Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • LECTURE NO. 12

    LECTURE NO. 12

    WHY HAWKING IS WRONG!

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1998

    Introduction

    The time has come when the wild imagination of those who indulge in cosmological theory based on the Big Bang theme needs to be tamed by reminding its proponents of something they should have learned in their student days. I am writing these words on February 25th, 1998 and have in mind a brief article by Nick Nuttall which has appeared here in U.K. in THE TIMES of Monday February 23rd, two days ago. Under the heading ‘The Universe will expand for ever, says Hawking’, it reads:

    The Universe began as a tiny particle, Stephen Hawking, the scientist and bestselling author has concluded. The Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University has turned his attention to what may have happened in the fraction of a second before Big Bang. Professor Hawking and Neil Turok, also of Cambridge, believe that not only was there a microscopic particle but that it was expanding in a process known as inflation just before Big Bang …… Their theory, based on one put forward by Professor Hawking in 1983 and Einstein’s theory of gravity, also concludes that the universe will expand for ever. …. The theory pointed to the Universe being cone-shaped, having started out as a dot in space and time and expanding like an ice-cream cornet over the 12 billion years. Professor Hawking will outline the theory at a meeting next month at the California Institute of Technology.

    Now, it is extremely easy, and involves quite elementary physics, to prove that the universe, governed as it is by the standard physics of electric fields, is subject to the space constraints imposed by planar boundaries. Were this not so, the energy density stored by an electric field would not conform with the established empirical formulations of fundamental physics. This precludes the evolution of a universe, one which necessarily embraces the field medium associated with its electric fields, as expanding from a point, even in a symmetric spherical expansion. Furthermore, one must challenge the very belief that the universe expands, given that it is based on the assumption that light waves once emitted by a radiating atom never ever suffer a loss of frequency in their billions of years of passage through space. I have discussed this latter point in the previous lecture, Lecture No. 11, but I will seek in this Lecture No. 12 to clarify what I have just said about the planar space boundary.

    A LETTER TO STEPHEN HAWKING

    I have, in Lectures 10 and 11, referred to the findings of Dave Gieskieng from his canyon experiments in Colorado. Well, looking through my piles of papers and concerning Gieskieng, I see that I was in correspondence with him from a period beginning in 1983. I find amongst those papers a copy of a letter which Dave Gieskieng sent to Stephen Hawking, bearing the date 31 March, 1984. I will quote it below in full, because I wish to make the point that Gieskieng was urging Hawking to consider the implications of his antenna research some 14 years ago.

    S. W. Hawking
    University of Cambridge
    Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics
    Silver Street
    Cambridge CB3 9EW
    England

    Dear Mr. Hawking:

    Thank you for the copy of your paper, THE LIMITS OF SPACE AND TIME. One of the central themes appears to be gravity, and I thought that you might be interested in a paper I wrote some time ago, DOES AETHER CAUSE GRAVITY? It would seem to be the only medium universal enough to accommodate both radio and gravitation.

    Harold Aspden of Southampton was kind enough to review my paper that you have, and suggested that I might write a brief paper, concentrating upon one of its graphs. This has just been done with rather startling perceptions of the aether and electric fields emerging. It is two pages, and titled: A CHARACTERIZATION OF THE AETHER.

    In my previous efforts on this I have not been able to get the radio magazines interested in the antenna and its results. Since you have had some success with the more scientific publication, Nature, I am wondering if you would care to perhaps join in critiquing it for submittal to them. Would you have any other suggestions?

    Yours sincerely,
    (signed)
    D. H. Gieskieng
    9653 Renselaer Dr.
    Arvada, Colorado 80004
    U.S.A.

    Now, let me say at once that I am not in the least surprised that this letter made no impact of Professor Hawking. Hawking is wedded to Einstein’s theory and the Big Bang. He is hardly likely to be interested in anything which implies interest in the ‘aether’ and he is a theoretical physicist, with a cosmological speciality, so experiments involving radio antenna are unlikely to evoke his interest. Nor, indeed, are such letters from non-academic sources likely to be given more than a cursory glance. That said, however, the point is made that the experimental evidence which I see as a killer, so far as Big Bang theory is concerned, is there in those Gieskieng experiments. The aether, the non-expanding aether, with its energy attributes and its planar boundaries governing how electromagnetic waves shed energy to rely on aether energy, is playing its part in those experiments by Dave Gieskieng.

    A LESSON ON ELECTRICAL SCIENCE

    The most fundamental property of space, meaning what we regard as the vacuum, is that it can store energy. We are introduced to this in our early lessons in physics by learning about parallel plate capacitors. Whether there is air between the capacitor plates or a vacuum, it has very little effect on the amount of energy one can store between two parallel metal plates by setting up a voltage between the plates.

    We know that most of that energy is stored in that something that we admit occupies the so-called vacuum. Teachers avoid reference to it as ‘the aether’. They prefer to assign a dielectric constant to the vacuum and then tell us that there is really nothing there inside that vacuum. If we define the vacuum as ‘space devoid of matter’ then that does not preclude the presence of that ‘something’, which I say is the ‘aether’. The teacher avoids the word and, if pressed, hides behind a screen of mathematics representing Maxwell’s equations, but a discerning student knows that there is an aether, whatever the textbooks may say. However, I am sure that some students must be so disillusioned by the lack of physical reality and reliance of mere mathematical formulations, all arising from the aether being ‘outlawed’ that some, at least, must turn away from physics and, as a result, wander into other fields of learning.

    There is an aether! To store energy in that aether, in accordance with the facts observed by experiment, it must have planar boundaries. A parallel plate capacitor has such boundaries, but take away the metal plates and, somehow, somewhere in the space we inhabit, there exists those boundaries as a property of space itself. Otherwise, the energy density stored in the vacuum medium by an electric field would not conform with the formulae that we know are valid.

    There is really no sense in imagining that the material universe can begin as a point and then spread to infinity, if one admits there is an aether present that already extends to infinity. What is the sense in trying to create a universe from ‘nothing’ – a mere point in space – when common sense tells us that if there is an aether present thoughout space, that aether is the likely source of the energy which feeds the creation of the universe? The universe should be associated with matter which is created throughout space and merely nucleates to form stars everywhere in space. So, to talk about expansion of the universe from a point one needs to explain how energy drawn from the aether ever converged on that point or bring the aether itself into the expansion scheme.

    I wonder if Professor Hawking has even thought of this, because it is rather basic and it bears heavily upon his conclusions concerning the expanding form of the universe. The chances are that for ‘aether’ he substitutes Einstein’s mathematical equations and it is then rather difficult to separate an argument about the ‘universe’ and whatever it is that those equations represent.

    I will try not to comment further in this style and will, instead, concentrate on merely presenting some additional background information and then the formal elementary proof of the planar space boundary proposition.

    THE UNIVERSE PRE-HAWKING

    It was in December 1954 that Albert Einstein signed off on the Preface Note of the Fifth Edition of his book The Meaning of Relativity. Contemporary with that the University of Cambridge issued Abstracts of Dissertations, the ones approved for research degrees 1953-1954. Amongst those dissertation abstracts, which included the one relating to my Ph.D. degree, there was one entitled ‘On the Origin of Inertia’ by Dennis Sciama. Sciama in later years provided the supervision for the PhD. research of Stephen Hawking.

    Writing about the meaning of his General Theory, I see on page 107 of that book by Einstein a set of conclusions which read:

    Thus we may present the following arguments against the conception of a space-infinite, and for the conception of a space-bounded, or closed, universe:-
    1. From the standpoint of the theory of relativity, to postulate a closed universe is very much simpler than to postulate the corresponding boundary condition at infinity of the quasi-Euclidean structure of the universe.
    2. The idea that Mach expressed, that inertia depends upon the mutual action of bodies, is contained, to a first approximation, in the equations of the theory of relativity; it follows from those equations that inertia depends, at least in part, upon mutual actions between masses. But this idea of Mach’s corresponds only to a finite universe, bounded in space, and not to a quasi-Euclidean, infinite universe. From the standpoint of epistomology it is more satisfying to have the mechanical properties of space completely determined by matter, and this is the case only in a closed universe.
    3. An infinite universe is possible only if the mean density of matter in the universe vanishes. Although such an assumption is logically possible, it is less probable than the assumption that there is a finite mean density of matter in the universe.

    So this tells us that we need to understand inertia before we really can say much about the limits of space and our universe, which brings us to the Sciama’s Ph.D. dissertation. It was entitled ‘On the Origin of Inertia’. The abstract tells us that:

    As Einstein himself was the first to point out, general relativity does not fully account for inertia. Thus a new theory of gravitation is needed.

    The abstract goes on to refer to:

    a precise theory, according to which local observations of inertia suffice to specify the large-scale structure of the universe.

    So here we see that the scale of the universe, its shape and its boundary form, as well as its evolution over time, are matters intimately interwoven with the theory of relativity, but ever dependent upon our understanding of what it is that endows a particle with its inertial property or mass. It is not sufficient to declare that E=Mc2; one must know why it is that E is equal to Mc2!

    The Mach principle was deemed as governing inertia back in 1954.

    Well, a decade later, I had evolved my own theory of gravitation based on a structured aether and the numbers, meaning those that related to the relationship between G, the constant of gravitation, electron mass and charge etc., came out right only if I assumed that E=Mc2 was attributable to the non-radiation of energy by the accelerated charge. Here I was saying that if you try to accelerate an electric charge by putting it in an electric field, i.e. by causing other charges to act upon it, it will react to resist dissipation of its energy. It will seek to preserve itself – a normal reaction one can surely expect – and that means a reluctance to move spontaneously as it prefers to move in just such a way as to keep its energy in proper order. Here was the the property of inertia and that E=Mc2 formula was derived on that basis, namely that energy is conserved and not shed by radiation. In one single step I had circumnavigated around Einstein’s theory and solved the mystery of inertia, but I had no need to even think about the far-off deployment of mass at the outer bounds of the universe and its gravitational interaction with the particle in question.
    I visited Cambridge from time to time and one day called in to chat about this with someone in the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics in Silver Street. That ‘someone’ who gave attention to my request was Sciama. He invited me to join him over his tea break and we talked about my theory. Sciama was courteous but I had scored no success. I left with my ears recollecting his words of advice: “if you write about these matters you should not use the word ‘aether’. Yes, there is an ‘aether’, but we call it ‘space-time’”

    It was another ten years on before, the E=Mc2 proposition of mine, though published in my 1966 book The Theory of Gravitation was finally accepted as a formal peer reviewed paper by the International Journal of Theoretical Physics,
    1976b.

    So far as the above Einstein conclusions are concerned, by eliminating the Mach principle as an explanation of inertia I had no need to be concerned about whether the Universe was closed or infinite, but I do wonder how Stephen Hawking can theorize on these matters without a proper understanding of the nature of inertia.

    I will come now to my own theme concerning the boundary conditions governing the medium that fills space.

    PLANAR SPACE BOUNDARY THEORY

    I have already, in Essay No. 2 in these Web pages presented the case for establishing that space is ‘sliced’, as it were, into segments which have planar boundaries. However, I will develop the argument here from a slightly different standpoint.

    Firstly, imagine that someone tells you that the surface of the United States of America is expanding steadily. That either means that it is growing at the edges where it interfaces with the oceans or it is literally stretching outwards everywhere as if it is supported on a elastic base which is expanding. The question one might then ask is how this might affect the division of U.S.A. into its several states. Would there be need to add new states to the areas formed at the boundaries or will all the existing states get progressively larger in the process?

    Now, that is not something one needs to worry about, but let me now come to my second point. Imagine instead a block of steel which is progressively extended by welding on more and more steel. As physicists already known and as cosmologists should already know, that body of steel comprises minute ‘states’ called ‘magnetic domains’, each one populated by many trillions of iron atoms. Those domains, which have planar boundaries and measure of the order of 100 microns between adjacent planar boundaries, do not expand in proportion to the growing size of that steel block. In fact, new domains are added as the block grows, because those domains are governed by macroscopic physical conditions not deriving from the individual component atoms within the domain. Those conditions are linked to the collective properties of a number of those atoms, determined in conjunction with the electrical properties of the underlying medium, space or aether, however you might choose to term it, but really the capacity of that medium to store field energy.

    In short, there is, in every piece of steel, indeed in every ferromagnetic substance, a latent presence of domains which exist in their own right, governed solely by the way in which energy present chooses to deploy itself to suit its optimum lifestyle.

    Now, what I am coming to by this argument is the proposition that, on a very large scale, extending throughout outer space, the presence of matter which we see as the ‘universe’ exists in an all-pervading system of space domains each of which has planar boundaries. This is not really hypothesis, because if you do not accept what I am suggesting then you have grounded yourself as a physicist until you wrestle with and resolve the issue of how it is that the energy density of an electric field in the vacuum medium can possibly have the value as formulated in your textbooks. Yes, you can say that empirical data based on observations here on body Earth are sufficient for your needs, but if you are a theoretical physicist, especially a cosmologist, you cannot build your notions with confidence unless you can deduce that energy density formulation by theory which takes full account of boundary conditions applicable in space, even in outer space!

    At this point it may comfort the reader if I quote two paragraphs from a paper on this subject published by the Italian Institute of Physics in 1983. See: 1983k in these Web pages.

    Modern physical theory is tending to regard the vacuum medium as having structure somewhat analogous to that of crystalline materials. Thus we see WEISSKOPF [1] discussing quantum electroweak dynamics and asserting that the Higgs field implies that the vacuum has a certain fixed direction in isospace, namely that of the spinor associated with the Higgs field. WEISSKOPF states that the situation is like that of a ferromagnet, in which the direction in real space is determined as long as the energy transfers are smaller than the Curie energy.

    This, of course, implies an ordered structure of the vacuum medium, a feature discussed at some length by REBBI [2] in an article entitled The Lattice Theory of Quark Confinement. REBBI refers to a 1974 proposal by Wilson that QCD (Quantum Chromodynamics) should be formulated on a cubic lattice, an array that divides space and time into discrete points, but is essentially an approximation to real space-time. The advantage is that this allows calculations to be made that would otherwise be impossible.

    The references just introduced are:

    [1] V. F. Weisskopf: Physics Today, 69 (1981)
    [2] C. Rebbi: Scientific American, v. 248, 36 (1983)

    You see! Physicists have a very complicated way of communicating their agony at not being able to fathom what is really going on in space. Given that admission that there is the glimmer of a connection with ferromagnetism, let us move on by keeping our physics in proper perspective.

    The planar domains in steel should be your clue, if you venture to theorize about the expansion of the universe and wonder about its outer bounds. Indeed, you should be very careful about how you define your ‘universe’, because there is that something in space that provides the storehouse for the energy which comes with your material universe and you cannot just ignore its extent and the simple question of whether it also ‘expands’ with your universe. If you believe in Einstein’s theory then you really have to weigh how that four-space system shares that expansion.

    Where Stephen Hawking’s ‘cone-shaped’ universe expanding from a point and destined to go on a never-ending trek all the way to infinity, fits into the picture of reality, you must judge for yourself. My case is that space contains planar boundaries and I do not see them as part of a universal expansion. Do not be deceived by the conical sections I shall introduce below to develop the mathematical analysis. I am merely sectionalizing space into segments defined by spherical angles to perform elemental analysis before merging the results to apply to space as a whole.

    Note that the task is to explain how energy is stored in space. To store energy in a linear system you need to do work against a force arising from the distortion of whatever it is that fills that space. By linear system I mean one with a linear force rate. Twice the force implies four times the energy stored. This is the essential ingredient of simple harmonic motion, and related oscillations, as well as the property of electric and magnetic fields. So, space must contain something that has two parts which it tries to keep together but which we separate slightly by storing energy.

    The obvious assumption then is that we are talking here about electric charge, which comes in positive and negative forms that attract one another, but which can, at least in a macroscopic sense, compensate one another if not displaced by storing energy. The question then is how boundaries can form within such a system to create something analogous to those domains. To answer this we need to introduce an asymmetrical property. There is something special about negative charge compared with positive charge in what we see as our local space, but that feature inverts as between the two charge polarities in an adjacent region of space, thereby giving scope for defining a boundary between two types of vacuum medium, shall we say ‘space’ and ‘anti-space’?

    Speculate if you will about how this can be and be guided by a clue I now offer. Maybe positive and electric charge are really only states of an oscillating system. All positive charges share the same oscillation phase and all negative charges share the same phase of oscillation but the latter are in anti-phase with the former. Yes, that involves instantaneous action at a distance, but we are talking here about electric charges fields and not propagating disturbances characterized by electric and magnetic field effects. Remember that quantum theory requires action at a distance to be effective in the Coulomb gauge.

    What then is that asymmetry? I will illustrate what I have in mind. Referring to the following figure, suppose that in one domain of space there are negative charges which are depicted in white and that these are set in a a continuum of positive charge which is depicted by a black background. The amount of charge of the two opposite polarities is the same in any domain. It is just that one form is concentrated in a kind of particle form, whereas the other is spread thinly as a uniformly dispersed charge form. Then, in an adjacent space domain, these charge forms are reversed, the negative charge being the background continuum and the positive charge having the particle-like form.

    There will be a planar boundary between the two space domains. Now you may ask why this is important and the answer to that emerges once we consider the effects of actions which displace those charged particles from their positions of equilibrium. This is an action which stores energy, the physical basis for electric field energy as stored in the vacuum.

    We shall suppose that all those charged particles in a given region of space are displaced in unison when an electric field is present and this means that they retain their relative positions. The force we are considering is the force on each such displaced charge that arises from the electric interaction with that background continuum in the local space domain.

    We will define an area A subtended by a cone, the apex of which is at point P and which has a spherical angle S. See the following figure.

    Our object is to determine the force acting on a charge at P and attributable to a planar slice of the background charge continuum distant y from P. That planar slice is parallel with the space domain boundaries of the domain region in which P is located. See the next figure, where the boundaries are those separating the local (green) domain and the adjacent (black) domains.

    Let q denote the charge density of the background continuum and assign the charge at P a unit value. Then the charge in the section denoted by the area A is qA(dy), where dy is the elemental thickness of the planar slice of the continuum as shown. The electrostatic force acting on the charge at P will be an attractive force pulling the charge towards the planar slice. By the inverse square force law it will be of value qA(dy)/x2 directed at an angle B to the line drawn at right angles to the planar form. Accordingly, the component force pulling the charge in the normal direction will be given by:

    (qA/x2)cosB(dy) …… (1)

    Now, AcosB is x2 times the solid angle S. It follows therefore that the force expression in equation (1) can be written simply as:

    qS(dy) ……..(2)

    which means that, owing to that segment of continuum charge of area A, there is an attractive force component pulling the charge at P towards the planar boundary and that force component is given by the expression (2). The total force attributable to a ‘slice’ of continuum charge is simply q(dy) times the whole of the solid angle subtended by the area of the slice, namely half of 4(pi).

    To work out the overall effect of displacing the charge at P towards the planar boundary, we simply note that we are displacing it from a position of equilibrium and so a step through a distance y will reduce the action of a slice of continuum of thickness y in front of the charge and enhance the action of a corresponding slice of continuum behind the slice. The former involves a reduction of the attractive force by 2(pi)qy and the latter corresponds to a restraining force of 2(pi)qy. Together these amount to a restoring force acting on the unit charge of 4(pi)q per unit charge per unit distance of displacement.

    You can then work out why it is that, in cgs units as used in the early days of field theory in physics, the energy stored in unit volume of space by electrical displacent within the vacuum state is 1/8(pi) times the square of the electric field strength. The force is subject to a linear rate and half the resulting force times the distance through which it is displaced gives the energy involved.

    DISCUSSION

    Now, of course, we need to keep all this in proper context. We know the energy stored in a unit volume of vacuum when there is an electric field of a given strength present. We know that because experiments prove it and because electrical technology builds on the basis of that knowledge with success.

    We therefore know, or should know, that there is something in space that is affected by that electric field condition so as to be able to store energy. To comply with what is observed I am saying that there are two opposite kinds of electric charge that are pulled apart just a little in storing that field energy. Now, I could say that, given that the applied electric field is uniform over the region where we are interested in energy stored, that small displacement of charge must, in effect, amount to the development of a planar slice of electric charge. In that case, it seems irrelevant to worry about the ultimate boundary conditions governing space; everything that is affected is local to the test region. Indeed, when I first developed my theory that was my way of looking at things. However, then, sometime around 1966-1967, my employer IBM suggested that I visit Professor L. H. Thomas at Columbia University in New York to see what he thought of my aether theory and its gravitational aspects. He urged me to consider and take full account of boundary effects, as these could affect my conclusions.

    Now, for my part, since I believe in the reality of the aether as containing a uniform continuum of one charge polarity populated by a lattice-like array of identical discrete charges, which, being crystal-like itself, can nucleate its structure on material crystals, I regard the planar boundary state as an implicit property of the aether. If scientists are unwilling to accept the real aether of this form then they need to find their own way of giving physical form to the field energy storage process. My theory, however, implies conditions governing the gravitational action, conditions which demand harmonious motion such as stem from that linear restoring force rate deduced above.

    In order to derive the law of gravitation from electrodynamic analysis and go on from there to derive the value of G, the constant of gravitation, neither of which are possible based on Einstein’s theory, one has to accept that harmony of motion by charge displaced in unison in that non-emptiness of outer space. The seat of the gravitational action is the system that is in dynamic balance with that charge motion. This is all explained elsewhere in these Web pages by reference to my published work of academic record. However, the planar boundary problem that we are discussing is part of the story.

    Possibly Professor Thomas had Mach’s Principle in mind when he stressed the boundary factor. That principle suggests that the mass of a particle here on Earth depends upon its gravitational interaction with all matter extending to the bounds of the universe, but I do not subscribe to that belief. I do believe that the rhythm of the aether charge motion has to be preserved within each and every space domain in order for gravitation to be a universal force within that domain, but I suspect that mass on one side of a planar domain boundary will not interact in the normal gravitational sense with mass in an adjacent boundary.

    For that reason I submit that one needs to study the major geological upheavals and reversals of the Earth’s magnetism that occur from time time, because that signals an event lasting a matter of seconds when body Earth, moving at 400 km/s, relative to the cosmic background, is carried through a space domain wall. We measure that motion by assessing the thermal condition of space through which we are travelling at cosmic speed. Though isotropic, its anistotropy, as we see it, tells us how fast we are moving. The temperature measured tells us the strength of the gravitational potential of matter confined within our local space domain. You see, the energy released by the gravitational interaction between matter and those aether charges in space has nowhere to go other than into a state of thermal agitation of the aether charge, a motion superimposed upon its rhythmic oscillations. So we can relate the individual mass of each of those aether charges with its temperature and the gravitational potential at the point in space where it sits. The 2.7 K temperature background of space can be calculated by such theory, if the gravitational action of the solar system approximates that of the local gravitational potential. See my paper ‘The Determination of Absolute Gravitational Potential’, 1983d.

    Such evidence compells me to believe that there are those planar boundaries in space, even though they exist with a separation distance that can be 100 or so light years, meaning that body Earth experiences those major upheavals at intervals that can be as long as a few hundred thousand years. See the ‘Feedback’ comment elsewhere in these Web pages: Feedback Note 02.

    Now, before I leave this subject and leave you to choose whether to believe Stephen Hawking or believe what I am saying here, I will invite review of the Appendix added below. It is quoted from the published paper: 1983k. I just wish to emphasize the point that if the boundaries of space were spherical in form, then the harmonious oscillation property would not have the form needed to explain the known energy density property of electric field theory, and if the boundaries of the universe were conical, as Hawking believes, I doubt if one could ever derive a theoretical value for the constant of gravitation. There seems no point in working out the ultimate shape of the universe, if one cannot explain the existing property of gravitation here on Earth!

    APPENDIX

    If the elements of this vacuum structure are in a state of stable equilibrium and comprise electric charge, then, in order to satisfy Earnshaw’s law, they must pervade a charged electrical continuum of opposite polarity. The latter is necessary to assure stability by providing a restoring action upon displacement. Accordingly, the only feasible model for a vacuum state having structure is one for which the discrete charges e of the same polarity interact to form a lattice within a continuum of opposite charge density q. It seems logical that the charges e are of equal magnitude and that q is uniform over a local region of space.

    Then, by simple analysis, one may show that if a lattice parameter d is written to satisfy:

    e = qd3 …. (1)

    the electrically-neutral state of the vacuum implies that each charge e takes up a space volume d3. With a uniform electric field of intensity E applied we find that the charges e will all be displaced in unison to satisfy:

    Ee = ky ….. (2)

    where k is a constant restoring force rate and y is displacement. In effect, the whole lattice is displaced relative to the background continuum.

    The energy density stored by this displacement is:

    W = ky2/2d3 …… (3)

    or, from (2):

    W = (Ee)2/2kd3 …. (4)

    and, as this is E2/8π, for a vacuum of unit permitttivity, we find that k is given by:

    k = 4πe2/d3 = 4πqe …..(5)

    from (1), thereby justifying the statement that it is constant.

    The use of this restoring force rate is fundamental to classical theory and it might seem somewhat elementary to have derived it from the electrically neutral vacuum model under discussion. However, the problem emerges upon analysis of radial displacement of a charge q within an arbitarily spherical bounded system. At a distance R from the centre of a sphere of continuum charge the total continuum charge acting on e is 4πqR3/3. The electric field is 4πqR/3, where R is now a vector.

