energy to sustain a vacuum spin about the discharge axis. This spin may be shared by the air surrounding the discharge with the result that the tornado angular momentum becomes explicable.

    Another way of developing a charge distribution is by the gravitational condensation of stellar substance. Two heavy masses will have greater mutual acceleration under gravity than two lighter masses. In the cosmic dust from which astronomical bodies form there will probable be quite a few free electrons. Thus the heavier matter will aggregate to form a core temporarily leaving an electron population behind in surrounding space. The core need not stabilise initially by a balance of nuclear energy pressure radiation and gravitational force. It can stabilise by a balance of gravitation and the mutual electric repulsion of the positive charge associated with the core. Therefore we know that when an astronomical body is first created it has an electric charge given by G½ times its mass, where G is the constant of gravitation.

    As explained already, this charge will then develop a vacuum spin and we can formulate a mathematical relationship between this speed of rotation and the mass density of the body, involving only the value of G and a density parameter of the vacuum.

    [p. 8]

    VACUUM MEDIUM ANALYSIS

    σ/w = √(Aρ)   by vacuum spin induction

    σ = √G ρm by core stabilisation

    Therefore:   Aρ = G(ρm/w)2

    I   If the sun had 100% of the angular momentum of the solar system when created it would have

    (2/5) MR2w = 3.2 1050 where R = 6.96 1010 cm

    and M = 1.989 1033 gm. Hence w is 8.3 10−5 rad/s

    For the sun ρm = 1.4 gm/cc and G = 6.67 10−8 cgs units

    Therefore:   Aρ ≈ (6.67 10−8 (1.4)2)/(8.3 10−5)2   ≈   19 gm/cc

    II   For the Earth-Moon system according to R.A. Lyttleton (Science Journal, 5, 53, May 1969) the Earth rotated once every 5.5 hours before the Moon was ejected. ρm for Earth is 5.5 gm/cc.

    Therefore:   Aρ ≈ (6.67 10−8 (5.5)2 (3600)2 (5.5)2)/(2π)2   ≈   20 gm/cc

    III   For the Asteroids the data of G.P. Kuiper (Celestial Mechanics, 9, 321, May 1974) show that the mean speed of rotation is once in 6 to 7 hours. If we estimate the value of ρm as 4 to 5 gm/cc this gives:

    Aρ ≈ (6.67 10−8 (4.5)2 (3600)2 (6.5)2)/(2π)2   ≈   19 gm/cc

    [p. 9]

    THE SOLAR SYSTEM

    By supposing that the vacuum spin will be coupled, albeit rather loosely, with the body, the speed of rotation of both will become the same. Thus we have basis for explaining how the newly-created sun or Earth was caused to rotate. Furthermore, the production of satellites becomes explicable. Once the electron population reaches the surface of the parent body it will begin the process by which the vacuum medium returns its energy to matter. The vacuum spin will slow down as the atmosphere of negative charge accumulates this energy. The electrical attraction between the positive core and this negative orbiting atmosphere will balance the centrifugal force. This will determine how much mass from the parent body will be swept into the satellite system. Then, as the two charges become neutralised by mutual discharge or extraneous particle radiation the satellite will move away from its parent to take up its eventual orbit. Meanwhile much of the energy released will have gone into electric discharges and possibly have been dissipated. Some energy may even, as I suggested at the outset, have found its way into an ordered state of translational motion of the sun in its galactic path through space.

    Suffice it to say at this stage that the creation of the solar system need present no insuperable mystery, of the kind which has troubled us to date. The data verify the hypotheses involved, because we can deduce the same numerical vacuum density property from three separate creation processes. These are the asteroid creation, the sun creation and the Earth creation. Furthermore, when this then-known density parameter of the vacuum is applied to the formulae for satellite creation, we deduce the satellite/parent mass ratio in reasonable accord with that of the solar system and the Earth-Moon system.

    [p. 9]

    SATELLITE FORMATION

    A circle of charge +Q and mass M with radius R; at its top a small mass m carrying charge −Q moves along the circle with angular momentum X

    X = angular momentum of m

    Force balance gives:

    (kQ2)/(R2) = (X2)/(mR3)(1)

    Charge −Q will be where k < 1 because not all fully effective as implied by the illustration.

    Note that:   GM2 = Q2(2)

    It appears that a spinning charged system tends to concentrate angular momentum in a faster-rotating surface region. Taking X as the factor β times the initial angular momentum of M at creation:

    X = (2/5) β MR2ω(3)

    where   ω = ρm √(G/Aρ)(4)

    and   M = (4π/3) R3 ρm(5)

    Combining equations (1) to (5):

    m/M ≈ (6β2ρm)/(50πAρk)

    but Aρ ≈ 20 gm/cc so that   m/M ≈ (β2/k) (ρm/524)

    For the sun with ρm = 1.4, if β ≈ 0.5 and k ≈ 0.5:

    m/M ≈ 1/748   (observed value 1/745)

    For the Earth with ρm = 5.5, if β ≈ 0.75 and k ≈ 0.5:

    m/M ≈ 1/85   (observed value 1/81)

    Note that β will not represent deployment of angular momentum between parent and satellite as observed today because tidal effects promote angular momentum transfer.

    [p. 10]

    STRUCTURED SPACE

    An important question is that of why the solar system suddenly came into being some 4,500,000,000 years ago. It is as if there was a sudden decision that gravitation would come into being. The usual starting point is to suppose a diffused cosmic dust begins to come together due to gravitation. But why should there be such a beginning? If matter dispersed in space was created slowly and steadily the results which have just been presented would not apply. An answer comes from the understanding of the nature of the force of gravitation and the realisation that it only exists in a vacuum medium which has structure. The analogy is found in ferromagnetism. There are forces which depend solely upon the prevailing ordered state of the ferromagnetic substance. Above the Curie temperature there is no magnetism. Similarly, in any crystalline substance there are forces which vanish once the crystal becomes disordered by high temperature effects. Therefore, I offer the suggestion that the electrical medium permeating the vacuum has structure and that some 4,500,000,000 years ago this structure went through a transition which allowed gravitation to assert itself. Eventually, when the sun cools and its density increases it may well be the seat of a disturbance which can spread through space creating a new disorder in the vacuum structure belonging to the sun’s cosmic domain. This is speculation founded upon a great deal of evidence indicating that the vacuum is structured.

    The geometry of a lattice structured vacuum can yield parameters determining the fundamental physical constants and assuring their universal equality.* However, this takes us beyond the scope of this paper and I wish to conclude by suggesting some experiments.

    * H. Aspden & D.M. Eagles, ‘Aether Theory and the Fine Structure Constant’, Physics Letters, 41A, p.423, 1972.

    H. Aspden & D.M. Eagles, ‘Calculation of the Proton Mass in a Lattice Model for the Aether,’ Il Nuovo Cimento, 30A, p.235, 1975.

    [p. 10]

    LINEAR MOVING VACUUM FRAME: a square lattice with a circular region whose lattice is displaced and moving off diagonally
    LINEAR MOVING VACUUM FRAME
    ROTATING VACUUM FRAME: a square lattice with a circular region whose lattice is turned at an angle, with a curved arrow showing rotation
    ROTATING VACUUM FRAME
    The Earth with an arrow showing its rotation: Vacuum medium of Michelson-Gale-Pearson experiments. No rotating apparatus
    The Earth with an arrow showing its rotation and a small circle at its edge turning the opposite way: Vacuum medium of an experiment involving rotating apparatus

    [p. 11]

    OPTICAL SENSING OF THE VACUUM

    It should be possible to distinguish between linear motion and rotation by optical sensing of the vacuum medium. A sphere of rotating structure will not disturb a similiar surrounding structure. The linear motion of a lattice-like structure through a similar surrounding structure seems impossible. Yet it is possible if the lattice density is reduced by linear motion and the free lattice substance is in counter-motion within the body of the lattice. Analysis* shows that the optical reference frame moves with the lattice in linear motion, a result confirmed by the famous Michelson-Morley experiment. On the other hand, since the lattice density is unchanged in the rotation state, the optical reference frame remains the non-rotating reference frame. Thus an experiment involving the measurement of the speed of light in the Earth’s rotating frame should be sensitive to the Earth’s rotation. This is confirmed by the experiments of Michelson, Gale and Pearson (1925)**.

    The interesting question is whether the vacuum can be set in rotation by test apparatus and this Earth rotation component obscured in optical tests. For example, at the equator the laboratory moves at a speed of about 460 m/s. Speed of light tests should indicate a difference of 920m/s between the west-east and east-west speeds. This is provided the apparatus has not become, in effect, a system within its own rotating vacuum and so carried forward around the equator with what is effectively a vacuum system in linear motion. In short, if rotating apparatus is avoided it should be possible, as in the Michelson-Gale-Pearson experiment to detect the 920m/s speed difference in the light tests. If the presence of rotating apparatus obscures this measurement and differences of a few

    * H. Aspden, ‘The Fresnel Formula applied to Empty Space’, Int. Jour. Theor. Phys., 15, p.263, 1976

    ** A.A. Michelson, H.G. Gale & F. Pearson, Astrophysical Journal 61, p.140, 1925.

    [p. 11]

    CHARGE INDUCTION BY VACUUM SPIN
    (Linear Oscillator Property)

    A radius R drawn from the spin axis O to an element moving in a small orbit of radius r at angular frequency Ω, with an arrow ω showing the vacuum spin

    Each element of the structured vacuum rotates at the universal angular frequency Ω′ in small orbits of radius r. If there is vacuum spin at angular frequency ω then in plane of Ω an element moving at radius R from spin axis 0 will be radially displaced by Δr = ωR/Ω. The area of a disc of radius R will change in proportion to 2Δr/R or 2ω/Ω.

    Note then that   σ = σo(2ω/Ω)(1)

    Let α be the restoring force rate when a charge e of mass mo is displaced amongst a sea of opposite charge of charge density σo in a vacuum which is electrically-neutral in the non-spin state.

