Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • PHYSICS NO. 7

    THE PHYSICS OF CREATION: LECTURE NO. 7

    The Standard Model and the Muon g-factor

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 2001

    INTRODUCTION

    In preparing this Physics Lecture I am venturing into new territory. I am about to speculate on the physics of a problem that has emerged earlier this month (February 2001) as a news item published by the U.K. Institute of Physics. See PhysicsWeb.

    It states that:

    “The international team (at Brookhaven National laboratory) – which believes the discovery may hint at a new and unexplored area of physics – broke the news in a special conference held at Brookhaven yesterday (8 February 2001) and hopes to publish its work in Physical Review Letters.”

    What is that discovery? Simply that “the Standard Model of particle physics – which has mapped the subatomic world with remarkable success for over 30 years – has been challenged by new results from Brookhaven National Laboratory in the US. Precise measurements of the behaviours of muons in a magnetic field disagree significantly with the Standard Model.”

    My interest in this stems from the fact that, for more than 30 years, I have been thwarted in my efforts to gain recognition for my theoretical efforts in delving into the physical properties of sub-atomic particles, by having the finger pointed at something beyond challenge, namely the ability of QED (quantum electrodynamics according to the standard model) to account for certain numerical quantities with a level of precision that is so astounding as to be beyond question.

    What I found to be particularly offensive was the fact that when I submitted a paper that offered a well-reasoned physical explanation for the factor-of-2 component of the electron g-factor, I was told that I should not waste my time; the methods of QED were sacrosanct and so precise that all other theoretical avenues did not warrant a hearing.

    I was not at the time interested in the minor feature of the anomalous g-factor of the electron or that of the muon, the latter being the subject of this Lecture. By this use of the word ‘minor’ I mean what modern physics terms ‘the anomalous’ component of the g-factor. I personally regarded the more dominant factor-of-2 as ‘anomalous’, but the standard opinion is that for the electron g-factor of 2 times (1.0011596522) it is the 1.0011596522 that is anomalous but not the dominant factor 2! Indeed, my attention from my earliest efforts in physics research had concentrated on this factor-of-2 because I saw it as evidence that the magnetic moment produced by electric charge in orbital motion was really double the value assumed by orthodox teaching but was halved by a reaction set up by the aether of our environment. Such an effect would only be detected by an experiment which could give a true measure of the gyromagnetic ratio, the ratio of the magnetic moment to the angular momentum, which is the theme of my concern. It has been my life’s effort to try to get the physics community to see sense and recognize that the aether exists and sets up this reaction. I see it as the very secret of how the vacuum stores the energy we ascribe to magnetic inductance. However, particle physicists have yielded to Paul Dirac’s relativistic interpretation; the invention of the word ‘spin’ to describe an anomaly concerned with magnetic moment. (As if a point charge, or a charge sphere, when spinning can possibly set up a magnetic moment! Really, the notion is ridiculous!)

    I was, of course, normally polite in the way I expressed myself when writing a scientific paper for referee consideration, but the referee rejections were not so considerate. Though I tried to avoid it, the very hint of the word ‘aether’ was like a red flag to a bull.

    So, where do we stand now with the Standard Model under challenge?

    As one can imagine, having my work rejected merely made me scrutinize the methods of QED and how the Standard Model gave that 1.001159… quantity.

    Well, I soon realized that here was a branch of physics where experiment was always ahead of theory. Nothing was ‘predicted’. Everything was ‘explained’ by inventing new features which complicated the story.

    I was researching anomalous energy aspects of magnetic induction in the 1950-53 years. That was experimental research. My related theoretical efforts began to tell me that there had to be an aether reacting to a magnetic field in storing magnetic field energy in the vacuum of space. Yet the aether was a taboo subject. Physicists had accepted it did not exist!

    It was in 1955 that an excellent book entitled Atomic and Nuclear Physics was published (author: Robert S. Shankland) and one reads on page 319 that the theoretical value of the magnetic moment of the electron in terms of the Bohr magneton is:

    1.001145

    which was compared with the experimental value of:

    1.001146 +/- 0.000006

    So, you see, in 1955, everything was well with theory versus experiment. One could hardly argue with such success.

    However, over the years, as the measurements became more precise, the theory had to be ‘doctored’ to keep up with state of the art. New ingredients such as ‘hadron corrections’ had to be invented to get the theory to conform. Accordingly, by 1986, one finds that the experimental value of the ‘magnetic moment of the electron’ in terms of the Bohr magneton has risen to:

    1.001 159 652 193(10)

    and, not surprisingly, the Standard Model was adapted to keep the theory in accord with the experimental findings.

    As you can see, in 31 years, the experimental value had moved more than two standard deviations up on the 1955 experimental value and well above the theoretical value of 1955 period, as reported by Shankland, but yet the theory rose to the challenge.

    Meanwhile, during these intervening years I had pondered on the question of why, in addition to the factor-of-2, the electron moving in restricted orbital motion (so-called ‘spin’) could exhibit a different magnetic moment to that it has in normal large radius orbital motion. My answer was that it is not the magnetic moment that is anomalous, but rather the angular momentum, the latter involving a slightly lower mass than applies for linear motion or motion in orbits of large radius. This was in contrast with the factor-of-2 anomaly, which arises from the magnetic moment being larger by that factor. For the ‘spin’ anomaly it is the angular momentum that is anomalous. What is excluded is the mass-energy of the field of the electron charge that lies outside a radius set by the value of the half-wavelength of the Compton frequency of the electron.

    One needed further to allow for the finite size of the electron charge, but, essentially, there is a wave resonance condition that sets the bounding radius severing the coupling of mass energy deployed in the electron field. My analysis, as was duly reported in the papers I did manage to have accepted for publication after referee scrutiny, are to be found in International Journal of Theoretical Physics 16, p. 401 (1977) and Lettere al Nuovo Cimento 32, p. 114 (1981).

    Based on a very simple theoretical presentation the latter paper showed how easy it was to derive an electron g-factor of:

    g = 2(1.001 159 652 200)

    and, it being published in 1981, this was five years before the above 1986 value was adopted by the International CODATA task force.

    So, you see, somehow those responsible for the Standard Model have contrived to tune their model to fit the experimental electron g-factor of the electron and my theoretical derivation sits there of record, but unnoticed, in the vast spectrum of published scientific literature. That, therefore, seems to be a closed chapter in scientific progress, but at least it serves as an introduction to the latest development, the failure of the Standard Model so far as the muon g-factor is concerned.

    THE MUON g-FACTOR

    The experimental breakthrough that challenges the Standard Model is reported in a Physical Review Letters paper dating from February 8, 2001 by H. N. Brown plus 67 other authors entitled: “Precise Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment”.

    It appears that it is possible to use a beam of muons moving at a speed which causes their mass to be increased by a factor in excess of 29 can be contained in orbit in a magnetic field and still serve at a speed close to that of light as a test source for measuring their anomalous g-factor with extremely high precision. The result obtained was:

    g/2 = 1.001 165 920 2 +/- 0.000 000 001 4

    which exceeds the theoretical Standard Model derivation, in spite of all its hadron corrections, by some 2.6 standard deviations. The verdict, according to the abstract of the paper, is that “This difference may be due to physics beyond the standard model”.

    So, here we are, repeating the scenario of the 1955 theory of the electron g-factor, as overtaken by more than two standard deviations in adapting to the experimental value adopted in 1986, having, it seems, to adapt theory to fit observations or devise new theory.

    So you may ask how I react to this situation, given my efforts of record concerning the electron g-factor. Well, here I confess to a little bewilderment, mainly because it seems so fantastic to extract such incredibly precise measurements from such a high energy scenario of muons in decay. However, accepting what so many physicists involved in the Brookhaven collaboration are claiming to have achieved, I will share my thoughts with readers of this Web Lecture.

    I begin by quoting two equations from my 1981 paper referenced above, namely Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 32, p. 114 (1981). It was entited ‘The Anomalous Magnetic Moment of the Electron’. The equations are:

    g = 2/(1 – δ)

    and:

    δ = 1/(2πα-1 + 4/31/2)

    Note that α is the fine-structure constant. Given that α-1 is a little below 137.036 you may verify that the equations indicate that the value of g for the electron is approximately that given by:

    g/2 = 1.001 159 646

    but note that that particular paper was written to take account of the fact that there is an effect owing to gravitational potential which increases this g-factor by some 5.281 parts in a billion. Furthermore, my theory had indicated that the fundamental value of α-1 is 137.0359148. This increases g to the value given by:

    g/2 = 1.001 159 652 200

    Addressing the problem of the muon, which I did in my papers in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 33, p. 481 (1982) and 37, p. 210 (1983), I reasoned (note the use of a minus sign to replace a plus sign) that the g-factor would be given by:

    g = 2/(1 – δ)

    and:

    δ = 1/(2πα-1 – 4/31/2)


    which, without the gravitational factor, yield:

    g/2 = 1.001 165 891 637

    and, with the gravitational factor, give:

    g/2 = 1.001 165 896 918

    That was very good indeed, given that the measured value reported by E. R. Cohen and B. N. Taylor in J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, 2, p. 663 (1973) was:

    1.001 165 895(27)

    Now, however, some 18 and more years on from that 1983 paper, I confront this new evidence, telling me that the experimental g/2 factor of the muon is:

    1.001 165 920 02 +/- 0.000 000 000 14

    and I can but react to this situation.

    So I invite the reader to share my thoughts on how to proceed as I now confront the problem.

    A SPECULATIVE DISCOURSE

    The fascination of the above analysis is the fact that the mere reversal of a plus sign to convert it to a minus sign has changed the g-factor formula of the electron to give it relevance to the muon. What does this really mean?

    Well, first of all, the 2π/α term was the dominant factor in separating the two mass values of the particle, the normal mass and the mass effective in the spin state. It was calculated by regarding the field energy of the particle located beyond the range of half the Compton wavelength as not contributing to the spin mass.

    In contrast, for the electron, the 4/31/2 term was the adjustment needed to offset that half wavelength from the centre of the electron charge, given that the electron cannot be a point charge. So far as that goes the physical model taken as the basis of the theory seemed in order.

    However, when we come to the muon, the model adopted required the half wavelength to be offset, not from the outer convex surface determined by the physical spherical form of the charge, but rather from the concave surface encountered by waves which penetrate through the charge and are reflected from the corresponding diametrically-opposite contour of the charge. That explains the sign polarity reversal, the plus becoming a minus.

    This is best depicted in Figure 1 below.

    [image not preserved: muong.gif]
    Fig. 1

    Note that the distance depicted as A is the λ/2 factor as applies to the elrectron, λ being the Compton electron wavelength. For the muon, albeit it on a much reduced scale, the distance B is the relevant λ/2 applicable using the Compton wavelength of the muon.

    Note further that the significance of the inner circle is the cavity radius of a resonant wave system depicted in regard to the electron in Figure 2 below. This figure is that shown on page 51 of the author’s book Aether Science Papers where the electron g-factor is also discussed.

    Fig. 2: Pattern of electron field cavity wave resonance

    The inner circle at the centre depicts the surface boundary of the muon charge and so the small arrow-marked lengths are the radius a of the muon charge. The field cavity formed between that radius a and the sphere depicted at an intermediate radius can be seen, from the geometry of the standing wave system shown, to cause that intermediate radius to be 31/2 times a. This therefore should complete the picture of the two wave systems, that of the electron and the muon.

    However, even if I can justify the above model for the muon in the state in which it demonstrates its g-factor, I confess some apprehension in using the Compton wavelength as applied to the muon. My concern arises from the fact that my whole aether theory is based on the aether having a rhythmic motion in universal synchrony at the frequency determined by equating the rest-mass energy of the electron and the photon energy that corresponds to the Compton wavelength of the electron. In short, whereas the electron wavelength is fundamental to the aether and so the aether can control the electron’s wavelength properties, for the muon to have a corresponding wavelength, shortened by a factor of some 207th (the inverse of the muon/electron mass ratio) of the electron wavelength, raises some doubts.

    I am inclined to accept that the rest-mass energy of the muon, if equated to that of a high energy photon, will indicate a very high frequency and a tiny wavelength, but do wonder how that specific wavelength can be kept constant as an influence regulating the properties of the muon in spin. I much prefer the thought that a resonance condition linked to the radius of the muon charge is involved in the determination of the precise value of the effective wavelength. With this in mind I explored the proposition that the Compton wavelength λ of the muon or a small integer multiple thereof could be an integer times that charge radius.

    Rigorous analysis revealed that 2λ was indeed quite close to being such an integer multiple, the latter integer being 2583, and this meant that the effective value of the term 2π/α was precisely 861.

    It is then a simple matter of algebra to reformulate the g-factor of the muon in a way more conducive to accurate calculation using a hand-held calculator. One obtains:

    g/2 = 1 + 1/(hc/e2 – 1 – 4/31/2)

    which is:

    g/2 = 1 + 1/(2π/α – 1 – 4/31/2)

    which we now suggest could, owing to a resonance, be:

    g/2 = 1 + 1/(861 – 1 – 4/31/2)

    Upon evaluation this is:

    g/2 = 1.001 165 921 6

    which compares with the recently measured value given above of:

    g/2 = 1.001 165 920 2 +/- 0.000 000 001 4

    So you see, the ‘aether’ interpretation of particle physics, as based on an understanding of the causal factors governing α, when combined with the Thomson charge formula, gives a result superior to that of the so-called Standard Model.

    It remains to be seen how even more precise measurement of the muon g-factor will affect what has been presented here, but, at least for the moment, all seems well.

    Note that the Thomson charge formula:

    mc2 = 2e2/3a

    gives the radius a of a charge e having a rest-mass m. In units of a the Compton wavelength h/mc is then hc/e2 multiplied by 3/2 and so you can see how a charge of radius a enclosed in a field cavity of radius 31/2a, when set alongside a λ/2 distance, will account for that term 4/31/2 in the above equations. Also, the 4/3 factor when divided into 861 gives 645.75 as a measure of (λ/2)a, which means that 2λ is 2583a or 3 times 861a. The resonant wave action of the muon involved overriding the formal value of 2π/α of 861.0225 and replacing it by 861.

    Now, in spite of this theory giving such a satisfactory result, one needs to point out that the muon form under test at Brookhaven was in a very artificial state. The muons were moving at relativistic speeds with their energies enhanced more than 29 times. Such muons would have to be in bare charge form, albeit then complying with the Thomson formula, but surely lacking the structure of the composite charge form by which their rest-mass value is determined as being 206.768 259(62) times that of the electron, which I see is a recent measurement of record in Particle Data (European Physical Journal 15, No. 1 (2000) at p. 314).

    I can but therefore refer to my 1983 paper entitled ‘The Mass of The Muon’, where I showed, using the same theoretical principles as discussed above, that the muon in its low energy structured state will have a mass in electron mass terms of:

    206.768 307 8

    which is comfortably within the estimated range of error of the measurement.

    I note that the Standard Model offers no explanation of the mass of the muon.

    CONCERNING PARTICLE LIFETIMES

    Since the question of particle lifetime may arise where, as in the Brookhaven experiment, muons are travelling at speeds augmenting their mass by a factor of 29 it is appropriate to comment on the phenomenon involved. The aether has an underworld of a quantum-electrodynamic activity in which electron-positron pairs and muon-pairs are ever active. The electron does have a finite lifetime of the order of 10-13 seconds, whereas the muon has a finite lifetime measured in microseconds. The former is less in evidence because when the electron decays it is replaced by another electron and so the phenomenon is only manifested by experiments in which electrons are assumed to ‘tunnel’ through potential barriers. In fact the electrons decay into the aether on one side of the potential barrier and reappear from the aether on the other side of that barrier.

    The muon lifetime can be derived theoretically from first principles as is shown in my 1980 book Physics Unified at p. 146. The theory indicated a lifetime of 2.1973 microseconds, whereas the measured value (1976) was:

    2.197134 +/-0.000077 microseconds

    Now, when a muon moves at very high speed, such as that applicable in the Brookhaven experiment, it is accompanied by an entourage of muon pairs in measure, on average, equal to the mass-energy added as kinetic energy. Accordingly, its chance of decay changes, because the muon runs around and hides amongst the muons in its field entourage by partnering, as it were, one of the muons of opposite polarity. If ‘hit’ by a decay transient when so partnered it will merely annihilate its partner and a new muon pair will reappear nearby. If ‘hit’ when it stands in isolation, then it will decay into an electron in the normal way. The odds of such a ‘hit’ therefore diminish as the mass-energy represented by that muon field increase, in a direct inverse relationship so that the muon lifetime ‘appears’ to be time-dilated according to the formula we refer to as the ‘relativistic’ mass increase, even though the physics involved owes nothing to Albert Einstein.

    Now, that said, it is appropriate to speculate as to why the g-factors of the electron and the muon are different. Referring to the above figure one sees that the wave resonance for the electron is assumed to be confined to a cavity region between a field cavity enclosing the charge and the sphere separation the spin mass energy from the external field energy. In contrast the wave resonance assigned to the muon is assumed to extend through the central field cavity region. Note that the former, electron resonance state, involves waves reflected between a concave outer surface and a convex inner surface, whereas the muon resonance involves waves reflected between two concave surfaces. The former is seen as a less stable state and this is consistent with the electron being relatively short-lived compared with the muon. Accordingly, I suspect that the particle lifetime determines which resonance condition is adopted, but this is a feature of the theory that can but be somewhat speculative at this time. It is, after all, one step to decode what is hidden by the numbers involved, the secret behind those specific g-factor values, and another step to find the correct interpretation of that result. I can but leave that as a source of inspiration for others.