    For any displacement x, as shown in the figure below, a charge e at P will be subject to a restoring force which is the expression 4πq/3 times the vector difference between two radius vectors R and R’. This is simply 4πqx/3. It follows that if e is part of a rigid lattice which is displaced as a whole by the distance x within the bounding spherical continuum, then the lattice is subject to restoring forces which are only one third of those expected from equation (5).


  • LECTURE NO. 11

    LECTURE NO. 11

    THE HUBBLE CONSTANT: ITS ‘FREE ENERGY’ ROLE

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    In Lecture No. 6 I declared that I would tell the story about deducing the Hubble constant in a later Lecture. This is that Lecture. It is about my discovery that there is something amiss in Maxwell’s Equations as applied to free space, something which gives us insight into why light waves emanating from distant stars lose frequency. This avoids the need to interpret that shift of frequency towards the red end of the visible spectrum as an indication of an expanding universe having, as a start point, what cosmologists have named the ‘Big Bang’.

    The story I tell is not all theoretical, as will be seen when we come to the details of Gieskieng’s Canyon Experiments. It is based on the loss of energy by propagating waves, coupled with their loss of frequency. It is based also on the role played by the aether in energy recovery, meaning our ability to extract energy from the aether locally in response to the absorption of those propagating waves by matter in their path.

    As proof of my case, apart from the experimental findings of Gieskieng, I will show how to formulate a value for the Hubble constant H. That should wake cosmologists up from the slumbers and help to put a stop to their dreams about the creation of the universe as a Big Bang phenomenon.

    To conclude this Introduction I will first present the equation connecting H with the other fundamental constants of physics that we have measured in the confinement of laboratories on body Earth, doing so in a form which can be compared with the six ‘Governing Equations’ that I listed in Lecture No. 6. Then I will quote a passage from a book by Brian W. Petley of the National Physical Laboratory in U.K. to set the scene for the onward discourse.

    The Hubble Equation, according to my theory, is:

    H-1 = (2mμ/me)9(N3)[72π]3(e2/mec2)[6/πc]

    where c is the speed of light and e2/mec2 is the ‘classical radius of the electron’, a recognized fundamental physical constant having no particular physical meaning, but one tabulated with very high precision in the standard physical data tables, it being listed as 2.81794092(38)x(10)-13 cm. N is an integer characteristic of the galactic domain region through which the electromagnetic wave travels, its value being normally 1843, as we have seen from what has been said in the Tutorial Notes in these Web pages and particularly in Lecture No. 6. The expression 2mμ/me is the ratio of the mass of a pair of virtual muons to the mass of the electron, it being the mass-energy of such a pair of muons that accounts for virtually all of the energy in one unit cubic cell of the aether, the lattice dimension of that cell being 72π times that classical electron radius or 108(pi) times the Thomson radius of the electron.

    We shall be deriving the above equation as we proceed, but, from the data just given and the knowledge from Lecture No. 6 that 2mμ/me is twice 206.3329, you can calculate H-1, the Hubble time, to find it is 4.5x(10)17 seconds or about 14.3 billion years.

    What this means is that a light wave needs to travel for 1.43 million years through space devoid of matter in order to suffer a loss of frequency of 1 part in 10,000. Such are the numbers on which modern ideas concerning our universe are based.

    Quoting now from Petley’s book: The Fundamental Constants and the Frontier of Measurement, as already referenced in the Discussion section of my Keynote Address in these Web pages, one reads on pp. 41-42:

    The question of time formed the crux of Dirac’s argument. The largest time that we encounter is the age of the universe, ~1017s, and the smallest is about the time it takes for light to travel a distance equal to the classical electron radius, the tempon, or chronon, and which for many scientists represents a natural unit of time, ~0.49x(10)-23 s. Taking the ratio of these again yields about the same number ~1040.

    The essential point made by Dirac was that the dimensionless ratios all came to this value, not as the result of an accidental coincidence, but because they depended on the age of the universe in chronons. This therefore led to his theory for the change of these ratios with time. Thus the force ratio led to a prediction that the gravitational constant would vary with time.

    There have, of course, been a number of theories proposing time variations of certain combinations of the constants since that of Dirac. These constants are as follows:
    (1) the fine structure constant,
    (2) …… ,
    (3) …… ,
    (4) the quantities δ and ε

    δ = Hh/mec2 ~ 1042
    ε = Gdo/H2 ~ 2x(10)-3

    for

    do = 7x(10)-28 kg/m-3

    Both δ and ε involve the Hubble constant H, which characterizes the variation of the red shift of stellar light with distance and is roughly the reciprocal of the age of the universe. The different cosmologies predict different variations of the parameters with time, and the fact that none of them has been entirely successful is an indication that the subject is still an open one.

    Item (2) is a constant of Dirac’s theory that we shall not address, it relating to Fermi’s theory of beta decay. Item (3), the ratio of Coulomb force to gravitational force, will be addressed separately in the theory of record in these webpages.

    Note that δ is dimensionless in that H has the dimension of the reciprocal of time, whereas h/mec is distance, it being the Compton wavelength of the electron (a recognized fundamental constant of 2.42631058(22)x(10)-10cm) and so c, which is a speed, renders the expression dimensionless. The quantity do is a density, it being representative of the order of the average mass density of matter in the universe.

    Whatever you, the reader, make of this interest which Nobel Laureate Paul Dirac took in the Large Number Hypothesis, I hope you will come to see it for what it is, merely a play on numbers. It is not true physics to infer that because two ratios, which man can contrive to relate to physical constants, are both very large and of the same order, then there has to be a physical relationship based on those ratios being the same. That is mere wishful thinking and it should not be allowed to substitute for the methodical explanation of each of those two ratios in terms of a genuine physical process. It is so unlikely that the ratios would prove to be equal in the real world as governed by Nature. Our task ahead is to show what determines the Hubble constant and so deduce the true physical value for that quantity (delta). We have already, in Lecture No. 6 given the physically-based formula for G in terms of the charge/mass ratio of the electron and that yields one of Dirac’s ‘Large Numbers’. We find, of course, that we cannot associate that number with the one which will be derived below from our study of the Hubble situation.

    THE STEADY-STATE FREE ELECTRON POPULATION OF FREE SPACE

    This was the title of a paper of mine that was published in the English language periodical Lettere al Nuovo Cimento of the Italian Institute of Physics, a periodical noted for its rapid publication of scientific papers. It appeared at pp. 252-256 in vol. 41 and was dated October, 1984.

    As my object in writing these Web pages is to (a) present my aether theory to the world, (b) arouse interest in exploring the scope for extracting useful energy from the aether and (c) to make it very clear that the main body of those who see themselves as true scientists has chosen to ignore the truths evident from the research findings I have reported. I will in this section now be quoting extensively from that 1984 paper, interjecting a few comments in italics.

    Note that the argument is developed in two parts. The first part concerns how it is that in what we see as empty space there is a uniform ongoing activity that creates the transient presence of a kind of pseudo-matter. The aether attempts to create protons but does not succeed because there is no energy surplus to the equilibrium requirements of the aether. Yet those attempts intrude into the pathways of propagating light waves and cause the aether to absorb energy from those waves. The second part explains why the resulting attenuation of those waves with distance, attenuation over and above the normal inverse of distance degradation, will involve frequency attenuation as well, the latter having been misinterpreted as a Doppler effect attributable to a cosmic expansion seated in a Big Bang.

    In referring to that 1984 paper, I will here be incorporating a few corrections, entering those in italic text in the quoted extracts. My notes, as such, will be put in brackets, as will the reference data amended to refer to the Bibliography section of these Web pages. The only other preliminary point I wish to make concerns the ‘Thomson scattering cross-section’.

    This formula:

    A = [8π/3](e2/mec2)2

    gives the area deemed to obstruct an electromagnetic wave owing to the presence of a single electron of mass me and charge e. It is a formula derived by J. J. Thomson and is based on the assumption that an electromagnetic wave will promote oscillatory electron acceleration f so as to dissipate energy at a rate given by the Larmor formula 2e2f2/3c3. The force of the electric field of the wave acting on the electron is equated to mf to get this result and it is assumed that the energy radiated as electric field energy is doubled to account for magnetic field energy accompanying the radiated wave.

    Now, I wish to make it abundantly clear that this formula for energy scattering by a single electron is incorrect, because the acceleration of an electron does not involve energy radiation. Indeed, the inertial response of an electron in its efforts to make sure that its intrinsic electrical energy is not dissipated, is just such as will endow it with mass according to the formula E=Mc2. That is a vital feature of my theory and one which makes my method independent of the Einstein assumptions. What Larmor had overlooked was that, so far as the single electron reaction is concerned, the accelerating electric field that produces the acceleration interacts with the electron’s own field and the cross-products of that field interaction cancel any energy radiation from the body of the electron. This does not govern the collective interaction of electrons and so the Larmor radiation formula does have physical meaning and some practical use. It can be used to explain radio propagation from an antenna, where billions of electrons all accelerate in harmony to set up the electromagnetic waves. As to the single electron, you can see that it cannot radiate energy, as otherwise every atom would collapse with its electrons coming to rest in the nucleus. Avoiding that scenario led to Bohr quantizing electron motion in the atom and declaring, quite arbitrarily, that the atom could only radiate if an electron, for some reason, jumped from one of its quantized orbits to another. The point I make about deriving E=Mc2, was the subject of a paper of mine in the ‘International Journal of Theoretical Physics’. [1976b]

    However, in the free space situation we shall be considering, even that collective action does not result in any energy absorption, because the electrons that are transiently present are so far separated that they do not share the same accelerated motion, meaning one that is in-phase with that of adjacent electrons.

    So we need to look again at the action of the electromagnetic wave upon the electron. The wave has two energy components, the electric component and the dynamic component, the latter being regarded as the ‘magnetic’ feature of the wave. Only the electric component accounts for the force accelerating the electron and all of the energy absorbed goes into kinetic energy. This energy, which is half that we might otherwise have presumed to be captured according to the Thomson scattering cross-section, acts to cause that electron to become a wave-transmitting antenna itself and it produces a wave that is 90o out of phase with the intercepted wave. This sets up a secondary wave. However, as this secondary wave propagates it loses half of its energy as it settles to a condition in which the in-phase electric and magnetic fields adapt to a more natural mode of oscillation in which they are in phase-quadrature. This latter situation corresponds to energy oscillations in what is a standing wave system, as between the electric and dynamic action of the aether charge conveying the wave. The waves do not convey energy through space; they merely ripple the aether energy which exists in a sea of uniformity and equilibrium spread throughout all space. However, this secondary wave process involves a loss of half of that energy absorbed by the electron. It is shed to the quantum underworld as entropy pending its eventual deployment in those ongoing efforts to create matter in the form of protons.

    Overall, this means that we can use the formula for the scattering cross-section of the electron, provided we recognize that the relevant absorbing cross-section is one quarter of that cross-section as formulated by Thomson.

    Quoting now from the paper:

    In an earlier letter [H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, v.41, 423 (1972)] it was suggested that space may have properties associated with a characteristic cubic-cell of lattice dimension d=72πe2/mec2, a characteristic frequency f=mec2/h and a characteristic threshold energy quantum which analysis gave as the combined energy of 1843 electrons. This led to a value of α-1 of:

    108π(8/1843)1/6 = 137.035915 …….. (1)

    Above, e is the electron charge, me the electron mass, c the speed of light in vacuo and h is Planck’s constant. The expression (alpha) is the fine structure constant.

    The theory also indicated that space may well be populated by virtual energy quanta, equivalent to having a muon pair in each cell. In 1975 this model was applied to the exact derivation of the proton/electron mass ratio ([1975a] in the Bibliography of these Web pages), the dual muon energy constituting the nucleus on which the proton form was synthetized. Recently, by regarding these muon constituents as point charges migrating at random at the frequency fo, (the Compton electron frequency), the model has found further application in explaining and evaluating the muon lifetime,(See my book: ‘Physics Unified’, pp. 145-146), the neutron lifetime [1981b] and the pion lifetime [1982d]. Furthermore, the critical energy threshold set by the 1843mec2 quantum was crucial to the neutron lifetime determination and is of significance, on stability criteria, to the creation of the proton.

    Physically, this quantum arises because each cubic cell has a lattice charge element q set in a uniform background continuum of opposite charge density and the condition for which q can change in form without displacing the continuum is that it absorbs energy to create N electrons and positrons occupying the same volume. Thus:

    q = N(e+, e–) ………….. (2)

    The argument is that q has to be zero or at near zero potential in relation to all other q charge and the continuum charge. This fixes the cubic structure and the position of q in relation to the centre of each cell. The dynamics of the space model are linked to the properties of the electron and the physical size of the electron charge in relation to that of q. The analysis shows [1972a] that a true zero potential condition would correspond to a non-integral value of N lying between 1844 and 1845. Since the potential cannot be negative for a true vacuum state, N has to be lower than this and it must be odd to cater for electron-positron pair creation and q converting to an electron or positron. Thus N is 1843.

    ( I have quoted this from that 1984 paper to show that enough concerning the detail of my aether theory is of record in university libraries for scientific academia to have taken my research seriously and so realize that this account of the Hubble constant kills the hypothetical notion of an expanding universe!)

    The pair of virtual muons in each cell were identified as such because they assure energy equilibrium by giving the cell the same energy density as the q elements. Analysis indicated that their mass was very slightly less than the mass of the real muon. The same analysis (‘Physics Unified’, pp. 103 and 108), applying the Thomson formula relating charge radius and energy, allowed the volume of q to be determined as (1/N)1/2(me/mmu)d3, where mmu is the mass of the virtual muon.
    The advance now to be presented in this paper is based on the simple realization that in free space the transition indicated by equation (2) will occur naturally but with a very low probability. It takes the energy of nine virtual muons to exceed the energy threshold set by Nmec2, with N=1843. The virtual muon mass is a little in excess of 206me. Therefore, we look to the event when four muon pairs plus one muon of charge opposite to q all combine within the volume of q in the same cycle of migration. The muon pairs have a random freedom of movement and are not confined to a particular cell. (See comment below) The chance of one muon entering the q volume is one in (1/N)1/3(me/2mmu). Therefore, the chance of nine muons entering the same cell volume at the same time is this factor raised to the power 9.

    (The way I visualize this process is that the entry of a muon, or a muon pair, into the body of the q charge traps the energy for one period of the aether rhythm. This allows the cell occupied by q to be replenished by energy inflow from surrounding aether in readiness for the next muon strike. If this occurs in the following cycle, then the energy of the muons remains trapped, otherwise that first muon (or muon pair) will decay during that cycle and displace any energy that has entered the cell in its absence inside q. This scenario therefore permits a chain of events building up the energy inside q, but with a diminished probability factor for each successive step in the chain. I am now saying that, by ‘simultaneous’ as used in the paper, I mean the sequence of events that occur within a charge q without rupturing the timed energy chain.)

    The logic of this supposes that each muon arrives independently and simultaneously and that the chance of four negative muons appearing is the factor raised to the power 4, whereas the chance of five positive muons appearing is the factor raised to the power 5, the total chance being the product of the two. We find that the overall effect is that at any time the chance of a q element converting according to eq. (2) is (1/N)3(me/2mμ)9.

    (By this it is meant that at any instant the chance of the q charge in each cell of space being excited to the threshold state is that specified by the above expression. With N=1843 this means that momentarily the q charge has become 921 electron-positron pairs plus a residual electron, assuming that q is the same as the electron charge.)

    The electron-positron pairs will not obstruct the passage of electromagnetic waves because they have a mutual inertial balance and are collectively neutral in their response to electric fields. This leaves the electrons as presenting a scattering cross-section to radiation.

    (Here I introduced the ‘Thomson scattering cross-section’ as providing the obstruction to onward propagation of an electromagnetic wave. However, I ought really to have termed this the ‘absorbing cross-section’, for the reasons already stated above where I indicated I would be using a factor 4 in what follows in order to correct an error in that 1984 paper.)

    The formula given in the introductory paragraph can be used to evaluate d as 6.37×10-11 cm, meaning that there are 3.87×1036 cells in a cubic metre of space. With N=1843 and mmu/me=207 (or, to be precise, 206.3329, an adjustment now incorporated in the onward text.) it is evident that one cell in 2.17×1033 is subject to the transition just discussed. There are, therefore, approximately 1,780 excited electron cells in each cubic metre of free space.

    The Thomson scattering cross-section of the electron is well established as 0.666 barns or 6.66×10-29 m2 and, accordingly, our theory tells us that the vacuum should present a cross-section of 1780 times 0.666 barns or 1.185×10-25 m2 per metre cubed. Here, however, we must divide by 4 for the reasons already stated. This reduces that cross-section to 2.96×10-26 m2 per metre cubed. On average, therefore, a photon would have to travel at the speed of light 3×108 m/s for 1.125×1017 seconds before being wholly absorbed.

    It is noted that this period is really a rate of exponential decay but is does mean that we are here contemplating a period measured in billions of years. We are now ready to move on to the task of explaining why waves lose frequency reduces in their through free space. First, note that the paper contained a reference to ‘missing matter’.

    The mass density of the electron population causing this obstruction of radiation is as low as 1.6×10-27 kg/m3, which is curiously of the order of the mean mass density seen in the galaxies and attributed to the so-called missing mass in cosmological theory.

    There is purpose in examining whether the scattering process has some bearing upon the cosmological red shift. Universal expansion by which the red shift becomes a cosmological Doppler effect is the accepted hypothesis. The alternative provided by the ‘tired light’ hypothesis, which requires the degeneration of frequency in transit, is discounted by Misner, Thorne and Wheeler (‘Gravitation’ (Freeman, San Francisco), p. 775) who quote Zel’dovich (Sov. Phys. Uspekhi, v.6, p. 475; 1964. He stressed that the statistical picture of photon interception by particles in the interstellar space would require some photons to lose more energy than others, resulting in a spectral line broadening that is not observed. Yet space is so tenuous that one may well question how one can be sure that a statistical interception process applies when the particles involved are about 10 cm apart.

    (Here I would have liked when I first wrote the paper to have expressed my view that photons really do not convey energy at the speed of light. They are events which occur in space when waves are generated or absorbed. The wave is the only feature we need consider. Neither photons nor waves transport energy across interstellar space at the speed of light. It was only the belief that there is no aether that led physicists into the syndrome which drove them down that blind alley where all they could ‘see’ as explaining a cosmological red shift was the so-called ‘Big Bang’.

    There is something very special about the true vacuum that is never mentioned in this context. It has the ability to transmit waves without frequency dispersion, the very property which Zel’dovic sees as missing when matter is present. The author ( H. Aspden: ‘Wireless World’, v. 88, p. 37; 1982) has recently discussed this zero dispersion vacuum property and argues that space itself must adapt to the local wave disturbance so as always to be in tune locally with the signal in transit. Furthermore, the frequency property must somehow be codified at each point in space-time without regard to whatever happens at adjacent points and without involving the propagation speed c.

    The author has shown that this state of affairs applies if one accepts that the electric field vector E is a composite of two electric field vector components E1 and E2 having separate physical significance. This allows us to write two equations:

    E = E1 + E2 ……………… (3)
    dE/dt = (E1 – E2)F(E1/E2), ………….. (4)

    where t is time and F is a function of the ratio of E1 and E2. The rate of change of the amplitude of an electromagnetic wave can be codified in this way in terms of the strengths of two electric field components at the point in question. It need not be determined by the speed at which the wave progresses to adjacent points.

    The function F is governed by the condition that there is zero frequency dispersion, at least up to the threshold frequency at which electrons and positrons are created. One can infer that at this limit E2 is zero, whereas at frequencies in the radio and optical spectrum E1 and E2 are approximately equal, though their actual ratio is a crucial indicator of frequency.

    With such a feature electromagnetic theory admits the possibility that the presence of matter could attenuate E1 and E2 unequally, that is, not in linear proportion. In this case the ratio E1/E2 can change and the frequency might vary in transit. In the quantum situation, where collective action of intercepting matter co-operates in a photon reaction, the change is substantial and the frequency is reduced in a quantum step, but in a very rarified interstellar medium, the frequency will reduce progressively as each element of matter is intercepted to scatter energy.

    The analysis involves analogy with a simple harmonic oscillator for which the linear restoring force rate is a variable giving a resonant frequency fr, where:

    (fr)2 = kfo2 ………… (5)

    The variable k is equal to E/E1, this being 1-E2/E1. It gives E2=0 when fo is the Compton electron frequency.

    For a sinusoidal planar wave the amplitude of dE/dt is 2πfrE or:

    2πfok1/2(E1-E2),

    which is of the form given by equation (4) because k is a function of E1/E2. Also, E1 and E2, though approximately equal in magnitude over much of the frequency spectrum, are associated with relatively very different charge densities and inversely so related to very different physical displacements. This causes one of them to be the seat of almost all wave energy loss so that E1 is effectively constant in a planar wave and E2 is the main variable.

    The energy density W of such a wave is proportional to E2 or (kE1)2, which means that (1/W)dW can be written as (2/k)dk. Also, from (5), with f constant, we find that (2/fr)dfr is (1/k)dk. Taken together, these relationships allow us to write:

    (1/fr)dfr/dx = (1/4W)dW/dx ………. (6)

    where x is the distance travelled by the wave.

    We arrive, therefore, at the remarkable proposition that the dual component electric displacement, needed to explain the zero dispersion property of the vacuum, gives it the property of attenuating the frequency of waves in transit at one quarter of the rate at which the wave energy is absorbed, subject to overriding quantum effects associated with matter when present.

    In the true vacuum where only the transient electron induction process discussed in this paper causes any attenuation, there should be a progressive reduction of frequency with a time constant of 4.5×1017 seconds, that is four times the period calculated for energy attenuation. This is 14.3 billion years, a quantity comparable with the 12 billion years estimated as the average age of the galaxies as judged from their spectral character (Narlikar: The Structure of the Universe, Oxford University Press, 1977, p. 228).

    The author sees the contribution in this paper as a major advance in a theory of the structured vacuum which has been evolving for many years. It is extremely gratifying that a theory which has proved to be so fruitful in determining fundamental constants with high precision should so easily lead to the theoretical derivation of the most relevant constant in cosmology. The interpretation of Hubble’s constant as a phenomenon linked to dual displacement in the field medium should now encourage experimental enquiry into the detection of this property of radiation, one avenue being the study of anomalous antenna properties reported by Gieskieng (D.H. Gieskieng: The Mines Magazine (January, 1981), p. 29).


    As already noted the above account concerning the theoretical evaluation of the Hubble constant was published in 1984 in the Italian Institute of Physics periodical, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 41, pp. 252-256. That is a publication in the English language which offered rapid publication of scientific contributions which could survive peer review by referee scrutiny. It was shortly after that that the experimental research findings of Dave Gieskieng came to my attention. They confirmed to me that the aether does have the self-tuning, dual displacement property, which sustains natural oscillations at the signal frequency of electromagnetic waves. Nature’s ongoing attempts to convert aether energy into protons put that something, a kind of ghost-like, quasi-state of matter, into space and, as explained above, it can weaken those waves and progressively reduce their frequency, according to distance travelled. That led to efforts to publish what Gieskieng had discovered. The story on that it now told in these Web pages as the Appendix to the previous Lecture No. 10. I have deferred entering this Lecture 11 until I was able to record it immediately following Lecture No. 10.

    Harold Aspden
    February 25, 1998.


  • APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 10

    APPENDIX TO LECTURE NO. 10

    AN ANTENNA WITH ANOMALOUS RADIATION PROPERTIES

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1987, 1998

    This paper dates from the 1986 period when it was offered for publication to the journal Radio Science. Its original form was much greater in length and contained a more extensive account, mainly in the experimental section. The referee opinion was that it was important and warranted publication, subject to it being contracted in length. This resulted in the paper having the form presented here. However, it was rejected upon submission by the Editor, without further comment. The paper is exactly as it stood at that time, giving the following addresses of the authors then applicable, though Dave Gieskieng still resides at the address stated. An Abstract of the paper was published in the No. 1 issue of volume 10 of Speculations in Science and Technology (1987), coupled with an an offer to supply copies of the paper to readers upon request. Only one or two such requests were received. In view of this Web page presentation that offer is now withdrawn. The Abstract presented in the above periodical is more informative than that heading the paper below. Its full text is to be found elsewhere in these Web pages in the Bibliographic section under reference: [1987n]


    D. H. GIESKIENG, WOFK,
    9653 Rensselaer Drive, Arvada, Colorado 80004
    and

    H. ASPDEN, FIEE,
    Department of Electrical Engineering,
    University of Southampton, Southampton SO9 SNH, England.



    Antennas designed to radiate electric and magnetic fields in quadrature time-phase are found to have anomalous radiation properties relative to the in-phase propagation properties of the conventional dipole. It is shown that there is a marked advantage in wave survival efficiency over the dipole, increasingly evident beyond a mile range. This is attributed to the excitation of a natural wave propagation mode by the new antenna, rather than the dipole’s forced wave propagation mode and the deceleration of the latter over the short range into a natural wave with some energy dissipation.

    INTRODUCTION

    This paper is a joint contribution by one author (D.H.G.) who has performed the extensive experimental investigations reported and another author (H.A.) who seeks to show that the experimental findings have important fundamental significance to electromagnetic theory. From a practical viewpoint, the discovery of what will here be termed the Gieskieng antenna is significant because it appears that by accepting a little degradation of signal strength over an initial short range of transmission there is a pay-off for longer range transmission which shows that the antenna is more efficient than conventional dipole antennas. This most unusual and somewhat anomalous propagation property is difficult to explain and appears not to be a consequence of ground or atmospheric reflection. It has, therefore, been examined in the context of hitherto unsuspected properties of the propagating medium.

