Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le05Ap2

    LECTURE NO. 5: SECOND CONTINUATION

    SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION (CONTD.)

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1977, 1997

    SATELLITE FORMATION

    [It has been shown above that the parameter Ad, which is a property of the vacuum medium, must have the value of approximately 20 gm/cc. This does not mean that this mass density is that attributed to the vacuum medium, because A is a numerical constant and the three separate empirical sets of data that tell us the value of Ad have not revealed the value of A on its own. However, we can now proceed further, using the result we have obtained to tell us something about the satellite system that can develop, whether we consider Sun or Earth. The following analysis was summarized in a box illustration in the 1977 lecture paper. However, it also features in the text at pp. 158-159 of my 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’ and, taken in combination with pp. 166-167, is expressed there with greater clarity. Accordingly, apart from the diagram below (which did not include the suffix feature for M or m) I shall here, in the remainder of this text under the heading SATELLITE FORMATION, reproduce text from this book to complete this section.]

    Let ms denote the mass of a satellite material in orbit around the parent body in its surface regions of radius R, that parent body being of mass Mp and let X represent the angular momentum of that satellite system. Suppose that the parent body has a net electric charge +Q during the satellite formation phase and that the satellite material has a net electric charge -Q. Then force balance gives:

    kQ2/R2 = X2/msR3

    where k may be less than unity if, for some reason, not all of the charge seated in the satellite region is effective in setting up the attractive force between parent and satellite.

    Note that:

    GMp2 = Q2

    R. A. Lyttleton in his book ‘Mysteries of the Solar System’, Clarendon Press, Oxford, p. 34, 1968 has explained how magnetic forces exerted within a system of charge by its rotation and self-gravitation will force angular momentum outwards. Thus the transfer of the angular momentum X to a concentrated surface zone is understandable. In a sense this can be thought of as a phenomenon similar to the gyromagnetic reaction already discussed. The reaction angular momentum of the field absorbs angular momentum from the centre of the body and the primary balance of angular momentum is driven to the outer periphery of the rotating system, all as a result of the diamagnetic screening effects within the electrical core.

    Once the equation involving kQ and X above is established, the body is primed to create its satellite system. All that has to happen is for the Q charges to neutralize by slow discharge and as this happens the satellite matter of mass ms will leave the main body. It will take up an eventual orbital position governed by gravitational balance between Mp-ms and ms and the centrifugal forces on ms.

    This is all rather simple and it lends itself to immediate verification because we can develop a formula for ms/Mp which can be checked with observation. Use the above equation to link G, Mp and Q and write Mp as 4π/3 times dpR3. Replace X by 2MpR2w/5, the angular momentum formula for a uniformly dense sphere of mass Mp and radius R rotating at angular velocity ω. Then the equations combine to give:

    ms/Mp = 3w2/25πdpGk

    Now apply this to the Sun, noting the initial angular velocity ω is found by summing the present angular momentum of the solar system and computing ω from the above expression for X. This is shown in Appendix II of the book ‘Physics Unified’ to make ω a little greater than 8×10-5 rad/s. [But note that this assumes that the Sun’s mean mass density of 1.4 gm/cc applies as a uniform distribution throughout the solar form.] On this assumption, we then find that if k=2 the planet/Sun mass ratio given by our formula is 1/764. The observed value of this mass ratio is 1/745.

    Next, let us check this same formula with the Earth’s own satellite, the Moon. The Earth has a dp value of 5.5 gm/cc and ω of the initial Earth before the Moon was ejected was, according to Lyttleton, 5.5 hours per revolution or (3.2)x10-4 rad/s. This is easily verified by adding the Moon’s angular momentum in orbit around the Earth to that possessed by Earth today. In this case we find that if k=1 we obtain from our equation a value of the Moon/Earth mass ratio of 1/83. The observed ratio is 1/81.

    It follows that we have a viable theory of creation of our planetary system if only we can explain why k=2 for the Sun and k=1 for the Earth. This is a vital clue to the understanding of the cosmic medium and the source of the Sun’s initial angular momentum.

    [The 1977 lecture paper did not resolve the question as to why k should be different by a factor of 2 for Sun and Earth and so we will not here follow through with the explanation that later appeared in the 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’. However, it will be the subject of a later Lecture included in these Web pages and, in the meantime, copies of that book are in print and are still available at this time (June, 1977). The subject Lecture now proceeds by reverting to the next section of text in the 1977 lecture paper.]

    STRUCTURED SPACE

    An important question is that of why the solar system suddenly came into being some 4,500,000,000 years ago. It is as if there was a sudden decision that gravitation would come into being. The usual starting point is to suppose a diffused cosmic dust begins to come together due to gravitation. But why should there be such a beginning? If matter dispersed in space was created slowly and steadily the results which have just been presented would not apply. An answer comes from the understanding of the nature of the force of gravitation and the realization that it only exists in a vacuum medium which has structure. The analogy is found in ferromagnetism. There are forces which depend solely upon the prevailing ordered state of the ferromagnetic substance. Above the Curie temperature there is no magnetism. Similarly, in any crystalline substance there are forces which vanish once the crystal becomes disordered by high temperature effects. Therefore, I offer the suggestion that the electrical medium permeating the vacuum has structure and that some 4,500,000,000 years ago [or whenever it was that our Earth and solar system were created] this structure went through a transition which allowed gravitation to assert itself.

    The geometry of a lattice-structured vacuum can yield parameters determining the fundamental physical constants and assuring their universal equality [1969a, 1975a]. However, this takes us beyond the scope of this paper and I wish to conclude by suggesting some experiments.

    OPTICAL SENSING OF THE VACUUM

    It should be possible to distinguish between linear motion and rotation by optical sensing of the vacuum medium. A sphere of rotating structure will not disturb a similar surrounding structure. The linear motion of a lattice-like structure through a similar surrounding structure seems impossible. Yet it is possible if the lattice density is reduced by linear motion and the free lattice substance is in counter-motion within the body of the lattice. Analysis [1976a] shows that the optical reference frame moves with the lattice in linear motion, a result confirmed by the famous Michelson-Morley experiment. On the other hand, since the lattice density is unchanged in the rotating state, the optical reference frame remains the non-rotating reference frame. Thus an experiment involving the measurement of the speed of light in the Earth’s rotating frame should be sensitive to the Earth’s rotation. This is confirmed by the experiments of Michelson, Gale and Pearson (A.A. Michelson, H. G. Gale & F. Pearson, Astrophysical Journal, v. 61, p. 140; 1925).

    The interesting question is whether the vacuum can be set in rotation by test apparatus and this Earth rotation component obscured in optical tests. For example, at the equator the laboratory moves eastwards at a speed of about 460 m/s. Speed of light tests should indicate a difference of 920 m/s between the west-east and east-west speeds. This is provided the apparatus has not become, in effect, a system with its own rotating vacuum and so carried forwards around the equator with what is effectively a vacuum system in linear motion. In short, if rotating apparatus is avoided, it should be possible, as in the Michelson-Gale-Pearson experiment to detect the 920 m/s speed difference in the light tests. If the presence of rotating apparatus obscures this measurement and differences of a few metres per second are measured then this is evidence supporting the vacuum spin hypothesis presented above. I submit that the many experiments which now verify the isotropy of the speed of light relative to the laboratory and claim results to within a few metres per second all have test apparatus in rotation during the experiment. Therefore, what is needed is an experiment which involves no rotating apparatus and measures Earth rotation speed, but which can then be subjected to rotation and shown to become insensitive to Earth rotation. Then any delay in the onset of this change following rotation of the apparatus will give evidence of the inertial properties of the vacuum spin. The follow-on from this is to seek to sense mechanically the coupling between the vacuum spin and the rotating apparatus.

    ELECTRICAL SENSING OF VACUUM SPIN

    Another experiment worth attention involves setting up an electrical charge and seeking to induce vacuum spin which might be sensed by its magnetic field. In this connection it is noted that the Earth generates a magnetic field which is of the magnitude expected from vacuum spin. This is known from the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis baed on the fact that the Earth exhibits the magnetic moment it would have if it had electric charge related by the factor G1/2. Blackett (P.M.S. Blackett, ‘A Negative Experiment Relating to Magnetism and Earth Rotation’, Phil. Trans. Royal Society, v. 245A, 309; 1952/53) claims to have disproved this hypothesis experimentally. He sought to concentrate the magnetic effect by using a dense gold cylinder but obtained a null result. However, he did not suspect that the vacuum medium might generate the field and this is not influenced by the density of gold.

    Finally, an interesting experiment has been performed by Ryan and Vonnegut (R.T. Ryan & B. Vonnegut,’Formation of Vortex by an Elevated Electrical Heat Source’, Nature Physical Review, v. 233, 142; 1971). They arranged for a cage to rotate around an electric arc discharge at quite low speed and found that this stabilized the arc. The task of stabilizing an electric arc is one of the major problems of thermonuclear fusion research. It seems therefore very difficult to believe that the wild antics of the arc discharge are tamed merely by the slow rotation of a column of air. Perhaps there is vacuum spin in this experiment and it is the influence of the induced vacuum fields which stabilize the arc. Here then is more scope for research. Can the arc be stabilized in a vacuum? It is research which the modern physicists will not readily undertake because there is widespread belief that the vacuum is a non-entity devoid of any special properties. It is a belief encouraged by the development of relativity and in my experience those who believe in relativity deny the existence of the aether. On the other hand I was once reassured by a comment Professor Cullwick made about something I published (E.G. Cullwick, ‘Relativity and the Ether’, Electronics & Power, v. 22, 40; 1976). He quoted Einstein as saying: ” The special theory of relativity does not compel us to deny the existenceof the ether….there is weighty evidence in favour of the ether hypothesis.”

    [The above lecture paper was dated 15 September, 1977. It did include another boxed illustration containing the following analysis explaining the induction of charge by vacuum spin.]

    CHARGE INDUCTION BY VACUUM SPIN

    [Beneath this heading in the 1977 lecture paper there was a sub-heading (Linear Oscillator Property) which stressed the point that the vacuum medium exhibits the characteristics of a simple harmonic linear oscillator. The vacuum medium has a natural oscillation frequency which has the value found by dividing the rest-mass energy of the electron by Planck’s constant. At the speed of light that frequency corresponds to the Compton electron wavelength h/mc. As an angular frequency it is denoted Ω.]

    Each element of the structured vacuum rotates at the universal frequency Ω in small orbits of radius r. If there is vacuum spin at angular frequency ω then in the plane of Ω an element moving at radius R from a spin axis will be radially displaced by the amount ωR/Ω. The area of a disc of radius R will change in proportion to 2ω/Ω.

    Note then that there will be an induced charge density of σ, given by:

    σo(2ω/Ω)

    where σo is the overall charge density of the aether structure not allowing for the compensating effect of the non-displaced neutralizing charge background. Now let K denote the restoring force rate so that Kr is the centrifugal force component attributable to each element mo forming that aether structure and K is moΩ2.

    The electrical nature of the restoring force and the electric induction developed by vacuum spin are then readily explained by dimensional analysis. Note that the ‘=’ sign used here implies equivalence or proportionality and not equality.

    K = MT-2
    σo = ML-3/2T-1k1/2
    e = M1/2L3/2T-1k1/2
    eσo = MT-2k

    Thus K, as a property of the vacuum, is proportional to eσo and:

    eσo = moΩ2

    which, by multiplying by the number of charges e in unit volume of the aether structure, can be rewritten as a statement that the mass density of the vacuum structure is proportional to (σo/Ω)2.

    Then, since we have shown that σo(2ω/Ω) is proportional to σ, we find that the mass density of the vacuum structure is proportional to (σ/ω)2 which we also inferred earlier from dimensional analysis, but without giving reason for the induction process in terms of the linear oscillator property of the electrical system that exists as the aether medium.

    ***

    ADDED NOTE

    The question of vacuum spin, by which is meant the storage of spin energy in the vacuum medium, and the prospect that the vacuum itself may thereby assert turning forces on matter has been implied in the 1977 lecture paper by reference the research of Zinsser. Also there may seem to be some confusion in presuming, in the discussion about electrodynamic interactions, that out-of-balance turning effects cannot be induced electrodynamically, and then suggesting the opposite, as by reference to the Zinsser experiments. The point I wish to stress is that the vacuum spin is set up by electrostatic action attributable to a radial electric field and does not owe its origin to electrodynamic action. It would seem that out-of-balance linear force can arise from electrodynamic action, by energy transfer attributable to moving electric charge, whereas out-of-balance turning couples, really balanced by aether reaction, are the province of electric displacement from a central axis.

    Concerning Zinsser I cannot vouch in any way for the authenticity of what he claimed, but I think it appropriate to refer here to some comments I quote from a book by Thomas F. Valone entitled ‘The Homopolar Handbook’, published by Integrity Research Institute, 1377 K Street NW, Syuite 204, Washington, DC 20005.. This book is dated 1994, but it includes on pp. 74-75 an account of a meeting between Valone and Zinsser in Hanover, Germany in 1980. The report there published had appeared earlier in ‘Energy Unlimited’, No. 9, publisher’s address: Rt. 4, Box 288, Los Lunas, NM 87031, USA.’

    Valone’s remarks read: “At dinner, Adam Trombly and I were interrupted by Dr. Nieper re-introducing Rudolph Zinsser as the foremost German expert on gravitation. Then the friendly, white-haired Zinsser began to describe his 10 years of research to us as I reached for my tape recorder. There was an excitement in the air as Adam and I struggled to comprehend Dr. Zinsser’s patented pulse generator (US Patent No. 4,085,384) causing an unprecented 3 to 5 hour force from a brief ‘activation’ of only 90 seconds. We were shown a 6-inch plexiglas cylinder with two aluminium plates inside submerged in a water dielectric. He described the small activator in front of us energizing an object suspended in a vacuum.

    Dr. Zinsser showed us graphs recording the angle of deflection of the object which was labelled in terms of force. A maximum of 8 dynes manifested within 1/4 hour of activation, slowly dropping to zero about 5 hours later. He said everything could be scaled upwards without difficulty. In comparing the impulse delivered to power input, he said that it was at least 10,000 times the ratio obtained from chemical rockets (based on Dr. Peschka’s analysis). I am really glad I met Rudolph Zinsser who certainly destroyed my conventional notions of force and energy.”

    ****

    To continue this lecture press:

    *
  • SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION

    LECTURE NO. 5: FIRST CONTINUATION

    SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1977,1997
    This is a copy of the lecture material and hand-out as presented by the author to the students and staff of the Physics Department at the University of Cardiff in 1977. There was some interest at that location in the author’s research on gravitation, as reported in the books ‘Physics without Einstein’ and ‘Modern Aether Science’ and the author was invited to give this as a special lecture. Some of the findings were later mentioned in the 1980 book: ‘Physics Unified’. Note, however, that there will be some comments included in square brackets in the text below by way of explanatory notes needed to explain something quite important which the author attributed in error to Clerk Maxwell, but which in fact the author should have claimed as his own original brainchild. As to the references, where these refer to this author’s papers these are given as they are indexed in the Bibliographic Reference Section of these Web pages. Other reference detail will be included in italics in the body of the text.

    INTRODUCTION

    This lecture presents some new scientific evidence which may help our understanding of the creation of the solar system. It suggests an experimental approach for exploring the phenomena involved. It results from theoretical enquiry into the structure of the vacuum medium, a pursuit which is somewhat controversial. It is hoped, however, that the evidence presented will speak for itself and encourage those with the resources to undertake the necessary experimental research.

    SOLAR ENERGY AT CREATION

    We believe the Sun to be a nuclear inferno and that it was formed by matter in space condensing under gravitational force. This resulted in a build-up of temperature until eventually the primordial matter in the form of hydrogen began to be steadily converted into helium by nuclear processes. The radiation from this nuclear core then prevented the Sun from contracting further and we have a stable, but slowly dying, Sun which could well feed us with solar energy for another 10,000,000,000 years.

    We no longer worry about what happened to the energy released by the gravitational field when the Sun was first formed. There was enough energy from this source to sustain the present level of solar radiation for about 20,000,000 years. We suppose that it was all radiated away long ago. However, it must have performed some role during the early stages of the Sun’s creation and it is this which I find of interest.

    For example, if the energy released was somehow all stored by the Sun as kinetic energy, the Sun would have to move at about 500 km/s. Curiously, measurements of the Earth’s motion through space by reference to the supposed-isotropic cosmic background radiation do indicate speeds of this general order (E. K. Conklin, ‘Velocity of the Earth with respect to the Cosmic Background Radiation’, Nature, v. 222, p. 971; 1969). This then leads one to ask whether the gravitational energy released is perhaps conserved in the local cosmic environment as a state of motion.

    Speculation such as this raises problems of momentum balance. We know that interactions between matter must satisfy the action and reaction law of Newton. Angular momentum is conserved in any complete system subject to central laws of force such as the law of gravitation. This follows from energy conservation principles.

    However, the source of angular momentum of the solar system poses very perplexing problems. We would like to think that the planets were formed from the Sun, but the planets revolve in their orbits in exactly the same sense as the rotating Sun. Somehow the Sun must have acquired a substantial angular momentum when it was first formed and somehow it shed most of that angular momentum in giving birth to the planets.

    So difficult is this problem that philosophers have resorted to the unlikely hypothesis that another star once passed close to our Sun, imparting angular momentum and inducing planetary creation. Such an event, they recognized, is so improbable that the solar system could be unique in the universe, assuring mankind a rather special place in the cosmic scene.

    I prefer to regard the problem of the source of the Sun’s angular momentum as a clue linked with the storage of gravitational energy released when it was formed.

    ENIGMA INVOLVING ROTATION

    There is other evidence of phenomena which involve unusual angular momentum properties or raise difficulties with the principle that action balances reaction.

    One example is the mysterious energy source of tornadoes. It has been argued very persuasively by Vonnegut (B. Vonnegut, ‘Electrical Theory of Tornadoes’, Journal of Geophysical Research, v. 65, p. 203; 1960) that this energy really comes from the electrical discharges we associate with thunderstorms but the very substantial angular momentum of the tornado is also a problem. It may be that the energy somehow concentrates the angular momentum of an ordinary whirlwind or, as Vonnegut writes: ” it is possible that the vortex is initiated directly by electrical energy.” Vonnegut also remarked that: “an understanding of ball lightning may very well be necessary if the tornado puzzle is to be solved.”

    [Vonnegut illustrated features of the tornado as above, noting that there is ‘incessant lightning’ and a ‘brilliant cloud’ within the funnel.]

    Thus ball lightning becomes the second enigma. It is the problem of glowing spheres which are regularly seen to float about in the air following a thunderstorm. They have an aetherial character because they can pass through walls, get inside aircraft and vanish suddenly, sometimes explosively with release of substantial energy. They are so peculiar and subject to such strange reports that they evoke a great deal of scepticism. However, the fact remains that they are a mysterious scientific phenomenon produced by lightning. They contain energy of some 107 joules per cubic metre and apparently form as spinning spherical objects. The implication is that they have an associated angular momentum.

    In the laboratory there are, to my knowledge, two reports of anomalous behaviour which are seemingly relevant. In 1972 a demonstration at a meeting of the Institution of Electrical Engineers in U.K. surprised its author. A rotor in a machine speeded up when the power was switched off. It happened and yet could not be reproduced in later efforts to study the phenomenon (E. Laithwaite, ‘Unexplained Phenomenon’, Electronics & Power’, v. 18, p. 360; 1972). It is as if, by some very special circumstance, energy was stored as rotational kinetic energy in the environment of the machine and was fed back to the machine when it was switched off.

    The other report appeared in the German publication Umschau in 1975 (R. G. Zinsser, ‘Kinetobarische Effekte – ein neues Phanomen?’, Umschau, v. 5, p. 152; 1975). Experiments are here reported as consistently verifying a phenomenon which defies explanation. An energy pulse communicated at high frequency across a capacitative coupling is absorbed in a torsion balance. After the pulse has subsided, a unidirectional torque prevails in the system for up to two hours for no apparent reason. It is as if energy is stored by some kind of unseen flywheel that feeds energy back to the apparatus slowly once the power is switched off in the system.

    The Zinsser apparatus. The system senses a very-slowly decaying uni-directional torque once the capacitor excitation is switched off.

    It is clear from these examples that there is a case to answer and we can rightly examine the source of the Sun’s angular momentum in relation to electrical action and the rotation of an unseen medium. I am therefore suggesting that the vacuum medium itself may exhibit properties attributable to its rotation. Before developing this thought, however, I wish to give one more example of the problem we have with the balance of action and reaction if we choose to ignore the role of the vacuum medium in interactions between matter.

    THE LAW OF ELECTRODYNAMICS

    Theoretically there is good reason to suppose that the electrodynamic action between two charges in parallel motion can produce forces which develop rotation.

    By suspending a charged capacitor any transverse motion should result in a turning effect until the line joining the effective centres of charge is at right-angles to the motion. Only then will action balance reaction in a steady uniformly-moving system.

    Electrodynamic interaction between two opposite charges in parallel motion, as expected from conventional theory.

    The experiment was performed by Trouton & Noble in 1903 (F.T. Trouton & Noble, ‘The Mechanical Forces acting on a Charged Electric Condenser moving through Space’, Phil Trans. Roy. Soc. London, v. 202A, p.165; 1903)). They sought to detect the Earth’s linear motion through space, but a null result was reported. It gave stimulus to relativistic doctrine but equally it demonstrated the inapplicability of Lorentz’s electrodynamic formula. The Lorentz law is inadequate to deal with actions between isolated electric charges in motion.

    All the empirical evidence before that time had involved the interaction of effectively closed circuital motion with individual charges. This did not give enough empirical data to formulate a unique law of electrodynamics. It was a point well appreciated by Maxwell because he wrote about this in his great treatise (J. C. Maxwell, ‘A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism,, Section 526 of 3rd Edition, 1891. See p. 173 of reprint vol.II by Dover Publications, New York, 1954). He presented four alternative laws of electrodynamics, all equally valid for the closed circuit charges in motion.