    Then   α = moΩ2

    where Ω is also the natural frequency of the vacuum

    The electrical nature of the restoring force is readily explained by dimensional analysis.

    Dimensionally α = MT−2
    σo = MT½L−3/2T−1 k½
    e = M½L3/2T−1 k½
    Hence eσo = MT−2 k

    Thus α as a property of the vacuum is proportional to eσo so that:

    eσo ∝ moΩ2

    or   σo2 ∝ ρΩ2(2)

    where ρ is mass density of the vacuum.

    From (1) and (2):

    (σ/w)2 ∝ ρ

    [p. 12]metres per second are measured then this is evidence supporting the vacuum spin hypothesis presented above. I submit that the many experiments which now verify the isotropy of the speed of light relative to the laboratory and claim results to within a few metres per second all have test apparatus in rotation during the experiment. Therefore what is needed is an experiment which involves no rotating apparatus and measures the Earth rotation speed, but which can then be subjected to rotation and shown to become insensitive to Earth rotation. Then any delay in the onset of this change following rotation of the apparatus will give evidence of the inertial properties of the vacuum spin.

    The follow-on from this is to seek to sense mechanically the coupling between the vacuum spin and the rotating apparatus.

    ELECTRICAL SENSING OF VACUUM SPIN

    Another experiment worth attention involves setting up an electrical charge and seeking to induce vacuum spin which might be sensed by its magnetic field. In this connection it is noted that the Earth generates a magnetic field which is of the magnitude expected from vacuum spin. This is known from the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis based on the fact that the Earth exhibits the magnetic moment it would have if its mass had electric charge related by the factor G½. Blackett (1952)* claims to have disproved this hypothesis experimentally. He sought to concentrate the magnetic effect by using a dense gold cylinder but obtained a null result. However, he did not suspect that the vacuum medium might generate the field and this is not influenced by the density of gold.

    * P.M.S. Blackett, ‘A Negative Experiment Relating to Magnetism and the Earth’s Rotation’, Phil. Trans. Royal Society, 245A, 309, 1952/53.

    [p. 13]Finally, an interesting experiment has been performed by Ryan and Vonnegut (1971)*. They arranged for a cage to rotate around an electric arc discharge at quite low speed and found that this stabilised the arc. The task of stabilising an electric arc is one of the major problems of thermonuclear fusion research. It seems therefore very difficult to believe that the wild antics of the arc discharge are tamed merely by the slow rotation of a column of air. Perhaps there is vacuum spin in this experiment and it is the influence of the induced vacuum fields which stabilise the arc. Here then is more scope for research. Can the arc be stabilised in a vacuum? It is research which the modern physicist will not readily undertake because there is widespread belief that the vacuum is a non-entity devoid of any special properties. It is a belief encouraged by the development of relativity and in my experience those who believe in relativity deny the existence of the aether. On the other hand I was once reassured by a comment Professor Cullwick** made about something I published. He quoted Einstein as saying:

    ‘the special theory of relativity does not compel us to deny the existence of the ether …… there is weighty evidence in favour of the ether hypothesis.’

    15 September 1977

    * R.T. Ryan & B. Vonnegut, ‘Formation of a Vortex by an Elevated Electrical Heat Source’, Nature Physical Science, 233, 142, 1971.

    ** E.G. Cullwick, ‘Relativity and the Ether’, Electronics & Power, 22, p.40, 1976.

  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le27 Notes

    NOTES ON BERLIN LECTURE

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 2002

    This set of six Notes was compiled as an aide memoire for use in the author’s onward discussions following the presentation of the Lecture at the 2nd Berlin Conference for Innovative Energy Technologies organized by BINNOTEC e.V., Berlin and held the location of SolarEnergy 2002, Messe Berlin, Messedamm 22, D-14055 in Berlin, Germany on June 13th-15th 2002.

    I

    EINSTEIN: ENERGY AND THE VACUUM

    When reading about energy as a property of the medium we call the ‘vacuum’, there will
    be those who wonder about the role which Einstein played in clarifying our picture of things.
    Well, much as you may wonder, you will find that Einstein had very little to say about energy, as
    such, and far less, if anything, about the vacuum as a source of energy. Do not be deceived by
    what you think may be implied by the formula E = Mc2. This equation is easily derived by
    investigating how an electric charge accelerated by an electric field can respond to avoid radiating
    its energy E and, indeed, its very charge. Its response has to be such that it exhibits inertia
    according to a mass property M as given by the above formula, c being the speed at which electric
    field disturbance propagates through the vacuum from the seat of action, the electric charge.
    However, that was not how Einstein came to formulate that equation. His approach was
    somewhat philosophical, albeit guided by a fact known from experiment in the latter part of the
    19th century that, the faster an electric particle moves, the greater its mass, subject to a limiting
    threshold set by the speed of light c. The correct interpretation, however, is the simple fact that
    energy has to be conserved and, as an electric charge has an associated amount of energy, energy
    which increases by augmenting the electric field energy of the particle with a retinue of kinetic
    energy, that energy is not dispersed by radiation and so accumulates and enhances the mass.

    As you can see, under that heading of the Berlin Lecture ‘Capacitor Magic or a Mere
    Dream’, I began by asking you to ‘imagine’ a capacitor as having a rather unexpected property
    and followed this by asking how you would turn this into a ‘practical’ device. Imagination of
    what might be possible in our world of reality, coupled with practical skill are characteristic of the
    engineer and inventor and energy is the realm of the engineer. In contrast, noting that that Berlin
    Lecture, though prepared in draft form in January 2002 before I accepted the invitation to speak
    at the Berlin meeting and completed on 8th March after returning from a four week absence on
    vacation, it struck a chord in the author’s mind to read, on 14th March 2002 in the English
    newspaper THE TIMES, that that day was the anniversary of the birth of Albert Einstein and that:

    While at secondary school, Albert Einstein – who was born on this day in Ulm,
    Germany in 1879 – wrote an essay in which he proposed becoming a teacher of
    theoretical science, because of his “disposition for abstract and mathematical
    thought, and my lack of imagination and practical ability”.

    It is no wonder, therefore, that Einstein came to see the aether, or rather space-time, as an
    abstraction definable in terms of mathematical equations but could not imagine its real form and
    see its potential as a practical energy source!

    Admittedly, this author is here giving vent to his feelings, having in mind the hostility he
    encountered when trying to advance his insights into the nature of the aether and encountering
    shocked reaction expressed by the words “Have you never heard of Einstein?”. To have one’s
    scientific papers during a 14 year period up to 1969 rejected on sight for non-conformity with
    Einstein’s teaching did leave its scars. This accounts for the unusual choice of title of the author’s
    first major printed work, namely Physics without Einstein, a 224 page book which, incidentally,
    at pp. 8-14, presents the full mathematical analysis proving that an accelerated electrical charge
    that seeks to preserve itself from loss of energy must exhibit an inertial property according to a
    formula E = Mc2 where M is the mass defining that inertial property, E is the energy of the particle
    and c is the speed at which disturbances produced by accelerating electric field action propagate
    by displacing the electric charge system of the aether.

    [H. Aspden: 15th March 2002]

    II

    AN UNEXPLAINED ANOMALY

    It was only as I finalised the text of the BERLIN LECTURE that I recalled that, some 19
    years before, in 1983, I had been given a copy of a Ph.D. thesis by someone I knew as a Research
    Manager at IBM’s development laboratories in U.K., Dr. Bruce P. Piggin. I and Dr. Piggin had
    just retired from IBM and I had become a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the University of
    Southampton in England. Dr. Piggin’s Ph.D. research had been in the Chemistry Department of
    that university and his thesis entitled ‘Pulse Studies on an Electrochemical System’ was dated July
    1967.

    I remembered that he had some particular views about capacitors and an aspect that he
    saw as warranting attention, but what he had said at the time did not stir my interest, even though
    I was then intent on experimenting with a torsionally suspended capacitor system excited by high
    voltage pulsations to repeat my own version of the Trouton-Noble Experiment, which had in 1904
    been an attempt to detect the Earth’s motion through space. Indirectly that experiment is
    concerned with the law of electrodynamics because the detection of motion through the aether
    depends upon a certain interpretation of that law, as it concerns the notion of two spaced
    capacitor charges moving with body Earth through space and an experiment aimed at detecting
    the effects of electrodynamic interaction forces as between the moving charges.

    So my copy of that thesis has lain dormant in my files for those 19 intervening years, and
    it is only now, having been inspired by new ideas to write the BERLIN LECTURE, that I have
    seen reason to browse through it once more. My reason is that the test capacitor of Bruce
    Piggin’s thesis is a cell of concentric cylindrical electrode construction and it is pulse-charged.
    I also note that, as I now read this 1967 Southampton University thesis, it has occurred to me that
    the cold fusion theme that captured our headlines in the 1989 era, had involved a cell of somewhat
    similar construction and that Professor Fleischmann, of cold fusion fame, had his professorial seat
    in the Department of Electrochemistry at Southampton University.

    Now, in this brief note, which I admit I present as possibly only of passing interest, I only
    wish to draw attention to a feature of the Piggin thesis that I find curious as it may have some
    bearing upon the claim I am making in presenting that BERLIN LECTURE. Remember that in
    that Lecture I am suggesting that the aether can import energy anomalously into a concentric
    cylindrical capacitor. Critics will ask for evidence in support, so I feel obliged to point to anything
    that can help in this quest.

    So all I intend to present here is a copy of page 105 from Dr. Piggin’s thesis, which
    introduces his Fig. 49, and couple this with a quotation concerning that Fig. 49 that appears on
    page 100 of the thesis. I leave others who may read this to infer what they may, but say further
    that in his experiment Piggin applies an electrical pulse to charge the capacitor and follows this
    by an opposite polarity pulse to force its rapid discharge, after which, for some mysterious reason,
    that capacitor begins to recharge of its own accord. Can the inertial energy of the aether that I
    discuss in the BERLIN LECTURE be feeding in by a sub-microsecond delay?