    In summary, the Gieskieng antenna differs from conventional antennas in that it is expressly designed so that the electric field energy and the magnetic field energy are not forced into the field medium in time-phase with each other, as applies for a conventional half-wave dipole. Instead, the antenna is so structured that the electric and magnetic fields are set up in quadrature phase. For the same excitation this appears to produce a signal of half strength initially, but it has, it seems, the property of being less subject to dissipation and attenuates more in accord with theoretical prediction, whereas conventionally produced signals attentuate more rapidly.

    It will be argued that this phenomenon is attributable to the field medium having a natural propagation mode which is directly excited by the Gieskieng antenna, whereas the excitation by the dipole antenna develops a forced propagation mode with which we are familiar, the forced propagation degenerating into natural mode propagation with energy dissipation over an initial range of transmission.

    Gieskieng [1] disclosed the features of his new antenna in a short note published in The Mines Magazine in 1981 and interpreted its unusual properties as due to a separation of the truly electromagnetic radiation from that associated with the electric field. Such argument was tentative, as may be the theoretical argument now offered below. The essential point is the appreciation that there is an anomaly involved in the antenna radiation properties and that an answer must be found in the interests of communication technology. The experimental findings reported here are, therefore, the more important element of this paper. However, since measurements of the kind reported are notoriously difficult and it is, therefore, easy to doubt their validity, some elaboration of the theoretical background relating to wave propagation, seems in order. In this way it is hoped that the reader may see the results in context and favour further research into what does appear to be a quite fundamental avenue for development.

    MAXWELL’S EQUATIONS

    It is generally accepted that full and sufficient basis for our understanding of electromagnetic wave propagation is contained within the framework of Maxwell’s equations and that Maxwell’s equations are on very firm foundation. Within the field of radio science it is not usual to become concerned with the quantum properties which govern energy transfer processes, a duality between wave and photon actions being tolerated as something we have to live with. However, we must be ever conscious that there are aspects of the field medium and its propagation properties which are not embraced by present knowledge. For example, we do not understand why the field medium, when excited by waves at the frequency we associate with the Compton wavelength 2.426×10-12 m can suddenly absorb the wave energy and create electrons and positrons.

    Maxwell’s equations are silent on the subject of such threshold frequency conditions, but it is clear that something endows the vacuum medium with a resonant property at the Compton electron frequency 1.24 1020 Hz.

    Historically, Maxwell’s equations had a physical basis. They relied upon the so-called displacement current and belief in the ether as a tangible medium filling space. This was before Compton’s discovery of the wave interaction with the electron. The measured isotropy of light speed led to the ether going out of fashion. Displacement currents were retained only within the mathematical framework of Maxwell’s equations, which, however, gave no physical picture from which to assess threshold conditions. The ether has been revived by quantum techniques. The energy fluctuations known to exist in the vacuum and the quantum interactions which form the basis of quantum-electrodynamics and electron-positron pair creation and annihilation have made the ether respectable again, but in a new adaptable form. Graham and Lahoz [2] have gone further in demonstrating that the vacuum can be the seat of electrically-induced inertial reactions and have affirmed from their experiments that Maxwell’s displacement currents are real properties. Maxwell’s equations warrant rescrutiny in these circumstances.

    There are of historic record proposals for generalizing Maxwell’s equations in order to accommodate for the motion of the ether with an observer. Hertz [3] postulated the need for total time derivative formulations, a theme followed recently by Tombe [4], who suggests that the partial derivative form of Maxwell’s equations prevents them from
    being Galilean invariant and proposes corrections modifying the equations. Tombe refers to independent proposals along the same lines by Phipps [5] and Kosowski [6]. Also of record in connection with efforts to adjust the equations to conform with speed anisotropy observations are the modifications proposed by Trimmer and Baierlein [7] which retain the partial derivative form but introduce small anisotropy constants connected with a preferred direction in space.

    Such modifications of the fundamental equations which have proved quite well founded must be seen as speculative, pending experimental evidence stronger than that now available. Here, we do have some experimental evidence, but it strikes at something more basic than the equations themselves, that is the energy transfer issue not really embraced by the field equations as formulated.

    The points at issue, theoretically, are the energy transfer process, the threshold frequency condition and, a rather unusual question concerning the nature of a magnetic field in a wave propagating through the free vacuum. If the field arises from electric displacement currents, there is the question of what is actually displaced and relative to what is it displaced? We avoid these questions, and perhaps miss technological opportunities, if we look only at Maxwell’s equations.

    Considering the threshold frequency condition and the prospect from the above-mentioned experiments by Graham and Lahoz that a mass property must be associated with the vacuum medium, Aspden [8] has shown that the displacement is a relative displacement. There are two constituents in the field medium which move in opposition when an electromagnetic wave is in transit in a natural propagation mode. It is only by this means that the medium can have an inertial property which is hidden from us under normal circumstances and does not cause frequency dispersion in long range wave propagation. The same principles have recently been shown to give basis for calculation of the small but progressive reduction of frequency associated with the red shift of modern cosmology. The Hubble constant was found to be in full accord with the observed value, without recourse to the expanding universe philosophy [9]. This endorses the proposition that we should look to the foundations of Maxwell’s equations for new properties affecting electromagnetic wave transfer.

    The energy transfer question is crucial and here we find that there is, of record, a quite challenging account in the work of Professor G. H. Livens, Fellow of Jesus College, Cambridge, England. In his book ‘The Theory of Electricity’, 2nd. Ed. published by Cambridge University Press in 1926, under the heading ‘On the flux of energy in radiation fields’, he wrote:

    ‘The usual procedure is to base the whole of the discussion on Poynting’s form of the theory, which appears to provide the simplest view of the phenomena, and to ignore the possibility of alternatives. We must not however forget that our viewpoint may be coloured by a long use of the particular form of the theory as the sole possibility, so that its apparent suitability may be misleading. It is therefore essential that we bear in mind that Poynting’s theory is not the only one which is consistent with the rest of the electromagnetic scheme.’

    Liven’s then demonstrated that all the empirical evidence was also consistent with the field oscillations being established by energy stored in the kinetic energy of the field in the proximity of the antenna and sustained in propagation without energy transfer at the wave velocity. When waves are intercepted the same energy is absorbed as one calculates from conventional theory based on Poynting’s assumptions. In a sense, therefore, we have here, in 1926, proposals which could well be compatible with the waves acting as catalysts in promoting quantum energy transfer
    from a symmetrical energy-primed background, a theme later developed in quantum physics. Liven’s work is extensively discussed in a 1972 book by Aspden [10].

    FORCED AND NATURAL WAVE PROPAGATION

    Given the above basis for taking a more open-minded approach to the wave propagation problem, we now address the mechanism which appears to underly the experimental work to be reported.

    When a standard half-wave dipole is excited the electric field oscillation is set up as shown in Fig. 1 and propagates at the speed c in the direction shown by the arrow. The field medium has a response time of the order of 10-20 s and will follow these field oscillations with negligible dispersion. The related dipole current sets up
    a magnetic field oscillation in time phase with the electric field but in space quadrature. Energy is, therefore, forced into the waves, shared equally between the electric and magnetic fields, and must travel at speed c. Maxwell’s equations assure that the electric and magnetic waves are mutually sustained. In energy terms, we expect that energy from the electric field transfers forward to the magnetic field and vice versa.

    Fig. 1

    The above is conventional. Now we add our constraints. First, if the field medium has a natural threshold frequency and so a related inertial property, then such a wave must eventually suffer frequency
    dispersion. Yet, in the true vacuum that we associate with outer space, Warner and Nather [11] have found that the group velocity of light is constant to better than 5 parts in 1017. We must, therefore, at least have a suspicion that the accepted form of wave oscillation shown in Fig. 1 is not of the type which really does penetrate the vast distances of interstellar space. In theory, if we admit that a real vacuum medium is involved and are looking for technological consequences, we are forced to the view that such a wave must be degenerate.

    Now we ask if a wave can be produced without forcing the magnetic field to be in phase with the electric field, a condition that will be a deliberate design constraint of the antenna to be described. Note here that a magnetic field requires charge to move relative to the electromagnetic reference frame. According to modern relativistic principles, the latter is the observer’s reference frame, but for waves in outer space this requirement stretches the imagination. On conventional old fashioned theory, this frame is set by the ether itself. So, either way, one wonders how, in true vacuum, there can be such a thing as a magnetic field. The thermodynamic characteristics of a magnetic field suggest reaction effects (see Aspden [12]) within a primary medium. Therefore, in the absence of matter, the basic symmetry of the primary vacuum medium to which it owes its transparency must be broken to create field substance sustaining the magnetic energy condition. This is a forced and unnatural state ultimately incurring dissipation of energy, but one which can no doubt exist, in view of the conventional type of wave depicted in Fig. 1.

    In any event, there is good reason for accepting that the magnetic property is a special state of the field medium in which the kinetic energy of charge in a motion reacting to the inducing action appears to constitute what is, in a thermodynamic sense, the magnetic field energy.

    The Gieskieng antenna to be described produces the electric field wave with a 90o time phase advance compared with the magnetic field wave, because in relation to the direction of wave propagation the electric dipoles are set one quarter wavelength ahead of the section producing the magnetic effect. This wave system is shown in Fig. 2.

    Fig. 2

    The question at issue, however, is whether this is done in breach of Maxwell’s equations, thereby implying their need for modification to more general form, or whether the physical processes truly involve a reacting magnetic field in the conventional sense. If the field medium had a natural oscillation frequency equal to that at which the antenna is excited, then the energy deployment could involve electric displacement with energy transferring at each point in space between the electric field and the kinetic energy of the displacement rate. This is the condition contemplated by Livens, as already discussed. Electric energy need not then be fed into the reacting magnetic field system and the oscillation of the electric field is sustained by its own displacement motion. In fact, there need not be a true magnetic field in this case. The electric field does all the work, a condition in evidence, incidentally, in optical phenomena.

    The magnetic field H, shown in Fig. 2, may, therefore, be a notional field signifying dynamic energy in the field medium. On such an interpretation, Maxwell’s field equations change from the form:

    (1/c)dE/dt = curl(H) …….. (1)
    – (1/c)dH/dt = curl(E) ……… (2)

    to:

    – (j/c)dE/dt = curl(H) ……… (3)
    – (j/c)dH/dt = curl(E) ……… (4)

    where j is the familiar operator signifying phase advance of 90o and electric field strength E and magnetic field strength H are varying sinusoidally with time t.

    The proposition is that it is possible for the field medium to be set in a natural propagation mode which conforms with equations (3) and (4), so far as analogy with Maxwell’s equations are concerned. These new equations are symmetrical, a favourable contrast with the conventional equations of (1) and (2), if they are to represent conditions in the vacuum medium not governed by the forced constraints of action involving matter.

    The physical process involved in generating the Fig. 2 wave is that as energy is supplied into the electric field we do not drive energy into the magnetic field at the same rate but rather leave it to the electric field displacement to do all the work. The inductive effect of changing magnetic field does not then develop the electromotive forces which oppose and so contain the displacement. The result is that, for the same electric field, the Fig. 2 wave involves a much larger physical displacement of the field medium than does the Fig. 1 wave. The kinetic energy represented by the magnetic field is then primarily energy of the motion of the electric displacement, a much slower process than the one involved in the Fig. 1 wave. Indeed, there is a counter-displacement which offsets the electric field condition and adapts to the frequency of the signal in transit so as always to be in resonance at a level set by the energy density of the wave. This resonance is not excited in the forced wave mode of Fig. 1.

    This process is justified elsewhere [8, 9], but the outline above will serve to show that we may expect unusual properties to be displayed by an antenna excited in the special mode just discussed. In particular, the Fig. 2 wave propagation mode should be subject to no dispersion and so should have better long range characteristics.

    Two other points should be mentioned at this stage. The first is that a wave generated in the Fig. 1 mode will tend to degenerate into the Fig. 2 mode as the electric field oscillations progressively need to transfer energy into the kinetic form because the magnetic energy is slowly dissipated and cannot sustain the back EMFs which absorb energy from the electric field. Secondly, it is of interest to note that at zero frequency the counter-displacement state mentioned above is wholly balanced against any forward displacement. This is the state for which the vacuum medium has adapted to the local frame of the notional Earth-bound observer and moves with him through the cosmic space. However, in radio propagation we are concerned with the lateral displacements and these always have a partial, though nearly equal, electrical counterbalance displacement. Only at ultra high frequencies does this counter displacement become small, being zero at the threshold at which electrons and positrons are created.

    PRINCIPLE OF EXPERIMENT

    The principle of the experiment involves direct comparison of the propagation properties of the special antenna and a half.-wave dipole antenna. We compare their relative signal strengths under conditions not unduly contaminated by reflections by making measurements at numerous positions over a wide range. The detector used was a conventional dipole. It is designed to detect waves emitted by a standard dipole antenna and so the comparison is dependent upon this factor. In retrospect the measurements should also have been made using an optional receiving antenna of special design to complement the test antenna. However, in the event, it appears that the dipole receiver was 50% efficient in absorbing energy from the natural wave produced by the special antenna based on a 100% reference for detection of the forced wave produced by the dipole antenna. Thus, at close and long range, taking the natural wave mode of the special antenna as reference, the 50% signal loss has to be kept in mind. The dipole transmission was at 100% signal strength close to the transmitter, on this basis, but, as the results will show, it degenerated rapidly in relation to the natural propagation from the special antenna and settled 50% below the latter within a few miles. This is interpreted as indicating that the dipole transmission degenerates from its forced mode to the natural mode by losing half of its initial energy by additional dissipation compared with the special antenna transmission. In the natural mode, its wave energy is subject to the 50% factor at the detecting dipole. So, in effect, it appears that the dipole has lost three quarters of its signal compared with the special antenna. In fact, it has lost half, but it needs a special antenna to extract the optimum signal from the waves propagating in natural mode.

    The results are deemed to confirm the theory presented above, but it is emphasized that the data provided by these experiments was of record before the above theory was related to the specific findings. It is, therefore, quite rewarding to find that the extensive work involved in collecting the data has given results which stand up well against a theoretical background.

    Further experiment will, no doubt, give additional confirmation. As noted in the earlier publication (Gieskieng [1]), experiments using the special antenna as a receiver have shown it to have significant advantages, as if it is particularly adapted to the natural wave mode which all radio signals degenerate into, according to the above proposition. Experiments have already been performed to set up interference tests between two transmitting antenna, firstly dipole versus the special antenna and secondly special versus special antenna. With the dipole interference the data show a progressive and predictable change of wavelength as between signal peaks close to the dipole (about ten wavelengths distant). However, with the interference between the two special antenna, the peak to peak distance does not change and so is not affected at this range by the direct wave components we associate with the dipole. This, itself, shows that we are dealing with a special wave mode propagation. These interference experiments are the subject of continuing research and will be reported on separately in due course.

    The new antenna has been termed the ‘Maxwell Antenna’ by Gieskieng in his prior work, partly because of the emphasis placed upon the pure electromagnetic wave propagation properties and magnetic, as opposed to electric, content of Gieskieng’s tentative interpretation as to its operation. In view of the new emphasis in this paper upon its operation as an electro-kinetic wave propagator, it seems preferable to label it with the name of its creator. Hence the use of the term ‘Gieskieng Antenna’ in the onward description.

    THE GIESKIENG ANTENNA

    This antenna is illustrated in Fig. 3.

    FIG. 3

    It is a transmission line stub antenna having two legs of length B and a shorting bar of length A connecting adjacent ends of the two legs. In the form used in the tests described it was fabricated from tubing of diameter C. At the free ends there are tuning sleeves and there is a balun feed adjacent the shorting bar. The design requires the overall length 2B+A to be about a half wavelength of the signal to which the antenna is tuned. Suggested dimensions to cover the following amateur bands are as tabulated:

    Table I
    Band

    A B C
    20 mtr

    48 180 4
    15 mtr

    38 133 3
    10 mtr

    30 84 3
    6 mtr

    18 45 2
    2 mtr

    7 17.25 2

    The lengths of A, B and C are given in inches.

    THE TEST GROUPS

    The test results reported relate to antennas operating at 2 meters
    20 meters nominally, with frequencies of 145 MHz and 14 MHz, respectively. The antenna can be mounted with its plane vertical or
    horizontal. In choosing the different sites for the many tests performed, care was taken to exploit the natural features of the terrain to minimize ground reflections which might affect the comparison of the performance of the antenna relative to the reference antenna.

    The 145 MHz comparisons were made at a height of several wavelengths in addition to being on the edge of large cliffs, where both antennas could radiate with a great deal of certainty that the forward radiations would have negligible involvement with immediate ground and that when the downward portion of the wave did finally reflect it would be prevented from reaching the monitoring antenna by placing the latter some 300 feet back from the edge of the opposite cliff.

    It was found impractical to make similar cliff-side tests at 14 MHz and the new antenna was therefore tested against existing beams, using a mountain-top Monitor station.

    The following is a synopsis of some of the tests which were performed over a period of four years with the help of many colleagues (see later acknowledgement).

    Test Group 1

    This involved many 14 MHz tests from three significantly different sites in Arvada, Colorado area, transmitting to the top of Squaw Mountain, which averaged some 5,000 feet higher and 24 miles distance to the West. The monitor station included a horizontal dipole and a vertical dipole, crossing near their midpoints, closely cut to resonance and fed separately into the receiver building. The test antenna used for transmission was constructed of 4 inch diameter aluminium pipe with a line portion spacing of 24 inches. As indicated above, it was resonant by virtue of its total component length being half-wave. It was tested at numerous rotations, tilts and heights, ranging from the shorting bar section touching the ground to a position in which it was at a height of 50 feet. Well over one thousand data readings were taken in assessing the consistency of the system by repeated test.

    In this case, to provide the standard of reference, six existing commercially made triband Yagi beams and one monoband Yagi beam in the Golden-Arvada-Denver area were also tested to Squaw Mountain, with several checks in their favoured direction to assure obtaining their peak values. To provide a common basis of comparison their signal readings were adjusted to a range of 24 miles and further adjusted for lobe angle so as to provide a common reference. The latter correction was necessary because the monitor station on the top of Squaw Mountain only subtended vertical angles ranging from 2.0o to 3.33o from the test sites, whereas the lobes of the beams used peak at vertical angles ranging from 12o to 37o.

    Both Yagi and Gieskieng antenna results are summarized in Fig. 4, where the average of the polarization components are shown. The curves relate the different Yagi beams according to their antenna height above ground and the Gieskieng antenna, in both vertical and horizontal positions, also for different heights. This result is best interpreted in the light of the further tests reported below.

    Fig. 4. Power averages of vertical and horizontal monitor antennas Yagi beam stations (*) and the Gieskieng antenna in horizontal mode (broken line) and vertical mode (full line), all related to antenna height above ground.

    Test Group 2

    Two double element quad beams were found beyond the area suitable for inclusion in the above tests but having a reasonable angle with respect to Squaw Mountain. Both were on 80 ft. towers and less than one mile apart. This test group involved the opportunity to install the 20 meter Gieskieng antenna on one of these towers, which was temporarily not being used. Through the years the other quad had always obtained world-wide reports identical to the quad originally on this tower. This made it an established comparison for the Gieskieng antenna.

    First, the Gieskieng antenna was rotated to Squaw Mountain to test its directional properties. It was found to be omnidirectional within about 1 db, confirming a result found for the test group 1 data, and then left in a fixed position. The owners of the two stations then undertook a closely-monitored comparison between the Gieskieng antenna and the two element quad (both being horizontally polarized). An analysis of the log of 17 stateside and worldwide mutual contacts, including reports on a Yagi that joined in on 9 of the contacts, gave 26 long range comparisons of antenna performance.

    The contacts reported results for the quad and Yagi beams that were on average 4.5 db over the Gieskieng antenna performance. However, half of the 26 contacts reported precisely equal performance for the Gieskieng antenna, indicating that, in these instances, the latter has, approximately, a 3 db advantage over a dipole in long range wave survival efficiency.

    The reason for this is understood if we compare performance as adjusted for isotropic radiation. The dipole lobe is 2.2 db over this reference level and the calculation of lobe off-centre power levels for the highest (80 ft) Yagi beam in the Fig. 4 data indicated that the beam lobe was only 0.75 db over the dipole. The Yagi beam should, on this basis, have about a 3 db advantage over the omnidirectional Gieskieng antenna. Yet, as Fig. 4 shows, the Yagi beams gave about the same results as the Gieskieng antenna, showing that the omnidirectional power of the latter could match the lobe power of the Yagi beam and had a 3 db advantage in wave survival efficiency. The same result was confirmed for half the 26 contacts of test group 2.

    Test Group 3

    Whilst the rotation and inclination tests of the 20 Meter antenna suggested that it had a spherical radiation pattern, it was desired to be certain that there was no null in its overhead pattern, to be sure of the above conclusion. The first test utilized a manned balloon flyover. A short steerable receiving dipole was carried by the balloon and kept broadside to the transmitting Gieskieng antenna on the ground. It revealed sphericity through the maximum 60o vertical angle of its passage, but unfortunately a wind shift prevented a directly overhead flight.

    Subsequently, experiments at 2 meters made it possible to explore higher vertical angles by using a Gieskieng antenna to monitor the OSCAR satellite beacon. Passages above 80o still failed to indicate an overhead null. Thus the pattern of the antenna is regarded as being very nearly spherical (see later discussion).

    Test Group 4

    Direct comparison of dipole and Gieskieng antenna properties
    were made at 145 MHz. The data obtained was of the form shown in Table II and as plotted in Fig. 5. The transmitting antennas were horizontally polarized and the receiving antenna was arranged so that it was always broadside to the transmitting antenna, but could be rotated in a vertical plane to side tilts of 0o (horizontal), 22.5o, 45o, 67.5o and 90o (vertical). The voltage drop across the receiver meter was fed into a strip chart recorder, which recorded signal strength received from the transmitting antenna through its 0o – 360o horizontal plane rotations.

    Dipoles constructed of 12 gauge wire, 1.25 inch and 2.5 inch tubing were tested in the transmitting mode with a complete horizontal plane revolution for each of the receiving antenna side inclinations. The test group 1 work had shown that it was imperative to procure the average of at least the vertical and horizontal energy components to obtain consistent figures of merit and obtaining three additional intermediate components was a further refinement.

    Immediately following the dipole tests, Gieskieng antennas constructed of 5/8 inch, l.25 inch and 2 inch diameter conductors were similarly tested. It should be noted that the 2 inch and 1.25 inch Gieskieng antennas were fed with untuned ferrite baluns, which provide symmetry but occasion some loss at 145 MHz. This loss was determined to be about 1 db and this was allowed for in the data presented for these two antennas. Subsequent tests using a ‘bazooka’ feed to eliminate cable contribution and to avoid the toroid loss verified this adjustment to within 0.2 db.

    The test site was the Golden, Colorado area which has two large equally high basalt-capped plateaus, North and South Table Mountains, which are nearly one mile apart, have precipitous cliffs and are joined by a flat valley some 600 ft. below. This terrain provided an ideal opportunity to let the 2 meter transmitting antenna located near the edge of one of these cliffs radiate freely, in the knowledge that the earth reflections would be effectively blocked from reaching the receiving antenna, set back some 300 ft. from the edge of the other Table Mountain. The transmitting antenna was on a 16 ft. pole and the receiving antenna on a 20 ft. pole.

    Table II
    Antenna

    Horiz 22.5o 45o 67.5o 90o Mean Feed
    G (2 in)

    18.99 17.73 14.90 10.04 2.44 14.53 (1)
    G (1.25 in)

    18.08 17.92 16.12 10.43 3.14 14.62 (1)
    G (5/8 in)

    18.37 17.99 15.35 10.38 2.97 14.58 (2)
    Mean

    18.48 17.88 15.46 10.28 2.85 14.58
    D (2.5 in)

    16.90 16.60 13.75 8.76 3.09 13.18 (3)
    D (1.25 in)

    16.76 13.27 0.91 12.46 (3)
    D (12 ga)

    16.91 15.26 12.66 6.88 2.38 12.30 (3)
    D (12 ga)

    16.62 15.89 13.37 8.29 0.29 12.59 (4)
    Mean

    16.81 15.92 13.29 8.05 2.08 12.71
    G – D

    1.67 1.96 2.17 2.23 0.77 1.87

    The table shows signal strength in db for the different Gieskieng (G) and Dipole (D) antennas. It shows how a reading for a set position of the transmitting antennas is obtained. The average for the antennas in this particular position is 14.58 db for the Gs and 12.71 db for the Ds, given a mean advantage of the Gieskieng antenna over the dipole antenna of 1.87 db at the one mile range.

    Fig. 5. Comparison of signal strengths from Gieskieng antennas and dipole antennas for receiving antenna side tilts of 0o (horizontal) (dotted line points), 22.5o (crosses on broken lines) and 45o (circles on lines).

    The feeds used in Table II are (1) untuned balun, (2) untuned gamma, (3) tuned gamma and (4) double tuned balun.

    The effect of rotating the transmitting antenna is shown in Fig. 5. This confirms the omnidirectional properties of the Gieskieng antenna in the horizontal plane and shows its power advantage over the equally energized dipole antenna.

    Test Group 5

    A year after the above tests were performed another 2 meter test was made over the same mile range using a 2 inch diameter Gieskieng antenna and a standard dipole. Both had Bazooka feed. The power difference was 1.66 db or within 0.21 db of the foregoing test.