    A NOTE CONCERNING GRAVITY

    Astute readers may have noticed that, with regard to the muon, I have not introduced the correction for gravitational potential that was applied to the electron. The reason for this needs some explanation.

    There is something quite unusual about the experimental physics used in measuring the electron g-factor and the muon g-factor. The theoretical physics treatment applies the methods of Standard Model to both, as if they have a common basis, with one simply having more mass than the other. Yet the electron g-factor does not involve measurements in which the electron mass has been increased nearly 30-fold, as applies to the reported muon experiment, owing to its acceleration to ultra-high energy at close to the speed of light. This may not seem to be of much importance, given that the experiment allows the g-factor to be measured with such high precision, but herein may be hidden the key which unlocks a door giving access to something having a truly fundamental bearing upon gravitation. It may be something that strikes a death blow to the heart of Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity.

    Simply stated, take note that we have in issue three energy components each of which manifests itself as mass. Firstly, there is the mass of the energy bounded within that field cavity system centred on the electron or the muon. This is the ‘spin’ mass. Secondly, there is the mass of the energy of the particle that lies outside that cavity and which, together with the spin mass, accounts for the normal mass of the particle that we sense for translational motion, including normal orbital motion if the path radius is high in relation to the Compton wavelength. Thirdly, there is the extra mass arising from the kinetic energy acquired by a particle in moving at speed, a mass which, in the case of the reported muon g-factor measurements, is 29 times that of basic mass of the particle.

    Now, viewing this from the background of my aether theory and its extension to give account of gravity, I have good reason to believe that only the spin mass is subject to the force of gravity. The reason is that the spin motion is a quantum condition involving a jitter motion in which the particle moves at the Compton electron frequency in a very small orbit in synchrony with the corresponding motion of other matter and it is balanced dynamically by a graviton system. The latter sets up the force of gravity. In contrast, the added mass energy effective in translational motion is that of a physical field system that is too dispersed for it to share the ‘spin’ motion which induces the gravitational reaction.

    The result is that ‘spin’ mass is slightly less than the normal mass and so we have that anomalous component of the electron g/2 factor. However, owing to there being a gravitational potential effective here on Earth, and owing to the fact that the energy associated with gravitational potential is negative, Nature keeps the energy books balanced by keeping a small amount of thermal energy at the seat of the particles subject to that gravitational potential, and this, in fact, as referenced on the electric charge form of the underlying aether accounts for the 2.7K temperature in the Earth’s locality. That is all explained in my 1980 book Physics Unified pp. 175-177 as is the fact that the gravitational potential prevalent here on Earth is almost wholly attributable to the mass of the Earth and the mass of the Sun. It amounts to 9.493×108 joules as between the Sun plus Earth and one kilogram of matter here on Earth. Half of this is effective in augmenting the non-spin mass of the electron as tested in our Earth laboratory. Therefore, division of this energy by the speed of light squared, that is division by 8.987×1016 m2/s4 gives us the factor 5.281×10-9. As we have seen above, the anomalous electron g/2-factor will therefore be increased by this small amount owing to the effect of gravity.

    Now, when we consider the muon, we have the problem that the spin mass-energy is overwhelmed by a factor of nearly 30 owing to the energy added in bringing the muon up to the speed associated with the 3.09 GeV beam energy. This form of added energy is that possessed by the induction a statistical presence of virtual lepton pairs, positive and negative muon-sized particles that feature in the quantum-electrodynamic background of space. Such an energy form is not part of the system of matter that is involved in gravitation. It is non-gravitational and so the muon of the Brookhaven tests is not subject to g/2-factor enhancement by that 5.281×10-9 factor. The energy does exhibit the normal g-factor properties because each individual virtual muon still has its field cavity system and stands as a particle subject to segregated quantum and non-quantum states of motion alongside the core muon. Yet only the latter particle senses the effect of gravity and so one can only justify adding about 3% of that factor to augment the g/2 value. As this is less than 2 parts in 1010 and the experimental error of the Brookhaven measurement is 14 parts in 1010, the case presented in this Web Lecture holds.

    However, the point of special interest is that here, in the experiment under discussion, we see a route forward if one wishes to challenge Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity. That theory will not tolerate the argument that gravitational mass and inertial mass can be distinguished. Yet, here, we have seen reason for saying that energy added by motion, the energy that augments mass upon division by c2, will exhibit inertial effects but not gravitational effects. That is something that warrants attention by theoretical physicists intent on probing physics to its limits in their search for their ‘holy grail’, the Unified Field Theory.

    CONCLUSION

    Now, in conclusion, I will not summarize what has been said above. Instead, I will end by referring to a communication I received by E-mail even as I was compiling this Physics Lecture for posting on the Web.

    The message was sent to me on February 23, 2001 by Richard Geist who lives in Michigan, USA and I hope he will not mind me quoting two relevant passages:

    “I wanted to make sure it had come to your attention that a new measurement of the g-factor has been reported (g=1.0011659203) by the Brookhaven National Laboratory. The short article in U.S. News and World Report (2/19/01) calls it “…the first sign of error in the biggest theory of all, the so-called Standard Model….”

    You may recall I ordered a copy of “Physics Unified” in August of 1999 and you were kind enough to sign it for me. …. Lastly, I was fortunate enough to obtain a used copy of “Physics Without Einstein”. I know that with your remaining copies of this book you wanted them to be placed into libraries, so I expect it will not be received as good news that libraries are dropping the book. But I wanted to assure you that you have a long-term proponent of your theory. I like to describe your efforts as that of the consumate engineer trying to solve a problem. Your theory is geared towards predicting known quantities (an aim atypical of physicists), paying close attention to inconsistencies in prior theories and unexplained experimental findings, logically building upon prior theoretical efforts (the aether theories abandoned after Einstein). The systematic, logical nature of your approach – and incredible attention to detail – should be evident to anyone with an open mind willing to take the time to study your work. But that is it in a nutshell, is it not: finding open minded people, able and willing to take the time to study your work is a rarity.”

    All I can say is: “Thank you, Richard Geist, and may others, particularly those who build their physics interest on an engineering background, come to see the creative forces of Nature as building our universe from an energy background rather than from a complex system of mathematical symbols woven into a multi-dimensional mould that defies imagination. I have heard it said by adherents of relativistic doctrine that “God is a Mathematician” but the skills needed to build the world in seven days are closer to those of the engineer.

    Meanwhile, however, I just hope that one or two of those 68 authors of the Physics Review Letters paper reporting the muon g-factor measurement will scan through this Web Lecture and learn about something that rivals the Standard Model. Hopefully, having regard to the comments of Richard Geist, this will be before all of those library copies of my book Physics without Einstein are committed to oblivion.


    The author’s E-Mail address is:


  • PHYSICS NO. 8

    LECTURE NO. 8

    TO BE ADDED



  • PHYSICS NO. 9

    LECTURE NO. 9

    TO BE ADDED



  • PHYSICS NO. 10

    LECTURE NO. 10

    TO BE ADDED



  • ENERGY SCIENCE UPDATE: ENERGY SCIENCE ESSAYS: 2000 SERIES

    ENERGY SCIENCE UPDATE

    Until August 29 this web site had not been updated since May 1999. This was because I, the author, had diverted my attentions to an experimental project. That pursuit is still holding my attention and it will be a little while yet before I can develop these pages further on a regular basis. However, owing to one interested reader having expressed a little humour in sending me the odd E-Mail message asking if I had passed away, I did on August 29, 2000 launch four new web page items. Two of these, notably the third and fourth items, are new and of particular importance in the realm of physics, but the third will interest those concerned with new free energy motor technology, whereas the first is essentially a repetition, for the physics community and those interested in radio science, of an earlier message in these ENERGY SCIENCE web pages. Other Essays have now been added, the last on November 10, 2000.

    ENERGY SCIENCE ESSAYS: 2000 SERIES

    ESSAY 2000: ARE AETHER WAVES REAL?
    ESSAY 2001: IS THERE A REACTING AETHER?
    ESSAY 2002: THE CONSTANT OF GRAVITATION
    ESSAY 2003: THE THEORY OF GRAVITATION

    I later added:
    ESSAY 2004: THE SWISS M-L CONVERTER
    ESSAY 2005: UNEXPLAINED PHENOMENON
    ESSAY 2006: WHY HIGGS?
    ESSAY 2007: COSMIC MUD OR COSMIC MUDDLE?
    ESSAY 2008: SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND THE SUPERGRAVITON
    On February 20, 2001, I began to build further on what has already been published and addressed the set of questions posed by a panel of US physicists and astronomers working under the aegis of the National Academy of Sciences.
    PHYSICS LECTURE No. 5: THE PHYSICS OF CREATION: THE EARLY UNVERSE
    PHYSICS LECTURE No. 6: 11 KEY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE UNIVERSE

    Now, on February 28, 2001, I add the following:
    PHYSICS LECTURE No. 7: THE STANDARD MODEL AND THE MUON g-FACTOR



  • THE ASPDEN LECTURES

    THE ASPDEN LECTURES

    These are science lectures in which you will learn about
    gravitation, magnetism and begin to understand how the
    universe was created. You will be introduced to a limitless
    source of ‘free energy’ which we can harness to meet our
    future energy needs without polluting our planet. It is
    limitless because Nature conserves energy and, if we use the
    energy Nature feeds to us in a consumable form, Nature has a
    way of recapturing that energy as we shed it and reprocessing
    it through its sub-quantum underworld to feed it back into
    its original form. Yes, you will learn to question what you
    read in contemporary textbooks which say that there are
    man-made laws preventing Nature from working in that way. But, as
    you learn, you will, I hope, become all the more interested
    in what I have to say, because it affects your future and the
    destiny of mankind.

    Amongst the earlier Lectures that I shall be including in this section of my Web pages, you may find Lecture No. 5 of special interest as it will show you how the solar system and the Earth-Moon system was created. However, if you have the temerity to say, as do some scientists, that theories mean nothing unless they predict what has not been discovered, then go to Lecture No. 6 and see what is evolving on the cosmolological scene.

    If you need to see technological consequences emerging from the Energy Science discussed here then, be assured, I will be moving more in that direction as I update the Energy Science Report section of these Web pages. These Lectures and those which will be added are for those having a general interest in science who want to see the orthodoxy being challenged.

    LECTURE NO. 1

    2020 VISION

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE No. 1

    THE CASE FOR THE SUB-ELECTRON

    LECTURE No. 2

    WHY EINSTEIN WAS WRONG: PART I

    LECTURE NO. 3

    COSMOLOGY UNDER SCRUTINY

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE No. 3

    CONCERNING PULSARS

    LECTURE NO. 4

    THE SCHUSTER-WILSON HYPOTHESIS

    LECTURE NO. 5

    BINARY VISION?

    LECTURE NO. 6

    PROTON CREATION

    LECTURE NO. 7

    THE INVENTION OF HANS COLER

    LECTURE NO. 8

    THE ADAMS-ASPDEN MOTOR PATENT

    LECTURE NO. 9

    SUPERGRAVITONS AND COLD FUSION

    LECTURE NO. 10

    THE OCEAN OF SPACE

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE No. 10

    AN ANTENNA WITH ANOMALOUS RADIATION PROPERTIES

    LECTURE NO. 11

    THE HUBBLE CONSTANT: ITS ‘FREE ENERGY’ ROLE

    LECTURE NO. 12

    WHY HAWKING IS WRONG!

    LECTURE NO. 13

    EINSTEIN’S QUESTION: WHAT IS NUCLEAR FUSION?

    LECTURE NO. 14

    COLD FUSION: A WAR STORY

    LECTURE NO. 15

    ENERGY FROM FUSION: THE OPINION OF A PATENT ATTORNEY

    LECTURE NO. 16

    50 YEARS AND ON WE GO

    LECTURE NO. 17

    THE MAGIC OF MIRRORS

    LECTURE NO. 18

    THE EDDY CURRENT LOSS ANOMALY

    LECTURE NO. 19

    THERMOMAGNETIC POWER GENERATION

    LECTURE NO. 20

    DEBATE ON CREATION

    LECTURE NO. 21

    THE EXPERIMENTAL PATHWAY TO NEW SOURCES OF ENERGY

    LECTURE NO. 22

    THE RABBIT AND SCHROEDINGER’S CAT

    LECTURE NO. 23

    MENTAL INERTIA AND NEW ENERGY TECHNOLOGY

    LECTURE NO. 24

    THE ETHER – AN ASSESSMENT

    LECTURE NO. 25

    THE MARINOV MOTOR

    LECTURE NO. 26

    THE CONTEMPORARY AETHER

    LECTURE NO. 27

    OUR FUTURE ENERGY SOURCE – THE VACUUM!

    LECTURE NO. 28

    SPACE, ENERGY AND CREATION

    LECTURE NO. 29

    ENERGY CHALLENGES FOR THE 21st CENTURY

    LECTURE NO. 30

    THE ASPDEN EFFECT

    LECTURE NO. 31

    THE ENGINEER’S ANATHEMA: PERPETUAL MOTION

    LECTURE NO. 32

    PIONEER 10/11 GRAVITATIONAL ANOMALY

    ******

    Quotation from the 1897 English translation of Flammarion’s book

    ‘POPULAR ASTRONOMY’:

    The sun is but a star; he will meet with the fate of his sisters; suns, like worlds, are born to die. … May we conclude, then, that in these successive endings the universe will one day become an immense dark tomb? No: otherwise it would have already have become so during a past eternity. There is in nature something else besides blind matter; an intellectual law of progress governs the whole creation; the forces which rule the universe cannot remain inactive. The stars will rise from their ashes. The collision of ancient wrecks causes new flames to burst forth, and the transformation of motion into heat creates nebulae and worlds. Universal death shall never reign.

    *
  • LECTURE NO. 26

    LECTURE NO. 26

    The Contemporary Aether

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1996


    This is the text of a paper written as a contribution to a conference held at the University of Perugia in Italy in 1996 to pay tribute to the memory of Rene Descartes.

    It was later (1999) published at pp.291-307 of ‘La Scienza e i Vortici del Dubbio’, Pubblicazione dell’Universita degli Studi di Perugia (ISBN88-8114-996-6)

    Introduction

    Although 20th century scientific philosophy has sought to banish
    the aether and outlaw it from our modern civilisation, that effort has
    failed. The great contributions of philosophers of earlier centuries,
    giving us recognition of the aether, and notably by Rene Descartes,
    live on, nothwithstanding acceptance of the four-space notions of the
    theory of relativity. The aether remains the essential fabric of
    space, the canvas on which Nature has painted the glorious picture of
    the world and the universe we see around us. This paper will simply
    point to one scientific phenomenon which reveals a direct
    manifestation of the aether and shows us how to tap into its power.
    This paper also provides a bibliographic listing of this author’s 20th
    century discoveries concerning the aether, this being research which
    has been published in spite of the opposition by those who prefer to
    accept the virtual reality images which stem from Einstein’s
    doctrines. The key property of the real aether is its universal
    rhythm, its universal time keeping, as enforced by a phase-lock
    between its quantum properties. This property is manifested by aether
    in rotation because the phase-lock involves one-way energy transfer
    from aether to matter in company with an electric charge induction by
    rotation, neither of which feature in Einstein’s vision of the
    properties of space.

    Descartes was the first to bring the aether into science, by
    postulating that it had mechanical properties. Descartes assumed that
    the aether comprises particles that are continually in motion, but as
    there is no empty space, he inferred that those particles are
    continually moving into places vacated by other aether particles which
    are themselves in motion. Overall, the motion was that of vortices as
    the particles were all part of a great machine, but one which we can
    now examine at a microscopic quantum level and see as a kind of
    universal clock mechanism.

    Sadly, however, towards the end of the 19th century, the
    mechanistic aether seems to have lost favour, because the aether came
    to be viewed, not as a clock which kept everything in the universe
    together in a rhythmic dance, but rather only as the ‘sea’ rippled by
    light waves. The luminiferous aether concept became the dominant
    consideration. The aether was not deemed to be the bonding agency
    which wedded all matter in the universe together in an energy machine.
    Electromagnetic waves and their finite speed were seen as the
    signature that proved the aether existed and, once that signature
    became blurred, there were those who broke away from the aether faith.

    It was in the early part of the 20th century that a French
    astronomer, Alexandre Veronnet, made a bid to arouse interest in an
    ‘etheron’ particle picture of the aether, bringing the Bohr magneton
    into that ‘clock mechanism’, but wave mechanics had a different style
    of presentation and the aether began to sink into its own sea of
    oblivion.

    Einstein was the champion who led the aether dissenters. As
    philosopher Bertrand Russell explained:

    ”
    Empty space, to Descartes, is as absurd as happiness
    without a sentient being who is happy. Leibnitz, on
    somewhat different grounds, also believed in the plenum,
    but he maintained that space is merely a system of
    relations. On this subject there was a famous controversy
    between him and Newton. The controversy remained
    undecided until the time of Einstein, whose theory gave
    the victory to Leibnitz.”

    History of Western Philosophy, 1961 Edition,
    Published by Allen & Unwin, page 87.

    Well, I now submit here that the controversy is far from over.
    Space is not merely a system of ‘relations’. It is a real mechanism,
    albeit one that is, as is all matter, rooted in the electrical form of
    the constituent aether particles.

    The way forward from the Einstein diversion requires that we
    heed what another British philosopher had to say about Einstein’s
    theory.

