Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Lectures

Lecture series on aether physics

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • LECTURE NO. 22

    LECTURE NO. 22

    THE RABBIT AND SCHROEDINGER’S CAT

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    Physicists enjoy debates concerning quantum theory, ever confident that in championing that theory they are always on the winning side in any contest. They do not enjoy being drawn into debates concerning the reality of the aether or suggestions that one can build operable machines that can generate electrical power by tapping energy from that aether. Their version of quantum theory does not incorporate equations consistent with such a possibility.

    One of the most bizarre notions in science is the proposition that physical events depend upon an ‘observer’. To be registered as occurring an event needs an observer. Can one then say that, without an observer being present and looking at a region of space, there can be no physical happening in that space region?

    This introduces the subject I wish to discuss here, which is the outrageous state of affairs prevailing in physics, where practically-minded people are expected to believe in the nonsense which has been devised under the pretence that it is true science.

    THE RABBIT

    Before I introduce the role of Schroedinger’s cat, I will digress a little and talk about my ‘rabbit’. I imagine a high stone wall with a rabbit sitting on one side of that wall. That is what I can see in my imagination, but it could equally be that I can see a real rabbit in such a real situation. A short period later I look again and the rabbit is missing. I look over the wall to see it now sitting on the other side. How did it get there? The wall was too high for it to have jumped from one side to the other.

    Well, the simple answer is that it got there by burrowing underground. It tunneled its way from one side of that barrier to the other.

    Now, in physics there is a similar situation which involves the electron. In theory, meaning a classical theory based on the teachings of real life situations, an electron cannot penetrate an electric potential barrier unless it has enough dynamic capability to surmount that barrier. Just as the rabbit could not surmount the high wall, because it could not muster enough energy in its hind legs to make such a high leap, so the electron cannot be expected to penetrate through a high potential barrier if it lacks the necessary energy. That, at least, is what the physics teachings of the pre-quantum era suggest. However, our modern textbooks tell us that electrons can, in fact, penetrate such barriers by ‘tunneling’ their way through.

    They have, notionally, become rabbits, or perhaps it is more to the point to say that the authors of those ideas have adopted the ‘rabbit mentality’. Electrons do not ‘tunnel’. They are governed by energy criteria and only do what the available energy dictates as possible!

    Let me now suggest another scenario. The wall I mentioned is on rock solid foundations which cannot be penetrated by that rabbit trying to tunnel underground. Instead of there being one rabbit on one side of that wall there are 10 rabbits and, indeed, there are also 10 rabbits on the other side of that wall as well. When I look a little while latter there are only 9 rabbits on one side of that wall and 11 on the other side. Now, how might this be explained in real life?

    Well, one answer could be that a new rabbit has been born on one side of the wall and an old rabbit on the other side of the wall has been eaten by a fox. The idea of any ‘tunneling ‘ by the rabbits is then in error. Applying this line of argument to the analogous situation involving the electron, well, we know that when we talk about electrons we normally mean millions, billions or indeed trillions of electrons as they are seldom seen in a free state in isolation. Then you may say that, unlike other fundamental particles in physics, apart from the proton, an electron has no finite lifetime. It does not exhibit a natural decay. So the analogy with rabbits dying and being born is not feasible.

    In reply I say that physics has embraced the notion that electrons and their positive counterparts, positrons, can annihilate in pairs and be reborn in pairs close by. That is a feature of quantum electrodynamic theory. So I might need to say that the numbers of rabbits on one side of the wall became 8 whilst the 10 on the other side became 12, a pair having been ‘born’ and an older pair having been swallowed into oblivion, whether by that fox or by being absorbed into the aetherial background. Certainly, however, I can argue in this way my case that electrons do not penetrate a potential barrier, but rather they decay on one side of that barrier and their energy is reincarnated as a new electrons on the other side of that barrier.

    To turn this into a meaningful account I need to declare that electrons do have a finite lifetime, even when standing alone in isolation, well removed from a positron, but that if they suffer decay, their energy is absorbed into our energy underworld and promptly repackaged as a newly created electron. The electron therefore never seems to decay, but it does. It is just that we cannot tell the difference between the new electron and the old electron!

    It would, of course, help if one can estimate the lifetime of the electron using theory which gives reliable estimates of the lifetimes of other particles which do exhibit decay. That I have done and the answer is close to 10-13 seconds. It then gives me satisfaction to see that there is a measurable time lag of just this value in observations of the phenomenon which physicists have chosen to term ‘electron tunneling’ as their explanation of how an electron can overcome a high potential barrier.

    The message of all this is that matter in the form of electrons is being created throughout our environment by deploying energy from the aether’s own sea of energy, but energy must first be shed to upset the prevailing equilibrium and trigger electron creation. There is a related message which applies also to protons.

    In summary, therefore, whereas quantum theory offers you mathematical symbols and curious notions about what is observed and what is not observed, the alternative of probing how energy is deployed in the equilibrium of the quantum underworld will expose the truth in a more meaningful way.

    There is every reason, therefore, to predict that, by using the right techniques, we should be able to intercept energy from the turmoil of upsets of that equilibrium, after it is shed by decay or spent as radiation and before it is reincarnated as matter in the form of protons and electrons. That is the quest I see as warranting attention and the entry point is the quantum connections manifested in interactions involving ferromagnetic materials.

    However, let us now consider Schroedinger’s cat.

    SCHROEDINGER’S CAT

    Theoretical physicists interested in quantum theory do not relate their interpretation of how electrons can tunnel through potential barriers to the behaviour of rabbits. No, they talk instead about wave functions and probabilities of particles appearing somewhere by virtue of the ‘reduction’ of the wavefunction. However, they do, sometimes, refer to Schroedinger’s cat.

    Is it dead or is it alive? It depends on who is looking!

    I shall quote here from a book by Euan Squires entitled ‘The Mystery of the Quantum World’. It was published in 1986 by Adam Hilger Ltd of Bristol and Boston, the publishing house of the U.K. Institute of Physics.

    Chapter 4, Part 3, had the heading: ‘Does wavefunction reduction require conscious observers?’ Squires introduces this section of his book by writing:

    “Here we shall examine more closely the possibility that external reality consists of a wavefunction and that this wave function only reduces when an observation is made by a conscious observer. It is the existence of consciousness that introduces the probabilistic aspects into
    the quantum world.”

    Soon thereafter Squires notes that “wavefunction reduction is an inexplicable phenomenon associated with quantum theory.”

    Eventually, after further noting that quantum theory denies that the external world possesses the properties we observe, until we actually observe them, he comes to the ‘cat’.

    “The paradox of ‘Schroedinger’s cat’ is an example of the sort of problem we can get into here. We suppose, for example, that the right-hand detector in our potential barrier experiment is a trigger that fires a gun and kills a cat as soon as a particle reaches it. After one particle has passed through the apparatus the wavefunction thus contains a piece in which the cat is dead and a piece in which the cat is alive. Only if the cat is conscious can we say that one of these represents the truth. What however could we say if the cat was asleep? If, on the other hand, a cat is not conscious, or if we used instead a being or a thing that is not conscious, then it remains in a state of being part-dead/part-alive until some conscious observer forces the wavefunction to go to one state or the other. Like Schroedinger himself we probably consider this as an unlikely picture of reality.”

    So, there you are! Quantum theory never fails – it always gives the right answers! It depends upon wavefunctions and observers, but what is meant by such notions and how the universe ever got started before someone other than God was around to observe that event is open for imagination. Will those electrons really be able to tunnel through a potential barrier if the observer has fallen asleep? If you want to dream there are better things to dream about than the world of the quantum as portrayed by those who teach physics today. Whether your slumbers are aided by counting sheep, rabbits or cats that may be dead or alive according to your perception of their ‘wavefunctions’ I cannot say, but I can say that it is due time that physicists concentrated on the energy issue. Whether a particle is at A or B can only be ascertained by locating the seat of its energy and that is not a function of who happens to be around as a conscious observer!

    CAN PHOTONS THINK?

    Quantum theory is the realm of the photon and the electron, it having emerged from the study of processes occurring in the atom. The photon is characterized by an event which occurs when an atom absorbs or radiates a quantum of energy and that concerns the changes of the energy state of an electron.

    Science writer Anjana Ahuja, writing in the INTERFACE section of the British newspaper, THE TIMES, on July 30, 1997, chose as the title: ‘Great photons think alike’, and explained how it had been discovered that pairs of photons travelling through optical fibre could communicate at a speed 10,000 times faster than the speed of light.

    What, I wonder, is meant by that word ‘communicate’? The discovery by Dr. Nicolas Gisin involved feeding pairs of photons down optical fibres, sending them in opposite directions. As each photon neared the end of its journey to a Swiss village, one north of Geneva and one south of Geneva in Switzerland, ‘it was forced to decide between several alternative routes’. The experiment indicated that there had to be some communication between those photons when they made those decisions, because they made matching decisions instantaneously, even though they were then located seven miles apart. It was said that this is ‘a distance record for this type of experiment. Dr. Gisin is at the University of Geneva.

    So here was action-at-a-distance, something that runs contrary to Einstein’s theory, and the article describing that discovery went on from there to tell us that this discovery heralded the technological prospect of a form of cryptography that could provide absolute security for data transmission.

    So you are invited to believe that photons can ‘think’, but that they can communicate by a form of telepathy that is instantaneous action-at-a-distance.

    In my opinion those who suggest such ideas have no real notion concerning the nature of the photon. The photon is not a particle. It is merely an event that happens when energy is exchanged between matter and aether in a certain way, a way which involves aether spin, which in turn sets up or is set up by electromagnetic waves that do travel at the finite speed of light. However, action-at-a-distance is physically possible so far as it concerns the Coulomb interaction as between electric charges. Indeed, I have build my whole account of the physical basis of gravitation and electromagnetism on a picture of the aether that has charges sharing a synchronous motion as if coupled by actions that are instantaneous.

    The point to remember, however, is that, when two photon events are linked by their twin-creation, they each not only initiate propagating disturbances in the propagating medium, but they also impart momentum to the aether background. That momentum is imparted to a hidden structure that has a kind of rigidity owing to that synchrony and coupling provided by the Coulomb interactions in the charge structure of the aether. So, when physicists talk about the ‘wavefunction’ they are referring to the data encoded in the momentum pattern that has been generated by the events they are describing. They seem able to picture discrete ‘wavefunctions’ amongst the numerous trillions of overlapping ‘wavefunctions’ that exist everywhere in space. Yet, when it comes to experiments, they somehow create a concentration of ‘wavefunctions’ of the same form, so that they can avoid the confusion of deciphering how they interact.

    Given that the aether absorbs momentum shed by photon creation and it works to recreate photons to rid itself of that momentum, there is a coordination between photon events thanks to the role played by that real aether. It all seems very complicated, but it makes far more sense than the notion that nothing happens in the universe unless someone is watching the spot where it happens.

    No doubt, there will be some who read this and conclude that I do not know enough about quantum mechanics to form any valid judgement. Well, my answer to that is that there has to be something wrong when one is told that quantum theory always gives the right answers but yet informed physicists write books on the subject drawing attention to its uncertainties and its mysteries.

    As to my modest contribution to the subject I will mention, by way of a conclusion to this Lecture, one final point that may be of some interest.

    QUANTUM UNCERTAINTIES

    In 1986 I was invited, with all expenses paid, to participate in a NATO-sponsored Advanced Research Workshop on the subject of ‘Quantum Uncertainties – Recent and Future Experiments and Interpretations’. It was held at the University of Bridgeport in Connecticut, USA from June 23-June 27, 1986.

    The book recording those proceedings had that same title and was published by Plenum in the NATO ASI Series as Series B: Physics Vol. 162. My contribution was my paper ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Photon in a Lattice Vacuum’ and it appeared at pp. 345-359.

    It was at that meeting that I heard a great deal about anomalous correlations between photons, but what occupied my thoughts during my return journey home to England was what I had heard about neutron diffraction. I was perplexed by the apparent wave-like behavior of neutrons – but not for long! Indeed, I had the answer before I arrived home and I promptly recorded my thoughts in a scientific paper and mailed it off to Physics Letters.

    If you look up that paper, which was published in Physics Letters 119A, pp. 105-108 (1986), you will see that it was received by the Editor on July 7, 1986. It is entitled A Causal Theory for Neutron Diffraction.

    A single neutron in finding a route for passage through a test apparatus can experience diffraction, as if it is capable of generating wave interference which somehow governs the route it takes. It seems therefore that a neutron, as a particle, rather than a wave or ‘wavefunction’, travels as if subject to some kind of constraint, seemingly governed by statistics, but yet that neutron is not one of many that is seen as a statistical mean position.

    My paper approached the problem by analyzing first the corresponding circumstances governing electron diffraction. The electron is a particle, not a photon, but when in motion relative to the aether it develops energy associated with that motion and that energy involves interplay with the aether. It gives rise to a sequence of photon events and an associated ongoing statistical electron-positron pair creation and annihilation activity. I discussed then the way in which the aether acts as an energy sink preserving overall equilibrium. I stated, for example, that ‘When a photon unit stops spinning at the photon source, its angular momentum is balanced by a transfer of energy E, (as determined by the equations specified), from the two-dimensional mode of oscillation to a linear oscillation.’ The important step then was to regard this latter event as part of a collective action of all photons present.

    This led to a showing that four photon units, all collaborating in an ongoing association, involving creation and annihilation in vacuum energy exchanges, served to hold the kinetic energy of the electron, whilst trapping what is, in effect, a standing wave oscillation as part of a system moving bodily with the electron. In summary, I was saying that an electron is a particle, a discrete unit of charge, moving with an entourage of four photons, but that the photons were aether spin states that were created and annihilated cyclically at progressive positions along the electron path. Travelling freely and without obstruction the package of energy and its standing wave system would shed no radiation.

    In some respects it is as if each electron is part of a miniature Michelson-Morley apparatus in which mirrors trap radiation as standing waves so that the energy is carried along through space at the speed of the apparatus and not at some notional fixed speed relative to something called absolute space. I have explained elsewhere in these Web pages that the orthodox interpretation of the Michelson-Morley experiment takes no account of energy transport by standing waves, the reason being that the standing wave phenomenon had not been discovered in the 1881-87 era when Michelson and Morley devised their experiment.

    As to why an electron is diffracted, I quote from my Physics Letters paper:

    When the electron is diffracted the waves produced by the photon units interfere and the units can regroup in a new configuration to contain the residual wave energy in a new standing wave system following the diffraction. Wave interference from the multiple-photon unit system therefore determines the redirection of the electron, because its kinetic energy is wholly that of the photon spin units. single electron diffraction is possible simply because the four spin units can each develop their own waves.

    So, I was saying that there is wave interference where a single electron is concerned because there are four wave-generating sources associated with the electron and, unless disturbed, these interact to contain wave energy by their standing wave interference and collectively offset one another so far as external radiation is concerned. I was saying also that the energy we assign to an electron as kinetic energy flips in form as it is exchanged between those photon spin units and the aether.

    Now, I do not seek to get too deeply into the processes involved, but I can say, as I have shown in that contribution of mine in those proceedings of that Bridgeport NATO workshop, that a photon spin that generates the Compton electron frequency has the unit angular momentum of h/2(pi) that we see as the quantum used in Bohr’s theory of the atom. Those photon spins, in their interchanges with aether energy as part of their forward migration with the electron motion, are involved in electron-positron pair creation and annihilation as well.

    In summary, therefore, I feel that whatever mysteries there are concerning quantum theory, these mysteries can only be resolved by a belief in a real aether having structure and electrical form. They can only be resolved by separating the actions which occur in the Coulomb gauge from those which occur in the electromagnetic gauge, this being a line of demarcation as between instantaneous action-at-a distance and actions propagated at the finite speed of light.

    I will not go further here and describe how my paper extends to show the basis of the wave diffraction of the neutron, save to say that if you think the neutron, meaning the particle form one can test in experiments, is an electrically neutral particle you are indulging in fantasy. It is a cluster of component electric particles which move together for a while before experiencing decay. I referred to quarks in my Physics Letters paper in order disguise my true opinion and use terminology that would introduce my picture of the neutron in a way that would find referee acceptance. The neutron is nothing other than a fluctuating cluster of charged particles that comprise electrons and positrons along with a proton or antiproton. The electrons are essential as they bring with them those photon spin units which set up the waves that give the neutron its diffraction properties.

    The Physics Letters paper advances the case by showing how the photon spins develop the deBroglie wavelength applicable to the neutron. The frequencies involved are much smaller than those applicable to the electron and the argument used is based on that momentum exchange as between matter and aether, the overall conservation of which accounts for the seemingly unretarded coordinated interplay of photons.


  • LECTURE NO. 21

    LECTURE NO. 21

    THE EXPERIMENTAL PATHWAY TO NEW SOURCES OF ENERGY

    Copyright, Harold Aspden, 1998

    The following is the full text of the author’s notes for a talk delivered to the Society for Scientific Exploration, Second European Conference, August 24-26, 1994 in Renfrew, Scotland.

    However, in the latter part of July 1994, after these notes were prepared, we heard about the collision with Jupiter of the comet Shoemaker-Levy 9. It caused the author to add a few extra items to show by the overhead viewer during the initial stages of the presentation. The viewgraphs used are those presented below in block form. The case presented was that the evidence adduced from the collision of that comet with Jupiter helped to confirm that the aether plays a role in powering the energy conveyed by a comet. The author sees scope for gaining access to some of that energy locked in aether spin, a feature of all astronomical bodies, but one that appears also in plasma research in our laboratories. The initial set of block illustrations used as viewgraphs and pertaining to the subject of the comet will, therefore, be presented ahead of the ‘introduction’ in the main text, appearing in the sequence in which they were shown at the Renfrew meeting.

    INTRODUCTION

    The author discusses the scope for experimental exploration of the role which the aether can play in the energy science of the future. Under three headings concerned with exploration of (a) the ‘past’, (b) the ‘unknown’ and (c) ‘bench space’, attention is drawn (a) to the misinterpretation of an early experiment, (b) to the ‘unknown’ experiment that is decisive on the aether question and (c) to the experiments that are now needed to tap into the energy resource of the aether in the space environment of the laboratory bench.

    EXPLORING THE PAST

    A century ago it was generally accepted that space was filled with an aethereal medium. This invisible medium was regarded as having two important properties. It limited the speed of passage of electromagnetic waves and it contained electrical charge in some neutral mixture which could develop electric fields when oscillated by the passage of those waves.

    Science confronted two problems, one of a theoretical nature and one that had been encountered by experiment. Aether theory needed to model the medium as both a fluid and a solid and that seemed illogical. Experimentally, Michelson and Morley, in their efforts to detect our Earthly motion through space, found that they could not sense that from the speed differential of reflected light waves.

    Today most scientists know about the latter experiment and have heard of that Einstein’s theory came to the rescue by telling us that Nature requires us to adapt our experimental frame of observation when moving in such a way that we cannot detect motion through space using apparatus sharing that motion. They go further and will tell you that the ‘aether’ is a figment of past imagination, not needed by modern science and having no real existence. The mathematically abstract formulation of the ‘space-time’ manifold, with its four-space dimensions, is the accepted model.

    Now, very few scientists really care enough about the fundamental truths concerning space and aether to give voice to their doubts about the Einstein doctrine. It is easier to accept what they do not really understand, because those who profess superior knowledge seem satisfied with the theory. Yet, there are, in fact, numerous individuals who dabble in matters scientific and struggle to build their own alternative picture of that ‘aether’ medium.

    I am one such individual and, having shown my interest, I have become the recipient of accounts of many such theories, but I have yet to see a consensus developing on anything but the common belief that Einstein’s theory is wrong and should be replaced by something better.

    So, I well know that I would be wasting my time to devote effort here into presenting my theoretical ideas and this is why I seek now to urge my case forward by experiment.

    The problem with this is that experiments need funding and those which are devised to explore science along lines that manifestly go against standard teachings are non-runners in the contest for funds and even the proposal can brand the proponent as a heretic. As a result the only really challenging experimentation that one expects to see in this field is that which is undertaken by the so-called ‘crank’, the individual who has time and his own personal resource to embark on research to test his or her own hypothesis.

    Now, in devising a new experiment one must first question whether that experiment has already been done by others. There are important experiments of historical record that are not mentioned to us in textbooks because they do not fit in with the teaching of standard principles.

    Since my subject is an interest in the ‘aether’, I draw attention to one such experiment, the 1903 Trouton-Noble experiment. This was an experiment which argued that, if the accepted teachings in electrodynamics were correct, two opposite electrical charges carried forward through the aether should set up a turning couple in their mutual interaction. This couple, which ought to be measurable by suspending a charged parallel plate capacitor in a torsion balance, should then give a measure of the Earth’s motion through space. By switching the charged condition of the capacitor on and off in timed sequence related to the natural oscillation period of that torsional suspension, so any motion through the aether ought to be detected.

    The experiment gave a null result. This was in 1903. A discerning scientist at the time would have seen that result as meaning one of two things. Either the Lorentz force law, which requires electrodynamic force action to be directed perpendicular to the charge motion, was wrong in that the experiment revealed that the mutual force acted directly along the line joining the charges, or there was no motion through the electromagnetic reference frame, meaning that, whatever it is in the aether that regulates the speed of light locally, so far as that experiment was concerned, that something has to be moving with the Earth.

    Now, if any scientific historian can point to any record that such alternative interpretation was considered at a time contemporary with that experiment I would, indeed, appreciate being sent the reference. As it was, I suspect that Lorentz upset the situation by immediately taking the initiative. He was convinced that his law was right and he was mindful of the null result of the Michelson-Morley Experiment and so the Trouton-Noble experiment was seen by him as justification for what has come to be termed Lorentz invariance. Our concepts of space and time were then distorted to squeeze from the experiment something that looked compatible.

    To explain the Michelson-Morley experiment, Lorentz had, in his 1895 paper, argued that apparatus can shorten in the direction of motion. He introduced his 1904 paper by reference also to the Trouton-Noble experiment and in 1905 we see Einstein enter the fray with his theory of relativity.

    Yet, where was that discerning scientist who could argue by logic that if two assumptions are relied upon, motion through the aether and conformity with an arbitrary law of electrodynamics, and the experiment gives a null, then either or both of those assumptions could be wrong?

    One can say that Lorentz was guided by the null of the Michelson-Morley experiment, and this favoured the abandonment of the aether hypothesis, but that was also justification for not performing the Trouton-Noble experiment in the first place and the fact that it was performed as an electrodynamic experiment should have put the emphasis on the fact that the Lorentz force law was, as just stated, arbitrary. It was arbitrary because, as was well established from the work of Ampere, as amplified later by others including Maxwell, all empirical data on the subject had involved at least one closed circuital current in the tested interaction. The Trouton-Noble experiment was an experiment which involved two discrete charges transported as individual charges with neither forming part of a closed current circuit.