    This problem attracted my attention because there is an interesting choice available in the formulation of the likely general law. Either one has to admit inequality of action and reaction in the linear sense or one has to accept it from the point of view of rotation. This, bear in mind, applies to a system which may not be complete because we ignore the presence of charge in motion in the vacuum itself. We seek a law of electrodynamics applicable solely to interaction between two charges. [I note here that the attempt by Ampere to say that action and reaction balance applies both for linear and angular momentum does not afford a simple form of law that I can regard as ‘likely’].

    Faced with this choice and guided by the null result of the Trouton-Noble experiment it seemed that the mutual electrodynamic action of two charges cannot develop a torque. This favoured the third law of electrodynamics in Maxwell’s work [provided a minus sign replaces the plus sign before the middle term in the following equation]. Maxwell’s third law, expressed in scalar vector notation rather than quarternion form, was:

    F = (qq’/r3)[(v’.r)v+(v.r)v’-(v.v’)r]

    where q, q’ are the electric charges in c.g.s emu, v, v’ are their respective velocities and r is the separation distance between the charges. F is the force acting on q’ and r, as used in the square brackets, is the vector drawn from q to q’.

    Note that, if v and v’ are parallel and if that plus sign is replaced by a minus sign, the equation becomes:

    F = -(qv)(q’v’)/r2

    which compares with Newton’s Law of Gravitation:

    F = -G(mm’)/r2

    where G is constant and the interacting masses are m, m’.

    [Note here that the law with the plus sign ensures that the interaction of the two charges cannot produce an out-of-balance linear force but normally will produce an out-of- balance force couple tending to turn the orientation of the charge pair in space. In contrast the law with the minus sign precludes such turning action but allows linear force imbalance. There is no way in which the far more complicated law of Ampere can reduce to a form compatible with gravity given that the charge velocities can be in any direction relative to the charge separation vector.]

    Now, independently of such a choice based on hypothesis, there is theoretical justification for deducing the law empirically. This comes from an analysis of the magnetic field energy deployment and its change when two charges separate.

    The law [with the minus sign replacing the plus sign] has two very interesting consequences. When applied to charges of like polarity moving with the same velocity we obtain an inverse square law of attraction exactly of the form needed to correlate with Newton’s Law of Gravitation. This gives basis for unifying field theory. Secondly, there is the curious problem of the linear imbalance of action and reaction, which arises for generally-directed charge motion or, as analysis has shown [1969a], for parallel motion if the interacting charges have different mass.

    Aspden’s Law of Electrodynamics is:

    F = (qq’/r3)[(v’.r)v-(m’/m)(v.r)v’-(v.v’)r]

    Experimentally there should be interesting anomalies in the forces exerted by electrons on ions in arc discharges and plasma. This is now appearing in the literature, though the anomalous behaviour of cold-cathode discharges (those involving ions rather than electrons) has been of record for many years. More recently it has been recognized that there is a high anomalous acceleration of ions by electrons in plasma [1977a]. The new law which I have been urging is the Maxwell’s third law of electrodynamics [as modified by that minus sign coefficient replacing the plus sign of the (v.r)v’ term] but adapted to cover interactions between charges of different mass. It is a law which is different from that derived using relativity as a faith and the refusal to consider criticism of relativistic doctrine has hindered the rational development of electromagnetic theory. I am quoting here from a paper dated 1977 circulated by Professor McCausland of the University of Toronto in which he makes reference to some words by Dr. Essen (L. Essen, ‘Einstein’, The Economist, March 19, 1977, p.4.) [Note that Dr. Essen was a Fellow of the Royal Society and was famous for his work at the National Physical Laboratory in U.K. concerning time measurement and his discovery of the caesium atomic clock.]:

    “There is some evidence that a new theoretical approach could break the stalemate in the development of nuclear fusion, which appears to offer the only source of energy that could prolong our civilization far into the future.“

    Such is the possible importance of resolving the problems which are addressed here.

    CHARGE INDUCTION BY VACUUM SPIN

    Reverting now to the problem of anomalous angular momentum effects, we consider the hypothesis of vacuum spin. If rotation of the vacuum medium induces an electric charge displacement we can show from dimensional analysis that the induced charge density will be proportional to the speed of rotation and proportional to the square root of a mass density. In short, the vacuum medium has a mass property which must be manifested when spinning. Now it is known from Maxwell’s work that charge is displaced linearly in the vacuum. It is the basis of his displacement currents. Therefore we must be open to the possibility that charge can be displaced in a radial sense. Put another way, we can expect that a charge density within a volume of matter might induce a reaction by the vacuum medium to cancel the matter charge. Such a reaction should involve vacuum spin.

    The mass, time and length (M,T,L) dimensional relationships were also shown in that 1977 paper in the box enclosing that figure, the box illustration being as used by the author as an overhead viewer transparency when delivering the lecture.]

    Charge density σ: M1/2L-3/2T-1k1/2
    Angular momentum ω: T-1
    Mass density d: ML-3
    (σ2/ω2d): k
    k is dielectric constant, a known property of the vacuum.
    Hence if σ is proportional to ω the vacuum must have a mass density d.

    [Note that the author was here using cgs units in which the vacuum has a magnetic permeability and a dielectric constant both set at unity, but there is purpose in using k for generality in this analysis. The vacuum medium is not deemed to be capable of reacting to a magnetic field in any way that would endow it with a magnetic permeability other than unity in this system of cgs units. It can, however, break up into a kind of fluid crystal form when matter is present and then exhibit a dielectric constant. More will be said about that in these Web pages by particular reference to the topic discussed in reference [1976a] where the Fresnel coefficient is applied to the vacuum medium to explain the basis of the null finding in the Michelson-Morley experiment.]

    One way of developing a charge distribution is by a strong electric discharge. The fast moving electrons will be drawn together by the ‘pinch effect’, so generating a radial electric field centred on the axis of the discharge. If the vacuum medium reacts to develop a compensating effect then it will absorb the field energy to sustain a vacuum spin about the discharge axis. This spin may be shared by the air surrounding the discharge, with the result that the tornado angular momentum becomes explicable.

    Another way of developing a charge distribution is by the gravitational condensation of stellar substance. Two heavy masses will have greater mutual acceleration under gravity than two lighter masses. In the cosmic dust from which astronomical bodies form there will probably be quite a few free electrons. Thus the heavier matter will aggregate to form a core temporarily leaving an electron population behind in surrounding space. The core need not stabilize initially by a balance of nuclear energy pressure and gravitational force. It can stabilize by a balance of gravitation and the mutual electric repulsion of the positive charge associated with the core. Therefore we know that when an astronomical body is first created it has an electric charge given by G1/2 times its mass, where G is the constant of gravitation.

    As explained already, this charge will then develop a vacuum spin and we can formulate a mathematical relationship between this speed of rotation and the mass density of the body, involving only the value of G and the density parameter d of the vacuum.

    [The following six illustrations, which should be self-explanatory, appeared opposite page 8 in the 1977 paper.]

    THE SOLAR SYSTEM

    By supposing that the vacuum spin will be coupled, albeit rather loosely, with the body, the speed of rotation of both will become the same. Thus we have basis for explaining how the newly-created Sun or Earth was caused to rotate. Furthermore, the production of satellites becomes explicable. Once the electron population reaches the surface of the parent body it will begin the process by which the vacuum medium returns its energy to matter. The vacuum spin will slow down as the atmosphere of negative charge accumulates this energy. The electrical attraction between the positive core and this negative orbiting atmosphere will balance the centrifugal force. This will determine how much mass from the parent body will be swept into the satellite system. Then, as the two charges become neutralized by mutual discharge or extraneous particle radiation the satellite will move away from its parent to take up its eventual orbit. Meanwhile much of the energy released will have gone into electrical discharges and possibly have been dissipated. Some energy may even, as I suggested at the outset, have found its way into an ordered state of translational motion of the Sun in its galactic path through space.

    Suffice it to say at this stage that the creation of the solar system need present no insuperable mystery of the kind which has troubled us to date. The data verify the hypotheses involved, because we can deduce the same numerical vacuum density property from three separate creation processes. These are the asteroid creation, the Sun creation and the Earth creation. Furthermore, when this then-known parameter of the vacuum is applied to the formulae for satellite creation, we deduce the satellite/parent mass ratio in reasonable accord with that of the solar system and the Earth/Moon system.

    [The evidence as shown in a box illustration used in the 1977 lecture is reproduced below under four headings, three being the creation processes just mentioned.]

    VACUUM MEDIUM ANALYSIS:

    σ/ω = (Ad)1/2

    by vacuum spin induction

    σ = (G)1/2dm

    by core stabilization, where dm is the mean mass density of the body of matter associated with that spin. Therefore:

    Ad = G(d/ω)2

    SUN CREATION:
    If the Sun had 100% of the angular momentum of the present solar system when created it would have (2/5)MsR2ω or (3.2)x1050 cgs units of angular momentum, where its mass is denoted Ms and its radius R is (6.96)x1010 cm. Ms is (1.989)x1033 gm. Hence ω is (8.3)x10-5 rad/s. For the Sun dm is 1.4 gm.cc and, as G is (6.67)x10-8, we obtain from the preceding equation:

    Ad = 19 gm/cc

    EARTH CREATION:
    For the Earth-Moon system, according to R.A. Lyttleton (Science Journal, v. 5, p. 53, May 1969), the Earth rotated once every 5.5 hours before the Moon was ejected. dm for Earth is 5.5 gm/cc. Therefore, again from the preceding equation:

    Ad = 20 gm/cc

    ASTEROID CREATION:
    For the Asteroids the data of G. P. Kuiper (Celestial Mechanics, v. 9, p. 321, May 1974) show that the mean speed of rotation is once in 6 to 7 hours. If we estimate the value of dm as 4 to 5 gm/cc, say 4.5 gm/cc, this gives:

    Ad = 19 gm/cc

    To continue this lecture press:

    *
  • BINARY VISION?

    LECTURE NO. 5

    BINARY VISION?

    An Insight into Space, Energy and Creation

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1977, 1997

    INTRODUCTION

    These Lectures are intended to show how easy it is to build an understanding of the primary factors involved in the creation of the universe and which govern the way in which Nature regulates the activity which underlies what we describe as ‘physics’. By that I mean that I intend to show how easy it is to explain, for example, not only the cause of gravitation, but also how the Constant of Gravitation G is determined in terms of the charge to mass ratio of the electron. If one really can explain gravitation and go on from there to show why and how protons are created with their mass of some 1836.152 times that of the electron, then we are well on the way to success in the ultimate search for complete understanding of the science which governs our existence.

    Sadly, I have had in my previous Lectures to pay some attention to the role played by Albert Einstein, because his philosophical picture of space has made everything obscure and has blocked the way forward in progressing to the ultimate truths. I have much more to say on that subject in the Lectures that will follow. Here in this Lecture, however, I will introduce my account of things by presuming that Einstein has never existed.

    The question is: “Where to begin?” and my answer to that is to presume that those of you that are interested in what I have to say are the kind of people who might read the American Journal of Physics or the equivalent periodical published by the U.K. Institute of Physics, namely Physics Education. Physics teachers, their students, including those involved in research, and graduates in physics are the kind of people who will be able to understand the subject I now address.

    So, I shall begin by referring first to something you can read on page 938 of the No. 10 issue (Volume 53) of American Journal of Physics, dated October 1985. In the upper portion of that page there is a Letter to the Editor entitled: ‘THE PROTON ENIGMA’ and, nested alongside that, there is another Letter to the Editor entitled: ‘THE SOLAR SYSTEM AND A BINARY STAR: IS THERE A CONNECTION?’. So here we have protons mentioned alongside stars, a spectrum of physics ranging from the basic building blocks which form our universe to the stars into which those building blocks cluster. We need to explain how those protons are created and why they group together to form those clusters and I am going to develop what I say here from what was written in those two short communications to the Dr. J. S. Rigden, the then-editor of the American Journal of Physics.

    Now, concerning my method of approach and the need to interest you, the reader. The question you face is whether you want your physics to be expressed in symbols, equations and formulae or whether you want physics to provide the checks and balances that come essentially from getting the numbers right. By that I mean that you may be the type of person who enjoys the elegance and symmetry of a mathematical formulation, even though it gives only rough answers, numerically speaking, or you may be the type of person who expects the numerical answers to come out right and expect precise accord with observation before you can believe anything expressed by fancy mathematics.

    You see, here I have suffered from experience in that I have always regarded the constants of physics as Nature’s challenge to us as an invitation to decode or decipher what is hidden behind those numbers. Like most people interested in science, I have enough imagination to invent a variety of explanations for certain unexplained phenomena which interest me. However, ideas and inventions are not sufficient in themselves to solve the basic problems of physics. One can so easily go astray. What one needs is the simple truth and I emphasize here the word ‘simple’! You can be sure that Nature builds on foundations that are firm in their structure, just as the fundamental form of solid matter comprises and orderly arrangement of atoms in a crystal structure. That is why what we measure as physical constants in our physics laboratories in USA are the same as those in Europe or elsewhere around the world. The factor which decides whether something is a constant is simply whether the numbers come out the same at those different laboratory locations. The number is important!

    So, about my experience, I found that when I offered my ideas on the fundamental issues of physics, as hypotheses developed to show interesting connections and relationships, with some formulations in support, they were rejected as ‘mere speculation’. If I stressed their success in giving the right numerical values for the constants of physics that hitherto lacked a physical basis of derivation, I was told that I was merely ‘playing with numbers’. As if I would be stupid enough to sit patiently pressing keys on a pocket calculator, just hoping to see some numerical coincidence appear that looked like it had the same value as one of the dimensionless physical constants!

    In fact, my main breakthroughs on the theory I am writing about in these Web pages, were made before I ever owned a pocket calculator or any form of computer other than a simple engineer’s slide rule. Yes, my first calculations leading to the value of hc/2(pi)e2, which is slightly greater than 137 were made using a slide rule in the mid-1950 period and it was not until 1960 that they appeared in published form in a printed publication, necessarily, in those days, hand-set in printer’s type. So, please believe me when I say that the subject I am now addressing is simple in its component form and is something that you, the reader, can check, step-by-step, if I guide you through the process. You will find that you can calculate the value of G in terms of e/me, the charge to mass ratio of the electron, but that will be a few Lectures ahead.

    First, we need to put some method into our approach. At this point, I ask you to ignore what you may have heard about neutron stars and Black Holes. My reason is very simple. It is that physicists do not know enough about neutrons here on Earth to make sense of what they see, so how can they begin to convince us that there are neutron stars? Also, not heeding my findings, they do not know how to calculate G, which means that they do not understand the physical cause of gravitation. That further means that they do not know the limits and constraints which govern the action of gravity. Suppose I were to explain why an apple falls to the ground by saying that I do work in lifting it to a height of 2 metres before allowing it to fall, adding that gravity is like the action of a stretched spring linking apple and Earth, and that was all you knew about gravity by way of theory and experiment. You would be justified then in saying that gravity is something that has a range of action of two metres and it applies to objects having a mass approximating that of the apple. To apply the same theory to more massive objects separated by very large distances you surely would need to know something about that spring and to wonder whether God did the work of stretching it in the first place to separate those objects. You see, something or somebody has to wind up the spring that runs a mechanical clock and there has to be something in space that constitutes the universal ‘time machine’!

    Ah, but you now say that Isaac Newton convinced us that the action of gravity involves that constant G and an inverse square law of action which applies to interaction between Sun and planet, Moon and Earth and even to that apple and body Earth. True, but now go from there with your neutron in mind and ask how the force of gravity can override the electrostatic forces of repulsion between electric charges seated in protons, for example. If you say that the proton charge is always neutralized by the presence of an electron, as in an atom, so that there need be no electrical restraint on gravitational compaction, then you have imposed your own limit on the effect of gravity. It can never crush atoms together so as to squeeze them into less space than is needed for their atomic electron shell form.

    To go further than that and argue that Black Holes exist, as by neutrons alone forming into stellar objects, then you have invented your image of a neutron and given it properties of your own choosing and you have also declared, in effect, that the force of gravity is not seated in actions which stem from electrodynamic effects. You have lost contact with physics as we see it from laboratory measurement and wandered off into no-man’s land, where you go unarmed and unequipped to deal with the problems you then can only imagine.

    A sensible person waits in his Earth laboratory environment until the riddle of G is solved and then begins to think about the consequences of that solution. So, reverting to our American Journal of Physics reference, we will now build from there, following the two separate tracks defined by each of those Letters to the Editor and beginning with the one concerning the solar system. It was authored by Jerry Webb of the University of Arkansas at Monticello in Arizona.

    THE SOLAR SYSTEM

    Webb’s brief Letter to the Editor reads:

    “Some time ago I noticed a very interesting feature of the solar system that evidently has not been commented upon before. If it has I have been unable to find any reference to it. If one calculates the total energy and the total angular momentum of the planets, the numbers turn out to be the same as those of a single planet having a mass essentially the same as the total mass of all the planets, and orbiting the Sun in an orbit which is near to the present day center of mass of all the planets. The possibility that the solar system was once a binary star (or is in the process of becoming one) needs to be examined more closely.“

    You will see here that Webb is influenced by that numerical circumstance into speculating that the planets formed by the break-up of a small star orbiting around our Sun. Now, long before Webb wrote this, I had taken some interest in a different aspect of this same problem. The idea of a binary star was not in my mind, because the total mass of the planets is so small compared with the mass of the Sun that a binary system was not, as I saw it, a logical implication. My approach had been to say that the Earth must have formed and then shed the Moon to carry away most of its angular momentum and, by analogy, the Sun first formed and shed the planetary matter from which the Earth emerged. I did wonder if the sequence of events involved shedding the planetary matter in one go, as it were, or whether it was shed step-by-step, each step involving two planets, dynamically disposed on opposite sides of the Sun at the time they initially formed.

    Now although cosmologists spend most of their efforts and their funded resources on theorizing about what there may be out there in space well removed from our solar system, there is a great deal to be learned still, and at very little cost, from deliberating on the kind of question put by Jerry Webb. However, we must be guided as much by those numbers and what they imply as we are by notions about the underlying processes needed to account for those numbers and the way things work out. Here there are two kinds of numbers, those which apply specifically to one system, such as our solar system, and those which apply universally, such as the constant of gravitation G, Planck’s constant h and the proton/electron mass ratio M/me. The values of those numbers do tell us something!

    For example, using the measured values of G and M and me, as well as the magnitude of the electric charge e of the electron and the proton, we can work out that the gravitational force of attraction between those two particles which form the hydrogen atom is very much less than the force of electrical attraction between them. Indeed, that electrical force is some 23×1038 times greater than the gravitational force. If we consider instead two well-spaced hydrogen atoms then the electric force between them is zero because the positive proton charge and negative electron charge cancel to leave us with a neutral entity. So here the force gravity is infinitely greater than the electrical force. If, then, gravitation has to be explained in terms of the electrical properties of matter, we need to consider the possible effects of charge motion, meaning electrodynamic forces of the kind we associate with electromagnetism.

    However, here we encounter problems that are not numerical in significance, but are more related to the direction of the forces set up by moving charges, because there is the problem that the standard interpretation of the electrodynamic force between two charges in motion does not give a force acting directly along a line linking the two charges.

    On this account the problem of gravitation might seem to be quite formidable, but yet we can solve the riddle involved and know we are right, because the value of G emerges with the correct value and so provides the needed confirmation.

    Explaining the creation of the solar system is not the best place to start in this quest to solve the riddle of gravitation, but it has some appeal and can engender interest and give the reader the initial confidence needed to keep with me as I work my way through that challenging task.

    I will return to discuss the other Letter to the Editor in American Journal of Physics, the one alongside that by Jerry Webb, after presenting what I will be saying below under the heading: ‘Space, Energy and Creation’. That other Letter was entitled ‘THE PROTON ENIGMA’ and it opens what I will have to say in this Lecture concerning the proton and the neutron, which are recognized as the primary actors having the main gravitational role in our universe.

    Concerning the solar system, the following presentation of data is identical in form to what was presented on the page facing page 2 in a Lecture paper ‘Space, Energy and Creation’ that was published 20 years ago in 1977:

    THE SOLAR SYSTEM

    		
    OBJECT		MASS	ORBIT	 REVS.	ANGULAR MOMENTUM
    			RADIUS	 /YR.	IN EARTH UNITS
    SUN	    332,800.00	  --	   --	  20 (approx.)
    MERCURY	 	0.05	0.387	  0.24	  0.03
    VENUS		0.82	0.723	  0.62	  0.69
    EARTH		1.00	1.00	  1.00	  1.00
    MARS		0.11	1.52	  1.88	  0.135
    JUPITER		317.8	5.20	 11.86	724.6
    SATURN		95.2 	9.54	 29.46	294.1
    URANUS	      	14.5	19.18	 84.01	 63.5
    NEPTUNE       	17.2	30.07	165   	 94.3
    PLUTO          	0.11 	39.44 	248  	  0.69
    					______________
    					1200 (approx.) 	  	   	
    

    Note that in the above tabulation 1 Earth unit of angular momentum in the c.g.s. system of units (gm.cm2/sec) is given by combining the relevant astronomical components such as Earth distance from the Sun and Earth mass:

    2π(1.496×1013)2(5.977×1027)

    divided by:

    (365)(24)(3600)

    Therefore the angular momentum of the whole solar system, as 1200 Earth units, is (3.2)x1050 in c.g.s units.

    Now the significance of all this can be understood if one now takes note that Jupiter spins about its axis in less than 10 hours and that Saturn spins in just over 10 hours, as does Uranus, whereas Neptune has a spin at nearly 16 hours. The Sun spins once in 25 days. Then observe that 1200 divided by 20 is 60 and so, if all the planetary angular momentum were to be put back into the Sun, then the primordial spin rate of the Sun would be just about the same as we see for Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus!

    Here is a curious fact. Does it not tell you that when large astronomical objects first form, as by coalescing from whatever form matter takes at that stage of Creation, there is for some reason a process that likes that spin rate of the order of 10 or so hours per revolution?