    That quotation reads:

    ” An interesting observation is shown in Fig. 49. In this case, decay of the stored
    charge is assisted by the search pulse of opposite polarity. It is observed that the
    voltage decays at an accelerated rate during the search pulse as expected. The
    interesting question posed is why should the decay voltage rise of its own accord,
    after the search pulse has finished? Similar observations will be reported in later
    chapters.”

    Readers do need to be mindful of the fact that Dr. Piggin’s thesis concerned tests on cells
    using a chemical dielectric in the capacitor system, platinum electrode in iodine-iodide solutions
    and so chemical factors may account for the observed anomaly, but equally the chemical factor
    would not preclude aether-energy inflow and that phenomenon could well have been in evidence.
    Without there being test data for cells not loaded with a chemical dielectric this remains an open
    question.

    The following is a copy of page 105 from the thesis.

    Footnote

    As a point of interest I recall from my school education (some 60 years ago) that my
    physics master introduced us to the properties of a Leyden jar by demonstrating an experiment
    with two concentric electrodes and a removable cylindrical dielectric spacer element. He charged
    the assembly as a capacitor and then removed the dielectric element before (I believe – if my
    memory serves me well) then connecting the electrodes to discharge any energy they might have.
    Then he reassembled the capacitor with its dielectric spacer element and showed us that the
    capacitor did, indeed, still have some electric charge. His message was that there was energy
    stored in that dielectric spacer element, which I now can imagine as attributable to an inertial
    aether spin action within its cylindrical form, an action which can shed energy immediately on
    demand only if the electrode system is present and its electrodes are short-circuited so as to permit
    a discharge current to flow.

    [H. ASPDEN : 16th March 2002]

    III

    THE ASYMMETRICAL CAPACITOR ACTION

    In the BERLIN LECTURE it was suggested that a capacitor, particularly one of
    concentric cylindrical electrode construction, might deliver as output, when discharging, an
    amount of energy that could be as much as double that supplied as input when charging. This
    might seem to pose a problem with regard to the conventional mathematical analysis of capacitor
    properties, bearing in mind that we assume that the charge input Q is equal to the capacitance C
    multiplied by voltage V.

    I will, therefore, examine this problem from two points of view. I will begin by making
    a strong assertion, expressing an opinion that I feel sure 99% of the academic community versed
    in electrical theory will support, but I will then contradict what this implies by reference to
    experimental data. After that I will engage in a measure of theoretical speculation in presenting
    the only alternative point of view available, an approach which not even 1% of that academic
    community would support, and then I will endorse what this implies by pointing to experimental
    data that has been drawn to my attention but which I cannot vouch for as verified by independent
    researchers.



    The First Point of View

    One can be sure that the charge displaced around a circuit from one electrode to the other
    cannot suddenly double in value merely because of the transition which occurs as the charge-discharge cycle peaks at its maximum value. The action, therefore, must occur in the state of the
    aether between the two electrodes of the capacitor as the energy stored in that region of aether
    seeks release as the aether there senses a transition from the input to the output state.

    In short, it has to be the effective permittivity of the dielectric properties of the capacitor
    that changes to deliver the extra energy as output. In mathematical terms, it would seem that the
    permittivity during discharge must be half that applicable during the charging period, even though
    we are referring essentially to the properties of what we understand as the vacuum state. This
    implies a capacitance during discharge that is half that during the charging period, so that the
    charge Q, which equals CV, remains the same at the instant of transition, whilst the voltage V
    doubles. C, which is proportional to that permittivity value, is halved. In energy terms, bearing
    in mind that energy E = CV2/2, this results in a doubling of the energy E, meaning that the
    discharge will release twice the amount of energy that was fed in as input during charging.

    Now, the problem here is that I am not aware of any experimental evidence that reveals
    a doubling of output voltage when a capacitor begins to discharge. Even if the case is restricted
    to capacitors having concentric electrodes I still think that, if such a phenomenon were to occur,
    it would have been mentioned in our textbooks on the subject. Indeed, to the contrary, as
    reference to the Ph.D. thesis of Bruce Piggin just discussed in the preceding note shows, the
    capacitor voltage of the concentric cylindrical electrode capacitor merely follows the normal path,
    but yet, if then abruptly fully discharged by a negative input pulse, there is some kind of after
    effect which does show a mysterious voltage build-up.

    Accordingly, adopting this first point of view, has still left us with the problem of
    understanding how a capacitor can shed energy electrically if in truth it has acquired an excess of
    energy from aether input.



    The Second Point of View

    Here I need to outline a feature of the aether that my rigorous theoretical analysis of that
    structured vacuum medium has revealed. The aether has a cubic cell structure with an aether
    particle seated in each cell. It sits in a uniform continuum of electric charge which fills the space
    in that cell not occupied by the particle form and this continuum charge has a polarity opposite
    to that of the aether particle, so that the aether overall is electrically neutral. The aether particle
    would itself expand under its internal electrostatic repulsion forces were it not for there being a
    an energy presence in the cell pervading that continuum, the energy concentration matching that
    of the aether particle form so as to have equilibrium and balance of pressure. That energy
    presence is provided by a virtual pair of leptons, the heavy electrons that particle physicists refer
    to as mu-mesons or muons. They perform no known role in the physical constitution of the
    universe, because that role is primarily the one they serve in assuring pressure equilibrium within
    the aether itself and because the aether, as such, is ‘unknown’ to the theoretical physicist of today.

    I know this fact about the aether virtual muon system because my theory has allowed the
    evaluation of the unit cell energy in terms of the rest mass energy of the electron and the analysis
    suggests that a virtual muon can be either a positive or negative electron unit of charge with an
    associated energy quantum that is either 205 or 207 times the value of the electron rest mass
    energy. The theory indicates that the 207 units outnumber the 205 units by a two to one ratio.

    Indeed, by assuming that these virtual muon quanta migrate through space and suffer
    mutual annihilation and recreation at the same cyclic frequency as the quantum jitter motion of
    those aether particles, one can recognize their secondary role which accounts for the process of
    proton creation and so derive a theoretical value for the proton/electron mass ratio that is
    1836.152, in good accord with the measured value.

    This is all of record in this author’s published work, as summarized in ‘Aether Science
    Papers
    ‘ (1996), but I make particular reference to the ninth of the fourteen appended papers in
    that book, which is ‘A Theory of Proton Creation‘, Physics Essays, v. 1, pp. 72-76 (1988). It
    discusses the role of the virtual muon in creating the proton from the energy underworld of the
    aether, the energy equilibrium of that medium being maintained as it absorbs energy dissipated by
    matter, reorganizes it into a quantized virtual muon form and then sheds it as surplus by creating
    protons with an accompanying electron to keep the electrical charge balance.

    Now, why is this relevant to our capacitor problem? The simple answer here is that, if the
    capacitor is to deliver twice the amount of energy on discharge as it receives during the charge
    period, and do this without doubling its voltage for the discharge period, then it must somehow
    be able to double its charge so as to deliver twice as much output charge as it received as input.
    That is impossible unless the vacuum medium within the capacitor plates can itself produce a flow
    of charge through what is normally seen as a non-conductor of electricity.

    My proposition, therefore, is that, given that the aether has energy it seeks to release and
    given that it is alive with a virtual muon activity that passes unnoticed normally, we can look to
    that muon activity to find a way of shedding that energy as a flow of current from that capacitor.

    The action is probably one where a negative muon of 207 electron mass units sheds two
    electrons at the negative capacitor electrode and converts into a positive virtual muon of 205
    electron mass units, whilst the reciprocal action occurs at the positive electrode as two electrons
    are drawn from that electrode and absorbed into a positive virtual muon 205 to convert it into a
    negative virtual muon 207. As the virtual muons deploy in their equilibrium activity this will
    amount to a flow of electrons through the space between the electrodes.

    It means that the capacitor can, without doubling its voltage, deliver the double energy
    output by delivering double the input charge as output.

    It may all sound highly speculative and that I do not deny, but at least I offer a possible
    answer to the problem. Furthermore, though it is indeed quite fortuitous, I find that, after a lapse
    of 14 years since a previous contact, a U.S. researcher named Alexis Guy Obolensky mailed me
    a letter dated February 28, 2002 in which he reminds me of a supporting opinion I expressed back
    in 1988 concerning his discovery of faster-than-light-speed action in an experiment involving
    transmission via coaxial cables. It is quite astounding to find that, as I write this commentary as
    a Note to back up the text of the BERLIN LECTURE that I compiled in January, I can quote a
    paragraph from Obolensky’s February letter that seems to endorse my speculation. It reads:

    “I was the first to employ matched coaxial cable time delays and phase matched
    current sensors to demonstrate the existence of electromagnetic (faster than light)
    shock waves. This substantiated Tesla’s magnifying transmitter patent
    application’s superluminal claim. His technique to extract fuelless coherent-energy, from the incoherent-heat of the ambient medium, was suggested but not
    proven back in 1988. This, notwithstanding the numerous superluminal shock
    wave experiments that revealed an approximate doubling of the remote receiver’s
    integrated-current output compared to a simultaneous measurement of the local
    transmitter’s integrated-current input. To my knowledge, electronic research has
    still not investigated electromagnetic shock waves by using equal-time-delay,
    simultaneous measurements, to circumvent the Einstein clock problem.”

    That reference to the electric charge output from a pulse-excited coaxial transmission line
    being double the charge input has attracted my attention. It implies an energy gain which
    Obolensky, in the next paragraph of his letter attributes to ‘the incoherent heat in our planet’s
    atmosphere’ as the source. However, my opinion, as is evident from my BERLIN LECTURE is
    that the aether is the energy source and I can but point out that a voltage pulse travelling along
    a coaxial cable is the sequential charging and discharging of a capacitative component which has
    a conductor as central electrode and an earthed electrode formed by a concentric conducting
    sleeve, that is a concentric cylindrical electrode capacitor in which one can develop aether spin.