    Test Group 6

    North Table Mountain had a number of long extending fingers with cliffs and a range of 0.36 mile was utilized to repeat tests on Gieskieng and dipole antennas similar to the test group 4 tests. The results gave a 5 angle integrated similarity within 0.1 db, that is, their wave energies were essentially equal at this distance.

    Test Group 7

    A short non-resonant dipole was used to monitor 145 MHz Gieskieng and dipole rotations from a distance of 24 ft., without the benefit of the intervening chasm. This was as close as it was possible to still obtain coherent recordings. The dipole had an integrated advantage of 3 db.

    Test Group 8

    Another 145 MHz cliff side test was made over a distance of 5.1 miles and resulted in a 2.2 db integrated advantage of the Gieskieng antenna over the dipole.

    The data obtained from these various tests are summarized in Fig. 6. The curve shows the measured power of the dipole antenna signal relative to that of the Gieskieng antenna, the five data points marked by dots being the comparisons at 145 MHz and corresponding to test groups 7, 6, 5, 4 and 8, respectively. The + data point was for the 14 MHz test of test group I and the * data point is the one inferred by the method of test group 2.

    Fig. 6. Comparison of signal strength of dipole transmission in relation to that of equally powered Gieskieng antenna
    taken as 0 db ordinate reference.

    DISCUSSION

    Other tests have been conducted with a view to developing beaming properties in a system using the Gieskieng antenna and, as stated earlier, experiments on interference between antennas are giving interesting results bearing upon the unusual properties of this new antenna. However, these are outside our present scope and will be reported separately.

    The omnidirectional properties of the Gieskieng antenna are of special significance. If, as implied by the theoretical introduction, this antenna produces a displacement oscillation in the field medium which is a true natural oscillation in a direction parallel to the free ends of the antenna legs then it is logical that the wave radiating from it should be symmetrical about this axis. Radiation should therefore be isotropic in a transverse plane. However, radiation perpendicular to this plane will-also occur owing to the current in the two legs. This current is in anti-phase in these legs and, owing to their separation by the distance A in Fig. 3, a wave representative of the spacing will be propagated as a forced wave in the antenna plane and in a direction parallel with the shorting bar A. Since the legs are longer than the shorting bar, the fact that A is much smaller than a half wavelength will tend to be balanced and a somewhat spherically-symmetrical wave propagation can be expected, at least over a short range.

    It is submitted that the data in Fig. 6 bears out the proposition that, whereas the Gieskieng antenna, radiates what is essentially a natural non-dispersive electromagnetic wave oscillation, the dipole antenna radiation is dissipated over a range of a few miles as half of its power is lost in adjusting to the natural propagation mode. The dipole antennas used in the tests would then respond at 50% efficiency at the longer range for the dipole and at near range and longer range for the Gieskieng antenna, thereby explaining the curve in Fig. 6.

    Further research is needed to verify that if a Gieskieng antenna had been used as the receiving monitor in the tests, the transmitting Gieskieng antenna would have a four to one advantage over the dipole.

    It is recognized that tests comparing theoretical propagation properties of antennas with their actual propagation properties are very difficult and hardly practical. See for example the work of Dolle and Cory [13] who compared radiation from a dipole antenna and a loop antenna at various frequencies and various close ranges. Above 100 MHz they found that the field attenuation measurements were erratic because they were influenced by nearby objects. However, though they did find that the dipole field attenuated more rapidly than theory predicted, other than obtaining some useful empirical data nothing of fundamental significance can be attached to the discrepancy.

    It is submitted, therefore, that the tests reported here are rather special in the way in which the ground reflection problems are overcome and in the way an entirely new type of antenna forms part of the comparison.

    If one considers whether tests could be performed on wave propagation under more controlled conditions, the question is then raised as to whether a pure sinusoidal signal propagated along a coaxial cable would degenerate in transit from a forced wave mode to a natural wave mode. On the theory presented it seems probable that the phase of the electric wave field will alter by one eighth of a wavelength over a range of adjustment (of the order of a few miles) because the in-phase electric and magnetic oscillations (Fig. 1) adjust to a quadrature phase relationship (Fig. 2). The question then arises, firstly, whether this, in fact, occurs and, secondly, if it does, what determines the rate of degradation of the signal? Such an experiment seems viable but, happily, it seems that this first possibility has already been tested and found affirmative. Torr and Kolen [4] have reported some very perplexing results in an experiment sending a 5 MHz signal along a 500 meter coaxial line. They sought to measure the one way speed of propagation, or rather its variation, by sending the signal between two atomic clocks and keeping track of its phase change. Assuming that the phase change measured was solely due to variations in propagation speed they inferred that the speed of light could vary in a one way measurement by as much as 1%. Phase differences of 8 nanoseconds or 0.04 wavelengths were found and they had a spurious dependence upon the time of day, an implication that there might be some sensitivity to atmospheric conditions. However, a change of wavelength of 0.04 in 500 meters would correspond with phase shift accompanying the attenuation predicted by this paper and apply over a range commensurate with the measurements reported in Fig. 6.

    It follows, therefore, that the antenna data reported here may have independent support and relevance to basic research on coaxial cable transmissions. Torr and Kolen admitted being perplexed by their findings and drew attention to their dilemma by saying:


    Since there is no theory available which can account for these variations, we believe that it is essential to repeat the experiment with different clocks ….

    A theory has been provided in this work, but it remains to be seen whether it will stand the test of time. Meanwhile, however, there is purpose in exploiting the new antenna proposed and investigating the reasons for the degeneration of the forced Maxwell wave by studying wave interference phenomena.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

    Particular thanks are expressed to ‘Bob’ Swanlund, WOWYX, who, as live-in owner occupier of the Squaw Mountain repeater station, gave some 500 reports in the evolution of the horizontal and vertical
    monitor array and subsequently made over one thousand readings in the
    actual tests. Since his retirement he has moved to Golden, Colorado
    and has participated in most of the 2 meter tests around Table Mountains. As a practical radioman, his continued interest over a 4 year span was a special inspiration, as was that of my (DHG) brother, originally 9BDF, 1924.

    Over 25 others came, in some cases repeatedly and from over considerable distances to help in manning the field stations, in loaning equipment, use of their towers and stations for the quad comparison tests as well as providing photographs of several field tests. This assistance included also the provision and manning of a balloon (Don Ida) for the flyover tests, provision of a computer and considerable time in integrating the Table Mountain tests and expert advice in antenna performance evaluations.

    References

    (1) D. H. Gieskieng, The Mines Magazine, 29 (January 1981).
    (2) G. M. Graham & D G Lahoz, Nature, 285, 154 (1980).
    (3) H. Hertz, ‘Electric Waves’, English translation by D. E. Jones, MacMillan, London, 1893; Dover, New York 1962.
    (4) F. D. Tombe, The Toth-Maatian Review, 2, 839 (1984).
    (5) T. E. Phipps Jr., Journal of Classical Physics, 2, 1 (1983).
    (6) S. Kosowski, unpublished manuscript.
    (7) W. S. N. Trimmer & R. F. Baierlein, Physical Review D, 8, 3326 (1973).
    (8) H. Aspden, Wireless World, 88, 37 (1982).
    (9) H. Aspden, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 41, 252 (1984).
    (10) H. Aspden, ‘Modern Aether Science’, Sabbdrton, Southampton,
    p. 133 et seq 1972.
    (11) B. Warner & R. E. Nather, Nature, 222, 158 (1969).
    (12) H. Aspden, Lett. Nuovb Cimento, 39, 247 (1984).
    (13) W. C. Dolle & W. E. Cory, IEEE Trans. Electromagnetic Compatibility, EMC-10, 313 (1968).
    (14) D. G. Torr & P. Kolen, ‘Precision Measurement and Fundamental Constants II’ B. N. Taylor and W. D. Phillips, Eds., Nat]. Bur. Stand. (U.S.), Spec. Pub]. 617, p. 675 (1984).
    


    There has been some feedback from Dave Gieskieng on the content of this Web page. See Feedback Note 3/98. See also Message from Dave Gieskieng

    Readers may appreciate that what has been discussed in this paper and its introduction as provided by Lecture No 10 has very far reaching implications. The issue concerns the latent energy condition of the aether and it offers scope for reinterpretation of cosmological redshift data to avoid the absurdity of the belief that the universe was born at a single point in space and has been expanding ever since. It gives scope for a new interpretation of the source of heat which powers the sun. Indeed, at the end of the day, a day sometime in the 21st century, we will see that ‘cold fusion’ in its broadest sense will feature in the recognized forces of creation, the materialization of matter from the energy residing in the aether. These Web pages have much to report on this author’s contribution to this subject.

    *******
  • LECTURE NO. 10

    LECTURE NO. 10

    THE OCEAN OF SPACE

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1998

    Introduction

    This lecture topic was conceived as I relaxed on an ocean crossing. I was on the cruise liner ‘ORIANA’ headed from the port of Southampton in England to Auckland, New Zealand, by way of the Panama Canal, San Francisco, Hawaii and Fiji. I am writing this on February 22nd, 1998, just a few days after returning from New Zealand by air with a refuelling stop at Los Angeles. I had been reflecting on a dinner conversation over dinner with a table companion who had boarded the ship at San Francisco. His background was technical, that of a senior executive in the steel industry. Our conversation touched upon our past experiences and present pursuits, mine, as my wife duly explained, being a scientific interest in proving that I was right and that Einstein was wrong. Our dinner companion expressed his curiosity; he had never really understood what Einstein’s theory was about. I was now in deep water, metaphorically speaking. There was the Pacific Ocean beneath us, but I ask, how can one begin to explain the intricacies of Einstein’s theory, and far less my own efforts, as part of one’s social intercourse over dinner without sharing the motion of the ship and floundering a little? So, I compile this lecture from my secure foundation back at home and will use the gist of it as my fall-back position if I am asked the question again on a future ocean voyage.

    Making Waves

    From one’s viewpoint on a ship in mid-ocean one sees sea, its horizon and the sky above. The ocean is vast. The sky above, meaning the atmosphere that we can see, extends upwards over a few kilometers, but beyond that there is that mysterious medium we cannot see. We call it space and, so far as we can judge, that extends to infinity.

    In the 19th century that space was deemed to be a subtle medium which was referred to by the name ‘aether’ otherwise spelt as ‘ether’. The aether was seen as a real medium which regulated the motion of waves, meaning the kind of wave we associate with radio communication or light radiation. The 19th century scientist assumed that those waves, which he knew travelled at the high speed of light (some 300,000 km/s), were moving at that constant speed by reference to the aether.

    Towards the end of the 19th century, scientists developed a way by which to attempt to measure the speed at which body Earth was moving through space by setting up multiple reflections of light between mirrors. They expected that, relative to that apparatus, the light would travel between the mirrors one way faster than it would in the opposite direction. That assumes that the light travels parallel with the direction of the Earth’s motion. For light making such a round trip at right angles to the motion but over the same distance there should be no such difference and so, comparing the two conditions, there should be a small detectable effect which would indicate the Earth’s speed through the aether. To their horror and dismay, however, their scientific tests gave a null result. This suggested that the Earth was at rest in the aether, even though we know it travels around the sun at some 30 km/s. What had gone wrong?

    Now, I want you to imagine that you are the captain of an ocean liner travelling through the waves on the ocean. You can, if you wish, measure the speed of the ship by dropping something that floats overboard and timing its passage over a measured distance along the side of the ship. You would have reason to be most concerned if the test proved that the ship was at rest even though you know it is moving at speed. But there is a difference here between this test and that based on motion through space. Those 19th century scientists did not drop something into the aether which then stayed put in that aether as we moved away from it, nor could they measure distance between two fixed points in the aether. Instead, they made assumptions about waves and looked at how the crests of two separate waves stood in relationship to one another. So, let us ask our captain to perform an experiment analogous to that of the aether tests.

    To perform this test, the captain has to go to a swimming pool on board the ship and jump in. (In fact, I witnessed the captain of the ‘Oriana’ being duly ducked in the pool on the occasion of the equatorial transit – 1998 World Cruise – but that is by the way. He was not performing the test I now describe.)

    The pool has to be square in form and the object is to see how the wavelength of a surface ripple depends upon the frequency of the wave, for ripples set up in the direction of the main axis of the ship and for ripples set up in the transverse direction. If there is a difference then a scientist can deduce the speed of the ship, at least according to the same logic as was used in devising that aether test based on light waves.

    The captain has to go into the pool so as to be an observer immersed in the medium he is observing, without being distracted by having sight of the surrounding sea, as otherwise he would be able to judge the speed of the ship without relying on a test analogous to the aether experiment.

    Now of course this test is not feasible owing to ship’s vibration, resonances and numerous other factors, but it helps to put the problem in context. The water in the swimming pool is not part of the body of water in the ocean and so the speed of waves in the pool will hardly be affected by the speed of the ship. Indeed, common sense, backed if necessary by some modest knowledge of Newtonian mechanics, assures us that what happens to water in the ship’s pool is referenced on the pool and not the external ocean.

    Note that water is trapped in the pool and so moves with the ship. In the analogous case of the aether, surely one can imagine that there is something in the aether than can move bodily with an optical apparatus bounded by mirrors.

    The experiment in question is known to physicists as the Michelson-Morley Experiment but they seem not to have heeded the statement by N. R. Campbell in his 1913 book ‘Modern Electrical Theory’, published by Cambridge University Press. He challenged the meaning of the word ‘aether’. On page 388 one reads:

    This is the simple way out of the difficulties raised by the Michelson-Morley experiment. If from the beginning we had used a plural instead of a singular word to denote the system in which radiant energy is localised (or even a word which, like ‘sheep’, might be either singular or plural), those difficulties would never have appeared. There has never been a better example of the danger of being deceived by arbitrary choice of terminology. However, physicists, not recognising the gratuitous assumption made in the use of the words ‘the aether’, adopted the second alternative; they introduced new assumptions.

    In short, physicists failed to see the null test of that experiment as telling us something about the properties of the aether. They just slept on the problem, only to be aroused from their slumbers when Albert Einstein came into the picture by, in effect, saying there was no problem anyway, because, as our ship’s captain could have explained, what happens on and inside a ship takes its reference from the ship itself. It is a question of relativity, but not the kind of ‘relativity’ that Einstein was to present. Yes, there was no problem, because the aether has a way of adapting to wave energy when that energy is confined by apparatus in motion, but Einstein’s ‘no problem’ stipulation was to say that physical processes are all referenced on the observer witnessing those processes; non-accelerated motion is said not to affect what is observed. In other words, Einstein said: “Let us adopt a new philosophy that says there is no problem and adjust our physics to fit what we say – the aether can be ignored if we think along those lines.”

    Well, either the aether exists or it does not and I am not one for ignoring it, given that it is the only source of energy that offers promise for our future salvation. There is much to learn about the aether and how it creates matter and only a fool would be content to follow the Einstein flag, given that it leads only to a fool’s paradise.

    Our ship’s captain, according to Einstein, cannot see the ocean through which his ship moves. Instead, he has to be content with what he sees occurring in his swimming pool and his observation of ships on the distant horizon. If those ships happen to be moving at the same velocity, they will appear to be at rest; there is no relative motion. However, the captain knows that without reference to Einstein’s theory.

    So, my reflections amount to defending the need for an aether and urging enquiry into its form, not so much because I care how the speed of light is affected by it, but because I care about its energy properties. It is a storehouse for energy, what is known as field energy, the energy we associate with electric and magnetic fields. One cannot declare that it does not exist, simply because it seems not to live up to one’s imaginary expectations!

    Einstein has obstructed our progress in understanding every aspect of the aether, especially its role in the creation of matter and its role in regulating the quantized motion of electrons in atoms.

    Making More Waves

    Still on the theme of waves on water, suppose you throw a bucket of water into a pool having an unruffled surface. You will set up waves. There will be a travelling wave, a kind of surge spreading from the point at which the water entered the pool and this will subside to leave the pool agitated by the up and down motion of water and the attendant waves, before the pool eventually reverts to having once again a flat surface. The surge was a ‘forced’ effect, what I could refer to as a ‘forced wave’, whereas the up and down movement of water can be said to involve ‘natural waves’.

    The question of interest is whether such a distinction between forced waves and natural waves exists in the case of electromagnetic waves propagated through space. If it can then we know for sure that Einstein’s theory has had its day; it offers no feature that can explain the two forms of wave. The real aether offers such a feature and so aether theory must replace relativity.

    The proof that forced waves and natural waves do exist for radio communication is to be found in the canyon experiments reported by Dave Gieskieng.

    In summary, a natural wave involving that up-and-down motion, is one in which the potential energy (electric field energy) is exchanged with kinetic energy (magnetic field energy) without obliging energy to move at the wave propagation speed. This means that the energy sustaining this exchange process is conserved locally in space; it is energy that exists ab initio, just as there is water in the ocean before it is rippled by surface waves. The forced wave arises where energy is forced into the space medium, as by a radio antenna, with the kinetic energy (magnetic field energy) and the potential energy (electric field energy) being fed together so as to be driven forward, keeping in phase, with both having their wave crests at the same instant along the propagation path.

    As might be expected, with the passage of time, the forced wave subsides into the natural wave form and the experiments need to be able to detect the transition. Obviously, if you accept Einstein’s theory, which says that light waves travel at a constant speed, you will not expect there to be any transition to a natural wave. Indeed, you would face a scenario where energy must travel from sun to Earth at the speed of light, rather than one where the wave oscillations merely release energy from the aether where the waves are intercepted, leaving the aether to find its own equilibrium, as does the ocean, if a bucket of water is taken from it.

    You are deep into the need for an aether once you face the facts concerning forced and natural waves. However, if you accept Einstein’s theory you will not be one to seek funding to perform the necessary experiments. You would rather sleep on the dilemma as to how the energy transported by waves is deployed when two waves crash into each other from opposite directions. Somehow, when you wake up, you will need to reconcile the fact that when two light waves pass through one another their amplitudes are unaffected and if the two waves have the same amplitude you must explain how they acquire extra energy at their instant of interception. Bear in mind that energy is a function of the square of wave amplitude, and two squared implies four units of energy, but only two such units are available. Also bear in mind that, if you say that energy travels at the speed of light, you confront some interesting issues, particularly for waves of long wavelength. Your energy will need to dash around hither and thither in a motion superimposed upon the speed of light, but yet the energy cannot move at any speed other than the speed of light!

    Maybe before you wrestle with that problem it is better for you to go back to sleep and dream about Einstein. Or maybe you will be content to rely on Maxwell’s equations. They are based on theory which is empirically based on observation of the action of forced waves, so they are silent on the question of natural waves and they lack symmetry for that very reason!

    Putting all this into practical terms and coming to the experiments performed by Dave Gieskieng, the issue faced is whether an efficient radio antenna is one which puts out the greatest amount of power by literally forcing energy into the radiating field or one which is designed to exploit the natural wave properties of the aether by setting the energy latent to that aether in motion at the point of transmission. Note that the energy forced into the aether is always lost and dispersed as heat in its passage from the antenna. It is the onward natural wave oscillation that is the true work horse covering the mileage to a distant receiver. If that receiving antenna is designed specially to pick up natural waves then it will do better than one, such as a simple dipole, which is one which might seem to be optimum for forced waves.

    Well, I will close this introductory theme here by saying that the Gieskieng experiments prove my case and prove the need for an aether able to sustain natural waves. By testing different combinations of the two types of antenna for transmission or reception and using a radiation path traversing a deep canyon in Coloroda, Dave Gieskieng has discovered something that simply tells its own tale. However, here is an other example where those in authority simply do not want to know the truth, because they have treasured beliefs instilled in them by their academic training. For my part I could not stand by and turn a blind eye to what Dave Gieskieng had to say and so I joined forces with him in documenting the report ‘An Antenna with Anomalous Radiation Properties’. It presents the facts of experiment. It has not been published hitherto because the scientific community, those who referee scientific papers, fear the consequences of challenging the equations of Clerk Maxwell and the doctrines of Albert Einstein. Also the experimental research involved was performed by an individual acting on his own initiative and not being part of an institutional academic or governmental research team.

    The above-mentioned paper is reproduced in full in the continuation pages of this Lecture.


    To continue this lecture press:

  • LECTURE NO. 9

    LECTURE NO. 9

    SUPERGRAVITONS AND COLD FUSION

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1997

    This Lecture is an article that appeared on pp. 112-116 of the July-August, 1997 issue of ‘Infinite Energy’.

    Introduction

    There are millions of patents and millions of scientific papers and many, many books. Indeed, as I see from reading a 1997 issue of CAM, the Alumni Magazine of Cambridge in England, over 8 million copies of a scientific book by Stephen Hawking have been sold to readers interested in his ‘A Brief History of Time’.
    All of those copies of that book say the same thing in discussing whether time can run backwards and how time began, as well as whether the universe is infinite or enclosed in boundaries. There is no way of proving what is said on these matters, but 8 million people in the world are avidly interested in such scientific issues. Whether they can understand what the book discloses about the topics just mentioned is questionable, but they can rest assured (by the scientific community) that the content of the book is backed by ‘reputable evidence’, meaning the goodwill of Hawking’s fellow researchers who spend their lives delving into the secrets of space-time.

    I use the expression ‘reputable evidence’ because I find that this is a criterion applied by the U.S. Patent Office in examining ‘cold fusion’ patent applications. There is, it would seem, no ‘reputable evidence’ supportive of the ‘cold fusion’ phenomenon.

    On the one hand there are 8 million books all explaining to the world something that they can never ever understand, far less verify or see as a benefit to their existence, and on the other hand there are millions of patents and millions of scientific papers all saying something different and all being understandable because they have been scrupulously refereed by patent examiners or peer scientists. That is, if you are fortunate enough to have the backing of ‘reputable evidence’, as by being employed in the research laboratories of a major corporation. Yet, we are not destined to see amongst the U.S. collection of patents any which are based on the discovery of ‘cold fusion’, simply because the evidence in support is said to be of no ‘repute’! It was not ‘of repute’ because it went against the vested interests of those researching ‘hot fusion’ and even though the attempts to prove its feasibility are of more than forty years vintage, that research has the proper ‘repute’.

    Why is it that ‘cold fusion’ does not have the backing of ‘reputable evidence’? The reason is the startling nature of the scientific phenomenon involved. It is basic to the issues involved in the creation of the universe, but ‘cold fusion’ has not developed from the efforts of those who work with big particle accelerators or those who interpret four-space and worry about ‘Black Holes’ and such like. The orchestrated collaboration which keeps universities in funds applied to study the grand issues of the universe by computing what happened in the first few milliseconds after the beginning of time has assured a peer activity in creating the type of ‘reputable evidence’ that Examiner Behrend of the U.S. Patent Office would find acceptable.

    If the Wall Street Journal says ‘cold fusion’ is not viable, then Examiner Behrend takes that as reason to reject an application for an invention, the structure of which is new and which has never been considered by those who brief the journalists of the Wall Street Journal.

    Lack of 2020 Vision at U.S. Patent Office

    Now, apart from these opening remarks, I have something more constructive to say amd I am going to exercise a little 2020 vision in declaring that, by the year 2020, we will have commercially viable materials that are superconductive at temperatures well above room temperature and which also exhibit ferromagnetic properties. I go further here and ask you to join me in conceiving a new invention by a process of grinding that material down into small particles which are closely moulded inside an electrically insulating substance. That might seem a rather futile thing to do, to take a superconductor and then mould it into a non-conductive block form, but remember that invention ought to have an element of surprise, as otherwise it would be obvious and so non-patentable.

    So, in 2020 we find we can make something that ostensibly lacks utility. That is another criterion which Patent Examiner Behrend keeps in mind in judging patentability. But then I say that by doing something obvious we can endow that non-conductive block we have fabricated with ‘utility’. It must be useful. Even with our old knowledge of physics we know that a strong magnetic field can destroy the superconductive state, but that, once a magnetic field penetrates the superconductor it can become locked into place at a level of field strength below a critical threshold. Our invention is therefore to take that block we have moulded and apply a very powerful magnetic field which we progressively reduce to zero. I then suggest, with my 2020 vision, that we are then left with what is, in effect, a permanent magnet.

    If what I say is true, all we need, therefore, is to be patient and wait until we have on the market a material that exhibits superconductive properties at temperatures of the order of the boiling point of water and, hey presto, we can fabricate something new in permanent magnets.

    Now, if I were to file a patent application today based on the invention just outlined, the U.S. Patent Office would not grant me a patent unless I could identify a substance suitable for fabricating those magnets. The U.S. patent system does not allow one to speculate, however ingenious the speculation. As a result, the system favours those who confine their efforts to building and testing devices that can be demonstrated with consistent results. The greater issue, such as the prospect of ‘cold fusion’, which may need exhaustive research to unravel all its mysteries, cannot be patented in U.S.A. because Patent Examiner Behrend has to be sure the invention really is a ‘fusion’ device. The idea that a patent can be granted for something meritorious that may need funding and experiment to verify fully its operability is not contemplated. To someone like myself who is familiar with patent practice elsewhere in the world this simply means that, owing to the trend now set by the cold fusion saga, there will be inventions galore that will never see the light of day in a commercial sense if they originate in U.S.A. and rely on U.S. backing for their development.

    Readers of ‘Infinite Energy’ will know that Martin Fleischmann estimates the value of the ultimate breakthrough in ‘cold fusion’ as some 300 trillion dollars. We are, after all, talking about a new source of energy, one which can rival that of the so-called Big Bang creation of the universe, said to be somehow connected with hot fusion. That means temperatures of 100 million degrees rather than the temperatures I contemplate for those magnets fabricated from a new superconductive material.