    The need for that ‘discerning scientist’ was even more in evidence when, in retrospect, one can see that the Trouton-Noble experiment reveals that, if there is motion through the electromagnetic reference frame as the Earth moves through the aether, so the mutual electrodynamic force between two discrete charges acts directly along the line joining those charges and so develops no out-of-balance couple. Here was evidence of the link with gravitation, that quest in search of the Holy Grail in unified field theory, the clue by which to link electrodynamic action and gravitation.

    It was missed when it should have been seen, as Lorentz took the initiative and went adrift in pushing his ideas on the invariance theme, defending his force law but at the price of abandoning the role played by the aether in the Trouton-Noble experiment.

    So, in exploring the science of the past, one can begin to see where the wrong path was taken. It was a path leading away from the aether and its vast energy resource – a pathway to an abstract world of illusion and fantasy bred from doctrinaire beliefs in Einstein’s theory.

    EXPLORING THE UNKNOWN

    Scientific exploration may be deemed to involve research into new territory, but science today is such that explored territory, already mapped, can fail to be included in modern surveys. The reason is that the Establishment suppresses that which it finds embarrassing and so the scientific work fails to be recorded in the citators giving reference access. Certainly, there is a tendency by those who teach and engage in research to presume that, if they have a specialist knowledge in a particular subject, anything of importance in that field will somehow be drawn to their attention by their ongoing involvement in conferences or inspection of primary refereed literature.

    Therefore, now ask the question whether that Lorentz force law that I have mentioned above and challenged as being arbitrary and invalid when applied to the discrete charge interaction has ever been proved to be invalid by direct experiment. Note that in mentioning the Lorentz force law I am not referring to some unimportant feature of science. Every electrical machine in existence depends upon the way moving electric charge acts on other moving electrical charge. The Lorentz law sums up our understanding of the forces acting between those moving charges. Therefore, what is at issue here is not something of a curiosity that might concern rare phenomena or events in outer space. The subject in question is the force that dominates the electrical power industry and the peripheral questions that arise such as where the energy is stored when an electric current is fed into an induction coil in an automobile.

    All that the Lorentz law tells us is that the electrodynamic action between moving charges acts on a charge at right angles to its motion, so it in no way gives basis for an induction energy process, which needs a force action directed in the line of motion. I submit that the experiment of record that actually disproves the Lorentz force law is unknown to those who profess to teach electrical engineering in our universities. They will question what I say because they can ‘get by’ without that knowledge, teaching machine design based on empirical evidence from the past, but they will not then be teaching what is possible in future machine design, because there is territory in electrical science that they have not explored themselves.

    It was 35 years ago that I published a work on the theory of gravitation, drawing attention to the error in the law of electrodynamics. Several years later I was visited by a young London University research student. He was writing a thesis on General Relativity for his Ph.D. It was his exposure to my dissident opinions that caused him to direct his attentions away from Relativity and turn his mind to the flaws in electrodynamic theory. As an aside I mention that Einstein’s famous 1905 paper was entitled ‘On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies’, so one will understand why relativity and electrodynamics are connected. Now, I mention this because that then-young research student, whose name was Pappas, eventually teamed up with a radio enthusiast in USA, named Vaughan, and together they performed a definitive experiment which disproves the Lorentz force law.

    They built what they termed a ‘stigma antenna’ and set up internal oscillations in the antenna so that current in the three sections of the antenna interacted to set up, according to the Lorentz force law, a unidirectional turning couple. Note that here the charge was oscillating between the poles and so the current was confined to exchanges between the intrinsic capacitance and inductance of the antenna. Any forces on that moving charge, as determined by the Lorentz force law, would then set up that couple. In a sense, this was the Trouton-Noble experiment where, instead of relying on motion through the aether to set up the couple, the charge was actually set in oscillatory motion. This, therefore, was not a test concerning the aether, but one concerning simply the Lorentz force law. However, if the Lorentz law fails, as I predict it must if we are ever to explain gravitational force, so, as with the Trouton-Noble experiment, one can expect there to be no couple in evidence in this Pappas-Vaughan test.

    I declare that this experiment, which did give a null result, is one that ranks alongside those of Michelson-Morley and Trouton-Noble, but the world of modern science has shunned the experiment because the implications are too far reaching. It is of record in Physics Essays, v. 3, 211-216 (1990).

    There are physicists who will say that the experiment does not take account of the electric displacement currents in the enveloping space and claim that that the Lorentz forces exerted on those currents will account for the balance of that predicted turning action. In saying that they are declaring that the vacuum medium can absorb forces and be part of the dynamic system under consideration. That is tantamount to an admission that one can push against the aether itself and be pushed by the aether and that means there is scope for drawing energy from that aether. Such are the implications if one pays attention to the experimental evidence and avoids being misled by false theory.

    It must be understood that to change the course of science it is no longer sufficient to perform an experiment, unless it is one that is done within the corridors of institutional power. Experiments that challenge established doctrine are not undertaken in such institutions. Experiments performed outside are not accepted. The only way forward for those enterprising souls who really want to see a major advance from scientific exploration is to head in the direction of an experiment that is destined to have a major technological impact.

    This is the theme I will now follow, based on some groundwork references to my own perception of the aether. Note I am not urging interest in my theory. All I seek is to give the foundation for the two experiments I propose. The first experiment I will leave to others to perform, but I will undertake the second experiment myself and report on its outcome in due course.

    EXPLORING BENCH SPACE

    I stated at the outset that in the last century scientists faced the irreconcilable problem of modelling the aether as a fluid and as a solid, inasmuch as the properties of both need to be merged. Those scientists did not have in their possession the pocket calculator with its liquid crystal display. Crystals form when particles find they can settle into a lower energy state if they group together in an orderly way. Thus, water can turn into ice as it sheds heat energy. The ‘liquid crystal’ is something that depends upon extraneous electric fields, meaning that the transition from fluid to crystal form is controlled by external influence. Equally external influence in the form of heat or vibration or simply a motion of material structure through the liquid could well preclude crystal formation.

    Thus, if the vacuum were to have the natural attribute of a crystal form – a kind of solid structure – it could well be that the presence of matter could cause it to dissolve into fluid form before regrouping to crystal form sharing the motion of that matter. My point here is that, whether we are talking about aether or water or that special liquid we see in our pocket calculators, we must be prepared for the structure of a crystal form to play some role.

    It was analysis of the aether on these lines that led me to develop an understanding of a process I call ‘vacuum spin’. The action of producing an electric field radial from an axis should, in theory, promote any structural form of aether nucleated on that axis to spin and draw inertial energy from the space environment. I saw this as featuring in the creation of stars and planets, and as accounting for the creation of thunderballs developed from electrical action centred on the axis of a lightning discharge, but in a bench experiment the effect could occur in certain types of rotary machine. A Faraday disc is one such apparatus because the rotation of a conductor in an axial magnetic field induces radial electric displacement in the aether coextensive with that disc.

    One should expect anomalous energy and inertial effects if one spins the rotor of such a machine and, indeed, I hear of reports that do confirm anomalous generation of power – power from the aether, as it were – emerging from such experiments. However, that aside, for a moment, the experiment I would commend to a laboratory physicist is one in which an arc discharge in a near vacuum is set up between two electrodes, one positioned vertically above the other and a cylindrical wire mesh cage coaxial with the discharge path is caused to spin around that axis when there is a discharge. The object of the experiment is quite simple. It is well known from the early research which led to the interest in hot nuclear fusion that it is virtually impossible to tame a discharge and keep it on a straight and narrow path as it pinches at high currents. The discharge is wild in its snakelike movements. The non-rotation of the enclosing cage has no effect on that activity, but I have in mind an experiment with a rotating cage to see if the arc becomes stable.

    If it does keep in place along the central spin axis then that is evidence that the aether exists and that vacuum spin is setting up reacting radial electric fields which hold it in place. This is nothing other than Maxwell displacement of charge, but radially instead of linearly as we see in electromagnetic wave propagation. To make the experiment more interesting observations should be made at different pressures as air is pumped from the test apparatus. this would show progressively how the turbulence of air affects the arc before one comes to see the action of the vacuum on its own.

    As I stated above the expectation with the Faraday disc experiment is that the vacuum would shed energy and develop rotational inertia in that disc. This should depend upon the angle subtended between the spin axis of the apparatus and that prevailing in the vacuum medium itself, meaning that as the Earth rotates to reorientate the experimental set-up so the power of the coupling action between vacuum and disc should vary. That again would reveal exciting information about the true existence of the aether.

    Whilst still on the theme of bench-type experiments, vacuum spin and fluid crystals, I think it worthwhile to mention a recent BBC television programme about Heretics, the first in the series being concerned with a phenomenon attributed to water. Does water have a property which allows it to replicate crystals which store information so that however often it is diluted it can retain that information? Physicists ridicule this suggestion even though it is an experimental finding of a well-established French scientist. However, consider what I have said above with water in mind as a medium that can develop fluid crystals.

    Take a single ion H3O+ together with a group of normal water molecules and consider the radial electric field which emanates from that ion. It will, by the argument I have put above, develop a ‘vacuum spin’ and I can visualize it being the nucleus of a tiny fluid crystal, a very small structure that could be deemed to be what we might term ‘warm ice’. Now, how can this have a ‘memory’ and how can it replicate itself?

    Well, firstly, I would like to digress a little and talk about another type of ‘fluid crystal’, that which develops as a ‘fluid’ crystal within a solid crystal, namely the ferromagnetic domain that forms inside a crystal of iron or nickel, for example. These ferromagnetic domains, indeed the whole state of ferromagnetism, occurs because their formation is energetically favoured, thanks to a certain structural combination of atomic properties in such atomic elements under appropriate temperature conditions. Physicist do not speak of these domains as ‘fluid crystals’ but they sometimes choose a terminology that is used to convey much the same meaning; they talk about ‘magnetic bubbles’!

    In 1969 I published a book entitled ‘Physics without Einstein’. It was about my aether theory in which I explained how ferromagnetism developed in crystals as a function of the mechanical stress energies involved and their relation to the interaction forces between atomic electrons in atoms. I based this on orbital electron motion so that I could use the n level of quantization applicable to the Bohr atom even though in more formal atomic theory in iron, for example, the 3d electron state is the one with the n = 2 orbital quantization.

    A graphical illustration taken from that 1969 book shows why I was satisfied with my findings and felt I had understood the true nature of ferromagnetism as being really an orbital electron motion and not a fanciful electron spin action as conventional theory suggests. That issue is debated in my book and it need not be considered here. However, what I do want to point to is the fact that my theory indicated that if oxygen were to form as a solid substance its crystals could well exhibit ferromagnetism under certain conditions. Oxygen is the optimum candidate in the n = 1 state, just as iron, nickel and cobalt are those we find in the n = 2 state.

    So, I am now asking myself, after watching that BBC programme on July 5th about the heresy of Jacques Benveniste, whether the oxygen component of a water crystal could, in a very minute way, nucleated in water as a fluid crystal centred on an ion, be part of a ferromagnetic structure. That makes it easier to contemplate ‘memory’ and recordal of information.

    My speculation then extends to asking how such tiny magnets in water could avoid detection and here, thanks to that ion charge, I see an answer. There is a reacting vacuum spin of aether and, as readers of my 1969 book will see, a vacuum spin means the generation of a magnetic effect. The Earth is a magnet but we do not understand the source of that magnetism in spite of the various theories of record. I see the vacuum spin coextensive with body Earth as the seat of that magnetism and see no way for explaining the precessional motion of the magnetic poles unless the magnetism is developed in a medium which can move in an angular sense inside the Earth.

    In water, therefore, those fluid crystals could nucleate a vacuum spin which cancels their intrinsic ferromagnetic field so far as effects remote from the crystal are concerned. The vacuum spin would have ellipsoidal, near spherical, form, inasmuch as this gives complementary uniform magnetic field density assuring perfect balance of the ferromagnetism of the crystal.

    Now, where does memory feature in this situation? Well, just as for the Earth, where the axis of the magnetic poles precesses around the axis of the geographic poles, so the collective action of the ferromagnetic water crystal and its vacuum could account for some very small electromagnetic effects at a characteristic frequency. Conversely the external influence of an electromagnetic field varying at that frequency would condition that action, perhaps the ellipsoidal shape, meaning the ratio between the dimensions of its major and minor axes. This ratio is the variable which determines a demagnetization factor to thereby alter the magnetic property and so the appropriate frequency response.

    The key question one now asks is how such crystals replicate one another. Here, the answer is that the ion and the molecular crystal centred on that ion actually nucleate a vacuum spin activity which can become separated from the ion so that the ion develops a new vacuum spin system. The free vacuum spin system is preserved by its inertial property and its energy and, as it develops an internal electric charge effect, it can promote ionization of the water in its new position. This action is therefore one that replicates the ellipsoidal form and so the characteristic frequency of the parent system but I suspect this replication process, if it occurs at all, can only occur in still water and that the water has to be shaken first to help to separate the crystals and vacuum spins that already exist.

    It is along such lines that I see a route to understanding the heresy of Jacques Benveniste and also understanding certain other accounts of phenomena that involve energy anomalies in water, phenomena which seem to be excited at ultrasonic frequencies.

    Once more is known about the latter phenomenon and particularly as concerns the measured frequency responses, so the physics of this proposal can be examined and possibly developed as a formal theory. One needs to see in this the role of aether in a structured crystal form, aether that can spin to capture and store energy, much as we see in the thunderball phenomenon and as we shall soon see, I believe, in a Faraday disc type of machine which is designed to tap the zero-point field energy.

    I may further mention that the arc discharge as electrical corona from a point electrode can also be the nucleating factor in developing vacuum spin in the form of tiny spherical plasmoid forms which liberate energy as excess heat, energy being drawn from the vacuum medium.

    Unquestionably, as I see it, it is now mandatory to pursue experimental research into the action of radial electric fields centred on an axis about which a spin condition in matter can be induced. The use of conductive metal discs to probe inertial properties induced by a radial electric field is the experimental theme that I shall now be exploring myself.

    Such research offers a new source of energy now on our near horizon and there are those in our world today who can reveal the secrets of such machines. I have in mind the Methernitha community in Switzerland, where machines are in operation based on rotating discs which incorporate conductors and promote circuital electrical currents in the disc which are tapped by electromagnetic induction to deliver power continuously. The vacuum spin action sustained in those discs draws power from space itself and generates electricity measured in kilowatts from quite small machines.

    Now, concerning the link with gravitation, I will end by referring to one other theme concerned with aether and vacuum spin. If one has a flywheel and imagines it to have a coextensive vacuum spin system, there is the question of what happens if one forcibly precesses that flywheel to upset the coupling with that vacuum spin. The issue centres upon whether gravitational force asserted by matter on matter is really communicated via the aether system or is communicated directly as a kind of action at a distance. If the aether plays a role in that process, as I believe, then so that forced precession can interfere with the pull of gravitation. Forced precessed gyroscopic flywheels feature as another heretical pursuit, that of Professor Eric Laithwaite, and, again, because physicists prefer not to believe in the existence of the aether so they cannot countenance scientific anomalies as effects which depend upon that aether. They would rather ridicule the proponent than help in resolving the mysteries in question.

    The BBC programme featuring Laithwaite as a ‘heretic’ is to be shown on T.V. on August 9th, some days after completion of this text, but until we see the antigravity phenomenon used to technological advantage there is little chance that the world of science will allow itself to be turned upside down by talk of ‘antigravity’.

    I should mention the heresy theme of Rupert Sheldrake, ‘morphic resonance’. This was the subject of another in the ‘Heretic’ series of BBC programmes produced by Tony Edwards. After what I have said, there is reason to question whether the storage of information in the structure of water can be replicated on a larger scale in the aether itself. I have always seen the aether as a kind of all-embracing elusive ‘ferromagnet’ or rather what one might better refer to as an ‘antiferromagnet’. Indeed, it was the study of ferromagnetism, with its domain patterns superimposed upon a crystal form with its underlying quantization, that led me to research the structural nature of the aether itself. The aether does contain domain patterns but I see these as of vast proportion, as bounded regions representing the transition barriers between what one may term ‘space’ and ‘anti space’. The difference is one connected with an underlying asymmetry of the polarities assigned to the vacuum charge which accounts for Maxwell’s displacement currents, the carriers of electromagnetic waves. In anti-space’ ‘positive’ becomes ‘negative’ and vice-versa. However, I need planar interface boundaries between these domains in order to obtain the necessary homogeneous mathematical relationships governing restoring force rates when aether charge is displaced and this tells me that there are domain patterns in the aether, in close analogy with what we see in ferromagnets.

    I have discussed these in my book ‘Modern Aether Science’ and also in my book ‘Physics Unified’ but, based on cosmological evidence connected with geomagnetic field reversals, they are so large that, as resonant entities or memory elements like cores in the old-fashioned computer, they can in no way meet the needs of the proposition suggested by Rupert Sheldrake. So, as Sheldrake’s theme concerns interplay between life forms, whether of plants or animals, all I can suggest here is that in researching the physics of morphic resonance, assuming the concept is deemed to have basis in reality, I would look at the role water plays as the host medium for those patterns and the influence of ultrasonic magnetic excitations. In short, I would seek to confirm the findings of Jacques Benveniste before going on from there to link that with the intuitive doctrines that are advocated by Sheldrake.

    However, for my part, the inertial energy experiments are a sufficient preoccupation and I must confine my efforts to that endeavour.

    *********

    
    It is nearly four years since the above was presented to the conference held by the Society for Scientific Exploration in Renfrew, Scotland. Much of what I said was based on my conviction that the setting up of a radial electric field, meaning one directed radially outwards from, or inwards towards, a central axis, must act to promote an aether spin reaction about that axis. That is a recipe for assuring that the aether of our environment will feed energy into that spin and that is a one-way process. It means that excess energy can be produced in a latent state from which it will disperse as a ghost-like turbulence or vortex that dissipates itself, unless, that is, we can somehow trap that energy and first use it to our material benefit.

    I shall be writing more in these Web pages on the prospect of there being experimental verification leading to several ways by which this phenomenon can be explored. In this regard I invite you to progress to the next item ESSAY No. 13.


  • LECTURE NO. 20

    LECTURE NO. 20

    DEBATE ON CREATION

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    There is nothing more fundamental so far as concerns physical science than the understanding of the processes involved in creating the matter which constitutes our universe. Yes, one can think that there are greater questions, concerning God and the creation of the human life form or, indeed, the sub-structure of that stage on which our universe performs, meaning what physicists refer to as ‘space-time’ or what I, as a physicist, prefer to refer to as ‘the aether’, but one must have a foundation on which to build an understanding of all things. There is no better foundation than an insight into how matter is distilled from the sea of energy that pervades space and that means that we must begin by explaining how the proton, which accounts for more than 99.9 per cent of all matter, is created and we must explain why the proton is 1836.152 times the mass of its companion particle, the electron. Together, these two particles create the hydrogen atom and from that all other forms of matter evolve.

    Now to create the heavier atoms we see around us in solid matter and in the air we breathe, those hydrogen atoms have to undergo a process of fusion. Physicists like to think that the nuclear fusion which created our universe occurred in a one-off event some ten and more billion years ago. That is their hypothesis as developed from their problem in understanding how light radiation from distant stars can degenerate in its frequency spectrum as it travels ever onwards at the enormous speed of light for billions of years before reaching us here on Earth. So they have signed off, as it were, in trying to understand how it might be that those protons and electrons can be involved in an ongoing process of creation and decay here and now wherever matter already exists.

    Those physicists think that protons have no finite lifetime, because they do not see proton decay. They see that when neutrons appear they decay with a half-life of several minutes and, yet, notwithstanding that, they are naive enough to imagine that there are neutrons in the atomic nuclei of atoms heavier than hydrogen. Such is the parlous state of affairs in modern physical science.

    So when, in 1989, the discovery of ‘cold fusion’ involving a heavy isotope of hydrogen was reported and no neutron emission was in evidence, that discovery was ridiculed by the scientific establishment. Here the issue was not just the prospect of a new much-needed energy source, but also the opening of a pathway which could lead to a more sensible understanding of the actual processes of the Creation of our material universe.

    This introduces this Lecture theme. I seek to debate the case for the ongoing creation of matter by making reference to ‘cold fusion’.

    IS THE IDEA OF ‘COLD FUSION’ NONSENSE?

    I find it quite hard to believe that there are so many trained physicists in the world who have such confidence in their intuitive opinions that they are willing to reject outright the very thought of ‘cold nuclear fusion’.

    No doubt those same physicists will tell me that I must be off track in even thinking that a proton might be involved in an ongoing scenario of creation and decay. They may have read somewhere that attempts to measure the decay lifetime of the proton gave a null result and that in fact there is no evidence of decay even over a period estimated on a scale going back to before the event of their imaginary Big Bang.

    Well, let me ask you how you can measure the lifetime of a particle if the energy it sheds in its decay is pooled in a sea of energy from which those very particles are being recreated to keep the energy equilibrium. I could answer that myself if Nature was obliging and was willing to deploy the energy shed so as to create two separate families of stable electrically-positive particles. We might then see the decay process in our experiments, but that will not be the case if a proton decays, sheds its energy to the underlying energy pool, thereby upsetting its equilibrium, which it promptly restores by creating a new proton at the very location where the original proton suffered decay.

    Now, if you, the reader, wish to be a critic and you say that cannot be, then you must have some special knowledge which we ought to share. You may ‘think’ that there is no such thing as that ‘sea of energy’, because you do not subscribe to the belief that there is an aether. Such thought does not amount to knowledge. Remember that there were those who once thought that light travelled at a constant speed relative to the aether and, when they read about an experiment that they ‘thought’ would confirm that assumption but found it gave a null result, they did not question their own notion that light speed was constant relative to the aether. No, they drew the illogical conclusion that the aether does not exist. They did not take account of a discovery made only after the experiment had been performed, namely that, since the apparatus used involved mirrors, the reflected light waves were setting up standing waves locked to the mirror surfaces. The light energy was being dragged along with the apparatus as part of the system of those standing waves. The velocity of the light, as such, in relation to a frame of reference external to the apparatus was meaningless in those circumstances. You see, thought can mislead when it comes to interpreting physical phenomena! I note, by the way, that Wiener discovered and first demonstrated the standing wave phenomenon in 1890, whereas the Michelson-Morley Experiment dates from 1881-1887.

    Somehow physicists have become hooked on the idea that the Michelson-Morley Experiment rang the death knell of the aether and then blew the trumpet acclaiming the birth of Einstein’s notions about the speed of light being relative to an observer. How long will it be before they learn what their experiments are really saying to them?

    Now, I cannot prove that protons decay, just as no one can prove that they do not decay, but I can suggest that, if one assumes that protons can be created and so, in a universe in equilibrium, they must decay, then it is a step forward in support of that hypothesis if one can deduce the precise mass value of the proton in relation to its companion at creation, namely the electron!