    I add here the point that those 20 Earth units of angular momentum assigned to the Sun were estimated assuming that much of the solar mass is concentrated towards its centre and so a figure was used of about half of the value applicable if the Sun’s mass density were to be uniform throughout. The figure adopted was only intended to show the scale of angular momentum deployment as between Sun and its satellite system.

    Now one may next ask about the Earth and Moon system. Yes, here too we see that the primordial form of body Earth, before it shed the Moon would spin far faster than it does today, even faster than that 10 or so hour rate implies. However, these are only early clues to help us on our way and, for my part, my contribution is summarized in just a few pages in chapter 8 of my 1980 book: ‘Physics Unified’. If you have a copy of that book then read that section. If not, then I invite you to read on here in the continuation of this Web Lecture as I reproduce the text of my 1977 lecture paper on ‘Space, Energy and Creation’.


    To continue this lecture press:

    *
  • LECTURE NO. 4

    LECTURE NO. 4

    THE SCHUSTER-WILSON HYPOTHESIS

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    Having completed three years of experimental research on the loss anomalies in
    ferromagnetic materials, I left Cambridge in June 1953 to write my thesis and earn my living
    in the Patent Department of a corporate organization. My spare time hobby for the next six
    years was to delve into the scientific mystery which underlies electromagnetic phenomena
    and solve one particular problem that had troubled me as a Ph.D. research student. Simply
    stated, it was the question of why a steady magnetic field can penetrate a lump of copper
    without being virtually completely suppressed by the diamagnetic reaction set up by the
    numerous free conduction electrons in that copper.

    The solution to that problem providing the first stepping stone in a quest which was
    later to lead me to a deep understanding of the nature of gravitation and its unifying link with
    electromagnetism. There was enormous spin-off from my early endeavours, too much for me
    to be able to express in a style compliant with the prevailing methods then being used in
    physics. These were intolerant of the idea of an aether and subservient to the Einstein
    philosophy, whilst the quantitative successes of early quantum-electrodynamics were flagged
    before me as rival territory onto which I must not intrude.

    I had my living to earn and my patent professional qualifying examinations to pass
    and so that self-imposed extra-curricular research was really a labour I would have soon
    abandoned, were it not for the incredibly exciting discoveries that were emerging.
    My scientific papers offered for publication were no longer authored from an
    academic address and they were systematically rejected. So, when, in September 1959, IBM
    offered me the position of Patent Manager heading their U.K. Patent Department, I decided
    to wrap up my hobby interest and publish myself a printed 48 page monograph. It was
    completed on 22nd November 1959, before I took up my new position with IBM and promptly
    published under the title: ‘The Theory of Gravitation’.

    I shall in these lecture notes refer again to this first of my publications on my aether
    theory, but for the moment I will just mention that its chapter 5 was entitled ‘The
    Geomagnetic Field’
    . I had been able to calculate the geomagnetic moment in terms of
    aether spin with the Earth and the result was in full quantitative agreement. I deduced on
    page 32 that aether spin results in the induction of electric charge density of 4.781 esu per cc
    per rad/sec of spin rate, subject to a reducing factor cosA, where A is the angle between the
    spin axis of that aether spin and a preferred axial direction in space.
    The preferred direction, incidentally, lies parallel with the axes associated with the
    quantum spins of the aether particles at those lattice sites already mentioned.

    Taking the angle A as being approximately 23.5 degrees for body Earth this told me,
    as can be seen from page 32 of that 1959 monograph, that the Earth’s geomagnetic moment
    should be (0.000319)(4/15)πwR5/c, where w is the Earth’s angular velocity, R
    is the radius of the Earth’s aether and c is the speed of light, the conversion factor translating
    electrostatic units of charge into electromagnetic units of charge.

    The Earth’s measured geomagnetic moment was 8.06×1025 emu so I
    was able to estimate the mean height of the spherical boundary of the Earth’s aether as
    being 140 miles above the Earth’s surface.

    On page 33 I then addressed the question: “Will the above explanation account for
    the dipole character of the geomagnetic field?” This is an important issue confronting any
    would-be theorist who tries to understand the Earth’s magnetism. The shape of the Earth’s
    magnetic field is somewhat similar to that applying if it were all due to a magnet placed at the
    Earth’s centre, it resembling the field of a magnetic dipole. I then concluded that Chapter 5
    by two paragraphs using the following words:

    “It is found that the actual magnitude of the effective particle displacement in the
    Earth’s aether matrix caused by the Earth’s rotation is very much less than the interparticle
    spacing. On this basis it is clear that the charge effect caused by the rotation may merely
    amount to the displacement of charge to the aether boundary. When this is interpreted in the
    terms of magnetic moment it is found that the magnetic moment of the boundary charge is
    exactly twice that of the distributed charge and acts in opposition. The result is a net
    magnetic moment equal in magnitude to that already estimated, but the magnetic field
    distribution becomes more nearly that of a dipole.”

    “Although not related to gravitation the explanation of geomagnetism provided by
    this theory lends extremely strong support to the theory upon which the understanding of
    gravitation is founded, and its inclusion in this work is considered pertinent. This chapter will
    also have proved of interest to those familiar with the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis.”

    Now at this point I emphasize again that there is a difference between the theoretical
    formulation for the magnetic moment of a planet, such as Earth, and that applicable to a star.
    The above formula for induced charge density in body Earth was a function of w, the angular
    speed of Earth rotation. In contrast, the applicable formula for a star is governed by the
    mass density, 1.41 gm/cc and the connection with the constant of gravitation G.
    In my earlier writings on this subject I was more concerned with the role played by
    aether spin charge induction than the resolution of the charge density differences between
    the non-ionized body and the ionized body. Therefore the reader may well see that I could, in
    retrospect, have given a much more comprehensive account if I were now to rewrite the text
    which appeared in my 1966 second edition of ‘The Theory of Gravitation’.

    I had been with IBM for six years when I finally found time to work again at my hobby
    interest, having been promoted in the meantime, in 1963, to a position where I was then in
    charge of IBM’s Patent Departments throughout Europe. So, I wrote an enlarged 132 page
    version of my earlier monograph and added the discovery I had by then made that gave the
    mu-meson or muon a role in my aether theory. The mu-meson is a heavy version of an
    electron and I had come to look at an even heavier version which played an essential role in
    determining G, the constant of gravitation.

    The graviton was found, theoretically, to have a mass-energy of 2587 Gev, nearly
    5063 times the mass of the electron. Should the reader wonder how this relates to G, then
    the formula, taken from page 80 of my 1966 book, is:

    G1/2=(4)(108)-3(5063)-4π–
    2
    (e/m),

    where (e/m) is the electron’s charge to mass ratio, then measured as being 5.27299 esu/gm.
    From this G has the theoretical value of 6.67×10-8 cgs units.

    That theoretical derivation of G based on a deep understanding of the
    electrodynamic interactions involved is fully in accordance with the measured value and it is
    stressed that the 5063 quantity, which is the graviton mass measured in units of electron mass, i.e. 2.587 GeV, is itself theoretically derived from first principle analysis.
    It was this achievement that motivated me to entitle my book ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, but
    I wish here to proceed with my discussion of the magnetism of astronomical bodies.

    Addressing the subject of geomagnetism I showed how the formula for the Earth’s
    magnetic moment MM was derived by theory common to that used to deduce the value of G.
    The formula without the cosA term is presented on page 93 of the book as equation (6.12)
    [referred to below] and is:

    MM=16π(er)R5w2/15d3c2

    where er is the Bohr magneton, 9.26×10-21 esu-cm, R is the Earth’s
    aether radius in cm, w is the Earth’s angular spin velocity, 7.26×10-5 rad/s, d is
    the spacing between aether particle lattice sites in the cubic structure, 6.37×10–
    11
    cm and c is the speed of light, 3×1010 cm/s. The radius of the Earth
    is 6.37×108 cm but the aether boundary will no doubt be somewhere in the
    ionosphere and I noted that if R were 6.45×108 cm, this would give an estimate
    of geomagnetic moment of 7.9×1025 in the cgs system of units, compared with
    the measured value of 8.06×1025. If R were greater and located in the upper
    ionosphere then that would give a greater value but one downwardly adjusted by the cosA
    factor. There could be no question that the theory offered an excellent quantitative account
    for the geomagnetic moment.

    However, the modern physicists seem to be unimpressed by theory which is based
    on an aether, whatever the numbers mean in comparison with the facts of observation. They
    would rather rely on a vague theory which gives no numerical check, because they cannot
    abide any thought that the aether may play a role in determining the values of the
    fundamental physical constants.
    So, I can but extend this review by reproducing the discussion section between
    pages 94 and page 109 of my 1966 book in the hope that the modern physicist will see that
    there has been no progress in understanding the source of geomagnetism and stellar
    magnetism during the past 31 years and come to see in retrospect that my 1966 book gave a
    valid basis for such understanding.

    DISCUSSION REPRODUCED FROM THE 1966 TEXT

    The following text, apart from notes in [..] is all directly quoted from the author’s 1966 book.

    “It is important at this stage to pause to discuss this account of the geomagnetic
    field. There is scope for much argument about the manifestation of the aether phenomenon
    in the form of terrestrial magnetism and we must therefore deal with the main arguments
    even though we digress from the main objective.
    The topic will be introduced by a brief historical account of the Schuster-Wilson
    Hypothesis.

    The phenomena of terrestrial magnetism and gravitation present challenges of long
    standing to the theoretical physicist. Effects governed by both phenomena have been
    understood for centuries but the true nature of the phenomena has gone unexplained, even
    though it is believed that they should be related to something more fundamental. Today,
    while on the one hand we have the hydrodynamic theory of geomagnetism and on the other
    we have a so-called gravitational theory in the form of General Relativity, neither theory is
    able to bridge the gap and make connection with fundamentals common to both and neither
    theory is wholly satisfactory in accounting for the prime phenomenon.

    It is not, therefore, surprising that some excitement was aroused by the Schuster-
    Wilson Hypothesis which purported to relate magnetism and gravitation and it is well to
    introduce the problem under study, that of accounting for geomagnetism in terms related to
    mass or momentum, by a review of that hypothesis.

    Schuster [A. Schuster, Proc. Phys. Soc., v. 24, pp. 121-137; 1912] and Wilson [H.A.
    Wilson, Proc. Roy. Soc. A., v. 104, pp. 451-455; 1923] have shown that the magnetic
    moments and angular momenta of the sun and Earth are approximately related by a
    common ratio. This has led to the hypothesis that a fundamental property exists which
    causes any rotating body to have a magnetic moment. A particularly significant result
    appears when the quantitative aspects of this hypothesis are considered. It was shown by
    Wilson that the right order of magnitude for the magnetic fields of the Earth and the Sun is
    obtained is obtained if it is assumed that a moving mass, measured in gravitational units, has
    the same effect as a moving negative charge, measured in electrostatic units. Blackett
    [P.M.S. Blackett, Nature, v. 159, pp. 658-666; 1947] has expressed the same result in the
    following terms:

    (magnetic moment)/(angular momentum)=G1/2β/c

    where β is a constant of the order of unity, c is the velocity of light in vacuo and G is the
    Constant of Gravitation.

    This possibly coincidental result suggests a link between geomagnetism and
    gravitation. Unfortunately, however, the impact of the hypothesis was mitigated by a negative
    result of a laboratory experiment carried out by Wilson. from magnetic tests on a swinging
    iron bar, he was able to show that the magnetic field to be expected on the basis of the
    hypothesis did not in fact exist. The hypothesis therefore stood refuted.

    Interest revived when Babcock [H.W. Babcock, Publ. Astr. Soc. Pacif., v. 59, pp.
    112-124; 1947] succeeded in measuring the magnetic field of the star 78 Virginis. It now
    became possible to apply the hypothesis to three bodies instead of two. The hypothesis was
    verified as being fully applicable to them all, the range of angular momenta being 10:1. The
    hypothesis, now called the Schuster-Wilson Hypothesis, became the subject of more detailed
    examination. Various anomalies were discovered. For example, Babcock [H.D. Babcock,
    publ. Astr. Soc. Pacif., v. 60, pp. 244-245; 1948], Thiessen [G. Thiessen, observatory, v. 69,
    p. 228; 1949] and Von Kluber [H. Von Kluber, Mon. Not. Roy. Astr. Soc., v. 111, p.2; 1951]
    have found that the solar magnetic field varies in a manner which is not consistent with the
    simple conception afforded by the hypothesis. Attempts were made to test the hypothesis
    again in the laboratory. Blackett [P.M.S. Blackett, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc., v. 245A, pp. 309-
    370; 1952/3] studied the magnetic effects of dense matter rotating with the Earth. His
    experiments are conclusive in showing that no magnetic effect of the appropriate character
    and magnitude exists as a general property of matter on Earth. Furthermore, Runcorn and
    others [S.K. Runcorn et al, Phil Mag., v. 41, pp. 783-791; 1950] & [S.K. Runcorn et al, Phil.
    Trans. Roy. Soc., v. 244A, p. 113; 1951/2] measured the variation of the Earth’s magnetic
    field over a range of depths below the Earth’s surface and compared the results with those
    predicted on the basis of a distributed theory and those applicable to a core theory. In the
    core theory the Earth is assumed to have a field produced by a magnetic dipole. The
    distributed theory involves the assumption that each element of a body gives rise to a
    magnetic effect as if it had a charge proportional to its mass rotating with the Earth, as
    required by the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis. The principal distinction between the results
    predicted by the two theories is that on a core theory the horizontal component of the
    geomagnetic field should increase with increasing depth below the Earth’s surface, but on the
    distributed theory there should be a decrease. The measurements showed there to be an
    increase. The result went against the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis. This was a great pity in
    view of the seeming applicability of the hypothesis over such a wide range of
    momentum.

    Consideration shows that there is scope for reviving the substance of the hypothesis
    at least over the results of Runcorn if we argue that not all of the geomagnetic field is
    attributable to rotation of distributed charge. Gunn [R. Gunn, Phys. Rev., v. 33, pp. 614-620;
    1929] has suggested a radial limitation of the Sun’s magnetic field by ionic moments in the
    Sun’s atmosphere. Ions moving at their kinetic velocities in a magnetic field spiral about the
    lines of force to oppose the fields present. Can it not, therefore, be that some reaction effect
    in the ionosphere opposes the magnetic field produced by the distributed charge? it is a fact
    that the Sun’s field is weaker than one would expect if beta had the value of unity as implied
    above. According to Blackett’s data, the values of beta are, for the Earth 1.29, for the Sun
    0.92, and for 78 Virginis 0.95. Allowing for such reaction effects, particularly for the Sun
    and 78 Virginis, it seems that the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis could just as easily have
    required the ratio of magnetic moment to angular momentum to be 2G1/2/c, the
    factor of 2 perhaps having analogy with the gyromagnetic ratio factor. It is well known that
    the ratio of magnetic moment to angular momentum for changes in magnetism in iron is
    about twice that predicted in terms of the motion of electron charge associated with electron
    mass. Hence, if we can retain the simplicity of the Schuster-Wilson Hypothesis while
    incorporating the factor of 2, we need to accept substantial field reaction effects in the Earth
    to reduce the factor 2 to 1.29 and need even more substantial reaction in stellar bodies.

    It is, therefore, suggested that this reaction effect
    presented by Gunn may well reconcile the difficulties with the
    Runcorn experiment. The same effect could also account for the
    variable nature of the solar field and the anomalies arising from
    this.

    However, even if the Runcorn experiment can be overcome,
    there is still the negative result of Blackett’s experiment and
    that of Wilson on the swinging iron bar. This might be dealt
    with if we consider the implication of the hypothesis that there
    exists in close association with any element of matter a negative
    electric charge proportional to its mass. This is really the
    basis of the statement expressed by the above formulation of the
    hypothesis.

    Augenheister [Augenheister, Phys. Zeit., v. 26, p. 307;
    1925] has shown that this assumption gives the correct ratio for
    the magnetic fields of the Sun and the Earth, but he also
    recognized the physical difficulties of assuming the existence
    of real charges of the necessary magnitude and the consequent
    very large electrical fields which must accompany them in an
    electrically conducting material such as the Earth’s core. One
    way out of this difficulty is to argue that in an aggregation of
    matter as with the Earth the negative charges associated with
    mass are cancelled by migrating charge, but that the balance is
    made up by a repulsion of free migrating charge displaced to the
    outer boundaries of the body. For example, in order to establish
    charge balance with the negative-mass charge some electrons might
    be displaced from the atomic structure of the matter involved,
    and these electrons would spread around the Earth in the
    ionosphere. On this model, mass exhibits no charge in laboratory
    experiments and has no apparent magnetic effect detected by the
    Wilson or Blackett experiments. Furthermore, the Augenheister
    problem is overcome. Even the Runcorn experiment is no longer
    applicable because the distributed charge theory does not hold.

    This interpretation of the hypothesis puts the prime source
    of the geomagnetic field outside the Earth, in the ionosphere.
    This has been objected to by Bauer [L.A. Bauer, Terr. Magn., v.
    28, pp. 1-28; 1923] who has shown by spherical harmonic analysis
    that most of the Earth’s field is of internal origin. For
    example, Bauer ascribes as much as 94 per cent of the Earth’s
    field to internal causes. Since the Earth’s ionosphere would
    need to cancel a substantial part of the field arising from the
    distributed charge for Runcorn’s results to be reconciled with
    the Schuster-Wilson Hypothesis, this objection is of paramount
    importance. However, even here it is very important to remember
    that the most general assumption used in spherical harmonic
    analyses of the Earth’s field is that the Earth’s magnetic
    potential is composed of two portions, one due to magnetic matter
    within the Earth’s sphere and the other due to magnetic matter
    outside the Earth’s sphere. The operative words in this
    assumption are ‘magnetic matter’. In this sense a current
    encircling the Earth and seated in the ionosphere does not
    constitute magnetic matter located wholly outside the Earth’s
    surface. For example, a current around the equator at a height
    of 200 km gives rise to two elements of magnetic matter, one
    situated inside the Earth and the other outside the Earth, the
    latter being related to the former in the ratio of the areas
    2(pi)Rx200 and (pi)R2, where R is the Earth’s radius in km.

    Since r is 6,371 km, it is seen that, curiously enough, this
    gives 94 per cent of the magnetic matter ascribable to ionosphere
    currents as seated within the Earth.
    The results of spherical harmonic analysis do not preclude
    magnetic reaction seated in the ionosphere, provided this
    involves charge migration around the whole Earth. For stellar
    bodies, no harmonic analysis data are available and, therefore,
    the closed spiral-type motion of gas ions may supplement the
    reaction effect of any charge migration. The result deduced by
    Bauer is certainly of no relevance to stellar bodies.

    From such consideration, the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis
    could well survive in a modified form. We have introduced a
    charge in the ionosphere which could well be objected to for
    other reasons. Perhaps we can even regard this as compensated
    by charge which does not rotate with or at the same speed as the
    Earth. Perhaps, though, this is stretching the hypothesis too
    far.
    Nevertheless, this gives scope to understand reasons for
    substantial changes in magnetic fields in astronomical bodies
    over short periods of time, and there is now evidence that the
    magnetic poles of many stars even exchange positions in a few
    days. As Runcorn [S. K. Runcorn, The Times (London), April 26,
    1965, p. 11] stated very recently: “This is one of the most
    stimulating challenges of cosmic magnetism”.

    The Schuster-Wilson Hypothesis stands rejected today.
    Instead, the theory of hydromagnetism is applied to account or
    the geomagnetic field. An excellent account of this subject has
    been presented by Elsasser [W.M. Elsasser, American Jour. Phys.,
    v. 23, pp. 590-609; 1955] and [W.M. Elsasser, American Jour.
    Phys., v. 24, pp. 85-110; 1956]. This theory will have great
    difficulty in accounting for the reversal of the magnetic poles,
    though it can be applied to account for the Earth’s secular
    variation of magnetic field. Bullard and others [E.C. Bullard
    et al., Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc., v. 243A, pp. 67-92; 1950] have
    provided an account of he westward drift of the Earth’s magnetic
    field in terms of theory which they state to be consistent with
    other theories of the origin of the main field, provided there
    is a differential rotation within the core. This statement
    recognizes that the prime source of the geomagnetic field might
    well stem from something other than a hydromagnetic effect. The
    great concern for the reversal of the magnetic field in stars
    stimulates a consideration of other possible accounts for cosmic
    magnetism.

    The above discussion of the Schuster-Wilson hypothesis does
    stress the possibility that there might well be some link between
    gravitation and cosmic magnetism. It is therefore of some
    interest that new ideas about gravitation already presented in
    this work are found to be capable of extension to geomagnetism.
    The fact that, in developing equation (6.12) [the above
    formula for magnetic moment MM], the elemental magnetic moment
    is found proportional to X squared [X being a distance from the
    Earth’s centre] shows that the character of the geomagnetic field
    matches that of a uniformly distributed charge over the Earth’s
    volume. The distributed charge theory was found by Runcorn to
    give field gradients opposite to those observed in practice.
    Here, however, it must be remembered that, by the theory
    developed, the geomagnetic field is attributed to a radial
    displacement of charge. The charge is displaced, in effect, to
    the boundary of the rotating aether. Clearly, therefore, if the
    effect of the rotation is to generate an effective uniformly
    distributed charge within the aether, an exactly balancing charge
    of opposite polarity must be established at the boundary. The
    displaced charge is, by its nature, constrained to balance in the
    radial plane. Thus, in considering magnetic moment, it is found
    that the charge displaced to the boundary, in rotating with the
    Earth’s aether, produces exactly double the magnetic moment given
    by (6.12) in the opposite direction. Quantitatively, therefore,
    (6.12) still applies. In considering magnetic field gradients,
    however, by Runcorn’s mine experiments, the component of magnetic
    field attributed to distributed charge is oppositely directed
    with respect to the general magnetic field of the Earth. Thus,
    the result of the Runcorn Experiment actually supports the theory
    developed.