    Coming back to that theme, suppose I think some more about invention and put those grains of superconductor in a tube with no insulating bonding, but there being spaces through which a hydrogen gas can flow over the surface of those grains of superconductor. Suppose I then ask the question, “Might the superconductivity property be enhanced or weakened by the pressure of that hydrogen gas?” Would not that mean that, if I applied a magnetizing field, then a ferromagnetic condition exhibited by the system would respond by developing, as a function of the pressure of that hydrogen, a magnetic polarization coupled with the enormously powerful magnetic fields we associate with permanent magnets? Would not this involve possible hydride formation and heating and cooling as a function of the hydrogen gas pressure and would not that superconductive feature be an important factor in this type of research?

    Now, I am going to develop this argument, basing my case on a granted U.S. Patent that has been cited against a ‘cold fusion’ application of mine currently in its examination phase in the U.S. Patent Office.

    The subject of that granted patent is the conversion of room temperature heat into electricity. The technique involves the control of hydrogen gas pressure in a cyclic way to produce related variation of the magnetic state of the material. As it switches between a high and low value in unison with the change of pressure, the magnetic field, which is enormous, changes too and it can deliver electricity as output if a coil having many turns is wound around the device.

    A little reasoning tells us that the hydride formation is necessarily a surface phenomenon owing to the fairly rapid cycle rate used in the reported experiments. It is governed by the gas pressure and involves cyclic heating and cooling, this being a reversible process, but if we can take power off as the magnetic field goes up and down then we must either be tapping that heat and so cooling the device or… well, you, the reader, can tell me where the energy comes from. There is doubt, because the device has to be cooled to get its hydride cycle to run faster. Can it be that the heat cycling is akin to an electrical switch mediating in an energy supply system which only controls action but yet can get a little warm in the process?

    Patent Examiner Behrend would expect some ‘reputable evidence’ before granting a U.S. patent having claims to such an invention.

    I will identify the U.S. Patent as we proceed, but let me first digress to discuss the ‘supergraviton’.

    The Supergraviton

    The supergraviton is my own brainchild. It stems from my years of research into the true nature of the force of gravity. It comes into prominence in connection with the neutral Z boson of the high energy particle physicist. But technologically it comes into play in connection with the warm superconductivity phenomenon and I suspect it also may play a role in the cold fusion scenario.

    In this article it is inappropriate to present research ideas that are wholly new. The reader has a right to expect what is described to have matured a little with time and so I will delve into a little history. You see, the years pass by and the research findings of those of us who trespass and express views not in accord with Establishment belief get brushed aside. They are, so to speak, swept under the carpet, but there can come a time when we need to look under that carpet and point the finger of recrimination at those ‘sweepers’.

    Like almost everyone in the scientific world, I had not heard of, or contemplated the possibility of, ‘warm superconductivity’ until its discovery, in breaking through the liquid nitrogen barrier, was announced two or so years before we heard of cold fusion. Alex Muller and Georg Bednorz of IBM’s Zurich Research Laboratory were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1987 for their discovery.

    I spent my main working career with IBM, 19 years of it as their European Patent Operations Director, and visited that Zurich laboratory regularly during those years, years during which my theory of gravitation was evolving as a private venture and had no reason to know that one day my gravitational interest might have bearing on that warm superconductivity phenomenon. I retired from IBM in 1983 and with their support and initial funding became in my retirement a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the University of Southampton in England, close to my home. My object was to develop my theory by showing it could have technological consequences, the effort being on the electrodynamic issues which I knew were at work in the phenomenon of gravitation. A far cry from superconductivity and cold fusion, you might think, but gravitation is an all-pervading force and there is much to learn.

    Having now moved into the latter stages of my retirement I have begun to scan though my published work and it is appropriate to highlight some that is lost in the dark corners. It is apt here to reproduce the text of a note I wrote on ‘The Theory of Anti-Gravity’ for BASRA, the Journal of the British-American Scientific Research Association, as published in volume XII of the March 1989 issue at pages 2-5.

    It was written at a time when those of us interested in these matters sensed a feeling of euphoria because it was understood that advanced project management in British Aerospace was willing to fund an event at Edinburgh University in Scotland under the direction of Professor Salter, an expert on gyroscopic systems, expressly staged to assist inventors in demonstrating their mechanical anti-gravity devices. This was to be an activity conducted behind closed doors until the machines were performing and had been tested, after which there would be a public disclosure at which the press would be present. In the event, however, as seems to be an inevitable circumstance, the show did not take place. Whether this was due to the definition of the test protocol being too stringent or due to intervention by the [Establishment] powers that be or simply due to the lack of readiness by the inventors of these wonderful machines I cannot say. What I can say is that having been with Scott Strachan when he demonstrated his antigravity machine to an audience of two hundred or so scientists and engineers in Canada in 1988 and knowing that his machine was kept in Edinburgh in a state of readiness for demonstration at the time of the intended event, it is difficult to see why the show did not proceed. Strachan lives about two or three miles from the University laboratory at which Professor Salter was located. The machine, as demonstrated in Canada, developed an out-of balance force sufficient to lift an apple, a tribute to the proverbial discernment of Isaac Newton. Curiously, some years after this event Professor Eric Laithwaite and Alex Jones, in the South of England, both of whom had something to demonstrate were featured in a television program on the subject. Professor Laithwaite stood on a weighing platform and manually forced his spinning flywheel into its abnormal precessing mode. The professor with his flywheel lost weight, as clearly shown by the measurements conducted in a university laboratory. I can but wonder why this demonstration was not made years earlier at the Edinburgh site, but given Laithwaite’s professorial status at the Imperial College of Science, and the fact that he had regularly demonstrated his gyroscopic anomalies at that location, the trek to Scotland to perform for another professor might not have had appeal. Be that as it may, when I wrote the following short paper on ‘The Theory of Anti-Gravity’ for the BASRA Quarterly Journal, I was reacting to the events at the time. The reader will need, therefore, to keep in mind my above comments about the situation as it stood during a winter period in 1988/1989.

    The BASRA paper reads:

    The recent confirmation that a spinning body can lose weight under certain circumstances presents a challenge to those who theorize on the nature of gravitation. The author here explains how his theory of long-standing can cope with this problem.

    There are many experimenters who have discovered loss of weight anomalies in spinning bodies. They have been ignored by those established in the system which governs science funding and regulates the teaching of future generations of orthodox scientists. However, the recent confirmation by a specially commissioned commercial testing laboratory that one such device does lose weight has begun to cause rumbles which might well upset the complacent posture of the relativists who monopolize the field.

    This is a reference to the machine built by Scotsman Sandy Kidd and tested in Australia, but, as readers know, there are many others who have demonstrated such effects, for example Bruce de Palma in USA, Eric Laithwaite in England, and, as was noted in a recent BASRA article [1], Scott Strachan who demonstrated a machine in Canada in 1988.

    A Scottish newspaper, the Dundee Courier of 28th December 1988, reported a projected event at Edinburgh University planned just after Easter 1989 at which as many as 12 such machines might be tested before responsible adjudicators with the object of settling this question once and for all.

    Now, in the likely event that the phenomenon is verified on this occasion, what will the theorist do to cope with this very troublesome problem? We can guess that those interested in commercial exploitation will be in no such dilemma. Einstein’s followers look like being left behind in the advance of technology because their theory is then destroyed for the reasons already of record [1].

    The answer for the non-relativistic theorist is, in this author’s opinion, to be found in the theory of gravitation which is of record [2] and which has the following basic features.

    Firstly, one needs to admit that space is full of something that has energy but is invisible and very elusive. It is a sea of something having equilibrium to such a degree of perfection that it reveals itself only as a carrier of energy at light speed and, even then, it finds a way of confusing us when we try to detect the reference frame that it provides. We can be sure, however, that it is the seat of an inertial reference frame since only empty space provides the universal metric in which rotation is measured.

    Secondly, one needs to admit that matter, as we know it, exists as a disturbance or misfit in this background sea of energy. Matter exists in some measure related to past events of happenings in this background energy sea, but we need not speculate on that in our quest to understand gravity.

    Thirdly, all elements of matter suffer a jitter motion according to Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle. Matter has mass and is in a state of jitter in the inertial frame. Accordingly, guided by our own experience of how we get things to jitter, we must look for something that provides a counterbalancing action. It is here that the author intuitively made the presumption that some energy is displaced from the local background medium to form concentrated mass quanta (called gravitons) which move in inertial juxtaposition with the jittering matter to keep things in balance.

    In summary, therefore, the theory regards a mass M of matter as moving in a pattern of motion constituting what we may term an E frame, which jitters about the inertial frame in which an energy deficit (-Mc2) has occurred accompanying the creation of a graviton mass M in balancing motion in what we may term a G frame.

    So far as we can see, the matter mass M stands alone, but jitters. In reality, however, there is a graviton mass M coupled with the matter mass M but neutralized by a mass deficit effect in the sea of empty space.

    How does this help us to understand gravity? Well, firstly, we stand a chance of quantifying gravitational action in terms of a standard graviton unit, especially if we say that the real action of gravity is not between matter mass but between graviton mass. Secondly, we can use electrical theory in an interesting way by saying that the electromagnetic reference frame (the E frame) is somehow determined by the collective presence of matter mass. This explains why no electromagnetic gravity action is seated in the matter mass. However, because the gravitons move relative to this E frame they are able to assert mutual electromagnetic actions and so give scope for interpreting gravitation as an electromagnetic effect, assuming that the gravitons are electrically charged, pervade a tenuous uniform sea of charge, and come in equal numbers as positive or negative.

    Indeed, this theory has developed over the years and the author can now show that the tau lepton is the primary graviton form, whereas the muon lepton forms the background space medium defining the inertial frame. The remaining charged lepton form, the electron, is, of course, a feature of the matter frame or E frame.

    What about that demonstrated loss of weight? Well, how can matter mass lose weight if its rest-mass energy is conserved and gravitates, meaning it has weight? It cannot. So the fact that matter mass ‘appears’ to lose weight is clear verification that matter mass has no weight in the first place. It merely can be coupled, and normally is, to graviton mass which does have the right properties. This is what the author’s theory is all about. Evidently, by suitable manipulation of flywheels in the reported experiments, that close coupling is severed transiently and sufficiently for the gravitons to begin to fall under gravity when freed from the connection with matter.

    In fact, being leptons present in charge pairs, the gravitons die and are recreated constantly by a pair annihilation process. Therefore, as they fall within the coextensive body of the flywheel, they move from positions of higher gravitational potential where they are created closely coupled to matter mass to positions of lower gravitational potential where they decay. This involves energy exchange not sustainable by the vacuum energy equilibrium state if the body of matter itself alters its position relative to the gravitational potential. The reason is that we must have overall energy conservation and if, periodically, the matter mass has its coupling with the gravitons restored, equilibrium demands that any gain of gravitational potential energy in the real matter world must come from somewhere. The laws of mechanics governing the precessing flywheel keep energy conserved so far as concerns motion of the flywheel about axes other than its spin axis. So, unless we can draw on energy of disordered motion, heat energy, the flywheel spin has to yield kinetic energy in some way to meet the demands of gravity, even if this breaches Newton’s Third Law of Motion [3].

    The loss of weight by the force-precessed offset gyroscopic machines must, therefore, be accompanied by a slowing down of the flywheels in a levitating system. Conversely, we should expect the flywheels to speed up in a descending situation. Such are the issues now facing researchers in this field. The author’s theory of gravitation looks like being able to cope with the gravity challenge now before us.
    [1] H. Aspden, BASRA J., pp. 2-4, Dec. 1988.
    [2] H. Aspden, ‘Physics Unified’, (Sabberton), 1980.
    [3] H. Aspden, ‘Anti-Gravity Electronics’, Electronics and Wireless World, vol. 95, pp. 29-31, January 1989.

    In the above paper it was stated that only empty space provides the universal metric in which rotation is measured. By this is meant space devoid of matter. It is an experimental fact that a vacuum state enclosed within an evacuated cavity can be the seat of propagating electromagnetic waves which, by their interference, give a measure of the speed of rotation of the enclosing cavity. There has to be something in the vacuum that endows it with a non-rotating frame of reference, something real rather than a notion in a mathematician’s mind, and I can but say that this has to be an aether medium.
    In referring to Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle it may seem that I too am building theory on the notions of a mathematician, Heisenberg. I am not, because I see the graviton system and its dynamic balance with matter as the cause of a universal jitter which accounts for that uncertainty relationship. When something jitters in a circular motion and you see it from a distance it might appear to be at rest, but yet at all times its position is uncertain in measure represented by the radius of that orbit and its momentum is uncertain because it reverses direction constantly, but yet the product of the two is a constant which we relate to Planck’s action quantum.

    Concerning the mention of heat at the end of the paper, I am not really expecting researchers to find that a gyroscope cools when exhibiting anti-gravity. Only experimental research can resolve this question, but if there is an anomalous gain in energy then I have no problem in accepting that it is the aether that cools upon shedding energy. Indeed, the aether heats owing to the gain in entropy and by that jitter motion it puts order into this thermal chaos. When it gets too much energy it sheds it by creating protons and electrons, but maybe the anti-gravity process allows some to be intercepted before reaching the proton stage. The research aimed at ‘free energy’ is all focused on this same point. We must convert heat into useful power by drawing on the ‘heat’ of our ambient environment or on the ‘heat’ of the underworld of the aether!

    Now, this is where the supergraviton enters onto the stage in playing a role as part of the process leading to ‘warm superconductivity’.

    How Particle Discovery reveals a Source of Infinite Energy

    In spite of the resources deployed by high energy particle physicists, they still do not understand why Nature creates mesons such as the mu-meson, otherwise known as the heavy electron or muon. Nor do they recognize that elusive ghost, the signature of the graviton, which occurs at 2.587 GeV. This compares with the electron rest-mass energy of 0.000511 GeV, the muon rest-mass energy of 0.106 GeV or the proton rest-mass energy of 0.938 GeV.

    However, in 1964, the aether theory I had then worked on for ten years revealed the secrets of the mu-meson and, shortly thereafter, in 1965, the 2.587 GeV graviton emerged. It was then a simple matter to evaluate theoretically the precise value of G, the constant of gravitation, expressed in terms of the electron charge-mass ratio and based on energy perturbations of that graviton form.

    At pp. 81-82 of the 1966 edition of my book ‘The Theory of Gravitation’ I show how three well-known mesons were all unstable spin-off products of a decay involving the 2.587 GeV graviton. I also show, from pure theory based on my interpretation of the structured form of the dynamic aether, how its 5063 ratio of mass to that of the electron emerged from the theoretical analysis. By 1969, when I published ‘Physics without Einstein’ I was able to point to the relevance of the discovery, as later reported by Krisch et al [Physical Review Letters, 16, 709 (1966)], of the ‘largest elementary particle to be discovered’. They write: “We believe that this is firm evidence for the existence of a nucleon resonance with mass 3,245 +/- 10 MeV … It seems remarkable that such a massive particle should be so stable.” This nucleon resonance occurred when protons were fed into a high energy environment in which pi-mesons (pions) were being produced. I immediately saw this as a particle resonance in which that graviton ghost had combined with the proton to shed pions and leave the transient signature as the energy quantum discovered by Krisch et al. Here was proton decay brought about by that graviton ghost! Note that 2.587 GeV plus 0.938 GeV less 0.279 GeV, the rest-mass of two pions, leaves 3.246 GeV.

    Those were the days when particle physicists were probing the scope for creating exotic particles in the energy region we associate with the mass regime of protons, deuterons, and tritons, but nowadays they have gone to the very high energy region where they seek to decipher Nature by discovering particle resonances at mass values akin to those of atoms seated at the middle of the periodic table. This is the region where the supergraviton develops in response to the need for a more effective dynamic balance in that quantum jitter condition of the aether.

    My onward research into that territory led me to discover that, if the gravitational balance were to be a joint effort shared by a group of ghost particles, where the mass and charge displacement properties were pooled, then the ratio of these quantitities which preserved the G-value would demand a unique supergraviton form as well as a super-heavy electron form (identified as the tau-particle or taon). The supergraviton is the cluster of such a group, but a degenerate form involving the mutual annihilation of a particle pair from this cluster leaves a residual neutral particle resonance in the region of 91-92 GeV, evidently the so-called neutral Z-boson which preoccupies much of the attention of theoretical particle physicists at this time.

    The scientific paper disclosing this theory was published in Speculations in Science and Technology, 12, 179-186 (1989). The paper is entitled: ‘The Supergraviton and its Technological Connection’. The supergraviton cluster has a rest-mass of 95.18 GeV, corresponding to 102.18 atomic mass units.

    As explained in that paper, the technological spin-off had implications for cold fusion, but the key technological contribution was the account of the warm superconductive properties of the perovskite materials Sr2CuO4 and La2CuO4. These involve a dynamic balance tuned to the near-resonant conditions of interaction with three and four supergraviton masses, respectively. The lanthanum composition has a molecular mass of 405 or 407 according to the Cu isotope present. The strontium composition has a molecular mass of 303 or 305 amu according to the Cu isotope present. This implies an effective supergraviton mass of value between 101 and 102 amu. Warm superconductivity arises because the electron collisions with atoms involve energy transfer from the thermal motion of the atom to the electron, owing to the impact being absorbed through the centre of mass of the dynamic system, whilst field energy stored in magnetic induction sustains the current by its regeneration effect.

    This then is some of the background leading to the supergraviton. I have, as I have reported under the title: ‘Extracting Energy from a Magnet’ in New Energy News, August 1995, come to realise that the supergraviton is at work in magnetic materials, particularly those exhibiting the very high coercive force needed by a permanent magnet. Indeed, in the latter part of my latest communication to New Energy News entitled ‘The New Energy Spectrum’ I drew special attention to the ‘free energy’ implications of a U.S. patent just cited against one of my patent applications. It is U.S. Patent 4,435,663 granted to IBM and dated March 6, 1984. Its title is ‘Thermochemical Magnetic Generator’. What is described is an apparatus which uses hydrogen as a working gas and magnetic intermetallic compounds which absorb hydrogen as the working magnetic material’. The description of the invention says that ‘thermomagnetic generators are devices that convert heat into electricity’. The description further shows that hydrogen is not consumed, it is trapped in an enclosure and merely transferred forwards and backwards from one absorbing substance to another cyclically under the regulated control of heat input. The magnetic transitions induce output electricity in a coil wrapped around the chamber housing the working substance. This patent presents experimental data showing that the mere variation of hydrogen gas pressure resulting from the heat cycle will generate electricity. This is a room temperature device but the magnetic state of the intermetallic compound transits through the Curie temperature reversibly, converting ferromagnetic state to non ferromagnetic state and vice versa, merely in response to hydrogen pressure, as thermally controlled. My interest is aroused by the fact that the chemical composition of the lanthanum pentacobalt working substance varies by absorption of hydrogen and a group of seven or eight such molecules, without the hydrogen, has a mass that is an integral multiple of 101 or 102 amu. The addition of hydrogen in changing LaCo5 to LaCo5H4 can affect the resonant tuning in the supergraviton coupling.

    In my New Energy News communication I also mentioned that on March 26, 1997, I was granted GB Patent No. 2,278,491 entitled ‘Hydrogen Activated Heat Generation Apparatus’. It has 18 claims and is part of my, albeit theoretical, efforts to contribute something to the cold fusion theme. I also mentioned that the British Patent Office has notified me that on April 16th the grant of my GB Patent 2,283,361 will be published. This is entitled ‘Refrigeration and Electric Power Generation’. It bears upon the thermoelectric theme, the subject of my Energy Science Report No. 3, but it also exploits the 101-102 amu supergraviton resonance theme by disclosing why oxidized polypropylene is a room temperature superconductor and showing how this can be incorporated in a thermoelectric power converter. A group of seven molecules in the chain structure of oxidised polypropylene [C3H6O]7 has a molecular mass that is 4 times 101.5 amu.

    The IBM patent is, of course, the one which I had in mind in referring to 2020 vision. If you have followed my logic in suggesting invention in using room temperature superconductor materials to fabricate a permanent magnet, then the converse implication is that, with the right treatment, the substances used today in fabricating permanent magnets might prove to be viable room temperature superconductors. The substance lanthanum pentacobalt warrants attention with that thought in mind.

    I shall write more extensively on this subject and point to other evidence of anomalous effects arising from hydride (and deuteride) composition resonances as I expand my website presence on Internet.

    Footnote

    Readers who are curious to know where the 2.587 GeV graviton is mentioned in an easily accessible scientific periodical shelved in a university library, may look up the review paper by D. M. Eagles at pp. 265-270 in International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 15 (1976). It is entitled: ‘A Comparison of Results of Various Theories for Four Fundamental Constants of Physics’.


  • LECTURE NO. 8

    LECTURE NO. 8

    THE ADAMS-ASPDEN MOTOR PATENT

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1996

    This Lecture is an article that appeared on pp. 50-53 of the September-October, 1996 issue of ‘Infinite Energy’. It has been edited in a very minor way at the point where there is reference to the research of W.G. Tifft concerning the quantization of galactic red shifts, the subject of Tutorial No. 10 in these Web pages and Lecture No. 6.

    INTRODUCTION

    I first heard of Robert Adams and his motor at a mountain retreat north of Denver, Colorado during the days just before a New Energy Symposium. That was in April 1993. A benefactor interested in knowing the truths about `free energy’ and its potential for solving the world’s pollution problems had funded the expenses of the invited speakers and the preliminary `think tank’ event at that retreat. My talk would be about magnetism and the aether as an energy source, but our `think tank’ groups each had an allocated theme. We were expected to point the finger at the best candidate for onward investigation, from the vague information and reports we had about discoveries and claims pertaining to the new energy world.

    Yes, there were several to choose from, machines involving magnets and solid-state devices such as that devised by Hans Coler, dating from the World War II era, or the then-current activity of Floyd Sweet (now deceased). In fact, one of our team, a colleague from U.K., had visited Sweet just prior to that Colorado meeting. However, specific information as to how to build any of these devices was not available, nor was there any acceptable theoretical account of their operation on which we could recommend action.

    Fortunately, however, someone had brought with him information publicized by the NEXUS magazine and a Manual, available from Nexus, describing a motor devised by a New Zealander named Robert Adams. `Over-Unity’ performance was claimed and enough was disclosed as a blue print for replication of the machine. We did not really understand how it could operate quite as well as Adams had indicated, but we were convinced that `over-unity’ was in prospect. Accordingly, as it seemed easy to build a motor such as Adams described, our group settled for the recommendation that the Adams motor should be looked into and somehow constructed to verify its performance.

    That was how I first came to know about the Adams motor.

    COLLABORATION WITH ADAMS

    At that time such experimental work that I had pursued on the `free energy’ theme was basically on solid-state magnetic systems and, in collaborating with a Scotsman, Scott Strachan, I had been involved with the invention of a thermoelectric device which was extremely efficient at converting low grade heat into electricity. Undoubtedly it defied the Second Law of Thermodynamics, but that point was not stressed in those early days. That invention had proved problematic because the devices built worked for a while by repeated operation for half an hour or so at a time, day after day, for several months, but then came the inevitable progressive weakening in conversion efficiency, ending with a defunct piece of equipment.

    The story on that is told between pages 124 and 128 of Jeane Manning’s excellent book `The Coming Energy Revolution – The Search for Free Energy’, ISBN 0-89529-713-2 published in 1996 by Avery Publishing Group, Garden City Park, New York.

    I was distracted from that thermoelectric venture when I took a more practical interest in the magnetic reluctance motor, inspired by what we had heard about Robert Adams. I was to be distracted again towards the end of 1995 when the Correa `Pulsed Abnormal Glow Discharge’ invention came to my attention, with its 5:1 over-unity feature clearly demonstrated. And now, as year-end 1996 approaches, I am destined to be distracted again, this time by having discovered myself why those thermoelectric devices mentioned above had failed. The remedy is easy as the problem does not involve deterioration. It is as if a bistable system has flipped to its off-state and just needs to be flipped back into its on-state, provided, that is, one knows what to flip!

    Now, to come to the point about my collaboration with Robert Adams, I am writing these words on October 28th, 1996 and in a week from now the granted patent I have procured jointly with Robert Adams will become available from the British Patent Office in its issued form. It is Patent No. GB 2,282,708. I plan, in these pages, to introduce my own motor research and relate it to that patent and explain my connection with Adams.

    I am also mindful that Adams, now recognized by an honorary doctorate from the Open International University of Sri Lanka, to become Dr. Robert George Adams, has recently published an addendum to the Adams Motor Manual entitled: `The Revelation of the Century’ and has included in that work some of my written contributions.

    The immediate focus of my attention, however, is a rather critical letter communication authored by Michio Kaku and sent to a programme producer of a radio station based in New York. It was dated May 20th 1996, but it is only now that I have become aware of this communication from Robert Adams’ new book.

    Adams need not have included Kaku’s letter in his book, but he did and I commend him for it. Apart from saying that Robert Adams was either the next Einstein and Newton rolled into one or a crackpot, he made these two comments:

    “Apparently, he (Adams) wants to extract energy from the ether by using rotating magnets, thereby violating the first law of thermodynamics (conservation of mass and energy). This is an ancient idea, going back centuries and was most popular in the 1880s, but was disproved by the Michelson-Morley experiment and Einstein’s relativity theory. Ether, which was supposed to be a magical substance which pervaded the universe, has never been measured in our laboratories.”