    Accordingly, I can but regard what Obolensky describes as supporting this second point
    of view and endorsing my conductive aether notion based on those virtual muons.

    [H. ASPDEN: 16th March 2002]

    IV

    CAPACITOR ENERGY ESCALATION ANALYSIS

    Here we calculate the condition for the circuit shown in Fig. 7 of the BERLIN LECTURE
    to tap aether energy based on the capacitor property there discussed, namely the feature that for
    a cyclic change of capacitor energy the capacitor energy doubles during the discharge. It seems
    appropriate to assume that the development of aether spin in a system which is to be governed
    by a phase-lock between a space region in spin and a non-spinning enveloping space region will
    require that a small but finite threshold of radial electric field intensity between the capacitor
    electrodes has to be exceeded.

    Let C be the value of each capacitor. Let V be the d.c. capacitor priming potential in
    volts. Let v denote the voltage of a transient potential drop across each of the two sections of the
    inductor system. Let R here denote the resistance of each such inductor section, this resistance
    including that of a load which is connected to the secondary winding of a transformer of which
    the primary winding is the inductor system just mentioned.

    At any instant the voltage across one capacitor will be V-v when that across the other
    capacitor is V+v. This is because capacitor charge can oscillate between the two capacitors as
    current flow through the inductors changes cyclically, the corresponding induced EMFs of
    strength v across each inductor section being in anti-phase and so of opposite polarity relative to
    the central earth terminal.

    By standard electrical theory the energy stored by the two capacitors is given by:

    C(V+v)2/2 + C(V-v)2/2

    which is:

    C(V2 + v2)

    and so as v changes there is no energy gain but merely a loss owing to the flow of current through
    the overall inductor resistance 2R.

    However, we are considering a situation where the discharging capacitor is shedding twice
    as much energy as it gained during charging. Therefore, allowing for the presence of the aether
    energy acquired during the charging stage, in discharging to the V-v condition, a capacitor will
    shed an excess of energy drawn from the aether amounting to:

    C(V+v)2 – C(V-v)2

    which is:

    4CVv

    This excess energy is deemed to flow in as input from the aether owing to the quantum
    synchronisation of the zero-point vacuum energy of that aether medium. This latter energy is
    replenished in each half cycle of oscillation only to the extent needed by the fluctuation of the
    voltage v across the inductors.

    Suppose now that v, which is zero initially, is induced by some internal fluctuation or
    external field stimulus and so begins a natural oscillation at the resonant frequency of the circuit.
    Let v now denote the amplitude of a sinusoidal variation so that as this passes through its zero
    value the energy 4CVv which has come from the aether has been shed in half a cycle.

    This energy has to do more than overcome resistance loss if there is to be a build up of
    the oscillations as needed to render the system useful as a power generator. Note then that the
    resistance loss plus power delivery will be proportional to v2, because v is the amplitude of the
    voltage acting across the inductors and so, with inductance fixed, the current magnitude is
    proportional to v and the resistance loss plus power delivery is proportional to the current
    squared. Accordingly, the crucial factor is whether kv2, with k determined by that inductance and
    resistance, is less than 4CVv when multiplied by twice the frequency of oscillation. If so, and
    provided that threshold condition mentioned above is exceeded, then the oscillations will escalate
    in strength and provide a source of ‘free’ energy. It is then clear why the priming voltage V is
    important.

    The factor k will also depend upon the capacitance of the capacitor as this limits the
    current. Indeed the current amplitude is 2πvC times the frequency of oscillation and if 2R is the
    circuit resistance the overall condition for an escalating energy action becomes one for which
    2V/v is greater than π2CR times the frequency. This is a simple numerical ratio because CR has
    the dimension of time. It is a condition that, at least in theory, is easily satisfied but that unknown
    threshold value of electric field intensity has to be exceeded, a factor which makes that priming
    voltage V extremely important.

    It must be high and, being high, this means that v will increase more and more until it rivals
    V in value, which in turn means that a high rate of energy output can be achieved if V+v is of the
    order of 25,000 volts and the resonant frequency is of the order of 100 kHz. Indeed, potentially,
    a pair of capacitors each of only 1 nanofarad capacitance could, on this theoretical basis, deliver
    aether energy at a power rating of the order of 50 kW, 62.5 kW being applicable if v were to
    climb to a limiting value V.

    To put this in perspective, if this capacitor energy escalation theme is a valid proposition,
    one can begin to contemplate a practical application based on the above 50 kW power output
    from a pair of 1 nanofarad capacitors. Such a capacitor using air as dielectric would need an
    electrode separation of the order of 1 cm to withstand the 25,000 volt charge. If it were to
    comprise two concentric cylinders, one having an internal diameter of 20 cm and the other an
    external diameter of 19 cm, and an overall length of 50 cm, then its capacitance would be 2.2
    nanofarad and two such capacitors would only take up a fraction of the space assigned to the
    engine compartment of an ordinary automobile. Yet the potential power rating, based on that 2.2
    nanofarad value would be in excess of 100 kW, which is an acceptable level for such an
    application. The equipment needed to generate a 25 kV capacitor priming voltage, taken together
    with a standard electrical car battery to feed in the initial charge of the capacitors plus the
    inductor/transformer units which form the resonant circuit and provide a lower voltage
    transformer output need be no larger in volume than the capacitors. One is then left with the need
    for an electric motor that can provide the mechanical drive for the automobile, this being standard
    technology but the greater weight factor in terms of drive power generated and so the primary
    design criterion that could limit vehicle performance.

    One can, however, be sure that if the new technology implied can meet the requirements
    of powering an automobile, it can be even more advantageous in large scale electric power
    generation for domestic and industrial use as well as in ship propulsion.

    Accordingly, the scientific principle involved warrants the necessary research to verify or
    disprove what is suggested and, if viable, ascertain such criteria as may impose limitations on
    performance.

    [H. ASPDEN: 17th March 2002]

    V

    POWER FROM CONCENTRIC CAPACITOR PAIRING:

    A GENERAL OBSERVATION

    The inevitable question concerning my BERLIN LECTURE is: “Why what is suggested
    has not been discovered already in the electrical laboratories of our many universities?” To
    suggest that energy outputs of some 100 kW could be delivered as if from nowhere by connecting
    two capacitors of a few nanofarads capacitance by inductors to form a resonant circuit is an awe
    inspiring proposition.

    My simple answer has to be to ask where I can look up the record of such an experiment
    having been performed and its negative result recorded. Clearly, had such an experiment been
    performed and had it delivered a ‘free’ energy output, then that would inevitably have been
    newsworthy besides being documented in a scientific periodical.

    Has the experiment ever been performed? Until someone can say: “Yes” to this question
    and quote the reference for my inspection, then I must assume the answer is: “No” and adhere to
    my argument that the issue must be clarified in view of its potential importance.

    However, just ask yourself why anyone in a university electrical laboratory would be
    interested in setting up an oscillation in an inductor-capacitor circuit as between two series-connected capacitors and an inductor and how they would proceed. I suggest that if they did they
    would obtain the capacitors commercially and that those capacitors would not be of concentric
    electrode construction. I suggest that they would not see much point in using a series connection
    of the capacitors, given that one normally connects capacitors in parallel if one seeks to augment
    the capacitance in circuit. I suggest that the series connection, if adopted, might be deemed to
    serve only as means for using capacitors of lower voltage rating in a higher voltage application,
    perhaps in a high voltage laboratory for delivering high voltage d.c. pulse discharges for test
    purposes, but not as part of a resonant inductor-capacitor circuit.

    Then consider the chance that someone would deem it worthwhile to build themselves two
    large concentric cylindrical electrode capacitors for coupling with an inductor in a resonant circuit
    and then connecting a high d.c. voltage source to the junction between the two capacitors when
    standard circuit theory says that, once connected, no steady current would flow from that d.c.
    source. Yes, were the capacitors to be of electrolytic form and have the necessary polarized
    medium as the dielectric element, one might contemplate such an assembly but then consider the
    point I now make. The ‘free’ energy theme we are discussing requires a high priming voltage V
    and a resonance that involves the capacitance attributable to the aether alone. A high dielectric
    permittivity merely means a higher loss-generating current oscillation, whereas the maximum
    ‘free’ energy gain arises from the base permittivity value of the vacuum medium and the
    capacitors with vacuum or an air-cored dielectric medium offer that maximum gain. Any spurious
    power gain in a circuit using electrolytic capacitors, even if their assembly were to be a simple
    single-pair electrode form (which is extremely unlikely) would easily be overlooked in an
    application aimed at some other objective than power generation.

    Then there is the factor of operating voltage level. I have used 25,000 V as a nominal
    voltage in estimating the ‘free’ energy potential output of the order of 50 kW based on operating
    a pair of 1 nanofarad capacitors at 100 kHz. However, an experiment on a laboratory test bench
    not in a high voltage electrostatic test laboratory environment is more likely to be performed at
    a voltage of the order of 250 V. This would lower the anomalous output power to a mere 5
    watts, which could easily pass unnoticed unless one was expressly looking for such a power
    discrepancy.

    The chance of building a circuit of the kind required and then discovering that it generates
    power in a manner contrary to expectation as founded on conventional theory is, therefore,
    extremely improbable. Yet, given that this has happened in history, what chance is there that the
    discoverer of the new ‘free’ energy source can stir interest by those in authority who are
    committed to their belief that what amounts to a ‘perpetual motion’ device is impossible because
    it defies the established laws of physics?