    So, proceeding along that track, where do we begin? Well, I am going to begin by referring to the published obituary of a very eminent British physicist who died very recently, namely Sir Charles Frank.

    His obituary was published in the Monday, April 27 1998 issue of the British newspaper THE TIMES. Sir Charles died in Bristol earlier that month, on April 5, aged 87. The obituary is relevant to this discourse because it began with the words:

    “Sir Charles Frank was an inspirational physicist who worked in a wide range of fields, from earthquakes to cold fusion.”

    Now, much as physicists in general seem to find the thought of ‘cold fusion’ amusing, whereas there is nothing amusing about earthquakes, it is appropriate also to consider ‘cold fusion’ as a serious proposition and one must respect the wisdom of Sir Charles Frank for adopting that stance.

    So far as this discourse is concerned, it is relevant to quote a paragraph from that obituary referring specifically to ‘cold fusion’:

    “Charles Frank was the first scientist to think of the idea of cold nuclear fusion. In 1947 he suggested using an elementary subnuclear particle, a muon, to catalyse the fusion of deuterium and tritium. It would take the electron’s place and allow nuclei to approach some 200 times closer than usual, and so help produce fusion. The investigations in this field that Frank began at Bristol are continuing around the world, and his original paper on the subject is still widely quoted.”

    COLD FUSION AND THE MUON

    The muon is the ‘heavy electron’. Its mass is a little below 207 times that of the normal electron. Its role in Nature is a mystery, at least so far as is judged by physicists in general. In fact, the muon is the prime constituent of that sea of energy which those physicists ‘in general’ refuse to recognize as existing as something that fills all space.

    Incredible though it may seem, I have the experience of one conference concerned with nuclear physics where I ventured to suggest how the muon played a role in creating the proton and was a particle, more prevalent in space than even the electron, where a young experimental researcher sought to assure me that I was wrong, because he had studied muons experimentally. I was presenting the theoretical evidence I had discovered and he was basing his opinions on experimental facts concerning how muons interact with matter. I had to be wrong, in his opinion, because what I was saying did not conform with the kind of physics he was learning about in his academic pursuit.

    If you try to talk about ‘aether’ at a conference on physics, I can assure you that the physicists present will have no patience and will pay no attention to the substantive basis of your talk. That is the way things are. Equally, however, those same physicists admit they are searching for that elusive Holy Grail, the unified field theory, that they do not understand how Nature determines the proton/electron mass ratio and that they cannot begin to understand where muons fit into Nature’s scheme. They know so much and yet will not listen when someone ventures to say: “Here is the answer you seek, but you must accept there is an aether!”

    So, physicists in general are stubborn creatures, having sheeplike behaviour, but one has to persist in presenting what has that ring of truth and just hope that someone, somewhere, might pay attention.

    Muons are seen in high energy reactions and in cosmic radiation, but in our laboratory experiments they are not seen in their full glory as the dominant constituent of the sea of energy in the aether background. Yet it is the ongoing activity of those muons, involved, as they are, in a continuous quantum-electrodynamic cycle of mutual pair creation and decay that is the very reason for proton creation and decay. The muons are effectively missiles which attack the proton and destroy it, but, equally, they are both its creator and its destroyer.

    The creation process involves muon bombardment of a charge form that constitutes the lattice-forming components of the aether. The lattice structure, its role in forming photon ‘units’ and its spin feature determine the action quantum which we term the Planck constant. However, those lattice charges present a relatively large target for the ongoing bombardment by the virtual muons in that aether energy sea and it is the coincidental bombardment by nine muons collectively hitting one such lattice charge that triggers proton creation.

    The full analysis of this is to be found in my book ‘Aether Science Papers’, but see also Tutorial No. 9 in these Web pages.

    As to the decay of the proton, this follows as a consequence of proton creation, given that there is a prevailing state of equilibrium as between matter and aether, in that the release of energy to augment the entropy of the environment contributes to the surplus which builds in the sea of energy and replenishes the energy deployed into proton creation.

    What this amounts to is the fact that energy which we regard as radiated as heat or electromagnetic radiation is regenerated by creating protons. That is governed by a statistical process of chance, ever ongoing. Then there is a balancing proton decay once the energy deficit is felt and the muon background needs to claw energy back from the protons and recreate those muon pairs.

    With new energy technology in mind, I can see that in an intermediate state, owing to the way in which Planck’s constant is determined by the systematic motion of those lattice charges forming the aether structure, which motion acts as a buffer in the energy activity, there is scope for gaining access to that aether energy by somewhat devious means, intercepting energy that otherwise will go into proton creation. That motivates my present interest in this whole field of research that I am describing in these Web pages.

    Essentially, however, concerning my ground work on fundamental theory, what we see overall is a stable system of protons surviving in a state of equilibrium with the aether background. Underlying all that there is an ongoing fluctuation as a kind of zero-point energy activity in which protons are created and decay virtually in situ, as it were. It means, however, that there is a possibility that protons could decay as part of one atomic nucleus and be recreated as part of a different atomic nucleus in very close proximity. This hints at both cold nuclear fusion and cold nuclear fission and, the more we read about transmutation of elements in what seem to be nothing other than chemical-type processes, the greater the support for the scenario of proton creation and decay as just described. The periodical Infinite Energy is an important source of information on such discoveries. The URL of its Web site is http://www.infinite-energy.com for those interested in knowing more about that publication.

    In summary, my suggestion differs from the proposal of Sir Charles Frank. I do not see muons as replacing the electrons in hydrogen atoms and occupying orbits very much reduced in size. Instead I look to the role of the muon in the aether background as the creative agent which is able to form new protons very close to existing protons and capture electron-sized charges which can transmute hydrogen nuclei into deuterium nuclei or deuterium nuclei into tritium nuclei. That seems a possible feature associated with the phenomenon of cold fusion.

    Either way, however, or whatever might be the action which occurs in cold fusion reactions, there can be no doubt that the muon is involved in proton creation and that proton creation is an ongoing manifestation of the presence of aether energy everywhere in space.

    Once that is recognized the challenge will attract more who will try to discover the best way of tapping into that sea of aether energy and that is the main message I seek to convey.

    DON’T FORGET THOMSON

    This section heading was the title of a Letter to the Editor published by the American Institute of Physics in their journal Physics Today, November 1984, p. 15.

    Since I want the world of physics to be left in no doubt as to whether or not I have put my views on this matter on proper record. I am accordingly, reproducing below the full content of that Letter to the Editor so that I can point to the ignorance of those physicists who persist in saying that there is still no theory that can explain the proton-electron mass ratio.

    Don’t forget Thomson

    Writing in PHYSICS TODAY (November 1981, page 69), Victor F. Weisskopf tells the remarkable story of the development of field theory throughout the last 50 years. The triumph of Dirac’s quantum electrodynamics was, however, left in sharp contrast by the awesome remarks that “we have no explanation for the mass of the electron; that is, the smallness of the ratio (1/1836) between the electron mass and the proton mass” and “there is not the slightest indication why electrons with different masses should exist.” Here Weisskopf had in mind the normal electron, the tau-electron and the muon.

    Forgotten, it seems, in these modern developments is the classical basis of electrodynamic theory developed by J. J. Thomson. Thomson gave a formula specifying the energy of the electron as 2e2/3a, where a is the radius within which its electric charge e is confined. He did not know about muons and antimatter, but it needs little imagination to write:

    μ+ + μ– = Qo

    where Qo is an energy quantum formed from the mutual annihilation of a positive and negative muon. Adding energy to such a quantum could well produce a pair of Thomson-sized charges, including Q–. Thus, for charges e and -e in touching relationship, the total energy, including that of the Coulomb interaction, is:

    W = P+ + Q– – e2/(x+y) ……… (1)

    where P = 2e2/3x and Q = 2e2/3y.

    Eliminating x and y:

    W = P + Q – 3PQ/2(P+Q) ……… (2)

    Given a background source of muon pairs and an amount of energy NP used to create N protons, we have N systems given by equation (2), NP constant and NW tending to a minimal value, for optimum stability. We can therefore differentiate W/P with respect to P to find its minimum. This occurs when:

    P/Q = [(3/2)1/2 – 1]-1

    and tells us that:

    P = 1836 because Q = 2(mu) = 413

    in electron mass-energy terms.

    This is such a remarkably simple result based on the Thomson formula, that one really must exclaim, “Let us not forget the heritage he left us.”

    Proton creation follows naturally from the existence of the dimuon energy quantum. Also remarkable is the fact that W is exactly half of the mass energy of the tau-electron (half of 1.782 GeV or 1743 electron units). Put P = 1836 and Q = 413 in equation (2) and W is 1743.

    Such results cannot be fortuitous; bear in mind that the formal derivation of the proton-electron mass ratio using equation (2) in terms of a theoretical determination of Q gave 1836.1523. This was published in 1975 in a paper I coauthored [1] with D. M. Eagles of CSIRO in Australia. It antedates by eight years the measurement by Van Dyck, Moore and Schwinberg [2], which puts the ratio at 1836.152470(80). The discrepancy is one part in ten million, but even this is explicable from the basic theory as it stood in 1975, as I have recently shown [3]. Using the same Thomson formula, the muon-electron mass ratio of 206.7683 has also yielded to theoretical explanation at its one-in-a million level of measurement [4]. Classical electromagnetic theory can, therefore, be usefully combined with quantum electrodynamics to solve some of the mysteries of particle mass.

    References

    1. H. Aspden, D. M. Eagles, Nuovo Cimento 30A, p. 235 (1975).

    2. R. S. Van Dyck Jr, F. L. Moore, P. B. Schwinberg, Bull. Am. Phys. Soc., 28, p. 791 (1983).

    3. H. Aspden, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 38, p. 423 (1983).

    4. H. Aspden, Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 38, p. 342 (1983).

    THE ONWARD DEBATE

    Again I remind readers that the full updated account of my proton theory plus related theory concerning many other fundamental particles is to be found in the published papers as reproduced in my book entitled: Aether Science Papers.

    I come now to the points of debate which I am sure some readers will wish to raise.

    Firstly, I have suggested above that J. J. Thomson long ago presented the correct formula relating the mass-energy, electric charge and the radius of the sphere bounding that electron charge. In short I am saying that I support the view that the electron has a finite volume.

    I note also that, if J. J. Thomson had not presumed that the electron charge was all concentrated at the surface of that bounding sphere, his corresponding formula for electromagnetic mass would have given E=Mc2 long before Einstein came on the scene. As it was, Thomson’s electromagnetic mass formula corresponds to E=(3/4)Mc2. The true picture of the electron is that of a charge sphere in which the charge is so distributed within the sphere as to set up a uniform electric energy density inside the sphere. That gives the E=Mc2 formula and is consistent with E being 2e2/3a.

    It was, incidentally, on April 23, 1997 that I saw reported in the INTERFACE section of the British newspaper THE TIMES that a major discovery had been made concerning the electron. Scientist Ken Long was proposing that the electron is no longer a truly fundamental particle, but is believed to consist of smaller particles ‘which some people are already calling preons’. He stated “This might solve problems with the electron, such as the fact that it appears to have mass but no volume.”

    Well, if physicists give themselves a problem because they think the electron is a point charge and then they seek a solution by saying the electron is composed of smaller particles, they are lost in a wonderland of their own making. I think it more important to begin with the findings of J. J. Thomson, the man who discovered the electron and keep faith with the belief that the electron must have a finite radius. That leads me to that 1836.152 proton/electron mass ratio and I am then ready to listen to the case, if there is one, supporting the view that the electron has to be a point charge. I hope that case is not just one relying on the quantum-electrodynamic numerology of Paul Dirac in explaining the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron. If it is then, that makes my alternative explanation presented in my book Aether Science Papers all the more relevant.

    Then there will be those who will tell me that the neutron accounts for an important and substantial part of the material universe and that matter is not all protons and electrons. Well, I can defend my case here, though I regard antiprotons and positrons as featuring also in the substance of our material world. The neutron is a short-lived particle form that emerges from certain nuclear processes. It does not exist inside stable matter, whatever your textbooks might have to say on the subject!

    I can, for example, see no reason why two protons cannot sit on opposite sides of an electron, meaning that they are in touching surface contact with the charge sphere of the electron and that they sit on opposite sides of that electron because they repel one another but are held by attraction to the electron. What proven law of physics denies that as a possibility? I once was told that Earnshaw’s Law precluded such a possibility, but I dismissed that once I checked how that law was derived. It was based on the assumption that the charges were in a complete void, whereas they are set in a background continuum of other charge and that makes stable association possible.

    Then again, who says stability is a key necessity? Why cannot a form of ‘stability’ exist where a system of particles changes states in a cyclic sequence, always recycling in the same manner so as to preserve certain characteristics such as the a steady mean mass, momentum, overall charge and so on?

    Who says that, when an electron is moving at high speed, it is travelling alone? Why cannot the energy added as kinetic energy be deployed into the transient creation and decay of electron-positron pairs which keep company with the electron in motion?

    It is only by exploring all such possibilities with a physically-real spherical charge form of the electron in mind that one can progress towards a better understanding of particle physics. However, one must take note of that major discovery of mine that the 1836.152 proton/electron mass ratio tells us how the proton is created from muons. One must see those muons as the primary energy source of the aether. Furthermore, one must then come to terms with that real aether and its properties.

    At this point I will close this Lecture and will invite the reader to refer next to Lecture No. 24 in which I reproduce a version of an article of mine published in 1982 and entitled: The Ether – An Assessment’.


    Harold Aspden
    May 26, 1998
  • LECTURE NO. 19

    LECTURE NO. 19

    TEC IV

    THERMOMAGNETIC POWER GENERATION

    Copyright © 1998 Harold Aspden

    In this Lecture we will show why it is that the heat generated in a transformer core can be regenerated as electricity, now relying on that experimental evidence presented in Lecture No. 18. In this Lecture 19 some further evidence will also be drawn from the author’s experimental research as reported in his Ph.D. thesis and in the author’s papers published in the Proceedings of the Institution of Electrical Engineers. The prospect of exploiting such a regeneration phenomena is discussed and deemed viable.

    INTRODUCTION

    Once it is suspected that the heat generated by magnetization loss in a transformer has a way of regenerating electricity it is logical to look at the physics governing thermoelectricity. In the transformer we do not have current circuits involving junctions between two metals. This rules out the Peltier and Seebeck Effects. The Thomson Effect is one discovered and reported by Lord Kelvin (then Professor William Thomson) in 1855. He showed that an EMF can be set up within a metal simply by there being a temperature gradient in that metal. In the transformer lamination we have such a temperature gradient owing to need for the heat to find an exit path. However there is no circuital EMF such as is needed to enhance eddy current flow and so the Thomson Effect does not account for regeneration. At best, owing to the Thomson Effect, there is an electric potential difference as between the middle section of a lamination and its edges. What we seek is some connection in a metal between EMF or electric current and a temperature gradient. Such an effect was discovered by H.W. Nernst and A. von Ettinghausen, Wied. Ann., v. 29, p. 343; 1886. We shall refer to this as the Nernst Effect, taking note that there is a complementary phenomenon known as the Ettinghausen Effect, the latter being the setting up of a temperature difference in a metal in a direction mutually orthogonal to a magnetic field and a flow of current. The Nernst Effect is the reciprocal phenomenon, namely the production of an EMF in a direction mutually orthogonal with respect to a magnetic field and a flow of heat through that field consequential upon there being a temperature gradient. We have such a situation in the core of a transformer.

    Here I should have said that we have such a situation in the magnetic domains existing within that transformer core, meaning within those domains which happen to have their magnetic polarizations suitably orientated. The action of the magnetic field is to cause the heat flow in the plane of a transformer core lamination to develop a Nernst EMF across the thickness of the lamination, thereby encouraging the eddy currents in that lamination to flow selectively through those domains which generate a supporting EMF.

    Note my use of the word ‘generate’ because what we have here is nothing less than the generation of electricity from heat and the action is not related to temperature as an absolute measure, but rather the difference of temperature effective in promoting heat flow by thermal conduction in metal.

    Our 20th century eddy current anomaly can be explained simply by taking account of the Nernst Effect, which dates from 1886. It is difficult to believe our ignorance of this as being the true cause accounting for the mysterious loss of billions of dollars worth of electricity every year in power transformers.

    Simply stated, the Nernst Effect converts heat into electricity and is very efficient in that action. Indeed, the conversion efficiency can but be 100%. The only problem is that of tapping the electric power generated before it dissipates itself as eddy currents in the metal. It is no wonder that what we see in our power transformers is simply that, the anomalous generation of heat owing to the enhancement of the eddy current action.

    In order to understand a little better what I have just described, consider the following Fig. 1.

    Fig. 1

    This illustrates the cross-section of a steel lamination such as is used in a transformer. The transformer usually comprises large rectangular laminations stacked together but separated by an insulating coating to prevent the induced eddy currents from flowing from one lamination to an adjacent lamination, thereby restricting their effects to the thin metal section of each lamination. The EMF induced as the source of the power developing these parasitic currents is that set up by the rate of change of the magnetic flux local to that lamination.

    So one must imagine that that flux is directed at right angles to the illustration of Fig. 1 and it really comprises the combined action of contributions by magnetic domains all polarized to a state of magnetic saturation in a preferred direction governed by the crystal structure of the steel. In practice the magnetic polarization will tend to be along one of the crystal axes that is closest to the plane of the lamination. For our purpose it suffices to depict two domain polarization states, one shown in pink which has its polarization directed in the same direction as the magnetic flux in the transformer core and one shown in pale green which has its polarization set in the opposite direction.

    As the core flux increases the domain walls between domains shift so that, more and more, the red domain regions dominate and when the flux decreases the green domains grow until, at the point where the core flux reverses, they become the dominant domain species. However, while this is an ongoing process in the operation of a power transformer, those eddy currents are induced with a appropriate phase lag and these circuital eddy currents, shown as having rectangular flow paths duly reverse direction with an out-of-phase relationship relative to the transformer core polarization.

    The key point I wish to make is that the magnetization losses associated with these eddy currents and the hysteresis of the core produce heat in the lamination and that heat, along with the current, is confined by that insulation between the laminations and obliged to flow laterally to get to the outside edges where the core interfaces with a cooling medium. Taking the shortest route, the main heat flow is lateral to the core magnetization direction and so is as shown in Fig. 1 and also in Fig. 2, which applies to the periods when the eddy currents have reversed direction.

    Fig. 2

    The difference between Figs. 1 and 2 is the different current flow paths near the edges of the lamination. The currents take the paths of least resistance or rather the path of maximum forward EMF, because the heat is converted into an electrical action all the way along the flow path owing to the Nernst Effect interaction with those domains. The potentials developed at intermediate positions are acting against the insulation or are opposed to the induced EMFs that drive the eddy currents or they may aid eddy current flow but that only deploys heat locally. However, in the relevant magnetic domain type at the edges of the lamination the two actions invariably supplement one another to add impetus to the basic eddy current flow. There is then a cooling action adjacent the edges of the lamination as heat is deployed in that effort and the overall result is that far more current flows as eddy-current than one expects theoretically from calculation based on magnetic induction theory. The heat deployed by that cooling reappears as resistance loss in the central regions of the lamination. Hence there is what has been termed ‘the eddy current anomaly’.

    Indeed, in a sense, here we see the room temperature action of what amounts to ‘warm superconductivity’ except that we do not see the ‘over-run’ condition where the thermally-induced EMF overtakes the potential drop associated with the normal resistance property which is still there in those so-called ‘warm superconductors’. However, the latter phenomenon is not dependent upon the Nernst Effect, but rather the simple phenomenon of magnetic induction preserving current flow when two electric charges of opposite polarity come into collision owing to their motion in opposite directions. The energy stored by induction prior to collision survives the collision and sets up the EMFs needed to restore the opposed motions of the charge after their collision. However, in the process the heat energy of the heavier ions, atoms and molecules, involved has been depleted and transferred to the magnetic induction state of the region surrounding the collision, only to be returned as the electrical drive power which keeps the current flow ongoing. I have discussed that subject elsewhere in these Web pages towards the end of Lecture No. 9 under the heading Supergravitons and Cold Fusion.

    From a technological point of view the fact that transformers operate at normal ambient temperatures and exhibit the eddy current anomaly tells us that we should be able to develop energy converters which run on ambient heat to deliver electrical power. Conversion efficiencies are, it seems 100% in the ‘warm superconductor’, but we have yet to see that technology develop to become reliable at room temperature and it will need a leap beyond that to reach a margin of excess allowing some of the self-generating action can be tapped to deliver electrical power for useful purposes. One day we may perhaps see large induction coils composed of superconductors carrying a high current and, by cyclically altering the inductance, it could well become possible to take off electricity as the system cools to absorb ambient heat. That must remain a pipe dream at this time, but meanwhile one can take stock of the eddy current anomaly and what that may imply.

    As will be understood by those familiar with the calculation of eddy current loss in transformers, the passage of the eddy currents through the very thin layer of metal section is the seat of heat generation by eddy current loss. One seeks to obstruct the current flow by using steel of high resistivity consistent with good magnetic properties and by making the laminations thin one can minimize the current flow and so contain such losses. However, remember that Nernst Effect and note that there is in excess of 20,000 gauss acting as a magnetic field strength in each magnetic domain. Therefore, the flow of heat through those domains will induce an EMF mutually orthogonal with respect to the direction of heat flow and the direction of magnetic polarization. Consider this and you will see that one domain type, say the green form illustrated will act in Fig. 1 to develop an EMF adjacent one edge, the right hand one shown, acting between the faces of the lamination but in a direction which opposes the flow of eddy currents, whereas the pink domains shown will develop an EMF which strengthens the flow of eddy currents.

    The result of this is that, whatever be the momentary phase of the flux or the eddy currents, the Nernst Effect will always capture some of the heat flow that is trying to escape from the edges of the lamination and cause it to generate an EMF which strengthens the current. The current will always flow along the path where it is assisted rather than opposed.

    Indeed, without knowing the Nernst coefficient of the metal forming the laminations or its composition and physical properties, such as resistivity, but knowing the eddy current anomalous loss factor, one can estimate the actual value of that coefficient. The Nernst Effect is quite difficult to measure under normal circumstances because one needs to set up a known temperature gradient in what is a good thermal conductor and, though an EMF can be measured under zero current flow conditions, it is the operating state where that Nernst EMF promotes current flow that one seeks to explore in measurements having a technological objective. The standard transformer affords the means of measurement, simply by virtue of the phenomenon of the eddy current anomaly.