    “The effects of rotation are among the most widespread
    phenomena of the apparent world, exemplified in the most
    gigantic nebulae and in the minutest molecules. The most
    obvious fact about rotational effects is their apparent
    disconnection from outlying phenomena. Rotation is the
    stronghold of those who believe that in some sense there
    is an absolute space to provide a framework of dynamical
    axes. Newton cited it in support of this doctrine. The
    Einstein theory in explaining gravitation has made
    rotation an entire mystery.”

    The above was quoted from p. 356 of ‘The Principle of
    Relativity’ in the book ‘Alfred North Whitehead: An Anthology’,
    published by Cambridge University Press, 1953. (A further quote at the
    end of this text is from p. 357).

    So, I introduce the subject of this paper by asserting that we
    must look to ‘rotation’ to see how we can revive belief in the aether,
    and I note that vortices and rotation are complementary aspects of the
    universal mechanism that is tuned to the spirit of Descartes.

    Vacuum Spin

    Can the aether spin? If those ‘vortices’ or those aether
    particles describing minute circular orbital motion, as part of that
    universal clock we call the aether, can store energy, as by expanding
    their orbits so as to move faster, then we have territory to explore.
    If, further, those aether particles can, by analogy with matter, group
    together to form structure, but by keeping their mutual spacing, then
    we have the makings of a geometry which determines a dimensionless
    physical constant connected with both energy quanta and that aether.
    That gives us a larger aether form that we can explore in terms of
    spin, a form which might set up pulsating ripples as surrounding
    aether is disturbed by that structure in rotation. This suggests a
    route to the photon, linked to the theoretical derivation of the fine-structure constant, the latter comprising Planck’s constant, the
    fundamental unitary electric charge and the speed of light.

    On a larger scale, maybe large spherically-formed expanses of
    aether can be set in rotation, as with body Earth or the Sun, all
    leading to interesting properties revealing the role of the aether.

    On an intermediate scale, there are other possible spin forms of
    aether. Remember that we can move through the aether, as if it does
    not exist, and so aether in spin can move through a solid wall to
    transport its action from one side of that wall to the other. Yes,
    there is evidence of that to be seen in the thunderball phenomenon,
    which becomes a candidate for research enquiry into the aether. There
    are other mysteries connected with atmospheric electrical phenomena
    and invariably there is something spinning, as in the funnel of a
    tornado. Indeed, observers have seen the tornado travel one way when
    the prevailing wind direction was in the opposite direction!
    Rotation, therefore, offers the logical entry point for a fascinating
    study of the aether.

    Now, my main aim here is to interest the reader in my theory as
    a whole, but that can only be by individual study of my many published
    papers and other writings on the subject. The appended bibliographic
    listing is, therefore, the primary contribution I make in presenting
    this paper.

    In 1977 I was invited to explain my aether theory to the
    students and staff of the Physics Department at Cardiff University in
    Wales [113]. My argument was that the aether contains electric
    charge, as needed to sustain displacement according to Maxwell’s
    theory. Charge has the dimensions of mass M, length L, and time T,
    taken together with the electrical dimension of the dielectric
    constant k. The question at issue was that of understanding how, if
    the aether could develop spherical pockets that could rotate inside
    enveloping aether, its angular rotation or spin would relate to
    electric charge. If I assumed that a uniform charge density would be
    induced in proportion to the angular velocity of vacuum spin I found
    that the aether would need to exhibit a uniform mass density to keep
    the dimensions to balance. In fact, I developed the relationship
    between vacuum spin, the radial electric field and the angular
    momentum of aether spin, together with their energy connection.

    charge density σ ………. M1/2L-3/2T-1k1/2
    angular velocity ω ………. T-1
    mass density ρ ………. ML-3
    (σ2/ω2ρ) ………. k

    I was aiming at the objective of showing that the energy added owing to that rotation would be both the electric field energy stored by charge displacement and an equal amount of kinetic energy.

    The easiest way in which to explain this ‘vacuum spin’ induction is to imagine that all space exhibits a quantum activity as if everywhere there is electric charge keeping in universal phase in minute orbital loop motion at the same frequency. Here we need to picture large spheres of aether as capable of spin at an angular frequency ω and see every charge in that aether as a quantum unit having a microcosmic orbital spin motion at a very high frequency compared with ω. This latter frequency is the Compton electron frequency (Ω/2π) and it corresponds to the photon energy needed to create an electron. Quantum mechanics involves linear harmonic oscillations and that tells us that the controlling medium has a linear restoring force rate when displaced. An electric charge e in the aether, as needed in Maxwell’s displacement theory, complies with a force rate of 4πNe2, where there are N charges e in unit volume of space, all neutralized overall by a universally-constant density of background charge of opposite polarity. Here I use the c.g.s system of units, in which an electric field of strength E stores energy density E2/8π in vacuum of unit dielectric constant, owing to Ee being equal to 4πNe2.

    This restoring force rate determines the jitter frequency of
    the vacuum state by the equation:

    8πN2e2 = ρ(Ω)2 …… (1)

    where ρ is the effective mass density of the aether, which is
    proportional to N. In the equation 8π has replaced 4π because, to
    assure dynamic balance, the orbital radius of the motion is half of
    the displacement, which spans the orbit diameter.

    Now consider the superimposed effect in a sphere of aether which
    spins at the angular frequency ω. If the spin is in the same sense (parallel axes of spin) as the quantized orbital motion, then to keep the phase-lock as between enveloping aether and aether in spin, the
    equation (1) becomes:

    8π(N-δN)e2 = (ρ/N)(Ω – ω)2 ……. (2)

    where ρ/N is constant.

    From (1) and (2) we can deduce the relationship:

    δN/N = 2ω/Ω …………. (3)

    This means that δN charges e per unit volume of that aether
    sphere are displaced from it owing to spin ω.

    Conversely, if we can feed electrostatic energy into that sphere
    to displace that amount of charge, the phase-lock asserted by the
    external aether will promote the spin at ω. Or, if we can get the
    aether sphere to spin by other means, the phase-lock asserted by the
    external aether will promote charge induction. Once the external
    aether has to assert itself to hold that phase-lock as between
    different regions of aether, it does work and that is our ‘free
    energy’ input!

    Suppose we can contain some positive ions into a small sphere.
    The aether will see this as producing a radial electric field from the
    centre of that sphere and it will develop a charge displacement to
    neutralize that core charge and effectively transfer the charge effect
    to the surface of the sphere. Now, this means that N has been changed
    in that sphere and so the natural frequency of quantum jitter will
    change. The aether charges lying outside that sphere will, however,
    not allow this loss of synchronism and very powerful electrostatic
    forces are asserted to ensure that the synchronism holds. The vast
    amount of energy sustaining the quantum jitter at the Compton electron
    frequency in the aether of enveloping space will be pooled with that
    of the rotating aether sphere to keep that state of synchronism. The
    relative frequency is what is held constant. Thus, if N increases in
    the sphere to cause the local value of Ω to increase, then the offset of ω, will assure that synchronous condition. In other words, rotation at ω follows as a consequence of the phase-lock constraint.

    This imports energy from the aether.

    Owing to the linear harmonic motion properties of the quantum world, there is equipartition of energy in the sense that for every unit of electric field energy stored there is an equal unit of kinetic energy stored. Therefore, by adding one joule of energy in one pulsation of the ‘vacuum spin’ state we receive ‘gratis’ one further unit of energy drawing on the universal energy priming of the aether activity at that jitter angular frequency Ω.

    It has therefore become an interesting task, technologically, to
    reiterate this action at a rapid pulse rate, given that we can, in
    fact, set up that priming radial electric field or the spin in an
    effective way. This is what now takes this aether subject from the
    realm of oblivion and, without stopping in the arena of philosophical
    debate, progressing directly into the field of technology, where the
    aether can be seen to serve us as an energy source.

    As long ago as 1960 I published my first account of this ‘vacuum
    spin’ induction theory [107] and evaluated the spin charge density in
    relation to spin angular frequency ω. The formula gave the charge
    density as 4.781 esu/cc per rad/s of spin (page 32 of that reference).
    In terms of coulombs, one micro-coulomb per cc would correspond to
    aether spin at 6,000 rpm. I note that one micro-coulomb per cc.
    squeezed into a sphere of 7 cm. diameter corresponds to an energy
    density of the order of 109 J/m3.

    I now note that the experimental data of record in recently
    granted U.S. patents [116, 117] concern a method of holding 500 J in
    an abnormal glow discharge which is trapped between electrodes, close
    to the cathode, and probably confined to a volume of a fraction of 1
    cc, which also corresponds to 109 J/m3 of energy density.

    In my 1977 lecture paper [113] I explained how the Sun was created by gravitational attraction between protons setting up a positive core charge which produced a radial electric field. That charge had the density of (G)1/2 times the 1.4 gm per cc mass density of
    the Sun. Put G as 6.67×10-8 in c.g.s units and one obtains 3.6×10-4 esu/cc, which develops a vacuum spin of 7.5×10-5 rad/s or one revolution every 23 hours. If the whole angular momentum of the solar system as it is today were to be put back into the Sun, then, as that paper [113] shows, the Sun would spin at 8.3×10-5 rad/s or one revolution every 21 hours. My 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’ [112] put on record a more formal account.

    This is close enough to explain how the solar system got its angular momentum from the phase-locked aether and support the proposition that energy can be shed by this ‘vacuum spin’ activity of the aether and transferred to matter. Our experiments can tap the aether energy in the same way, simply by setting up a radial electric field inside a conductive medium that can sustain the build up of the charge displacement.

    In 1983 I presented the theory of ‘vacuum spin’ at a conference
    held by the U.K. Institute of Physics at Oxford University. See pages
    179-184 of reference [29]. I explained how the known facts about the
    energy density of thunderballs pointed to an aether in which there
    could be energy storage by spin.

    I referred to Altschuler et al. of the High Altitude Lab. in
    Boulder, Colorado (1970) and their suggestion in Nature [114] that
    thunderballs might be nuclear powered because they all had an energy
    density in the range 2 to 5×109 J/m3. This is the same energy density as mentioned above!

    My 1983 paper went further because I knew that if the Earth shared its spin with the aether then that would involve two systems each neutralizing one another in electric charge terms but in a way
    which would still produce a magnetic field. The Earth’s magnetic
    field is seated in the charge displaced in, and rotating with, the
    Earth, but the vacuum charge involved in that aether spin cannot
    develop a magnetic field because it is the reference against which
    magnetic action is measured.

    From knowledge of the strength of the Earth’s magnetism I could
    calculate the Earth’s vacuum spin charge and it was found to have a
    value which would constrain vacuum spin, whether in thunderballs,
    tornadoes or in our motor experiments, to have an energy density
    estimated as being 2.37×109 J/m3. See page 183 of reference [29].

    Proof that there is an Aether

    If we can get energy from vacuous space, energy in excess of that we can store by setting up electric or magnetic fields, then that proves there is something in space that stands apart from matter. That ‘something’ is the aether.

    Now, I know of several ways in which this ‘free energy’ scenario
    can be demonstrated. Indeed, it is the subject of my primary research
    interest at this time. However, I will take up the theme that follows
    from my 1983 paper [29]. It refers in its penultimate paragraph to
    Nobel Laureate Kapitza’s efforts to produce thunderballs for
    application in triggering fusion reactions [121]. Then, in the last
    sentence, I declared in my paper that:

    ”
    It remains to devise and conduct experiments aimed at
    inducing this (vacuum) spin condition by using radial
    electric fields, so as to verify and perhaps apply the
    phenomenon to useful ends.”

    That was my outlook in 1983. I can now quote the research achievement of Dr. Kiril Chukanov. He reports [119]:

    ”
    I first produced experimental proof that artificially
    created ball lightning could produce energy for practical
    needs in 1987 in Bulgaria.”

    After describing his experimental set-up, which involved an
    ionized gas discharge in a quartz tube, he wrote:

    ”
    I experienced great difficulty in evaluating the amount
    of power produced by the quantum plasma macro-object, but
    my rough estimation was three to four times more power
    output than that being supplied by the (input of the high
    frequency signal-generating) lamp.”

    By 1990 he had taken his research project into Sunnivale,
    California and his onward reporting on his production of excess energy
    showed that he had measured heat generated in a water jacket enclosing
    the evacuated glow discharge chamber used in his tests. In his 1994
    book ‘Final Quantum Revelation’ he reports a 900 watt rate of excess
    energy generation using electrodes of some 3 cm separation. The
    vacuum, or rather, aether spin in a filamentary discharge region
    having a volume of, say, 3 cc, drawing in ‘excess’ energy at the rate
    of 109 J/m3, would need to take about 3 seconds to regenerate each action cycle to give the 900 watt excess output.

    Chukanov mentions a 3 second duration of the burst discharge before the discharge, in writhing like a snake, spread to the sides and touched the walls of the containing tube and caused overheating.

    Professor Chernetskii and his team of researchers in Russia have
    also produced excess energy at power levels in a self-sustaining
    plasma discharge device, claiming 4 to 5 times electrical power output
    compared with power input. This was reported in 1989 in a Novosti
    Press Agency Press Release [115].

    Dr. Wingate Lambertson at a conference in 1994 in Denver, Colorado reported similar levels of power gain from a solid-state discharge device formed as a specially-fabricated thyristor [120].

    Recently reported Canadian research in 1995 by Dr. Paulo Correa and Alexandra Correa [116 & 117] has established a sustained excess power generation of 500 J per pulse in a cold-cathode discharge confined to an abnormal glow region, with a prospective 40 megawatt-hour electrode lifetime. The Correa technology delivers electrical d.c. output steadily at several hundred volts and a power gain that is also of the order of 5:1 over d.c. input at similar voltage level.

    The Correa technology will undoubtedly lead us forward on the quest to
    exploit energy sourced in the aether, especially as it is already
    well-patented in the USA.

    Several other reports of excess energy production are now of record in the scientific and patent literature and one needs, therefore, to be prepared for the aether to reappear into our scientific philosophy, as being the only source that can supply that excess energy.

    When the consequences of these developments and onward research
    on this new energy theme become generally known and accepted, the
    aether will reclaim its rightful place in physical science and then
    acquire a stature which will dwarf its early role in history.
    Meanwhile, we need to be a little patient and watch events as the
    interest grows and conferences on the subject as well as new journals
    devoted to these matters escalate in numbers.

    Methodology in Science?

    In conclusion, it is submitted that science has lost its
    methodology. Technology has needed science to point the way forward
    towards new sources of energy that are non-polluting, but science has
    faltered. Sensible methodoloy would have been tolerant of retention
    of the aether as the foundation on which to build the material world.
    Even though it is academically interesting to see how far we can go
    without using a word meaning the ‘aether’, it was not at all wise for
    science to reject the concept totally and without reservation. Now,
    in the present circumstances, too many of the scientists who build
    their hopes on physical theory are committed to the denial that there
    is a universal timing mechanism governing everything. They deny the
    possibility that energy can be delivered to us by an aether, which, if
    seen at all, is deemed wholly passive in its role. As a result,
    instead of leading our thought processes and guiding us forward into
    a new technological era, building on knowledge of the aether, the
    scientific philosophers of today have crippled the mental agility of
    younger generations and made progress so much more difficult.

    For my part, in writing this paper, my main objective is to draw
    attention to the bibliographical record of papers I have written in
    connection with aether theory. I say there is an aether and I use it
    throughout my research to explain much in physics that has otherwise
    remained unexplained.

    I have been obstructed in my efforts by the prejudice of orthodox belief and have had many more papers rejected than have been accepted, especially in my earlier years of endeavour, from 1955 to 1975.

    I here acknowledge my gratitude to the Italian Institute of Physics for their more tolerant review of several of my papers that were published thereafter in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, that is, until the demise of that periodical. I think it was a great pity that the Italian Institute of Physics ceased publication of their Letter periodical at the end of 1985. Indeed, I almost wonder whether there was any special significance in the fact that two of my papers, referenced [46 & 47] in the appended list, featured together at the end in that last issue!

    The future ahead now rests, not with reason and philosophy, but
    with the forces of new technology, because pursuit of reason and logic
    is claimed as the exclusive province of those who insist on inventing
    descriptive language alien to Nature’s own method of revelation. In
    physical science we now destined to witness a slow reformation as
    technology leads the field and those amongst us who are wise enough to
    seek recovery of lost ground will hopefully do so by paying more
    respect to those who have pioneered a belief in the aether. We need
    to pay homage to the memory of Rene Descartes and, again quoting the
    words of philosopher Alfred North Whitehead, words he used by
    reference to Albert Einstein:

    The worst homage we can pay to genius is to accept uncritically formulations of truths which we owe to it.

    In my writings I have not criticised Rene Descartes. Indeed, in
    my book ‘Modern Aether Science’ [110] published in 1972, I have
    developed my theory on the basis of Descartes’ work, but as further
    advanced by that early-20th-century French astronomer, Alexandre
    Veronnet [118]. He quantized the aether particle motion in units of
    the Bohr magneton and partly anticipated what I was later to discover
    from my research as an analogy between aether and the ferromagnetic
    state. I go much further, even including the domain aspect of
    ferromagnetism. I came to picture each individual star nucleating
    within its own space domain as gravity appeared, akin to ferromagnetism appearing when a crystal inside iron cools through the Curie temperature.

    There is always the need to be critical as, so often, revision
    of one’s ideas and formulations is necessary, but, progressively, so
    long as we keep the main uncertainties in science as our target, we
    will solve all problems. The need for the phase-lock on a universal
    scale has been my main target, because it brings together magnetism,
    gravitation and the quantum connection as encapsulated in the fine-structure constant and from that flows the photon and the problem of
    duality with electromagnetic wave theory.