    There is the greater chance of what seems to be a ludicrous scientific claim being given
    attention for its general interest as a story worthy of the telling. So it is the authors of books on
    fringe-science topics that we must applaud for bringing such ‘free’ energy claims to our attention.
    There is entertainment value in the subject and, as ever, the excitement that the underdog may yet
    be proved right and turn the world of energy science around just in time to save us from the
    impending disaster that is getting ever nearer owing to the demise of our oil reserves. In saying
    this I am mindful of the reference I made in my BERLIN LECTURE to the book by Keith Tutt.

    I can but conclude that the formal academic task of pursuing the necessary experiments
    is there as a challenge for our learned brethren of the physics and electrical engineering sectors
    to undertake. Disprove by experiment what I have suggested in that lecture and find comfort in
    the ongoing belief that all is well with the prevailing laws of energy conservation which exclude
    energy inflow from the aether. Alternatively, prove that such inflow can occur and ease our
    concern about future energy resources, besides opening the door for the entry of a new
    cosmological belief, namely that our Sun and Earth were created by energy shed by an overactive
    aether.

    [H. ASPDEN: 12 April 2002]

    VI

    THE PARALLEL PLATE CAPACITOR

    The key factor pointing to how energy is extracted from the vacuum medium by the cyclic
    charging and discharging of a capacitor, the subject of my BERLIN LECTURE, is the need for
    synchronisation as between the orbital motion of charge forming the quantum underworld even
    though the charges sit in different regions subjected to different extraneous field effects. The
    presence of an electric field between the electrodes of a capacitor displaces the charge orbits there
    located and this means that, to hold that synchronism with charges elsewhere throughout the
    orbital cycle, the system of that charge between the capacitor plates must move in a direction at
    right angles to the electric field direction.

    This is possible in the cylindrical electrode capacitor configuration of Fig. 6 but this poses
    problems for the action in the parallel plate capacitor configuration of Fig. 5. I have suggested
    that the linear motion of the charge system in this latter case does deploy energy from the vacuum
    medium to keep that state of synchrony but that as the capacitor discharges the collapse of that
    linear motion would dissipate the energy within the aether itself and so not be available as a useful
    excess power output.

    Here, on reflection, I find that I may have been in error in suggesting that holding to strict
    synchrony throughout the orbital period without lateral motion might lead to an impossible
    process of continuous very high frequency oscillation of energy exchange. If that linear lateral
    displacement of charge were to be precluded by the fact that charges would be driven into one
    another and so set up an electric field opposing that motion, then the charge orbits between the
    capacitor electrodes could not be displaced in that lateral direction.

    Then what I at first deemed to be impossible may indeed be possible. The quantum
    underworld may well be able to cope with extremely rapid exchanges of energy as between its
    constituent vacuum charges and the ruling factor has to be the facts of experiment that prevail in
    the different circumstances. The phenomenon under consideration appears not to manifest itself
    in experiments involving parallel plate capacitors, where we see no anomalous behaviour, but the
    evidence, as discussed in that BERLIN LECTURE, does reveal itself when the capacitors have
    cylindrical concentric electrodes. In other words, in order for us to gain access to energy that can
    be shed by the vacuum medium by setting up a pulsating electric field between two capacitor
    electrodes, those electrodes must have a configuration which provides a passageway for free flow
    of the charges in the direction lateral to the field direction.

    [H. ASPDEN, 28th April 2002]

    ***************************
  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le27 Berlin

    LECTURE NO. 27

    OUR FUTURE ENERGY SOURCE – THE VACUUM!

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 2002
    HAROLD ASPDEN
    LECTURE FOR BERLIN MEETING
    June 2002

    This was written for presentation at the 2nd Berlin Conference for Innovative Energy Technologies organized by BINNOTEC e.V., Berlin and held at the location of SolarEnergy 2002, Messe Berlin, Messedamm 22, D-14055 in Berlin, Germany on June 13th-15th 2002.

    A Scientific Introduction

    Whilst oil companies scan ocean beds in search of future drilling sites by which to
    replenish our dwindling energy resources there seems to be little or no interest in looking for
    energy within the omnipresent vacuum medium which exists everywhere, both here on Earth and
    in outer space.

    The reason, of course, is that scientists do not recognize the vacuum as a source of energy.
    They tell us that the vacuum is, in simple words, a mere ‘nothing’, but yet they teach by reference
    to textbooks which declare that the vacuum has a magnetic permeability expressed as �o of value
    4π10-7 henries per metre and a permittivity 1/�oc2 of 8.854187817×10-12 farads per metre.

    How can the vacuum, as a medium devoid of matter, be said to have such curious
    properties if it is a mere nothing? Consider what we mean by that word ‘permittivity’. It tells us
    how much energy we can store by setting up a voltage between two metal plates in a vacuum.
    That energy sits in the vacuum – not in those metal plates! The vacuum has a way of releasing
    that energy when that voltage is reduced and that mysterious quantity we call ‘permittivity’
    governs that action.

    Note now my point that a magnetic property is also involved owing to that �o term, as is
    c, the speed of light. Magnetism is basically a dynamic action arising from electric charge in
    motion and motion implies energy. The vacuum, that mere ‘nothing’, also somehow determines
    the speed of light c, a factor in the famous energy equation E = Mc2, and yet scientists ignore the
    vacuum as a potential source of energy. There is indeed much they have to learn about this aspect
    of Energy Science and I intend here to summarize this in four stages.

    In the first and third of these I will point to free energy technology that has been
    demonstrated. In the second stage I will outline the physical principles involved and in the fourth
    stage I will conclude my message by reminding you that our universe had to be created from
    energy that apparently came from nowhere and cast some light on that great mystery.

    I. Capacitor Magic or a Mere Dream?

    I want you to imagine that you have discovered an electrical capacitor that you can charge
    with energy and which, on discharge, gives you double that amount of energy as output. It is as
    if you can perform magic, though you are merely dreaming.

    How would you turn this into a practical device? The problem you face is that the
    capacitance is quite small. Let me tell you how I would do it.

    I would connect two identical capacitors through an inductive circuit to form a resonant
    system and let the energy oscillate between the two capacitors, as one discharges whilst the other
    charges. I would draw power off, as, for example, by incorporating an electrical load denoted R
    in the Fig. 1.

    Fig. 1

    Now, the chances are, that if I built such a device it would not work because of that low
    capacitance property and the energy loss owing to the resistance of the inductive circuit. So,
    exercising my ingenuity, I would connect a high d.c. voltage V to the capacitors (see Fig. 2),
    knowing that this additional source could not deliver energy continuously, once I had switched
    the device on. The reason is that d.c. does not flow through capacitors.

    Fig. 2

    For a high enough d.c. voltage this would, as I can verify by basic electrical theory, have
    the quite remarkable effect of making the energy oscillations escalate in strength sufficiently to
    overcome the resistance loss problem. I would then surely have a working ‘free energy’ device.

    If I did not use that high voltage d.c. polarizing source then there is still the possibility that
    I could get a self-sustaining oscillation and draw as output a small amount of ‘free energy’, but
    only if I made sure that the inductors were quite large and wound from thick gauge wire so as to
    have a very low resistance.

    Can solving our future energy problems really be so simple? It is such a wonderful dream,
    truly magical, but we have, of course, to live with reality and here we need to face up to the facts
    of life. Can such a capacitor property ever be a reality? As to facts, I have several examples in
    mind, three of which I now mention.

    Fig. 3

    Firstly, as long ago as 1871, there was a U.S. patent granted which comprised two cross-coupled inductive components each having two concentric windings separated by insulation and
    so constituting, in effect, a capacitor which could develop a resonant oscillation with the
    inductance of the other cross-coupled component. Fig. 3 is a copy of Fig. 2 of that patent. The
    introductory paragraph of the patent specification stated that the invention:

    ‘relates to the combination of two or more simple or compound helices and iron
    cores or magnets in such a manner as to produce a constant electric current
    without the aid of a galvanic battery’.

    Here then in 1871 was U.S. Patent No. 119,825, as granted to Daniel McFarland Cook
    of Mansfield, Ohio, telling us how to build a device which somehow generates electricity with no
    evident power input source. Here I see a device in which electric charge can oscillate between
    the two components and somehow generate a steady excess of output energy which is supplied
    by the windings on those two inductive components. Here there was no priming d.c. high voltage
    input source, but large gauge wire was specified as essential for the inductive windings.

    These were very early days in the history of the electrical power industry. Thomas Edison
    was only 24 years old and Nicola Tesla was 15 years of age at the time, so it is no wonder that
    this very important invention was buried in Patent Office records.

    Secondly, there is the almost incredible story of the efforts of Dr. Henry Moray. It was
    reported that on 21 December 1925, Moray and three others, who went along to witness what
    was to be demonstrated, took a trip to a canyon in USA which was well removed from any
    electric power lines. A wire antenna was strung between two points well above the ground and
    connection made from the antenna to Moray’s apparatus, which itself had a ground connection.
    Electric power was delivered as if from nowhere. It was said to be powered by ‘radiant energy’,
    energy somehow delivered via the aether, but in spite of repeated demonstrations, some delivering
    substantial power measured in kilowatt terms, Moray’s discovery, notwithstanding our developing
    hunger for a new energy source, has not found its way into modern technology. The reason, of
    course, is incredulity on the part of our learned scientists plus lack of insight as to the true energy
    source.

    A description of the Moray device by T. J. Yates of Cornell University, dated 16 March
    1929, says that, in the demonstration he witnessed, two wooden boxes were placed on a table.
    On one box there was a high-frequency transformer and in the other box there were ten large
    capacitors and ten small capacitors, these all being connected by wires in a circuit including the
    antenna. One can see, therefore, that somehow it is possible to set up a resonant inductor-capacitor circuit which can deliver aether energy with the help of an antenna placed well above
    ground level in open air which delivers that high d.c. input voltage but not the steady input power
    needed to explain what was observed.

    It is, by the way, experimental fact that atmospheric electricity exists everywhere in the
    open air and has a vertical voltage gradient of several hundred V/m. It is caused by solar-powered thermal radiation exerting a downward pressure on electrons in the atoms of our
    atmosphere. Of itself, this is not a useful source of power but, as the Moray apparatus shows, it
    can serve as a priming agency in setting up the operating charge on those capacitors.