    The method is implicit in the numerical examples recorded in the preceding Lecture No. 18 entitled The Eddy Current Anomaly. Note that the wider the lamination, the greater the mass of steel generating the magnetization loss. This means that the heat generated will escape by conduction through the metal at a rate which sets a temperature gradient somewhat independent of the lamination width, but dependent, of course, on lamination thickness. As to the latter one presumes that the same steel lamination stock is used in transformers large and small, so the core thickness becomes the next parameter we need to consider. The larger this thickness, the more the number of laminations in a core stack. Now, the thicker the core, the greater the induced EMF which generates the eddy currents, the ratio being linear for a given core width. So, this width dimension, being that of the direction in which the thermoelectric Nernst EMF is developed, governs the magnitude of this EMF. It will increase pro rata with that core thickness. Therefore, the induced EMF responsible for the primary eddy current flow and that EMF added by the Nernst Effect will be in linear proportion. It follows that, regardless of the size of the transformer, the measurement of the eddy-current anomaly factor, meaning the ratio of the actual and theoretical eddy current loss components, will allow one to estimate the actual Nernst coefficient effective in the steel used in the transformer core.

    What this means, of course, is that one cannot escape the consequences of the eddy-current anomaly by scaling up the size of a transformer. Conversely, if one contrives to find away of exploiting the phenomenon described to tap into the potential power output from that anomalous increment of EMF, the task will not be thwarted by incorporation in very large power generating units. The phenomenon can be used in the large scale implementations of the technology.

    ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE

    To add further confirmation of this interpretation of the anomalous loss phenomenon, ask yourself what happens when a transformer core is d.c. biased, meaning that the magnetic polarization has displaced the hysteresis cycle towards core saturation. As mentioned in TEC III, if the bias is substantial, this will reduce hysteresis loss for a magnetization cycle having the same flux density range. However, if the flux change occurs at the same frequency and the voltage waveform is sinusoidal in form, there should, by standard teaching, be no change in the theoretical eddy current loss. Yet, what we have done is to set up a higher proportion of magnetic domains with their magnetic polarization in one direction than applies in the opposite direction. This reduces the scope for the Nernst Effect to be active in enhancing the bidirectional oscillation of those eddy currents and it will reduce the anomaly. In short, we should expect tests such as are confined to regions near magnetic saturation of the core to show very little anomaly.

    This also means that even during the normal magnetization cycle, with no polarizing bias applied to the core, there will be strong enhancement of eddy current flow when the flux density is of low value but much reduced enhancement at high flux densities. Tests expressly conducted to see how the anomaly factor varies instantaneously as we progress around the whole of the B-H loop of the core should confirm this, if the Nernst Effect interpretation is correct.

    I am able to report such confirmation because I made those tests long before I came to realize that it was the Nernst Effect that was causing the problem. The following Fig. 3 was in my paper entitled ‘An Investigation of the Eddy-current Anomaly in a Low Silicon Sheet Steel’, Proc. I.E.E., vol. 104C, pp. 2-7 (1957).

    Fig. 3

    I had devised a technique for measuring the instantaneous loss anomaly factor arising at different parts of the normal B-H magnetization loop. Fig. 3 shows the mean loss anomaly factor, such as one would find by normal measurements. Thus the sample tested had a mean loss anomaly factor of the order of 1.5, but this reduced for magnetization over a cycle that ranged between the higher flux densities. That is shown by the broken curve.

    The full line curve, however, shows how the loss anomaly factor varied as the flux density climbed during the magnetization cycle. It dropped virtually to the zero anomaly level over the upper flux range where all the magnetic domains are polarized in a common direction.

    The technique of measurement used for this purpose depended upon knowledge of the effective incremental permeability over the selected range, the sector selected for test having substantially linear permeability. However, the measurement of that permeability value had to be based on the analysis of the static hysteresis loop, meaning the B-H loop measured by fluxmeter tests at zero frequency rather than one involving a.c. activation. Assuming discrepancy between the measured permeability and that effective owing to a.c. excitation, it was appropriate to estimate a worst case scenario, one, however, which just cannot possibly prevail, just to see if it was at all possible to escape the evidence of that loss anomaly. That worst case adjustment is indicated by the arrows and the findings were clear that there was just no way of avoiding the acceptance of a significant anomalous energy loss. The eddy current anomaly is not something that is fortuitous in the sense that it can be attributed as a consequence of misinterpretation of the measurement data.

    When an entirely different method of measurement was tried, one reported in my paper entitled ‘The Eddy-Current Anomaly in Electrical Sheet Steel, Proc. I.E.E., vol. 103C, pp. 279-285 (1956), in this case restricting the measurement to instantaneous rate of loss as the magnetic flux traversed to zero flux density state in the B-H loop cycle, some quite substantial anomaly factors were measured.

    A typical result, taken from Table I of that paper, applies to Superstalloy laminations having 4.3 Si composition, a lamination thickness of 0.309 mm and a specific resistivity of 59 microhm-cm. It was found that the instantaneous anomaly factor effective at zero B flux density was 4.81 when the B-H loop ranged up to a maximum flux density of 6,775 gauss, 5.22 for a loop having a maximum flux density of 10,250 gauss and 5.03 for one having a maximum flux density of 13,550 gauss.

    An entirely different set of tests were performed on solid steel cores where higher frequencies were used to confine the cyclic magnetization to surface layers of the test specimen. These were based on the eddy current effects affecting the phase angle of the magnetizing current in relation to voltage. The action is tantamount to a time-lag effect which affects that phase angle. The hypothesis I was exploring was that hysteresis loss involves transient adjustment of magnetic flux as domain boundary walls move in abrupt steps when there is instability. I reasoned that, if the magnetizing current were to increase so fast that those transient adjustments did not occur at the trigger level of that current, as applied to the zero-frequency B-H magnetization cycle, then there would be added loss. It would, in effect, be a dynamic hysteresis loss, and I wondered if this could be the true cause of the eddy current anomaly.

    So I did experiments with that in mind and the results are to be found in my paper Magnetic Time-Lag Effects in Solid Steel Cores, Proc. I.E.E., vol. 103C, pp. 272-278 (1956). Note that the measurements of such a time-lag effect do not tell us whether there is, in fact, a retardation in the magnetization process or whether there is an increase of eddy-currents owing to a reduction of electrical resistivity. Certainly, the thermoelectric effect discussed above should still be of consequence in tests using solid cylindrical steel cores, because the heat escapes radially and the currents flow circumferentially, with magnetic flux polarization being longitudinal. There was no doubt that the time-lags recorded were commensurate with those applicable to laminar core tests, but one vital fact did emerge. The time-lag reduced virtually to the minimal no-anomaly level when the core was polarized close to saturation, though still subject to sufficient oscillatory flux change for eddy-currents to be measurable and of significance.

    In summary, my experimental research on the eddy-current anomaly gave results all of which were consistent with the thermoelectric regeneration interpretation, the interpretation which goes against the Second Law of Thermodynamics as having an governing influence upon the heat to electricity conversion.

    THE ONWARD IMPLICATIONS

    With such knowledge the question now confronting me is how I can exploit the action I see at work in the standard power transformer core to tap into that Nernst Effect power before the energy is lost in those eddy currents.

    At this stage it helps to do some quantitative evaluation. The suggestion is that the EMF set up across a flow path equal to the thickness of a sheet steel lamination (0.3mm) is sufficient to overwhelm the EMF set up around the whole eddy current circuital flow path in that transformer. The latter can easily be of the order of 0.05 volt in a moderately large power transformer. One then sees that the Nernst EMF per cm induced in that lamination has to be of the order of volts per cm and, taking the Nernst coefficient of iron at 10,000 gauss as 10.5 volts per cm, per degree C per cm, this really tells us that a temperature gradient of 0.1oC/cm will suffice to account for the eddy current anomaly factors observed. The magnetization loss need only be a few milliwatts per cc to sustain such a temperature gradient, which is consistent with the specification of loss properties of electrical sheet steel. Accordingly the theory does have quantitative support.

    Before proceeding I will here comment on my objective in drawing attention to this topic. I believe one could build a solid-state device which will tap the thermal energy of the background environment and provide cooling in combination with electrical power generation. If we can do this we have breached the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

    We are in these Web pages exclusively concerned with the physics which has eluded the scientific community at large. If what is presented here were merely a repetition of accepted knowledge as taught in academic institutions, the author would be enjoying his retirement in other ways, rather than striving to attract attention to what is here disclosed. It is a very daring pursuit to try to convince scientists in general that the Second Law of Thermodynamics can be breached to our advantage, but it is even more daring to declare that we can derive our power needs from the energy of the environment or that of the aether.

    I am all too aware of the words of Sir Arthur Eddington which I have seen quoted on page 639 of the book ‘The Anthropic Cosmological Principle’ by John D. Barrow and Frank J. Tipler, as first published by Oxford University Press in 1986 and reissued in 1996:

    “The law that entropy always increases – the Second Law of Thermodynamics – holds, I think, the supreme position among the laws of physics. If someone points out to you that your pet theory of the universe is in disagreement with Maxwell’s equations – then so much the worse for Maxwell’s equations. If it is found to be contradicted by observation – well, these experimentalists do bungle things from time to time. But if your theory is found to be against the Second Law of Thermodynamics I can give you no hope; there is nothing for it but to collapse in deepest humiliation.”

    I am now going to show why these words of Eddington should be ignored, but first I will quote one other item from that book just mentioned. It appears in the Introduction on page 5:

    “The Holy Grail of modern physics is to explain why these numerical constants – quantities like the ratio of the proton and electron masses for example – have the particular numerical values they do. Although there has been significant progress towards this goal during the last few years we still have far to go in this quest.”

    Let me now ask you, the reader, a question. Suppose you set off in search of that Holy Grail. How do you proceed? There are only two routes to follow. Either you say that all the protons in the universe were created in the early phases of the hypothetical Big Bang which marked the beginning of time or you can imagine that protons are being created even now throughout the universe, but only where energy has been shed by proton decay. This presumes that there is a regenerative process, involving, as ever, conservation of energy, but nevertheless a process that can be regulated by physical principles based on what can be measured in the laboratory. You see, you need to understand how a proton is created before you can deduce its mass. All protons are the same. It is as if they come from a common mould and understanding that mould is the secret of that Holy Grail.

    If you read that book by Barrow and Tipler, you will learn nothing about Creation, because, as they declare in that quotation from page 5, they do not know how protons are created and yet protons account for 99.9% of the mass of the universe. On the other hand if you read my 1980 book Physics Unified, published six years before that book by Barrow and Tipler, you will see how protons are created and be able to calculate the proton/electron mass ratio. You will see that the theoretical value is slightly greater than 1836.152, which is also its measured value. Further you will see that this explanation of the creation of matter in the form of the proton, was published in the scientific literature five years before that, in 1975. So if you go in search of that Holy Grail all you need to do is to obtain a copy of my book or just look elsewhere in these Web pages, starting with the Tutorial section.

    My point in saying this is to stress that it is illogical for physicists to try to understand how matter is created unless they are prepared to accept the regenerative energy process. Energy shed into space in that ever-increasing entropy process has a way of joining in a quantum dance and packaging itself into a form that can materialize to produce protons.

    From this position it seems a trivial exercise to argue against the Eddington proposition that the Second Law of Thermodynamics is sacrosanct. Let us therefore now come back to that lesser task, the prospect of building a solid-state device that can cool and generate electricity by tapping the energy of heat in our environment.

    THE THERMOELECTRIC CIRCUIT

    Consider what happens when an electric current flows around a circuit formed by connecting two wires, each of a different metal, say nickel and aluminium, with the two junctions maintained at different temperatures. We do not need an electrical power supply to set up this current flow. That temperature difference is sufficient.

    It is found that the current will flow from the nickel wire to the aluminium wire at the hot junction and from the aluminium wire to the nickel wire at the cold junction. This phenomenon is known as the Seebeck Effect, discovered in 1826, though at that early date the nickel-aluminium combination was not in Seebeck’s list. The heat drives the current. In other words heat is converted into electricity. Now, how efficient is this process?

    Well, here we have a problem, because what is happening at the hot junction is a cooling process and that means that the temperature over the restricted interface where the current crosses the junction is substantially reduced. Indeed, it must be well below the temperature of the heat source applied to that junction, because with reduction of temperature these two metals develop an increased conductivity and this can become confined to spot regions owing to the current flow escalating its concentration into those regions. However, whatever the actual spot temperature at the point of junction crossing, it is heat at that temperature that is converted into electricity.

    Now, quite obviously, this has to be conversion at 100% efficiency. Heat becomes electricity and if this process were inefficient all that would mean is that there would be some heat produced to augment the heat supplied. Conservation of energy means 100% conservation as between heat and electricity.

    There is, of course, something happening at the cold junction, but my concern here is the part of the circuit on the left hand side of Fig. 4.

    Fig. 4.

    Here I show two metal interfaces or junctions and ask you to look at that left portion of the circuit, the hot junction, from the viewpoint of those two different metals. Owing to the local temperature at that junction there is a voltage V across the interface and a current I flows. It is d.c. current and so the electrical power flow across that interface is VI. I say that VI is 100% of the heat extracted from the thermal state of that hot junction between the two metals.

    I well realize that an overall assessment of the energy conversion efficiency of the circuit needs to allow for some heat loss owing to thermal conduction through the metal, but that need not be too great. What is important is the fact that that voltage generated cannot supply its energy to a normal load such as a resistor. It must, owing to the configuration using two metals, pass that current through the junction from aluminium to nickel, where it converts electricity back into heat and does so with 100% efficiency.

    In that process the cold junction will not demand as much electricity as is generated at the hot junction, because it has a lower temperature. Its V value is lower, lower in proportion to absolute temperature. Now, if the EMF acting between the different metals is proportional to the absolute temperature of the junction temperature then the Seebeck Effect cannot convert heat to electricity with an efficiency exceeding the Carnot factor, namely the difference of the two temperatures as divided by the one of higher value, the latter being expressed in absolute units.

    With the Nernst Effect that we discussed with our transformer eddy-current anomaly in mind there is no opposing EMF in the circuit other than that attributable to the load. In other words, apart from a little loss owing to circuit resistance, the heat deployed is all active in generating useful electrical power. It is just that in the context of eddy currents in the power transformer there is no ‘load’ as such other than that circuit resistance, which is why the regenerative feature presents itself as the enhanced loss which is known as ‘the eddy current anomaly’.

    Now at this point I shall conclude this Lecture. I have contended that there is in every electrical power transformer a manifestation of an anomalous energy phenomenon which, if properly interpreted, tells us that low grade heat, meaning heat at ambient temperatures driven by a temperature differential of 10 or so degrees C, is being converted back into electricity with remarkable efficiency. That efficiency is such that one can contemplate harnessing the phenomenon to advantage, By building a conventional reverse heat engine, a heat pump, and running it back-to-back with an energy converter harnessing such principles it seems economically feasible, indeed highly feasible, to expect to be able to harness heat extracted from our environment at its ambient temperature and generate useful electrical power.

    My hope is that those having the resources needed to fabricate laminar metal assemblies based on bonded core structures for use in a modified type of transformer will show interest in this prospect and take up this proposition. I shall enlarge on this theme as I add to these Web pages.


    Harold Aspden
    May 9, 1998

  • LECTURE NO. 18

    LECTURE NO. 18

    TEC III

    The Eddy Current Loss Anomaly

    Copyright © 1998 Harold Aspden

    This is the third item presented under the heading ‘Thermoelectric Energy Conversion’ (TEC). Press TEC I or TEC II to see those earlier chapters on this subject.

    INTRODUCTION

    There is a sound basis for thinking that we should be able to extract electrical power from the heat of our environment, notwithstanding the fact that this would be a breach of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. This TEC III chapter is an introduction showing why it is that the author expects to succeed in this effort. It will be shown that a recognized anomalous loss condition that affects all electrical power distribution systems worldwide, once understood as arising from that breach of the Second Law of Electrodynamics, can point the way towards a future avoiding further pollution by the existing energy generation methods.

    Transformers are used in several stages to adjust the voltage of electrical power as it is transmitted from the generators to the ultimate user. All of those power transformers generate heat owing to what are called ‘magnetization losses’. Those losses cannot be avoided. The transformers are designed to keep them at a minimal level and, commercially, they are a tolerable overhead in the economics of power distribution. However, what is not general known, even by many electrical engineering professionals in academic institutions is the fact that there is a significant proportion of that loss that defies explanation. The problem was highlighted in 1936 by Dr. F. C. Dannatt (Journal I.E.E., p. 667; 1936) who measured the loss in various steel stampings as used in the assembly of transformers. The component of loss attributable to what are called eddy-currents, meaning the parasitic currents induced internally within each lamination forming the transformer core was found to be as much as 3.5 times greater than it should be according to electrical teaching.

    Yet the teaching is not wrong. It relies on proven principles of electrical science. The electrical EMFs induced in those laminations are no different from those induced in the winding turns of the transformer and, since the resistivity of the material of those laminations is known, the electrical loss is a quantity that can be calculated with the same confidence as applies to standard electrical circuit design. Yet, for some mysterious reason, there is that threefold increase in the eddy current loss.

    Indeed, Dannatt reported measurements on several sample materials of different resistivities, different mass densities and widely different thickness, ranging from 0.052 mm to 0.354 mm and found that the eddy current anomaly factor ranged from 2.8 to 3.5, that factor being the ratio of actual eddy current loss to its theoretical value as determined by the design principles we are taught as part of our professional electrical engineering education.

    Onward research to explore this phenomenon and solve its secrets seems not to have attracted physicists as a worthy pursuit, with the result that six decades on from the publication of that paper by Dannatt I can survey the subject as if it were virgin territory. As you will see there is much to learn about this mystery energy loss of power that silently and unobtrusively disposes of billions of dollars worth of electricity every year, without our having understood why that happens.

    Now I do have a special interest in the subject. I heard about it in 1947 and, after graduating from my Electrical Engineering studies in 1948, but during a period of onward practical training in the heavy electrical industry in U.K., I resolved to seek the chance to research that theme. In 1949, during that training period, I wrote a thesis in support of my application for a research scholarship with that anomalous loss problem in mind. My proposal in that thesis was a new method of measuring hysteresis loss by a technique which was not dissimilar from what is known today as an application of the fast Fourier transform. My aim was to analyze the waveform of the magnetic flux in the transformer core to achieve the rapid measurement of the hysteresis component of loss and track how the separate loss components varied during the cycle of a.c. magnetization.

    I began my Ph.D. research on the eddy current anomaly at Cambridge in 1950 and spent three years on experiments probing all aspects of the problem that I could think of. Some of my tests revealed anomaly factors as high as 6 applicable during parts of the magnetization cycle. By this I mean that calculation of the instantaneous power dissipated as eddy current loss, as determined at different stages in the cycle of magnetization, was only one sixth of the corresponding measure of that form of power loss at that same instant.

    Now I say here that I probed all aspects of the problem that I could think of at the time, but I confess, in retrospect, that there was one aspect that I should have thought of but didn’t. It never occurred to me that the heat being generated as loss could regenerate itself as electricity in a way which augments the EMFs driving the eddy currents. Had I thought of that possibility, I would in all probability have dismissed it immediately from my mind, because it would have involved challenging the Second Law of Thermodynamics. However, I am, I believe, now a wiser being and I will here redeem myself by surveying the evidence which supports that contention.

    I cannot claim that the resolution of the mystery of the eddy-current anomaly will save that loss of billions of dollars of electrical power in future transformer design technology. All we can do is to accept the loss, but come to know full well how that loss arises. However, inasmuch as uncovering the secret tells us how to deploy environmental heat to generate electricity, there is promise here of something even more rewarding.

    REGENERATION EFFICIENCY

    To proceed, let us presume that a proportion of the heat generated as magnetization loss does find its way back into electrical power which drives stronger eddy currents and so increases that loss. On this basis we shall consider what clues this offers based on different operating factors, namely different excitation frequency, different ratios of hysteresis and eddy current loss and different flux bias conditions of the transformer core. Then we will compare what the hypothesis tells us and what is actually observed. With the hypothesis fully supported we shall then, after making a few comparisons with Carnot efficiency considerations, move on to explain the physical cause of the phenomenon.

    Note that magnetization loss comprises two components, the hysteresis loss which transformer designers regard as increasing linearly with frequency and eddy-current loss which increases as the square of frequency. Thus, since 60 Hz is the standard power frequency used in USA and 50 Hz is the U.K. power frequency, the eddy-current anomaly is a more serious issue for U.S. power generators. Even so, the research interest in the subject seems to have been essentially a mid-century pursuit in U.K. and if there has been significant interest elsewhere or in more recent times I would appreciate being guided to references to that information.

    Transformers are designed based on an optimum choice of electrical sheet steel. The choice of material determines the hysteresis loss for the standard operating condition of the core, the appropriate maximum magnetic flux range that gives high permeability, and determines the electrical resistivity, which is preferably high and usually some 5 or so times that of pure iron. Given the resistivity, the thickness of the steel laminations is the factor which determines the eddy-current loss for the chosen operating conditions. The smaller that thickness, the less the loss, at least in theory. However, there is the extra cost of the material and assembly if the sheet steel used is too thin and, considered with the hysteresis loss, there is little to be gained in designing for minimal eddy-current loss if that leaves hysteresis as too dominant a component. Accordingly one finds that these two components are much the same at 50 Hz or 60 Hz when electrical sheet steels of the order of 0.3 mm thickness are used.

    Experimentally, one can distinguish between hysteresis loss and eddy current loss by measuring overall magnetization loss at two different frequencies but with the strength of the magnetizing voltage in proportion to assure that the range of flux density is kept the same. One needs to allow for losses arising from current flow through the resistance of the magnetizing winding and exclude these from the measurement. Then, by dividing the rate of loss by frequency, the plot of the increment with frequency, when extrapolated back to the origin gives the hysteresis component and the increment with frequency represents the eddy current component. See Fig. 1.

    Fig. 1 Iron loss in watts per 50 Hz per kilogram

    This figure has a straight line relationship corresponding to the theoretical notion that hysteresis loss per cycle of a.c. oscillation is constant for a given range of magnetization flux change in the iron of the magnetized core, whereas eddy-current loss increases with frequency squared and so the loss per cycle is a linear increase. However, in practice, one finds that the loss per cycle relationship increases as a curved relationship, the rate of rise being far more rapid at lower frequencies and then looking more linear as the frequency reaches 50 Hz, but always exceeding the theoretical eddy-current component by a quite substantial factor.

    To understand this, consider now the situation where, for a given core sample, the hysteresis loss under 50 Hz operating conditions is 1 watt and, in theory, the eddy-current loss is 0.5 watt, whereas in practice the eddy-current loss is actually 1 watt. We can interpret this as meaning that 25% of the heat actually generated has found its back into regenerated electricity which augments the EMF driving the eddy currents. Here the anomaly factor is 2.