    In considering the dipole nature of the geomagnetic field
    as evidenced by the results of Runcorn’s experiments, it is to
    be noted that a double strength shell containing an opposed
    single strength distributed charge would appear to present a
    field form more like a dipole than does a single strength shell.

    The rotation of Earth has been argued to produce the
    geomagnetic field by an induction effect in an electrical aether
    medium rotating with the Earth. The result of the Blackett
    Experiment imposes upon the analysis the need to regard the
    induced charge within the Earth as compensated locally or
    alternatively the need to regard the lattice as not concentrated
    by local matter. In Blackett’s experiment the magnetic effect
    of a dense body rotating with the Earth was under investigation,
    in contrast with the Wilson experiment where the body under study
    moved in the Earth frame.
    This strengthens the concept that the origin of the
    geomagnetic field is a uniform aether medium rotating with the
    Earth frame. We have to recognize that the aether has some
    uniformity, a lattice charge density, not affected by changes in
    mass density within the Earth.

    We now come to the real problem. The distributed charge and
    the balancing boundary charge of the rotating aether have to be
    cancelled by other charge to balance the electric field effects,
    but this other charge must not cancel the magnetic field effects,
    that is, it must not rotate with the Earth. The solution to this
    problem is amazingly simple.
    As the Earth moves in its orbit, its aether lattice will
    come into collision with surrounding aether lattice. We have
    shown that one constituent of the aether has the form of fluid
    charge and the other constituent is the lattice system of
    particles of charge e of opposite polarity, the aether as a whole
    being electrically neutral. The fluid constituent cannot move
    through itself. A spherical volume of it can rotate about its
    own axis, but it cannot move laterally in the sense that an
    element of the fluid moves laterally. The sphere housing fluid
    which rotates can move laterally, however, provided the rotary
    motion is transferred from fluid left behind by the sphere to new
    fluid coming into the sphere. The particle constituent, on the
    other hand, can move through itself.

    Imagine now the well ordered particle lattice formed within
    the Earth’s aether to move laterally and collide with surrounding
    particles. This lateral movement of the whole particle lattice
    in the Earth’s aether causes a deficiency of particles behind the
    lattice and a surplus in front of it. Thus an electrical field
    is set up along the line of travel of the whole lattice system.
    this field is not strong enough to disrupt the lattice but is
    strong enough to cause some of the particles in front of the
    lattice to migrate through it to fill positions vacated in the
    fluid behind the lattice. In short, the particle lattice can move without undue disturbance through similar surrounding particle
    structure if surrounding particles in collision with it travel through it to fill vacant locations left behind. Thus, if we
    regard the Earth’s aether to behave in this way, we see that
    there is, traveling through the Earth, an abundance of free
    lattice particles which are constrained to move in opposition to
    the Earth’s motion in its orbit. The magnetic effect of these
    particles cancels exactly the magnetic effect of the matrix
    particles in their travel with the Earth in its orbit.
    Consideration shows that there is also balance of linear momentum
    in such a system. However, these free particles do not rotate
    with the Earth. They are free to a limited degree to cancel the
    electrostatic effects of the induced charge, but they do not
    share the Earth’s rotation and therefore no cancellation of the
    geomagnetic field occurs.

    This albeit rather peculiar notion of particles moving in
    formation, with other particles moving at higher speed traveling
    freely in opposed directions and between the ranks of the ordered
    particles, gives a very simple and direct account which overcomes
    the Augenheister problem introduced above.
    It introduces the requirement that the Earth must move
    laterally and not just rotate to obtain this electrostatic
    balance condition. The faster the Earth moves then the greater
    the number of free particles in it to cancel the electrostatic
    charge. Clearly, the particles are likely to fall out of harmony
    with the general system and deploy their velocity in their small
    orbits to travel at this velocity through the matrix. This
    velocity is seemingly constant for all particles. Therefore, the
    ratio of free particles to bound lattice particles in the Earth’s
    aether lattice depends upon the ratio of the Earth’s orbital
    velocity to the velocity of the particle in its small orbit.
    It is suggested that if the Earth were to stop in its orbit,
    then, apart from being drawn into the Sun by gravitation, there
    would be nothing to balance the strong electric field induced by
    its rotation and, since these fields are of the order of many
    millions volts per cm, all matter in the Earth would become
    ionized. The Earth would then lose its magnetic field.
    It is suggested that if the same argument is applied to the
    Sun there is cause, owing to the Sun’s relatively slow motion,
    for understanding why its magnetic field is less constant than
    that of the Earth.

    MAGNETIC MOMENT OF THE SUN

    The expression (6.12) for the magnetic moment can not really
    by tested for other planets until we know their magnetic moments.
    the magnetic moment is proportional to the square of the speed
    of rotation. Thus, the Moon will hardly have any significant
    magnetic field. Using (6.12) it is to be expected that the
    magnetic moment of Mars will be about 3.2×1024 emu.
    We can, however, test (6.12) by applying it to the Sun. The
    Sun rotates once every 25 days and has a radius 108 times that
    of the Earth. Hence its magnetic moment should be
    (108)5/(25)2 that of the Earth, or 1.9×1033 emu.

    Estimates of the solar magnetic moment have to take into
    account the sporadic magnetic fields produced in sunspots. Some
    early estimates may therefore be unreliable. One recent analysis
    by which the dipole moment of the sun has been estimated is that
    of Sakurai [K. Sakurai, J. Geomagn. Geoelect., v. 11, pp. 21-33;
    1959] who observed a value of 5×1032 emu.
    This is somewhat less than that predicted by this theory but
    the data is of the right order and the result adequately supports
    this theory.
    Furthermore, as has been stated, there is evidence that the
    solar magnetic field has been decreasing over the past few years.
    There is also evidence that in some stars the field reverses in
    direction very frequently, in some cases every few days.

    To account for this, let us regard the estimate of
    1.9×1033 emu to be the solar magnetic moment in the absence
    of cancelling charge of the kind developed by ionization. Then,
    considering the Sun to be in motion so as to provide the
    constrained charge carriers able to prevent total magnetic field
    cancellation owing to ionization. The magnetic field will then
    be partially cancelled, perhaps in the ratio of the abundance of
    ions to the abundance of the constrained migrating charge
    carriers. Now, this relative abundance will be a function of the
    speed of the Sun. The faster the Sun moves, the more abundance
    in constrained carriers and the stronger the magnetic field.
    Also, and of great interest to this account, the abundance
    density of the constrained carriers will be uniform throughout
    the Sun but the abundance density of free ions may be greater in
    the outer regions of the Sun than in its core. It is seen,
    therefore, that what will happen as the Sun changes from fast to
    slow speed is that when moving rapidly it will have a fairly
    normal dipole moment induced by its rotation, the constrained
    aether constituent in its inner and outer regions being more
    dense than the ions. Then, at a lower speed the abundance of
    ions in the outer regions outweighs the effect of the unbound
    lattice particle charge, thereby substantially cancelling the
    magnetic action of the outer field-generating shell of displaced
    lattice. The inner core field generation will not be affected in
    such a significant way by the lower speed. As a result the double
    strength magnetic moment of the shell is cancelled and the
    opposed single strength magnetic moment of the core remains
    unchanged. The total effect is a complete reversal of the dipole
    magnetic moment of the Sun. This has not required any change in
    rotational speed of the Sun. It merely requires that the Sun
    should fluctuate in speed in its own orbit. The reversals of its
    magnetic moment should appear in phase with the variation in
    speed.
    We predict, therefore, that the variation of the solar
    magnetic moment must depend upon the motions of Jupiter and
    Saturn.

    There is perhaps insufficient data available at present to
    check this account of the solar field reversals, though it does
    appear that over the past few years the solar field has decreased
    and indeed reversed, whilst the Sun has decreased in speed as
    Jupiter and Saturn have moved into opposition.
    The fact that some stars can reverse magnetic field in only
    a few days indicates that their orbital speed changes at this
    frequency. This is possible if a star has a satellite close to
    it. [It may belong to a binary pair, with both stars orbiting
    around one another every few days, as for DI Herculis mentioned
    in the first of these lectures on cosmological questions.]

    CONSERVED ANGULAR MOMENTUM IN THE SOLAR SYSTEM

    We have seen how the motion of an astronomical body through
    space provides a constrained aether constituent which prevents
    ionization owing to the induced charge caused by aether rotation.
    If a body such as the Sun did not move through space, then, apart
    from any other source of ionization, its rotation alone would
    induce electrical fields and cause ionization.
    Motion at varying speed through space arises from the need
    to be in balance with a satellite planet. Then ionization need
    not occur as a consequence of rotation. If it does occur its
    effects will moderate the induced magnetic field, but this
    moderating effect will be weaker, the faster the Sun moves
    through space.

    The rotation of an astronomical body is accompanied by the
    rotation of the aether it contains. For the planets the aether
    rotation momentum about the centre of the solar system is
    insignificant compared with their material orbital momentum.
    However, for the Sun the contribution of the aether angular
    momentum due to the Sun’s rotation is very substantial in
    relation to the angular momentum of the solar system.
    It has long been a difficult question to account for the
    formation of the solar system in terms of a solar explosion which
    somehow imparted substantial angular momentum to the planets but
    left the sun with a balancing angular momentum of the order of
    1% that imparted to the planets.

    This is no problem in the case of the formation of secondary
    satellite systems, where the satellites are assumed to form from
    a mother planet (see work of Alfven [H. Alfven, Astrophys. Jour.,
    v. 137, pp. 981-990; 1963]). Yet, while it is debatable whether
    the Moon, for example, came from the Earth, it is less debatable
    that the Earth came from the Sun and it is here that angular
    momentum balance presents a baffling problem.
    This theory may help in resolving this anomaly because the
    value of aether lattice density mo/d3 is of the order of 100
    times the Sun’s density, showing that the aether angular momentum
    of the solar system might well be in balance with the material
    angular momentum. [Note that mo denotes the mass of an aether
    particle and that the value of mo and d, the cubic lattice
    spacing of the particles in the aether structure, were
    theoretically determined in the earlier pages of the book from
    which this text is quoted].

    While this hypothesis will not be pursued here, it is of
    interest to mention, in passing, that in discussing the origin
    of the satellites and the planets, Alfven and Wilcox [H. Alfven
    & J. M. Wilcox, Astrophys. Jour., v. 136, pp. 1016-22; 1962] have
    proposed that this has come about from the interaction of a
    neutral gas and a plasma. In contrast, the present theory, which
    is concerned mainly with the magnetic and momentum properties of
    such bodies, regards them to consist in reality of a neutral
    material substance and an all-pervading plasma which we have
    termed the ‘aether’.

    It is appropriate to observe that the aether lattice moving
    with the Earth through aether fluid not only gives us the account
    of terrestrial magnetism presented but explains the experiment
    of Michelson-Morley by confirming the words of Campbell [N.R.
    Campbell, ‘Modern Electrical Theory’, 2nd. Ed., Cambridge
    University Press, pp. 387-388; 1913]:

    “If we speak of ‘aethers’
    and not ‘the aether’ all our experiments prove is that the
    particular aether with which we are concerned in any case is that
    which is at rest relative to the source and may be regarded as
    forming part of it. This is the simple way out of the
    difficulties raised by the Michelson-Morley Experiment. If from
    the beginning we had used a plural instead of a singular word to
    denote the (aether) system….those difficulties would never have
    appeared”.

    Thus, the Earth and the Sun may each have their own
    individual aethers as envisaged here and we need have no
    inconsistency with the observations from the Michelson-Morley
    Experiment.”

    [The above is quoted from a book I wrote in 1966, more
    than 30 years ago. About 10 years on from that time
    I was actually able to derive the quantitative basis
    for a theory explaining how the planets formed from
    the mother body, the Sun. Moreover, I then found that
    the Moon did, in fact, come from body Earth by the
    same process. Without aether theory there is no way of
    deriving this result. That theory appears in my 1980
    book ‘Physics Unified’. I hope, however, to provide a
    section later in these Web pages based on a lecture I
    was once invited to deliver to the students and staff
    of the Physics Department at the University in Cardiff
    in Wales, with diagrams to illustrate my case.]

    To go to that Cardiff lecture press:

  • APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 3

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 3

    CONCERNING PULSARS

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    I know that cosmologists will argue that Neutron Stars exist because they can think
    of no other way by which to give account of the rapid pulsation of the radiation we receive
    from some stellar objects. They believe that the radiating source is rotating at a frequency
    which can be of the order of only one revolution per second. A star the size of the Sun would
    have a peripheral surface speed exceeding the speed of light, if rotating that fast. It would
    be subject to enormous centrifugal forces which would far exceed the gravitational action
    holding it together and so it would explode long before it could reach such a fast speed of
    rotation.
    However, it is a bold leap to infer the existence of Neutron Stars based solely on the
    fast pulsation of some mystery sources.

    I suggest, therefore, that the true nature of a pulsar is still an open question. It could
    be a phenomenon involving the periodic discharge in a stellar plasma drawing on energy
    which accumulates in the capacitative system of the star. Just as a star must have an electric
    potential owing to that charge density already mentioned, so the storage of that energy
    means it has capacitance. There could then be radial oscillations at a frequency of the order
    of the speed of light divided by the radius of the star. Indeed, thinking along these lines I do
    wonder if the research reported on the Correa invention [Energy Science Report No. 8 listed
    in the Book and Report section in these Web pages] may have some bearing on this
    cosmological issue.

    To enlarge just a little on that theme, I am now going to delve into history. I will then
    ask a question and give you my answer. It will surprise you, but I defy you to find fault with
    what I say.
    First, I wish it to be understood that, unlike most scientists of this modern age, I
    believe we need to revive belief in the aether as a real medium.

    Recently, I was asked by someone who had discovered my writings if I could
    recommend a textbook on aether theory. That person, Mike Dawson by name, said he was
    already familiar with Sir Edmund Whittaker’s authoritative ‘History of the Theories of Aether
    and Electricity’
    [1951 edition, published in U.K. by Thomas Nelson and Sons. My answer to
    that enquiry drew attention to Max Born’s book ‘Einstein’s Theory of Relativity’, my copy
    being the revised edition published in 1965 by Dover Publications Inc.
    I refer here to the section in this work dealing with Faraday’s lines of force and quote
    below from pages 170-171 of volume 1.

    “According to the theory of action at a distance, the effect of the dielectric is an
    indirect one. The field in the vacuum is only an abstraction. It signifies the geometrical
    distribution of the force that is exerted on an electric test body carrying a unit charge. But the
    field in the dielectric represents a real physical change of the substance consisting of the
    molecular displacement of the two kinds of electricity.
    Faraday’s theory of contiguous action knows no such difference between the field in
    the ether and in insulating matter. Both are dielectrics. For the ether the dielectric constant
    equals 1, for other insulators it differs from 1. If the graphical picture of electric displacement
    is correct for matter, it must also hold for the ether. This idea plays a great part in the theory
    of Maxwell, which is essentially the translation of Faraday’s ideas of lines of force into the
    exact language of mathematics. Maxwell assumes that in the ether, too, the production of an
    electric or a magnetic field is accompanied by ‘displacements’ of the fluids. It is not
    necessary for this purpose to imagine the ether to have an atomic structure, yet Maxwell’s
    idea comes out most clearly if we imagine ether molecules which become dipoles just like
    material molecules in the field. The field is not, however, the cause of the polarization, but it
    is the displacement which is the essence of the state of tension that we call an electric field.
    The chains of ether molecules are the lines of force, and the charges at the surface of the
    conductors are nothing but the end charges of these chains. If there are material molecules
    present besides the ether particles, the polarization becomes strengthened and the charges
    at the ends become greater.”

    Now, with this historical background in mind, the question I now ask is how energy is
    stored in such an aether when subjected to an electric field. The statement that it is by some
    kind of tension is not sufficient. If our ultimate task is to unify the force of gravitation with
    electromagnetic theory, then we must be consistent. It seems improbable that one could
    ever explain gravitation in terms of the mechanical properties of matter. Our unification
    quest is more likely to succeed if we aim to explain everything in terms of electrical
    fundamentals. Therefore, if the aether can store electrical energy by ‘tension’, that ‘tension’
    must itself arise solely from electrical force.

    It really suffices to note that if two planar layers of uniformly distributed electric
    charge, one of positive and one of negative polarity, are spaced apart slightly in a mutually
    parallel relationship then there is a mutual attraction between those charge layers. Energy is
    stored in the intervening space owing to their mutual electric potential. Now, if those layers
    are the two plates of a parallel plate capacitor separated by a vacuum, the aether in that
    vacuum can be regarded as the seat of a multiplicity of pairs of charge layers that are pulled
    apart when the capacitor is charged. Each such layer has the same distributed charge as
    that on one of those plates. The energy density in the intervening spaces is the same,
    however numerous those pairs of charge layers.

    So, one could adopt conventional practice and merely regard the vacuum as a void
    between the two electrically-charged plates and formulate the energy accordingly, or get the
    same result by imagining that a real aether medium exists between those plates and still get
    the same energy formulation. However, the charge displacement concept, as an aether
    property, serves another purpose. Owing to its analogy with the dielectric properties of a real
    solid medium, it gives a basis for understanding electromagnetic wave propagation at a finite
    speed that is a function of the properties of that medium.

    When I first considered the physical form that the aether might have I opted for it
    being a plenum, containing no voids and comprising a uniform continuum of charge of one
    polarity in which there is a distribution of identical aether particles having the polarity
    opposite to that of the background continuum. My reason for this was simple logic. If I had
    regarded the aether as being a void containing electric discrete charges of both polarities and
    assumed that there would be no mutual annihilation of charge pairs, then I would be unable
    to justify an equilibrium state in which the charges take up sites in a lattice having the
    structure needed to characterize a solid. You see, I knew that Maxwell’s equations demand a
    solid-like structure to sustain the lateral oscillations associated with wave propagation. I also
    knew that I had to set up a model in which the aether particles could take up sites from which
    they could be displaced to become subject to a restoring force proportional to the
    displacement. I knew that the continuum model would meet that requirement and I
    suspected that I was the first to conceive an aether with an in-built asymmetry of this
    kind.

    I found that the structure of the aether would be simple cubic, meaning that those
    aether charges will be located at corner sites in a cubic array. This implies planar layers of
    charges and planar boundaries. The aether model was simple and easy to analyze in
    mathematical terms. I was well satisfied with the fruits of that analysis. Nature’s aether is
    not the least bit complicated. It has structure, but its structure is not close-packed-hexagonal
    or body-centred cubic or face-centred cubic, as were the ferromagnetic substances I knew of
    from my main subject of research.
    I pictured the aether as having the properties of a fluid crystal. Where present the
    local energy fields set up by matter affects the aether and promote its local crystallization
    nucleated on that matter.

    Reverting now to that cosmological theme, I saw a star as having a spherically-bound structured aether, capable of sustaining the propagation of waves at a finite speed
    determined by the structural properties of that aether model. I went further and studied how
    energy could be stored in that aether by displacing each of those aether particles from its
    neutral position. I saw each such particle as having a quantized orbital motion about that
    neutral position. That gave me the link I needed to relate the aether to quantum theory and
    Planck’s constant. More than this, I imagined what would happen if the system I had just
    envisaged were to spin as a whole, sharing the rotation of a star. That led me to see how
    there was electric charge displacement relative to the spin axis, resulting in a distributed core
    charge and a compensating charge at the spherical boundary of the whole system. I saw the
    coextensive matter content of the star as being ionized and so compensating the aether
    charge electrically but not compensating it magnetically or gravitationally. My reason was
    that, if the aether lattice structure is the frame of reference for electromagnetic wave
    propagation, the frame’s distortion or motion cannot set up gravitational or electromagnetic
    fields.

    For the purpose of this general introduction I can summarize the situation in the
    following way. Inside any astronomical body there is a kind of ‘ghost’ form, a crystal-like
    structure that is aetherial. It comprises electric charges set in an oppositely charged
    background continuum. This structure cannot withstand linear forces because it will yield as
    a fluid with a counterflow which compensates and nullifies its overall linear momentum. A
    spherical body of that structure can, however, rotate about an axis through the centre of the
    sphere and the aether in this mode can store angular momentum. Similarly such a spherical
    structure can exhibit some elasticity in resisting radial compression or expansion. In short
    the solid aspect of the aether within a star will serve to prevent the star from collapsing under
    gravity, even though its own distributed charge induced by rotation cancels the free proton
    charge that accompanies ionization.

    The star, as a gaseous plasma, would, if there were no aether, compact to a form in
    which its internal gravitational interactions just balance the charge interactions of the protons
    released by the ionizing contact of the hydrogen atoms. However, with the aether present
    and rotating to set up a charge displacement which neutralizes the proton charge in the star,
    the electrical repulsive forces within that stellar gas are no longer present but the
    gravitational compression is transferred to the lattice structure of the aether. This prevents
    the compaction of the star beyond the ionizing limit already determined before the aether in
    the star acquired its spin.

    The physical sequence of events by which this process can be formulated involves
    firstly the stellar material being a finely dispersed ‘dust’ comprising hydrogen in its fully
    ionized form. Then something on a grand cosmic scale occurred, such as the condensation
    of the aether to form its lattice-like structure. By analogy with the ferromagnetic state which
    requires crystal order and further cooling before magnetism appears, so eventually the
    phenomenon of gravitation appeared on the physical scene. This then caused the protons to
    accelerate rapidly to some focal point, together with the hydrogen atoms that had been
    formed by ion recombination, and the primordial stellar form then appears with its positive
    core charge. The size of this stellar object is limited by the contact of the K-electron shells of
    adjacent hydrogen atoms. There will be more ionization arrested, as already described, by
    the balance of the gravitational and electrical forces. But along with these events, that charge
    of the newly formed star will promote radial displacement in the coextensive body of aether
    and that is a recipe for that body of aether to begin to spin. Indeed, as the electric field
    cancels to shed the electric potential energy, which came from the release of gravitational
    potential, so the aether spin absorbs that energy as kinetic energy needed owing to its
    angular momentum property.