    I leave it to my papers, as listed in the following bibliography, to tell their own story and to prove that many of the
    secrets of the aether are now exposed.

    References

    Papers by H. Aspden

    [1] ‘The Law of Electrodynamics’, Journal of the Franklin Institute, 287, 179-183 (1969).
    [2] [Jointly with D. M. Eagles] ‘Aether Theory and the Fine Structure Constant’, Physics Letters, 41A, 423-424 (1972).
    [3] [Jointly with D. M. Eagles] ‘Calculation of the Proton Mass in a Lattice Model for the Aether’, Il Nuovo Cimento, 30A, 235-238 (1975).
    [4] ‘The Fresnel Formula applied to Empty Space’, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 15, 263-264 (1976).
    [5] ‘Inertia of a Non-radiating Particle’, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 15 631-633 (1976).
    [6] ‘A New Approach to the Problem of the Anomalous Magnetic Moment of the Electron’, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 16, 401-404 (1977).
    [7] ‘Electrodynamic Anomalies in Arc Discharge Phenomena’, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-5, 159-163 (1977).
    [8] ‘Energy Correlation Formula Applied to Psi Particles’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 1, 59-63 (1978).
    [9] ‘Crystal Symmetry and Ferromagnetism’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 1, 281-288 (1978).
    [10] ‘G Fluctuations and Planetary Orbits’, Catastrophist Geology, 3-2, 1-2 (December 1978).
    [11] ‘Ion Accelerators and Energy Transfer Processes’, U.K. Patent Specification No. 2,002,953A (Published 28 February 1979).
    [12] ‘The Spatial Energy Distribution for Coulomb Interaction’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 25, 456-458 (1979).
    [13] ‘Energy Correlation of Radiative Decays of psi(3684)’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 26, 257-260 (1979).
    [14] [Jointly with D. M. Eagles] ‘The Spatial Distribution of the Interaction Contribution to the Magnetic-Field Energy Associated with Two Moving Charges’, Acta Physica Polonica, A57, 473-482 (1980).
    [15] ‘The Inverse-Square Law of Force and its Spatial Energy Distribution’, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 13, 3649-3655 (1980).
    [16] ‘Speculations in General Plus Some of My Own’, Specculations in Science and Technology, 3, 114-116 (1980).
    [17] ‘UFOs and the Cosmic Connection’, Energy Unlimited, 8, 37-40 (1980).
    [18] ‘A Theory of Neutron Lifetime’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 31, 383-384 (1981).
    [19] ‘Atmospheric Electric Field Induction’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 4, 314-316 (1981).
    [20] ‘The Anomalous Magnetic Moment of the Electron’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 32, 114-116 (1981).
    [21] ‘Electron Form and Anomalous Energy Radiation’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 33, 213-216 (1982).
    [22] ‘A Theory of Pion Lifetime’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 33, 237-239 (1982).
    [23] ‘The Correlation of the anomalous g-Factors of the Electron and Muon’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 33, 481-484 (1982)
    [24] ‘Mirror Reflection Effects in Light Speed Anisotropy Tests’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 5, 421-431 (1982).
    [25] ‘Charge Induction by Thermal Radiation’, Journal of Electrostatics, 13, 71-80 (1982).
    [26] ‘The Aether – an Assessment’, Wireless World, 88, 37-39 (October 1982).
    [27] ‘Relativity and Rotation’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 6, 199-202 (1983).
    [28] ‘The Lamb Shift for a Cavity-Resonant Electron’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 36, 364-368 (1983).
    [29] ‘The Thunderball – an Electrostatic Phenomenon’, Institute of Physics Conference Series No. 66: Electrostatics 1983, pp. 179-184.
    [30] ‘The Determination of Absolute Gravitational Potential’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 37, 169-172 (1983).
    [31] ‘The Nature of the Muon’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 37, 210-214 (1983).
    [32] ‘Theoretical Resonances for Particle-Antiparticle Collisions based on the Thomson Electron Model’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 37, 307-311 (1983).
    [33] ‘Meson Lifetime Dilation as a Test for Special Relativity’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 38, 206-210 (1983).
    [34] ‘Planar Boundaries of the Space-Time Lattice’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 38, 243-246 1983).
    [35] ‘The Mass of the Muon’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 38, 342-345 (1983).
    [36] ‘The Assessment of a Theory for the Proton-Electron Mass Ratio’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 38, 423-426 (1983).
    [37] ‘The Scope for First-Order Tests of the Light Speed Anisotropy’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 38, 568-572 (1983).
    [38] ‘The Finite Lifetime of the Electron’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 7, 3-6 (1984).
    [39] ‘Electromagnetic Reaction Paradox’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 39, 247-251 (1984).
    [40] ‘The Muon g-Factor by Cavity Resonance Theory’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 39, 271-275 (1984).
    [41] ‘Boson Creation in a Sub-Quantum Lattice’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 40, 53-57 (1984).
    [42] ‘The Steady-State Free-Electron Population of Free Space’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 41, 252-256 (1984).
    [43] ‘Don’t Forget Thomson’, Physics Today, 15 (November 1984).
    [44] ‘The Nature of the Pion’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 8, 235-239 (1985).
    [45] ‘The Maxwell-Fechner Hypothesis as an Alternative to Einstein’s Theory, 8, 283-289 (1985).
    [46] ‘Unification of Gravitational and Electrodynamic Potential based on Classical Action-at-a-Distance Theory’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 44, 689-693 (1985)
    [47] ‘The Paradox of Constant Planetary Mass as Evidence of a Leptonic Lattice-Structured Vacuum State’, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, 44, 705-709 (1985).
    [48] ‘The Exploding Wire Phenomenon’, Physics Letters, 107A, 238-240 (1985).
    [49] ‘A New Perspective on the Law of Electrodynamics’, Physics Letters, 111A, 22-24 (1985).
    [50] ‘Theoretical Evaluation of the Fine Structure Constant’, Physics Letters, 110A, 113-115 (1985).
    [51] ‘The Proton Enigma’, American Journal of Physics, 53, 938 (1985).
    [52] ‘More on Thomson’s Particles’, Americal Journal of Physics, 53, 616 (1985).
    [53] ‘Weak Violation – a New Concept in Relativity?’, Nature, 318, 317-318 (1985).
    [54] ‘Earnshaw’s Theorem’, Nature, 319, 8 (1986).
    [55] ‘Anomalous Electrodynamic Explosions in Liquids’, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, PS-14, 282-285 (1986).
    [56] ‘How to Test Special Relativity’, Nature, 321, 734 (1986).
    [57] ‘Classical Relativity’, Nature, 320, 10 (1986).
    [58] ‘Electron Self-Field Interaction and Internal Resonance, Physics Letters, 119A, 109-111 (1986).
    [59] ‘The Mystery of Mercury’s Perihelion’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 5, 2475-2481 (1986).
    [60] ‘Flat Space Gravitation’, Physics Education, 21, 261-262 (1986).
    [61] ‘Fundamental Constants derived from Two-Dimensional Harmonic Oscillations in an Electrically Structured Vacuum’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 9 315-323 (1986).
    [62] ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Neutron and the Deuteron’, Hadronic Journal, 9, 129-136 (1986).
    [63] ‘Meson Production based on Thomson Energy Correlation’, Hadronic Journal, 9, 137-140 (1986).
    [64] ‘An Empirical Approach to Meson Energy Correlation’, Hadronic Journal, 9, 153-157 (1986).
    [65] ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Photon in a Lattice Vacuum’, pp. 345-359 in the Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Quantum Violations: Bridgeport, Connecticut 23-27 June 1986, published by Plenum in NATO ASI Series B: Physics vol. 162.
    [66] ‘A Causal Theory of Neutron Diffraction’, Physics Letters 119A, 105-108 (1986).
    [67] ‘On the Creation of the Sun’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 5, 2609-2612 (1986).
    [68] ‘The Case for the Sub-Electron’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 5, 2827-2833 (1987).
    [69] ‘Ampere’s Law: Comments on a Discussion by Milnes’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 6, 2981-2984 (1987).
    [70] ‘Derivation of the Electrodynamic Force Law’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 6, 2985-2987 (1987).
    [71] ‘The Exploding Wire Phenomenon as an Inductive Effect’, Physics Letters, 120A, 80-82 (1987).
    [72] ‘Earthquake-Related EM Disturbances’, Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, 28, 535-536 (1987).
    [73] ‘A Note on the Silvertooth Experiment’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 10, 9-12 (1987).
    [74] ‘Earnshaw’s Theorem’, American Journal of Physics, 55, 199 (March 1987).
    [75] ‘The Physics of the Missing Atoms: Technetium and Promethium’, Hadronic Journal, 10, 167-172 (1987).
    [76] ‘Synchronous Lattice Electrodynamics as an Alternative to Time Dilation’, Hadronic Journal, 10, 185-192 (1987).
    [77] ‘Steady State Electrodynamic Induction – A Feature of the General Law of Electrodynamics’, Progress in Space-Time Physics 1987, Editor J. P. Wesley, Benjamin Wesley, Blumberg, Germany, pp. 137-155 (1987).
    [78] ‘Tests of Photon Theory in Terms of Precision Measurement’, Problems in Quantum Physics; Gdansk ’87, (Conference Proceedings), Editors L. Kostro et al., World Scientific, New Jersey, pp. 353-373 (1987)
    [79] ‘EM Wave Interference’, American Journal of Physics, 56, 103 (February 1988).
    [80] ‘Ghost Mass and the Unseen Energy World as Revealed by the Anomalies of the Gyroscope’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 6, 3165-3171 (1987).
    [81] ‘Instantaneous Electrodynamic Potential with Retarded Energy Transfer’, Hadronic Journal, 11, 307-313 (1988).
    [82] ‘The Theory of the Proton Constants’, Hadronic Journal, 11, 169-176 (1988).
    [83] ‘A Theory of Proton Creation’, Physics Essays, 1, 72-76 (1988).
    [84] ‘Do We Really Understand Magnetism?’, Magnets, 1, 19-24 (1988).
    [85] ‘The Vacuum as our Future Source of Energy’, Magnets, 3(8), 15-18 (1988).
    [86] ‘A Modern Test for the Ether?’, Physics Today, 41, p. 132 (March, 1988).
    [87] ‘The Proton Factor and its Unknown Effects’, The Toth-Maatian Review, 7, 3725-3734 (October 1988).
    [88] ‘Anti-Gravity Electronics’, Electronics & Wireless World, 29-31 (January 1989).
    [89] ‘Extremely Low Frequency Electromagnetic Radiation and Biological Effects’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 12, 17-20 (1989).
    [90] ‘Conservative Hadron Interactions Exemplified by the Creation of the Kaon’, Hadronic Journal, 12, 101-108 (1989).
    [91] ‘The Theory of the Gravitation Constant’, Physics Essays, 2, 173-179 (1989).
    [92] ‘A Theory of Pion Creation’, Physics Essays, 2, 360-367 (1989).
    [93] ‘The Supergraviton and its Technological Connection’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 12, 179-186 (1989).
    [94] ‘Standing Wave Interferometry’, Physics Essays, 3, 39-45 (1990).
    [95] ‘The Harwen Energy Radiation Regenerator’, Speculations in Science and Technology, 13 295-299 (1990).
    [96] ‘Maxwell’s Demon and the Second Law of Thermodynamics’, Nature, 347, 25 (1990).
    [97] ‘Switched Reluctance Motor with Full A.C. Commutation’, U.S. Patent 4,975,608 (4th December 1990).
    [98] ‘Thermal Power Device’, U.K. Patent Specification 2,239,490A (Published 3rd July 1991).
    [99] ‘The Theory of Antigravity’, Physics Essays, 4, 13-19 (1991).
    [100] ‘Power Lines, Cancer and Cylotron Resonance’, Electronics World and Wireless World, pp. 774-775 (September 1991).
    [101] ‘Magnets and Gravity’, Magnets, 6(6), 16-22 (1992).
    [102] ‘Electricity without Magnetism’, Electronics World, 540-542 (1992).
    [103] ‘The Law of Perpetual Motion’, Physics Education, 28, 202-203 (1993).
    [104] ‘The First Law of Thermodynamics’, Physics Education, 28, 340-342 (1993).
    [105] ‘Retardation in the Coulomb Potential’, Physics Essays, 8, 19-28 (1995).
    [106] ‘Vacuum Spin as a New Energy Source’, Proceedings: International Symposium on New Energy, Denver, Colorado, pp. 1-19, April 25-28, 1996.

    _________________________

    Books by H. Aspden

    [107] ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, pp. 48 (1960), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.
    [108] ‘The Theory of Gravitation’, 2nd Ed. pp. 132 (1966), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.
    [109] ‘Physics without Einstein’, pp. 224 (1969), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.
    [110] ‘Modern Aether Science’, pp. 165 (1972), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.
    [111] ‘Gravitation’, pp. 78 (1975), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.
    [112] ‘Physics Unified’, pp. 206 (1980), Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.

    ____________________________

    Other publications by H. Aspden

    [113] ‘Space, Energy and Creation’, pp. 24 (1977) Sabberton Publications, P.O. Box 35, Southampton SO16 7RB, England.

    ______________________________

    Other references

    [114] Altschuler, M. D., Howe, L. L. & Hildner, E., ‘Is Ball Lightning a Nuclear Phenomenon?’, Nature, 228, 545 (1970).
    [115] Samokhin, A., ‘Vacuum Energy – a Breakthrough?’, Press Release No. 03NTO-89071CM04, Novosti Press Agency, Moscow (1989).
    [116] Correa, P. & Correa, A., (1995). ‘Electromechanical Transduction of Plasma Pulses’, U.S. Patent No. 5,416,391.
    [117] Correa, P. & Correa, A., (1995). ‘Energy Conversion System’, U.S. Patent No. 5,449,989.
    [118] Verronet, A., Comptes Rendus, 188, 1380-1381 (1929).
    [119] Chukanov, K. B., ‘Final Quantum Revelation’, General Energy International, Salt Lake City, Utah, pp. 220-221 (1994).
    [120] Lambertson, W. A., ‘History and Status of the Win Process’, Proceedings of the International Symposium on New Energy, Denver, Colorado, May 12-15, 1994, pp. 283-288.

    

  • LECTURE NO. 25

    LECTURE NO. 25

    THE MARINOV MOTOR

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    Stefan Marinov was a man who set his sights on becoming a legendary figure in the future chronicles which will report on the history of the ‘free energy’ revolution. That revolution began in recent years and is gaining momentum as we approach the dawn of a new millennium.

    This Lecture is my way of recording, as much for my own benefit as for others who see this, my personal impression of some aspects of Marinov’s efforts that have come to my attention. I am doing this partly because of a letter I have just received (dated October 19, 1998) from Dr. Eugene Mallove, Editor of the magazine Infinite Energy (Web site: http://www.infinite-energy.com, which was accompanied by a video recording showing, in Dr. Mallove’s words:

    “Some Marinov motor demos done by Jeff Kooistra – April through June 1998. Superb work! I would appreciate your comments on what you can see. There appears to be a violation of Newton’s third law – quite remarkable, if true. Many strange things visible.”

    I will, in this Lecture, tell you what that tape illustrated and my reaction to what I saw, but first I will indulge in a little reminiscence about Stefan Marinov, who, sadly, committed suicide in a way which declared his desperation at having failed to convince the scientific community that what he had to say demanded their attention.

    My first encounter with Stefan Marinov was some time in the 1970s. I had, in 1969, published a book entitled Physics without Einstein. It bore the caption:

    “A confrontation with the anomalies of electromagnetism which reveals a unified explanation for the physical phenomena of the universe.”

    That book disclosed a new law of electrodynamics, wholly supported by empirical evidence, a law that was consistent with the Lorentz force law as applied to electron current flow in closed circuits but one that allowed unification with the theory of gravity. It was explained that the law gave scope for generating forces in breach of Newton’s Third Law. That could only mean that the aether could assert or absorb force and the book delved into the structure of that aether to show how it put action into quantum mechanics and provided a quantum theory of gravitation by incorporating gravitons having a mass-energy of 2.587 GeV, thereby allowing G, the constant of gravitation to be derived by pure theory. Empirical evidence was referenced to show that such gravitons do exist. The case presented was aimed at showing that Einstein’s Theory of Relativity had been overtaken by something better, something that meant revival of the aether theme, but in a modernized form.

    I had, in my wife’s maiden surname, Sabberton, founded ‘Sabberton Publications’, expressly to be of record as publisher of my book, so as to be sure I had control of its disposition.

    Marinov entered into the picture one day by writing to ‘Sabberton Publications’. He declared that he was in search of a publisher for his work, which also stood in defiance of Einstein’s Theory, and that his recent experimental investigations were sure to earn him the Nobel Prize in physics within a year or so, once his experiment became known. His claim was that the measurement of the speed of light in a special way proved there was a preferred frame of reference through which the Earth is moving, so contradicting Einstein’s Theory. His suggestion was to travel to U.K. immediately for discussions as he was impressed by the quality of my book, could see that the publisher was willing to promote work which challenged the Einstein doctrine and so he felt sure that his work would prove acceptable and could be completed and put in order for publication during such a visit.

    Naturally, being fully occupied with my management role in IBM, and regarding my publishing venture merely as a hobby, one devoted to my own efforts in my spare time, I certainly did not want to become embroiled in such a proposal. I duly explained my position to Marinov and declined to entertain such a visit, but wished him well in his pursuit. It was evident he was serious in thinking his finding did merit a Nobel Prize and, amused though I was at the suggestion, I avoided expressing my feelings about his audacity.