    “The proof is in the pudding. He (Adams) has to show a blueprint of his machines, show that they in fact generate energy, and show with a few equations how his theory works. Lacking a blueprint, a mathematical theory, and, say, video tapes of his motors generating energy from nothing, I cannot say with 100% certainty that he is wrong. (Only 99.99%)”

    Now, having just had an `over-unity’ motor patent granted in which I share inventorship with Adams, I will assume that those Kaku remarks are addressed also in my direction and reply accordingly, point by point.

    Firstly, as a educational exercise, the extraction of energy from the ether does not violate the first law of thermodynamics. By definition or simple semantics, if you extract energy from something and move it from that something A into something else B, the energy remains conserved overall. The first law of thermodynamics dates from before the time when the transmutation of mass and energy was recognized as the stellar power source by Sir James Jeans (1904). A critic might say, however, as Jeans himself did in his 1928 book `EOS’, that Isaac Newton knew of photosynthesis by which radiant energy transmitted through space is captured by plants and converted into matter, which stores energy by creating a combustible product. The transmutability of energy and mass was not discovered, nor was it first suggested, by Einstein. He was too late.

    Secondly, the existence of the ether was not disproved by Einstein. Indeed, Einstein has not proved anything, nor has he disproved anything. One simply cannot flaunt Einstein’s theory around as a reason for rejecting the prospect of an `over-unity’ motor. On the contrary, ask yourself why there are plans to test Einstein’s theory at a cost of $500,000,000 dollars by launching Gravity Probe B in 1999. If Einstein’s theory is right, why are there any doubts warranting expenditure on that scale?

    Thirdly, Kaku says the ether has never been measured in our laboratories and that its existence was disproved by the Michelson-Morley Experiment. The fact is that Michelson did not perform the experiment to test or refute the existence of the ether. He lived another 44 years after performing that experiment and believed in the ether to his dying day. He was trying to sense the Earth’s motion through the ether, but, since standing waves developed by mirror reflection had not been discovered when the experiment was planned, he had not allowed for that to affect the result observed. In fact, the ether energy stored in those standing waves, being trapped in the mirror system, makes the wave motion appear to be locked to the frame of reference of the mirrors, and not the ether as expected. The ether certainly was detected in the laboratory when Michelson found he could detect the Earth’s rotation relative to that non-rotating ether by his light wave interference experiments jointly with Gale in 1925. It was detected some years before that by Sagnac in France and is detected in modern navigation technology by the ring laser gyro. How can the speed of a laser beam travelling around a closed path inside an optical instrument detect rotation of that instrument if the beam is not keeping a fixed speed relative to something inside that instrument that does not share its rotation? That something is the ether! No amount of book learning or mathematics can avoid that simple truth, and even though the word `ether’ is seen as something `magical’ it is that something that delivers `free energy’, once we have decoded the combination of the magnetic lock which restrains its release. Note also that the ether reveals its existence when we have rotation and we have rotation in the Adams motor.

    Fourthly, as to Kaku’s pudding, which comes first, the chicken or the egg, the blueprint and the working machine, or the theory and the equations? Well, though we have no answer to this question of priority, we know there are chickens and we know there are eggs, so it really does not matter which comes first. Certainly, it seems, that in order for Kaku to decide whether `free energy’ is possible, albeit with only 0.01% chance, there has to be a theory, a machine and an ether.

    It is for this very reason that I have made special effort during 1996 to publish my book `Aether Science Papers’ as a forerunner of the Energy Science Report describing my own `free energy’ motor research. This Report No. 9 in the series is entitled `Over-Unity Motor Design’ and its date of publication is November 6th 1996, two days ahead of the first disclosure of details of my machine at a New Energy symposium held in Rotterdam in The Netherlands.

    The formal electrical engineering theory explaining the motor operation in tapping `free energy’ is contained in a few pages in that Report. The motor design is described and a photograph of the machine is included. Moreover there is an outline `blueprint’ that indicates the design of the multi-megawatt versions of the machine. However, as to the ether, or `aether’, to use my normal terminology, describing that in full detail needs more than a few pages for scientific proof and, as Kaku well realizes, the wisdom needed exceeds the talents of even an Einstein or a Newton.

    ABOUT THE AETHER

    I will digress here, just for a moment, before getting back to Robert Adams and the subject of the Adams-Aspden patent. My reason is another comment made by Kaku in that quoted communication. He asserted as a conclusion:

    “Inventors want to solicit money from investors, so I have a moral obligation to say exactly what I think about issues that, at some point, may hurt people.”

    Now that is a very poor reason for attacking someone’s lifelong efforts to probe the secrets of science with a view to advancing both knowledge and technology beneficial to mankind. The facts of life are that it is investors who want to solicit money by making profit from the creative endeavour of inventors. Invariably, inventors get hurt anyway, without some well-meaning individual doing his moral duty by hurting the inventor more by unwarranted criticism. Is it really a moral obligation to preach the gospel of Einstein’s theory in contending that investors should steer clear of Robert Adams, when his only thought is to have his efforts recognized?

    Of course, by the nature of things, the free-lance inventor can go adrift in a technical sense and then, if ensnared by those investors, he can be carried off into obscurity by a tidal wave of turmoil. Meanwhile the orthodox scientific establishment stands by and watches, mildly amused at the futile efforts of the free-lance inventor who ventures beyond the level of gimmicks for use in the household and garden. That is the way it is.

    As to my book `Aether Science Papers’ it shows how so much of vital importance, explained by neither Einstein’s theory nor quantum theory, has a straightforward answer. You see, just as Robert Adams in New Zealand and I in England sit poles apart on this our Earth, yet we are governed by the same laws of physics and subject to the same constants of physics. Body Earth is our common rotating frame of reference, but body Earth does not explain why those physical constants are, so far we know, universal. We take that for granted, just as our forebears took for granted the fact that they all inhabited the same aether. Our modernist society and its Einstein enthusiasts tell us there is no aether and so, Robert, you are on your own and only God can tell you why your experiments would work as well in England as they do in New Zealand!

    You might then wonder why scientists at the U.S. Bureau of Standards, at the National Physical Laboratory in England and at the equivalent CSIRO National Measurement Laboratory in Australia bother to measure the same physical constants to very high precision. Give or take a fraction of a part in a million attributable to experimental error, they always come out the same. Surely, that is because the aether spreads through all those locations and has the same structure everywhere. What do I mean by structure? Well, you need to look up the paper in Physics Letters, 41A, 423-424 (1972), entitled ‘Aether Theory and the Fine Structure Constant’ to find the answer. That paper emerged from the Australian CSIRO laboratory just mentioned. It shows how alpha, the most basic dimensionless constant in quantum theory, is derived by aether theory to give:

    (α)-1 = 108π(8/N)1/6

    and how N is found to have the lowest cell energy if N is 1843. This gives (α)-1 as 137.0359, correct to part per million precision in comparison with its measurement at any of those laboratories. If there were no aether then you might as well think of a number and try that, though it would be your ghost that makes that effort because you would no longer exist.

    Of course, there will be the Kakus of this world who say that the above formula is mere number play, contrived to fit known results. Well, that may be true for Einstein’s ‘1,2,3’ theory, but it certainly is untrue for the aether theory. You see, all Einstein did by the disguised mathematics of his General Theory of Relativity was to say (1) that the spectral red shift was the same as that evident by use of Newtonian theory, given that energy gravitates, (2) that light beams grazing past stars are deflected by twice the amount expected from Newtonian theory and (3) that planets describe orbits around the sun as if the planet’s motion-dependent attraction is three times stronger than the value predicted by classical theory. It is so easy to contrive a theory for a 2 and a 3 factor. A German schoolmaster Paul Gerber had, in 1898, 18 years ahead of Einstein, presented a theory for the ‘3’ factor, based on the speed-of-light propagation of gravity across space, but that was not mentioned by Einstein. The factor of 3 arises because the energy transfer between sun and planet is not confined to a pencil thin line drawn between sun and planet, but rather fans out as it transfers to the aether field and then converges on its target after taking more time over the longer route.

    Einstein’s theory is sterile. It offers no physical insight into the truths of the role played by the aether. It cannot explain that 137.0359 that governs quantum theory and, even on its own territory, it cannot explain the dimensionless constant involving G, the constant of gravity, nor, indeed, can it explain the unifying link between electrodynamics and gravitation!

    So, Robert out there in New Zealand, take note that you are in a part of the universe where the aether has the energy state corresponding to N having the value 1843! Note that I first discovered the formula above long ago in the 1950s using an engineer’s slide rule, backed up by logarithmic tables for higher precision.

    Take further note that, years after that 1972 paper was published, a famous astronomer in USA (Tifft), discovered that distant galaxies closely paired or in small groups exhibited differences in red shift. The differences were always multiples of 72.5 km/s in relation to the speed of light. Explaining this is a complete mystery. Why should Planck’s radiation constant be different from one galaxy to the next? Well, if you, the reader, were to study my aether theory (as by reading the Tutorial Notes and Lecture No. 6 in these Web pages), you could work out that, since aether energy density throughout space has to be uniform on a universal scale, the microwave emission frequency of a radiating atom will vary in proportion to N1/9.

    Now take 1843 as the base value of N and decrease it in steps of 4 as you look for higher energy per unit cell states in different galactic regions. It recovers in steps of 1, but since two electron-positron pairs are involved in the decrementing phase, that 4-step feature is what is seen. You will find that the result is the 72.5 km/s observed by Tifft. Check that by calculating 4c/9N as N decreases from 1843 to 1828, c being the speed of light. Check the Tifft paper to verify what I say: W.G. Tifft, Astronomical Journal, 211, 31-46 (1977). Refer to Lecture No. 6 and see how the more recent evidence bears out the intermediate steps giving the 18.1 km/s intervals. You will see in that paper just referenced Tifft’s comment that he could find no evidence of gravitational interaction between those adjacent galaxies! So, what has happened to Einstein’s theory. It requires universal gravitation with each of you being an individual observer at the centre of your own universe. I would rather believe in the aether, knowing that there is proof of its reality, and devote my efforts to tapping some of its store of energy to safeguard the future of mankind from unnecessary pollution.

    THE ADAMS MOTOR AND THE ADAMS-ASPDEN PATENT

    I have not built an Adams motor as described in his Manual. I do know that when I returned to Denver in May 1994 for the New Energy Symposium there were machines on show or described in the Proceedings which purported to be Adams motors but they did not perform over-unity. It was reported that one such machine came very close to being 100% efficient. Adams did not attend that meeting. However, in the intervening year I had struck up a contact with Adams. I found he was under the impression that such machines are unpatentable and I had skills in the patent field as well as knowledge about the physics governing the operation of motors and magnetism generally. In fact, I already had a granted US patent for a motor designed for over-unity operation, but never built [US Patent 4,975,608]. Adams had possession of motors which he claimed had the over-unity performance. I had, at the Denver 1993 meeting, declared my belief that over-unity motors were possible and supported the plan to explore the Adams machine.

    My distant association with Adams resulted in an exchange of technical information and the proposal to adapt the design of his motor in a novel way. His motor had open-ended magnetic stators and magnets in a single plane forming radial arms. The invention we jointly devised placed the magnets axially parallel with the rotor shaft, fitted two sets of toothed rotor pieces and made the stators into bridging yokes. The resulting configuration was of the form shown in Fig. 1, taken from the patent specification that we filed in U.K.

    The machine has to work over-unity, if properly designed, because the magnetic flux switching assures that much of the flux across the pole gaps is diverted, as the poles separate, so that it still links the magnetizing windings but finds a return closure path sideways from the rotor pieces and so exerts no braking action on the motor. The magnets provide the drive torque pulling the poles into register when no current is applied to the windings. The input of current drives the flux from the stator bridging yokes and forces it into the lateral route as the poles separate.

    There can be no input of inductive power by the magnetizing winding if there is no change of net flux linkage. It will change to some degree but, if the design were perfect, then the machine could run on negligible inductive power input. That leaves normal resistance loss and some magnetization loss, much of which can be reduced by making the machine larger and more powerful. A small machine could prove the principle, especially if we allowed for the heat generated in the windings and explored the overall energy situation to see if we really are tapping energy from the aether.

    The patent application was filed on 30th September 1993. It named myself and Adams as joint applicants and joint inventors. It has now been granted, as already stated. However, in May 1994, during the early days of its patent pendency, I encountered the reaction of those in Denver who had been unable to confirm `over-unity’ operability of the Adams motor. I saw our patent application as offering an improved design, but there were clouds developing and Adams was facing the problem of defending his position. As background also there was the rumour about rival Japanese motors and, as things developed, I heard of claims for a machine constructed in Hawaii that indicated over-unity operation and could, for all I knew, be quite similar to the one covered by the Adams-Aspden patent application.

    I was not too sure how Robert Adams was measuring his energy input and his energy output, so I could not vouch for his performance claims and, indeed, Robert was careful about the information he did disclose. When I heard he was adopting calorific measurement to verify the output energy, which would include heat generated in windings as well as magnetization loss, then I felt we were on track towards confirming the performance rating. I still wonder about the measurement of input power, having regard to the pulsed form of the current, and I am not reassured by the reference to the communication from the Group Research Centre of Joseph Lucas Ltd which Robert includes in his new book `The Revelation of the Century’.

    That said, however, going back to that 1994 period, I felt I had to take more initiative myself and so I decided to ask the U.K. Department of Trade and Industry to consider my application in a competition for an award of research funding based on a meritorious invention proposal. I offered something new, based on a new patent application, and backed by the patent cover I already had from my U.K. patent corresponding to the US patent already mentioned. In August 1994, though I was 66 years of age, I won that award and had 75% of research costs covered by the U.K. government. In the event that funding carried my motor research through to year-end 1995.

    I did not build the specific form of machine shown in Fig. 1, but instead constructed a motor that was designed to contain the magnetic flux more effectively within what became a single all-embracing magnetizing winding enclosing the whole motor. This is the basis of my own initiative on the ‘over-unity’ machine and, as the U.K. patent specification on this new machine is to be published early in December 1996, I am now releasing information by publication on November 6th of my Energy Science Report No. 9 entitled ‘Power from Magnetism: Over-Unity Motor Design’. Figure 12 of that Report, backed by design detail, shows how the over-unity factor is determined and I reproduce that figure below as Fig. 2.

    Without going into full details, note that the diagram is an idealization of a B-H magnetization curve. It has a linear B-H relationship drawn through the origin O but at high flux density levels the curve bends over as it creeps towards saturation and the slope of the curve drops. The areas a, b, c and d, respectively, represent energy density input in energizing the magnetic system. The areas a and b apply for low flux range magnetization over the lower part of the curve. The areas c and d apply to flux changes confined to the upper region. Areas a and c are energy inputs from the magnetizing winding, whereas c and d are energy inputs that electrical engineers never consider, because that energy is supplied by the aether.

    Where does the energy go? That is an interesting question fully explained in my Report, but the answer, simply, is that it is pooled by being shared equally between the space occupied by the ferromagnetic core and the space taken up by the air gaps in the core. That energy in the air gaps, or pole gaps in the motor, provides the mechanical drive.

    So, you can see for yourself that, if you run the motor over the lower flux density range, which is normal, then you operate at an efficiency which cannot exceed (a+b)/2a, which is 100%. On the other hand, if the motor operates over the higher range, the efficiency can reach up to (c+d)/2c, which is very much higher than 100%!

    Consider some realistic figures by putting the knee in the curve at 15,000 gauss and assuming that the incremental B/H ratio is 1000 over the lower range but only 50 over the upper range. Operate the stator core of the motor up to a B value of 20,000. H ranges from 15 to 115 over this upper range. Work out the area c as being (15+115)x5000/2 or 325,000 and the area d as being (15,000+20,000)x100/2 or 1,750,000. You will then see that operation close to 319% efficiency is indicated!

    Be less ambitious in power output terms and run the motor over an upper range between 15,000 and 17,000 gauss, to find that area c is (15+55)x2000/2 or 70,000 and the area d is (15,000+17,000)x40/2 which is 640,000. (c+d)/2c is then 507%!

    If the aether delivers energy on loan to you and you use it to run the motor as the poles come together but refuse to give it back, then the aether has to replenish itself by taking power from its own vast pool of energy activity. It merely ripples to find a new level of equilibrium just as the sea will recover if you take a bucket of water from it. Eventually, that energy borrowed finds its way back to the aether as we spend it by generating heat radiation..

    If you do not believe what I say, then wait and watch the progress as those who do believe, be it Robert Adams or whoever so decides to build a magnetic reluctance motor heeding the design principles I have recorded in my Report.

    As a final note I will echo one message which I have independently mentioned in my Report No. 7 (the Report used to brief the U.K. Department of Trade and Industry on my Award progress). It is that magnetic reluctance motors already being manufactured that are said to be 80% or 90% (or even 96% efficient as I now see reported on page 21 of the U.K. Institution of Mechanical Engineers 16 October 1996 issue of ‘Professional Engineering’) are already trespassing upon forbidden territory. That level of efficiency is either a false claim or the motors are already regenerating power from heat dissipated as loss. 


  • LECTURE NO. 7: CONTINUATION

    LECTURE NO. 7: CONTINUATION

    THE COLER REPORT

    The following is a collection of sections of text that are quoted from the British Intelligence Objectives Sub-Committee Trip Report No. 2394 BIOS Target Number: C31/4799) entitled: ‘THE INVENTION OF HANS COLER, RELATING TO AN ALLEGED NEW SOURCE OF POWER’, BIOS FINAL REPORT No. 1043: ITEM No. 31′, as made available to the public by the U.K. Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, National Lending Library for Science and Technology. The author of the report is named as R. Hurst, Ministry of Supply.

    On page 1, under the heading: OBJECT OF VISIT AND SUMMARY:

    Coler is the inventor of two devices by which it is alleged electrical energy may be derived without a chemical or mechanical source of power. Since an official interest was taken in his inventions by the German Admiralty it was felt that investigation was warranted, although normally it would be considered that such a claim could only be fraudulent.

    Accordingly Coler was visited and interrogated. He proved to be co-operative and willing to disclose all details of his devices, and consented to build up and put into operation a small model of the so-called ‘Magnetstromapparat’ using material supplied to him by us, and working only in our presence. With this device, consisting only of permanent magnets, copper coils, and condensers in a static arrangement he showed that he could obtain a tension of 450 millivolts for a period of some hours: and in a repetition of the experiment the next day 60 millivolts was recorded for a short period. The apparatus has been brought back and is now being further investigated.

    Coler also discussed another device called the ‘Stromerzeuger’, from which he claimed that, with an input of a few watts from a dry battery an output of 6 kilowatts could be obtained indefinitely. No example of this apparatus exists, but Coler expressed his willingness to construct it, given the materials, the time required being about three weeks.

    Opportunity was taken to interrogate Dr. F. Modersohn who had been associated with Coler for ten years and had provided financial backing. He corroborated Coler’s story in every detail.

    Neither Coler nor Modersohn were able to give any theory to account for the working of these devices, using acceptable scientific notions.

    There then followed two pages of ‘HISTORICAL NOTES’, divided into two sections, each relating to a different one of the two devices mentioned above. This was followed by the REPORT proper, which included several Appendices containing test data, copies of reports by German professors and drawings.

    1. The ‘Magnetstromapparat’

    This device consists of six permanent magnets wound in a special way so that the circuit includes the magnet itself as well as the winding. (See Fig. 1).

    These six magnet-coils are arranged in a hexagon and connected as shown in the diagram (Figs. 2 and 3), in a circuit which includes two small condensers, a switch and a pair of solenoidal coils, one sliding inside the other. To bring the device into operation the switch is left open, the magnets are moved slightly apart, and the sliding coil set into various positions, with a wait of several minutes between adjustments. The magnets are then separated still further, and the coils moved again. This process is repeated until, at a critical separation of the magnets, an indication appears on the voltmeter. The switch is now closed and the procedure continued more slowly. The tension then builds up gradually to a maximum, and should then remain indefinitely. The greatest tension obtained was stated to be 12 volts.

    The ‘Magnetostromapparat’ was developed by Coler and von Unruh (now dead) early in 1933, and they were later assisted by Franz Haid of Siemens-Schukert, who built himself a model which worked in December 1933. This was seen by Dr. Kurt Mie of Berlin Technische Hochschule and Herr Fehr (Haber’s assistant at K.W.I.), who reported that the device apparently worked and that they could detect no fraud. One model is said to have worked for 3 months locked in a room in the Norwegian Legation in Berlin in 1933. No further work appears to have been done on this system since that date.

    2. The ‘Stromerzeuger’
    This device consists of an arrangement of magnets, flat coils and copper plates, with a primary circuit energized by a small dry battery. The output from the secondary was used to light a bank of lamps and was claimed to be many times the original input and to continue indefinitely. Details of the circuit and a theory as to its mode of operation were given (summarized in Appendix I). (Note by H. Aspden: This Appendix is not included in these Web pages. I cannot accept Coler’s theory, which suggests that electrical charges are also tiny magnetic poles, of north or south polarity, which can move with current through the magnet and somehow gain energy from the magnet. Quite clearly, Coler did not understand why his device worked.)

    In 1925 Coler showed a small (10-watt) version to Prof. Kloss (Berlin), who asked the Government to give it a thorough investigation, but this was refused, as was also a patent, on the grounds that it was a “perpetual motion machine”. This version was also seen by Profs. Schumann (Munich), Bragstad (Trondheim) and Knuden (Copenhagen). Reports by Kloss and Schumann are translated in Appendices II and III.

    In 1933 Coler and von Unruh made a slightly larger model with an output of 70 watts. This was demonstrated to Dr. F. Modersohn, who obtained from Schumann and Kloss confirmation of their tests in 1926. Modersohn then consented to back the invention and formed a company (Coler G.m.b.h.) to continue the development. At the same time a Norwegian group had been giving financial support to Coler, and these two groups clashed. Modersohn’s connection with Rheinmetall Borsig, and hence with the official Hermann Goering, combined to give him an advantage in this. Coler then in 1937 built for the Company a larger version with an output of six kilowatts.

    In 1943 Modersohn brought the device to the attention of the Research Department of the O.K.M. The investigation was placed under the direction of Oberbaurat Seysen, who set Dr. H. Frohlich to work with Coler from April 1, 1943 to September 25, 1943. Frohlich was convinced of the reality of the phenomena and set about investigating the fundamentals of the device. He apparently concentrated on a study of the energy changes which occur on the opening and closing of inductive circuits. At the end of the period he was transferred to B.M.W. to work on aerodynamic problems and is now working in Moscow.

    In 1944 a contract was arranged by O.K.M. with Continental Metall A.G. for further development, but this was never carried out owing to the state of the country. In 1945 the apparatus was destroyed by a bomb, in Kolberg, whither Coler had evacuated. Since that time Coler had been employed sometimes as a labourer. Modersohn had severed his connection with Rheinmetall Borsig, of which he had been a Director, and was working for the Russian authorities as a consultant in chemical engineering.

    Following the above historical background commentary, the next three sections presented the REPORT as being, respectively, an interrogation of Coler, an interrogation of Modersohn and the actual construction and testing of the device by Coler in the presence of the visiting U.K. Government scientists:

    1. Interrogation of Coler
    Coler was questioned first about the history of his inventions, when the details above were given.

    He was then questioned about the theory of the devices, but he was unable to give any coherent suggestions as to the mechanism. He stated that his researches (apparently conducted with crude apparatus) into the nature of magnetism had led him to conclude that ferromagnetism was an oscillating phenomenon, of frequency about 180 kHz. This oscillation took place in the magnetic circuit of the apparatus and induced, in the electrical circuit, oscillations the frequency of which, of course, depended on the values of the components used. These two phenomena interacted and gradually built up tension (meaning voltage). As the mechanism was not understood the proper arrangement could not be worked out, but had been arrived at by experiment, and the apparatus had to be brought into adjustment by similar trial and error methods. Coler stated that the strength of the magnets did not decrease during use of the apparatus; and suggested that he was tapping a new sort of energy hitherto unknown, – “Raumenergie” (Space-energy). Coler gave a resume of the work done by Dr. Frohlich for O.K.M., and produced a copy of Frohlich’s report (translation reproduced as Appendix IV) and a report of his own (part of which is given in Appendix V).

    Coler was next asked if he would consent to build models of these devices if material was made available. He agreed that he could do this and stated that it would take one week to construct a ‘Magnetstromapparat’ and a month to construct ‘Stromerzeuger’. Accordingly we supplied the magnets, condensers and copper wire needed for the former, and Coler proceeded to build an apparatus as discussed in Section 3. A list of the material required to build the ‘Stromerzeuger’ was drawn up by Coler.

    2. Interrogation of Dr. F. Modersohn
    Modersohn was questioned about the history of these devices, with which he had been concerned financially, and corroborated the details given by Coler. He stated that he had at first disbelieved Coler’s claims, but had taken great precautions to eliminate fraud. He had seen the 70 watt ‘Stromerzeuger’ working on a number of occasions and had taken it while working from one room to another. All parts were visible and nothing was hidden. As he was himself not an expert he had tried to get experts to examine it thoroughly, but reputable scientists either refused to have anything to do with it at all, or else were more concerned to find a fraud than to see how it worked. The exception was Dr. Frohlich, who was convinced of the reality of the effect and who also believed that the secret was to be found in the energy changes in the special inductive circuit used. He had made experiments to test his ideas, but Modersohn denied knowledge of his results. Modersohn was extremely methodical and showed his files on the subject: these contained copies of all letters and reports concerning the device, since 1933.