    It will be seen from this that we have a whole new scenario to explore, thanks to the
    aether being recognized as a real medium. The thought that the aether within a star can
    display elastic properties in response to radial compression and expansion means that it can
    oscillate radially. If it does that in a background of charge associated with the matter
    constituting the charge, where a distributed core charge of positive polarity exists balanced
    by a cancelling electron charge in the ionospheric boundaries of the star, then some
    fascinating possibilities emerge.

    The spherical boundary charge of the aether sphere could be subject to a rhythmic
    oscillation which penetrates sequentially outwards and inwards through the electron
    ionosphere at a frequency of the order of one cycle every second. Pulsating bursts of
    radiation must then occur. Hence we see scope for understanding the pulsar without
    assuming that it rotates at what, in stellar terms, is an inconceivably high rate. Stars rotate
    with periods measured in days, not seconds!

    The enigma of the pulsar warrants a review of the orthodox belief that is linked to the
    Neutron Star theme and the Black Hole. It may be difficult for some readers to accept the
    revival of an aetherial basis for physical reality, but this makes far more sense than
    imagining the existence of Black Holes and Neutron Stars. Note that I shall have much to
    say later on the subject of the apparently enormous concentrations of energy radiation
    detected in radio astronomical observations. What follows will prove to be so comprehensive
    that it will pay to read on rather than halting and assuming that these ideas stand in isolation.
    What has been said about the equilibrium of the core charge in a star held in position by
    gravitation can be put to the test, because its initial cancellation by charge induced by aether
    spin has some fascinating implications. When the star sheds some of its angular momentum
    and breaks up to create planets or form a binary system, the ultimate state of aether spin is
    at a much lower speed. There is then only partial cancellation of the gravitationally induced
    electric charge.

    For a star, the ionization prevails and if the star sheds, say 98% of its initial spin
    angular momentum in creating planets, as is the case for the Sun, then the resulting
    magnetic moment of the star will be 98% of the value we expect from the assumption that its
    charge density (in esu) is equal to its mass density times the square root of the constant of
    gravitation (in cgs units).

    For an astronomical body such as Earth, which no doubt formed as an ionized object
    before solidifying, the ultimate state is one where there is no residual core charge held in
    place by gravitation. The gravitational forces are then absorbed by the compaction of the
    atomic substance and its resistance to compression. In this case the only source of a
    geomagnetic field is the aether spin associated with body Earth as sustained by inertia, after
    it has shed the Moon. However, that spin condition induces charge displacement in the
    aether and the Earth’s substance responds to set up a cancelling displacement of electrons.
    The result is a geomagnetic field having a magnetic moment determined, not by G, the
    constant of gravitation, but by the properties of the aether and the rate of spin which it shares
    with body Earth.

    It is then somewhat fortuitous that the formula involving G happens to be in
    reasonable accord with what is observed for body Earth, but there is an associated
    misfortune in the history of the subject, because scientists tried to confirm the validity of the
    formula from detailed tests on body Earth, not realizing that its true validity was restricted to
    the plasma systems of the stars.

    The next Lecture in these Web pages summarizes that history. I told the story in the
    1966 edition of my book entitled ‘The Theory of Gravitation’ and, some 31 years on from that
    time, I reproduce the text unamended, except for the use of the notation (x)1/2
    so signify the square root of x, so that the square root of G is written as G1/2.
    Also the Greek symbols used are replaced by words in brackets, such as (beta) and (pi).

    To continue to the next Lecture press:

  • LECTURE NO. 3

    LECTURE NO. 3

    COSMOLOGY UNDER SCRUTINY

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    INTRODUCTION

    Much of cosmology is founded upon our understanding of
    gravitation and the interpretation of the radiation spectrum of
    the stars and the galaxies to which they belong. The physics
    applicable in our laboratories here on Earth is relied upon by
    cosmologists as they extrapolate well beyond the limits of the
    empirical data on which our knowledge of physics is really based.
    This leads to ideas such as Black Holes, the Big Bang, the
    Expanding Universe, the Neutron Star and even Worm Holes in
    Space-Time through which it is supposed astronauts may travel to
    enter into other universes and other cosmological time zones.

    Seldom do we hear the voice of dissent on these matters from
    within the closed world of the astrophysicist. There are
    unanswered questions to be sure, but funding which supports the
    search for those answers is used for ever-onward extrapolation.
    When, I wonder, will there be academic funding for someone
    who has the good sense to say “something is wrong” and is willing
    to track back to survey the faults in the path already followed?

    COSMOLOGICAL QUESTIONS

    We know that stars like the Sun are composed mainly of
    hydrogen and that they radiate heat and light because they are
    hot enough to be ionized. This means that the hydrogen is
    monatomic and that some of the atoms have shed an electron. It
    means that there are free electrons and free protons being
    jostled around at the Sun’s surface, because the hydrogen atom
    is nothing other than a proton with a satellite electron and
    ionization means their separation.
    Were it not for the effect of gravity, the deployment of
    charge in the resulting body of stellar plasma would find
    equilibrium with virtually zero electric potential appropriate
    to an electrically neutral charge distribution. However, we know
    that gravitation acts between two bodies with a force
    proportional to the product of their masses. Therefore the mutual
    gravitational acceleration between protons, which have 1836 times
    the mass of electrons, must distort this charge distribution.

    It means that the Sun must have a positive electric
    potential, just as it has a negative gravitational potential.
    Matter, when free to move under the influence of gravitational
    forces, seeks a state of lower potential, but in the stellar
    plasma that means a commensurate increase in electric potential.
    How does Nature cope with this dilemma?
    The answer can be worked out as a simple mathematical
    exercise which any high school physics student should be able to
    perform. Nature allows gravity to bring just enough hydrogen
    atoms into close ionizing encounters to free enough protons to
    account for a positive electric charge density equal to the mass
    density of the hydrogen gas multiplied by the square root of G,
    the constant of gravitation. [The detailed analysis is in
    Appendix I of my book ‘Physics Unified’ ISBN 0 85056 009 8].

    In other words, the maximum mass density of a hydrogen star
    can be little different from that calculable from compacting
    rigid spheres, each having the mass of the hydrogen atom and the
    radius of the electron’s K-shell orbit around its proton nucleus.
    Furthermore, there will be a distributed uniform positive charge
    density throughout the body of the star, neutralized by an
    enclosing ionospheric surface sphere formed by an electron gas.

    The high school physics student who has been introduced to
    Bohr’s theory of the hydrogen atom will know that the relevant
    radius is 5.29 billionths of centimetre. Standard physics data
    sources show that it takes 0.67×1024 hydrogen atoms to sum to one gram.
    From these data, that physics student, if reasonably astute is estimating how small spheres
    pack together to fill a space cube, can work out the mass density of that star.

    The cosmological question this poses is “How does that
    theoretical mass density compare with the known mean mass
    density, 1.41 gm/cc of the Sun?”
    When you work out the answer to this question you will see
    reason for asking why what has just been described is not
    mentioned in textbooks on astronomy. You may further wonder what
    governs the temperature of the Sun and you should be puzzled by
    the following questions.

    “If the Sun has a uniform mass density throughout its whole
    body, owing to the perfect balance of gravitational pressure and
    electrostatic repulsion, then its pressure is uniform throughout
    its whole body as contained within the bounding ionospherical
    electron shell. Is this statement true or false?” “If true,
    then is it not likely that the interior of the Sun has a
    temperature little different from that at its surface?” “In that
    case, how can we ever even begin to believe that the energy
    source which sustains the sun is of nuclear origin, unless we
    accept the possibility of cold fusion?” “If the statement is
    untrue then where is the flaw in the argument developed above?”
    “Ought we not to see this question discussed in textbooks on
    astrophysics?”

    Now, let us digress to mention the so-called Neutron Star.
    The neutron has no electric charge. Hypothetically, therefore,
    if one could capture enough neutrons within a confined space,
    with no other matter present, then gravity could act unrestrained
    by electric potential and the neutrons would cluster into a very
    compact form having a mass density enormously greater than the
    1.41 gm/cc of the sun.
    However, we have used that word ‘if’ and quite glibly
    presumed that the neutrons will not behave as we know they do in
    our experiments. We know from those experiments that they are
    unstable and have a mean lifetime of a few minutes, decaying to
    become a proton and shedding an electron. Question: “Would not
    that return us to the scenario of the hydrogen star already
    discussed?” “Does not that mean that a neutron star is simply a
    figment of imagination?”

    Surely, there is something wrong with astrophysics if this
    kind of question is not properly addressed in the scientific
    literature. Now, I am not an astrophysicist but I found that my
    early writings, which concerned the electrodynamic nature of
    gravitation, were judged defective because they conflicted with
    certain cosmological assumptions. I was building my account of
    gravitation on the electromagnetic principles to which I had been
    led by my experimental research in magnetism on the laboratory
    test bench.
    I found that the mere suggestion that gravitation can be
    explained without building the argument on the doctrinaire
    principles of Einstein’s theory of relativity was a sufficient
    basis for rejection. Yet the theory which emerged from my
    research even allowed the derivation of the value of the constant
    of gravitation G in terms of the electron’s charge/mass ratio.
    [You will find the formula for G on page 115 of my book ‘Physics
    Unified’
    ].

    It is really for this reason that I have, in these lectures,
    decided to attack the establishment position, rather than defend
    my own theory, though I would have been delighted if I had ever
    needed to defend what I have proposed. It has never been
    attacked. Astrophysicists and particle physicists have simply
    chosen to ignore my writings, even though I provide the bridging
    link between particle physics and cosmology by the unifying role
    played by the force of gravity.

    Before I advance too far from what I have said above I must
    mention that, as we proceed, I shall be explaining why Einstein’s
    theory of relativity, whether in its special or general form, is
    wrong. It is wrong on every count, but in Part II of my Web page
    on that subject I will direct these particular comments at the
    cosmologists who have chosen to ignore the observations of two
    astronomers of Villanova University in Pennsylvania. Edward
    Guinan and Frank Maloney proved Einstein wrong by drawing
    attention to the measured the rate of perihelion motion of the
    two stars forming the double star system DI Herculis.
    Einstein’s theory required that their anomalous rate of
    advance of perihelion should be some 196 times faster than it is
    for planet Mercury. It was found to be only one seventh of the
    predicted amount for the classical and relativistic effects
    combined! Einstein’s theory has, therefore, to be wrong!
    A small additional component was also required from
    Newtonian gravitational theory, owing to the astrophysicist’s
    assumption that the gaseous plasma constituting a star can be
    dragged by gravitational action of the other star in a binary
    pair.

    In the event, it was found that the observed rate of
    perihelion advance was so small as to rule out any prospect of
    Einstein’s theory being of any relevance, but, surprisingly, the
    plasma drag was not in evidence either. Now, what might that
    prove? Well, if you have understood what I have described above
    concerning electric and gravitational potentials in stars being
    in balance, you will understand that the action between matter
    in two stars in a binary system will conform with the same
    principle. In other words, there can be no gravitational drag
    effect adding to the perihelion advance. You see, there can be
    no gravitational ‘tide’ effects if the star has a uniform mass
    density. In that context it reacts as if it were a homogeneous
    solid.

    The Guinan and Maloney observations, as reported on p. 23
    of the August 29, 1985 issue of New Scientist, therefore serve
    the dual purpose of proving Einstein’s theory is wrong and also
    verifying my proposition that the mass density within a star is
    not concentrated into a non-uniform distribution by the force of
    gravitation.
    The importance of this to cosmological science cannot be
    overestimated. It bears upon that question of how a nuclear
    fusion reaction can be initiated to feed the star’s energy
    output. It obliges one to consider the prospect of a cold fusion
    process or to look for other explanations for the stellar energy
    source.
    It should raise questions but where are those questions
    discussed in the science literature? Why do cosmologists waste
    time theorizing about Black Holes when they do not have the
    answers to the issues I am raising here?

    ENERGY RADIATION?

    As we proceed on this cosmological theme I shall explore
    three fundamental aspects of physics which need particular
    scrutiny. These are (i) the interpretation of the spectral red
    shift as a Doppler Effect, (ii) the validity of Maxwell’s
    equations and (iii) the radiation of energy.
    These three subjects are intermeshed in a way that has
    seemingly eluded the physicists of our modern age. There is so
    much wrong with what has come to be accepted and so much that I have to say on this matter, that I can but proceed a step at a time
    in the hope that the reader will bear with me, even though it may
    seem unbelievable that there is such scope for challenging
    physics that has come to be accepted.

    To most physicists Maxwell’s equations stand supreme because
    they withstood the onslaught of the revolution introduced by
    Einstein’s theory. They are compliant to Lorentz transformation.
    Yet they lack an essential symmetry, a failing which was
    deceptive, in that it caused scientists to think about the
    so-called ‘magnetic monopole’, something that is also an illusion
    with no real foundation.

    At this preliminary stage I will not use mathematics to show
    how the equations should be revised. It suffices to keep in mind
    what we can all witness as we watch waves ripple over the surface
    of water and the fact that electromagnetic waves are really no
    different so far as the energy factor is concerned.
    In an electromagnetic wave there are two energy forms. One
    is the electric potential energy, which rises and falls as the
    wave ripples along through empty space. The other is the energy
    of lateral motion we associate with those waves, namely the
    magnetic energy, which is really the electrodynamic component
    associated with that rise and fall of electric potential energy.
    Now, in the water analogy, the wave on the surface of water
    involves the rise and fall of water, which involves corresponding
    changes in the gravitational potential of that water. This is
    equivalent to the electric potential of the electromagnetic wave.
    The motion of the water, meaning the kinetic energy associated
    with that up and down movement, is equivalent to magnetic energy
    of the electromagnetic wave.

    The obvious conclusion to draw from this is that it is
    Nature’s way to provide that the propagation of waves in a real
    medium involves the harmonious exchange of energy as between the
    static and dynamic potential states. Throw a stone into a pool
    of water and the water displaced will mean a slight rise of the
    equilibrium level of water in the pool, but it will also set up
    a propagating wave or ripple which does not transfer water in the
    propagation direction, save for an oscillation over the range of
    half a wavelength.
    The way in which Maxwell’s equations have been formulated
    implies, however, that the propagation of an electromagnetic wave
    requires, not the exchange of energy between the electric
    potential and electrodynamic states, but rather their increase
    and decrease together in time phase. This forces the energy to
    travel with the wave at its propagation velocity and leads to
    some rather bewildering problems when we consider wave
    interference. In short, Maxwell’s equations do not represent a
    natural wave situation.

    You may then say that this merely indicates that the vacuum
    as a medium which transports electromagnetic waves is not a real
    medium and that we can only base our theories on empirical
    evidence. If that evidence indicates the radiation of energy by
    a radio antenna, then the radio wave has to convey energy,
    notwithstanding what one might expect from the ripple on water
    analogy.
    However, bear with me as I pose a further question. How do
    we know that the electromagnetic waves we receive from remote
    galaxies really do transport the energy shed by the source stars
    and convey it towards us at the speed of light for thousands and,
    indeed, millions of years, without shedding any of that energy
    on route?

    Could it not be that, just as we see when we throw a bucket
    of water into a pool, the initial effect is the deployment of
    that water as it spreads from its point of entry, but that the
    onward ripple, as an up and down oscillation of water already
    there in the pool, merely spreads to remote parts of the pool as
    a natural wave? The wave zone near the source is, on this basis,
    a forced wave having the form analogous to that of Maxwell’s
    equations. May it not be that the electromagnetic wave initiated
    as a forced wave sheds its energy over an initial range and then
    travels on as a natural wave conveying a virtually negligible
    amount of the energy shed by the source?

    Maxwell’s equations need only slight revision, the mere
    inclusion of a mathematical operator j which signifies quadrature
    time phasing, and they would then comply with the natural wave
    mode as well as still satisfying the Lorentz transformations.
    However, we would then have scope for understanding how a
    star can radiate energy to set up electromagnetic waves which
    propagate over distances measured in light years, whilst the bulk
    of the energy shed to set up those waves is dispersed to become
    matter whilst still within the grasp of the star’s gravity field.
    It would thereby return to the star and sustain its mass-energy
    content. Such a possibility would surely ease the cosmologist’s
    problems of understanding how a star’s energy radiation is
    sustained.

    Of course, as ever, I expect the astrophysicist to view this
    as mere speculation and so reject what I propose, but for those
    interested in the prospect of regeneration of energy and the
    theory of radio communication I invite close scrutiny of the
    experimental research I shall be reporting in these Web pages.
    This concerns the findings of Dave Gieskieng of Arvada, Colorado
    using special antennae specially designed to transmit and receive
    natural electromagnetic waves.

    To continue this lecture press:

  • APPENDIX TO LECTURE No. 2

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE No. 2

    This is a continuation of Lecture No. 2

    It is the continued text of the 1986 paper on ‘The Mystery of Mercury’s Perihelion’.

    […..It was as if the formula for the 43 arc seconds per century
    advance was not already known from the prior work of others, which
    Einstein presumably chose not to acknowledge.]

    In this regard, it should be understood that, before Einstein
    appeared on the scene, the physics of the 19th century had offered
    explanations for the precise advance of Mercury’s perihelion. The
    speed parameter c had appeared in electrodynamic equations and
    efforts were made to formulate analogous gravitational equations.
    These led to advance of perihelion. Suppose gravitation propagates
    at a finite speed c. This means that the radial perturbations of the
    planetary orbit will be retarded in relation to the orbital period.
    In each successive orbit it will take a little longer for the planet
    to come to perihelion and this means that the orbit will advance
    progressively. The only question was that of determining the rate of
    advance numerically. Physically, the advance was inevitable within
    the accepted framework of 19th century physics.

    The 19th century analysis of this proceeded on the assumption
    that gravitation propagates at the speed of light and culminated in a
    paper by Paul Gerber published in a leading German journal in 1898
    [Zeitschrift Math. Phys., v. 43, p. 93 (1898)]. It was entitled: ‘The Space and Time Propagation of Gravitation’ and, by analysis using retarded potential theory, Gerber arrived at the identical formula for the rate of advance of Mercury’s perihelion that later was used in Einstein’s 1916 paper on general relativity, which appeared in Annalen der Physik. (Note: If Einstein did not know
    Gerber’s 1898 paper, is it not curious that he presented the formula
    for the rate of perihelion advance in an identical form, even in the
    use of the same upper and lower case forms of the same typographical
    symbols?)

    As we read Whittaker’s historical account [E.T. Whittaker, ‘A
    History of Theories of Aether and Electricity: The Classical
    Theories)’
    , Nelson, London, p. 208 (1951)], Weber’s earlier ideas on electrodynamics led Tisserand in 1872 to work out that, if
    gravitation propagated at the speed of light, the perihelion of
    Mercury would advance 14 arc seconds per century. At that time the
    estimated anomaly was 38 arc seconds per century, but by 1898
    Gerber’s analysis gave a value three times that of Tisserand, namely
    43 arc seconds, in full accord with the value adopted by Einstein in
    1916.

    It was only when Einstein’s paper appeared that a revised and
    updated version of the Gerber paper was sent to Annalen der Physik
    [P. Gerber, Ann. Phys., Lpz., v. 52, p. 415 (1917)]. It was published in January 1917. Gerber was deceased at the time his paper appeared in print and so he could not defend it against Seelinger’s attack [H. Seelinger, Ann. Phys., Lpz., v. 53, p. 31 (1917)]. It was claimed that Gerber’s analysis was flawed. However, Oppenheim [S. Oppenheim, Ann. Phys., Lpz., v. 53, p. 163 (1917)] took up the challenge, stressing that the issue of finite propagation speed of gravitation was still open as a basis for explaining the perihelion anomaly. This led Seelinger into a response holding firm to his position [Ann. Phys., Lpz., v.54, p. 38 (1917)]. Thus it was that Gerber’s work was committed to oblivion. However, it was mentioned in the 1921 review of the literature by Pauli and emerged in translated form in the 1958 book by Pauli entitled ‘Theory of Relativity’. The following text appears on p. 169:

    ‘Recently, an earlier attempt by P. Gerber has been discussed which tries to explain the perihelion advance of Mercury with the help of the finite velocity of propagation of gravitation, but which must be considered completely unsuccessful from a theoretical point of view. For while it leads admittedly to the correct formula – though on the basis of false deduction – it must be stressed that, even so, only the numerical factor was new.’

    The footnote acknowledges Gerber’s 1898 paper and states that
    the 1917 paper appearing in Annalen der Physik was a reprint of a
    paper appearing in a rather obscure journal dated 1902. It may well,
    therefore, have been submitted to Annalen der Physik after his
    decease and by a colleague (Gerber was a school teacher) seeking to
    relate what Gerber had proposed long before with the new result
    claimed by Einstein.

    Gerber had obtained the correct formula 18 years before
    Einstein, but by a ‘false’ method. So, can it also be that Einstein
    has obtained the correct formula as well, but also by the wrong
    method? In saying this it is well to remember the preface note
    attributed to Heaviside in 1893 and quoted at the front of
    Brillouin’s book (as referenced above):

    ‘To form any notion at all of the flux of gravitational energy, we must first localize the energy’.

    This was five years before Gerber published his first paper.
    The message is clear. How can one think of calculating the delay
    effects of finite propagation of gravitation unless we know the route
    travelled by the energy and the seat of the source? Gerber and his
    predecessors assumed that it would travel along a straight line from
    Sun to planet, a very direct line of transit. In fact, the energy is
    likely to be spread over the field enveloping the Sun and planet. It
    must travel along numerous lines of flux all of which will imply a
    longer route than was used by Gerber. So if he did get it wrong and
    underestimate the rate of advance, may not a correct analysis put
    things right? This has been the author’s own challenge! The
    computations have been performed and, in fact, Gerber’s original
    formula can be sustained by heeding Heaviside’s advice, supported by
    Brillouin, and really coming to grips with the calculation.