    That said, it was a while later, early in 1977 I believe, when I saw a large notice published, if I remember correctly, in the journal Nature, announcing an ‘International Conference on Space-Time Absoluteness’ to be held in Bulgaria. The main attraction of that conference was to be the announcement of details of Marinov’s experiment revealing the detection of the Earth’s motion through space by optical tests conducted in an enclosed laboratory. It seemed, again if I recall correctly, that Dr. Sakharov, a distinguished Russian scientist, would be a patron of this conference, the implication being that this conference had official blessing by the Bulgarian authorities and would be well attended.

    I declared my intention to attend and offer a paper, conscious that I would need to avoid my IBM affiliation being recorded, except as necessary in the procurement of a visa. My position with IBM was that of Director of IBM’s European Patent Operations. It would have been inappropriate to imply that what I had to say about the ‘aether’ had any endorsement from the scientific fraternity in IBM. Indeed, my ‘hobby’ interest in that subject was only known to my IBM colleagues in the patent function and higher management to whom I reported. I had, in that IBM position travelled to iron curtain countries such as Poland, Hungary, Romania etc. by co-ordination with IBM’s facilities in Vienna, but this was to be one trip that was for my own private interest and, the conference being for 5 days or so, I knew it would have to eat up a week of my regular vacation. So, you see, I was genuinely interested in the subject and I was curious about Marinov’s claim, especially as he presumably had acquired official endorsement in his country.

    In the event, and at the time travel arrangements had to be put in place, I made a point on one of my business trips to London of calling in at the Bulgarian Tourist Office to ask about flight arrangements and visa procedures pertaining to the holding of that conference. The conference was to be held at a Black Sea resort location Varna, which made me think that the Tourist Office enquiry was warranted. I also reasoned that the conference would have to be of record in their diary of forthcoming events. When I made my enquiry by showing the copy I had of the conference announcement, I sensed some alarm in that they had no knowledge of that planned event and, indeed, I then got the measure of the situation very sharply. I decided on the spot that I would not be going to Bulgaria and so I went about my IBM business.

    It was not long thereafter that a young London University student of Greek nationality, doing a Ph.D. on Einstein’s Theory of Relativity, visited me to talk about my theoretical work and my book Physics without Einstein. Incidental to that our exchange of information came around to the Bulgarian conference. Professor Pappas, to use his later title, had in fact attended the Varna venue only to find himself greeted by Marinov and told that the conference had been cancelled. Pappas said that he went with Marinov to Sofia, where he there saw the laboratory equipment that Marinov had used in his speed-of-light experiment by which he claimed to have sensed the Earth’s motion through space. He was one of a handful of people who had somehow not received information that the conference had been cancelled, obviously because it lacked approval from the Bulgarian authorities.

    An interesting insight into the circumstances is afforded by Marinov’s own commentary in his book: The Thorny Way of Truth: Part IV: Documents on the Violation of the Laws of Conservation. On page 248 of that work, published in 1989, some 11 years after the intended Bulgarian event, but just one year after a different conference on a similar subject but held at the Imperial College in London, one reads:

    “The organizer (i.e. of that London conference) is Dr. Duffy who intended to visit the International Conference on Space-Time Absoluteness which had to meet in 1977 in Bulgaria but was prohibited by the Bulgarian government and 20 days before its beginning I was imprisoned in a psychiatric clinic where, after a bargain with representatives of the Bulgarian Academy of Science and the Bulgarian KGB, I ‘bought’ my freedom by consenting to cancel the conference because of ‘fear for an earthquake’.”

    The above is quoted from a section of Marinov’s book entitled: ‘MARINOV TO THE PARTICIPANTS OF THE AETHER CONFERENCE’, and, only now (October 25, 1998), as I come to write this text concerning the Marinov Motor have I, such a ‘participant’, come to read this part of Marinov’s book. It is introduced by a few words preceding what has just been quoted above:

    “The Conference ‘Physical Interpretations of Relativity Theory’ sponsored by the British Society for the Philosophy of Science will meet on 16-19 September 1988 at the Imperial College, London. All members of the organizing committee are people supporting the aether concepts and there is no single orthodox relativist who categorically denies its existence.”

    You will understand that here Marinov was giving vent to his feelings and endeavoring, by rebellious tactics, to force his scientific views upon a more orthodox but questioning group of scientists interested in clarifying doubts concerning relativity and aether philosophy. He goes on to explain that, in seeking to participate in that London conference, his letters to Dr. Duffy and Professor Kilmister, of the organizing committee, were not answered, but that a telephone call to Dr. Duffy elucidated the response that there was no time for Marinov on the programme.

    I said: “You, Dr. Duffy, know very well that I am the world’s patriarch in space-time absoluteness. It is an absurdity that now when a conference will meet, where the word ‘aether’ will no more be pronounced with the same hatred as the word ‘trotzkist’ in the Soviet Union, I am deprived of the opportunity to speak as this was always the case at conferences of the orthodox relativists”

    These latter remarks are quoted from p. 248 of Marinov’s book.

    I personally was unaware of all this when I attended that 1988 London conference. I was not involved with its organization, but I happened to be close to the reception desk in the lobby of the conference not far from Dr. Duffy when in came Stefan Marinov. I had known him from a meeting earlier that year (May, 1988) in Bologna. It was a disturbing situation. Dr. Duffy refused Marinov’s entry to the conference. I withdrew in silence, remembering a scene at the Bologna conference where Marinov had rather rudely interrupted a keynote speaker Professor H Bondi to tell him he was wrong in what he was saying about our inability to detect the existence of a background frame of reference by measuring our motion relative to that frame.

    I remember that occasion well because I had gone to Bologna in Italy to be a speaker at an academic event organized contemporaneously with the one at which Professor Bondi spoke. I went there with E W Silvertooth and Marinov sat next to us in the audience. At that other event Silvertooth spoke about his own experiment by which he had detected motion through space by optical means and I spoke about my interest in the aether. I later referred to the Silvertooth experiment in the paper I gave at that 1988 conference organized in London by Dr. Duffy. See my paper: ‘Four Questions Concerning Relativity’ [1988g]

    I was destined to meet Stefan Marinov again, on visits to USA, the first being as attendees at a conference held in Denver, Colorado, Marinov and I being amongst a group of invited speakers, also participating in a ‘think tank’ forum, concerned with new methods of energy generation.

    Ever enthusiastic, Marinov aroused our interest by demonstrating odd effects concerning setting things in motion, using magnets and electrical currents, but I saw nothing in his proposals that warranted a commercial interest. Over the years, Marinov had taken to heart what I had been advocating in my book Physics without Einstein concerning the fallacies of the conventional form of electrodynamic law, as indeed had Professor Pappas. Indeed, both Marinov and Pappas made their own contributions in challenging The Lorentz force law. This is a subject which relates to the way in which electric motors work and it has implications where setting up forces as between matter and aether are concerned. This is where Newton’s Third Law, the balance of action and reaction, enters into the picture, the issue being the question of whether we can set up forces on a machine by which it pushes against the aether to develop drive power. Forces asserted between the aether and a machine can further imply transfer of energy from the aether to the machine, a fascinating prospect and one which comes into perspective once we see scope for challenging, not just the Lorentz force law, but the earlier Ampere form of law.

    So it is here that we come to the theme of prime importance. It is a topic I have discussed from my perspective elsewhere in these web pages, but I am here concentrating attention on the Marinov motor theme. Both Pappas and Marinov became absolutely convinced that the Lorentz force law is incorrect, as applied to interactions involving an unclosed electrical circuit, meaning, for example, one where the action arises from current flow around a circuit path is that of current flow through wire in one circuit segment and that of displacement current through the aether in a another segment of that circuit. If action balances reaction as between current in the different parts of that circuit, then action and reaction forces are asserted between matter and aether and that means that one can devise a machine that moves itself by pushing against the aether.

    At pages 126-135 of his book The Thorny Way of Truth: Part IV, Marinov introduces us to an ‘Extremely Easy Experiment Demonstrating Violation of the Angular Momentum Conservation Law’ and his concluding sentences read:

    “With Ampere’s bridge one can set artificial satellites in orbit about a planet without atmosphere by ‘shooting them from a canon’. In the flying Ampere Bridge, however, the driving force can act during the whole flight and the force which is needed has only to overwhelm the Earth’s gravitational attraction.”

    Now here I would interject a word of caution. There is certainly scope for developing interaction forces as between a machine and aether, given an environmental ‘capsule’ of aether containing that machine, and we may find that the machine can wobble about by pushing against that entrained aether, but that is no warranty that the machine can push itself clear of the capsule and go off into outer space by pushing against aether in its path. It all depends upon what determines the frame of electromagnetic reference applicable in the locality of the machine.

    To proceed on this theme, I will now limit my discussion in this Lecture to three experimental topics. Firstly, I shall mention the Pappas-Vaughan experiment by which the Lorentz force law has been disproved. Then I will give my opinion of what I saw demonstrated on that video tape I mentioned at the outset, Kooistra’s April-June 1998 experiments on the ‘Marinov Motor’, and thirdly, I will revert back to the so-called ‘Ampere Bridge’ experiment which Marinov describes in his book, as referenced above.

    THE PAPPAS-VAUGHAN EXPERIMENT

    In the Pappas-Vaughan experiment the circuit was that of a dipole antenna powered from its centre. It was not a standard straight dipole configuration but one bent into a kind of Z shape with the angles being right angles. It was termed a ‘stigma’ antenna owing to that shape, but in essence the experiment amounted to setting up a current oscillation at radio frequency in that antenna laying in a horizontal plane and it suspended from its centre and watching to see whether switching between power on and power of would develop a torsional oscillation in that suspension.

    According to the Lorentz force law there should be a turning couple developed when current flows as current in the middle section interacts with that in the end sections. No such couple was in evidence. That meant that the Lorentz law is wrong and so is disproved experimentally. It left open the question of whether the action-reaction balance applies, owing to forces communicated through the centre of mass of the antenna, this being consistent with Ampere’s old formula or whether, consistent with my own law of electrodynamics, there is simply no aether reaction that can permit an out-of-balance couple, this not precluding a linear out-of-balance force in the general case, but such a linear force not being in evidence owing to the specific geometry of the antenna. Note that my law has such an action when applied to the problem of gravitation. This is evident from Tutorial No. 4 in these web pages.

    The Marinov book (1989) includes at pp. 158-168 a paper on the ‘Stigma’ antenna experiment, its authors being Professor P. T. Pappas and Tim Vaughan. Much the same paper appears also in Physics Essays, v. 3, pp. 211-216 (1990). A fully illustrated description of the apparatus is presented. This was highly original work, born out of the suspicion that the Lorentz force could be wrong, something very few establishment physicists would ever dream as being a worthwhile venture, yet it has to be seen as a major contribution to the subject of electrodynamics. Keep in mind the fact that Lorentz himself was confounded by the null result of the famous Trouton-Noble electrodynamic experiment reported in 1903. That experiment put the Lorentz force law to the test by switching the charge of a suspended parallel plate capacitor in time with the natural torsional oscillation period, the object being to see if the electrodynamic effects of the charges parallel moving charges carried along with body Earth would allow that motion through the aether to be measured.

    The same result was obtained as in the Pappas-Vaughan experiment, that is there was no turning couple. This could be interpreted two ways. Either there was no charge motion relative to the aether or the Lorentz force law was wrong. Lorentz in his famous 1904 paper, which predated Einstein’s efforts in 1905, chose the option which kept his law in place. Pappas and Vaughan, however, have performed a similar test with charge assuredly moving relative to the local aether frame and their result proves conclusively that Lorentz chose the wrong option! That will show you why their experiment is so important. Lorentz in 1904 had paved the way for acceptance of Einstein’s theory using paving stones that were cracked! They could offer no secure foundation for Einstein’s theory.

    I will move on now to the issues raised by the Kooistra video.

    THE KOOISTRA VIDEO

    The Kooistra video recording first demonstrated how one could make a test apparatus comprising a composite assembly of magnets, which form a cuboidal structure suspended on a length of what I understood to be cords of the kind used on fishing reels, ‘fish line’, the magnet thus supported being centrally located and free to turn inside a copper ring. On diametrically opposite sides of that ring one could position the tips of two probes connected by wires to a d.c. voltage source. The experiment involved, beginning with the magnet in its rest position, and then connecting the probes to the ring so as to allow current to flow into it on one side, divide in its onward flow either way around the ring and merge again to flow out through the other probe. Upon such connection one could see that the composite magnet began to rotate about its vertical suspension.

    The mystery question was: “Why should the magnet rotate?”

    The video illustrated sustained rotation for a period of several seconds, but did not, so far as that test using that apparatus was concerned, imply that continuous rotation was possible for an indefinite period. Indeed one must assume that the suspension would progressively become more and more twisted, meaning that eventually rotation must cease as the twist torque became strong enough to stop and then put the motion of the magnet into reverse rotation. That sustained rotation was probably illusory anyway, amounting to an impulsive action to set the suspended magnet system rotating and then, given its inertia and little resistance to rotation from the suspension, it could describe several revolutions.

    Indeed I understand from a witness to a live demonstration of the Kooistra experiments that Kooistra there also showed how the residual external field of the magnet assembly could interact with the currents in the ring to give a 90o rotation to a stable position. This is to be expected since the division of the current flow around two semicircular segments of the ring would have the effect of creating a closed magnetic field somewhat similar to that produced by the magnet assembly and the effect of superimposition of the two field systems would be a function of the angle between the two field systems as seen looking vertically downwards from above. That angle would tend to adjust to bring the magnet assembly and the terminal connection points to the copper ring to the optimum energy state in which the system becomes stable.

    The assembly of the magnet amounted to taking a plurality of small magnets and fitting them together so that this structure was equivalent to mounting two rectangular block magnets side by side, with the north pole of one magnet being adjacent to the south pole of the other, the magnetic axes of the two magnets being vertical. This would set up magnetic leakage flux in a vertical direction at the encompassing ring position and the strength of the leakage flux would diminish rapidly with distance from the axis of suspension owing to the compensating magnetic effects. The magnet stack was elongated, being at least twice the length in its vertical dimension as each of the two side dimensions, so as to be, overall, in geometrical terms, a rectangular parallepiped, otherwise known as a ‘cuboid’.

    I suspected at first that the cuboidal configuration meant that the assembly would exhibit, in effect, several axes of magnetization, meaning that an externally-applied magnetic field could hold the magnet stable in several different angular positions, depending upon the direction and presence of that field. However, on further consideration I realize that the system amounts to a kind of composite magnetic compass element with a horizontal N-S field at its upper portion and an opposed S-N field at its lower portion, though producing a fairly strong leakage magnetic field in a vertical direction at the radius where the copper ring is located.

    Now, before commenting further on the Kooistra demonstration, I will ask you to consider what you would observe if you took a small button magnet and suspended it from, say, a door frame using a length of cotton thread but provided another separate length of thread separately attached to that button magnet and just left dangling below it. You would see the magnet swing from side to side like a pendulum for some time before it stopped swinging and it would spin about its vertical suspension for quite a while, first one way and then the other, until it finally came to rest. In its rest position it would have an orientation determined by the direction of the Earth’s local magnetic field. After all, all you have done is to assemble what amounts to a kind of magnetic compass.

    Then, however, once it has stopped moving, take hold of the lower end of that dangling thread and, very carefully and gently, pull it downwards using very little force. You will find that the magnet begins to rotate once again about that vertical suspension.

    That downward force you have exerted will pull on that upper section of thread and cause it to stretch by untwisting itself a little, an action which converts your linear pull into a turning couple. This has nothing to do with magnetic fields and currents in wires. It is simple mechanics involving the theory of elasticity and the frictional effect between the strands of that cotton thread which preserve its twisted character. It would work if you replaced the magnet with a small copper ring but the magnet provides the means for exerting an influence on it without pulling on that dangling thread. You can slide a piece of iron under a magnet and find that it is attracted towards it, putting extra force on the thread, in addition to the weight of the magnet. That will promote rotation too. Alternatively you might just suspend a paper clip on the thread and hold your button magnet underneath it, raising your hand up or down to lift and lower the magnet and so alter the tension applied to that thread.

    You might not then be surprised if you happened to see the advertisement at page 6 in New Energy News, September 1998 issue, headed ‘Mysterious Magnetic Spinner’ and referring to a video by John Searl. It has a paper clip supported from one end of a tube with a magnet located at the other end but spaced from the paper clip which it attracts. It says “Here is a device invented by Lee Trippett to demonstrate ‘The Mysterious Magnetic Spin’” and that the “key point of this device is that college professors cannot tell us how it works. They will tell you that it is a simple magnetic motor action – a force is produced on a coil that is moved through a magnetic field. Now just try it with a coil of copper. No spin!”

    Well, I am not a college professor but I guess it works because the supporting filament is a length of twine, a twisted thread which turns about its axis when stretched, but if it works just as well with a thin single filament of copper wire, albeit with that steel (not copper) paper clip attached, then I bow to the world of mysticism and join the ranks of those who do not understand the phenomenon.

    With that in mind I was rather suspicious about the significance of the Kooistra demonstration. However, it did pose some perplexing questions and engendered considerable interest. This brings me now to a further demonstration shown in the Kooistra video, one where the copper ring and the magnet were both suspended on separate cords in very close proximity. The application of current, the flow bifurcating in its passage through the ring, had the effect of causing both to turn a small angular distance as a unit and that added mystery to that presentation, because this seemed to be action without reaction.