    3. Construction and Testing of the ‘Magnetstromapparat’
    In our presence and with material supplied by us (some brought from England and the rest bought locally) Coler built an apparatus as shown in Figs. 1, 2 and 3. It is to be noted that some magnets are wound in a clockwise direction looking at the N pole (called left) and others in an anti-clockwise direction (called right). The magnets were selected to be as nearly equal in strength as possible, and the resistance of the magnet-coil was uniform (about 0.33 ohm). The physical arrangement was as shown in Fig. 2 in a breadboard style. Measurements of voltage and current across A-B were made by Mavometer. A mechanical arrangement of sliders and cranks for separating the magnets evenly all round was made up.

    On July 1, 1946 experiments were being continued after three days of fruitless adjusting, and when the magnets were at a separation of about 7 mm the first small deflection was noted (about 9 a.m.). The switch was closed and, by slow adjustment of the sliding coil and by increasing the separation of the magnets to just over 8 mm, by 11 a.m., the tension was raised to 250 millivolts and by 12.30 p.m. it was 450 millivolts. This was maintained for another 3 hours, when a soldered tag became disconnected, and the meter slowly dropped back to zero. Soldering up the broken connection did not restore the tension. The magnets were closed up and left overnight and the same procedure for finding the adjustment was repeated on July 2, 1946. After about three hours a deflection of 60 millivolt was obtained; this was maintained for more than 30 minutes, but then decreased to zero when further adjustments were tried.

    During all this work the model was completely open, and nothing could be hidden in it. The breadboard and meter could be picked up and moved round the room, tilted, or turned, without effect.

    The apparatus would appear to be too crude to act as an a receiver of broadcast energy, or to operate by induction from the mains (the nearest cable being at least 6 feet away), and the result must for the moment be regarded as inexplicable.

    This was followed by a section headed ‘CONCLUSIONS’:

    1. It was judged that Coler was an honest experimenter and not a fraud, and due respect must be paid to the judgment of Frohlich in the matter, as deduced from his report to Seysen.

    2. The result obtained was genuine in so far as could be tested with the facilities available, but no attempt has yet been made to find an explanation of the phenomenon.

    3. It is felt that further investigation by an expert in
    electromagnetic theory is warranted and that Coler’s offer to construct a model of the “Stromerzeuger” should be taken up.

    The following comments apply to the Appendix section of the Report:
    (a) Concerning Appendix I, this outlines Coler’s theory, which does not warrant quotation.
    (b) Concerning Appendix II, this is the Report by Professor M. Kloss who tested a device constructed by ‘Captain Coler’ (March 4th, 1926). This had the ‘Stromerzeuger’ form, meaning that battery power is used as input to establish and sustain oscillations of current through the magnets. It includes tables of test data showing input in volts and amps for different tests under increasing load conditions and the corresponding output also measured in volts and amps across lamps used as the load. There is an enormous gain in both voltage and current, as between output and input. The Report contains the following remarks:

    The result of the investigation showed an astonishing working of the apparatus, which, without further researches cannot be explained or compared with hitherto known characteristics.

    Regarding the cause of the observed characteristics, especially the solution of the question as to where the energy originates, no explanation can be given yet, after the short and simple tests.

    Solely the conjecture can be expressed that the magnet-system is the source of energy.

    I should like to ask, however, the gentlemen (Coler and Professor Dr. R. Franke from the Technical College of Berlin, both present during the tests) not to mention my name and that of Professor Franke nor divulge the results of our tests without our express consent, or to make them known publicly and above all not in the press.

    (c) Concerning Appendix III, this is a Report by Professor W.O. Schumann (Munich) of tests on the Coler device in Berlin on 19th and 20th March 1926. This was a series of tests, again giving data of the results and based on the same arrangement as that tested by Professor Kloss. The last two paragraphs of the Report are quoted below:

    After the present examination, carried through as carefully as the limited possibilities of experimentation permitted, I must surmise that we have to face the exploitation of a new source of energy whose further developments can be of immense importance. The apparatus was visible and accessible in all its essential parts. The inventor agreed quite willingly to each trial in so far as, according to his statement, no harm could be done by working of the apparatus.

    I do not believe in a deception. I deem it expedient to put the apparatus to a further test, and I believe that a further development of the apparatus and an assistance, given to the inventor, will prove justified and of great importance.

    (d) Concerning Appendix IV, this was the Report based on the tests at (i) the Research Department of the Admiralty (OKM), Berlin, Wannsee, between April 1 1943 and June 6, 1943 and (ii) at the Physical Institute of the Technical University of Berlin, between July 1, 1943 and September 25, 1943. The Report concerns essentially the tests made by Dr. Frohlich. It was clear that he had his own theoretical notion as to why the Coler device worked and he allowed this to affect his experimental efforts and his conclusions. There are details of several separate experimental projects. The following are quotations from the Report:

    Apart from the great number of alternative arrangements and connections between the different parts, – during the period covered by this report eight different circuit diagrams were tested in addition to the experiments above (This is a reference to the four experiments reported in detail in the Report) – the following so far unsolved problems are hindering success in making the apparatus work:
    (a) The influence of the pre-magnetization and of the magnetizing effect due to the battery current, upon the individual frequencies of the oscillating circuits.
    (b) The influence of the Barkhausen effect on the phase conditions of the oscillations in the individual circuits and on the mutual magnetic and electrical processes.
    (c) The influence of the movement of electrons in the pre-magnetized steel rods by the high-frequency pulse-like field variations, through the oscillations of the molecules of the magnets.
    (d) The behaviour of the mutual effect between the flat coils and plates in a high frequency system.

    It is clear from the above (meaning Frohlich’s summary review of the Report) that the success of the inventor up to now could only be due to chance or happy accident. The necessity, therefore, arises to transfer the apparatus from the state of empirical development, with sufficient technical means and based on results of an exact basic research, to a state of working procedure which can be controlled.

    Concerning Appendix V, this was a Statement by Coler relating to Frohlich’s experiments. Coler is here explaining the circuit tests aimed at generating excess power by normal magnetic inductive techniques at a frequency of 100 Hz. It would seem that the Frohlich initiatives had set Coler thinking about operation at such low frequencies, whereas the theoretical case put by Coler during his later interrogation by that U.K. Government gives a more promising account. There is nothing in Appendix V that warrants quotation here.

    ******

    This concludes this documentary survey of the Coler Report. I will, however, be reverting to the subject later in these Web pages as well as discussing that induction theme which was attempted by Frohlich. One needs to keep in mind the importance of those air gaps between the magnets or the corresponding effect of demagnetization if an open-ended magnet is used. That 180 kHz resonance is causing movements affecting the energy deployment in the magnetic fields which penetrate those air spaces. To gain energy one has to avoid setting up detrimental back-MMFs (magneto-motive forces) by the induction of a current reaction. At 100 Hz there is negligible scope for gaining excess power in a solid-state magnetic device.
    H. Aspden, August 27, 1997.

    


  • LECTURE NO. 7

    LECTURE NO. 7

    THE INVENTION OF HANS COLER

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1997

    INTRODUCTION

    It was put under Official Secrecy after its operation had been verified by Government scientists. It was a device which involved magnets and it operated to generate electricity without any source of input power other than the space energy of Nature’s quantum underworld. It was denied patent protection by the German Patent Office, as being a perpetual motion device. It was ignored and the records relating to it were buried in hidden archives. I surmise that that was because the scientists who had to pass judgement on what should be done simply could not understand the physical reason why the invention actually worked.

    I believe I know the secret of its operation and I will in this Lecture present a brief outline of that reason before quoting the facts of the case from the now-declassified Government report, which was entitled: ‘THE INVENTION OF HANS COLER, RELATING TO AN ALLEGED NEW SOURCE OF POWER‘.

    My approach to the problem takes account of the fact that Hans Coler did not himself know why his invention worked, but he could replicate its operation and instructed others who were able to build working devices. The professors who tested such devices did ascertain that the magnetic field inducing the output power had frequencies in the region of 180 Khz and the evidence pointed to the source of that power being within the magnets. Yet the magnets did not lose any of their strength. The report, as will be seen from the sections to be quoted, gives one assurance that this is no fraud but is, rather, a genuine technological phenomenon, one we cannot turn away from. It must be understood as it may be the energy technology which will provide us with our power in the centuries ahead.

    A BRIEF NOTE ABOUT FERROMAGNETISM

    It is a fact of physics that the onset of ferromagnetism as iron cools through a critical temperature (the Curie temperature) involves a release of heat over and above that associated with the normal cooling process. It is as if Nature says to the iron:

    “When you cool below that temperature, you may find it more relaxing to become internally magnetized by adopting a state of lower energy potential. You will find you can shed even more heat energy by adopting that state and I promise that I shall keep active in regulating your state of energy potential so long as your temperature remains below that Curie threshold. However, should you let yourself get too hot then you will lose your magnetism and I shall take my energy back from you as you cross that threshold. My message, therefore, is that the onset of the magnetic state occurs because I, Mother Nature, let you have some of my energy, which I know you will dissipate as heat, but, conversely, should you contrive to lose your state of magnetism, then you will pay the price and I will take that energy back from you. You will then be obliged to find a way of sucking that energy from the material environment around you.”

    Now, physicists do not express themselves in such a style. They merely describe the process as one involving a specific heat anomaly and describe their application of it as ‘adiabatic demagnetization’. However, in the latter pursuit they do not work with iron, but rather with certain paramagnetic salts. Yet it is what is happening in iron that is of major interest.

    You see, it so happens that inside each iron crystal at normal ambient temperature there is an ongoing state of transition as the direction of magnetic polarization switches between the 001, 010 and 001 directions in the cubic structure. These are all easy directions of magnetization, because, in an x, y, z coordinate system x, y and z represent these directions and iron finds its optimum energy potential by letting its magnetism lie along a direction parallel with a crystal cube edge. The 011, 101, 111, 110 directions are diagonal directions and it needs a strong magnetic field to force iron to direct its polarization towards such non-preferred directions. Concerning that ongoing state of transition, suppose an iron crystal is polarized in the 001 direction, does this mean that the electron ‘spins’ or whatever it is that accounts for the magnetic condition, all point in the 001 direction all the time? It need not, because logic tells us that symmetry plays a role and the instantaneous state of polarization in a crystal could well lie on the x, y and z axes for equal periods of time in each cycle of transition. Using plus and minus signs to represent direction along a given axis, the sequence: +001, -010, +100, +001, +010 and -100, would add up to a net effect in the 001 direction.

    In case you think this is all mere speculation, I invite you to explain why the polarization of iron is 2.221 units of the Bohr magneton per atom. The Bohr magneton is the magnetic moment developed by an electron having one unit of angular momentum in quantum theory. Two electrons per atom are involved in setting up the magnetism and each has two Bohr units of angular momentum. This is where I bring in the ‘fudge factor’ of 2 that Nobel Laureate Paul Dirac used in his theory of electrin ‘spin’, but which I see in my theory of magnetic induction as an orbital charge motion in the aether by which that medium reacts to half-cancel any applied magnetic field.

    The field set up by each atom is 2x2x2 units in strength, but it spends only one third of the time directed along the +001 direction and so has an average value of 8/3 units. The energy of a reaction in the magnetic field is the same whatever the direction of magnetization and it is determined by that average. It acts as a reaction to halve the instantaneous value of the field and so its reaction strength is (8/3)/2 units, but it spends only one-third of the time reacting to the polarization along the 001 axis. Therefore, its average effect as a reaction is (8/3)/6 units, which offsets the primary action of 8/3 units. Work that out and you obtain 2.222 units as the overall polarization in Bohr magnetons per atom. This compares with the 2.221 observed and suggests that there is a slight delay in the process of losing magnetism in one direction and developing it in another direction, as the crystal experiences its cyclic magnetic transitions.

    This was how I interpreted that 2.221 factor some 20 years ago, long before I had heard about Hans Coler. I never thought that there would be any way of proving this ‘time-sharing’ hypothesis as applied to the three preferred axes of magnetization of an iron crystal.

    I could even estimate the switching time, because I knew there had to be such a phenomenon for other reasons, dating 20 years back before I found the explanation of that 2.221 factor. It concerned the stress conditions which go with the ferromagnetic state. Copper, for example, is not ferromagnetic because, if it were, the mechanical stresses set up by its magnetic state would rupture it. Iron, nickel and cobalt each have a high tensile strength and a high modulus of elasticity. That reduces the strain energy density that occurs with magnetism and permits the condition of ferromagnetism. Now, if the iron crystal was polarized 100% of the time in the 001 direction, it would be distorted in shape owing to that mechanical strain. The stress set up suddenly in a crystal direction with the onset of a field in that direction is followed by the dynamic adjustment of the crystal form. This does mechanical work and there is a limit on the energy available from that magnetic potential source discussed already. So, after a small displacement, the crystal decides to transfer its magnetic effects to another crystal axis and it starts the process again. This involves ongoing flipping of states between crystal axes.

    To estimate the period involved all you need to do is to apply the formula for the speed of propagation of a mechanical displacement in a metal, namely (Y/d)1/2, where Y is Young’s modulus of elasticity and d is mass density. These are 2×1012 and 7.86 in c.g.s units for iron. Take the latter quantity to be, in round figures, simply 8, so that that speed becomes 500,000 cm/s.

    Now note that the magnets used in the Coler tests as shown in the data in the Report were just over 10 cm in length (probably a nominal length of 4 inches). However, if such a magnet is deemed to expand as the polarization directions of all its domains flip into the longitudinal direction in harmony, then the expansion involves a stress wave which on average travels through only 2.5 cm. This is because the centre of the magnet does not move, whereas the extremities are at 5 cm from the centre. Note that this wave is the physical displacement of a very small fraction of the metal, sufficient to give a small contraction of the gap width separating the end poles of adjacent magnets in the magnet loop of the Coler device. By this I am suggesting that it takes a period of the order of 2.5 cm divided by 500,000 cm/s before the flip of the domain polarization takes effect in adjusting to the change. The result is that the magnetic flux linking the winding around the magnet will build up from a low value to a maximum value in 5 microseconds. Then, if the current in that winding is carried by a resonant circuit optimized to that 5 microsecond rise time, we can expect the oscillation to match that rise time. Almost immediately, once that expanded state is reached, the domains will relax to normalize the stress condition and the polarization will flip to the other modes. Now, laterally, the distances of stress wave travel in the magnet are small in relation to the length of the magnet and this could mean that the reset period is very short. Thus the electrical oscillation in the winding could correspond to a kind of sawtooth stress waveform in the main flux direction linking the windings on the magnet. If that 5 microseconds were then to correspond to a 6 microsecond period, that would imply oscillations at 167 kHz.

    Consider what this means. It suggests that Coler may, without knowing it, have discovered a way of interfering with the natural rhythmic domain flipping process which I am sure occurs in a ferromagnet. It tells us to expect that, though it may pass unnoticed, the polarization of each individual magnetic domain in an iron crystal is changing to and from the preferred direction in each crystal at a frequency in the 167 kHz region. Then remember that those professors who tested the Coler device measured a 180 kHz frequency for the power it was delivering. Is this a mere coincidence? I think not! Go further with this reasoning and take note that the mean magnetic polarization in that preferred direction could be much stronger, by a factor of nearly 3, if that sawtooth waveform action really is present. Yes, this is somewhat speculative, but it is going to need something new and challenging in the physics of ferromagnetism if we are to understand why that Coler device works. At least, if one has a theory that supports some aspect of what is observed, then one has then a guide as to which direction to follow in one’s onward research.

    HANS COLER’S EXCITATION METHOD

    Hans Coler did not apply any external source of power to his magnets. He set up the apparatus and its circuit, adjusted the spacing between the magnets he had arranged in a ring and waited. Nature then began its work as those polarization directions flipped statistically in a near random way, but Coler had devised a circuit, even though he did not know it, that helped those random flips to find harmony in their actions.

    His circuit meant that if an overall magnetic flux change did occur through the magnets then it would cause a pulsating current to flow through each magnet. Now consider what that means. It says that he had set up in each magnet a circumferential field pulsation around the central axis of the magnet. It says that when that circumferential field was strongest it would be energetically favourable for the flipping of the magnetic transitions in those crystal domains to be in a direction orthogonal with respect to the main polarization direction of the magnet. It says, therefore, that if the frequency of that pulsation happens to be in tune with the natural frequency of that flip action, then all of the domains in that magnet will try to get in step in their rhythm. In short, there will be a cyclic flux change right around the ring of magnets and linking those coils which Coler had wrapped around the magnets. Without that synchrony of action the random activity would simply give a steady overall magnetic flux around the inductive loop and so there would be no power output.

    On this basis the energy generated by the Coler device must come from whatever is powering the cyclic transitions in each of those magnetic domains. Now, standard physical theory has not developed far enough, as yet, to take this cyclic flipping action of magnetic domains on board. Physicists do not really understand the mechanism of ferromagnetism or that mechanical stress activity that is inescapable in that ferromagnetic condition. However, be that as it may, the activity that is occurring is one in which at each critical stress level when the strain energy and ferromagnetic condition get out of balance, the ferromagnetism collapses momentarily. This cools the iron locally, but the ferromagnetic state then develops in an orthogonal direction and an equal amount of heating occurs. This is an ongoing cycle of events. As the ferromagnetism is reasserted along the axis through the body of the magnets in the Coler situation then the harmony of the action means a flux change linking the main winding on the device. This takes energy out as Nature is doing its work to build up that magnetic polarization. In other words, the cyclic demand on Nature to keep reasserting the ferromagnetic direction along the axis of the windings around those magnets, draws energy from the aether at that near-to-180 kHz frequency.

    One must, of course, wonder about the implications of this for magnetic skin effects which restrict changing flux penetration according to our conventional theories of electromagnetism, but I take account here of the effective unity permeability one experiences for flux changes in permanent magnets. That would mean that induced currents would have little effect in restraining changes in magnetic flux such as occur in soft iron cores. Indeed, I can only be guided by the facts of the situation and I tend to see what is asserted in the Hans Coler Report as fact. I make an exception with regard to the commentary about an experiment described by reference to a Figure 4 on the last page of the Coler Report, but will comment on that later in these Web pages when I report on certain experiments of my own. Meanwhile, however, I believe I have said enough to set the stage for a review of the Coler Report and I hope that this introduction will encourage whoever reads this, and has the necessary influence, to urge forward the research needed to take Coler’s work through a development phase leading to its commercial exploitation.

    I should just mention here that one cannot examine the surface of a piece of magnetized iron, as by using an electron microscope, and expect to see an image blurred by such vibrations. The reason is that the surface layers of atoms extending several Angstrom below the surface of a ferromagnetic body are not polarized. However, the depth of the non-polarized region is a function of crystal orientation adjacent the surface. Data on this are presented in a book by R. F. Soohoo entitled ‘Magnetic Thin Films’, published in 1965 by Harper and Row (see pp. 90-91). That book also includes an interesting comment at the top of p. 238. Observation of some degree of surface anisotropy in the magnetic fields reveals certain ‘peaks’ in the energy coefficients indicated by the measurements. There was a curious statement which reads:

    “Assuming a lattice constant is equal to 3 Angstrom and 4(pi)M equal to 104 gauss, we find a value of Hs equal to about 8x(10)4. It is inconceivable that a change of 4(pi)M of this magnitude could even occur in a Permalloy film whose normal 4(pi)M is equal to 104 gauss. Thus it appears that whereas a lower magnetization surface layer is capable of explaining the disappearance of the spin-wave modes at a given field orientation, it can not in general account for the high intensity of the peaks.”

    If you have understood what is said above about the 8/3 factor and seen that 8 Bohr magnetons is the primary polarization which flips around to give a mean of 8/3 diluted slightly by reaction to become 2.222, then you may see a glimmer of a connection here with what has just been quoted. That 2.222 Bohr magnetons per atom corresponds to a saturation polarization of 2.2x(10)4 gauss. 8 Bohr magnetons per atom would give that 8x(10)4 gauss value. Note that the saturation polarization of iron at 0 Kelvin is slightly below the value at room temperature. The 2.221 Bohr magneton figure quoted above is observed at zero Kelvin.

    Returning now to the Hans Coler theme, reproduction of the full text of the Official Report on the Hans Coler invention is not my intention. Copies of the Report can no doubt be procured from the appropriate sources. I do not have the relevant data on that as I write this text, but I will amend this Web page section as soon as I can provide such information.

    What follows is a sequence of selected excerpts from the Report and I shall not offer further comment on it in this Lecture. You must draw your own conclusions as you proceed, though I hope you will keep in mind what I have said above. However, I believe I will have much more to say on the subject in the onward development of these Web pages.


    To continue press:

    *

  • LECTURE NO. 6

    LECTURE NO. 6

    PROTON CREATION

    © Harold Aspden, 1997

    INTRODUCTION

    There is nothing more fundamental in science than the processes involved in the creation of the proton, simply because the proton accounts for virtually all of the matter that forms the universe. The residue comprises the electrons which provide the electrical neutralization and so allow gravity full freedom as the governing force.

    However, read as many books as you may, as written by best selling authors, and you will not find any answers to the three basic questions:

    1. How are protons created?
    2. How are electrons created?
    3. How is that there is a force of gravity?

    Yes, they will tell you that there was a Big Bang at the beginning of time and that the universe was born out of the intense heat of that cataclysmic event. They will tell you that after a few seconds or so, indeed after a specific number of seconds from the beginning of time, the protons and electrons came into being and they will go further and explain that gravity comes about because ‘space-time’ is curved and particles, which like to move in straight lines, have to follow what they call geodesic paths, the straight lines of curved ‘space-time’.

    You may come to believe what they say, especially after they explain why they think the universe is expanding and has been expanding steadily for upwards of 10,000,000,000 years. You see, there is a phenomenon called the ‘red shift’. Light from distant stars appears redder than it does from our Sun and that is interpreted as a Doppler effect, which is the apparent reduction in the frequency of electromagnetic radiation sourced in those distant stars, should we be receding away from them in a relative sense. They will tell you about cosmic background radiation and how measurements conducted on aircraft in the upper atmosphere reveal an anisotropy in the intensity of that radiation, one which betrays the existence of our motion through space relative to a kind of residue of energy put there by the Big Bang. To them, it all makes good sense, but do you really understand what they tell you?

    When I read about the Expanding Universe Hypothesis I wanted to know why it was that a light wave traveling at close to 300,000 km per second could keep going for 10,000,000,000 years without its frequency reducing somewhat. That is what they assume! The observed loss of frequency, evidenced by the red shift, is interpreted as a Doppler shift, something to do with relative motion, and not simply as a loss of frequency owing to the transit of light over vast distances of space.

    Those who write about such matters will tell you they know they are right in their assumption because, if there was something in interstellar space which affected that light and caused its frequency to reduce, it would affect different frequencies to different extents and the red shifts observed reveal no such dispersion. That is the logic of their assumption, just as they assume the validity of Maxwell’s equations governing light wave propagation without understanding the physical process which accounts for those equations.

    I wanted to know what there was in the vacuum that could cause light to travel at the fixed speed which scientists label by the symbol c. You can be sure that the speed of light is not constant just because Einstein took that as a principle on which to build his theories. If there is something in that vacuum I wanted to know why it is that light can involve undulating waves which can travel through space without losing frequency. More to the point and consistent with observation, I wanted to know if light could lose frequency at a rate linearly proportional to the frequency at each position along the transit path. You see, there could be loss of frequency as a function of distance traveled and, provided the loss is proportionally the same for all component frequencies, there would be the property needed to account for the observed red shifts from those remote stars and their galaxies. There is then no need to imagine that the universe is expanding from a point in space at which it was suddenly born as a virtually infinite amount of energy compressed into a infinitesimal point – the infinite in the infinitesimal! Any alternative explanation, if scientifically founded, has to have a prior claim on our common sense alongside the horror of that Big Bang hypothesis.

    Surely the situation demands that physicists must look again at that vacuum and Maxwell’s equations and be prepared to accept that they have overlooked something. Just because light gets dispersed in traveling a few cm through matter, dispersion resulting from different component frequencies traveling at slightly different speeds, we should not assume that it will suffer the same fate in a populated vacuum. Whatever does populate the vacuum could well have the property needed to explain a slight progressive loss of frequency in traveling trillions of kilometers through space.

    It is clearly both absurd and illogical to say categorically that there is nothing in the vacuum but yet know that somehow something there regulates light in transit and then go further and compound that statement by saying that, if there were something there, it must cause dispersion and not a progressive loss of frequency.

    Remember that the ‘vacuum’ is ‘space devoid of matter’, not ‘space devoid of physics’. Those Maxwell equations are a statement about the physics of what is there in that vacuum. They tell me, at least, that a propagating wave undulates in planes at right angles to its direction of propagation. Then I ask myself how something physical can oscillate in that lateral sense without pushing on something equally physical to keep a balance. Quite obviously something is missing from Maxwell’s equations. There must be two mutually-interacting physical attributes in the vacuum medium that assist in the propagation of those light waves. Maybe these work together in a way which conserves the wave in spite of obstacles encountered, but at the price of some loss in terms of energy and frequency.

    So I say that we need to learn what that ‘something’ is and examine the physics involved to see how it accounts for that red shift we see as we look at distant galaxies. That I have done and I find I can deduce Hubble’s constant, a measure of that cosmological red shift phenomenon, in terms of a theory which admits that protons are being created everywhere in space

    THE PROTON CREATION HYPOTHESIS

    I will tell that story about deducing the Hubble constant in another Lecture. In the meantime the curious reader can look up my paper on the subject [‘The Steady-State Free-Electron population of Free Space’] abstracted under reference [1984e] in the Bibliography section of these Web pages. My object here in this lecture is to discuss how protons are created.