    The author’s paper was published in 1980 by the Institute of
    Physics in U.K. [H. Aspden, Jour. Phys., A: Math. Gen., v. 13, p.
    3649 (1980)]. Predictably, however, it has aroused no interest,
    because relativity remains sacrosanct; its doctrines cannot be
    supplanted. The author has also developed the same theory and its
    extensions in his book ‘Physics Unified’ published in the same year 1980.

    The perihelion of the planet Mercury has become synonymous with
    the name of Einstein, but, quoting again and finally some words of
    Heaviside which were used to open Chapter 11 of this author’s book
    ‘Modern Aether Science’:

    ‘The Einstein enthusiasts are very patronizing about the
    ‘classical electromagnetics and its ether’, which they have
    abolished. But they will come back to it by and by. Though it leaves
    gravity out in the cold, as I remarked about 1901 (I think), gravity
    may be brought in by changes in the circuital laws, of practically no
    significance save in some very minute effects of doubtful
    interpretation (so far). But you must work fairly with the Ether and
    Forces and Momentum, etc. They are realities, without Einstein’s
    distorted nothingness.’
    …………….(Unpublished notes of Heaviside, March 1920)

    Apart from the commentary on Mercury’s perihelion, much of what
    has been said above will be reminiscent of views expressed by N.
    Rudakov in the beginning of his book ‘Fiction Stranger than Truth’ [Rudakov, P.O. Box 723, Geelong, Victoria 3220, Australia (1981)]. This excellent study of the metaphysical labyrinth of relativity was the first revelation to this author that his (my) non-mathematical book ‘Modern Aether Science’ was, in 1973, branded by a reviewer as the work of a crackpot. The work did receive two critical reviews, one in Nature, and both naming the same reviewer, a strong and now well placed member of the relativistic aristocracy. This reviewer was no crank in the eyes of the Establishment; he had just had a book of his own published showing how relativity was consistent with the universe erupting from a pin point, expanding and then, as time reversed, contracting back into its initial singularity! Such is the arena in the modern struggle between we Davids and the relativistic Goliaths.

    This paper in The Toth-Maatian Review ended with a footnote
    which the Editor, Harold Milnes, had added as an ‘Editorial Comment’:

    ‘We, too, have been very favourably impressed by Rudakov’s excellent work. His criticisms of the relativity theory aredefinitive; after them, there is nothing left to that theory that may be seriously considered further by intelligent men of science. It is a pity that this person (Rudakov) seems to have departed from the scene of action, intimidated, we are given to understand, by a fear of controversy and the usual muck raking by the third line
    relativists.’

    *

    MORE ON THE PERIHELION ANOMALY

    The above paper dates from July 1986 but my own story
    concerning the perihelion of Mercury dates back more than 25 years
    before that.
    I had been developing my own account of energy storage in the
    vacuum by electromagnetic induction and my research was based on
    experimental anomalies that I encountered in my academic research. I
    came to believe that the aether was the essential foundation and was
    told that I was living in the past and should study Einstein’s
    theory.

    Well I had studied Einstein’s theory already, at least to the
    point where I understood its scope and how its mathematics evolved
    the result formulating the perihelion advance of a planet in orbit
    around the Sun. Faced with my own interpretation of the role the
    aether plays in the process of electromagnetic induction and
    Einstein’s theory, which offered no solution to the induction
    problem, I went my own way and I was rewarded almost immediately.

    My aether could not have linear momentum, but it could have
    angular momentum. When I pictured body Earth in orbit around the Sun
    as enveloped in a coextensive sphere of aether rotating with it about
    its axis, I knew I was looking at what was effectively a pendulum bob
    in motion about a distant axis.
    By this I mean that I was looking at two components, one being
    the normal picture we see of a rotating sphere of matter describing
    an orbit around a remote axis and the other being an aether
    component. The latter itself has two parts. One is a spherical hole,
    which I thought would be coextensive with the space occupied by the
    planet. The other was the aether displaced by the motion of that hole
    with the planet around the Sun. Now, I knew that the electric
    particles which give the aether its mass property move at a high
    speed associated with their quantum jitter (Zitterbewegung).
    Therefore, I did not assume that I was dealing with a fluid medium
    displaced by matter, which would mean that the fluid pushed ahead of
    the planet by translational forward motion of its substance would
    simply flow backwards around the planet. Instead, I took the view
    that, once those particles came free from their organized motion
    sharing that quantum jitter, they would simply deploy their existing
    kinetic energy to travel at their full speed and rectilinearly across
    the region of space within that ‘hole’. Here was the point of
    mentioning that ‘pendulum bob’. The angular momentum of the aether
    hole plus its content of aether particles in reverse flow would not
    be zero. It would be that of a sphere of the aether’s mass density
    rotating at the angular velocity of the planet’s motion around the
    Sun.

    This may need a little thought, based on the reader’s
    familiarity with Newtonian mechanics, but here, to be sure, was a
    feature that could bring in the aether’s angular momentum properties
    into the discussion of solar system dynamics.
    Believe it or not, the aether does have a mass density and it
    is of the order predicted from classical studies of electromagnetic
    wave properties. 19th century physicists deemed it to be of the order
    of 100 gm/cc. There is also need for rigidity to sustain the lateral
    vibrations as they propagate at the speed of light, but it is a
    quasi-rigidity governed by those aether particles (or sub-electrons,
    to use the terminology of one of these lecture topics) forming a
    structure which can dissolve at its boundaries.

    So far as Mercury’s anomalous perihelion motion is concerned,
    you, the reader, can now work out the rate of advance of perihelion
    yourself. You need simply to know, firstly, the effective mass
    density of the aether in its spin condition. There is a zero
    momentum, or rather a cancelling momentum, for rectilinear motion.
    Then you need to know that aether mass density and the radius of the
    ‘hole’, which should be a little larger than that of planet. By
    factoring the variation of aether angular momentum into your equation
    of motion for the planet about the Sun, the resulting anomalous
    progression of perihelion is derived.

    This was how I first tackled the problem of the perihelion
    anomaly in the 1950s, having already calculated that aether mass
    density in deriving the value of Planck’s quantum of action from
    basic theoretical analysis.
    For the record I mention that in the book I wrote towards the
    end of 1959, which I published myself early in 1960 under the title ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, the chapter on perihelion motion showed that the above method gave the following data:

    * For Earth: Observed value: 4.6 arc sec/century
    * For Earth: Relativity value: 3.83 arc sec/century
    * For Earth: Aether value: 5.2 arc sec/century
    * For Mercury: Observed value: 42.56 arc sec/century
    * For Mercury: Relativity value: 43.03 arc sec/century
    * For Mercury: Aether value: 44.3 arc sec/century

    Now, in doing my theoretical research, I had not set out to
    enter any contest with Einstein’s theory. I simply wanted to get my
    point across about the nature of magnetic induction and how the
    aether stores energy in a way that allows its recovery in our
    electrical machines. To be told I was wrong because there was no
    aether was extremely frustrating and it was that made me alert
    to the need to look for what Einstein had missed. Already, in
    developing my theory from day one, I had been lucky enough to be led
    from my study of ferromagnetism to see how electrodynamic force
    interactions can give a force that is needed for unification with
    gravitation. My target therefore was not the problems which concerned
    Einstein, but rather deducing G, the constant of gravitation, in
    terms of e/m, the charge/mass ratio of the electron.

    My pre-1960 efforts on that, as summarized in Chapter 4 of that
    book, show that I was on track. Indeed, equation (24) in that work
    gave the formula for G in terms of e/m, m/M and the dimensionless
    fine structure constant (1/137). Here, M was a mass also derived
    theoretically, but of value virtually equal to that of the neutron,
    that is very slightly larger than the mass of the proton. G was
    evaluated as within one part per thousand accord with its observed
    value.

    I therefore knew that aether theory of this kind could bear
    fruit, but these were early days, and my story here concerns that
    perihelion motion of the planets.

    For many years following this early work, I was struggling with
    the problem that, in regarding the advance of perihelion as a
    function of a planet’s aether radius, I had introduced a variable
    that I could not check with observation. I knew that, for body
    Earth, the upper ionosphere was the appropriate radius to put in the
    equation. For Mercury, the orbit of which has a high eccentricity,
    my equation had to allow for the aether radius being staged in having
    an inner and outer spherical boundary, as a function of that
    eccentricity. I was, therefore, more satisfied with the result for
    the Earth than for Mercury. I also recall that Venus could pose a
    problem, depending upon the true value of the observed advance of
    perihelion. This was certainly not known, with anything like the
    certainty that applied to Mercury. I noted that the radius of the
    aether might need to be less that the radius of the planet in some
    cases.

    It was for this reason that I concentrated my onward efforts on
    developing the theory as it applied to interpreting the basis of the
    dimensionless physical constants, because these are known to very
    high precision. This led me more towards particle physics and the
    underlying quantum features rather than cosmology, whereas Einstein’s
    theory had been seized upon by those who champion cosmological
    topics.

    It was therefore not until 1976 that I really began to look for
    other ways of addressing the perihelion problem. Then, starting from
    scratch, as it were, I made the bold step of seeing if I could begin
    with Kepler’s third law of planetary motion and simply allow for the
    retardation of energy transfer in a radial perturbation.
    I adopted the following hypothesis: If a particle of relatively
    small mass m is acted upon by a particle of relatively large mass M
    so as to be accelerated towards M at a rate f, then the force which M
    exerts on m is that applicable when m is a distance s further away
    from M, s being the distance ft2/2 corresponding to acceleration
    f in the time t, where t is the time taken for energy to travel from
    m to M and back to m.

    When I allowed for the differential effect of this upon the
    radial and orbital periods of cyclic oscillation in the formulation
    of Kepler’s law, what emerged immediately in a few lines of school-level mathematics was the formula for perihelion advance derived by
    Paul Gerber and later adopted by Einstein.

    I needed a little time to weigh what this meant to my aether
    theory, but I thought I had to at least try to get this derivation
    published. It was in no way dependent upon an argument which required
    mention of the aether. I was having very great difficulty getting my
    papers accepted by scientific journals at that time and I even
    wondered if I might succeed in this quest if by using an alias. That
    I did, as a test of the journal referee system, and, to my great
    surprise, the very short two-page paper I then wrote on this Kepler-based derivation of the perihelion formula was accepted. The alias I
    used was J. N. Kidman, using the maiden surname of my mother-in-law,
    thinking this was apt name for use as an alias in this instance.

    Teachers of Newtonian mechanics who wish to introduce anomalous
    planetary perihelion motion in their teaching syllabus will find it
    of interest to look up that paper. Its title is ‘Quantum Gravitation and the Perihelion Anomaly’ [Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 18, pp. 181-182 (1977)]. No longer published, this was, at the time, an English-text scientific periodical offering rapid publication, the publishers and referee structure being the Italian Institute of Physics. As a side comment, it is interesting to note that Einstein turned to this journal for publication of his later papers when he too found it difficult to satisfy U.S. journal referees.

    From then on, dating from that 1977 period, I was on the look
    out for ways in which to give a more formal basis to this method of
    solving the perihelion problem and by 1980 I had discovered the
    correct way forward.
    However, the fact remains that I wondered how I had been misled
    by the earlier pre-1960 analysis of Mercury’s perihelion anomaly
    based on aether theory. It is only now (1997) that I am ready to
    commit to a position on this dual theory proposition. I have come to
    believe that the energy retardation theory explains the actual
    perihelion motion, but that what I have said above about compliance
    with aether angular momentum applies as well. What this means is
    that the unknown variable, the radius of the aether sphere rotating
    with the planet, is not determined necessarily by the physical extent
    of the planetary body. Instead, in order for the aether angular
    momentum to adjust in compliance with the planet’s orbital motion, so
    as not to interfere with the motion of the matter system, that
    variable parameter must adopt the right value. In short, the aether
    spin radius of the planet is determined as a secondary consequence of
    the Newtonian dynamics of the solar system, as adjusted to bring in
    the energy retardation in radial Sun-planet orbital perturbations.

    For those who are interested in technological issues but have
    read this far, there is much that I will have to say on the vacuum
    spin theme as it applies to laboratory tests on a new kind of
    electrical machine. However, at this point, I bring this particular
    lecture to an end, but note again that there will be a Part II
    discourse to follow on ‘Why Einstein was Wrong’, where I address the subject from a different perspective.

    *
  • LECTURE NO. 2

    LECTURE NO. 2

    WHY EINSTEIN WAS WRONG: PART I

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    In these Web pages I plan to summarize my case for proving that
    Einstein’s theory, whether it be his Special or General Theory of
    Relativity has no merit whatsoever.
    As can be seen from the above heading, there will be two Parts
    to my attack on Einstein territory.
    This Part I is my incursion based on a little brain-washing by
    propaganda or common sense, whichever viewpoint you choose to adopt.
    It should be enough to convince most scientifically-minded
    readers, but scientists can be stubborn, as history shows. Part II is
    a completely separate account, written without assuming knowledge of
    this Part I material, and intended to convince the experimentally-minded physicist that Einstein’s theory is just plain wrong.
    Experiments prove it to be wrong! I will refer to experiments that
    were performed in accredited laboratories or observatories, the
    results of which the scientific world have brushed under the carpet
    to avoid the issues they raise.

    If the reader is a cosmologist or a professor who teaches the
    mathematics of Einstein’s theory then there may be an unshakable
    conviction that I cannot penetrate. That person, if willing to
    browse through what I have to say, may find that Part II is best read
    first, but Part I must not be forgotten. What I am saying will not
    go away. It has to be faced and I have to be proved wrong, point by
    point, before it can be taken for granted that I am launching myself
    as a misguided weapon on the Internet scene.

    I will now begin my Part I discourse.

    There used to be a saying in England which applied to someone
    who attempted to force something to fit where common sense should
    tells us that it is impossible. ‘You cannot squeeze a pint into a
    half-pint pot!’
    Yet scientists who dominate thought in the academic community
    concerned with cosmology and theoretical physics believe
    wholeheartedly that Einstein did achieve the impossible. He managed
    to convince the academic theoreticians that it was possible for
    different observers to see space as having different forms, simply
    because he wanted to keep the speed of light constant relative to
    each and every observer, wherever that observer may be located.

    Now, of course, that community take strength from one another,
    trusting that, if they see flaws, someone in their flock really
    understands Einstein’s theory better than they do themselves. They
    do not want to reveal their own inability to comprehend that which
    their peers understand so clearly! They are semi-blind, led by the
    semi-blind and they lead the semi-blind! Ask yourself why, if four-space has any meaning, all the experiments which are said to present
    data supporting such theory present those results in the familiar
    units of three-space with time as a separate dimension.

    The logic of the steps involved can be listed as follows:
    (i) Objective: We want to put a pint in a half-pint pot.
    (ii) Stage 1: Devise a mathematical way in which to transform a half-pint pot into one that appears larger on a computer screen.
    (iii) Stage 2: Write a computer program which shows a graphic picture
    of your half-pint of liquid being poured into that pot.
    (iv) Stage 3: Run the program to enjoy the illusion and then save the
    recorded images in your computer.
    (v) Stage 4: Invite others to see your program running so they can
    witness the pint being poured into the half-pint pot.
    (vi) Stage 5: Produce a print-out summarizing what has been seen and
    authenticated, in a readable version of text now using the standard
    language of three-space.
    (vii) Stage 6: Publish your findings as ‘physics’ and declare
    ‘Eureka’.

    If you really believe Einstein’s theory then please tell me
    when we will have optical instruments and electrical measuring
    equipment that are calibrated to register directly as four-space
    measurements. Otherwise, read the following article and then tell me
    what, in that article, you cannot accept! It was written and
    published in 1986. I still await reaction and comment. Now that I am
    putting it on Internet, I urge you to give it your serious attention
    and ask yourself why the points I make are not discussed with
    students as part of the standard relativistic teaching. Remember
    that Einstein’s theory is not something that has ever been proved by
    experiment. It is a philosophical viewpoint, a matter of opinion,
    just as was the hypothesis that the Earth was flat, before it was
    circumnavigated. However, what I am saying is not philosophy. It is
    the kind of science that an engineer can understand, meaning of the
    kind that delivers results and not just a string of mathematical
    symbols, but also provides design data that checks qualitatively as
    well as quantitatively with what is actually measured.

    THE MYSTERY OF MERCURY’S PERIHELION

    The following is the text of an article I wrote that appeared
    in the July 1986, v. 5, No. 2 issue, of ‘The Toth-Maatian Review’ on
    pp. 2475-2481. The editor of this periodical is, I believe, a
    disillusioned physicist who, in his retirement years, decided to run
    his own publishing house to give attention to opinions which were not
    in favour with editors of the more orthodox publications.

    Note that the orbit of a planet around the Sun is elliptical in
    form, but the orientation of the major axis of the orbit, as judged
    by reference to the background of distant stars, can be seen to
    change very gradually. It may take tens of thousands of orbital
    revolutions before the major axis turns through 360 degrees, but turn
    it will, owing to energy transfer involved in gravitational effects
    within the multi-body solar system. That slow turning motion, or
    rather a small anomalous component thereof, is what we have in mind
    when referring to the anomalous perihelion advance of a planet.

    The title of this 1986 article, which now follows, is:

    ‘The Mystery of Mercury’s Perihelion’

    Anyone interested in Einstein’s theory of relativity usually
    acquires that interest by first learning that, because our Earth is
    moving at high speed through space and because our measurements in
    the laboratory seem immune from that motion, our viewpoint of
    physical phenomena must be specially favoured. What we see and
    measure seems, relative to us, to be rather special and Einstein’s
    special theory of relativity exploits that feeling.

    The problems begin when we encounter the abstraction of a four-dimensional space interwoven with a time which ‘dilates’ as we move
    faster and faster. We are sceptical, and rightly so, but we have
    respect for those who lead us along the path of truth. When we ask
    how 19th century physics coped with this basic problem we then find
    that Newtonian mechanics has a built-in relativistic mechanism. It
    gives the answer quite well by the down-to-earth physics governing
    our daily lives, because Newton’s laws hold up if referenced on any
    frame of reference in steady motion. We are then guided into the
    problem of deciding between the action-at-a-distance effects implicit
    in Newton’s theory and the problems of the finite propagation speed
    of light. The latter suggest retarded actions in an aether, but we
    are assured that nobody has found a way of measuring our motion in
    the laboratory by tests referenced on this medium and that, if we
    turn to Einstein for enlightenment and forget Newton, then we can
    forget the aether too. Our future in physics lies, we are told, not
    in action-at-a-distance, but in Einstein’s field theory and its
    distorted space-time metric.

    Should we still drag our feet, and perhaps the aether along
    with us, then we are dealt the ‘coup de grace’ to put us out of our
    misery. Einstein’s theory predicted something that lies outside
    Newton’s world. Einstein obtained an equation that not only explains
    why light bends in acknowledging the stars it might be passing, but
    it also gives us reason to expect that the perihelion of planet
    Mercury must advance anomalously at a rate of about 43 arc seconds
    per century. The bending of light (refraction) was a subject that
    interested Newton too, as was the perturbing effect of astronomical
    bodies on the motion of other such bodies. Indeed, most of the
    actual perihelion motion of a planet is fully explained by Newtonian
    theory when applied to multi-body systems. It is the small amount of
    43 arc seconds per century that needs explanation in the light of the
    fact that Newton relied on action-at-a-distance, the instantaneous
    action of force in regulating the motion of planets.

    General relativity, once added to the base of special
    relativity, stands as an impregnable fortress in the eyes of those
    who speak on these issues. Relativity becomes the all-pervading
    regulator of our physical science. It has been sanctified and is
    beyond challenge and we are now no longer allowed to question its
    doctrines.
    However, whatever the ordinary-minded individual might think at
    heart, there is something unsettling when eminent authorities on
    relativity can suddenly see new light and then become so hostile to
    the subject and its flaws that they turn to attack it.

    The reader may have little concern about Einstein’s theory and
    the strength it derives from Mercury’s perihelion, which helps to
    hold in place a misguided belief in dogma that can obstruct
    technological progress to the benefit of mankind. There are those
    amongst us, however, who must pay due attention and be concerned.

    Herbert Dingle, as emeritus professor in the University of
    London in England, had written two books on relativity in his early
    years, ‘Relativity for All’ and ‘The Special Theory of Relativity’.
    Later he found that he could prove it was false, but no one was
    prepared to give him much of a hearing, so he eventually wrote
    ‘Science at the Crossroads’, published in 1972 in London by Martin, Brian and O’Keefe. It is a damning account beginning with the assertion that it is supposed to be so abstruse that only a select body of specialists can be expected to understand it, but that in fact most leaders in science, particularly experimentalists, regard the theory as nonsense but accept it because a few mathematical specialists in the subject say they should.

    Another scientist, whose main activity was the measurement of
    frequency and time during the 44 years he spent at the National
    Physical Laboratory in England, realized the error in Einstein’s
    theory early in his career. He became a Fellow of the Royal Society
    and earned distinction for his measurements of the velocity of light
    by a cavity resonator, besides building the first caesium clock in
    1955. When he retired he published a paper explaining why relativity
    was in error. The reasons are perhaps less telling than some of the
    side remarks he makes in this inspiring article: ‘Relativity and Time Signals’ in Wireless World of October 1978, published in U.K. These include:

    ‘The theory is so rigidly held that young scientists dare not openly express their views’.
    ‘I was warned that if I persisted (in refuting Einstein’s
    theory) I was likely to spoil my career prospects’.
    ‘The general public is misled into believing that science is a
    mysterious subject which can be understood by only a few
    exceptionally gifted mathematicians’.
    ‘Students are told that the theory must be accepted although
    they cannot expect to understand it. They are encouraged right at the
    beginning of their careers to forsake science in favour of dogma’.
    ‘…the continued acceptance and teaching of relativity hinders
    the development of a rational extension of electromagnetic theory’.