    Thirdly, there are the reports on the ‘free energy’ apparatus of the Methernitha
    community in Switzerland. They have an electrical generating machine they call Thesta-Distatica.
    It produces a substantial output of electrical power. Its main features are inductive coils
    connected to a pair of glass Leyden jars plus an electrostatic generator that we in England call a
    Wimshurst machine. When the discs of that Wimshurst machine rotate high voltages are
    generated and the pulsed output somehow activates the energy-generating properties of those two
    Leyden jars. A Leyden jar is merely a capacitor having concentric cylindrical electrodes, one on
    the outside and one on the inside of that glass jar. Here also we have two capacitors in an
    oscillatory circuit and a d.c. source that can supply high voltage but very little energy. Yet,
    somehow those capacitors can tap aether energy and generate electricity which serves that Swiss
    community.

    I believe we have here a situation where there is skill and knowledge in that community
    as to how to build this ‘free energy’ device, but I feel sure that no one there understands the
    physics that can explain where the energy that is generated really comes from.

    An extensive account of both this Swiss discovery and the story of Henry Moray’s efforts
    is provided in a recently-published book by Keith Tutt entitled ‘The Search for Free Energy’,
    published in 2001 by Simon & Schuster (ISBN 0-684-86660-9).

    II. The Physics of the ‘Magic’ Capacitor

    All physicists have heard of Clerk Maxwell and Werner Heisenberg. Some few may have
    heard of Alexandre Veronnet. Maxwell’s name is associated with electrical displacement within
    the aether (the medium we refer to as the ‘vacuum’). Heisenberg’s name is linked to quantum
    mechanics and the Principle of Uncertainty by which matter has an underlying jitter motion as if
    sharing a universal circular motion in tiny orbits at the very frequency physicists associate with
    the creation of the electron. As to Veronnet, he has also a place in history. On December 16, 1929
    the French Academie des Sciences conferred the Henry Poincare medal on Louis de Broglie for
    his work on wave mechanics, but on that same occasion Veronnet was presented with the Prix
    Lalande for his works in astronomy. The point I want to make is that Veronnet saw the aether
    as having electrical structure and an underlying quantized angular motion akin to that we learn
    of from Bohr’s theory. Veronnet realised that jitter motion in the aether could perhaps explain
    why electrons in atoms have a quantized angular momentum, that is, why they have specific
    energy quanta linked to their rotation.

    Fig. 4

    So, as I see it, it is quite logical that we should be influenced by the perceptions of these
    three great men of science and begin to portray the aether as I do in Fig. 4 which I copy here from
    page 89 of my 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’ (ISBN 0-85056-009-8). Here I depict the vacuum
    as having a cubic structure, a state of order of the kind we see in crystals or in the magnetic
    domains of a ferromagnetic material. In each notional cubic cell there is an aether particle
    describing a circular orbit with all such particles keeping in step in a synchronous motion. They
    all have the same electrical polarity and are immersed in a continuum of uniform charge of
    opposite polarity and are attracted to their respective centres of those cubic cells, but are
    displaced from those centres to radii at which their mutual electrostatic energy avoids being
    negative. Therefore they must move in orbit to assure that their centrifugal force is in balance
    with the electrostatic force attracting them to the centres of those cubic cells. It all sounds very
    hypothetical, but I can assure you that this model of the aether holds the key to solving the
    prevailing mysteries of physics, and it is unquestionably correct.

    However, here my subject is concerned with capacitors and their ‘free energy’ potential
    and I must not digress into other fascinating realms of fundamental physics. So let us now
    consider a parallel plate capacitor sitting in the aether as just portrayed. I refer now to Fig. 5.

    Fig. 5

    When I asked myself what happens when an electric voltage is applied between those two
    capacitor plates I could see that the aether charges would all be displaced in unison relative to the
    centres about which they are in circular orbit. Then I could see that they could not keep strictly
    in synchronism with their counterparts elsewhere in nearby space unless they were subject to a
    continuous very high frequency oscillation of energy exchange, something I felt was impossible.
    Then, and by ‘then’ I mean nearly 50 years ago, I saw how Mother Nature deals with this
    problem. If that applied voltage has a two-fold effect, in that it displaces the aether charge in the
    direction of the electric field to a new equilibrium position but also produces, between the
    capacitor plates, a continuous motion of that charge at right angles to that direction, then there
    can be absolute synchrony with external space charge with no high frequency energy exchange
    problems. In Fig. 5 the centres of the charge orbits are indicated and one can see that charges
    seated between the capacitor plates have an eccentric orbital motion and so their velocities in orbit
    need to be compounded with a superimposed velocity in order to keep in synchronism throughout
    their orbital period. This means the whole structure of aether particles must acquire a linear
    motion in the space between the capacitor plates, a motion which increases as the voltage between
    those plates is increased.

    In other words, I could see that one unit of electrical energy added to charge the capacitor
    would be supplemented by a further unit of energy accounting for that linear motion and it would
    be supplied by the external quantum jitter of the aether, since it was the external aether that was
    applying the constraint that assures the universal synchrony. Here was the ‘free energy’ source
    but the extra energy was locked into that aether motion and, as soon as the capacitor was
    discharged, that motion would collapse and dissipate the energy within the aether itself as it
    recovers and sustains its equilibrium.

    What I have just described applies to the parallel plate capacitor but even back in the late
    1950 era when I was researching on these matters I knew that that aether motion produced by
    electric field action could import both energy and angular momentum but I saw this as limited to
    the realm of cosmology and so of no technological significance. I earned my living by dealing with
    technological issues but still let my thoughts wander into pure physics and that higher plane that
    is the realm of those who seek to understand our universe on a grand scale and delve into that
    quest for the Holy Grail that is termed ‘Unified Field Theory’ and the problem of gravitation.
    With a Ph.D. in electrical engineering and working in a high technology corporate environment
    I really had no platform from which to project my scientific contribution, especially as my belief
    in a real aether medium made me an outcast from the world of theoretical physics.

    Nevertheless, 20 years on, in the 1970s I had seen how the aether feeds energy into events
    on body Earth, as evidenced by the creation of the thunderball and the inflow of energy to power
    the action of a tornado. This was still far from the ‘free energy’ technology theme we are
    discussing today.

    Fig. 6

    To jump rapidly ahead, now consider Fig. 6. Here I show a section of a concentric
    capacitor. That aether motion I mentioned is now not linear motion but rotary motion confined
    between the capacitor electrodes and so, when the capacitor voltage is reduced, that motion will
    have inertia and not dissipate by collisions which feed energy back into the enveloping aether.
    Instead, it will try to sustain the electric displacement, meaning that it will deploy its energy into
    the release of electrical energy which can be drawn from the capacitor. In other words, we have
    our ‘magic capacitor’. It can deliver very nearly twice as much energy on discharge as is supplied
    during charging!

    One, therefore, now has a physical explanation of the energy source that may have been
    tapped accidently and in ignorance of the true physics involved, by Cook back in 1871, Henry
    Moray in the 1920s and the Methernitha community in the 1980s.

    That, at least is my personal assumption, and I leave it to others to judge on such matters,
    whilst I am all too conscious of the implications of what I say here from the point of view of
    patenting technology in this field.

    If we now move ahead to develop technology that taps energy from the aether, guided by
    the physical principles just outlined, will the U.S. patent granted in 1871 be seen as prior
    disclosure? Will the work of Henry Moray, which was denied U.S. Patent protection, be seen as
    prior disclosure? Will the confusing reports we have heard concerning that Methernitha apparatus
    be seen as prior disclosure, when the only inference is that Leyden jars (concentric capacitors)
    were used in conjunction with a Wimshurst machine to deliver the `free energy’ as they claim?

    If so, then the patent system offers no incentive to those who pioneer the forthcoming
    revolution in the ‘free energy’ field, but we must do our best to take things forward in spite of the
    inevitable hostility of those who oppose our efforts.

    III. ‘Free Energy’: The Way Forward

    Fig. 7 shows how one can design a circuit aimed at tapping aether energy. I leave it to
    those of you who understand electrical circuit theory to work out what may be the practical scale
    of what is suggested on the basis of this ‘magic capacitor’ theme.

    Fig. 7

    My own calculations assure me that a concentric capacitor system running at a bias of, say,
    25,000 volts and oscillating at, say, 100 kHz, can deliver power, whether on a power/size or a
    power/weight basis, that can more than rival existing power plant technology – all with no
    chemical pollution and no cost for fuel input. It can even suit the needs we have for powering an
    automobile when our oil resources dry up.

    One can, therefore, dream of what might be possible, but, as ever, one might be deluded
    and encounter new obstacles, but, at least, one should confront those who ridicule the possibility
    by getting them to heed the underlying scientific message in the hope that they will wake up and
    see the sense of joining us, or leading us, in our efforts.

    As to those ‘obstacles’, one might doubt whether aether energy can flow in fast enough
    to satisfy one’s design specification, but I feel assured on that from the performance data reported
    by those who have witnessed Henry Moray’s demonstrations. The one ‘obstacle’ I would see as
    warranting special attention is the effect of large current oscillations at a high kHz or even MHz
    frequency in the large inductors of a future power generating plant. There are those who worry
    about the adverse EM (electromagnetic wave) radiation effects of using mobile telephones. To
    allay such concerns I draw attention to the Energy Science Report No. 10 that I published in
    1997, ‘Cyclotron Resonance in Human body Cells’ (ISBN 0-85056-011-X), where I discussed
    the real danger, which occurs at the much lower power frequencies as used in overhead power
    lines and in electric blanket heating. High frequency EM power radiation leaking from our future
    power generating systems need only be an interference problem affecting radio communication
    that happens to be in the same frequency band.