    In one experiment Kooistra arranged for the copper ring to be able to turn in its horizontal plane with the magnet assembly locked against rotation. He reasoned that the currents in the ring and the magnet were the seat of any interaction and proceeded to demonstrate that if he applied the current to the ring by having both the probes on the outside rim of the ring then the ring itself would rotate one way, but if both probes were making contact with the inside rim of the ring then the ring would rotate in the opposite sense.

    Here, seemingly, is a genuine mystery. However, I have my doubts, because when current flows into or from the ring it must have radial component in the horizontal plane in finding its distribution channel through those semicircular segments. That radial component of current will interact with the vertical field of the magnet assembly adjacent to the probe positions. So, if the two probes connect to the outer rim of the ring, the current flow will be radially inwards adjacent one probe but radially outwards adjacent the other problem, where the vertical field is of opposite direction. Keep in mind that split N-S, S-N configuration of the magnet assembly. What that means is that the field will interact with those radial current components to set up Lorentz forces that will apply an impulsive turning couple to the ring in the same sense adjacent both probes. When current flows the ring will begin to rotate in a horizontal plane. However, should the probes be put in contact with the inner part of the ring then the radial currents will be in the opposite direction and the turning impulse will also be in the opposite direction, which is what Kooistra observed.

    This action is illustrated in the figure below:

    This is a view of the magnet assembly and the ring as seen from above. The ring can turn about its centre. The north (N) and south (S), segments of the magnet assembly, being the upper poles, will produce, by the N pole, a downwardly directed magnetic field on the left hand segment of the ring (depicted by the + symbols to show the tail end of an arrow), whereas the S pole will produce an upward field on the right hand segment of the ring (depicted by the point symbols). When the current i flows through the probes and into the ring then it will divide between upper and lower semi-circular paths, but only one such path is shown. The Lorentz force law tells us that only the radial component of current in the ring can develop forces circumferentially around the ring as needed to set up rotation. Accordingly the action of the magnets on that short radial component of current in the body of the ring will develop the anticlockwise rotation.

    There will, of course, be forces as shown exerted on the probes and, if the magnet were free to rotate as well we could expect it to rotate owing to its action-reaction interaction with the probe current. The direction of rotation must depend upon the direction of the current flow through the probe circuit.

    Note also that if the probes were extended radially inwards in the above illustration so as to have contact with the inner part of the ring then the radial current components in the two ring segments would be opposite to the directions shown and so the ring would rotate in the opposite direction. This is what Kooistra demonstrated.

    Note that if the vertical leakage field from the rare earth magnets as effective at the ring radius is, say, 100 oersted, then a radial current of 10 amps even in just a few millimetres will develop a turning force of 100 dynes at the ring radius, which is ample to promote the rotation of the suspended copper ring in the Kooistra apparatus.

    Now suppose that the magnet assembly and the ring are both free to turn and current is applied to the ring. The ring will still tend to turn and I see no problem even if they do both turn together in the same direction, provided that rotation is through a limited angle. The interaction of a magnet and a current in a wire is an interaction between the seat of a magnetic field and that current. The magnetic field acting on the ring is strictly a state of the aether, a field condition of space. However, here I can but begin to wonder about an analogy with the operation of a magnetic reluctance motor, where I can see the Earth’s magnetism as providing the stator poles.

    The idea that angular momentum is conserved and action balances reaction does suggest that if the magnet rotates one way the ring must rotate the other, but all that is based on energy conservation in systems that are subject to central forces, such we see for the gravitational interaction between Earth and Sun. Once you bring in forces that act differently on different components of a system, particularly magnetic forces, then the standard principles of mechanics are not wholly reliable as a guide to what happens. Furthermore, in the Kooistra experiments, though he did assert that the reaction forces on his current probes would be swamped by the forces promoting rotation of the ring and the magnet, that statement needs clarification. There must be forces developing a turning couple on those two probes and they will have their reaction counterpart in the magnet and ring arrangement.

    Reverting to his experiments with the ring fixed in position and the magnet rotating, I still would keep in mind the notion of a magnetic reluctance motor with the geomagnetic field serving as a stator pole system and having its action modified by the current supplied to the ring. The cuboidal magnet assembly would have, owing to its opposed configuration of magnets, a residual relatively weak polarization, perhaps to some small extent resulting in a plurality of effective magnetic poles, perhaps one on each side face of the assembly. Now when a multipole rotor sits inside a stator in a small magnetic reluctance motor, the application of a sudden starting torque, such as a manual flick of an attached flywheel, can, if there is no load on the motor, result in the rotor spinning through several revolutions as it clicks on from one in-register pole position to the next. This is called a ‘cogging effect’. A little consideration will show that, if the rotor has an appreciable moment of inertia but is subject to very little ‘bearing’ resistance and can turn easily but for the magnetic ‘cogging’ action, then the initial energy input to turn it through one cogging step plus just a little extra impulse can cause it to rotate through many revolutions before coming to rest. Indeed there is no bearing as such, just the very slight frictional resistance involved in twisting that suspension cord.

    So consider what we have in the Kooistra demonstration. A relatively weak magnet assembly which can, if at rest, be held stable in one or more orientations with the Earth’s magnetic field providing that cogging feature and serving as the stator of the motor. Then we have that bifurcated conductor positioned in a horizontal plane and in which a current of a few amps flows through two parallel connected paths, thereby setting up a weak magnetic field which, depending upon the vertical position of the magnet assembly, can act on that assembly in a horizontal direction. That field can easily outweigh the Earth’s field in its strength and so, with current on, it can reorientate the suspended magnet. If that current is applied suddenly it can, given a little prior adjustment to set its magnitude and choosing the probe positions so as to get an optimum effect, cause that magnet to turn and so move through one of its ‘cogging’ positions. Once turning, however, its inertia, given the energy impulse that initiates its motion, will cause it to rotate through many revolutions as it builds up a reaction torque in the suspension by twisting it and so, in effect, winding it up as the kinetic energy transfers into the potential energy set by the elasticity of the system.

    This, I submit, can explain what seems to be a short duration state of rotation of the magnet assembly in the Kooistra demonstration, limited in duration because of the build-up of the twist reaction torque.

    In short, if my interpretation is correct, then one must be dubious in regarding the Kooistra experiments as being anomalous. I will qualify this, however, by saying that, to my way of thinking, there is nothing anomalous about a motor developing torque by pushing on a magnetic field, which, because that is a state of the aether, implies a push against the aether itself. I say this because there are experiments in physics where a cylindrical ferromagnetic rod housed within a concentric solenoid can be set in spin by passing current through the solenoid.

    If this latter statement is surprising then, guided by the following quoted sentence from a physics book in my possession, look up what is meant by the ‘effects’ mentioned:

    “Thus rotation should accompany magnetization, a phenomenon known on the continent as the Einstein-de Haas Effect and in England as the Richardson Effect.”

    Here I draw attention to the fact that any effect of a magnetic field on the current path through the solenoid will develop forces that are radial from the axis of rotation and so should cause no rotation attributable to reaction torque. Yet rotation can occur. However, I appreciate that the phenomenon underlying these physical effects is quite weak in comparison with that seen in the Kooistra demonstration, so I just mention this as being relevant and as being something to keep in mind.

    In the later section of his video presentation Kooistra goes on to show a ‘Marinov Motor’. This did have bearings allowing the rotor to spin about a vertical axis. It had current supplied through a commutator system and did rotate continuously. The purpose of this commutator was to act as a switch by which d.c. current fed to the copper ring could be switched on an off according to the orientation of the magnet assembly rotor. Ostensibly the only stator component was the copper ring and so this motor posed its mystery as to how it operates, given that the Lorentz forces acting on a circular ring carrying current in its arcuate sections can only act at right angles to the current and so radially, and perhaps also parallel, with respect to the motor spin axis. The issue raised is the question of how a reaction force can be set up which causes the rotor to spin.

    Well I suggest the answer is quite simple. The motor operates because it uses the Earth’s magnetic field as the ‘stator’ and the rotor spins by pushing against the frame of body Earth. That circular copper ring carries currents of the order of 10 amps in its arcuate segments. Such a current will produce a magnetic field acting on the rotor and having a strength of the same order as that of the geomagnetic field, about 0.5 oersted, given that the magnetized rotor sits about one inch away at the centre of the copper ring. Remember that the Earth’s magnetic field is subject to an angle of dip. It has a vertical component and a horizontal component. To put this explanation in perspective ask yourself if you think it possible to take a magnetic compass, put a wire close to it and get the compass needle to turn steadily by switching current on and off in proper timing related to the rotation of that needle. I think I could build such a device, but all I would have is a very weak magnetic reluctance motor if that current merely neutralizes the Earth’s magnetic field. If I pulsed the current to higher levels I would have a d.c. motor with a magnetized rotor not particularly sensitive to the Earth’s field, but I would not see anything special about that or any anomaly concerning electrodynamic theory.

    In summary therefore I am not excited by having seen the Kooistra video. I admit that there is the initial impression that something is anomalous, given that Kooistra takes pains to build into his devices a kind of symmetry which, in theory, should imply cancellation of normal force action. However, he could hardly avoid there being some residual asymmetry and a weak residual magnetism and it needs very little power to set a rotor spinning about an axis when subject to no load. Also, had he used a strong magnet and not provided a compensating feature, the rotation of such a magnet in the close vicinity of a thick copper ring would have implied eddy current damping which would have a drag effect leading to an unimpressive demonstration.

    That said, however, I would be pleased to be proved wrong by events. Given that Kooistra can demonstrate a motor action the task ahead is that of measuring its efficiency to see if, in pushing against the aether, assuming that is the seat of a balancing reaction torque, that aether is merely a passive catalyst not contributing to the energy balance or whether there is also an energy anomaly attributable to aether involvement.

    Concerning Marinov and his efforts in demonstrating anomalous motor effects, I will now complete this Lecture by commenting now on his Ampere Bridge motor, as described in his The Thorny way of Truth: Part IV.

    MARINOV’S AMPERE BRIDGE MOTOR

    When electric current flows around a closed wire circuit we well know that its action balances its reaction as one part of that circuit pushes against another. If you cause that current to flow around a circuit and over one short segment of that circuit the flow is that of displacement current in a dielectric, part of that displacement current is ‘aether’ charge displacement. In other words, the force balance can be between the aether and that wire. That is, or should be, self-evident and I was well aware of that once I embarked on challenging electrodynamic theory in the latter half of the 1950s.

    Obviously one can ask whether one can get a motor to rotate by developing an angular push against the aether or, as I had in mind, ask the question of whether the anomalous rotation of stars and the one-way rotation of solar system meant that that rotation had been set up by pushing against the aether itself. It raised the question of ‘aether spin’. My theory developed on those lines.

    It was in 1980 that I saw an article in the journal Nature announcing the experimental evidence that the field medium (in fact the ‘aether’) can provide a reaction force to quasi-static fields. G M Graham and D G Lahoz described their experiment in Nature, v. 285, p 154 (1980). I note here that Stefan Marinov referenced that paper on page 132 of his book, the one mentioned above. It was in his account of his experiment on ‘The Violation of the Angular Momentum Conservation Law’.

    Meanwhile, however, I myself had already ventured out in this field. It was upon the eve of my opting for early retirement from IBM to indulge myself in my research pursuits as a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the University of Southampton, close to my home. I got myself into a conference programme held by the U.K. Institute of Physics at Oxford University, the subject of the conference being ‘Electrostatics 1983’. My subject was ‘The Thunderball – an Electrostatic Phenomenon’. I started out by referring to the Graham and Lahoz paper and went on to discuss ‘vacuum spin’, the spin of the aether! I explained how the Earth’s magnetic field depended upon that spin and how thunderballs could form and exist in a quasi-stable state, simply because they were spheres of aether set spinning and slowly dissipating their energy by ionization of coextensive air. The paper was duly published in the conference proceedings [1983a].

    I well knew that an angular force, a turning effect, could be set up to act on the aether, either by developing a radial electric field about a spin axis or by configuring two or more current circuits to assert electrodynamic linear forces acting on the aether but offset from that spin axis so as to develop a couple. A single current loop will not exert a turning effect. Indeed, that was the essential fact that had led me in the late 1950s to derive the law of electrodynamics that was in accord with the law of gravitation.

    However, I have to applaud Marinov for his valiant effort in applying this apparent breach of Newton’s Third Law to the construction of a demonstrable motor. It was, in a sense, merely a version of the physics involved in that Nature article by Graham and Lahoz, but it was presented more boldly as a theme setting the stage for controversy in the context of new technology which defies orthodox physical law.

    His motor used a plurality (four) offset wire loops and provided for circuit closure through a capacitative segment in each of the loops which was radial to the motor spin axis. Out-of-balance for acting on a radial arm means a turning effect and hence rotation. The dielectric used was barium titanate, which has a very high dielectric constant, thereby allowing the current path through the dielectric to be large enough for the field interaction to involve the aether in a significant reaction. Power frequency was used and the circuit was designed to provide resonant tuning at that frequency. However, even then, with that use of barium titanate, to use his own words on p. 131 of his book, Marinov’s resulting ‘Rotating Ampere Bridge’ motor, with 50 Hz a.c. voltage input of 220 V and a current of 9 A, Marinov was only:

    “able to set the bridge in slow motion of one revolution in a couple of seconds.”

    His ‘motor’ was essentially a means for demonstrating that rotation by asserting a push on the aether is possible, seemingly in defiance of the law that requires action to balance reaction, but so far as I see that law must hold true for electrodynamic actions given that it can only having meaning if applied to a complete system, one which recognizes the aether as part of that system. Physicists err, however, if they ignore the aether and think that fields produced by matter are some kind of extension rigidly attached to matter, rather than being a conditional state impressed on the aether and causing it to react by storing the energy involved.

    I would, however, venture to say that a very substantial unbalance of angular momentum, as between aether and matter, can occur if the action developing aether spin is that of a radial electric field such as I see in the induction of thunderballs and the spin induced in astronomical bodies by initial coalescence of protons ahead of the neutralizing electrons. That offers greater promise in ‘new energy’ technology than what has been described by Marinov. Those radial electric fields can be induced in homopolar machines but there is something eluding those who work in that field and the subject warrants more research.

    In conclusion, you may wish to refer now to Research Note 15/97 which I added to these web pages shortly after Marinov’s decease and which, albeit by repeating some the above, will enlighten you further on the aspects not relating specifically to the motor topic.


    November 16, 1998
    Harold Aspden
  • LECTURE NO. 24

    LECTURE NO. 24

    THE ETHER – AN ASSESSMENT

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    The above is the title of an article of mine which appeared in the October 1982 issue of Wireless World. I wrote it because I had noticed that the Editor of that popular periodical was not averse to the idea that radio waves might well be waves propagated through the ether. He was not intent on suppressing opinions that put the ether on the winning side of the ever-ongoing debate concerning the relative merits of ether theory versus Einstein’s theory.

    Unlike so many editors of physics periodicals, who see it as a duty to censor all that they publish to ensure at all times an absolute adherence to the Einstein doctrine, here was an Editor who saw that those who read Wireless World enjoyed witnessing and indeed participating in the contest, the object of which was to glean the truth concerning the medium in which radio waves propagate.

    After all, Einstein’s theory is of no practical use in technology, but the technology of radio communication and the energy transfer processes which are involved in high frequency wave transmission has been developed by those who saw Maxwell’s theory as a foundation on which to build.

    Here, the operative word is ‘build’, not ‘destroy’, and it is no comfort to be told that Einstein developed his mathematical, but abstract, picture of ‘space-time’, in just such a way as to leave Maxwell’s equations intact, notwithstanding the distortions introduced by ‘four-space’ transformations.

    How can it be that those involved in the early days of radio technology, just as they were getting the measure of what was involved in radio propagation, were suddenly expected to deny their belief in the existence of the ether and adjust to a new philosophy? This was a philosophy which said: “If you cannot understand why something you think should happen but yet does not happen, then think about it in a different way and pretend it does happen! Transform your viewpoint and look at the problem from a different angle, one where you are the governing authority from which all physical action takes its reference, so that you will always see things in the same light and with reference to that something wiser beings once called the ‘ether’.”

    Well, thankfully, the Editor of Wireless World, saw the ‘world’ as one in which one can communicate by acting collectively by allowing the electromagnetic waves which they generate to be pooled in the common sea of energy that constitutes the real ‘ether’ medium. Given that as one’s foundation then one can take Maxwell’s equations and think about building on the common foundation that supports those equations, rather than destroying the foundation and then saying that Maxwell’s ghost is still there asserting influence – subject, of course, to that ghost not doing anything contrary to Einstein doctrine.

    So it was that I came to pay attention to three articles which appeared in Wireless World and I saw my chance to offer the Editor my paper of the above title: The Ether – An Assessment. Now let me say at the outset that I wrote the paper, not intending to play an old classical tune, but rather to show where opportunities had been missed when it came to interpreting the observed facts which feature in this scenario.