    Dr. Essen argued the absurdity of Einstein’s theory by
    reference to its paradoxical effects on time but ended with comments
    under the heading ‘A Hope for the Future?’ in which he wrote:

    ‘There are fortunately a few writers who are breaking with
    tradition and developing new ideas which may be fruitful. In this
    country (England) there are two small volumes by H. Aspden ….’

    It was here that Dr. Essen drew attention to this writer’s
    books ‘Physics without Einstein’ and ‘Modern Aether Science’, published in 1969 and 1972, respectively.

    Outside the realm of the relativistic specialists, who would of
    course be asked to review any book challenging relativity, the first
    of these works was well reviewed by Aslib Book List in U.K.: ‘An
    extremely well-written and challenging book which should be read by
    all physicists’
    and by ‘Geophysics’ in the USA: ‘The reviewer
    welcomes this new and stimulating challenge of the orthodox views of
    modern physics … well-written … a bargain’
    . However, in spite of this, the will to believe in relativity is strong and the chances are that very few readers of this paper have even heard of Dr. Essen or these books by this author.

    Amongst the eminent who have philosophized on these scientific
    matters is Alfred North Whitehead. He wrote a work [‘The Principle of Relativity with Applications to Physical Science’. See his ‘An Anthology’, Cambridge University Press, U.K. p. 356 (1953).] He set out to provide an alternative rendering of the theory of relativity, yielding as best he could to Einstein’s methods, but trying to keep what he calls ‘the old division between physics and geometry’. He acknowledges Einstein as a genius for assimilating space and time but declares ‘the worst homage we can pay to a genius is to accept uncritically formulations of truths which we owe to it’. He levies quite serious criticism against the theory, but makes concessions which leave things in the air, as it were. So here is the philosopher who is also puzzled but is carried along by the common acclaim for the Emperor’s invisible suit of clothes. [At this point in this paper, Harold Milnes, the Editor of The Toth-Maatian Review interjected the following footnote: ‘Hans Christian Anderson never recounted the rest of the story:- how, after the small child exposed the Emperor’s nudity, the crowd became ashamed and then how everyone took off his clothes too, in reverent support of his Majesty’s majesty.’]

    Whitehead makes his point as follows:

    ‘The effects of rotation are among the most widespread of the apparent world, exemplified in the most gigantic nebulae and in the minutest molecules. The most obvious facts about rotational effects are their apparent disconnections from outlying phenomena. Rotation is the stronghold of those who believe that in some sense there is an absolute space to provide the framework of dynamical axes. Newton cited it in support of his doctrine. The Einstein theory in explaining gravitation has made rotation an entire mystery.’

    From this summary of attitudes by those who have studied
    relativity in depth, we should, it seems, not be too impressed by
    those in authority in this field; relativity could be plain wrong.
    So let us look at just one of its claims to fame, the background to
    Einstein’s work on the anomalous perihelion motion of the planet
    Mercury.

    At the outset of this discussion the author emphasized that it
    is presumed that the measured value of this anomalous rate of advance
    is 43 arc seconds per century, a value which fits the formula derived
    by Einstein. It remains debatable whether Einstein should have
    allowed a factor for solar oblateness. This could destroy his theory,
    but Establishment science prefers to look the other way on this
    point, hoping the issue will die a natural death.

    There is also room for debate on whether Einstein’s theory
    contains a major flaw. This is where its abstruse nature tends to
    hide its blemishes. The basic paradox in the eyes of this author
    arises because the governing equations of motion under gravity are
    worked out in the four-dimensional metric to a point where the
    resulting equation has, of necessity, to be interpreted in a three
    dimensional space in order to have any relation to what is measured.
    However, the equation that emerges is not one specifying the position
    of the planet at a given time or in relation to planetary velocity.
    It is a quadratic equation which is solved in linear form in order to
    give the measured quantities. The solution involves a mathematical
    process which owes nothing to relativistic method; it is strictly
    analysis of the dynamical equation in three-dimensional space, a
    mathematical exercise which the non-relativist can understand. The
    equation to be solved involves an angular momentum term h, which is
    interpreted as the velocity moment of the planetary motion about the
    Sun. The equation is solved on the assumption that h is constant, as
    it would be in Newtonian theory because angular momentum is conserved
    and mass does not vary with speed. The solution gives the equation
    for 43 arc seconds advance, so all seems well. However, what has
    happened to the observation that mass increases with speed? How can
    this result of special relativity be suddenly ignored because we have
    arrived at a partial result using general relativity and made the
    last step by reliance on Newtonian assumption?

    Unless someone can explain why the mass of a planet in orbit
    is constant in spite of change of speed, the real solution would be
    way off Einstein’s 43 arc second figure. It is submitted that this is
    a direct contradiction in Einstein’s analysis; it is not consistent
    with relativistic method. Somehow general relativity can forget that
    mass increases with speed and adopt a constant h factor in line with
    Newtonian theory, merely by moving the analysis into four space-time
    dimensions. However, the nonsense involved in this seems to show up
    when the analysis stops short of answers that can be compared
    directly with observations in the real world and makes the last leg
    of the journey in a language that does have real meaning. This
    paradox has not, so far as the author is aware, been dealt with in
    the science literature. The author’s views on it have just appeared
    in a science periodical [H. Aspden, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 44, p.
    705 (1985)], but its readers will assume that someone more familiar
    with relativity will be able to dispose of the problem.

    On this latter point we can already see the escape route
    forming by a few words in a paper by Phipps:

    ‘The tendency of modern authorities is to dismiss ‘mass
    variation with velocity’ as an artifact of the possibly misguided
    attempt to express momentum in a celestial way.’

    Phipps has just published this paper in the American Journal of
    Physics, v. 54, pp. 245-247 (1986), showing how Mercury’s perihelion
    advance can be explained according to special relativity. He uses
    planetary mass variation of the planet, as did the famous American
    physicist H.E. Ives, to achieve this result. [H.E. Ives, Jour.
    Optical Soc. Am., v. 38, p. 413 (1948)]. In such analysis very much
    depends upon whether translation from energy equations to force
    equations requires angular momentum or planetary velocity moment to
    be constant. What some writers such as Surdin [M. Surdin, Proc.
    Camb. Phil. Soc., v.58, p. 550 (1962)] regard as a 7 arc second
    contribution to perihelion from the special relativity formula can
    become a 21 arc second contribution if the proper translation into
    the relativity formula is made in solving equations. This is doubled
    by the techniques used by Ives and Phipps to give the 42 arc second
    or 43 arc second result.

    So, even today, the question of whether Einstein’s general
    theory of relativity can hold up as an explanation of Mercury’s
    perihelion progression is in a state of turmoil.
    But, whatever we might say, surely (you might argue) we owe
    some tribute to Einstein for having first presented us with the
    formula that seems to fit the facts. This must bias us in his favour.
    Indeed, Leon Brillouin in his critical attack on Einstein’s theory of
    general relativity ‘Relativity Reexamined’ [published by Academic Press, N.Y. (1970)] conceded something in Einstein’s favour in writing:

    ‘The advance of the perihelion of Mercury (43 arc seconds per century) was hailed as a wonderful check.’

    It was as if the formula for the 43 arc seconds per century
    advance was not already known from the prior work of others, which
    Einstein presumably chose not to acknowledge.

    To continue this lecture press:

    *
  • APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 1

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 1

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1987

    THE CASE FOR THE SUB-ELECTRON

    This is an article by H. Aspden which appeared in The Toth-Maatian
    Review, v. 5, No. 4, January 1987 at pp. 2827-2833.

    Abstract: One of the most basic questions in physics is whether
    there is a degenerate form of the electron, a charge of smaller mass
    than that of the electron. If there is then it is likely to be a
    primary constituent of the background field medium we recognize as
    sustaining electric displacement, namely the aether. This paper
    discusses the evidence indicative of the existence of such a
    particle, a sub-electron, having an effective mass 1/24.52 that of
    the electron.

    INTRODUCTION

    If there is a charged particle of smaller mass than the
    electron why has it not been discovered? Can it be that it exists,
    but is only evidenced indirectly? We believe that an aether exists,
    but cannot grasp hold of it. Its existence is inferred by indirect
    evidence, such as the need to explain electric displacement current
    and energy storage in a vacuum field. Perhaps the aether is elusive
    because it is composed of something equally elusive. The sub-electron may be the primary constituent of the medium permeating all
    space, set in a lattice array in a continuum charge of opposite
    electric polarity so as to constitute a medium neutral overall. If
    this is so, then what are the properties to be looked for in order to
    confirm this hypothesis?

    Firstly, one must expect the space metric to have a structure
    and determine, by its geometry, the value of the dimensionless fine-structure constant 2(pi)e2/hc. Here e is the electric charge of the sub-electron and c is the speed of light, a property accepted as set by the vacuum medium. Logically, therefore, the constant h, Planck’s constant, which combines with e and c to give a
    dimensionless quantity, becomes a likely candidate for interpretation
    in terms of vacuum structure indicative of the existence of the sub-electron.

    Secondly, if the electron can become degenerate and transform
    into a sub-electron, the reverse process should be possible.
    Therefore, we should be open to the possibility that an electron
    might exchange its energy with that of the sub-electron, so that, in
    effect, they change places spontaneously. This is a process which
    conserves energy and involves no electrodynamic disturbance, but
    their centre of mass is changed so there is an inertial effect. If
    the sub-electron is a hidden particle in the vacuum metric then this
    action would constitute a vacuum fluctuation and the process would
    soon be repeated in the reverse sense to preserve equilibrium.

    All this is hypothetical until we can build some
    substance into the argument and show, for example, that several
    different phenomena can all be explained by appeal to the sub-electron and that the quantitative features of these phenomena all
    indicate the same mass property for the sub-electron. It will be
    seen that the sub-electron can be justified by diverse physical
    argument and that the evidence supports it having an effective mass
    1/24.52 times that of the electron. Its mass mo is, therefore,
    0.0408m, where m is electron mass.

    HYDRODYNAMIC CONSIDERATIONS

    When a spherical particle is in an incompressible medium of
    fluid form and has exactly the same mass density as that medium, its
    motion through the medium involves a kinetic energy corresponding to
    it having an effective mass of half its intrinsic mass. This is
    standard hydrodynamics. One cannot expect the vacuum to comply with
    hydrodynamic theory in every respect, but it is a guide to a possible
    property of the sub-electron. If this sub-electron is degenerate in
    form it will be in equilibrium with the surrounding medium, meaning
    that its pressure developed by repulsion of its charge will be
    uniform both inside the charge body of the sub-electron and in the
    surrounding space. Our expectation is that, unlike normal matter
    particles, the sub-electron will exhibit only half the mass derived
    from the E=Mc2 formula. In terms of its effective mass mo, this
    allows us to write E=2moc2 for the sub-electron, because its
    mass in a non-pressurized medium or true vacuum would be 2mo.

    The argument just presented warrants investigation to see if
    the anomalous factor of 2 governing the gyromagnetic ratio of certain
    fundamental particles in spin is attributable to a similar process
    set up by a local equilibrium in the self-radiation field of the
    particle. In a sense ‘spin’ may mean a confined motion of the charge
    centre in relation to a standing wave energy set up in the local
    field, with the result that translational motion exhibiting mass M
    may correspond to a spin motion of effective mass M/2. The magnetic
    moment developed by a given spin angular momentum will be double that
    exhibited by a motion of the full mass M. The anomalous gyromagnetic
    ratio of 2 need not be quite so mysterious as we are led to believe
    from conventional Dirac theory based on relativistic formalism.

    Readers interested in taking these thoughts further may find it
    useful to refer to Honig’s recent discussion of the fluid model
    electron [W.M. Honig, ‘The Quantum and Beyond’, Philosophical
    Library, N.Y., pp. 87-93; 1986] or the electromagnetic reaction
    theory for the factor 2 proposed by Aspden [‘Electromagnetic Reaction Paradox’, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 39, pp. 247-51; 1984] and further supported by analysis of the first principles of charge interaction in a later work [H. Aspden, ‘Unification of Gravitational and Electrodynamic Potential Based on Classical Action-at-a-Distance Theory’, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 44, pp. 689-693; 1985].

    PLANCK’S CONSTANT

    The more direct evidence of the sub-electron mass property
    comes from the derivation of the relationship:

    hc/2πe2 = 216π(mo/m)1/2 ……….(1),

    where:

    (m/2mo)3 = 1843 ………..(2),

    From this hc/2πe2 is found to be 137.0359 and mo/m is 0.04078.

    A recent derivation of equation (1) was presented by Aspden
    [‘Boson Creation in a Sub-Quantum Lattice’, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 40, pp. 53-57 (1984)] and the earlier computations proving equation (2) were reported by Aspden and Eagles [‘Aether Theory and the Fine Structure Constant’, Physics Letters A, v. 41, pp. 423-424 (1972)]. Essentially, equation (2) arises from a recognition that the space occupied by a sub-electron must be an odd multiple of that occupied by the electron. The mass of the electron is inversely proportional to its charge radius and the corresponding 2mo term for the sub-electron is similarly proportional to charge radius. For a suitable transformation in which the volume displaced by charge is conserved it takes 1843 electrons and positrons to fill the volume of one sub-electron, meaning that electron-positron creation demanding the energy quantum of the order of that of the proton mass is needed to achieve such a resonant transformation.

    The 1843 number is the nearest odd integer that assures a non-negative potential in the dynamic state of the structured vacuum
    medium. This is the subject of the paper by Aspden and Eagles just
    referenced. So far as equation (1) is concerned this is easily
    derived. The outline method involves taking the Planck radiation
    formula E=hf as a contracted statement of two equations. One
    equation says that, because the vacuum has the properties of a two-dimensional linear oscillator and stores energy E in proportion to
    angular momentum, there has to be something spinning to balance this
    angular momentum. The other equation relates this angular momentum to
    the moment of inertia of the spinning unit of the structured lattice
    and says that waves are set up as the unit rotates, the waves having
    the frequency f, which is indirectly proportional to energy E. The
    natural oscillation frequency of the vacuum medium is that at which
    electrons and positrons materialize, namely mc2/h. The
    derivation of equation (1) comes from determining the form of the
    spinning unit as the smallest symmetrical three-dimensional unit of a
    cubic lattice, with a sub-electron at its lattice sites and at its
    centre.

    The author’s theory of the photon is of long standing, but it
    is not well known. It is inappropriate to dwell upon it here, in
    view of the referenced publications, but it is mentioned that it was
    presented to a recent NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Quantum
    Theory [H. Aspden, ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Photon in a Lattice Vacuum’, NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Quantum Mechanics, Proceedings of Conference at Bridgeport, Connecticut, June 23-27, 1986, published in NATO ASI Series B: Physics Vol. 62 by Plenum (1987) at pp. 345-360] and the fact that the theory gives a
    theoretical value for hc/2πe2 to one part per million
    precision accord with its measured value was the subject of a recent
    comment in a review by Petley [B. W. Petley, ‘The Fundamental
    Physical Constants and the Frontier of Measurement’
    , Adam Hilger,
    Boston, pp. 161-163 (1985)]. The theory forms the basis of the
    statement that the mass of the sub-electron is 0.04078 times that of
    the electron. This paper now addresses other evidence of the sub-
    electron mass.

    THE SUN’S TEMPERATURE

    The energy needed to remove the electron from the lowest K
    orbit in the hydrogen atom is well known from physics texts to be
    equal to its kinetic energy E in a Bohr orbit, which is:

    E = α2mc2/2 ………. (3),

    where α is the fine structure constant (1/137), the reciprocal of the expression formulated in equation (1) above. This energy is 2.18×10-11 ergs, equivalent to a temperature T found by dividing by Boltzmann’s constant, 1.38×10-16, to be 158,000 K.

    If, however, we admit that the natural collision processes
    which occur in hydrogen under intense pressure and high temperature
    reduce this temperature threshold, then the Sun’s temperature of
    about 6,000 K becomes explicable. This is somewhat hypothetical. It
    is, however, quite interesting to imagine the process discussed
    above, where it is suggested that an electron and a sub-electron
    might exchange places transiently. Putting mo into equation (3) instead of m, reduces T by the factor 24.52, from 158,000 K to 6,400
    K, a quite representative value of the Sun’s temperature.
    Accordingly, indirectly, we have evidence here that the sub-electron
    might exist and could play a very fundamental role in stellar
    properties.

    THE WESSON CONSTANT

    To support what has just been said we will now consider an
    unexplained but curious fact of astrophysics. Wesson [P. S. Wesson,
    ‘Clue to the Unification of Gravitation and Particle Physics’
    ,
    Physical Review D23 (8), pp. 1730-1734 (1981)] has established
    empirically that astronomical bodies obey the formula relating
    angular momentum J and their mass M and given by:

    J = pM2 ………… (4),

    where p is a constant of approximately 8×10-16 in
    cgs units. Strictly, this expression seems to apply where two similar
    bodies form together as a kind of binary pair.

    To test the sub-electron theory we take the temperature T of
    6,400 K as giving the mean energy (3/2)kT of the free electron, k
    being Boltzmann’s constant. Then we argue that at the moment when two
    spherical bodies of mass M and radius r separate, their distance
    between centres is 2R. Therefore, the balance between gravitational
    attraction GM2/(2R)2 and centrifugal force MV2/R gives
    GM4 as equal to 4(MVR)2(M/R), so that:

    J = MVR = pM2 …………(5),

    where:

    p2 = G/4(M/R) …………(6).

    To find M/R we note that free electrons, like molecules in a
    gas, have three degrees of freedom and that their mean energy is
    (3/2)kT. In relation to the excitation energy of the hydrogen atom
    we used kT because there are only two degrees of freedom and because
    hf, as the energy quantum, is found empirically to relate to kT in
    the exponential distribution formulated by Planck.

    Provided an astronomical body composed of hydrogen has a
    temperature less than T=6,400 K, there should be no free electrons to
    be driven off by their thermal agitation. Above this temperature the
    energy (3/2)kT of the electrons can overcome the gravitational
    potential GMm/R, where m is electron mass, and move well away from
    the body, leaving it with a positive charge. This prevents the
    escalation of this process but it also arrests the build-up of the
    body to larger size, because protons in the surrounding plasma are
    repelled by the charge and the effect overcomes gravitational
    attraction. We see, therefore, that M/R is fixed as (3/2)kT/Gm and
    put this into equation (6) to find Wesson’s constant p.
    Thus:

    p = G(m/6kT)1/2 ……….. (7)

    To calculate p, we now put G=6.67×10-8, m=9×10-28,
    k=1.38×10-16 and T=6,400. The resulting value of p is
    8.7×10-16, which is virtually the empirical value discovered by
    Wesson, thereby confirming our theory.

    The theory has the further merit of explaining why the two
    bodies separate. As a binary star system they may heat very slightly
    above the critical temperature and acquire strong mutual repulsion
    owing to their positive charge and electron emission. The effects of
    gravitational attraction are weakened by this and the system acquires
    a kind of stability, but the mass and angular momentum of each body
    is unaffected.

    However, our objective of deriving some evidence for the
    properties of the sub-electron is met, even in these remote
    cosmological systems. Our attention now turns to the microcosmic
    world of elementary particles.

    THE MYSTERY OF THE NEUTRAL PION

    To the author the neutral pion is somewhat of an enigma. The
    author has developed a theoretical basis for the muon, the pion, the
    kaon and other mesons, explaining their mass ratios in terms of
    electron mass. Also the proton, neutron and deuteron have yielded to
    the theory, but the neutral pion, which is 264.1 times as massive as
    the electron has been a mystery. Relevant references are [H. Aspden,
    ‘The Mass of the Muon’, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 38, pp. 342-344
    (1983)], [‘The Nature of the Pion’, Spec. Science and Tech., v. 8,
    pp. 235-239 (1985)]. [H. Aspden, ‘The Theoretical Nature of the
    Neutron and the Deuteron’
    , Hadronic Journal, v. 9, pp. 129-136
    (1986)] and [H. Aspden, ‘Meson Production based on the Thomson Energy Correlation’, Hadronic Journal, v. 9, pp. 137-140 (1986)].

    It is therefore interesting to find that the neutral pion has
    revealed itself in the following theoretical analysis. The argument
    begins by considering the interchange of energy and so, state,
    between the electron and the sub-electron and looking for a standing
    wave resonance mode that develops between the two particle forms.
    Then we specify that a pair of oppositely charged particles can have
    a quasi-stable but short-lived interaction with the electron and the
    sub-electron. Together they form a neutral entity, which we shall
    find we can identify as the neutral pion.

    As mentioned already, the earlier theory indicated that the
    spherical volume of the sub-electron charge was 1843 times that of
    the electron. This means that its radius is (1843)1/3 times that of the electron. Now, from independent theory concerned with wave
    resonance effects [see, for example, H. Aspden, ‘The Muon g-factor by Cavity Resonance Theory’, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, v. 39, pp. 271-275 (1984)], there is reason to suspect that standing wave conditions can be set up around the charge periphery and develop resonance as
    between charges connected with disturbances propagating around the
    charge at the speed of light.

    The task, therefore, was to find the likely resonance as
    between the electron and the sub-electron. The method adopted is to
    suppose that there are X standing wave nodes on the electron charge
    taken around a circle centred on the charge. Then, in traveling
    through N wave nodes around the electron, a disturbance will take N/X
    units of time. The resonance requires this to equal the time required
    by a disturbance traveling through Y wave nodes around the sub-electron, which has N standing wave nodes.

    Thus: XY becomes NZ(1843)-1/3. Note that XY has to be less than NZ in the ratio of the radius of the electron charge to that of the sub-electron.
    X, Y, Z and N are all integers and, in order to assure a
    definitive resonance state not conducive to setting up harmonics, it
    is stipulated that at least three of these numbers must be prime.
    The author has searched for the best combination of numbers giving
    close equality in the above equation and discovered that the best
    combination, without going to excessively high values, is X=19,
    Y=139, Z=1619 and N=20. This has the advantage also that, in the
    transition from electron to sub-electron, the number of standing wave
    nodes only changes by one.