    As to the way forward, I can but draw attention to something I published in 1996 as
    Energy Science Report No. 8, ‘Power from Space: The Correa Invention’ (ISBN 0-85056-016-0).
    That report was essentially directed at highlighting the experimental findings in Canada of
    Alexandra and Paulo Correa, who have already proved over-unity operation of their PAGD
    (Pulsed Abnormal Glow Discharge) technology. As that report explains I see there the same
    physical action for generating excess power that I have just discussed. Also I mention that I was
    so interested by the recently reported experimental efforts of the Correas on another anomalous
    energy generating theme [‘The Reproducible Thermal Anomaly of the Reich-Einstein Experiment
    under Limit Conditions’, Infinite Energy, 7, 37, pp. 12-21, 2001] that it caused me to write about
    this energy inflow from the aether topic in a related article published earlier this year [‘Gravity and
    its Thermal Anomaly’, Infinite Energy, 7, 41, pp. 61-65, 2002].

    In that Report No. 8 I also mentioned the apparatus designed by Geoffrey Spence, an
    inventor based in U.K. This is the subject of
    his U.S. Patent No. 4,772,816.

    I feel, after what I have explained to
    you about the physical principles of tapping
    energy from the aether, that, just by looking at
    Fig. 8, copied from that patent, you will see
    how this relates to the Spence invention.

    Electrons injected into a chamber
    formed between two concentric electrodes are
    deflected into the inner electrode by a pair of
    magnets that provide and magnetic field along
    the central axis of the concentric electrodes.
    Of itself, this should add no excess energy,
    because the energy fed into accelerating the
    electrons is merely absorbed by electrostatic

    Fig. 8

    repulsion in charging the central electrode and so the capacitor. However, if that electron flow
    pulsates and there are connections to draw electron current from that central electrode then the
    pulsation implies a recurring sequence of charge and discharge. That ‘magic capacitor’ function
    is then harnessed.

    The questions then are whether the Spence invention really works and whether it is
    commercially viable? Well, I wrote that Energy Science Report back in 1996, six years ago, and
    it is only a few months ago that I heard any more of that project. Geoffrey Spence has developed
    the prototype product to the stage where he has closed the loop in the sense that a portion of the
    output power was fed back to impart the energy needed to sustain the electron beams. He has a
    self-sustaining unit that can deliver kilowatts of useful electrical power with no visible energy
    input.

    In the light of what I have discussed here, there will, no doubt, be those who take note of
    my message but say: “Well, we have heard it all before; so, when will see ‘aether energy’ heating
    our houses and powering our automobiles?” My answer is that it will be only be when the
    scientific explanation of that potential source of energy is well understood and endorsed by our
    energy research community. That is the real hurdle that stands in the way of progress, given that
    inventors in this field who see excess energy are mystified themselves.

    I recall Stanley Meyer in 1993 at the International Symposium on New Energy held in
    Denver, Colorado (April, 1993) describing his so-called ‘Water Fuel Cell’. He claimed to be
    producing a combustible gas mixture of hydrogen and oxygen by the electrical pulsing of a
    concentric cylindrical capacitor using water as a dielectric. His oral explanation and the paper as
    published in the conference proceedings were completely incomprehensible, even allowing for his
    terminology for a resistor as an ‘amp consuming device’ or as an ‘amp inhibitor’. He inferred that
    some kind of cold fusion process was involved but it was evident he had no idea as to the true
    source of the excess energy that he was claiming.

    So, having explained the energy source, and guided by what others have discovered, I feel
    vindicated in asserting that a concentric capacitor system can perform as the ‘magic capacitor’ of
    our dream world and I just hope that I may live long enough to see the technology applied on the
    grand scale.

    IV. The Energy of Creation

    As to the ‘grand scale’ of things, what can be grander than the creation of stars such as
    our sun and their satellites such as our Earth?

    I see a beginning where matter, essentially protons and electrons, is dispersed throughout
    space, along with the electrical charges that come together to form the aether. Once the aether
    condenses from a state of chaos into the ordered state of its quantum form, as by shedding a little
    more of the energy which created that matter, then the phenomenon of gravitation would be born.
    There is analogy here with the state of ferromagnetism which appears in iron only when it cools
    into a state of order that we see as magnetic domains in the iron crystals. I simply mention this
    because it was my Ph.D. research interest in ferromagnetism that caused me to think in depth
    about the aether.

    Once gravity appeared then those protons, being of greater mass than the electrons, would
    cluster together in each space domain to form a spherical body of matter having a positive
    electrical charge, pending the eventual arrival of all the electrons.

    That would set up a radial electric field and, as I have explained, that means aether energy
    inflow and aether spin. The star so formed will acquire angular momentum and, as that builds up,
    the star will seek to shed much of that angular momentum as matter, and so we have the planets.

    My message here is that the prospect of ‘free energy’ and our future on a non-polluted
    Earth is related to the very creation of this our Earth and the scientific community that seeks to
    explain everything as a Big Bang scenario in an expanding universe is wandering astray and
    neglecting the real issue common with the phenomenon of Creation, our concern with ‘aether
    energy’ as a ‘free’ energy source that can power our future.

    Harold Aspden

    8 March, 2002

    **************************

    See now the NOTES prepared to facilitate discussion of the controversial issues that the above Lecture will have opened.

  • KEYNOTE ADDRESS: DISCUSSION

    KEYNOTE ADDRESS: DISCUSSION

    THE ANTHROPIC PRINCIPLE

    INTRODUCTION

    Although I have chosen to talk about inventions in opening these Web pages, the primary topics to be dealt with as we proceed fall into two categories. These are Energy Technology and Fundamental Physics. The secret of tapping energy from the physical underworld of our environment can only be found by deciphering the data coded in what are recognized as the universal constants. Indeed, I have entitled my opening remarks as a ‘Keynote Address’, having in mind my attendance at the 1981 Conference on Precision Measurement and Fundamental Constants held by the U.S. National Bureau of Standards in Gaithersburg, MD, from June 8-12 of that year. At that meeting there was a Keynote Address on The Laws and Constants of Nature delivered by Professor Ian W. Roxburgh of Queen Mary College in the University of London. He spoke about unsolved problems in the theories related to those constants, problems which I knew I had already solved many years before. In contrast, I, who had taken leave from my management duties in a corporate environment and was there purely for my personal interest, was denied a spot on the conference programme. The two or three souls, like myself, who had ventured into this conference forum without the platform of a university department or government research institution, were allocated a few minutes at a poorly attended beer and pretzel session one evening. “Let him speak” was the cry when the moderator asked if the audience really did want to hear what I had to say about the way in which the aether determines the values of the proton-electron mass ratio and the fine-structure constant. You will not, therefore, find record of what I said in the proceedings of that conference, just my name as an attendee and my image on the group photograph of the event. However, though I did spend nine years back in academia following my later retirement from IBM, these Web pages are now my platform and I can pick up the thread of the fabric of space that I was speaking about by quoting from Professor Roxburgh’s Keynote Address at that NBS meeting. Take note that if one can explain how the energy needed to create the proton is wrapped up into that tiny particle, one can explain the creation of the whole universe. It is then a small step for mankind to find the way of tapping some energy from the same source to supply our energy needs, though not such a small step for the solitary individual.

    SECTION 12 OF THE ROXBURGH ADDRESS

    I quote now from Section 12 of the Conference Proceedings version of Professor Roxburgh’s Address. This is at pages 1-9 in the 646 page National Bureau of Standards Special Publication 617 dated August 1984.

    I have already pointed out that in standard theory (i.e. general relativity and quantum mechanics) the large numbers vary in time, and it is just a chance event that these three numbers happen to be about 1040. These numbers could be different, in which case the properties of the universe would be different, and in particular we, man the observer, would not be here to ask why the universe is as it is. This idea has been elevated to the status of The Anthropic Principle.

    Now I quote this because it brings together three facets of the energy scenario. These are the conflicting roles played (a) on the grand universal scale by Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity, with its implications for gravitational energy potential, (b) on the microscopic scale of quantum mechanics where the energy of the minute photon quantum does its work and (c) man, the observer, in the middle of an ‘Anthropic Principle’ which amounts to a conundrum concerning his energy requirements.

    It may be awe inspiring to think that the universe is as it is because we happen to be around to see it or, conversely, that we are around to see it because it is as it is, but such thoughts and those implicit in the Large Number Hypothesis are far removed from the fact that deciphering the values obtained by precision measurement of fundamental constants is what counts.

    Einstein’s theory does not tell me how energy is stored in empty space, meaning space devoid of matter, by the process of magnetic induction. Nor, indeed, does quantum mechanics. I do know that mankind would be in a sorry plight if that empty space could not somehow store the energy locked into a magnetic field. Numbers do creep into the picture here, because I realized that the real question we must face is not how we shed energy into space when we send magnetizing current through an air-cored coil, but how that energy can ever come back as electricity when we switch the current off? Mathematics or man-made laws based on empirical observation offer no answer.

    I had to reason that something equivalent to current flow in a coil was occurring within that space taken up by the real coil. This meant that if I applied a current having the effect of, say, 2 amps in the coil and that hidden space coil reacted by setting up a 1 amp current reaction, then the net effect would be that of a 1 amp input, but when I switch off the current input, that residual 1 amp reaction effect in space would collapse energy back into my primary coil. Overall, space would need to respond as if there was a 2:1 anomaly in the field reaction.

    As my Ph.D. research was all about magnetic reaction effects in steel and I knew there was a 2:1 anomaly observed in the gyromagnetic reaction of pivotally mounted ferromagnetic rods when subjected to field reversal, it was clear to me that here was the signature of space itself. It had a thermodynamic property. It would heat up when a steady magnetic field was applied and cool down when that field was switched off. For ‘it’ read ‘aether’, because it, meaning empty space, is ‘nothing’ and one can only put energy into ‘something’.