    Let us now work out how this would affect tests at 25 Hz, for the same range of the magnetic flux cycle. The hysteresis loss would be 0.5 watt and the theoretical eddy current loss would be 0.125 watt. However, using a little algebra you can work out that the actual eddy current loss would be 0.333 watt, giving an anomaly factor of 2.67. This gives overall heating in the core of 0.833 watt and if 25% of this is regenerated to feed it back as additional eddy current input power this adds 0.208 watt to 0.125 watt to give that 0.333 watt figure. You see, therefore, that the anomaly loss factor has increased as frequency has been reduced. Here is the first point that we can test to see if the regeneration theory holds up.

    Repeat this for 10 Hz conditions, where hysteresis loss is 0.2 watt and eddy current loss is, theoretically, 0.020 watt and one obtains an eddy current anomaly factor of 4.65. To verify this, note that the heat generated in the core is 0.293 watt and 25% of this is 0.073 watt, which together with 0.020 watt is 0.093 watt or 4.65 times 0.20 watt. In reducing the frequency from 50 Hz to 10 Hz the loss anomaly factor has increased from 2.00 to 4.65.

    Next, let us see what happens if we have a core sample in which at 50 Hz the hysteresis loss is as much as four times the theoretical eddy current loss. We are considering here an electrical sheet steel that is magnetized cross-wise to the rolling direction used in its fabrication. This does not take advantage of the optimum magnetic permeability which is higher for magnetization aligned with the direction in which the steel sheet has been rolled during its fabrication.

    This circumstance is a laboratory test situation, rather than one of practical significance to transformer design, but it does have practical significance where steel stampings are used to form rotors and stators of electric motors. Magnetic flux in the stampings used to form such motor components can flow in all directions parallel to the plane of the steel sheet, varying as the motor operates and, of course, there can be a whole spectrum of frequency conditions as the motor speed is varied. Here, we can contemplate very high eddy current anomaly factors. Using a 2 watt figure for hysteresis loss and 0.5 watt for theoretical eddy current loss, if 25% of the heat generated is regenerated as an supplementary electrical input, then the resulting eddy current anomaly factor is 2.67. The reason is that the heat generated is 2.00 watt from hysteresis and 1.33 watts from eddy currents and 25% of 3.33 is 0.83, which together with 0.5, sums to 1.33. In short, that anomaly figure of 2.67, which is quite representative of the Dannatt measurements already mentioned is consistent with observation, even where hysteresis loss is fairly high.

    Note, however, that Dannatt was not making measurements across the grain determined by the rolling direction of the steel and consider what would be the outcome of the latter calculation had two-thirds of the heat energy been regenerated as added eddy current loss. You will see that this implies an eddy current anomaly factor of 11, because a 2 watt hysteresis plus 5.5 watt of eddy current sums to 7.5 watt and if two-thirds of this heat is regenerated this adds 5 watt to the 2.5 watt input to give that 7.5 watt figure. If, therefore, we can show evidence supporting such a high eddy current anomaly factor, then we can infer regeneration of heat as electricity with a 67% efficiency.

    Consider what that would mean, bearing in mind that a transformer core operates at temperatures ranging only over a few per cent as measured on the Kelvin scale. Compared with the Carnot efficiency limit set by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, we would have here a clear breach of that law. We could, if we knew how to exploit the phenomenon, convert heat into electricity and use that electricity, not to drive more eddy currents which waste energy, but rather to power a conventional heat pump working according to Carnot principles. Using only a portion of the electricity generated from heat we could pump heat to the higher temperature needed to set up the temperature gradient which powers that eddy current anomaly in the transformer. We would have the ultimate clean energy source of power. Environmental heat, which exists in abundance, consumed to generate electricity needed to run our machines and light our homes before reverting to heat shed back to the environment. It may seem impossible, but you can be sure that there are surprises ahead in the technology of the future, provided we come to understand how Nature processes energy fed into the magnetic fields which we inhabit as part of our natural environment.

    Now let us suppose we have a way of testing the steel under conditions of very small hysteresis loss. How might this affect the anomaly factor? Logic says that less heat will be generated so that the eddy-current anomaly will not involve more than the feedback from the eddy current heating. That 66.7% feedback figure would indicate an anomaly factor of 3.00, which is in the range measured by Dannatt. However, we can suggest doing eddy current tests over a small range of magnetization but one confined to regions well above the knee of the B-H curve. When iron is magnetized its flux density increases rapidly and somewhat linearly as magnetizing current increases, until a point is reached at the knee of the magnetization curve. Thereafter the rate of increase reduces as it becomes progressively more difficult to increase the polarization. The reason for this is that the iron contains domain regions separated by domain boundary walls. As the walls move they increase the size of one domain and reduce the size of the adjacent domain. These domains are fully magnetized in opposite directions and all we see as net flux in the magnetic core is the difference in the flux contribution of all the domains. However, in the passage of those domain walls across inclusions (impurities) in the iron and in the flipping of the flux direction that occurs as the domains adjust to the change of magnetizing conditions, there are instabilities which we can detect as ‘Barkhausen’ noise. These are the source of hysteresis loss. The loss is a linear function of the number of cycles of magnetization and not a function of how fast we increase the magnetizing current.

    For this reason the hysteresis loss begins to tail off once the cycle of magnetization is biased so as to be confined to regions where those instabilities cease to occur. Above the knee of the magnetization curve flux changes occur in a more controlled way as the magnetization direction in a domain is forced to orientate itself in a direction angularly displaced from the preferred axial direction in the crystal housing the domain. The result is that rotational hysteresis at very high flux density drops to zero. The eddy current anomaly factor should be much reduced, therefore, for tests well above the knee of the magnetization curve, but there is some telling evidence that appears once such tests are performed, as I shall report as we proceed.

    So, we must now pay attention to those numerical factors which are a measure of the eddy current anomaly observed in electrical sheet steels. If the evidence supports what has been said above about the regeneration of heat as electricity then we can hope to move in the direction of that new energy technology.

    THE EVIDENCE

    In a book entitled Principles of Electromagnetism, 3rd Edition, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1955 by E.B. Moullin, the eddy current anomaly is discussed in Appendix II at pp. 285-286. The following is a quotation from that work:

    “It is as though the effective resistivity is about one-third of its true value. Now alloying and impurities always increase the resistivity; one cannot countenance any explanation which depends on the significance of decrease of resistivity. Whatever the cause of the effect may be it is certainly not due to the resistivity being much less than the value measured by a straightforward conductivity test.”

    Here was the verdict of the Professor heading the Department of Electrical Engineering in Cambridge in 1955. I was awarded my Cambridge Ph.D. on the eddy current anomaly in 1954. It had not entered my mind that the resistivity of the electrical sheet steel could be lowered artificially by some means peculiar to the magnetization process or from heat generation, which Professor Moullin could have declared also as something which increases resistivity. So how did Professor Moullin conclude his discourse on the subject?

    He wrote:

    “For some obscure reason the currents must be larger than we have calculated and, in some obscure manner, this must be brought about by the distortion of the wave-form caused by the hysteresis loop. Dr. Brailsford has made an important contribution towards the solution of the problem (see Journal I.E.E., vol. 95, Part II, p. 38; 1948), but the answer is not yet known. We do not propose to discuss here the possible mechanisms for the effect. It will suffice to report its existence to the reader and to impress on him that there is a loss in iron stampings which varies as frequency squared and whose magnitude is some two or three times the legitimate eddy current loss, appropriate to conditions when the effect of imperfect penetration is certainly negligible.”

    I may add here that one of the aspects I had considered in my research was the possibility that the hysteresis loss could increase with frequency squared if the domain switching involved retardation. A time-lag effect in the magnetization process would show itself with much the same signature as an eddy current loss. Also, there was the prospect that the inhomogeneities in the steel attributable to domains having sizes commensurate with the thickness of the laminations could explain some measure of increased eddy current loss. For example, in the extreme case of a single domain boundary wall parallel with the plane of the lamination and located midway across its thickness, the full measure of flux change produced by magnetization would be effective from the central plane and that could even explain that anomaly factor of 3.00. However, such ideal domain structures do not exist in reality, so one must rule out that possibility.

    The only other textbook discussion of the anomaly that has come to my attention is that in a 1966 book by Brailsford who by then had become Professor of Electrical Engineering in the University of London. These were the days, incidentally, when a professor at a British university was normally ‘the professor’, meaning the leading person in the relevant academic discipline. Brailsford’s book was entitled The Principles of Magnetism, published by Van Nostrand, (London, Toronto, New York and Princeton). Professor Brailsford had been one of the External Examiners of my Ph.D. thesis.

    His verdict on the anomaly, as stated in his book, was that ” its origin is a matter of speculation”, a statement made by reference to his paper co-authored with R. Fogg and entitled ‘Anomalous iron losses in cold-reduced, grain-oriented transformer steel’, which appeared in Proc. I.E.E., v. 111, p. 1463 (1964).

    Brailsford’s book, together with my own thesis record, provides the essential evidence I need here to support the case developed above. He refers to an interpretation by E.W. Lee entitled ‘Eddy-current losses in thin ferromagnetic sheets’ which appeared in Proc. I.E.E., v. 105C, p. 337 (1958). Lee had calculated the anomaly factor on the assumption that there were large domains spreading between both faces of the sheet lamination and that the planes of domain walls were at right angles to the sheet surface. Then, according to the ratio of domain width to lamination thickness it could be argued that the eddy current anomaly factor could increase, possibly to value of 10 or so. However, Brailsford dismisses this on page 240 of his book with the words: “It seems difficult to explain the observed results on this basis, for the domain widths would need to be two or more times the sheet thickness to obtain value of anomaly factor greater than 3, say, and the domains do not in fact appear to be as large as this.”

    He then goes on to say: “It is also necessary to explain the increase in anomaly factor with decreasing frequency, particularly for frequencies below about 10 Hz and also the large variation of the factor with direction in the sheet. The loss mechanism operating does not, indeed, appear to be well understood.”

    So one sees that, some 32 years ago, which was then some 11 years on from the date of Professor Moullin’s book, the verdict remained the same. Indeed, the mystery still prevails and awaits solution. However, compare Brailsford’s words with what I deduced above. I offered an explanation of the increased anomaly factor at lower frequency and, using the same argument, I said that magnetization across the grain of the steel could lead to higher hysteresis loss which would produce very much greater anomaly factors. On page 239 of his book Brailsford presented data showing how the anomaly factor in a grain-oriented material varied with direction of magnetization related to the direction in which the steel had been rolled. It was as high as 10 over a full range of flux amplitudes when the angle was 90o. It was between 6 and 8 for angles between 25o and 54o and it was between 3 and 3.5 or so for magnetization along the intended 0o direction.

    So here is the evidence supporting my case that the eddy current anomaly is attributable to an effective reduction of resistivity brought about by heat being regenerated to produce EMFs which augment the current flow. This is effectively an action that reduces resistivity, though in reality the resistivity remains the same and we have heating in full measure along current paths parallel to the lamination surface but very substantial cooling at the seat of the regenerative action, which I see as being traversal flow paths across the thickness of the lamination. I will explain this in detail in the next Chapter of this pursuit TEC IV

    I note that I have, in the above commentary, deliberately not brought to bear the further evidence I can offer from a new analysis of my thesis findings based on the thermoelectric regeneration proposition. I will hope to introduce that evidence as we develop this theme further in these Web pages, but I feel the reader will find more immediate interest in the development of the discussion the TEC IV chapter.


  • LECTURE NO. 17

    LECTURE NO. 17

    THE MAGIC OF MIRRORS

    TEC II

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    Professors will tell you that “In nature heat is never found to flow up a temperature gradient of its own accord”. From this, they and the textbooks on which they rely advance to the statement of a law according to which it is impossible for any machine to abstract heat from the coldest body of its surroundings and convert this into useful work, surplus to that needed to power the machine. The law thus justified is known as “The Second Law of Thermodynamics”.

    If you are a student of physics or engineering you are thereby indoctrinated and become committed to the belief that if someone, in your later life, whether in academia or in industry, comes to you with a bright idea or proposition about designing a machine that does not keep within the bounds of that particular law, then you are justified in giving vent to your scorn and ridiculing that person for being ill-educated.

    So it is that our world, in which we are so anxious to catch a glimpse of a ray of hope that we may one day inhabit a pollution-free environment, is left in darkness, thanks to the ‘good’ education that we physicists and engineers have received in our university years.

    I am now too old to think that I can put right the damage done by all those professors, but I can suggest that any student who listens to such teaching in the future should pay close attention to the argument used. Now read again the opening paragraphs above and ask yourself two questions: “Where in nature does one ever see a ‘machine’, as such?”, and: “What is the point of building a machine, said to be a heat engine, if all it does is to allow heat to flow ‘of its own accord’?” Surely, the very fact that man has intervened by providing a machine which deploys heat energy in some way, is an intrusion upon that territory of something doing something of its own accord!

    Search the whole spectrum of physics and ask yourself whether you see ‘order’ or chaos’ in nature. Surely you can see both. There is ‘order’ in the behaviour of electrons in atoms. There is order in the way atoms fit together in a crystalline structure. There is order provided by the magnetic domain structure inside ferromagnetic materials. All that order is governed by energy finding its optimized state. Seemingly, however, there is disorder in the energy activity we refer to as ‘heat’, and those professors of yours will delight in introducing you to the mysterious word ‘entropy’. They do not know what ‘entropy’ means, other than saying it is the quantity of heat as divided by its temperature and that it can only increase. That is because they have the conviction that heat can only ‘go downhill’ and degrade in quality, meaning that its temperature has to fall inexorably as the heat energy passes on into the oblivion of outer space.

    But suppose there is, in the system we call ‘space’, something that can be said to be a ‘machine’. Then your professors will smile at your suggestion and come back to that Second Law of Thermodynamics. The heat can only go ‘downhill’ in temperature and entropy can only increase!

    It is here that I step in and refer to something of mine that was published in the science journal ‘Nature’, 1990h in these Web pages. In fact, I have already introduced this subject in the first chapter TEC I of the sequence of commentaries I am putting on the Web as my account of ‘Thermodynamic Energy Conversion’. In this Lecture No. 17 I wish to delve into some simple physics, rather than technological detail, just to ease the path for those who are still under the spell of their professorial teachings.

    The Magic of Mirrors

    Imagine that a thin nylon cord supports two metal spheres, each at a different focus of a concave mirror. Now ask yourself whether the temperatures of those two metal spheres must be the same?

    To answer this question refresh your memory of what you may have learnt in your physics lessons. I quote from a 1957 textbook on ‘Geometrical and Physical Optics’ by R.S. Longhurst:

    Suppose there is a source of light inside a sphere then …. (by the analysis here presented …. the flux reflected from each part of the sphere is equally distributed over the other part, or the flux received by an element after reflection at other points is everywhere the same. For a given sphere it can therefore only depend upon the total flux radiated by the enclosed source.

    In your lessons on heat radiation you also learn about black body radiation and how uniformity of temperature prevails within a spherical cavity so that inspection through a small aperture in the cavity allows you to perceive the nature of that ‘black body radiation’. Indeed you are taught that the radiation is very similar to that of a perfect black body at the same temperature as prevails within that spherical cavity. The cavity, moreover, need not be of spherical form, given that equilibrium conditions will prevail anyway and the result of all this is enshrined in what is called The Law of Cavity Radiation.

    So, when you come to answer the above question your instincts should be to say that both metal spheres must be at the same temperature.

    Now consider the two metal spheres as being at the focal points of an ellipsoidal mirror which constitutes that radiation cavity, as depicted in Fig. 1.

    FIG. 1

    Here, if only by an argument based on symmetry, you can assure yourself that the two metal spheres will tend to remain at the same temperature. Now, however, ask yourself what happens if the sphere at A is cooled by some internal means. Will it then merely absorb heat from the cavity surface, whilst the metal sphere at B retains its equilibrium temperature as that prevailing at the cavity surface?

    The answer to this is known from Pictet’s experiment or that of Count Romford, which dates from 1800, as you may see mentioned in the ‘Background of the Invention’ section of my U.S. Patent No. 5,101,632. Metal sphere B will cool down to complement the cooling of metal sphere A.

    Now, although I say the answer is known from such experiments, with regard to the details of such experiments, I only see reference to the use of a concave mirror, so we need to look now at what is shown in Figs. 2 and 3.

    FIG. 2
    FIG. 3

    Here the mirror is not a complete ellipsoid but just a concave portion of such a form. We have asymmetry in the apparatus and, yes, we know from those experiments that, if one of A or B is at a temperature different from the equilibrium temperature of the environmental surroundings, so the other will adjust to a temperature that is also different from the ambient temperature. However, what I now ask is whether, without any predetermination of the temperature of A or B by some special heating or cooling means, A and B will adopt the same temperature under normal conditions of equilibrium?

    You can answer this in two ways. You can declare that according to the Second Law of Thermodynamics the temperatures of A and B must be the same, owing to it being contrary to experience for ‘heat to flow from a cooler body to a warmer body of its own accord’. It must do that if A and B are to adopt different temperatures, given that heat energy is conserved. Alternatively you could say that you do not know the answer to the question but that you surmise that, since in Fig. 2 the portion of the cavity housing surface radiating heat to sphere B is larger than that in Fig. 1 radiating heat to sphere A, it seems likely that B will get hotter than A. You can further argue that if the two spheres have the same size, then more heat will be radiated from A to B than is radiated from B to A. So B should become hotter than A.

    You do this by discussing the role of the mirror in capturing radiation from B over a small solid angle of radiation, and reflecting it to A, whereas, as is evident from Fig. 3, the mirror captures a large solid angle of radiation from A and reflects it to B. Inevitably you should be in a quandary as to whether you can trust that Second Law of Thermodynamics or whether, in fact, if you build such a device and eliminate air convection you will actually witness A and B developing a temperature difference.

    Think about it! Ask yourself what this means. I know myself that, if I can get heat to flow through a thermoelectric device from one metal heat sink to another, then I can generate electricity. However, if I can generate electricity by merely building a thermoelectric device combined with a mirror and without doing anything to feed in any other form of energy, then I have either worked a miracle, performed a feat of magic or, perhaps, found an alternative to imitating one of Mother Nature’s more subtle energy regenerative processes.

    This process does not in any way breach the First Law of Thermodynamics, namely the need to conserve energy, because all it does is to take heat energy from our ambient surroundings and convert it into electricity. Now, and I say this with emphasis, why do we persist in trying to solve our future energy problems by attempting to replicate the imaginary hot fusion processes occurring in the Sun when here we can see a possible way forward using the simple ‘magic of mirrors’?

    In fact, all this amounts to is the harnessing of Maxwell’s Demon, except we do let the mirror perform the task effortlessly. We do not need a demon sitting at the toll gates where passage of heat energy is allowed or not allowed, according a selection of the particles that convey heat. Maxwell’s hypothetical demon opens and shuts a gate, to admit and confine the more energetic particles in one heat chamber, whilst obstructing entry of the least energetic particles and allowing egress from the chamber by the least energetic particles. By the simple labour of opening and shutting a gate, heat is thereby transferred to that chamber to elevate its temperature. However, we use mirrors instead. Energy seeking entry to that chamber is direct to a mirror focus located at the point of entry through a small aperture, whereas energy coming the other way from within the chamber has to find its own way through the small aperture leading through that passage and so has some difficulty escaping, at least until its temperature raises sufficiently to give it the necessary impetus.

    Practical Considerations

    This sounds interesting, doesn’t it, but is it practical? Well it helps if the source of radiation is not simply a black body surface at room temperature, but rather one at an elevated temperature. The practical aspect could well just be one of scale and a consideration of economic factors, weight and volume to power ratio as well as capital cost to power ratio.

    If you think we might never be able to power an automobile by such a method then I will not argue with you on that point. After all, one hundred years ago there were those who could never see technology developing that could power the flight of a Boeing 747. Nor could they imagine the technology that we now see in the fabrication of electronics microstructure in the computer industry. All I can say is that my calculations, as summarized towards the end of that U.S. Patent No. 5,101,632 indicate the prospect of generating 15 kW in a structure the size of a cubic metre. One can, presumably, contemplate the development of automobiles using this new technology, given one hundred years of onward development!

    In such research so much does depends upon how we convert that heat at the elevated temperature into useful work, as by generating electricity. However, I have allowed for that in those calculations and suggested a way forward. There is the question of whether our mirror engine is subject to the Carnot efficiency. In fact, it cannot depend upon the Carnot criteria, because we are not losing any energy. We have no exhaust gases that carry away the degraded heat from which our engine has extracted its power. However, if we use a conventional heat engine, such as a steam engine or hot air engine to convert the heat our mirrors have produced at an elevated temperature then, sadly, we suffer from the Carnot efficiency limitation. What is also sad about this is the fact that we could well be considering using a reverse heat engine to increase the temperature of ambient heat intake as a kind of pre-heat stage in our engine. That offers the advantages of the Carnot criteria as a gain factor of the heat pump process. If only we can convert heat into electricity with an efficiency well in esxcess of the Carnot efficiency, then we can work the necessary miracle!

    The Magic of Magnetism

    Physicists will smile at the above suggestion, thinking, as they do, in terms of photons and such like. They believe that the energy carried by radiation of light and heat is transported by those so-called ‘photons’ which travel at the speed of light. Photons, if they exist as something that really does travel at that high speed, really can give physicists reason for having a headache, if they avoid being blinded by mathematical symbols and try to make sense of this photon notion. There is, for example, something called the ‘Langevin Paradox’. According to one expert on Einstein’s Theory of Relativity, writing as recently as in the September 15 issue of Physics Letters, vol. 234A (1997) pp. 75-85, to get Einstein’s theory to be consistent with photons as carriers of light energy, one needs to say that the photon has a finite mass. Now, Einstein’s theory is sacrosanct, not to the engineer, but to the physicist, so the world of physics must be losing its grip on reality. Can we afford to wait until physicists put their house in order?

    We all know that a particle travelling at the speed of light will acquire infinite mass, at least that is consistent with experiments on electrically charged particles that can be accelerated to speeds close to that of light. That was all known before Einstein tried to build on the fact as support for his theory. However, there is another fact that needs to be remembered, the fact that the Earth’s rotation can be sensed by optical interference techniques using a rotating system of mirrors (The Sagnac Effect). This fact known for most of the 20th century, still has to be reconciled with Einstein’s theory or the idea of photons as particles or both have to be rejected. Take note also that there is evidence that the west-east motion of our laboratories on body Earth can be sensed owing to the fact that it intrudes to upset the precision of measurements of the Michelson-Morley type. The latter is the famous experiment which disproved the notion that the aether had certain properties previously assumed. It did not disprove anything about the ability of the aether to store energy, it being a universal energy ‘bank’ in which we can deposit energy by magnetic induction and recover that energy on demand!