    I could see how there was error in deriving the Larmor formula for energy radiated by the accelerated electron. I could see that there was error in deriving what is known as the ‘Poynting Vector’. I could see that there was error in explaining how electric currents set up actions which inject energy into the vacuum as a so-called magnetic field, energy which is 100% recoverable, but yet letting the explanation ride exclusively on empirical formulations without giving any physical causal basis justifying why those equations work. I could see there was error in assuming that the ether could not sustain distortionless signal propagation, an assumption relied upon at their peril by cosmologists who interpret Hubble distances on such false assumptions. In this latter context I could but assume that they had not heeded Heaviside’s success in inventing the distortionless transmission line and so had not seen that Heaviside was merely replicating something Nature had provided as a feature of the ether. I could, further, see where Lorentz had erred in interpreting the Michelson-Morley experiment incorrectly and with it the Trouton-Noble experiment, an experiment of far greater importance, thereby opening the door for Einstein. I could see that those of us interested in electromagnetic waves, as real ether waves, and in learning also about the properties of stationary waves, as set up by reflections, had been left in the dark by physicists who did not trouble to apply standing wave theory to their opinions concerning the Michelson-Morley experiment. I could see that here Michelson and Morley could be forgiven for not taking such standing wave effects into account in setting the theory for their experiment. The reason was that Wiener, the scientist who first discovered the effect set up by standing waves, namely the phase-lock connection with mirror surfaces, did not make that discovery until some years after Michelson-Morley completed their experiments. However, how can we excuse those who let these facts pass them by as if they were irrelevant when set alongside the Einstein notion that light speed takes its reference, not from a mirror to which its standing wave energy is locked, but from an observer sitting outside the test apparatus and just looking at the light patterns of interfering waves?

    That, in summary, was why I decided to write the article of the above title. I will now work through that article step by step and will amplify the points made, by introducing links to other pages on this Web site, so as to leave the reader in no doubt that the case against the Einstein doctrine is formidable indeed. Conversely, the case in favour of a belief in the ether is overwhelming in view of the enormous vista of new physics and, hopefully, new technology, that one can then see.

    THE DYING PATIENT

    I hold firmly to the opinion that Einstein’s theory is defunct. It will, however, only pass away with the natural passage of time as the diehards who are committed to the Einstein doctrine themselves pass on to other pastures.

    With that I introduce the cartoon that the Editor of Wireless World commissioned based on my outline format and a caption I worded. I have received permission to reproduce that cartoon and it features also in the few copies of my work I had printed under the title: Aether Science Papers.

    THE ASSESSMENT BEGINS

    Does the ether exist? Dr. Aspden shows that Oliver Heaviside’s insight could have pre-empted Einstein’s success with the General Theory of Relativity and encouraged investigations into the properties of the ether.

    Though ‘Relativity’ has very little bearing upon the practical problems of radio transmission, it does preclude belief in the ether and wave propagation as contemplated by Maxwell, leaving us with no tangible alternative. Until we have a better understanding of the vacuum medium and the way in which it regulates electromagnetic wave motion, it is likely that Einstein’s ideas will be questioned.

    Essen, writing about relativity and time signals (Wireless World, October 1978), and Wellard, writing about the work of James Clerk Maxwell (Wireless World, March and May, 1981), both evoke this controversy.

    In fact, special relativity, which dates from 1905, has very dubious support, because alternative explanation of E = Mc2 and mass increase with speed is available from textbooks on classical electromagnetism [1]. Besides, the transmutation of mass and energy, the
    basis of E = Mc2, was recognized by Jeans, writing in 1904, one year before Einstein introduced his theory [2]. How, then, can we have confidence in relativity, when Essen demonstrates so convincingly the absurdity of expecting time to pass at a different rate when perceived by different observers in relative motion?

    What should be stressed here is the fact that Dr. Louis Essen was not one of those crackpot scientists that many physicists think of when the belief in an ether is in issue. No, Dr. Essen was a Fellow of the Royal Society who had earned recognition for his research on the measurement of time and his invention of the atomic clock. He served at the National Physical Laboratory in U.K. and, though it must have been somewhat embarrassing for that government institution to see Dr. Essen going out of his way to deride Einstein’s notions about time dilation etc., he nevertheless persisted in stating his opinions on that subject. So many academic physicists dare not express a dissident opinion on the Einstein theme for fear that the funding attracted by their universities would be put in jeopardy.

    Einstein’s theory really depends, for its acceptance, principally upon the success of the later 1916 General Theory of Relativity, which brought a slight modification to Newton’s Law of Gravitation. The successive elliptical orbits of the planet Mercury were known to have a progressive advance, part of which was anomalous, as judged from Newton’s Law. Einstein’s law gave the right answer and relativity was thereby acclaimed.

    Einstein made no reference to an earlier paper by Paul Gerber [3], entitled ‘The Space and Time Propagation of Gravitation’. It appeared in 1898 in a leading German scientific publication. So, one assumes that if Einstein had acquired some background knowledge concerning the anomalous precession of the orbit of the planet Mercury, he is likely to have seen Gerber’s paper. If he did not, then it is very curious to find that, some eighteen years after Gerber’s paper issued, when Einstein did write on the subject, he gave precisely the same formula for the advance of Mercury’s perihelion as that presented by Gerber. Now, by ‘precise’ here I mean not just the same in mathematical terms, but precise in the choice of parameters, their alphabetic notation and the case, upper or lower, that was used by Gerber. I cannot believe there is coincidence in that choice, unless it is that someone before Gerber had already published the formula in that form and that had been seen by both Gerber and by Einstein, which means that there would have to be an even earlier publication of the ultimate formula for rate of planetary perihelion advance. Note that Einstein never acknowledged the prior work of others. He was a genius in the eyes of some, but did they know where his ideas came from?

    Gerber’s paper explained how the anomalous perihelion motion of the planet could be explained by recognizing that gravitation propagated at the speed of light. When Einstein’s paper appeared in Ann. d. Phys. in 1916, a colleague of Gerber arranged for the publication of an updated version of Gerber’s work in the 1917 issue of this same journal. Note that Gerber, a schoolmaster, was then deceased, and so was unable to defend his theory against attack. Given the challenge it posed to Einstein at the time, it is no wonder that it attracted criticism. Sadly, in its detailed derivation of the ultimate formula, it was in error; the direct propagation of gravitational action between sun and planet at the speed of light, which Gerber assumed, only gives a partial account of the anomaly. Even so there were several exchanges recorded as Letters to the Editor in Ann. d. Phys. concerning that Gerber proposition, and there were two sides to that debate.

    Meanwhile, even before the Gerber 1898 publication, as we may read from the opening passage of Leon Brillouin’s book , Relativity Reexamined [4], Heaviside, in 1893, had pointed out that ‘to form any notion at all of the flux of gravitational energy, we must first localize the energy’. If this is taken to heart, it leads us to recognize that the flow of gravitational energy is not directly along the line between sun and planet, but is, of necessity, via a longer route. The energy must flow from one of these bodies to the surrounding field and then from the field to the other body. This modifies the resulting retardation of gravitational action, as calculated in that 1898 Gerber paper, and affects the perihelion motion accordingly. The result, as this author [5] has shown, is in exact accord with that originally predicted by Gerber. In fact, Gerber had the right answer but his paper combined a mathematical error with a slightly incorrect assumption, whereas the adjusted assumption plus correct mathematical analysis gives the same and correct answer, all without regard to the nonsense introduced by Einstein’s theory.

    The above diagrams show the distribution of the field energy E involved in the field interaction between two bodies as a function of distance x from either body. The electric field energy [1979a] is not deployed in the same manner as gravitational field energy [1980b]. The retardation in the action of gravity, as two bodies move relative to one another, can therefore be calculated and its effect on the motion determined. Based on conventional field theory, the corresponding diagram for the magnetic field energy distribution [1980a] is extremely complicated as it is a function of how the direction of motion of charge may vary as well as their separation distance. It does not afford meaningful results and is deemed irrelevant to the gravitational case, thereby explaining why scientists adhering to the Lorentz force law have not been able to unify the field actions of electromagnetism and gravitation. Bear in mind that E in the gravitational case is really an energy deficit, owing to gravitational potential being negative. One interesting way of then interpreting the implications of the above two diagrams is to say that the energy seeks deployment in the field away from the interacting bodies. This means that the electric interaction between two charged bodies, deemed to be of like polarity, develops a mutual repulsion. On the other hand, in the gravitational case, the field energy, in trying to move away from the bodies, brings the negative form closer to them and this implies mutual attraction.

    Einstein’s Law of Gravitation, the only significant consequence of his General Relativity Theory, can be deduced by a simple classical analysis, which exploits the intuitive remark of Oliver Heaviside dating from 1893.
    This, in itself, does not prove that Einstein’s theory is wrong. We do, however, have viable alternative theory which is quite simple, and one must wait for the experimental evidence to direct us on the right course. This evidence is likely to come from measurements evidencing the properties of the ether. Already, in 1980, we have the experimental data of Graham and Lahoz [6] showing that the ether can assert a force, and supporting Marwell. Burrows (Letter to the Editor, Wireless World, October 1981) asserts that this is a one-off measurement needing verification. It is nevertheless backed by the discovery that the Earth’s cosmic motion through space at a speed of some 400 km/s can be detected by measuring anisotropy in the intensity of the 3K background radiation. (See article entitled ‘The Cosmic Background Radiation and the New Aether Drift’ in Scientific American, May 1978). Furthermore, as we shall see below, it is supported by other evidence on electromagnetic-wave propagation suggesting that the Earth’s West-East motion due to its rotation can be directly measured as a linear velocity by optical techniques.

    A further note is interjected at this point to draw attention to the very important evidence that has emerged from the experiments of Dave Gieskieng on electromagnetic wave propagation involving a special radio antenna [Lecture No. 10: Appendix]. I believe that his findings show that the ether is essential in that it accounts for the absorption and dissipation of the propagating magnetic component of wave energy whilst sustaining a standing wave electrical oscillation. Such findings further lead us to a symmetrical form of Maxwell’s equations, thereby providing a more plausible basis for energy deployment activity in the ether itself. This is where justifiable criticism can be levied at the theory of the Poynting vector. Onward analysis on that theme will be necessary, but it is more important that physicists should rethink their interpretation of what they call the ‘photon’. As stated elsewhere in these Web pages [Tutorial No. 8], it is not a particle, being merely an ‘event’, that of an energy transaction as between ether and matter.

    On such a course, the ether is destined for reacceptance and Einstein’s theory will have to yield ground. There is, therefore, purpose in reassessing the ether and its properties, and in this quest we will again be mindful of Heaviside. It is to his great credit that he discovered how to design a telegraph line capable of propagating signals without distortion. The inductive and capacitative properties of a telegraph line cause the speed of propagation to depend upon frequency. By appropriate matching of these properties, as well as resistance and leakance, the attenuated signal can propagate without distortion. Now, electromagnetic waves propagate through the ether without distortion and, though the ether is not subject to resistance and leakance, it does have inductance and capacitance, because there are magnetic fields and electric fields in the vacuum.

    Nature, anticipating Heaviside’s contribution to telegraphic communication, has provided that extra something in the ether to secure distortionless signal propagation. This becomes an important clue in our quest to understand more about the ether.

    Here I interject the comment that, if Heaviside had not invented the distortionless transmission line and the physicists of this world had drifted on in ignorance, as they have concerning the propagation properties of the ether, then the natural philosophical assumption is that a transmission line that can convey distortion free signals is not really there as a real physical form. Evidently, since we know that there is distortion, meaning frequency dispersion, when high frequency signals propagate through real media, then the non-dispersion indication must be an indication that wave energy is travelling through something that is not there. Einstein’s theory would then have had to be embraced by those who are interested in telegraphic communication and it would, one must assume, have served as an obstruction to technological advance. Fortunately, however, thanks to Heaviside’s discovery, that obstruction has been limited to the interpretation of signals from the remote galaxies in the universe, seen erroneously as exhibiting a redshift indicative of an expanding universe, rather than the action of an intervening medium in space which attenuates signal strength.

    However, thanks to Heaviside, we were saved from that situation. Unfortunately, however, even though Heaviside declared that one could not explain how gravity acts across a distance without first localizing the energy involved, his message concerning gravitation was not heeded. That message dates from 1893, some three years after Wiener discovered those standing waves, but somehow physicists of the 1900 era missed their opportunity to solve the gravitation mystery hidden in the anomalous motion of Mercury’s perihelion and they feel prone to the Einstein doctrine and the new faith which then evolved.

    For my part, there were other reasons which convinced me that the ether is a real medium. Indeed, the Wireless World article included an inset box, which contained my photograph together with a few words about my background. These words included the following:

    “Shortly after embarking on a career in the patent profession, some 28 years ago (i.e. 1953), he (Dr. Aspden) had an idea on electromagnetic reaction which intrigued him and led to the firm belief in the need for an ether. Dr. Aspden has had success in his chosen career, having directed IBM’s European Patent Operations for the last 18 years, but his ambition is to achieve success in his private quest to bring the ether back into favour. The very substantial potential which Dr. Aspden sees in an ether is evident from his book ‘Physics Unified’, published in 1980.”

    I retired from IBM in May, 1983 seven months after this Wireless World article was published, in order to concentrate on the latter effort.

    WHY STUDY THE ETHER?

    According to its dictionary definition, ‘ether’ is ‘a medium, not matter, that has been assumed to fill all space and transmit electromagnetic waves’. With such definition, the ‘ether’ remains valid terminology. The problem which some scientists have in accepting the existence of the ether arises from a further assumption that the ether cannot adapt to its environment and so must regulate the constancy of the speed of fight in a universal frame of reference. When motion of the Earth about the sun could not be detected by speed of light measurements in the laboratory frame, the very existence of the ether came under challenge. Yet what logic is there in saying that A is believed to have property B, but we cannot detect property B, so A does not exist? Surely, the only valid conclusion is that A may still exist but it appears not to have property B.

    Why bother? We have Maxwell’s equations and we have relativity. The latter tells us not to expect to detect anything at all except according to physical laws which adapt to the reference frame of an observer. Without an observer, whether real or hypothetical, there can, in relativity, be no definitive physical phenomena. Hence we are supposed to live in a somewhat abstract world and are encouraged not to seek to understand the universal and uniform nature of whatever it is that permeates the vacuum and regulates electromagnetic wave propagation.

    I have good reason for believing that a great deal of opportunity is being missed in scientific and technological research by accepting doctrinaire theory and not keeping an open mind on this ether question. For example, it is to the credit of those engaged in precision measurement in fundamental physics that some constants can now be determined to a few parts in 1012. Such precision defies imagination if related to the measurement tasks we undertake domestically or in industry. Yet, what is really fascinating is that Nature is actually able to regulate physical quantities universally and hold them stable to such accuracy, notwithstanding environmental fluctuations, wherever we in the universe. This surely suggests a fundamental mechanism and a reference or control medium, having a universal metric binding all matter together as part of a common system. To me,this is the primary role of the so-called ether, with the light propagation characteristic assuming secondary importance.

    By postulating an electric but neutral medium of the simplest possible kind and analyzing its structure, as if it were a kind of invisible and elusive crystal extending throughout space, the author [7], in collaboration with Dr D M Eagles of the National Standards Laboratory in Australia, has found it possible to deduce fundamental constants, notably:

    to the measured accuracy of less than one part per million. It is this that has committed me to a course of scientific enquiry founded upon a positive belief in the ether rather than a passive acceptance of a rather sterile theory of relativity [Tutorial No. 8] and [1972a].

    In the above expression, c is the electric charge of the electron, h is Planck’s constant and c is the speed of light in vacuo. Hence the dependence of the fine structure constant upon the metric of the ether medium is very closely linked to electromagnetic wave propagation, because:

    This is Planck’s radiation law. It signifies that the energy propagated as electromagnetic disturbances at the speed of light is packaged in units which have energy E, given that the frequency is E/h.

    It is a relatively simple task to show that this structured vacuum medium which allows the precise value of that fine structure constant to be determined theoretically and which, of course, delivers the two physical formulae just presented, can accommodate to the propagation properties of electromagnetic waves, and particularly on two basic counts. These are: (a) the fact that the speed of propagation is referred not to an absolute frame but to one which can adapt to the reference frame of an Earthly observer and (b) the equally important fact that light travelling in true vacuum suffers no dispersion resulting from its speed varying with frequency.

    From the optical characteristics of ionic crystals it is known that there is dispersion, significant at frequencies in the vicinity of the natural resonant frequency of the crystal. One should than bear in mind that energy quanta of sufficient strength can induce the creation of electron-positron pairs in the vacuum. This suggests that the ether sets a critical frequency threshold (the Compton electron frequency) and so may have an electrical structure conforming with this resonant frequency. Thus, in proposing a kind of crystal structure for the vacuum medium and establishing, as I have [7], that it has a natural frequency given by:

    one is led directly into the question of frequency dispersion.

    Before dealing with this, consider first the other problem. Michelson’s experiments towards the end of the 19th century have shown that the Earth itself determines the local frame in which light has a speed c independent of direction. This is not in the least surprising if we admit the vacuum medium to be electrically-structured. Lorentz has shown that, according to classical electron theory, the speed of light in matter depends upon electron density and the oscillation period of such electrons in such material media. Electron density does not depend upon rotation, nor is it a vector. therefore, the speed of light (as opposed to its direction) should be unaffected by rotation. Hence, if there is any theoretical connection or analogy between this situation in matter and what may govern the speed of light in vacuum, the expectation must be that, in the laboratory vacuum, the speed of light is referred to the Earth’s inertial (non-rotating) frame. An experiment aimed at detecting the Earth’s rotation using optical techniques referred to the vacuum should give a positive result.

    Such an experiment was performed by Michelson in 1925, confirming the classical expectation from ether theory by sensing the Earth’s rotation. Earlier, Sagnac had sensed the rotation of optical apparatus by speed of light measurement, a technique now applied in the ring-laser gyro. It is assumed that detection of speed of rotation accords with relativity, owing to parts of the rotating apparatus having motion relative to other parts. On the other hand, if such experiments permit comparison of the speed of light East-West versus West-East and afford linear speed difference, it is relativity that is in difficulty. With the advance of optical measurement techniques, it should soon be possible to resolve this question.