    It may be verified that this combination satisfies the equation
    to about 4 parts in a billion. The numbers 19, 139 and 1619 are all
    prime and 19 differs from 20 by unity. These resonance criteria
    will, therefore, be the most likely to prevail as between the two
    most fundamental particles in nature.

    We now look for a particle that can exchange state transiently
    with the sub-electron so as to have ideally the same number N of
    standing wave nodes but which resonates with both the electron and
    the sub-electron in traversing XY wave nodes. This means that its
    radius (or the inverse of its mass) must be 1/Z times that of the
    sub-electron or N/XY times that of the electron. In other words, its
    mass must be XY/N times that of the electron mass m. This is
    (19)(139)/(20) or 132.05 units of m.

    This state of affairs can be interpreted by saying that a
    charge pair of combined mass (264.1)m can exist and that it may
    transiently cycle between the two states as one member of the pair
    assumes the sub-electron form and the other member absorbs the
    balance of the energy. The result is a neutral entity of total mass
    (264.1)m, which happens to be exactly the mass of the neutral pion.
    Hence the theory is well supported.

    Should the reader be sceptical, then we go a step further and
    explain the other property of the neutral pion using the same theory.
    Its lifetime is 8×10-17 seconds. The theory tells us that,
    because the neutral pion oscillates between two states, it presents,
    as a main target for decay, a volume some 1843 times that of the
    electron, the volume of the sub-electron charge, for half of any
    period of time, because it spends equal time in each state. Thus its
    lifetime will be 921 times shorter than that of the electron. Now,
    the electron is not believed to have a finite lifetime, but it does
    have one. It decays in 0.75×10-13 seconds. The lifetime has
    been rigorously calculated [H. Aspden, ‘The Finite Lifetime of the Electron’ , Spec. Science and Tech., v. 7, pp. 3-6 (1984)] using the same theoretical method as that involved in deducing equations (1) and (2) and found to be 0.75×10-13 seconds. It follows, therefore, that the same theory leads to a lifetime for the neutral pion of (2/1843) times this or 8×10-17 seconds, in full accord with observation.

    DISCUSSION

    The case for the sub-electron has been presented by showing how
    a number of phenomena lacking explanation in conventional physical
    theory, all become explicable with precise results on the basis of
    its assumed existence. It has an effective mass 0.04078 times that
    of the electron.

    It is debatable whether the effective mass of positive holes in
    semi-conductors may in some way reflect the transitional states of
    electrons and sub-electrons. The latter belong to the unseen aether
    lattice and removal of a sub-electron might be manifested as a
    positive hole. Experiments on p-type germanium crystals have given
    effective masses m* of positive holes as m*/m=0.04 and m*/m=0.3, whereas n-type germanium was found to sustain values of m*/m=0.11 [W.
    Ehrenberg, ‘Electric Conduction in Semiconductors and Metals’,
    Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 145-146 (1958)]. In a sense, the semi-
    conductor lacks the simplicity of the isolated particle in the
    structured vacuum medium, so analysis of such data by the author’s
    theory is unprofitable. Being unconventional in its technique it
    rests on the successful theoretical determination of precise values
    of measured quantities, some with part per million precision.
    Therefore, it has seemed best to seek out the indirect evidence of
    the existence of the sub-electron.

    One question that the author has faced up to is why electrons
    exist all, if the sub-electron is the natural degenerate form. The
    answer to this is believed to be dependent upon the proton and the
    derivative atomic nucleus. Just enough electrons exist to keep a
    neutral overall balance with the positive charge in the proton form
    and atomic nuclei. The surplus energy that has not found a fully
    dissipated destiny in the vacuum lattice, the world of the sub-electron and the neutralizing vacuum background continuum,
    materializes as protons. Larger particle forms cannot be stable
    because they would soon encounter the sub-electron and they would
    have enough energy to generate 1843 electrons and positrons from the
    sub-electron. The ongoing annihilation of electrons and positrons
    causes the energy to start again in its effort to create protons,
    which are stable because their mass is 1836 times that of the
    electron, that is, below the threshold set by the 1843 factor.

    Clearly, the theory outlined involves speculation and it gives
    plenty of scope for one’s imagination. For this reason, and so as to
    follow a path which is meaningful and not fanciful, the author has
    taken it to be essential also for any idea to have more than one such
    outcome. This has been demonstrated above in discussing the Wesson
    constant, and in deducing the neutral pion mass and its lifetime. It
    is hoped that the reader will find interest in the case for the sub-
    electron and be stimulated to probe other secrets of Nature that
    might bear out the views offered in this paper.

    *
  • LECTURE NO. 1

    LECTURE NO. 1

    2020 VISION

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    INTRODUCTION

    Much of what I describe in these Internet Web pages will
    interest anyone who has tried to follow the developments in cosmology
    and physical science during the course of the 20th century. This has
    been ‘Einstein’s century’ in the sense that physicists have flocked
    like sheep to follow the thought paths of one man, Albert Einstein.
    He took us into an imaginary world of so-called ‘four-space’ or
    ‘space-time’. This is a world which has to be seen as virtual
    reality, in which time is intermeshed with the three dimensions of
    space in a make-belief vision that has become a drug to which the
    modern physicist has become addicted.

    At this time of writing, 1997, there are signs that Einstein’s
    Theories of Special and General Relativity are about to go out-of-
    fashion. They have led us nowhere beyond the point reached by
    Einstein in 1916 on a trail which became a dead end at that time.
    There were then so many unsolved mysteries in the realm of
    gravitation and the electrodynamics of interacting electrical
    particles, the field explored by Einstein, but they have not been
    solved by his methods. Einstein never did understand the unifying
    link by which the force of gravitation can be explained in terms of
    electromagnetism.

    If you, the reader, are a student of physics, then I ask you to
    look through your physics textbooks, meaning those recommended as
    part of your orthodox curriculum. Can you find anything which tells
    you how to calculate the value of the Constant of Gravitation G in
    terms of the physical constants we associate with the electrical
    properties of matter? If you can, please draw it to my attention.

    Possibly you may also find that Einstein’s theory is not
    discussed in your textbooks, because it is deemed too advanced for
    your range of study. You will, however, know, as common knowledge,
    that you are expected to regard Einstein as a genius by recognizing
    the formula E=Mc2. Please do not think I am saying that this formula has no
    validity. Instead, do appreciate that there is history in science
    and that what I am saying is that the equivalence of mass and energy,
    as represented by the equation, was not discovered by Einstein. The
    conversion of the Sun’s mass into energy which could be radiated into
    space was a theoretical proposition mooted by British scientists in
    the journal ‘Nature’ and in at least one textbook before the Einstein
    decade (1905-1916) even began. J.J. Thomson discovered the electron
    and he went on to develop electron theory, arguing that the
    electromagnetic momentum augmented the mass-energy of the electron so
    as to preclude the electron from ever exceeding the speed of light.
    That was still in the 19th century.

    No, all I am saying in attacking Einstein’s theory is that
    there is a viable alternative and that Einstein’s theory is erroneous
    in its very foundations. It requires the time dimension to be merged
    into the dimensions of space to create a distorted mathematical
    illusion of reality. That is an absurd notion. We move in space
    that is three-dimensional and it is the passage of time that allows
    us to reposition ourselves in that three-dimensional world. This
    involves four dimensions, but not four ‘space-time’ dimensions as
    those who teach physics today would have you believe.

    It could well take another 20 years or so before the
    alternative physical theory will eventually come to replace
    Einstein’s doctrines. That alternative theory does exist. It was
    developed during the years 1955-1975, with gravitation succumbing to
    final solution midway through this period. The new theory is all-embracing. It extends into the quantum world and it does include that
    derivation G I have just mentioned. So my vision for the year 2020
    is that teachers will by then realize that all of the long-standing
    mystery of gravitation has been put right in the world of physics.
    Cosmological science will also have been revolutionized by
    eradicating the Big Bang hypothesis of creation. The universe will no
    longer be seen as expanding at close to the speed of light and enough
    will be understood about gravitation to declare unambiguously that
    Black Holes are an impossibility.

    If you think these are empty words and are impatient about
    reading on without some assurance that there is substance in what I
    say, then note the following reference and look up the paper at a
    university library. It is paper authored by Dr.D.M. Eagles entitled:‘A Comparison of Results of Various Theories for Four Fundamental Constants of Physics’ and it was published in the International Journal of Theoretical Physics, v. 15, pp. 265-270 (1976). Dr. Eagles was engaged on research at the Australian Government’s CSIRO National Measurement Laboratory at the time he wrote that paper.

    The abstract of this paper reads: ‘A comparison is made of
    theoretical values of various authors for the fine-structure
    constant, for the proton-electron and muon-electron mass ratios, and
    for the gravitational constant. It is shown that a lattice ether
    theory developed by Aspden gives the best overall agreement with
    experiment.’

    As the originator of this alternative theory, what I have to
    say in these pages is my own personal record. It is a series of
    lectures, that could form the basis of what can be taught in
    universities to students of physics in lieu of Einstein’s theory.
    As I am 69 years of age in this year 1997, you will understand
    why I have headed this introduction ‘2020 VISION’. In my remaining
    years there is little more that I can do to arouse the awareness of
    the scientific community on this matter. The theory in its full
    detail does exist. It exists in spite of the unwillingness, indeed
    the intolerance, of editors and referees of scientific journals, when
    confronted with the suggestion that Einstein’s way is not the path
    which mother Nature follows. I can but hope that common sense will
    prevail in the end, as I try to present to you my vision of things to
    come by the year 2020.

    Should you wonder why I am writing this at all, then my excuse
    is that I earned my living, not as a teacher nor as a researcher but
    rather in the corporate world centred on technological development,
    but that did not preclude me from being inspired by my early training
    in physics. I spent most of my working career with IBM at a time when
    the company motto THINK intruded upon our peace of mind. I took it to
    heart. I have always enjoyed the intellectual challenges posed by
    physical science. It has become my hobby and my obsession. I have
    been fortunate in my discoveries, my methods always being to heed
    reports of experimental anomalies that lay as obstacles on my chosen
    path. I searched for error of interpretation in what others had come
    to accept without question. My reward has been the fascinating
    findings that I will report again in the pages which now follow. I
    say ‘again’ because, here and there, in a piecemeal fashion, the
    substantive scientific elements of my discourse are all of record
    somewhere in the science literature. This Internet account aims to
    bring everything into perspective so as to facilitate the efforts of
    anyone seeking to collate my recorded research findings.

    If you, the reader, can find interest in what I say and if,
    perchance, you are likely eventually to become one of those who teach
    physics in the year 2020, then I urge you to make your own copy of
    what I shall be writing in these lectures and keep it for future
    reference. Perhaps you will be able to incorporate my findings into
    your own teaching and build further on what I say to become one of
    those who lead the physics revolution of the 21st century.

    If you are a student then what I say in these pages might even
    inspire you to put certain questions to your tutors now. How they
    respond should tell you how good they are at their job, which, do
    remember, is to equip you to face a future amidst a forum of ever-evolving science. You must not end your studies believing that, had
    you paid more attention, you, like your tutors, would know all the
    answers. No, you must end your studies knowing enough to be able to
    find your own way in a jungle where there are discoveries yet to be
    made. If your teacher can point you towards unexplored territory or
    poorly-mapped territory that has only supposedly been explored, then
    that teacher warrants respect. If your teacher tells you that you
    must not venture into certain territory, because it is forbidden,
    then beware of false doctrine and, secretly if necessary, do have the
    courage to resolve to explore some part of that territory very
    carefully yourself.

    To conclude this introductory section I will indulge in a
    little anecdotal history that you will see as relevant to what I have
    just said.
    In the early days, following publication of my 1966 book ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, I was visited in my home by a young student
    named Paul Wesson. He was interested in tectonic plates and the
    evolution of the Earth, which meant that cosmology, gravitation and
    geomagnetism were very much on his mind. Furthermore, he had in some
    way impressed the Astronomer Royal of the time, which I suspect may
    have helped him in later years to secure publication of a very
    extensive dissertation in the Quarterly Journal of the Royal
    Astronomical Society even though he was still in an early phase of
    his academic education.

    The article was entitled: ‘The Implications for Geophysics of Modern Cosmologies in which G is Variable’ and it was published in v. 14 of that journal between pp. 9-64 in 1973. It was a very long scientific paper. If you, the reader, are interested in cosmological questions and you are approaching the subject more as a student with an open mind then I suggest you also look up that paper in your university library.

    Early in that paper you will see mention of my name and I quote
    below the few words that Wesson wrote about my work:

    ‘The origin of geomagnetism as a cosmological problem is in a confused state, the only really connected account being that of
    Aspden (1966), whose theory of gravitation suffers from serious
    conceptual defects as viewed by present-day standards: the theory as
    a whole and hence the magnetic field aspect of it lacks adherents.’

    Paul Wesson was impressed by what I had to say about my theory
    at that meeting in my home, so much so that he included the above
    words in his formal up-to-date review of cosmology as it stood in
    1973. Note that he inferred that the conceptual defects of my theory
    were not such that they would have troubled a 19th century scientist.
    They are conceptual difficulties arising only because the 20th
    century cosmologist has decided there is no aether and so any theory
    that has aether as its foundation is deemed defective, by definition,
    whatever its merits!

    This reference to Paul Wesson’s 1973 account should show that
    my theory, even as it stood in its published form in 1966, was not
    hidden from view. The fact that it has been ignored by cosmologists
    who really do still seek to understand geomagnetism and gravitation
    must therefore be regarded as deliberate and wilful. An intelligent
    academic society should, I submit, have been prepared to put on
    record their evaluation of what I had to say about geomagnetism and
    gravitation, rather than simply ignoring the case I had to offer. If
    something that is new in theoretical physics is presented for
    consideration but is deemed to be wrong, then, particularly if it has
    survived peer review scrutiny to reach publication in a recognized
    scientific journal, the scientific community should point to the
    errors.

    I can say, incidentally, that when I did one day falter in
    making a proposal for an optical experiment, it was only a matter of
    months before I saw that someone had published a paper pointing out
    the flaw. It was a flaw that was easily rectified and I was glad to
    be corrected.
    Concerning my theory of gravitation, however, I have never been
    challenged. My theory ‘lacks adherents’, meaning that it still lies
    in no-man’s land, waiting for the aether wind to blow one way or the
    other in an arena in which four-space cosmologists see themselves as
    the only gladiators.

    However, concerning Paul Wesson, these latter comments are not
    why I mention his name here. Shortly after his visit to see me he
    told me that he would be going to Cambridge and that he had requested
    that his Ph.D. research subject would be the in-depth study of the
    theory of gravitation that I was advocating. His feedback to me was
    that his tutor-to-be had declared point blank that under no
    circumstances could he indulge in research specifically related to my
    work.

    Inevitably, of course, Paul Wesson, had to conform and become
    merged into the conventional academic community. I see that he became
    a Professor at a Canadian university and I wonder if he remembers
    much of what I had to say about gravitation and the aether. However,
    I can say that I was very interested when something he published in
    Physical Review. D23 (8), pp. 1703-1704 (1981) came to my attention.
    The paper was entitled: ‘Clue to the Unification of Gravitation and Particle Physics’.
    He had discovered a new constant in astrophysics, one which
    could stand alongside the Hubble constant for its importance. Ask
    yourself, have you heard of the Wesson constant? If not, perhaps his
    discovery is also destined to be lost in the archives, just as my
    discoveries have been buried in the no-man’s land of science. For my
    part, I was not prepared to sit by and watch and so I wrote the paper
    on the sub-electron which I shall reproduce shortly in these Web
    pages. I have had to dig it out from its grave, but you ought to find
    it interesting.

    Incidentally, the ‘sub-electron’ is a name I used to describe
    the most degenerate form that an aether charge can assume. Note that
    all fundamental charged particles of matter have a charge equal in
    magnitude to that of the electron, so is it not logical that discrete
    charge components of the aether should be a degenerate state of the
    electron?
    Before coming to that paper I wrote on the Wesson constant, I
    want next to introduce an item of mine that was published in the
    journal ‘Nature’, to reveal a little of the flavour of what my theory
    has to offer.


    The following text by H. Aspden is an item of Correspondence
    published in Nature, v. 319, 2nd January 1986 at p. 8.

    EARNSHAW’S THEOREM

    This theorem is not often mentioned in scientific journals. It denies
    the possibility that an electric charge can be held stable solely under
    the electrostatic influence of other electric charge. It was used in a
    recent letter [Nature v. 317, p. 208; 1985] to refute a case put earlier
    by Berezin [Nature, v. 315, p.104; 1985]. It is as well to keep in
    mind that the Reverend Samuel Earnshaw developed his theorem
    with an eye to the constitution of the aether as a medium comprising
    a structured system of electric charges, separated by what,
    presumably, would be regarded as a truly void state of the vacuum.
    The theorem fails if the charges permeate a charge plenum or
    continuum having a charge density, because displacement can then
    be subject to a linear restoring force rate, owing to interaction with
    this continuum.

    We have now come to accept that the vacuum medium
    does have some rather special characteristics and a possible structure,
    so it is not unlikely that it comprises electric charges permeating a
    charge plenum, notwithstanding the Earnshaw theorem.
    If this is the case, then the theorem cannot even be applied
    without some reservation when considering the mutual stability of
    charge in matter. The support for the structured vacuum is
    enhanced by the theoretical derivation of the fine-structure constant
    in terms of the geometrical features of an electrical charge system
    neutralized by a charge continuum. A value of the fine-structure
    constant in matching accord with its measurement at the level of one
    part in ten million has recently been reported from such analysis
    [Phys. Lett., 110A, 113; 1985].

    • I have introduced the above note concerning Earnshaw’s Theorem to show that my interest in the aether and its lattice structure of negative charges seated at lattice sites in a background continuum of positive charge has at least penetrated into the pages of that exclusive journal ‘Nature’. Those negative charges are the sub-electrons that will be the subject on my paper dealing with the Wesson constant. However, that comes as a kind of Appendix presented between this Lecture No. 1 and Lecture No. 2, but only after I have added a little light-hearted comment directed at … well, just read it and see!

    SCIENTIFIC REINCARNATION

    To bring a little light relief into these lectures I should
    like, at the outset, to refer to something I read recently in a book
    I purchased at an airport bookstore when traveling on vacation.
    It was a Bantam Books 1995 edition of Stephen Hawking’s ‘A
    Brief History of Time’
    which had the sub-title ‘From the Big Bang to Black Holes’. The book was billed on its own cover as ‘The record-breaking bestseller now in paperback’.

    Now, notwithstanding the fact that Stephen Hawking was said to
    hold Newton’s chair as Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge
    and to be ‘widely considered to be the greatest scientific thinker
    since Newton and Einstein’, I hold my ground in declaring that it is
    nonsense to believe in the Big Bang and the existence of Black Holes.
    I will give my reasons presently when I come to discuss how
    gravitation affects the formation of stars.
    What struck me with some force, when I read the text I have
    quoted in the paragraph above, was the opening sentence that
    introduced the bibliographic note about Stephen Hawking on page 221
    of his book. It read: ‘Stephen Hawking was born in Oxford in 1942,
    exactly 300 years after the death of Galileo’.

    Was this a suggestion that the spirit of Galileo has been
    reincarnated in the body of Stephen Hawking? Am I supposed to
    believe from this that Stephen Hawking was destined from birth to be
    a scientist ranking with Galileo, Newton and Einstein owing to some
    divine intervention?
    No doubt some readers may believe there may be something in
    such a claim, especially if they happen to read elsewhere that
    Einstein was born in 1876, the very year in which the famous
    scientist Clerk Maxwell died.

    Students of physics or mature philosophers alike should then
    ponder on how it is that the time lapse involved in such
    reincarnation is measured in centuries. The Earth makes 100
    revolutions in a century. If the reincarnation is an act of God, why
    is it that God counts, as we have done, in the decimal system, rather
    than the binary logic as now used in computers, and refers to a
    ‘clock’ which takes it time from but one planet of a star amongst
    countless billions of stars in God’s universe?

    No, this 300 year time lapse between Galileo’s death and
    Hawking’s birth, is mere journalistic nonsense. It is exploitation by
    enterprise aimed at striking awe in a public ready to believe
    anything that is branded as science. I simply find it amusing and say
    that one really must judge a scientist on his merits and not on such
    notions about time of birth.
    However, just in case there are those who do want to believe in
    the reincarnation of scientific spirit with gaps measured in
    centuries, then I do not want to miss out in commanding attention
    myself. As author of these lectures, I should be accorded special
    attention, because I was born in 1927, whereas Isaac Newton died in
    1727. Moreover, I first felt my inspiration concerning my theory of
    gravitation when I spent my three years of Ph.D. work as a Research
    Student at Trinity College, Cambridge. Trinity must surely have been
    haunted by Newton’s spirit, because that was his college!

    Of course, it may be that the word ‘exactly’ in the quoted
    reference to the 300 year connection between Galileo and Hawking
    meant the very day and month as well as the tricentennial year. In
    that case I can offer no matching competition, save to say that, if I
    were in charge of reincarnating a spirit, I would make the date of
    conception the anniversary date, because the biological separation of
    mother and child should follow without spiritual intervention after
    the clock has been set running by that act of conception.

    In the latter case, then I can even make a better claim to
    spiritual reincarnation than can Stephen Hawking, because Newton died
    on March 20th and I was born on December 12th, 200 years, eight
    months and three weeks after Newton died. March 20th also features
    in my case history, in being the date in the year in which I was
    married in Cambridge and the date on which I received my Cambridge
    Ph.D. degree.

    That said, I really think that if Newton’s spirit played any
    role at all in inspiring me towards scientific achievement, it was a
    role he played with all the other students at Trinity College. Apart
    from his statue in the College Chapel, there was his penetrating
    stare as he looked down upon us from his portrait during the three or
    so years of taking our meals in the College Hall.

    I therefore end these remarks by reserving the right we can all
    share of being able to criticize Stephen Hawking’s authority on the
    subject of gravitation and as an advocate of Black Holes and their
    effect on electrons and positrons in space.


    To continue this lecture press:

    *