    So, far from that large number of 1040, here was I, concerned about the simple number 2! When, back in the 1950s I told physicists about my factor-of-2 theory, I was duly kicked in the teeth for daring (a) to say there was an aether, when Einstein had proved otherwise, and (b) for ignoring Dirac’s explanation of the factor of 2 based on his contriving a combination of relativistic principles and quantum mechanics.

    I did know enough about Einstein’s theory and quantum mechanics to set about building an aether theory which fitted the empirical facts on which those two theories had been founded. That kept me busy for many years but was rewarded very early by the discovery of how to decipher those fundamental constants pertaining to fine-structure in the atomic spectrum, gravitation and the proton-electron mass ratio and, eventually even the Hubble constant fell into place on my aether theory. However, that factor of 2 holds the secret which tells us we can tap energy from the aether with the aid of ferromagnetism.

    So, when you have finished reading this discussion note and you return to the main Web page, the HOME PAGE, you have a choice in your onward journey through the subject of Energy Science. You may go directly along the TECHNOLOGY path by studying the relevant Lectures and Essays or you may take the more academic scientific route and embark on the PHYSICS route which has its own separate set of Lectures and Tutorials. Of the latter, do work through the Tutorials first, because you will then find how easy it is to understand how the key fundamental constants of physics are determined by aether theory. However, if your mind is on technology and tapping the energy of the aether, then the starting point should be my Lecture entitled ‘The Invention of Hans Coler, which is Lecture No. 7.

    SECTION 11 OF THE ROXBURGH ADDRESS

    Returning briefly to the Roxburgh Keynote Address I quote now from the early Section 11 of that paper:

    Other pure numbers we have considered are the fine-structure constant and the mass ratio of the electron to proton, these being approximately 1/137 and 1/1836, respectively. Why do these numbers have these values? What would the universe be like if these numbers were different? I think most scientists would conjecture that one day we will be able to explain why the particles masses are as observed and why the fine-structure constant has its particular value. At the moment we do not have a deep understanding of particle physics to provide the explanation. A similar view can be taken about the cosmological numbers of the order 1040. Such fundamental theories linking cosmology and microphysics have been pursued by several people, but without apparent success.

    On this latter point there were two references quoted, one being to Eddington’s ‘Fundamental Theory’ and the other to Roxburgh’s own account in ‘The Encyclopedia of Ignorance’.

    I may add that I had gone to the Conference expecting to be given a hearing on my own theory for those two numbers 1/137 and 1/1836. I was not intending to announce any kind of discovery, but rather to draw attention to what had been published on the subject already in well respected scientific periodicals. My 1972 Physics Letters paper: ‘Aether Theory and the Fine Structure Constant’, v. 41A, pp. 423-424, [1972a] was known to Brian Petley, an attendee from the U.K. National Physical Laboratory at that Conference. Indeed, he expressly referred to it in the book entitled: ‘The Fundamental Physical Constants and the Frontier of Measurement’, (Publishers: Adam-Hilger), which he wrote in the aftermath of that Conference. However, it seems he did not know about the 1975 paper: ‘Calculation of the Proton Mass in a Lattice Model for the Aether’, Il Nuovo Cimento, v. 30A, pp. 235-238 [1975a], as that eluded mention in his book, though it did attract later comment in a research paper by experimentalist R.S. Van Dyck, another attendee at that Conference, one famous for his measurements of the proton-electron mass ratio. I refer to that in my recent book: Aether Science Papers as listed in the Bibliographic section of these Web pages and commend that book for attention by any physicist willing to have an open mind on such matters as particle creation and those fundamental constants.

    So you see, I have a theory which gives the answers, but yet, because those answers come, not from relativity or string theory or from one of the popular modern theories, but come instead from the mundane aether, those answers are ignored. We shall have to see if physicists can ignore the energy bonanza that is now at hand, thanks to that aether source!

    WHY INTERPRET RELATIVITY?

    To end this discussion I offer a few words about the theory of relativity. Periodically there are conferences in London held under the auspices of the British Society for the Philosophy of Science on the subject of ‘Physical Interpretations of Relativity Theory’. The last such event at the time this was written was held on 6-9 September, 1996.

    As an attendee I was surprised to find that my research was praised by a speaker who was unknown to me, J. Dunning-Davies of the University of Hull. In the text of his paper, as later published, he writes:

    In this country, possibly the two best known critics of relativity are Louis Essen and Harold Aspden but, as Essen points out, even someone as academically eminent as ‘Rutherford treated it as a joke and Soddy called it a swindle’. On the other hand, equally eminent academics such as Eddington championed the pro-relativity cause. Recently, the fluid dynamist Kenneth Thornhill has reported significant results without recourse to relativity.

    Now, to correct the above impression it was really Essen, acclaimed for his discovery of the caesium atomic clock and the measurement of time at the U.K. National Physical Laboratory, who made a full-frontal attack on the theory of relativity. Essen pointed a finger in my direction as a ‘Hope on the Horizon’ and referred to my book ‘Physics without Einstein’ and also to ‘Modern Aether Science’, but I never did set out to probe the weaknesses of Einstein’s theory. All I was aiming at was to be sure that that theory did not block the path for acceptance of my aether theory. I do not wish to be remembered as a critic, but rather as the discoverer of the secrets hidden in the aether.

    Reading further in the Dunning and Cole paper: ‘Qualms concerning relativity theory and some of its applications’, in the conference proceedings of that meeting (pp. 52-63 in the Late Paper section), I was interested in the following reference to Thornhill’s work:

    Thornhill concludes by noting that a return to Newtonian mechanics and all that that implies would create a backlog of problems still demanding conventional solutions, as well as a suitable aether. However, he claims that such problems may be solved using the methods of unsteady gas dynamics and the theory of characteristics.

    On that subject I stress that it is a false approach to try to explain the properties of the aether in terms of the properties of matter and especially in terms of fluid dynamics. You see, the root of the problem is that of understanding the very nature of mass in terms of electrical energy. It is electrical action and the attendant magnetic actions that can assert their influence through the space which separates electric particles. Fluid dynamics requires contact and does not countenance action at a distance. If we are to tap energy from space there has to be something other than exchange of energy by collisions between particles. We have to tap into the energy pool to which we are coupled by those magnetic fields and it is the latter that come quantized in units determining the Planck constant. That tells us to look at the dimensionless fine structure constant as an aether property, because it combines Planck’s constant, the unitary electron charge and the speed of light in one numerical expression 1/137. Decipher that in terms of an electrical aether and you have arrived where you need to be and there are then really few unsolved problems even though Einstein’s theory sinks into oblivion.

    I end this Discussion by emphasizing that the subject of interest in these Web pages is ENERGY. We are dealing with Energy Science of the kind which concerns actions involving AETHER. This is the domain of those electrical phenomena we still do not fully comprehend. Our subject is not philosophically based on the problems of communication across space and Einsteinian-type questions such as how light can always travel at a constant speed and yet bend in its path around a star. Imagine two runners going around a curved track, side-by-side, and see one get ahead as they run at the same speed! Let two separate observers time their motion by their different stop watches to find they keep pace with one another. Then go away and make sense of those findings in the light of what you know you have seen. You will soon lose all sense of time and have no regard for the energy expended by those runners. I would say that those stop watches needed calibrating against the steady rhythm of Nature’s natural time and without reference to Einstein, the Swiss Patent Examiner.

    ENERGY is what counts, and once we understand all we need to know about how energy is juggled about in space, particularly in the space local to our Earth, then we can build a picture of that AETHER. So we will delve into Aether Science and Energy Science and jump between the two as these Web pages take form.

    I have much to say about what lies ahead in that territory, but there are still vast unexplored regions. The physical basis of that 1836 number ratio for the proton-electron mass ratio tells us about proton creation but does not fully answer questions such as “when” and “where” those protons found they could form the atomic nuclei of, say, carbon and oxygen. It is all too easy to speculate about what happens inside stars, assuming their cores are at temperatures of tens of millions of degrees. Give ‘cold fusion’ a hearing and you might wonder if stars need be much hotter than, say, 10,000 degrees. Resolve the anomalies surrounding the photon and the transport of energy by electromagnetic waves, with gravity in mind, and you might wonder if waves ripple through the aether, promoting fluctuations of aether energy already there, whilst the source energy of stellar radiation is pulled back to the star by gravity and so conserved. Such a hypothesis would account for how a star can sustain its radiant condition for billions of years. Go even further and face up to that question of whether the fundamental physical constants can change with time. They may be different in different galactic regions. If so it could be that those oxygen atoms could form in some regions of space as part of the ongoing process of proton creation, rather than by a subsequent fusion process. Then we could see a way of forming the hydroxyl ion and so water and begin to pay attention when scientists tell us that comets are composed of ice. One might even wonder if comets contain more than a good measure of spinning aether, inasmuch as the aether exists, what exists can move and a form of movement is ‘spin’. Anything, therefore, which involves energy in an unusual way and has bearing on both cosmology and microphysics warrants scrutiny with the aether in mind. However, amidst all of this, it is the interplay between aether and the ferromagnetic condition of matter or the interplay of aether and the electrodynamics of the heavy ion that offers us an access route to ‘free energy’. Do not let your false preconceived notions about the AETHER deter you from considering what is said on the subject in these Web pages. The aether is the only hope we have for avoiding the pollution caused by fossil and nuclear fuel. If that aether can create protons and package energy into photons then it has something useful to tell us about energy. If, as a scientist, you can explain proton creation and photon creation without needing an aether, then you can claim an alternative scenario. If you cannot, in a way which can rival what I have to say in these Web pages, then do see the aether as I do and offer it your support.

    Now make your choice. Go back to the Homepage and decide whether you wish to select a Lecture topic or work through the Tutorials to see how easy it is to explain those mysterious numbers 137 and 1836, or even those very large numbers that come into play as the Constant of Gravity gets into the act. I thank you for your interest.

    Harold Aspden, August 19, 1997