    Surely therefore we need to reconsider the foundations on which physicists rely when they express opinions on fundamental energy issues. Mirrors can reflect light, meaning energy if light transports energy at the speed of light, but it may well be that all that is transported is the ripple we associate with an electromagnetic wave, a ripple of the sea of energy that is everywhere in space. Now, I can deflect a moving electron by using a magnetic field, without injecting energy into the magnet producing that field. I cannot deflect an electromagnetic wave by using a magnet, at least not sufficiently for it to have any practical consequence. I decline to comment on whether a magnet can affect the motion of a photon, for the simple reason that I can only see the ‘photon’ as an ‘event’ that marks an energy-cum-momentum transaction as between aether and matter and events can occur at points A and B without requiring all the energy involved in those transactions to make the journey between A and B at the speed of light.

    Our Thermodynamic Energy Conversion project (TEC) involves us, not with photons, but with energy and temperature and our next task is to examine the physics of converting heat energy into electricity. We are aiming at something close to 100% conversion efficiency, with no Carnot factor to bother us. We cannot talk about photons, because photons do not have a ‘temperature’, even though they are deemed to represent a package of energy relating energy with Planck’s constant, h, times the frequency assigned to the photon.

    The Electron and Maxwell’s Demon

    Imagine that Maxwell demon sitting patiently at a point inside a block of metal. You are sitting outside. You connect that metal in an electrical circuit and you pass current through it. The demon sees electrons migrating past his viewing station as the current flow. Now we do not want our demon to exert himself by opening and closing a gate or shutter, so we have provided a magnet for him to sit upon. The magnet produces a field which acts on the electron and, as we all know from our basic physics education that electron will be deflected sideways. See Fig. 4.

    FIG. 4

    We can now, if we wish draw current from that metal at right angles to its normal flow path. The stronger the magnet and the greater the magnetic field H, the greater the EMF generated in the lateral direction, the electric field E being proportional to H and also to the velocity v of the electron e.

    This process is known in physics as the Hall Effect. There is no conversion of heat into electricity. The energy you supply in getting the electrons to migrate at that velocity v is all deployed in developing that electric field E and powering the current we might draw from the resulting EMF. The magnet does no work. It merely sits there and forces those electrons to change direction. The Hall Effect and the Carnot criteria of thermodynamic engines have no ground in common so beware of becoming confused as we now extend our Fig. 4 deliberations into the realm of heat energy conversion.

    We are only interested in heat and we want to equip our Maxwell demon with a whole assembly of magnets positioned along that electron flow path, having now in mind the fact that the flow of heat in metal is a flow of electrons! Our demon knows only one temperature, that where he sits, and he pays no attention to what physicists living outside that lump of metal might have to say about Carnot efficiency. That is something that depends upon the specific absolute values of two temperatures, whereas our demon knows that all that matters to him is the flow of heat energy carried past his viewing station and that merely depends upon a temperature gradient at his position.

    So those electrons migrating past him as heat are, as before, deflected to set up that transverse electric field, but this time their energy is that of heat and the magnet puts order into things and takes energy from that heat to feed it into the orderly state of an electric field. In short, we have quite efficient conversion of heat into electricity, because what is not converted moves on to be processed by the demon’s assistants further down the line, namely those other magnets.

    If we take electricity as output in that lateral direction, so we have cooled the metal. That is what we require in our mirror engine system. Two metal heat sinks at different temperatures T and T’ powered by mirror magic and linked by a metal path including our Maxwell demon, or rather his magnets. Let us just picture the flow path of electrons that make the lateral detour. This is illustrated in Fig. 5.

    FIG. 5

    When an electron flowing along the metal path is diverted laterally to flow around an external loop circuit which includes a load device (not shown) it returns on the opposite side of the metal to share the heat latent in the metal at that point of return and moves on in the forward direction conveying heat.

    The electron does not need any extra power to re-enter the main path of the metal conductor. Indeed, what has been described is simply the conversion of heat into electricity, an energy conservation process, but one which, thanks to the magnet and the established flow direction of the heat, converts thermal chaos into electrical order. You may ask whether this can really work. More to the point, you may ask what happens to the electrons that reach the end of the main path and what is the source of those that come from the beginning of the main path. Now, there is a mystery! Frankly, I have yet to see this explained in a textbook and I wonder how I have missed it. My textbooks tell me how electrons carry the heat flow but they do not say quite how. One is left to wonder if it is a kind of ‘knock-on’ effect, owing to collisions between faster-moving electrons coming from the left and slower moving electrons coming from the right. In that case, since at any instant the flow rate of electrons to the left must equal the flow rate to the right, given no external closure circuit between the ends as heat sinks, there can be no net field E generated at all!

    So one can say that heat is still carried by electrons in their ‘knock-on’ effects, thanks to a component of motion laterally directed with respect to the magnetic field, but that would mean no overall heat energy-to-electricity conversion. So, is the phenomenon described real? Well it is, because it is known as the Nernst Effect and those EMFs induced by heat flow, given the presence of a mutually orthogonal magnetic field, have been measured. They are particularly high in nickel. It follows, therefore, that our standard assumptions concerning the interaction of a magnetic field and an electron in motion must be erroneous.

    Now, I have long suspected this, because I have wondered why it is that the magnetic field of a permanent magnet can penetrate through a block of copper without the numerous free electrons in motion within that copper reacting to screen such fields virtually in their entirety. My answer, one I adopted long ago, is the following:

    When an electron in motion reacts to a magnetic field it is a quantum event, meaning that maybe it will and maybe it won’t, this being determined by whichever affords the optimum response from an energy equilibrium viewpoint.

    To picture what I mean here, note that an applied magnetic field is an ‘action’ and the response of the electron in that field is a ‘reaction’. If the magnetic field increases then there is more reaction opposing that field, but the reaction must allow the field to assume the level at which it has stored the maximum amount of energy density in the reacting electrons. Remember that kinetic energy absorbs potential energy and, as potential energy minimizes, so kinetic energy increases. The energy density in a magnetic field H is proportional to H2. So, if we are to store such energy density in a system of reacting charge in motion, then we are referring to the component of motion that acts to set up the opposing field. The energy transferred to those charges, whether electrons or not, is a kind of thermal energy and it is pooled with the thermal state of the absorbing medium. It is dispersed as a result, apart from just that amount of energy that is polarized by the need to sustain the field reaction.

    When I worked all this out, back in the mid 1950s, I discovered that what all this meant was that the magnetic field set up by an electron in orbital motion is really double the strength we have assigned to it in our standard electrical theory, but the optimum field reaction of the charge that retains that energy in readiness for its return when the electron’s motion ceases will always set up a back-field halving that primary action. It all made good sense and it explained what is known as the gyromagnetic ratio, the anomalous factor-of-two observed, in the ratio of magnetic moment to angular momentum, when the magnetic polarization of pivotally-mounted ferromagnetic rods is reversed.

    So what I am really saying here is that the Nernst Effect is evidence of the selective or quantized reaction of electrons when subject to a magnetic field. The Lorentz force law, which says how an electron or other charge in motion will react in a magnetic field, is not of universal applicability where the kinetic energy possessed by the reacting charges is so great as to exceed the magnetic energy density of the field in which they are present. There is also, it seems, a kind of pecking order, as between charges of different mass and even between charges of similar mass, such as electrons, if some have more energy than others.

    Now I do not want to dwell on this theme here, especially as it is further complicated by that EMF produced by Nernst Effect having a different polarity coefficient for some metals versus others. So, I will hide behind the facts of experiment and say that the Nernst Effect is a real phenomenon, which is described in some of the better physics textbooks. I will go further than this, as we develop these ‘TEC’ web pages and will describe two different technological consequences, giving technical details of performance of the resulting heat to electricity conversion.

    My concluding message here is that, if you are a physicist or student of physics and you are satisfied with what you have come to know about quantum electrodynamics and the application of the Lorentz force, sufficiently for you to think you can rely on that knowledge when judging the new energy proposals that I am introducing in these Web pages, then you will surely be missing opportunities for making a useful contribution to the energy technology of the future.

    Otherwise, if you wish to learn more, then I invite you to progress to the next item TEC III.


    Harold Aspden

  • LECTURE NO. 16

    LECTURE NO. 16

    50 YEARS AND ON WE GO!

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    INTRODUCTION

    I am, in this Lecture, going to go back more than 50 years to the time when I was a university student and tell you of something that happened in one of our lectures.

    In those days, at least in the British academic system, the title of professor was only bestowed upon someone who was head of a department, so we only had one Professor of Electrical Engineering. By today’s standards, the Senior Lecturer who was addressing us back in that 1947-1948 period would have been a ‘professor’, so I will refer to him by that title.

    The professor was presenting his lecture by writing a very lengthy sequence of mathematical equations on the black board. It was all about electrons and current emission from hot electrodes in vacuum tubes. There were perhaps fifty or so of us students, all trying to make notes, rather frantically, as the professor was rushing through his task. He was either bored with the mundane chore of that effort, perhaps wanting to get back to his research, or he had other personal reasons for his haste, but to be sure I began to feel that none of us were following or understanding what he was scribing on that blackboard.

    Eventually he turned around, looked at us, and I had the impression he was about to pick up his notes and close the lecture early. It was then that I had time to take a longer look at the last equation on that blackboard, the result he set out to prove.

    I then reacted, rather abruptly, to my own surprise, and openly declared that the result could not be correct. The professor was astounded and, consistent with his Germanic background, he reacted. In a rather abrupt and blunt way he began to go through what he had written on that blackboard, line by line, turning around after each recital and, looking directly at me, asked if I agreed with that step.

    I said: “Yes.” Indeed, I said “Yes” time and again until at one point, when the professor, with his back to us, was reading aloud through the next line and for my benefit, he suddenly hesitated. He did not turn around. After a few moments he began altering and correcting the subsequent lines on that blackboard. As he did that, I became conscious of the rising crescendo of stamping feet. My student colleagues were applauding in the time-honoured way. I had, it seems, scored some kind of goal in the great academic game. The professor, after correcting the final formula on that blackboard, did not look up. He said nothing and, with bowed head, picked up his papers and fled, quite evidently in a rare temper.

    I would have expected a professor, faced with such a situation, to contrive to smile, admit the oversight, and then jump on the rest of the students for not staying awake and spotting the flaw earlier, but that was not to be in this instance.

    I did, as did one other colleague in that student assembly, find that, when I graduated a few months later, I was awarded a first class honours degree, but the whole event was a lesson in itself. The lesson, though unintended by the professor, was to be sure that a derived physical formula has a proper balance of its physical dimensions. If you are counting oranges, you cannot mix them up with apples, and count both as equal. They are both items of fruit, but, as I say, ‘if you are counting oranges…’.

    So often there is, by those who try to crack the secrets of Nature, as hidden in the coded messages we receive as numbers, the physical quantities that we measure numerically, a tendency to forget the need to keep a true physical balance. There are certain ‘dimensionless’ physical constants, fundamental constants, such as the fine-structure constant, that are pure numbers, that one being approximately 1/137, but … well, all I can say is “Beware and be sure to avoid being faulted by not keeping a proper dimensional balance.”

    That, as you will see, introduces the subject of this Lecture.

    An Example – 50 years on!

    Well, in later life, I did find, once I started developing my own theory of gravitation, that there were those who expressed interest and then duly gave voice to their own brainchild – their theory of gravitation. I was sent so many and all of these theories suffered from a fundamental flaw that should have made them ‘still-born’.

    Indeed, there was one called ‘The Pushing Theory of Gravitation’, which had many variants. In essence it amounted to saying that there is a neutrino sea, or some such activity, in which all matter is immersed as if in a gas and these ‘neutrinos’ push matter together. When you draw attention to how matter might screen other matter and so destroy the picture that represents in the inverse-square law of force, the response is that the absorption is rather subtle. The neutrinos are only very slightly obstructed in their passage through matter. That, however, is inventing an ‘assumption’ to explain something that is not assumption.

    There was the case, I well recall, where one kind individual sought to convince me that gravity was attributable to the ongoing expansion of things. He was not talking about the post-Big-Bang scenario, but rather the prospect that we are held to body Earth by gravitation because the Earth expands so that its surface accelerates outwards at the rate we call g, some 32 feet per second per second or 981 cm per second per second. That really does pose a curious picture of things, especially if you then wonder how the Moon will appear to grow or shrink in size, as seen from Earth, because there is different g applicable to the Moon.

    Then there are those who see the numbers game as the way forward. Now, let me say here that those numbers, such as the 6.67 that precedes an order of magnitude as a representation of G, the Constant of Gravitation, are clues which point the way forward. If your own pet theory of gravitation tells you that G is some other number, then you know you are wrong, but, conversely, if your theory gives this very number, it does not mean you are right.

    So much depends upon the method being inherently self-consistent and consistent with other physical processes as well.

    Now, what causes me to be writing this at this time? Well, I am writing this on March 26, 1998, when I should be busy on other important matters, but it was late yesterday, March 25th, that I received a fax message from M. Zaman Akil of 49-50 Prince Albert Road in London. It was accompanied by a copy of a paper that he had had published in Apeiron, No. 12, Winter 1992. Its title was ‘On the Constant of Gravitation’.

    Akil was obviously concerned that his theory had been ignored. The preamble to the paper, a Note by Jean-Claude Pecker of the College de France in Paris, seemed to support Akil’s case, whilst observing that members of the Academy of Sciences were unwilling to accept Akil’s efforts to ‘equate a dimensionless quantity to a physical quantity’. On scrutiny the paper presents an equation connecting G with the inverse of a product of two expressions, one involving the proton-electron mass ratio, the other involving the muon-electron mass ratio, and both involving the factor 2π, G being in cgs units.

    The value of G provided by this arbitrary formula was, indeed, remarkably close to the measured value of G, but the physical dimensions did not balance. Therefore, there is no way that the formula can have any meaning whatsoever. Yet I can understand that, having discovered such an appealing numerical relationship, it is very hard to let go. Akil argues in favour of a new system of ‘natural units’ which would aim at a force-fit of the result in a proper dimensional balance, but that is a futile pursuit.

    I have my own way of explaining G and deriving a value for G that does involve certain mass ratios and, indeed, involves the muon and the proton in developing those ratios, notably for the ratio of the mass of something I call the ‘graviton’ relative to the mass of the electron. To me, the electron, the muon, the tau (or taon) and the graviton are all leptons on a rising mass scale and it was interesting to read Akil’s last sentence in his article:

    A number of investigators had already expected the proton to play such a part (meaning a role in a formula for G): but why the muon and not, say, a taon? This intriguing question certainly merits further investigation.

    Conclusion

    The point I make here is that I am not alone in the quest to present a theory of gravitation which allows G to be formulated and derived as a numerical quantity. Because I am not alone, but one of many, all claiming to have the right answer, and because ‘par for the course’, if this were a game of golf, would involve everyone normally falling into a hole, owing to a false assumption, then the assumption is that we are all trying to achieve the impossible.

    However, what can one do, other than seek to convince that one does have the right answer? At this time, March 26th, I am about to wave a flag to get the world to pay attention. My ‘flag’ is really a ‘spoof’, a ruse to get people to look at my Web pages, because on April 1, for one day, I will assert that I have discovered the long-sought proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem, achieved virtually by a few notes on the back-of-an envelope. Fermat, the great French mathematician, has been suspected of leading us astray by saying a simple proof did exist. Hopefully one day a simple proof will be discovered. However, Fermat’s Last Theorem is a problem that is purely numerical and devoid of physical dimensions, so one cannot go wrong on that score. However, though I cannot claim a solution to the theorem that the great minds of science could not solve in 360 years; but yet I do claim what is, I believe, a greater achievement, the solution of the problem of gravity. I promise you that it is not just a numbers game, the rules of physics are involved in the play!

    The derivation of my formula for G is to be found in these Web pages at:

    and my ‘spoof’ of Fermat’s Last Theorem, which I shall keep on these Web pages in order to preserve the argument presented here, is accessed by pressing:

    Fermat’s Last Theorem (not preserved)

    Harold Aspden
  • ENERGY FROM FUSION

    ENERGY FROM FUSION

    The Opinion of a Patent Attorney

    Copyright © 1998 Harold Aspden

    We are at War! Washington is involved. It is a fight between David and Goliath, Goliath being armed with the power vested in the United States Patent Office. I am one of those who ranks as a mere ‘David’, my weapon being my experience as a European Patent Attorney having scientific and technical qualifications. I seek to report here, in a somewhat anecdotal style, the story of the war as seen from my perspective. How the war will end, I do not know, but the outcome is important. The global problems on the energy front affect us all. Here is a war that can end by bringing happiness, prosperity and security on the energy front or end by leaving us to the mercy of the forces of pollution. At this time the United States administration is waging battle on the wrong side of this contest. It is important that this situation should be brought to the attention of the world at large.

    I note here that, in writing these Web pages, I have no personal ‘axe to grind’. I am 70 years of age and fully retired. All I seek is the satisfaction of knowing that I have tried to help the world by casting light on a few of the mysteries that pervade the sector of science with which I am familiar. I will be rewarded if I see that others come to understand the rudiments, if not the detail, of what I am saying, because, in the long term, the battle must be won even though it will take an army of like-minded souls. Once it is won the world will see at the edge of the battleground the path leading to an understanding of Creation, meaning how the building blocks of all matter in the universe emerge from the energy field in which we are immersed.


    Introduction

    It was in 1950 that my post-graduate training in a U.K. major engineering company took me, at my request, for a period into that company’s Patent Department. I had an aptitude for research and wanted to learn something about the protection of inventions. To become professionally qualified in the patent field and also venture on a three-year research project to earn a Cambridge Ph.D. degree would take six years. I decided to work for both and later decide which career path, patents or research, I would follow. In the event I earned my income as a patent professional, pursued my research as a theoretical physicist as a hobby, and eventually took early retirement to concentrate wholly on my academic research, my interest being in anomalous energy phenomena.

    I became IBM’s Director of European Patent Operations. I represented the International Chamber of Commerce at international meetings concerned with intellectual property matters and was, for two years, President of the Trademarks, Patents and Designs Federation in U.K. In short, I seek by this introduction to explain why I feel competent enough to express an opinion on the ‘war’ picture I now see when looking in the direction of the Examining Group of Art Unit No. 2204 in the United States Patent Office.

    I well recall that when, many years ago, the British Patent Office decided to adopt a new posture concerning what was or was not patentable in the computer field, they circulated a notification, stating their intentions and inviting comment. I am not aware that the U.S. Patent Office has done that in respect of their decision to obstruct the grant of any patents that purport to depend upon ‘cold fusion’.

    It is generally understood in patent practice that novel ideas relating, for example, to methods of accountancy are not patentable and, as computer software developed, especially in connection with banking and commerce, we were content to accept that computer programs, as such, were not patentable. It was British Petroleum in U.K. who rocked the boat one day by urging the British Patent Office to grant them a patent on linear programming. In the analysis of data gained from surveying for oil and gas reserves they had to compute optimum solutions to a plurality of mathematical equations. Could a computer program for solving mathematical equations be patented or not? The issue was important. IBM had not filed for patents on computer programs.

    This, as I saw it, was not so much a matter of corporate policy, but one of practicality. Yes, we could write patent specifications on computer programs but there is a reverse side to that coin. A patent ends with a set of claims which define a monopoly. It would be the task of the patent attorneys who reported to me to scan all such patents that might be granted and determine whether or not any of our computer programs came within the scope of any of those claims. Now, with an engineered product or a chemical process or a duly formulated chemical composition, there is a clear ‘something’ one can grasp mentally to classify and search. How could one be expected to check each line of code in a computer program, especially one subjected to repeated updates, and compare its content with the purported cover of the numerous claims that would emerge in patents if computer programs were patentable? In the end the task would itself need to be computerized and that would only be feasible if what one was seeking was proof of copying. In a court action concerning patents, the evidence is not concerned exclusively with copying, but with whether what the alleged infringer has done comes within the strict terms of the patent claims and whether those claims are in fact valid. Computers cannot make such judgements. If they could then one could eliminate the need for judge and jury when engaging in litigation, even in cases concerned with more general subject matter, and we are still some way off seeing that in prospect.

    It was for that reason that we urged revision of copyright law to extend to computer programs and argued against the formal recognition that patents could be granted for computer programs, as such. IBM made an offer to the British Patent Office to supply them with a copy of every IBM program for use in their patent searching, well knowing that the offer was unlikely to be accepted. Our posture was: ‘If you grant patents on something, you must first search the prior art.’ In the event, the offer was declined and the ongoing revisions of Patent law as well as the eventual European Patent Law and international arrangements took care of the problem.

    To the lay person the issue can be expressed in a simple way. If you write a novel with an ingenious plot, you get copyright protection for your work. Whether you get protection for the plot alone is also a question of interpreting the extent to which it is copied, meaning it is a matter of copyright law. You would not dream of filing a patent to cover the plot of your book, nor would the patent system grant you such protection. However, where there is technology involved and an industrial process or manufactured product, then patents are there to serve the inventor and those who sponsor the inventor.

    An invention that presents us with a new way of generating power by deploying energy in some special way is, beyond any doubt, proper subject matter for an invention. So, if the United States Patent Office has decided on a policy of refusing the grant of such patents, where they conflict with the commercial interests of those trying to get ‘hot fusion’ inventions to work, then the administration concerned should review their international treaty obligations besides inviting public comment. Indeed, if I were still to hold the voluntary position I once held as Rapporteur in the Intellectual Property section of the International Chamber of Commerce, I would be recommending overtures to the United Nations arm, the World Intellectual Property Organization, to get the United States to explain its action. The United States Patent Office should not be examining and processing patent applications through the Geneva service of the Patent Cooperation Treaty and then declaring to the applicant who seeks a U.S. patent on that same application that the invention is in a category not deemed patentable! The tactics used lack integrity in that they fall short of making such a ‘declaration’ and are those of a ‘war of attrition’ aimed at driving the applicant to despair – but I will come to tell the story about that later in these Web pages.

    A Wartime Secret?

    Above I mentioned that in 1950 I spent a period in London in a corporate patent department. Indeed, I kept my contacts with that department through my Ph.D. research years at Cambridge and earned a little money working for them during some of my vacations. In this way I ‘clocked-up’ several months of tutored training which made it possible to take my eventual patent examinations earlier than I could otherwise. It saved me a precious year.