    My proposition, one I have come to after studying the research findings on quantized galactic red shifts, is that there are vast regions of space in which a kind of natural equilibrium prevails at a low energy potential and some regions which are abnormal and at a higher energy potential.

    My hypothesis is that protons are created by a statistical process, as energy fluctuations in the vacuum intercept the hidden charge forms that sustain electrical displacement in Maxwell’s equations. A further aspect of the hypothesis is that there will be an incidence of proton decay keeping that proton population constant but not affecting its spatial deployment.

    We are, therefore, going to explore the physical processes by which protons are created in the vast expanse of space. Now, radio astronomers looking at their galactic radio sources pay close attention to the microwave emission at 21 cm wavelength. The source of this emission is the hyperfine feature of the spectral emission from hydrogen, the simple atom formed by the proton with its solitary satellite electron. The mass of the proton is crucial to the frequency of the signals emitted and the study of red shifts has something to tell us about the region sending us those signals.

    Though I shall show that the proton can have different mass values in some galactic regions, I shall give reason for believing that the mass of the proton, as it applies to the major part of the universe, is a universal constant. However, for those seeking assurance on the latter point and who need some experimental confirmation, I will here refer to the discussion of the constancy of the ratio me/mp by Petley at page 47 in his book: ‘The Fundamental Physical Constants and the Frontier of Measurement’, published by Adam Hilger of Bristol and Boston. He refers to an astronomical method which relies on evidence from quasars. The basis of this method is that wavelengths of the hydrogen lines depend upon the Rydberg constant and (1+me/mp)-1. In contrast, the wavelengths of lines emitted from heavier atoms have far less dependence upon the ratio of the masses of electron and nucleus. Therefore, if the red shifts of the hydrogen lines differ from those of the heavier atoms, for distant objects radiating with large red shifts, one has an indication of change of proton mass over time. However, the observational data quoted by Petley suggested that any change in me/mp has to be at a rate less than 5% per billion years.

    It is therefore appropriate to presume that, generally speaking, the proton/electron mass ratio does not change over time, but, being more specific, there are anomalies linked to the quantized red shifts that are now being observed in the study of 21 cm microwave radiation from remote galaxies.

    At this point I should like to summarize my objectives in presenting this Lecture. I know how protons are created and can deduce theoretically the precise value of the proton/electron mass ratio, meaning part in ten million precision. My theory, as it was developed many years ago, tells me that the protons created anywhere in the universe do have the same mass energy where a least energy state of the aether exists, but it also tells me that there are conditions, those prevalent in the higher energy regions of space, where that proton/electron mass ratio and the other of the two most important constants of physics, namely the fine structure constant, can have slightly different values. I do not suggest that any such constant can vary over time. All I am saying is that the value may depend upon energy conditions that are ‘frozen’ into the particular galactic domain locality under observation. My objective is to convince you, the reader, that I have here the answer to the first of those questions listed above.

    As to the second question, the creation of the electron, I will discuss that in a later Lecture in this series, but the third question, that of gravity has already been explained as you may see from Tutorials Nos. 6 and 9 in these Web pages.

    In fact, those Tutorial Notes (see particularly Nos. 8 and 9) also showed you how to calculate the proton/electron mass ratio, but I want here to prove the formula by applying it to the quantized red shift data which has emerged and which tells us that the proton/electron mass ratio can adopt different values in different localities of space.

    As you will see, the reason for this diversion has to do with the factor N, as used in those Tutorial Notes. There I was considering only circumstances local to our own space domain region, a low energy equilibrium space region, where N has a value proved to be 1843. However, N can be different, and have lower integer values under certain circumstances. This is important because the proof which verifies my theory, apart from the numbers coming out right, is the explanation of the quantized galactic red shifts that have been discovered since the theory was first developed.

    The route I followed in developing the theory initially took me into a formal analysis of the electrical structure of the aether and the need for its dynamic state to ensure that the interaction of its charge components avoided falling into a state of negative potential. The condition for zero potential was a factor which determined N, the number of electrons and positrons which, given energy input, could be produced from a simple element of aether charge without displacing the surrounding charge of a balancing continuum of opposite polarity. N was determined as being slightly greater than 1844, but the condition for least positive energy with N odd gave the definitive value of N as 1843.

    From this I was able to formulate the inverse value of the fine-structure constant as:

    108π(8/N)1/6

    which has the value 137.0359, if N is 1843, but there was a group of such formulae involving N. This gave the theory its full power by embracing the proton/electron mass ratio mp/me and the constant of gravitation G. To this group, as presented below, I will now add the expression showing how the hyperfine microwave radiation frequency of hydrogen depends upon N, this giving a measure of the quantized red shift.

    THE GOVERNING EQUATIONS

    hc/2πe2 = 108π(8/N)1/6
    mmu/me = [3/8π][108π]3(1/N)4/3
    mp/me = [4+2(6)1/2]mmu/me
    g = [3/4π][108π]3(1/N)
    G = (e/me)2[4π]2[1/108π]6(1/g)8
    fh = Kh(me/mp)(e/mec)2 = K'(N)1/9,

    where K and K’ are constants of proportionality. The expression for G is approximate, as a minor term has not been included. It does not concern our present analysis and is included here only to show how N affects the constant of gravitation.

    fh is the frequency representing the hyperfine radiation spectrum of hydrogen. As a red shift, expressed as an apparent Doppler shift velocity, based on the 300,000 km/s speed of light, this formula tells us that the quantized step in the red shift is:

    (300,000)[1 – (No/N)1/9]km/s,

    so you can verify that if No, as reference, is taken to be 1843, then as N decreases in integer steps so the red shift changes in steps of 18.1 km/s.

    To confirm the first five of the above equations one has to work through the details of an aether theory, as I have shown in the Tutorial Notes. I have written these Notes specially, as I have no doubt that the task of studying in depth the original periodical references was too daunting for even the few members of the scientific community who may have stumbled across my work. That plus the evident conflict with Big Bang theory, bearing in mind that the notion of an expanding universe does not suit the aether model I had proposed, is the likely reason for lack of interest. It was all too easy to say that I was ‘playing with numbers’, even though that is an unfair verdict, whereas those who think Einstein had to be right and aether theory had to be wrong did not heed anything I had to say.

    For those who wish to explore the background of my aether to learn more about the derivation of that integer N, I draw attention my paper entitled: ‘The Theory of the Proton Constants’, which is paper No. 7 of the 14 papers reproduced in my book ‘Aether Science Papers’. The periodical reference of the paper is Hadronic Journal, vol. 11, pp. 179-176 (1988). The subject was also addressed in my paper ‘A Theory of Proton Creation’, paper No. 9 in the above book. Its periodical reference is Physics Essays, vol. 1, pp. 72-76 (1988).

    Based on that derivation of the unique proton value of N as 1843 I shall now revisit the subject of Tutorial No. 10 in these Web pages to rectify an error that came about because I wrongly assumed that the quantized galactic red shifts observed by Tifft were seen in the optical spectrum rather than in the microwave radio spectrum of the hyperfine transitions in hydrogen.

    QUANTIZED GALACTIC RED SHIFTS

    If you refer to the pages of my Tutorial No. 10 you will see from equation (5) that the aether lattice dimension d was shown to vary as N-1/9. Certain other aether quantities, such as mec2, hfo, e2/d and fod, were all deemed to be truly universal constants, notwithstanding the possibility that fo, d, h and e individually could be different in different galactic domain regions. Note that fo is the Compton electron frequency, the frequency for which the energy quantum hfo equals mec2.

    The variation of d, the lattice spacing, was based on the assumption that the energy density of the aether lattice structure remains uniform throughout the universe. I now see that this was an error. I should have regarded the main energy constituent of the aether, that of the virtual muons, as being of uniform density. Thus, you can see, from the above expression for mmu/me, that it is (1/N)4/3/d3 that is the universal constant and this makes d proportional to (1/N)4/9.

    Keep now in mind the fact that our Tutorial analysis showed us that d is equal to 108π electron charge radii and that the rest-mass energy of the electron, which we assume to be a universal constant, is proportional to e2 and inversely proportional to that charge radius. This tells us that e4 is proportional to d2 and so to (1/N)8/9.

    Now, to come to the nature of the microwave radiation detected by Tifft and from which the quantization of galactic red shift was measured, it is noted that the formula for the frequency of hyperfine line separation producing the 21 cm emission is proportional, in theory, to the product of the Bohr magneton eh/4πmec and the nuclear magneton eh/4πmpc as divided by Planck’s constant h. This represents a term proportional to frequency and explains that sixth equation in the above group.

    Since me/mp is proportional to N4/3 and e4 is proportional to (1/N)8/9, that microwave expression becomes proportional to h(c)2/e2 times N4/9. Note that mec2 is a universal constant. Now we know from the fine structure formula above and its derivation that h(c)2/e2 is proportional to c(1/N)1/6 and c/r is proportional to fo, whereas r/d is proportional to (1/N)1/6, so that microwave expression becomes proportional to (N)4/9(1/N)1/6(1/N)1/6fod, which reduces to proportionality to N1/9, because fod is also a universal constant. Accordingly, we have justified the form of the sixth expression listed above.

    Remember that in the Tutorial No. 10 account, based on an assumed optical red shift, the corresponding variation was N4/9. That had explained the red shift steps of approximately 72.5 km/s with N stepping downwards through both odd and even integers.

    However, with our corrected analysis based on the radio spectrum observation, the theory implies red shift steps of 18.1 km/s as N decreases in integer sequence.

    Now it is my understanding from reading more of Tifft’s work that, though 72.5 km/s is the dominant feature in the quantization of galactic red shifts, there are intermediate levels of quantization, typically involving 36 km/s and 18 km/s red shift spacing.Tifft has written many papers on the subject, ranging over a 25 year period, many appearing in the Astrophysical Journal.

    It now becomes an interesting exercise to explore the factors which might govern how Nature selects one value of N with a stronger preference to another and to assess how this N quantization spectrum might have other cosmological implications.

    Having only recently come to see this feature that N can have a value other than 1843, I can only proceed tentatively in my own exploration of the subject, but a picture is developing. It is based on the belief that the virtual muon population, which must have the mean mass-energy values as determined by the above expression for mmu, adapt to a mix of virtual muon pairs of odd units disposed either side of that mean value. Thus, if the mean virtual muon has 206.3329 electron units of energy, as applies with N as 1843, then there are pairs of muons of 207 and 205 units in a mix having a ratio of very nearly two to one.

    Do note that this numerical circumstance might well explain why 1843 is rather special. An N value of 1844 corresponds to the least state of energy potential but it is 1843 that offers the easy route to proton creation, because nine virtual muons have to contribute to its creation and the statistical mix of 205 and 207 muons is virtually a 1 to 2 ratio. This means that three 205 muons plus six 207 muons can come together in a smooth energy transition to create the proton, whereas the N value of 1844 would involve some energy turmoil.

    Now, if you then consider how an aether domain can adapt to a higher energy state, meaning one for which r/d has increased and N reduced, there has to be creation of electrons and positrons to take up the volume of space freed by the reduction of N. Note that N is an integral number of electron charge volumes in an aether lattice particle, the quon. Now, there are only two ways in which N can change as a space domain boundary moves through the energy system that fills all space. N can increase or decrease. It will increase if it moves from a region where there are too many electrons and positrons in the quantum electrodynamic underworld. These will combine to create more compact forms of matter, those protons that we know are created by surplus aether energy. So as each electron positron-pair suffers its demise to shed energy for pooling as part of that creation process, their charge volumes will be taken up by two quons expanding their individual volumes by one unit. N will increase by 1.

    The reverse process is not that simple, because a quon has no way of acting alone to shed some volume and create an electron or positron. It has to look for assistance from the migrant leptons that are present everywhere in space. The electron-positron pairs cannot serve this purpose, because they act to increment N and we are now presuming that they are in a deficit state, because we are going to create them as the domain wall progresses.

    So we look to the virtual muons which we know bombard the quons to create the proton but we are only looking at an event where a virtual muon pair attacks the quon, rather than that rare event of proton creation when a multiplicity of virtual muons need to attack in the same rhythmic cycle period. The scenario therefore is one for which a pair of 207 muons, in ‘fertilizing’ the quon, shed energy to decay into a pair of 205 muons by creating two electrons and two positrons. This means that N can only decrease in steps of 4 units as the quon shrinks a little to free the space needed by those electrons and positrons.

    Consider what this means. There are regions of space in which there is an excess of thermal energy. Thermal energy is associated with motion of matter and all such motion involves inducing electron-positron activity in space. Indeed, the kinetic energy of an electron can be shown to be attributable to the statistical creation of electron-positron pairs in the close proximity of that primary electron. Space has a way of allowing such activity, whilst conserving energy, charge parity and the volume of space occupied by electric charge, but that process concerns the equilibrium of the interplay between matter and the aether and we are here considering the interplay between aether and aether at a space domain boundary wall. Those virtual electrons involved in the quantum-electrodynamic underworld are really part of the aether. They can store energy temporarily but we want our domain wall transition to be between two stable modes, each locked in a state defined by that number N.

    The thermal energy that escapes by being radiated well away from its matter source has to be absorbed by the aether and it must somehow over-populate space with those virtual electron-positron pairs which we see as affecting N at the seat of boundary transitions.

    We have argued that N can only increase one integer unit at a time, but it can only decrease in steps of 4 units. Decrease of N corresponds to increase of material energy activity in the domain. Therefore, where there are cataclysmic events in space releasing enormous amounts of thermal energy, the domains will form with lower N values, probably stepped down in units of 4 from the base value of 1843. As to probability of the N transition in the ‘cooling’ phase, domain boundaries do not move through points in space at short intervals of time. They are well separated by distances measured in light years, as evidenced by their effect on geomagnetic field reversals, so in stepping down one integer digit at a time we shall have a series of domains at the unit intervals which are associated with a ‘cooling’. The 4-step domain states are the ones set up by the ‘hot’ state, meaning the stronger source of microwave radiation.

    Then remember that each of those unit steps has been shown theoretically to involve a red shift difference of 18.1 km/s. The stronger radiation will come from the domains with the N tiering at the 4 unit separation. This would suggest 72.5 km/s red shift intervals between radiation from these domains. So what this all amounts to is my tentative explanation as to why 72.5 km/s is the dominant red shift interval, but red shifts said to be close to 36.6 km/s and 18.3 km/s are also observed.

    In questioning this idea, keep in mind that my theory holds firmly to the proposition that truly fundamental charge forms are spherical and comply with the J.J. Thomson formula relating energy E, charge e, radius R and mass M, namely:

    E = 2e2/3R = Mc2.

    This means that the quon, which has a charge volume N times that of the electron is important in these space volume considerations, as is the electron, but all other particle forms which have very much larger mass are insignificant as to the charge volume requirements. The story is, of course, very different for the taons and gravitons which sit in the G-frame, as even the most minute volume of space that they displace can make its presence felt through the space domain as a gravitational action.

    Having regard to the energy implications involved in these changes of N, it will need a great deal of analysis of the actual observations of those anomalous red shifts before one can comment further. I do feel, however, that it is here that the evidence can be found to prove my theory of the proton and with it the theory of the fine structure constant and the constant of gravitation. The parameter N holds the key and it seems that those red shifts observed by W. G. Tifft of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory, Green Bank, West Virginia and the Steward Observatory in the University of Arizona, Tucson have opened the door to which that key belongs.

    SOME CONCLUSIONS

    To put the above in an overall perspective, the following conclusions emerge:
    1. The energy density of the universe, meaning mainly that hidden in the aether, is uniform, but there are ongoing minor fluctuations.
    2. Those fluctuations can result in some hybrid forms of galactic domains in which the dimensions of the lattice structure, the rhythmic frequency of lattice oscillations and even the unitary electron charge can all adopt a different set of values characterized by a quantization integer N.
    3. The domain boundaries can move as domains grow and shrink in size, just as can the magnetic domain walls separating the polarized regions of a ferromagnetic material. New domains can develop and spread, each having its own set of characteristics according to that value of N which is locked into the domain pattern set by the level of excess energy above the aether norm as it is formed.
    4. As protons and electrons appear within the domains, gravity having been ‘switched on’ within the confines of a newly formed domain, stars come into being and those stars acquire motion which can eventually carry them through galactic domain boundary walls and so transfer them to other domains.
    5. Generally speaking, therefore, what we see in the universe is stellar activity from domains that have, in a sense, survived by being normalized at a common N value. However, there remains an ever-present proportion of domains that, by virtue of the energy fluctuations and the new domain creation activity, survive with abnormal N values.
    6. The norm of activity is for that stellar migration across domain boundaries to cause N to increase to its optimum value, one of least energy potential consistent with the physical processes involved in proton creation. The smaller N, the larger the red shift observed in the microwave radiation from the hydrogen atom. The optimum value of N is that which prevails here in our local galactic environment, namely N=1843.

    Harold Aspden,
    August 23, 1997.


  • Www Energyscience Org Uk Le Le05Ap3

    LECTURE NO. 5: THIRD CONTINUATION

    BINARY VISION (FINAL PART)

    Copyright Harold Aspden, 1997

    THE PROTON ENIGMA

    We began this lecture on ‘Binary Vision’ by referring to two Letters to the Editor that appeared side by side in the October 1985 issue of American Journal of Physics and have devoted our attention so far to the topic raised by Jerry Webb. That took us into the realm of cosmology and the role of the aether in developing vacuum spin which could account for the creation of our Sun and the angular momentum of the solar system, as well as the formation of the planets, and the Earth-Moon system.

    Now, in this concluding section of this Lecture, we shall revert to the first of those Letters to the Editor, which was entitled ‘The Proton Enigma’. In writing that 1985 Letter to the American Journal of Physics I had in mind that 10 years earlier I had, in collaboration with Dr. D. M. Eagles [1975a], reported on the process by which protons are created from energy shed by the aether. This is a continuous creation process but it is governed by energy equilibrium so that matter can regenerate itself in its primordial form. This is something of extreme importance to physical science and it has its implications for new energy technology, but the achievement was really the proof, as evidenced by the derivation of the proton-electron mass ratio being exactly in accord with its measured value.

    Now I spoke earlier in this Lecture about the significance of numbers in relation to the physical constants, meaning the dimensionless formulations, and the implications one might draw from a decoding exercise to trace what is hidden in the physics that determines those quantities. You will see an example of this as I come below to quote the text of that ‘Proton Enigma’ Letter. The prime number 23 is mentioned in connection with a property of the neutron, which I see as an anti-proton neutralized by the presence of a positron and a varying admixture of electron-positron pairs. I give the full theory, as it developed later, in reference [1986d] which is reproduced in full in my 1996 book ‘Aether Science Papers’, so you can tell from the 1986 date that I knew far more about that factor 23 than I was revealing in the short Letter I wrote in 1985 to the Editor of American Journal of Physics.

    In the full theory, the neutron has four different states and it flips between states as it is attacked by the ever-present virtual muon bombardment that is ongoing in the aether, spending most of its time in the ground state. In that ground state and in two of the remaining states the anti-proton component stands a little apart and it is this that accounts for the fact that the magnetic moment of the neutron is -1.913043 nuclear magnetons. Allowing for the g-factor of 2 which applies to the proton (or anti-proton) if wave resonance states cannot develop around it, as is the case in this multi-particle neutron system, this tells us that the fourth of those states of the neutron exists for the proportion of time:

    [1 – (1.913043)/2]

    Now, if you are reasonably adept at using a pocket calculator, you may run through the exercise that I performed when I first saw this figure for the measured magnetic moment of the neutron reported at a conference I attended at the U.S. National Bureau of Standards in 1981. I was sitting in the conference auditorium and I had my pocket calculator at hand. I pressed a few keys to evaluate the above quantity and then the key showing its inverted or reciprocal value, to find that the number that appeared was 22.9998735. That got me excited, because it was virtually the integer 23. So I checked further, taking note of the experimental precision of that measurement and … well, see for yourself in what I wrote in the Letter published by American Journal of Physics.

    Before quoting from that item to conclude this Lecture I will just add the further note that my [1986d] paper explained that the factor 23 came about, not because of wave resonance around the neutron, but rather because of the odds of the chances of transition between the four neutron states, given that each presented a different target for the virtual muon bombardment. You obtain the number 23 by virtue of the different electron-positron presence giving different target exposure and, wonder of wonders, this allows the mean mass of the neutron in flipping between states to be calculated. The value, expressed in energy terms as an excess over proton mass, is in perfect accord with that measured, theory giving 1.2933214 MeV and observation giving 1.293323+/-0.000016 MeV.

    If you wonder how 23 comes from the odds of Nature’s statistical game of chance, then you must read that paper [1986d]. It explains how there are four neutron states, A, B, C and D. It shows that the equilibrium ratio between states B, C and D is 2:3:1 with state A as the ground state. It develops a theme based on charge volume conservation and energy conservation in lepton transmutations which shows that the electrons and positrons develop in groups of 166. The B, C, D group must have 64 electrons and positrons collectively, because states A, B, C and D have an electron/positron target exposure areas of 3, 5, 5 and 7, respectively, corresponding to electron-positron pair populations of 1, 2, 2, 3. This complies with the need for 166-64 to be divisible by 3. Note that 7×2+6×5+4×5=64. State A is the ground state and state D is the only state in which the neutron exhibits its truly neutral character so far as magnetic moment is concerned. The equilibrium ratio of states A, B, C, and D is found to be 17:2:3:1 or, to get the 166 electron-positron combination, 34:4:6:2. This results in state D prevailing for 1 part in 23.

    This may all seem a little complicated but it has a logical simplicity and the underlying truth of it all is confirmed once the mass-energy of the neutrons in the various states is averaged according to the same probability distribution. As already stated above, one gets the precise mass of the neutron as measured.

    The text of ‘The Proton Enigma’ reads:

    This letter refers to the editorial entitled “Small things in physics can be big things.” [1] It begins by commenting that “Surely, the proton is predictable” and, after showing how minor discrepancies have led to major advances in theoretical physics, ends with the challenging reminder that, even after 50 years, there is still no resolution of what is a major discrepancy involving the proton magnetic moment. It is discrepant by a factor of almost 2.79285, with this its value measured in nuclear magnetons.

    Having recently [2] responded to Victor F. Weisskopf’s concern about the proton-electron mass ratio, by drawing attention to a 1975 theoretical derivation of this quantity, now valid at the one part in 10 million level of its precision measurement, I offer also a comment in response to the challenge of Ref. [1].

    I believe that the proton magnetic moment and, indeed, the neutron magnetic moment are explicable fully by a theory involving a standing wave system centered on the proton and its quantum electrodynamic interaction with virtual muons and electrons in the surrounding field. The method is too long to outline in this short letter, but it is hoped that my papers on the subject will be published in the scientific literature in the not-too-distant future. Meanwhile, readers can share my own fascination with a quite remarkable result, which, if fortuitous, would be a cruel act on the part of nature. The theory gives reason for believing, first, that the basic proton magnetic moment is governed normally by the usual g factor of 2, but that standing wave excitation increases this to its anomalous value of nearly 2.79285. Second, the neutron responds to a wave excitation between virtual muons and electrons in the magnetic field as if separated from a neutralizing charge to become a non-excited (g=2) antiproton for 22/23 parts of any short period of time. The standing wave resonance indicates integer relationships; it is relevant that the nearest integer 207 to the muon-electron mass ratio includes, as its highest prime factor, the integer 23. The consequence is that the neutron magnetic moment should then be (2)(l-1/23) or 44/23 nuclear magnetons attributable to a negative charge. Evaluated, this gives a theoretical neutron magnetic moment of -1.913043478 nuclear magnetons, in excellent accord with the measured value of -1.91304308(54)(0.28 ppm) reported by Greene et al. [3].

    If this standing wave explanation eventually finds acceptance, the theme of the editorial will still hold, because it was the explanation of a small discrepancy connected with the electron magnetic moment that suggested the standing wave approach to the proton and neutron.

    References
    [1] J. S. Rigden, Am. J. Phys., 53, 107 (1985).
    [2] H. Aspden, Physics Today 37, 15 (1984).
    [3] G. L Greene, N. F. Ramsey, W. Mampe, J. M. Pendlebury, K. Smith, W. B. Dress, P. D. Miller, and P. Perrin, Precision Measurement and Fundamental Constants, edited by B. N. Taylor and W. D. Phillips (Natl. Bur. Stand., Spec. Publ. 617, 1984).
    The above Letter to the Editor of American Journal of Physics was written from my then-address at the University of Southampton in England.

    ******

    Remember that in the body of this Lecture, which has extended through four sections of these Web pages, I have presented the full version of the Lecture paper on ‘Space, Energy and Creation’ that I delivered at the University at Cardiff in Wales back in the year 1977. You will, therefore, appreciate that as we progress further with these Web lectures by the author we will be building on a very far-reaching framework for our understanding of fundamental physics. As each new item is now introduced, I ask you not to judge it as if it stands alone unsupported and unrelated to these other research findings. If you sense weaknesses in the arguments used then that should be seen as your challenge to look for ways of contributing improvements, but please do not think you can discard the whole framework of what I have introduced. Explaining gravity and proton creation has been a formidable task. Be sure you understand what I am saying on this subject before you dream of its rejection as it may be a very long time, if ever, before any alternative answers are forthcoming from the work being done on superstring theory and the like. If you try to study quantum gravitation based on such ‘superstring’ theory, then I wish you ‘good luck’. You will need it if you are to make any sense at all from what is being written on that subject.

    H. Aspden
    June 19, 1997

    *