    For translational motion with the Earth, the vacuum structure acquires a linear displacement. Clearly, any displacement of electric charge in the vacuum must be transitory and oscillatory, unless it is balanced by a matching counterflow or reverse displacement of some of the charge present. Otherwise there would be a steady build-up of charge and an ever-increasing electric field. One may, therefore, visualize the vacuum as having two charge structures capable of moving through one another in opposite directions. This is quite possible because there are no rigid bonds between the chargers, just electric field interactions.

    It is this dual structure for charge displacement that is the key. The primary structure moves forward with the Earth. The secondary structure moves through the primary structure in the reverse direction and, by analogy with an optical effect named after Fresnel, we expect this reverse flow to affect the speed of light through the primary structure. Fresnel’s theory explains why the speed of light increases in proportion to:

    where u is the velocity of the disturbing medium. This can be deduced from electron theory, but it has been verified by experiments in which the speed of light through moving water is measured.

    Applying this same theory to the vacuum itself, and recognizing the counter displacement, it is an easy matter to arrive at the result discovered experimentally by the Michelson-Morley observations.

    We do not need to appeal to relativity for an explanation of this basic observation. The Michelson-Morley experiment verifies that Maxwell’s electric displacement theory can be a dual and reciprocal phenomenon. Oscillations of the electrical structure of the vacuum can occur at the resonant Compton electron frequency with no reverse motion of the secondary structure or counter-displacement. However, we may expect light propagation at lower frequencies to involve counter-displacement and it is this that brings a new and important dimension to Maxwell’s theory. With it comes a solution to the dispersion problem.

    Note that the frequency of an electromagnetic wave has no meaning at a point in space and time. Frequency concerns rate of change and this information implies comparison of signal strengths at two points in time or two points in space. However, given dual displacement at a point in space, as we now have in the theory just presented, the frequency can be codified by the relative strengths of the two displacement parameters.

    The frequency of the signal is, in fact, preserved in transit through the vacuum medium, because the medium propagates two electric displacement signals in anti-phase, and the relative amplitude of the signal strengths determines the frequency. As we shall now see, this involves the vacuum adjusting to the signal in transit to adopt a locally-tuned condition having the resonant frequency of the signal. The frequency at which electron-position pair creation occurs is the limit frequency beyond which there is no counter-displacement. However, the interesting point is that there is no forced oscillation and so no dispersion characteristic in the vacuum, since the vacuum adapts to any frequency and exhibits the properties of a tuned LC system.

    Such analysis assures us that the vacuum medium does not forcibly respond to the dynamic frequency characteristics of a signal. It propagates the primary and secondary displacements and the local vacuum resonates at the optimum frequency set by these displacements. In this way the signal frequency is preserved over vast distances.

    The dual electrical displacement suggested above greatly strengthens the base on which one can develop a phenomenological ether theory supporting Maxwell’s equations. More important, however, it opens the path for new avenues of research into the effects of energy absorption from electromagnetic waves and their mutual interference. Meanwhile, note that Einstein’s E=Mc2, the keystone of special relativity and his law of gravitation, the basis of his general relativity, have both succumbed to alternative explanation [5-8].

    It is likely to be in the optical measurement field, involving speed of light tests in relation to Earth rotation, that we may see the determining experiments, crucial to relativity. The Ether will surely survive.

    References

    1. H. A. Wilson,’Modern Physics’, 2nd. Ed., Blackie, 1946.
    2. J. H. Jeans, Nature, v.70, p.101 (1904).
    3. P. Gerber, Zeitschrift f. Math. u. Phys., v.43, p.93 (1898).
    4. L. Brillouin, ‘Relativity Reexamined’, Academic Press, 1970.
    5. H. Aspden, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen., v.13, p.3649 (1980).
    6. G. M. Graham and D. H. Lahoz, Nature, v.285, p.154 (1980).
    7. H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles, Physics Letters, v.41A, p.423 (1972).

    8. H. Aspden, Int. Jour. Theor. Phys., v.15, p.631 (1976).


    Harold Aspden
  • LECTURE NO. 23

    LECTURE NO. 23

    MENTAL INERTIA AND NEW ENERGY TECHNOLOGY

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    These comments were compiled as an aide memoire some two to three days prior to my participation in a discussion meeting on new energy topics held in London on May 10th, 1998.

    They constitute a brief summary of points which I feel need to be made in a general debate on how to progress in the task of awakening interest in new and revolutionary energy conversion techniques which, at this time, challenge orthodox science and so are not welcomed by those who advise on research funding.

    CONCERNING THE TITLE

    In the above title I refer to ‘Mental Inertia’. What is meant by this is the difficulty of deflecting the thought processes of the vast majority of physicists concerning heat and power generation, which seem to move forward relentlessly following a single track, that which conforms with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

    Heat dispersed into space is somehow lost forever. It has no destiny except infinity. As a result, the minds of those who ponder upon such questions, drift off themselves into that wilderness of infinity. Why not pause and surmise that, notwithstanding what we do achieve by building and testing heat engines, which spend energy, Nature has her own secret ways of processing spent energy and forcing it into a temporary holding condition, a ‘quantum dance’, before it can be packaged as a proton and released back into our real world. We see matter all around us. It is built from protons and electrons. Somehow it was created, necessarily from energy. Where did that energy come from? If you think the universe is a one-off product that came off God’s production line some ten or so billion years ago, then you are not thinking as I do. I think each and every proton is created by an ongoing mass-production process fed by energy tapped from that dispersed throughout space. If those who advise on energy research know otherwise, then they should explain how they know! It is an important issue warranting debate.

    Apart from that issue I am also suggesting that scientists have developed a mental block by relying too heavily upon their Second Law of Thermodynamics. They suffer from ‘mental inertia’ and it is to the detriment of progress on the ‘New Energy’ front.

    THE ENERGY SOURCE

    Energy cannot be ‘created’. It can only be converted from one form to another. Ignoring the usual energy sources, whether oil, gas, coal, nuclear, hydroelectric power, wind power and even solar power, there is new energy territory to be explored. There are two sources latent to our environment. One is the ambient heat, the energy stored in our atmosphere and the other is the energy stored locally in the quantum underworld of the vacuum state.

    Concerning the first of these sources, physicists reject the notion that exploitation of ambient heat is possible, because they live under the spell of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. As to the second of these sources, they refuse to believe that there is any energy in space other than that which is an extension of the matter form owing to what they term the ‘fields’, the electric and magnetic action of matter upon nearby space. Whether it is Einstein’s theory that has brushed the aether aside or quantum theory that provides them with pacifying answers, they choose not to recognize these two important sources of energy.

    Now, for the purpose of these notes I can only comment briefly on the major source, that vested in space, so I will do that first.

    Simply put, that source of energy hidden in the quantum underworld is the power house which creates the protons and electrons from which all matter in the universe is formed, whether as hydrogen atoms or as transmuted atoms formed from those protons and electrons. I can prove that proposition by showing how an understanding of the process involved can explain the precise value of the mass of the proton in terms of the mass of the electron. By precise I mean fully in agreement with the degree of its precision measurement, a part or so in ten million. However, that is mere theory.

    When we come to view this in the context of the real world, we can look at the phenomenon of ‘cold fusion’ and ask how it is that two atomic nuclei, that of hydrogen and that of heavy hydrogen, namely the proton and the deuteron can come close enough together to combine or transmute their forms in such a way as to shed energy. You might say that all those atoms were created long ago in something called the ‘Big Bang’ which is an event far removed from what can be happening here and now in the space local to body Earth. However, in that case you too would then be indulging in mere theory.

    In the obituary of Sir Charles Frank, reported on page 25 of the British newspaper THE TIMES of Monday, April 27, 1998, there is the statement that he was ‘an inspirational physicist who worked in a wide range of fields, from earthquakes to cold fusion’. There was a later comment in the obituary which referred again to cold fusion, by saying that:

    “Charles Frank was the first scientist to think of the idea of cold nuclear fusion. In 1947 he suggested using an elementary subnuclear particle, a muon, to catalyse the fusion of deuterium and tritium. It would take the electron’s place and allow the nuclei to approach some 200 times closer than usual, and so help produce fusion.”

    The problem with that idea is that the muon, which is otherwise known as the ‘heavy’ electron, just as the deuteron can be said to be the ‘heavy’ proton, is a mystery in itself. In fact, it has a ‘ghostly’ existence, to my way of thinking, because it is the primary ‘stuff’ which accounts for the energy of space, but that fact is not appreciated by the world of science. I know that to be a fact because my explanation of the creation of the proton involves the combination of those aethereal muons!

    So the evolving cold fusion scene will, I expect, one day make us appreciate the existence of that energy source in space. Meanwhile, however, I shall myself pursue another route aimed at gaining access to that sea of energy in space, namely by the process of magnetic induction designed to involve ‘magnetocaloric cooling’ of the vacuum medium. That introduces my interest in certain forms of magnetic reluctance motor, but to explain that in detail is also just a little too specific for the immediate purpose of these notes. So, apart from referring below to the problem of testing ‘over-unity’ performance, I shall here restrict my onward comments to the somewhat related subject of extracting energy from ambient heat in defiance of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

    THE SELF-GENERATING HEAT ENGINE

    It is not ‘perpetual motion’ in the sense of a machine that runs on no power but delivers power. No, it is simply a machine which absorbs heat from the atmosphere and generates an electrical power output. It is the ideal of a kind of air-conditioning system which cools but yet uses the heat extracted to produce useful power as output, sufficient power in excess of that needed to run the cooling system, so that the surplus is provided as ‘free energy’ output.

    That might seem to be an impossible ideal, but it is possible, given two heat engines connected back-to-back, if one is a conventional engine operating as a reverse heat engine, namely as a heat pump, and the other is an engine which feeds on heat but is not governed by Carnot efficiency limitations.

    I may add here that I have even secured grant of a U.S. Patent which includes the description of such a system and has a claim pertaining to that very proposition. It is the last claim of my U.S. Patent No. 5,101,632. It is noted that the subject of that patent has been introduced earlier in these Web pages as Lecture No. 17.

    To implement an energy generating process such as this, however, the main requirement is to have a device which does convert heat into electricity without the Carnot restraint imposed by compliance with that Second Law of Thermodynamics. The structure proposed in that U.S. patent would need extensive development of a technique of fabrication of a cellular mirror structure that deploys internal heat radiation.

    An alternative which warrants development is a technique based on the fabrication of a laminar structure composed of ferromagnetic metal films or plates. This is also described in the patent literature (U.S. Patent No. 5,288,336 and U.S. Patent No. 5,376,184) but it is felt that scientists generally need to be enlightened concerning the technical reason why the device functions, notwithstanding that Second Law of Thermodynamics.

    Now, instead of describing such a device in detail, I will point my finger at something that is occurring throughout the energy world everywhere, namely a phenomenon present in every electrical power transformer. This is the fact that there is an electrical power loss in the transformer that is a complete mystery to those who design them, including the university professors who teach those designers.

    Every power transformer that has a laminated steel core is subject to what is called ‘iron loss’, the magnetization losses which are ongoing when the transformer is connected in the power transmission circuit. There is a component of that loss which is attributable to magnetic induction of currents which circulate in each core lamination. Those currents involve higher losses than one expects from theoretical calculation based on a knowledge of the resistivity of the steel. For that to be the case there has to be something wrong with the theory underlying the calculation. Yet the electrical theory involved is a fairly exact science and errors of calculation as such can be ruled out, which leaves us having to face up to the fact that some physical phenomenon is present but not taken into account.

    That phenomenon is the fact that heat flowing from the transformer by passage through those laminations is being regenerated as electrical drive power which augments those circulating eddy currents and increases the loss which develops that heat!

    Now, the temperature difference between the centre of a transformer core and the surfaces across which it cools is little more than 10 or 20 degrees C. A conventional heat pump can elevate heat through such a temperature and require only one tenth as much energy as input to power the heat pump as is transferred between those temperatures. So one might suspect that the opposite applies when it comes to heat regenerating electricity, meaning that, at best, only one tenth of the normal heat loss could be converted back to electricity to augment that eddy current flow. In that case the eddy current anomaly factor, meaning actual eddy current loss, as measured, in relation to the theoretical eddy current loss would be a factor of ten or so per cent above unity.

    However, if that were the case, the ‘eddy current anomaly’ would never have been significant enough to be noticed. The overall eddy current anomaly factor came to attention when the technology of fabricating electrical steel laminations developed to the point where attempts to reduce eddy currents were confounded by the measured anomaly factor being 2 or 3 and sometimes higher, though 1.5 was the tolerable norm. In my own experiments as part of my Ph.D. research on this subject in the early 1950s I measured factors as high as 5 and 6. That is an additional loss of 400% or 500% and not a mere 10% extra loss.

    That can only mean one thing, now that I can see the evidence in retrospect, some 48 years on, and am no longer blighted by science orthodoxy pertaining to that Second Law of Thermodynamics. The heat generated is, in part, indeed for the most part, being regenerated as electricity inside the metal lamination. There can be no doubt that the conversion efficiencies involved exceed by far those set by the Carnot criteria which govern the conventional heat engine. I would suggest also that the so-called ‘warm superconductors’ are highly conductive because they are, internally, regenerating as a forward electrical action 100% of any heat shed by resistance effects.

    Based on such evidence those interested in new methods of generating energy must surely see the scope for exploiting the phenomenon. Its underlying cause is known in physics as the Nernst Effect, the thermoelectric effect by which heat flow through a magnetic field develops an electric EMF at right angles to the heat flow and the field direction.

    A device which I believe worked on this principle, has been demonstrated by John Scott Strachan. It is the subject of that U.S. Patent No. 5,288,336 mentioned above. It was shown to be able to run an electric motor, the only input being the temperature differential of a melting ice block such as one might put in one’s whisky glass. It was shown to operate in reverse, freezing water efficiently and rapidly when fed by an electrical power input.

    TESTING OF ‘OVER-UNITY’ DEVICES

    One of the major problems experienced by inventors of energy devices which exhibit anomalous power generation properties, is that of convincing an observer viewing a demonstration.

    Investors and those who advise investors and corporations who might develop the invention need absolute proof of viability of the technology. Demonstrations are suspect. Consider, for example, the problems confronting Dr. Paulo Correa and his wife Alexandra who have invented a glow discharge tube which delivers d.c. power output in pulses in amounts exceeding the electrical d.c. input power. The proof, so far as the inventors are concerned, resides in the fact that a battery of many electric cells supplies the input power and the output power charges an exhausted, but similar, battery of electric cells. This takes time and, if measurements are made for short interval runs, the energy involved, whether as input or output, is dependent upon simple d.c. calculations based on measurements of d.c. voltages that change by a small amount and a prior calibration of the cells to determine energy stored as a function of voltage.

    Ideally, one needs to measure the instantaneous energy activity to compare input and output in an ongoing manner. However, the pulsatory nature of the output, even when monitored by oscilloscopic means, makes it difficult to have trust in such measurements.

    A similar situation arises where one tests an electric motor that needs input energy to keep it operational but develops its output power mechanically by feeding a load, which, however, may be an electrical generator. That compounds the measurement problem because much depends upon the efficiency of the generator, rather than that of the motor. This applies, for example, to the motor developments of Dr. Robert Adams in New Zealand. It applies also to my own motor measurements, where to satisfy myself that ‘over-unity’ performance was in evidence I had to calculate the heat loss generated by pulsing the drive windings of the motor.

    Note that where input or output power involves transients and pulses one cannot rely on normal measuring instruments to give the relevant reading on a dial. One has to be sure that an energy anomaly is in evidence and one really needs a way of demonstrating that fact to others who witness the tests.

    For this reason I think it worth suggesting that tests in such circumstances can suffice as a demonstration if the power input to the machine is d.c. as drawn from an electric battery source, or normal a.c. if the source waveform is not distorted, whilst the output is all converted directly into heat. Then, by encasing the machine and/or the load in a thermally insulated enclosure, albeit one that does convect the same rate of heat from its surface without acquiring too high a temperature, one can monitor the internal temperature of that enclosure to see how it depends upon machine operation.

    Suppose, for example, that the test machine draws 100 watts of input power when delivering electrical output power to a load located outside that enclosure. It will, after a short period have settled to its operating state, meaning its own temperature will have stabilized. Meanwhile, by controlling the delivery of a calibrating power input to a heating resistor inside that enclosure one can see what stable temperature is reached by precisely the same amount of power, 100 watts, as is being fed into the test machine.

    Then the test consists of switching off the calibrating power input and switching the output from the test machine to supply heat input to the enclosure. If now the temperature being measured increases one has ‘over-unity’ operation as between test machine output versus input, not allowing for operational heat loss from the machine itself. To allow for the latter, the test machine needs to be located within the enclosure as well.

    In summary, therefore, with such a test procedure, given that one can measure electrical power input with little difficulty and the test then only depends upon watching a thermometer to see if its temperature goes up, I can see no reason why demonstrations of ‘over-unity’ performance cannot be made convincing. Besides that, such tests would not involve the need to disclose know-how or design details or even the principles of how the machine or device under test operates. The test could be adapted to estimate the degree of over-unity once its existence has been proved. For example, if the device delivers twice as much power output as it takes as input, then the calibration could be at 200 watts to see if the test temperature can be held with the 100 watt device input.

    On the other hand, if, to convince investors, the demonstration is intended to display a commercially viable working prototype ready for market production, then that is another story. I tend to believe that the real problem is one of convincing academic scientists and development engineers that ‘over-unity’, in the sense of generating excess power, as if from the environment alone, is a real possibility. If the test protocol I propose would not suffice for that purpose then that problem I call ‘Mental Inertia’ is worse than I could have imagined.