    Reminiscing a little about the previous 10 years, much of which I had spent at school, I found that my ‘tutor’ had been called up for service in World War II and, upon being asked about his aptitudes and inclinations, he had not stressed his expert knowledge at assessing and dealing with inventions. Instead, he had merely revealed his interest in his ‘hobby’, the mechanics of the motor vehicle. He was accordingly assigned to the army as a driver of a truck. When later on leave at Christmas time, by tradition, he took his wife to a dinner dance attended by many of his colleagues in the patent profession to find, to his wife’s dismay, that those of his colleagues who had joined the armed services had officer rank. His wife was adamant and took it upon herself to complain to officialdom that her husband’s skills were being wasted as a truck driver. The result was that he was transferred to a Whitehall government office and given the task of evaluating some of the wartime invention proposals that were coming through the system. So it was, as he told me about his experiences, that one submission he received proffered advise on how to win the war against the U-boat menace. The idea was quite simple. Drop something in the sea close to a U-boat, something that can boil the water surrounding it and so kill the crew inside. The question of what to drop in the ocean was left for the scientific experts to work out. In retrospect one can see that nothing short of an atom bomb would suffice in such a venture, but the point is made. There are crazy inventions, but not all, seemingly crazy, inventions that involve heat and water can be dismissed so easily. You see, we really have to face up to a similar situation where the invention is genuine but where we confront the ‘war in peace time’ issue of ‘cold fusion’.

    After the World War II my ‘tutor’ in patent practice, whose initials were W.A.R., returned to English Electric Company and, four or so years later, I joined him in their Patent Department. I eventually became fully qualified in the patent professional field and had my Ph.D. and then one day I had a briefing from a senior engineer who told me about the company’s interest in a project aimed at generating energy from fusion. There was reference to the ZETA project and how it had proved difficult to stabilize the pulsed electric current discharge that was supposed to pinch electrodynamically – enough to set up temperatures that could promote nuclear fusion.

    My Ph.D. concerned magnetism, particularly electromagnetic induction, so I was particularly interested in what I heard. The message was that the whole project had been kept under secrecy but that all efforts to trigger fusion had failed and those researching the subject had run out of ideas. They were releasing information about ZETA hoping that the scientific community at large might have something to add by way of inspiration. Here, then, was a verdict, as long ago as 1958, on the fate of ‘hot fusion’. It was not a viable pursuit and those closely involved in the project were on the verge of surrender.

    A little common sense is enough to assure us that, if it takes a temperature of 100,000,000 degrees or so to trigger the fusion reaction, then the chances of containing something transiently developing such temperatures in a commercial environment are beyond contemplation. A fleeting explosion and a momentary reaction are a long way away from a ‘hot fusion’ reactor technology. Evenso, I devised my own scheme for an apparatus which should have contained that discharge, had the laws of physics been obeyed by the ions involved in the discharge. English Electric Company did secure a patent on my invention, but the specific form of apparatus I proposed was never, so far as I know, put to the test.

    Undoubtedly, however, the standard laws of physics fail where heavy ions, such as protons or deuterons, constitute the discharge and those who examine patent applications tend only to allow the grant of patents for inventions which are not in breach of the well-established laws of physics. Given that so many scientists would say that the laws of electrodynamics are ‘well-established’, whereas I can point to clear experimental evidence that does not comply with those laws, I have not hesitated to debate the issue where appropriate and with success. However, I had not realised that one day I would be destined to encounter a U.S. patent examiner who could dictate his own laws as to whether or not something in science is or is not possible. By his dictates, ‘hot fusion’ is possible, ‘cold fusion’ is not possible. The sun is a ‘hot fusion’ source of energy. The hydrogen bomb is a fusion device. The endeavour to build a fusion reactor has his blessing, although that technology is getting to be prehistoric so far as having any patent relevance. Those who fund ‘hot fusion’, government organizations, do not need patents anyway.

    My story will develop and come to that U.S. patent examiner topic in due course. In the meantime let us think back in time and suppose that nuclear fission power had not proved itself to be a contender on the energy scene and suppose that the prospect of ‘cold fusion’ as a source of heat had become an option. Surely it would have been researched with vigour, backed by government funding, and surely the question of its operability as a viable source of power would have been settled. The funds involved would have been miniscule compared with what was to be wasted on ‘hot fusion’ research.

    Of course, you will say that ‘cold fusion’ was not on the table as a proposal, so it was not an option one could think about. Well, be that as it may, I remember, all those years ago, the efforts of a man named Bruce, who was with ERA (Electrical Research Association) in U.K. He was concerned with electrical discharge phenomena and he argued, from his knowledge of radiation from arc discharges in comparison with the available evidence from solar radiation, that the sun’s temperature was attributable to the same phenomena that accompanies electrical discharges. The scientific question became one of understanding how the electric potentials are set up at the solar surface and not one of just assuming ‘hot fusion’. We are talking about something that occurs at, say, 6,000 K and not 100,000,000 degrees of temperature. We are talking about ‘cold fusion’, if we use the word ‘cold’ as a relative term, ‘hot’ meaning millions of degrees.

    If I remember correctly, Bruce pointed to the fact that sun spots, which are blemishes inside the outer surface of the sun, are cooler than that outer region, the latter being a region of continuous electric discharge – perpetual lightning!

    If Bruce was right, then the source of the sun’s heat could be something other than attributable to the fusion of hydrogen nuclei or their derivatives. So, I ask, can we be 100% sure that the centre of the sun is at 100,000,000 or so degrees? After all, we can only see its surface and 6,000 degrees is what we see!

    I have referred to Bruce in my book ‘Modern Aether Science’. On page 13 of that work I quote a commentary on that subject by Sir Basil Schonland taken from his 1964 book ‘The Flight of the Thunderbolts’. A short extract from that quotation is the statement:

    Many hot stars, including our sun, emit radio waves of high frequency which penetrate our ionosphere; their sources are hot plasma in stellar magnetic fields and hardly qualifying for description as thunderstorms. But whether any of the dying stars have relatively cold atmospheres in which thunderstorms could be created is an interesting speculation. Bruce has developed ingenious theories. It is too early to form judgment on his many remarkable proposals.

    Here is one of those examples of an ‘expert’ making assumptions, albeit popular assumptions, and telling another ‘expert’ that his unorthodox opinion is wrong. Of course there is no mechanism in the solar atmosphere that can replicate that involved in creating thunderclouds and thunderstorms, but lightning is really nothing other than an electrical discharge set up by an electric field. The radiation from Sun to Earth is absorbed by electrons in the Earth’s surface and atmosphere and that initiates those electric fields here on Earth. The radiation reaction can do the same at the solar surface and, in addition to that, that hot solar plasma acted on by gravity can assert a preferential pull on the proton ions in relation to the electron ions. There will inevitably be a concentration of positive charge within the body of the sun, enough to set up those electric fields which sustain those ‘lightning’ discharges that Bruce mentions.

    That core charge will prevent gravity from compressing the plasma inside the sun beyond the point where more than a very small proportion of the hydrogen atoms present becomes non-ionized. That will keep the solar core at temperatures commensurate with those observed at the solar surface. Therefore, ‘hot fusion’ as the source of solar heat is not a viable proposition. It defies the standard and well accepted principles that I have come to accept from my physics education. I believe Bruce, the expert on lightning phenomena, was guiding us in the right direction. Certainly, if it was ‘too early to form a judgment’ thirty and more years ago, as Schonland then declared, then when can we expect that day of judgment? Why not now? How can the solar plasma ever allow the mutual gravitation of free proton ions to overwhelm the positive charge thereby induced? Keep in mind that two protons attract gravitationally with 1836 times the force per unit of mass acted upon when compared with the gravitational action between two electrons. To get balance in a true hydrogen plasma, meaning a ‘soup’ comprising only free protons and free electrons, there has to be a preponderance of protons, enough to set up a positive electric potential exactly balancing the negative gravitational potential. The sun must have a positive core charge! It can sustain continuous activity in the form of electrical discharges of the kind we associate with lightning. If it involves a nuclear fusion process, then ‘cold fusion’, albeit in the 6,000 K temperature region, is the fusion process we should be contemplating – not hot fusion!

    A Question for a Nuclear Expert

    Imagine you are an expert, a noted authority on nuclear physics. Imagine that you are called upon to advise the President of the United States. The subject is ‘cold fusion’. Now imagine that the President is not just a politician, but that he has a fair knowledge of physics, dating from his years at college and university. You begin by briefing the President on your own special background and then outline briefly the situation with respect to cold fusion. Then you declare your overall opinion that whatever accounts for the excess heat, if any is really generated, cannot be due to nuclear fusion – but it must be investigated.

    You think that is the final conclusion to what you need to say in proffering your advice. You instill bias into the picture, backing the venture as a loser, but cover your risk by saying that the claim should be investigated.

    However, the President asks a question, the kind of question that any reasonable person having a moderate knowledge of physics might put. The question is: “If you take a bottle full of pure H2O, meaning that its natural deuterium oxide content as been substantially depleted, and leave it on the shelf for a period of time, will it, ever so gradually, convert in part to deuterium oxide so as to recover the natural relative abundance state?”

    You see, one can buy, from chemical suppliers, deuterium-depleted water, typically having only 1% of the normal content of heavy water. I see from my 1967 edition of ‘Handbook of Physics’ edited by Condon and Odishaw (publishers McGraw-Hill) that the natural abundance ratio as between atoms of H2 and H1 is 1492 to 10 million, so I assume that there is a way of measuring that ratio. If one buys that depleted water it will arrive in your hands with about 1492 molecules of heavy water amongst every billion such molecules of water, light or heavy.

    So the President wants to know whether that bottle of water will witness a gradual adjustment of that abundance ratio as it creeps up in increments to increase one hundred-fold to become normal water. A simple question deserving a simple answer. A special commodity is involved, but it is only water! It is on the market. Does it have a ‘shelf life?’ and if so ‘what is the measure of its half-life?’

    Now I have cast you, the reader, as an expert and assume that you would not have read this far if you could not understand the significance of my question. The President is looking at you. What is your answer? You are an expert on nuclear physics and here is the most basic of all practical questions that could be put to you!

    You play safe. Maybe you do not have the answer. You cannot admit you do not know? That is tantamount to saying that the question of ‘cold fusion’ is a wide open question on which you, as an expert, are supposed to have an opinion. If you took that stance the President would move in for the kill throw you out. So you have only one course of action. You declare that the water in the bottle will never undergo change to become normal water. You know you are an expert but can you back that statement up by saying that experiments by Dr. X on water monitored for a period of Y years showed not the slightest trace of any increase in deuterium content, at least with specific limits of measurement error?

    You have given an ‘opinion’ that there is nothing in the ‘cold fusion’ claim, but the President has his doubts. He has the sense to realise that it would not cost much to fund a test involving monitoring a tank of deuterium-depleted water to see if it shows any sign of adjusting to the normal state of normal water. He wonders how water created from protons ever became contaminated with heavy water involving deuterons. However, he has other more pressing concerns and he sends you on your way, duly thanking you for your advice.

    Now you begin to think. After all, you are an ‘expert’ on nuclear fusion’. You reason that if two protons are somehow fusing to create a deuteron then there will be heat generated. Therefore the rate of heat generation will be a measure of the rate of transmutation involved. We do not need to monitor the composition, because there should be a temperature differential. That water in the bottle must be hotter than its environment, if nuclear fusion is occurring and it must occur if H20 changes to HDO or D20, D being the sybol for deuterium otherwise represented as H2. Add a satellite electron and you still get what, chemically, is a hydrogen atom, but the atom has a deuteron as nucleus instead of a proton. The proton and the deuteron each have the same unitary charge, both being positive and either being able to neutralize the negative charge of the electron. That is basic physics, of the kind also involved in physical chemistry. However, our ‘expert’ needs to estimate that temperature to see if we can expect it to be measurable.

    So he now sets about convincing himself that there simply can be no fusion process to worry about. If there is conversion from light water to heavy water by natural processes that conversion must be very slow, otherwise the oceans would be mainly composed of heavy water, and the oceans have been around for quite a long time. A little mental calculation than suggests that the rate of heat generated by fusion of protons to form deuterons would be so minute as to have no commercial significance. The advice to the President was therefore quite sound. Our expert can sleep in contentment.

    However, the President, meanwhile, has found a new way of enhancing his slumbers. Instead of counting sheep he has found that all he has to do is to picture hydrogen atoms trying to combine to form deuterons. Eventually, his mind wanders onto the thought of how two positively charged protons can fuse to create a deuteron having a single positive charge. Eureka! There has to be an inflow of negative electrical charge to permit such a fusion reaction. No input of electricity means no cold fusion. He has answered his own question. Do you remember the question?:

    “If you take a bottle full of pure H2O, meaning that its natural deuterium oxide content as been substantially depleted, and leave it on the shelf for a period of time, will it, ever so gradually, convert in part to deuterium oxide so as to recover the natural relative abundance state?”

    The conversion can only occur if electricity can get into the bottle and that needs some wires and an electrode system unless the bottle is electrically conductive and the atmosphere is well stocked with ions. ‘Cold fusion’, if that means expedited fusion of the hydrogen isotopes in water, therefore goes hand in hand with wires and electrodes. That seems to make some sense of what the ‘crank’ researchers are claiming! However, the ‘expert’ opinion said there could be no fusion involved in the laboratory-temperature experiments involving water. ‘Expert’ opinion must be respected and, after all, if ‘cold fusion’ were to be a viable technology it would have been discovered in the 19th century and the oceans are not seas of heavy water! Indeed, how would that electricity, essential to feed the proton fusion process, get into the sea? Ever heard of lightning, Mr. President?

    Now cast yourself as ‘Expert No. 2’. You see things a little differently. Water comprises molecules. Molecules involve atoms. Atoms have nuclei surrounded by electrons. The hydrogen atom, whether nucleated by a proton or a deuteron, has a satellite electron. It is a bodyguard running around the nucleus keeping all intruders at bay. As long as it is there no two atomic nuclei can ever come together and, even if they could they have positive charges which repel one another, so there is no chance that water can be involved in a nuclear fusion process. To get fusion one has to remove those electrons and bring the temperature up to the point where the protons and deuterons are dashing around at such enormous speeds that they can collide with one another in spite of the braking action of those repulsive forces.

    It may be true that the electrons can be stripped off at room temperature if the hydrogen atoms are absorbed into the body of a metal electrode, something that is a feature of the alleged ‘cold fusion’ experiments, but surely those protons and deuterons inside that host metal electrode cannot move at anything like the speed needed to collide and fuse. Obviously ‘cold fusion’ is a ridiculous proposition!

    And so it is that ‘experts’ will agree that the claims concerning ‘cold fusion’ are false. The President has been well advised.

    Gremlins in the White House?

    I am not at all sure what is meant by the word ‘gremlin’. It is not in my Concise Oxford Dictionary, but that bears the date 1939. Anyway, as far as I am concerned, it is as good a word as any for describing something that is appears sporadically, enough to ‘rock the boat’, as it were, but never for long enough for us to grab hold of it. Now ‘expert’ scientists will tell you that gremlins do not exist, and there may be the odd ‘crank’ pseudo-scientist who might picture them as some kind of ghost-like alien creature having eyes, ears and even the odd antenna. The gremlin I have in mind is something that appears momentarily as a ‘proton’ and then vanishes immediately with the result that our genuine scientists missed seeing it.

    You cannot say I am talking nonsense, because, when it comes to protons, you, however expert you are, have no idea where protons came from. You can pretend you know by saying they are formed from quarks, but where do quarks come from? Pretend again and think of gremlins. Say that the gremlin is a ‘virtual proton’ or a ‘virtual anti-proton’, just as you can imagine ‘virtual electrons’ and ‘virtual positrons’. They are all members of the gremlin family. They appear and vanish everywhere where energy abounds, even in what we think of as empty space, because they are the life’s blood of quantum electrodynamics, or, concerning protons, quantum chromodynamics. Scientists do have a way of inventing words to describe and classify what they cannot understand. Let us just use that word ‘gremlin’.

    Now those ‘experts’ who advise on matters scientific do not have nightmares, because nightmares involve imagination and fantasies that can involve ghostly phenomena. Experts deal in facts. They have no time to waste and no tolerance when they hear reports on strange phenomena which trespass into their territory but are not an accepted feature of their the stock of factual knowledge that they share with their peers. However, the President of the United States surely is entitled to have the odd nightmare, given the weight of his responsibilities and his problem in balancing fact and uncertainty in making his administrative decisions. So, given that gremlins are everywhere, they must have a presence in White House.

    So, our fictitious image of the President, allows us to imagine that his slumbers are interrupted by a dream in which those gremlin protons appear in that bottle of deuteron-depleted water. His nightmare dream assures him that all protons are clones of one another. So if God ordains that a proton should appear at point A and promptly vanish from the scene, but is satisfied if an existing clone very close to A vanishes instead, then we can have our gremlins being rather peevish and moving the property inside the White House around. This does not take the form of a rearrangement of the furniture, but a slight repositioning of the protons in the cells or molecules that constitute the substance or fabric of that furniture or the body tissue of the human form. In short, if there are gremlins at work, then there is scope for a proton at A to find itself in the arms of a gremlin proton that has appeared as if from nowhere and, with God demanding retribution, an isolated proton very close at B is sacrificed and swept away to that background underworld sea of energy that pervades space. Is this really a dream? It could be a ‘cool reality’ and we would only see a trace of what has happened if the protons in the water molecule change into deuterons. In short, if light water converts into heavy water by some natural process, we can blame it on those gremlins.

    ‘Nonsense’, you say, ‘It is all a dream’. So let us now look for those gremlins in the sea. If they can, so to speak, rearrange the furniture in the sea and create heavy water from light water, then why cannot they move the furniture around some more and convert heavy water into light water? Have we done any experiment, watching heavy water, to see if, slowly but surely, it converts into light water? Would you think it absurd if I suggested that the the process can work both ways? All it means is that, a bottle of deuterium-depleted water will slowly become a bottle of normal water and a bottle of heavy water will slowly become a bottle of normal water, whereas in normal water or in sea water, there is equilibrium between the two transmutation processes.

    Clearly those wires and electrodes, if present and energized electrically, will speed up the tranformations by supplying or extracting the needed electrical charge, but no such provision is needed for the equilibrium condition.

    Now, about now you will be telling yourself that anyone can ramble on like this, without saying anything that is meaningful or helpful. Therefore, I face the task of convincing you. Well, where would you like me to begin? Suppose I can show how protons are actually created and prove it by deducing the precise proton-electron mass ratio, meaning its value to the measured accuracy of a part or so in ten million. Suppose, further, that I can show you how to work out the equilibrium ratio in normal water, as between H2O and D2O and show that it is the same as that measured. I can do both and, indeed, in these Web pages I will do both, but will you then believe in those gremlins?

    Don’t you want to understand how the universe was created? All I have said is that our environment contains a sea of energy which is trying to materialize and does so very transiently by creating gremlins. There is, it seems, an equilibrium limit on how many of those gremlins can stay with us as the matter form – as protons and electrons. I admit that I have not seen a way of determining what governs that state of equilibrium but do appreciate that, in science, we can only proceed step by step. The next step that I hope to see is the acceptance of ‘cold fusion’ as a new technological source of energy. That will mean that we have got those gremlins working for us just as Clerk Maxwell said his ‘demon’ might serve us in generating heat by astute manipulation of a kind of valve separating two gas-filled compartments. It is all about interfering with the state of equibibrium as between two states of a physical system.

    Option Time

    At this juncture you, the reader, have a choice. You may, of course, transfer your interest away from these Web pages of mine or you may stay with my discourse. In the latter case, you might like to digress with me as I tell you something interesting about the Maxwell demon, something you cannot read elsewhere. Or you might like to delve deeply into that proton creation theme I have just mentioned. Instead, you might wish to go directly to the section of these Web pages where I show how Nature determines that ratio or relative proportion of light and heavy water. If cold fusion is your primary concern, in an academic sense – meaning theoretical physics, then that is the track to follow. It will lead you first into an interesting scenario but the onward journey gets a little demanding and involves a few formulae. However, halfway along that journey you will have another chance to break away and divert your attentions, always, however, being guided to the ultimate destination. If cold fusion is your primary concern, in a general or technological and commercial sense, then you may wish to be briefed on the tactics of battle, as being fought by the U.S. Patent Office. In the end, however, this Web page sequence of presentation will converge in technological terms on the ultimate source of energy that will provide power for future generations and with it will emerge a wholesome picture of Creation that avoids the warped notions of those living in a virtual image of multi-dimensioned space-time. Do remember that those gremlins I mentioned constitute more that 99.9% of your body mass. You are composed of virtually nothing but protons put together in a myriad of ways and held in place by the activity and the intervention of electrons. If your teaching has led you to believe that nearly half of your body weight is constituted by neutrons, then you need to worry a little as you try to figure how you can survive, given that neutrons have a decay lifetime that is little more than a quarter of an hour. You can escape that worry if you believe in gremlins! On the other hand, if you want to know the real truth about neutrons, take the first option listed below. Another option is to go back to the main Index page and to make your choice. My advice? Explore all options, but be a little patient. I am getting this material onto the Web as fast as I know how. It will be loaded progressively and quite soon.

    The choices are:

    Protons, Deuterons and Neutrons
    Cold Fusion: My Story: Part I
    The Maxwell Demon: A 21st Century Prospect
    Cold Fusion Index


    Post Script: I do emphasize that there is no way whatsoever for energy science to advance within the framework of our immediate environment unless we come to terms with that mysterious something that sits with us here and now and shares our environment. That something is the ‘hammering we are taking’ as the field energy in space tries to materialize in and around us. We are not alone, but we are in a state of equilibrium, though one could say that human decay and old age owes something to the transmutations produced by that ‘hammering’. We march towards our ultimate destiny living in that sea of energy. All I am saying is: “Recognize that it exists and seek to take advantage of it, whether directly, as in a ‘cold fusion’ reactor or, indirectly, by more subtle techniques exploiting its quantum characteristics.” The latter are revealed in certain types of electric plasma discharges and ferromagnetic processes. If you prefer to march on, simply accepting the laws of physics, which do not recognize that energy underworld and are devoid of hope, then you are depriving future generations the benefit they can derive from today’s research. If you do not believe that there is scope for such a source of alternative energy, then stand back from the field of battle and do not obstruct the fight you will witness from the volunteer forces who carry the flag. For one side, it is a fight to the death, because to win is to die, early death by energy pollution, a death to be shared by all who just stand and watch. Just hope that the contender side where my flag can be seen will prove to be the winner!

    Harold Aspden
    March 15, 1998


  • Cold Fusion: A War Story

    Cold Fusion: A War Story

    My Personal Encounter

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    Introduction

    I will begin this sorry tale by reminding you that in March 1989 two professors, Martin Fleischmann of the University of Southampton in England and Stanley Pons of the University of Utah, stunned the nuclear world by revealing experimental data which indicated that what seemed to be a nuclear fusion reaction involving hydrogen isotopes could generate otherwise unaccountable amounts of heat by an electrochemical process operating at room temperature.

    Nearly nine years later one has now to face the bewildering conflict of two basic facts:

    Fact No. 1: From April 19-24, 1998 a conference named ‘ICCF-7’ is to be held in Vancouver. It is the seventh of a series of well-attended international conferences, billed as “The Best Ever” and it will bring together hundreds of scientists whose experiments provide supporting evidence to show that cold fusion is a technological reality, that the rival ‘hot fusion’ factions cannot ignore.

    Fact No. 2: As one can read in the October 1997 issue of New Energy News:

    TERMINATION OF THE ORIGINAL PONS-FLEISCHMANN LICENSE
    ENECO, Salt Lake City – ENECO has now completely re-directed its business plan and internal development activities around its own “second generation” non-electric technology. In late May, we terminated our exclusive license agreement with the University of Utah regarding the original 1989 Pons-Fleischmann electrolytic patent applications. The timing of the decision to cancel the license was driven by the U.S. Patent Office’s final rejection of the licensed applications. The only remaining recourse for ENECO, as the licensee, was to pursue an expensive appellate process at an estimated cost in excess of $1 million over the next two or three years. ENECO terminated the license, with its impending high legal costs and other technical difficulties, to devote full corporate resources towards its own proprietary technology that is believed to have a quicker route to commercial success.

    These two facts tell their own story. Here was an invention which was recognized as patentable in Europe but which, for some ‘mysterious’ reason has been deemed unpatentable by the authorities administering the United States Patent Office. This, together with the hostile attitude of U.S. research funding agencies, has obstructed the development of a new technology which affords a prospective plentiful supply of heat energy without involving pollution. It is evident that those who benefit from research funding for ‘hot fusion’ projects have won the day by asserting their oppressive influence through political channels to break faith with the international patent treaty posture on what is, and what is not, patentable.

    An invention that is new, not obvious, potentially useful and is in the industrial category we associate with manufacture and industrial processes, is deemed universally to be proper subject matter for patent grant. If the United States Patent Office is unwilling to grant patents relevant to cold fusion technology then the Commissioner of Patents and Tradmarks should have declared that as a policy position, to stem the wastage of time and money that has resulted since 1989. There should have been appropriate overtures made through the auspices of the World Intellectual Property Organization in Geneva to bring the heads of other National Patent Offices on board with the reasons for that decision. Inventions in the energy field are important to mankind generally and it is unfair for U.S. corporations to be able to secure patents in other countries if the United States of America is not prepared to reciprocate.

    There is no reason why I should venture as a spokesman for the University of Utah in respect of their rights to U.S. patent grant on the Fleischmann and Pons inventions or for the many hundreds of U.S. patent applicants hurt by this situation. I am a British citizen and all I can do is to tell my own story based on my efforts to secure grant of a U.S. patent on cold fusion. From what I have heard my experience is typical of that encountered by others who dare to seek such patents in U.S.A. Now retired, I happen to have a scientific interest in the subject but, careerwise, I was a European Patent Attorney in the employ of IBM. I was Director of IBM’s European Patent Operations. Indeed, many years ago, when the draft of the Patent Cooperation Treaty (P.C.T.) was being discussed in Geneva, I recall being called upon to represent N.A.M., the National Association of Manufacturers at such a meeting. I could never have imagined that one day I would witness the situation that has now occurred in the examining division of the U.S. Patent Office that deals specifically with cold fusion patent applications.

    However, what I have to say below I say as an applicant-inventor but I preface that with the general observation that, in the practical world of the corporate patent environment, when a patent has been on the books for 8 to 10 years, if it is not by then earning its keep by being licensed or by protecting something to be seen on the production line, then its days before it is allowed to lapse by non-payment of renewal fees are numbered. I am not surprised therefore to hear that ENECO in Utah has decided to cut their losses and withdraw from their contest with the U.S. Patent Office. Given then that the files of record in the Patent Office are not available for inspection by the public until a patent issues, it may be that the histories of the file record on cold fusion applications will remain a secret. However, I can here record a little part of that history by making this disclosure as a patent applicant.

    It began in 1989

    In March 1989 I was in my sixth year after retirement and in my sixth year as a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the University of Soputhampton. I was in the Department of Electrical Engineering housed in the Faraday building close to the Department of Electrochemistry to which Martin Fleischmann belonged. There had been no reason for contact with Professor Fleischman, even though I had indulged in ideas concerned with protons, deuterons, and neutrons.

    Indeed, some three years previously, in 1986, I had been very pleased to secure publication of a sequence of three papers, Papers 1, 2 and 3 in the Part 2 section of my 1996 book ‘Aether Science Papers’, and the first of these was entitled ‘The Theoretical Nature of the Deuteron and the Neutron’. This paper explained how one could determine the proton/electron mass ratio, as being 1836.152, precisely in accord with its measured value. It further give similar precise account of the nature of the deuteron and the neutron. The theory told me that there is no neutron in the deuteron! (Keep in mind here that the Fleischmann and Pons experimental findings were later criticised because there was no evidence of neutron emission from what was ostensibly a deuteron fusion reaction.)

    Now I mention this because I did, at the time reprints of these papers were available, send copies of all three to the relevant professor in the Department of Physics at the university. I explained that, though I was in the Department of Electrical Engineering, the fact that these three papers concerned theoretical physics might lead to enquiries directed to his function and, therefore, it was appropriate that he should see what I had written. I did know that he and his research staff were involved in a funded project involving analysis of particle data and it was the quantum chromodynamic theory that was supposed to account for proton creation. My simple derivation of the proton/electron mass ratio to within a fraction of part per million agreement with its measured value should have impressed him.

    On the contrary, the professor was, dare I say, quite livid, so to speak, in his reaction, which came back in writing, with a copy to the head of the Department of Electrical Engineering. The letter expressed his outrage in the form of a declaration that these were the sort of ideas that he had been trying to stop his research students from voicing. He was not happy. I read this as meaning that my independent unfunded contribution to the understanding of the nature of the proton, deuteron and neutron, could conceivably impact his chances of securing continued funding for the particle research on which his group thrived. The head of my department expressed to me his dismay at the attitude his physics counterpart had taken. For my part, I wondered what was happening in the academic world if research students were not allowed some freedom to develop ideas of their own.

    Was research funding so important that it had to be expended on using ‘research students’, virtually as slaves who sift through particle data at the crack of a whip from their professor, but could not be let loose as free-thinking individuals, albeit targetting their attentions at the common objective? Could it be that that professor was concerned in case his students actually saw my way of deriving the proton-electron mass ratio and he feared their revolt against the theoretical route he was advocating? If so, I hope one of those students will see these Web pages of mine and make his or her own judgement. Would it not have been prudent for that professor to show my papers to his students, given that he knew that they had an inclination towards such ideas themselves, and then explain to them in clear terms why what I was advocating had to be in error?

    Well, that is water under the bridge, as they say, but it will, I hope, show why I was particularly interested when the University of Utah staged the Fleischmann and Pons announcement.

    It certainly caused me to exercise my mind, because here was a claim that an excess of heat was being produced in an electrolytic cell in which the deuteron content of heavy water had been adsorbed into a palladium cathode. As I saw it, if the process involved really was a nuclear fusion process, then that could confirm views I had held for many years concerning the fallacy that the sun’s power was dependent upon hot fusion.

    I had discussed this subject in a book I wrote in 1972: ‘Modern Aether Science’. On page 68 of that work I suggested that the energy released by stars was really coming from the aether. The aether is full of energy, primarily in the form of what are called ‘heavy electrons’ or mu-mesons or, to use another name, muons, but physicists see these as an enigma and wonder where they fit into Nature’s pattern. Those muons create protons and one can begin to see how the aether can shed energy when such mysteries of Nature are deciphered in terms of an acceptance that the aether does exist.

    My curiosity about the excess heat source of the Fleischmann and Pons cell had been aroused. I even wondered if it could be connected with something I had explored exerimentally myself, when I tried to set up electrodynamic forces between electric currents in two adjacent electrolytic cells containing a concentrated salt solution involving normal water.

    To formulate a law of electrodynamics which accommodates to the form of the law of gravity but complies with the basic experimental observations, one is driven into a rather special situation. If two electric charges in general motion interact electrodynamically, but with their electrostatic interactions compensated, then there is a form of law which prescribes that, so long as their motions relative to the electromagnetic reference frame are mutually parallel or antiparallel, there will be an inverse square law of force acting between them directed between their centres of charge. However, should those motions not be of that form, there will be imbalance of action and reaction. This means that the aether itself or whatever it is that determines that electromagnetic frame of reference will shed energy as it tries to assure that balance of action and reaction.

    My interest had focused on the electrodynamic interaction of electrons and heavy ions. In the cold fusion experiments I could see that here was a situation where heavy ions (deuterons) could move freely inside the metal body of a cathode in which there were electrical currents conveyed by electrons. The electrons had a short mean free path, but the deuterons might flow by meandering to avoid the positively charged base structure of the metal crystal and this I saw as a possible recipe for electrodynamic action leading to an anomalous acceleration of those deuterons powered by energy supplied by the aether. That would generate anomalous power in the form of heat.

    I saw, on the other hand, that here might be a true cold fusion process if those deuterons were able to fuse by being driven into one another by those anomalous electrodynamic forces, which my theory indicated would be thousands of times greater than could expected from an electron-electron interaction.

    Either way, it made sense, in my opinion to contemplate having an apparatus in which the cathode was part of a closed circuit path of very low resistance carrying a high current, meaning that this would involve very little heat injection by normal means. This, I reasoned, would enhance the activity in which those adsorbed deuterons were involved. One could have 100 amps circulating in a cathode and just a few amps traversing the electrolyte from anode to cathode. Inject heat to enhance the heat gain and do it by making the closed cathode circuit a secondary winding on a transformer fed with very little power input to its primary winding. That was my ‘invention’ as conceived a few days after I heard of the Fleischmann and Pons announcement.

    I filed my patent application on April 15, 1989 at the British Patent Office.

    So by this Lecture on my Web pages I introduce my own story of the saga I encountered once I took an interest in ‘cold fusion’.

    Harold Aspden
    March 14, 1998

    To choose a ‘cold fusion topic’, press the link button:
    Cold Fusion Index
    or, to read on, continuing this Lecture theme, press:


  • LECTURE NO. 13

    LECTURE NO. 13

    COLD FUSION: EINSTEIN’S QUESTION

    Copyright © Harold Aspden, 1998

    WHAT IS NUCLEAR FUSION?

    ‘Nuclear fusion’ is nothing other than the creation of heavier forms of matter as we know it from its constituent components. Physicists use the word ‘nucleon’ and, whereas the hydrogen atom has a nucleon count of 1, there being one unit of proton mass in its nucleus, gold, for example, comprises 197 nucleons, whereas cobalt comprises 60 nucleons, and aluminium, 27.

    Uranium has an even larger number of nucleons, its prime form having 238 nucleons, but it occurs naturally with the 0.7% presence of a form of uranium containing 235 nucleons and if the latter form is isolated and has sufficient size, those nucleons break out and one has fission, the opposite to fusion.

    Now, going back in history, it was the aim of the alchemist to transmute base metals into gold. Lead has more nucleons than gold so to form gold from lead those alchemists would have had to trigger a fission reaction, whereas to form gold from copper or silver, which have fewer nucleons, the transmutation process would have involved fusion. Isaac Newton, a notorious alchemist, was deeply interested in understanding Nature’s processes of creation and so pursued such research, no doubt having an eye on the initial financial rewards before the eventual devaluation of gold when the secret of the transmutation process became public knowledge.

    If you wish to read about Newton’s efforts on that front, then a book published in England in 1997 tells the story. It is entitled: ‘Isaac Newton: The Last Sorcerer’. Its author is Michael White and its reference is ISBN 1-85702-416-8.

    On page 183 of that book, after a statement in the main text: ‘If the experiments do not support the proposal then it will not be promoted from a mere hypothesis’, there follows a footnote, reading:

    A modern example is the case of cold fusion. In 1989, Professors Fleischmann and Pons, announced that they had achieved the process of nuclear fusion at around room temperature. However, before this staggering claim could be accepted, teams of scientists around the world tried to repeat the experiments. When these attempts failed completely, the idea was considered to be almost certainly false and tests eventually pinpointed the fault with the original experiments. Although Professor Fleischmann is still researching cold fusion at a centre financed by a collection of Japanese corporations, the cold-fusion hypothesis has been widely discarded by orthodox science.

    So, the historian who writes about the alchemist’s dream based on the life and times of Isaac Newton has already taken note that the ongoing fiasco concerning ‘cold fusion’ is destined to becomes history repeating itself, alchemy and cold fusion being different names for the same kind of pursuit, where the word ‘energy’ substitutes for the word ‘gold’.

    Now, when I read the book about Isaac Newton’s efforts to transmute one element into another, I had no difficulty in appreciating why Newton had that intuitive belief that Nature must have its own way of causing elements to undergo transmutation. Surely, just because we now think that these transmutations occurred once and for all in a Big Bang event or in an still ongoing activity at the centres of stars, that should not affect our intuitive feeling that there might be other ways of promoting the transmutations here on Earth at normal temperatures.

    If you say that such ‘intuition’ is unwarranted then please give me an answer to Einstein’s question. Einstein was not an alchemist. He merely promoted his hypotheses and remember that it should take more than hypothesis to establish a belief which can be sustained in the world of orthodox science. I have never accepted the doctrines of Einstein’s theory, simply because they stand in the way of onward scientific development and technology based on there being an energy resource locked into the aether that fills space. I see that aether as the energy source from which those nucleons are created and on from there, when we talk of alchemy and cold fusion, we are only concerned with how those nucleons can combine to form a variety of atoms. I am attentive to what I hear about such reactions occurring at modest temperatures and that brings me back to Einstein’s question.

    EINSTEIN’S QUESTION

    You may not have heard about this ‘question’, so this may come to you as an item of news. The question is, in Einstein’s own words:

    Why does there still exist uranium, despite its comparatively rapid decomposition, and despite the fact that no possibility for the creation of uranium is recognizable?

    This question was raised in the ‘Appendix for the Second Edition’ of Einstein’s book ‘The Meaning of Relativity’, Princeton University Press. Einstein did not even attempt an answer. The paragraph in which the question was raised ended with the sentence: ‘But it would lead too far to go into questions of this type.’

    So, ‘Hail, Einstein’, the scientist who did not want to extend himself by probing questions which even Isaac Newton was willing to explore by his alchemical pursuits, and which Professors Fleischmann and Pons later probed by contemplating transmutation of elements at normal laboratory temperatures. Yes, it is much easier to ‘discover’ what is happening in the far depths of space-time than it is to discover how things are as they are on body Earth.

    There is my own question, with Isaac Newton in mind, one I would add to that of Einstein: “Why is it that gold appeared on Earth in the form of gold nuggets, rather than as atoms sprinkled around and mixed with atoms of other elements over the whole of the Earth’s crust?” You see, if those atoms of gold were formed in hot fusion (or hot fission) reactions in a Big Bang event or deep in the hot core of stars, how did they contrive to come together as a solid lump of gold to form that nugget on planet Earth? It is just as important, indeed probably far more important, to discover how they got together on Earth as it is to know, or rather imagine how they were formed as atoms some billions or so years ago.

    Physicists, it seems, those of our modern academic community only raise questions that they can answer. So Einstein deserves credit for putting that question I mention above. So, what is the answer? Does ‘orthodox science’ offer such an answer?

    THE GOLD NUGGET THEORY

    We know from the folklore of modern physics that the heavier elements, such as gold, were created in the nuclear activity within stars. However, physicists who subscribe to that belief but yet advocate exclusive reliance on facts they can verify by observation have not taken account of a fact known to every prospector who has searched for gold. This is that gold is a rare commodity found only where gold exists in concentrated form.

    By this statement I intend to stress the fact that atoms are not dispersed in a random distribution in a general mixture with the myriad of other atomic species which constitute matter. We find gold where there is gold, just as in the Wild West of America one found wild horses where there were other wild horses. The ‘herding instinct’ is at work in the latter case but, more to the point, there is the ‘creation and survival factor’. People are ‘created’ where there are people and it does not need a physicist to tell you why. There are two principal factors which govern this circumstance, the emergence of the embryonic form and its survival after birth. Survival depends upon community, collective association and parental care.

    In the particle world of the physicist the close association of two particles of opposite electrical polarity, a parent particle and a ‘seeding’ particle, given energy input, can create a parent and offspring, which separate to build a family of mixed polarity but like particle forms. That is something you can read about elsewhere in these Web pages. See [1978b]. However, following the creation of such particles, they are subject to processes of decay much as applies to us humans. They have interplay of energy amongst themselves and the rest of the particle world. They are bombarded at random by energy activity from the background environment, but their chance of survival is enhanced by a mutual proximity which allows them to nurture one another by pooling their energy. So, their mean lifetimes increase if they cluster or herd together. Again that is something that can be explained by basic physical principles. See, for example, [1981b] and [1982d]. Here I ask you just to accept the proposition that the creation of an atom is followed by its inevitable decay, but that chance of decay depends upon two factors (a) whether the atom is over-weight or of a specially-awkward form and (b) whether the atom keeps close company with a family atoms of identical form.

    You can recognize radioactivity as being the symptom of the first category. There are two ‘mid-weight’ atoms in the periodic table of atomic elements which are awkward in the sense just described, these being promethium and technetium. They are social mis-fits in the quantum world and suffer early demise. I show why in one of my published scientific papers. See [1987a]. Then, concerning the lifetime factor and family proximity that has to do with mutual stability, energy exchange in a local conservative exchange requiring at least three identical particles to keep close company. In the case of the atom as a whole, the nuclear core charge is the ‘particle’ in question. I do not mean the atomic nucleus as a whole, but rather the Ze charge form, Z being the atomic number of the atom.

    My conception of an atom is one having a positive core charge Ze surrounded by a local ‘cloud’ of anti-protons which have displaced negative aether charges from adjacent lattice sites. Remember that Nobel Laureate Dirac theorized that the aether contained electrons sitting as latent occupants of positive holes, sites in the aether compartments where a negative charge could sit and exhibit only a neutral effect. According to Dirac an electron is ‘created’ when such a ‘hole’ is vacated and this leaves a positive charge behind which is interpreted as a ‘positron’.

    Well, I have my own way of describing the aether, but it amounts to something similar. My vision is that anti-protons can sit in those positive holes and appear as electrically neutral nucleons. I do not use the word ‘neutron’ in this description of the atom. A neutron, as such, is something only seen in free flight, well clear of the atom from which it is created as a decay product, which itself decays with a half-life of a few minutes. So, overall, an atom comprises the Ze charge unit, a series of latent, neutralized anti-protons clustered around that Ze charge, and the familiar satellite system of Z electrons which make the atom electrically neutral as a whole.

    The stability and equilibrium factor depends upon how those Ze charges of adjacent atoms get on with each other. They will be stable, mutually stable, if Z is the same for all members to the group.

    To sum up, if Nature creates a gold atom somewhere by a kind of random process, then it will decay if it is not in the near presence of other gold atoms. It will decay anyway eventually, as do all atoms, but the overall result, what we see, is the outcome of an ongoing contest, governed by chance and probabilities of creation and decay as between the various atomic species, tempered by events which juggle the atoms about in geological or cosmic turmoil.

    In short, there is nothing in this story that says that the spectrum of atomic species must originate exclusively within the inferno of a star or a Big Bang event. My answer to Einstein’s question is that uranium is still being created here and now on body Earth, as is gold and deuterium and even hydrogen.

    So, if Nature has a way of determining the natural abundance as between the respective elements and we, for example, move all the heavy water component, D2O, deuterium oxide, into isolation in, say, the Dead Sea and leave the oceans replete in their purified form as H2O, we might expect Nature to get to work and transmute by fission or fusion until the proper balance of heavy and light water in the seas and oceans is restored. That would involve ‘cold fusion’ such as we have seen in the accelerated process reported by Fleischmann and Pons.

    Einstein’s question might well, therefore, find its answer in the work of Isaac Newton and the efforts of those now active on the cold fusion scene.

    COLD FUSION: MY PERSONAL OPINION

    As someone trained professionally as a Patent Attorney, having to understand inventions, often in greater depth than does the inventor, I have learned to be attentive when I hear of something new and important in the technological fields in which I have specialized. The technology of electrical power systems, and computers during their years of evolution from the 1950s, even the electronic aspects of control systems for ballistic missiles were all part of my spectrum of activity. So one does not set up a hostile barrier upon hearing of a new development. Rather one must seek to understand, in the knowledge that, when the inventor wanders off to get on with his pursuits, one has to document a full description of the invention and stand ready to argue with a Patent Examiner its operation and its merits in relation to prior art.

    I had retired from my position with IBM and was engaged in my own research at university when I heard of the ‘cold fusion’ breakthrough by Fleischmann and Pons. I imagined the situation if that invention had come my way for patent protection in the days when I was handling such work myself. My guess was that the invention would be seen more as a chemical process for generating heat than as a heat-generating apparatus. I knew that if the invention really was to be the energy breakthrough that was promised, there would be numerous onward developments all patentable and that competition to get patent cover in this new field would be enormous. It is characteristic of all major technological developments.

    What struck me as particularly relevant to my interests was the fact that it seemed that no neutrons were emitted as deuterium atoms fused to shed heat. My published scientific work had established to my satisfaction that there is no neutron in the deuteron and so here was something that I thought could confirm my theory. My published scientific work had also revealed my interest in anomalous electrodynamic forces set up when an electric current is transported, not by electrons, but by heavy atomic particles such as protons (or deuterons), these having masses some thousands of times larger than the electron mass. Those anomalous forces reported from research dating back half a century and more had never been explained. They were – well, I will not digress. I have written about this elsewhere (See [1969a] and 1977a), so suffice it to say here that I wondered if the deuterons absorbed into the cathode of the Fleischmann-Pons electrolytic cells were being accelerated anomalously so as to collide with one another in the metal of the cathode and so trigger fusion. I also knew of other energy anomalies occurring in metal when carrying electric current and so my interest was aroused as well as my imagination.

    I thought about the effects of introducing a strong electric current flow, with very low energy input to a closed circuit including the cathode in a modified cell, based on what Fleischmann-Pons claimed to have discovered. I knew this would add heat and the real object was to generate heat as output rather than supply it as input, but it makes sense to add a little of something, a strong electric current stimulus, to get more action from the cell.

    So it was that, on April 15, 1989, a matter of days after the Fleischmann-Pons discovery became news, I filed a patent application at the British Patent Office with apparatus claims directed at that proposition. It was eventually granted. However, the corresponding U.S. Patent Application was destined to become part of a saga that I could never have imagined during my years of experience in the patent profession.

    I intend to tell that story in these Web pages, but that will take us to another Lecture and on from there. My object in this Lecture is to defend the spirit of scientific enquiry that motivated those of long ago who sought to transmute the elements and to point out that Einstein, the champion of orthodox science, as he has become, never did answer his own ‘cold fusion’ question concerning the presence of uranium on body Earth.

    To read about the cold fusion saga, press the link button:
    or choose a cold fusion topic from: