Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Papers & Publications

Peer-reviewed papers and publications by Harold Aspden

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • 1983f

    1983f

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 37, pp. 307-311 (1983).

    THEORETICAL RESONANCES FOR PARTICLE-ANTIPARTICLE COLLISIONS BASED ON THE THOMSON ELECTRON MODEL

    Abstract: A hypothetical quantum-statistical lepton particle model which gives a non-relativistic account of time dilation is shown also to predict natural resonances for quark-containing particles colliding with their antiparticles of equal energy. For proton and antiproton collisions the hypothesis indicates only one resonance between 70 and 95 Gev. This is at 82.03 GeV, a result in accord with recently reported experiments at CERN aimed at detecting the W-boson.

    Commentary: The author here developed the charge-pair-creation theory by which the kinetic energy of a particle in motion is really a statistical energy of a mean presence of particle-pairs in the surrounding field. This is shown to give a phenomenological basis for the observations usually associated with relativistic mass increase and relativistic time dilation. High energy transitions based on these principles indicate a spectrum of particles developed from a base particle and it is further shown that the proton base particle develops a spectrum including the W intermediate vector boson.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1983f]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 307]

    LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO   Vol. 37, N. 8   25 Giugno 1983

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    Theoretical Resonances for Particle-Antiparticle Collisions Based on the Thomson Electron Model.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories
    Winchester, Hampshire S021 2JN, England

    (ricevuto il 12 Aprile 1983)

    PACS. 13.20. – Leptonic and semi-leptonic decays of mesons.

    Summary. – A hypothetical quantum-statistical lepton particle model which gives a nonrelativistic account of time dilation is shown also to predict natural resonances for quark-containing particles colliding with their antiparticles of equal energy. For proton and antiproton collisions the hypothesis indicates only one resonance between 70 and 95 GeV. This is at 82.03 GeV, a result in accord with recently reported experiments at CERN aimed at detecting the W-boson.

    Although it is generally accepted that the increase in muon lifetime with speed is a consequence of time dilation according to Einstein’s theory of relativity, it is prudent to explore alternative hypotheses on occasion, if only to strengthen confidence in the primary theory. If the alternative can explain other phenomena, newly discovered, then there is cause for some reassessment of basic theory.

    There are very few viable phenomenological accounts for the apparent time dilation properties of the decay lifetimes of mesons. Experiments (1) have well confirmed that the relativistic formula

    τ = τ0/(1 − v2/c2)1/2(1)

    holds for the lifetime τ of a muon moving at speed v. Here c is the speed of light in vacuo and τ0 is the muon lifetime at zero speed relative to the observer.

    Cullwick (2) has suggested that the fact that the energy E of a particle increases with speed, according to the formula

    E = E0/(1 − v2/c2)1/2 ,(2)

    (1) J. Bailey and E. Picasso: Prog. Nucl. Phys., 12, 62 (1970).

    (2) E. G. Cullwick: Bull. Inst. Phys., 52 (1959).

    [p. 308] suggests a direct and proportional relationship between lifetime and energy. E0 is the rest mass energy of the particle.

    According to Cullwick, the evidence favouring time dilation, as judged from meson lifetime measurements, is equally evidence for a hypothesis that the lifetime of a particular particle is enhanced in proportion to the energy it acquires from its motion.

    This author (3) believes that an explanation of increased lifetimes of particles caused by their motion should await a viable theory for particle decay at rest. In principle, given such a theory, the doctrines of special relativity suffice to explain the increase in lifetime as viewed by an observer in relative motion, but it would be gratifying if a complementary explanation were available which is phenomenologically related to the processes of decay at rest.

    Such an explanation can be developed by correlation with the author’s recent theoretical derivations of the lifetimes of the pion and neutron (4,5). The latter theory supposes that space is permeated by virtual muon pairs which migrate about in a random statistical manner at the electron Compton frequency mc2/h. Particle decay is then a function of the probability of the particle coming sufficiently close to one of these virtual muons of opposite polarity. Here m is the electron mass and h is Planck’s constant.

    In common with the theory used in ref. (4,5), the hypothesis to be developed relies upon the Thomson concept of an electron charge e as having a bounding radius a given by

    a = 2e2/3mc2 .(3)

    This expression is also applicable to other simple charges e having mass m as used in a more general sense.

    The hypothesis by which we can develop lifetime as a function of the speed of the particle is that the properties of the vacuum medium are such that the space occupied by a particle, that is the volume 4πa3/3, remains constant on a statistical mean basis as the particle fluctuates in form and includes virtual charge pairs in its field, induced as energy is exchanged statistically about a zero mean by interaction with the vacuum. These same principles are incorporated in a 1978 account and its sequel in 1979 by which the author (6,7) sought to explain the nature of the psi-particles and the resonance associated with their decay products.

    Figure 1 represents diagrammatically the hypothetical process just proposed. A particle at A satisfies the Thomson equation (3) and moves towards B. For a proportion k1 of its time of travel it has the simple phyisical form associated with its rest

    Fig. 1 – a particle moving from A to B along a line, divided into intervals k1, k2 and k3; during k2 it is joined by a pair of virtual charges shown on a circle, with arrows marking an energy quantum absorbed and emitted
    Fig. 1.

    (3) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980), p. 145.

    (4) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 237 (1982).

    (5) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 31, 383 (1981).

    (6) H. Aspden: Spec. Science Tech., 1, 59 (1978).

    (7) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 26, 257 (1979).

    [p. 309] state, that is it occupies a space volume 4πa3/3 and has an energy E0. For a proportion k2 of its travel time it has this same form, but is further associated with a pair or pairs of oppositely charged virtual particles identically satisfying the Thomson equation. Thus charge parity is conserved, but an energy quantum depicted by the arrow has been absorbed from the vacuum medium to ensure that there is enough energy (2N + 1)E0 to sustain the existence of these N pairs of charges in addition to the primary charge.

    The action of creating the charge pairs causes a space volume fluctuation, owing to the extra space needed by the induced charges. As a result, upon the emission of the energy quantum coupled with the mutual annihilation of the charge pairs to restore the energy balance, the primary charge reverts to its isolated state, but in so doing it assumes a contracted form for a period proportional to k3 before reverting to its initial state. In this contracted form the primary charge has the reduced volume given by the Thomson formula in relation to its full energy E.

    This seemingly elaborate model presents the optimum system conditions for i) pair creation ii) mean-volume conservation and iii) mean-energy conservation, as linked with exchanges between the system and the vacuum medium. The conditions can be formulated as three equations from which k1, k2 and k3 can be deduced. Thus

    k1 + k2 + k3 = 1 ,(4)

    k1 + (2N + 1)k2 + (E0/E)3k3 = 1 ,(5)

    k1E0 + (2N + 1)k2E0 + k3E = E .(6)

    Charge parity is ensured by specifying that N is an integer. Equation (4) merely ensures the relationship between the time parameters. Equation (5) expresses the unit volume conservation, bearing in mind that the charge radius given by equation (3) is inversely proportional to energy and so a charge of energy E will have a volume (E0/E)3 times that of the charge in its rest state of energy E0. Equation (6) gives the energy balance.

    The lifetime of the particle, by the principles discussed in ref. (4,5) is reduced, the greater the volume displaced on the average by the primary charge. There is then a greater chance of and annihilating encounter with the migrant muon system. Hence decay occurs with a reduced probability owing to the offset of 2Nk2 from unity, corresponding to the volume of the created pairs. Their decay is irrelevant because the system is constantly creating and annihilating them anyway. For high-energy particles (E0/E)3 is small and can be neglected in eq. (5) so that when the 2Nk2 term is offset we are left with k1 + k2 as a direct measure of the probability of decay in relation to unity. Thus

    (k1 + k2)τ = τ0 .(7)

    From (4), (5) and (6), this is shown to be

    τ = τ0(E/E0) ,(8)

    when (E/E0) is appreciably greater than unity. The thoretical time of decay therefore converges rapidly upon the relativistic value as the speed of the particle closely approaches the speed of light. This result is in accord with the proposal made by Cullwick.

    It is conventional to test the time dilation formula by measurements on mesons [p. 310] having very high energies, but this theory suggests that tests at lower energies might reveal discrepancies which could be of significance.

    The hypothesis just discussed has particular bearing upon particles which readily induce virtual charge pairs of similar type, the notable example being the muon. It would help the model further if the electron itself had a recognized lifetime. None is of record, but one readily could question whether in fact the electron does decay but merely constitutes its own decay product and recreates itself after decay by reappearing in its near vicinity. Thus the decay phenomenon may pass undetected.

    When we consider particles which include quarks, that is particles other than electrons and muons, there is a further dimension introduced into the model. The three conditions of charge parity conservation, charge volume conservation and energy conservation require a triple set of equations of state satisfied by energy exchanges with the vacuum medium. If, however, there are three quarks in the make-up of the particle, the quarks can collectively assure that the three conservation conditions are satisfied without requiring any energy exchanges with the vacuum medium. It may then be that the time dilation phenomenon is somewhat anomalous when manifested by quark-structured particles and it does not suffice to verify time dilation by experiments on muons.

    Meanwhile, we can still test the theory on the supposition that, with volume conservation assured by exchanges between the quarks, the critical energy thresholds for resonance with the charges of the separate quarks having minimal interdependence will be set when the energy E of the particle is enough to create 2N + 1 sets of quarks, each of energy Es and, according to the Thomson formula (3), having a charge volume proportional to (1/Es)3.

    For conserved overall volume of charge, including that of the charge pairs induced, we find that there are threshold energy levels given by

    E = (2N + 1)Es(9)

    and

    (2N + 1)(1/Es)3 = K ,(10)

    where K is a constant. From these equations

    E = (2N + 1)4/3/K1/3 ,(11)

    and, with N = 0 corresponding to the rest state E = E0, so that K can be eliminated to obtain threshold values of E at which a resonance condition can be expected. Thus

    E = (2N + 1)4/3E0 .(12)

    In an experiment in which a particle and an antiparticle of the same energy are brought into collision, the total energy quantum of the resulting object produced by the mutual annihilation of the clustered particle pairs will be twice the value given by (12)

    E′ = 2(2N + 1)4/3E0 .(13)

    A recent experiment at CERN brought protons and antiprotons into collision with the object of seraching for a resonance in the region of 80 GeV. It was reported that [p. 311] such a resonance appeared at (82 ± 2.4) GeV (8). It is then very relevant to note that with E0 = 0.938 GeV, the energy of the proton mass, the value of E′ given by (13) has but one value of 82.03 GeV between 70 GeV and 95 GeV and this is that for which N is 8.

    It is submitted that the discovery of a particle resonance at 82 GeV is not necessarily confirmation of the existence of the W intermediate vector boson.

    (8) E. Gabathuler: Lecture on « Quarks and Leptons », IBM Science and Synergy Conference (London, 3-4 March 1983).

  • 1983e

    1983e

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 37, pp. 210-214 (1983).

    THE NATURE OF THE MUON

    Abstract: A quark-like model of the muon based upon the Thomson formula for the electron is correlated with a recent account of the muon g-factor and shown to determine the muon-electron mass ratio. The theory indicates that this is 206.6787, in close accord with its measured value. The model involves a resonance governed by the period at which a disturbance propagates around the electron charge, the radius being the same as that of the de Sitter micro-universe model of the electron suggested by Caldirola.

    Commentary: Readers should understand that the author’s aether theory revealed that the vacuum energy sea comprises ‘virtual’ muons, meaning muons of a primordial form that only exist in that subtle medium we are terming ‘aether’. Such virtual muons have a calculable energy in relation to rest-mass energy of a real muon. It is 206.3329. The author had to confront the problem of reconciling this with the mass of the real muon and the subject paper develops that theme.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1983e]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 210]

    LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO   Vol. 37, N. 6   11 Giugno 1983

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    The Nature of the Muon.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories, Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 18 Gennaio 1983; manoscritto revisionato ricevuto il 20 Aprile 1983)

    PACS. 12.70. – Hadron mass formulae.

    Summary. – A quarklike model of the muon based upon the Thomson formula for the electron is correlated with a recent account of the muon g-factor and shown to determine the muon-electron mass ratio. The theory indicates that this is 206.7687, in close accord with its measured value. The model involves a resonance governed by the period at which a disturbance propagates around the electron charge, the radius of which is the same as that of the de Sitter microuniverse model of the electron suggested by Caldirola.

    It seems likely that in the highly energetic parts of our universe energy quanta nucleated by electron-sized charges can merge to create numerous particle forms. The question why particular particles exist may then reduce simply to the understanding of their relative stability. It will be shown that there is something quite special about the muon in this contest for survival, because it can interact with the electron in a unique way by setting up a natural resonance within a radial-field cavity. The model differs from that of Caldirola (1), which requires the muon to be an electron excited to a higher-mass state and the electron to constitute a de Sitter microuniverse governed by a specific time unit known as the « chronon ». However, as will be shown, there is an interesting connection which should encourage further research.

    Suppose N electron and positrons combine to form a charged particle of mass Nm and charge e, where m is the electron mass and e the electron charge. The mass of the muon is approximately 206.77m and, though this is not in accord with the integral relationship, we can imagine a quarklike combination of the core charge + e with two electrons each of charge − e, under less energetic conditions, so that the total energy, allowing for offset by Coulomb interaction forces, can be nonintegral in electron terms.

    The most simple particle model of this kind, based on N being 207, would be one with a core charge + e of energy 207 mc2 with two electrons symmetrically disposed on either side at centres distant Δ from the centre of the core charge. If this is taken to be a negative muon (the positive one having two positrons and a negative core)

    (1) P. Caldirola: Nuovo Cimento A, 45, 549 (1978).

    [p. 211] then, in electron mass units m, we find that its mass will be

    207 + 2 − 2(e2/Δ)(1/mc2) + (e2/2Δ)(1/mc2) .(1)

    The author (2-4) has found the Thomson formula

    m = 2e2/3ac2(2)

    to be quite effective in the interpretation of charge properties, particularly in developing a heuristic model for explaining the electron and muon anomalous magnetic moment (the g-factor). Formula (2) correlates the electric energy of a charge e of radius a with its mass m, c being the speed of light in vacuo.

    From (1) and (2) the muon mass expression becomes

    209 − (9/4)(a/Δ) .(3)

    The g-factor theory has a resonant feature by which the mass difference for translational motion and spin arises from the separation of field energy outside the cavity from the spin component. There is a field resonance at speed c for radial oscillations between an inner cavity radius and an outer-field cavity radius. The radial spacing between the cavities is half the Compton wave-length. The inner cavity radius is determined by a balance of energy scattered and energy radiated, as with Thomson scattering, and is found to be √3 times the charge radius a given by formula (2).

    The g-factors of the electron and muon are then found to be

    ½g = 1 + 1/(hc/e2 − 1 ± 4/√3) ,(4)

    where hc/e2 is a parameter in the fine-structure constant α = 2πe2/hc and the plus sign applies to the electron resonance, whereas the minus sign applies to the muon resonance. The reason for the difference in resonance mode as between electron and muon concerns the stability conditions and whether the radial oscillations penetrate the inner-field cavity so as to be reflected on its inner surface rather than its outer surface.

    This model for cavity resonance has an interesting bearing upon the evaluation of the mass expression (3). The electron radius is a and the muon radius, from formula (2), is a/207. The inner cavity radius of the muon is √3a/207. The minimum possible value of Δ/a is therefore 1 + 1/207 and, from (3), this corresponds to a minimum muon mass of 206.760 8m, which is very slightly smaller than the measured value reported by Casperson (5) of 206.768 59(29).

    The table below of comparative values of mass and Δ/a applies, if we write Δ/a = 1 + δ/207, where δ is a measure, in terms of charge radius, of the spacing between the surface of the sphere bounding the electron charge and the centre of the muon field cavity.

    (2) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 16, 401 (1977).

    (3) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 213 (1982).

    (4) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 481 (1982).

    (5) D. E. Casperon: Phys. Rev. Lett., 38, 956 (1977).

    [p. 212]

    Muon mass δ
    206.7682m 1.688
    206.7683m 1.697
    206.7684m 1.707
    206.7685m 1.716
    206.7686m 1.725
    206.7687m 1.735
    206.7688m 1.744

    The basic quarklike model of the muon presumably has its two electrons positioned so that their charge surfaces are either in touching relationship or very close to this relative to the inner-field cavity boundary of the muon. For touching relationship a value of δ of √3 or 1.732 applies, corresponding to a muon mass of 206.768 7m.

    In contrast, the muon g-factor given by the formula (4), which also relies on this same δ value, is 2(1.001 165 89) in good accord with the measured value of 2(1.001 165 895(27)) as listed by Cohen and Taylor (6). In this calculation a value of α−1 of 136.036 is used.

    It would be remarkable if the explanation of the muon g-factor and the muon mass in terms of a √3 cavity radius factor were merely fortuitous. The electrons are, it would seem, kept outside the inner cavity radius by the same actions which make this radius a reflecting boundary for radiation.

    The analysis suggests that, given an available energy quantum of the order of 208mc2 or 209mc2, one might expect to create a particle mass having the precise value associated with the muon. The author has suggested elsewhere (7) a process by which such an energy quantum is formed naturally and has further drawn attention to the possible correlation of muon mass mμ, proton mass mp and the proton spin magnetic moment, also involving α. The proton spin magnetic moment in nuclear magnetons is given by

    (0.8/(1 − 2α))(mp/2mμ − 1) .(5)

    With α−1 as 137.036, mp as 1836.152 and the experimental value of this quantity known to be 2.792 845 6, we find that mμ, also in electron units, is, from (5), very close to the value deduced above. It is 206.7689.

    There remains also the key question concerning the possible existence of other particles according to the model discussed. This may be answered from a remarkable feature of the model evident when the electrons and the outer-field cavity centred on the positive-charge core are drawn to scale, as in fig. 1.

    The electrons are wholly located in the field cavity of the muon. The distance between the inner and outer cavity radii is ½λC(m/mμ), where λC is the electron Compton frequency. In contrast, the diameter of the electron is 2αλC/3π.

    (6) E. R. Cohen and B. N. Taylor: J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, 2, 663 (1973).

    (7) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980), p. 140-142.

    [p. 213]

    Fig. 1 – the muon model: a positive core charge +e with two electrons −e on either side, inside a dashed outer field cavity
    Fig. 1.

    The time taken for an oscillation to traverse the return distance radially between the cavity boundaries is, therefore, almost exactly the same as that needed for a disturbance to travel at the same speed c around the periphery of the electron charge. This is because mμ/m ≃ 3/2α ≃ 206. No doubt, therefore, this helps to determine the unique resonance condition of the muon mass level and accounts for the quasi-stability of the muon. It is noted that it is easy to show that the speed at which a disturbance propagates within the body of charge of the Thomson electron is exactly c. It follows directly from the pressure and energy density, both uniform, within the body of charge.

    On the theory proposed above the Compton wave-length for the electron will become an integral multiple of the Compton wave-length associated with the core charge of the muon, because N = 207. Bearing in mind that the radiation process involves an inward and an outward flow of energy, this should establish a resonance state by setting up standing-wave boundaries in the field. This is because the integral relationship between the frequencies assures that common boundary conditions for standing waves at both frequencies are possible. This could be the reason why the muon is held relatively stable with a core mass component that is an integral multiple of the electron mass.

    It is important to correlate the rather simple model of charge depicting the muon in fig. 1 with the more sophisticated proposals of Caldirola (1). Caldirola’s theory has the advantage of embracing relativistic criteria by the remarkable intuitive step of introducing the basic unit of time, the « chronon », given by

    θ0 = 2e2/3mc3(6)

    and regarding the electron as analogous to a de Sitter microuniverse having a positive constant curvature given by 1/c2θ02.

    In (6) e and m are the electron charge and rest mass of the electron, respectively. Thus θ0 is the time taken by a disturbance propagating at the speed c to traverse the radius a of the electron charge specified by the Thomson formula (2). This radius, therefore, becomes that of the electron’s de Sitter microuniverse in Caldirola’s theory.

    The excited state of the electron which constitutes the muon can, therefore, be a state in which there is resonance as between the disturbance propagating around the boundary of the electron’s de Sitter world and one propagating radially within the cavity boundaries setting the Compton wave-length of the muon.

    Caldirola (1) was able to formulate the approximate relationship

    (mμ − m)c2 ≈ (3/2)(hc/2πe2)mc2(7)

    [p. 214] from his analysis, a theme well supported by Freyberger (8) and further developed by Caldirola (9,10) by being applied to predict the existence of high-energy leptons.

    Meanwhile, it should also be mentioned that the concept of a particle bounded by a resonant cavity has been proposed by Jennison and Drinkwater (11) as a method of explaining inertia.

    So far as this paper is concerned, it may point the way towards bridging the gap between the approximation of eq. (7) and the actual measured mass of the muon, by underlining the role played by the cavity dimension of √3 times the effective muon charge radius. Finally, it is noted that there are advantages in the muon model presented in fig. 1, in that the decay process may be easier to understand. The decay product is an electron, resulting from the mutual annihilation of the positive core charge and one electron. This yields energy and traces of two neutrinos represented by the imbalance of the spatial volume represented by the electron annihilation. This bears upon the creation and decay processes discussed elsewhere by the author (12,13) in regard to the psi-particles, because energy, charge and the volume occupied by charge overall tends to be conserved in particle interactions.

    (8) D. Freyberger: Phys. Rev. D., 24, 979 (1981).

    (9) P. Caldirola: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 27, 225 (1980).

    (10) P. Caldirola: Lett. Nuovo Cimento (in press).

    (11) R. C. Jennison and A. J. Drinkwater: J. Phys. A, 10, 167 (1977).

    (12) H. Aspden: Spec. Science and Technology, 1, 59 (1978).

    (13) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 26, 257 (1979).

  • 1983d

    1983d

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 37, 169-172 (1983).

    THE DETERMINATION OF ABSOLUTE GRAVITATIONAL POTENTIAL

    Abstract: The scope for determining absolute gravitational potential P is discussed. It is shown from two quite distinct methods, one relying on data from electron g-factor measurements
    and the other on the 3K cosmic background data, that the absolute value of P at the Earth’s surface is only 8% greater than that due to the mass of the solar system. It is inferred that gravitation has a range of action limited to a distance of a few hundred light years.

    Commentary: This paper is an extremely important paper from the viewpoint of cosmology. The subject was introduced in the author’s 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’, but its importance to our understanding of galaxies and the nature of the universe can not be underestimated. In particular, from a futuristic viewpoint, whereas the author dismisses the Einstein syndrome of time dilation, with its imaginary time distortion that can cause us to think of twins aging at different rates, the author’s theory points us towards a destiny of catastrophe.

    Space is seen as comprising very large domains defining zones separating matter and anti-matter and what we may term aether and anti-aether, meaning electric polarity reversal in traversing the space domain boundaries. Gravitation forces will not act in
    the normal sense across such boundaries. When, eventually, the Earth crosses such a boundary on the next occasion, we will witness a delayed reversal of the Earth’s magnetic field but experience the sudden shock waves of mammoth earthquake disruption. The latter catastrophic events occur with varying degrees of severity in long duration cycles as a function of the oblique angle at which the solar system crosses carries the plane of the Earth’s orbit through a space domain boundary. As a result there is a correlation between geological and cosmological events in the Earth’s history. See the author’s references [1977c, 1978a].


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1983d]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 169]

    LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO   Vol. 37, N. 5   4 Giugno 1983

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    The Determination of Absolute Gravitational Potential.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 28 Marzo 1983)

    PACS. 12.20. – Electromagnetic and unified gauge fields.

    Summary. – The scope for determining absolute gravitational potential φ is discussed. It is shown by two quite distinct methods, one relying on data from electron g-factor measurements and the other on the 3K cosmic background data, that the absolute value of φ at the Earth’s surface is only 8% greater than that due to the mass of the solar system. It is inferred that gravitation has a range of action limited to a distance of a few hundred light years.

    If gravitation has a range of action traversing the whole ambit of the visible universe, the gravitational potential at the Earth’s surface should outweigh by far that attributable to mass local to the solar system. This assumption is the basis of Mach’s Principle, which requires the gravitational potential φ to be an absolute scalar quantity referenced on matter constituting the whole universe. Evidently, therefore, if the local value of φ could be measured, this would be of primary importance, because it could resolve many questions in cosmology, including the dependence of local inertia upon the presence of distant stars.

    A direct measurement of φ would enable us to assess the range of gravitational action. For example, if φ were found to be only slightly greater than that attributable to the solar system, this would signify a range encompassing relatively few stars and so of the order of a hundred or so light years. On the other hand, if φ were about three times greater than this, the range of gravitation would be local to our Galaxy, whereas significantly greater values of φ do imply the universal range of gravitational force.

    Changes of φ as between separated positions can be measured, as by the Pound and Rebka experiment (1,2), so allowing us to isolate the Earth’s component of φ. The question, however, is whether φ can be measured on an asbolute basis by a test at a single position. Most scientists would say that this is impossible, even though φ is taken to have a physical influence at that position. This is based on practical considerations rather than fundamental philosophical reasoning, but the measurement of the absolute φ may well be possible.

    (1) R. V. Pound and G. A. Rebka jr.: Phys. Rev. Lett., 3, 439 (1959).

    (2) R. V. Pound and G. A. Rebka jr.: Phys. Rev. Lett., 4, 337 (1960).

    [p. 170]

    Indeed, experimental evidence is already available which suggests a viable method of approach. This is reviewed below in the hope that it will encourage a research program aimed at verifying the assumptions implicit in the following interpretation of the data. It is found that the absolute value of φ is only about 8% greater than that due to mass in the solar system.

    The governing experiment is the accurate measurement of the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron. The electron g-factor has been found by Van Dyck (3) to be given by

    ½g = 1.001 159 652 200(1)

    to an accuracy of 40 parts in 1012.

    The accurate experimental determination of the fine-structure constant α or 2πe2/hc is also important. Williams and Olsen (4) have found that

    α−1 = 137.035 963(2)

    to an accuracy of 11 parts in 108.

    In some theories the inertial and radiant properties of the electron are taken to depend upon interactions with the rest of the universe. Though the theoretical basis of the argument applied here does differ from the conventional method adopted, this connection between the rest of the universe and the electron is incorporated in the following formulation:

    ½g = (1 + ½φ/c2)(1 + 1/(hc/e2 − 1 ± 4/√3)) .(3)

    The plus term in the denominator applies to the electron g-factor and the minus term applies to the muon g-factor (*). The derivation of this formula is quite simple It involves a resonant-cavity model of the electron with radial field oscillations in the field cavity at the Compton frequency λC. It is a model similar in many respects to that proposed by Jennison and Drinkwater (5) for explaining inertia as a local property of mass. A full analysis has been presented elsewhere by the author (6,7) based on a work first reported in 1977 (8).

    The g-factor depends upon the difference between the normal mass of the electron and the spin mass, the latter being lower because the spin motion is one confined well within the cavity and so it excludes the effects of field energy located outside, that is beyond a radius of approximately ½λC. The φ term arises if one accepts the hypothesis that the gravitational energy φ per unit mass, being negative, sets a threshold for the thermal-energy content of the interacting masses. For equal partition of energy

    (3) R. S. Van Dyck jr.: Bull. Am. Phys. Soc., 24, 758 (1979).

    (4) E. R. Williams and P. T. Olsen: Phys. Rev. Lett., 42, 1575 (1979).

    (5) R. C. Jennison and A. J. Drinkwater: J. Phys. A, 10, 167 (1977).

    (6) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 481 (1982).

    (7) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 213 (1982).

    (*) The muon g-factor formula presupposes an alternative resonant mode to that applicable for the electron. If the muon is created by charge pair annihilation, then its g-factor involves the same resonance mode:

    ½g = (1 + ½φ/c2)(1 + 2/(hc/e2 − 1) − 1/(hc/e2 − 1 + 4√3)) .(4)

    (8) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 16, 401 (1977)

    [p. 171] between similar mass elements, an electron of mass m would have a kinetic energy of ½φm at its equilibrium temperature. This energy would, on a quantum electrodynamic interpretation, not be assigned to the spin mass and so, being wholly outside the cavity boundary, would contribute directly to the g-factor, as the term ½φ/c2 in eq. (3).

    Both g and hc/e2 are known with precision for the electron and from the measured values quoted above the equation should give a direct estimation of the absolute energy potential term φ/c2. With c as 3·1010 cm/s, φ is found to be 10.25·1012 c.g.s. The value for the solar system is 9.49·1012 c.g.s., being almost wholly due to the Sun of mass MS of 1.989·1033 g distant Ra of 1.496·1013 cm and the Earth of mass ME of 5.977·1027 g and radius RE of 6.378·108 cm. With G as 6.67·10−8 c.g.s. the value of φ at the Earth’s surface, or G(MS/Ra + ME/RE) becomes 9.49·1012 c.g.s. This is about 8% smaller than the measured value of φ.

    The muon g-factor is not yet known to sufficient accuracy to be used to test the alternative eqs. (3) and (4) and so is less reliable as a means for determing φ, but the results are consistent with those obtained from electron g-factor data.

    There is scope, nevertheless, for alternative estimation of φ. This depends upon measurements of the temperature of the cosmic background. Research is also needed to confirm the mass of the hidden charge carriers which soustain Maxwell’s displacement currents, whether in the vacuum proper or in materials with few electrons. The author, in collaboration with Dr. Eagles (9), has given a theoretical basis for determining the fine-structure constant as a vacuum property associated with the basic charge carriers permeating space. In theory, these have a mass 0.0408 times that of the electron. Experimental evidence from the dual resonances in p-type germanium crystals suggest that these hidden particles do reveal themselves when the local electron population is limited. Ehrenberg (10) reports measurements showing that their measured mass m* is 0.04 times that of the electron. Recently, Graham and Lahoz (11) have found that Maxwell’s displacement theory is upheld by their experimental achievement of imparting angular momentum to the vacuum itself and establishing reaction forces on the apparatus. Accordingly, further research should establish the mass property of vacuum charges.

    Meanwhile, assuming a value for m*/m of 0.04, one can explain the sustained cosmic-background temperature T from an equation such as

    φm* = kT ,(5)

    where k is Boltzmann’s constant 1.38·10−16 erg/°C.

    The traditionally quoted temperature of the so-called 3 K cosmic background is 2.7°. With electron mass as 9.1·10−28 g, (5) then gives a value of φ of 10.24·1012 c.g.s., in exact accord with the value found from the electron g-factor data.

    Thus we do have good reason for proposing that the absolute value of gravitational potential can be determined experimentally. Since it appears to be about 8% larger than that due to the solar system, we can infer that gravitation has a limited range of action which assures that enough nearby stars are within range to account for this additional 8%.

    Apart from the cosmological implications involved in such a conclusion, there is the pointer from the duality of the result obtained affirming the evident presence of

    (9) H Aspden and D M. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, 41, 423 (1972).

    (10) W. Ehrenberg: Electric Conduction in Semi-conductors and Metals (Oxford, 1958), p. 145.

    (11) G. M. Graham and D. H. Lahoz: Nature, 285, 154 (1980).

    [p. 172] vacuum charges with a mass of 0.04 m. The author is currently projecting experimental work aimed at tracing these electrodynamically.

    Finally, though it is really outside the scope of this paper, it is mentioned that the apparent gravitational potential φG of stars acting on the Earth and central to our Galaxy may be shown to contribute to φ by

    φ = φG(Δ2/δR) ,(6)

    where R is the distance to our galactic centre, Δ is the approximate range of gravitational action and δ/Δ is a measure of the concentration of galactic mass density in progressing over a distance Δ towards the centre of the Galaxy. A value of φ/φG of 0.1, Δ/R of 0.01 and δ/Δ of 0.1 present a reasonable galactic interpretation and infer a range of gravitational action over a distance of a few hundred light years.

    H. Aspden
    4 Giugno 1983
    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento
    Serie 2, Vol. 37, pag. 169-172

  • 1983c

    1983c

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 36, pp. 364-368 (1983).

    THE LAMB SHIFT FOR A CAVITY-RESONANT ELECTRON

    Abstract: The author’s recently reported anomalous g-factor evaluations for the electron and the muon, based on a model charge centred in a cavity resonating at the Compton frequency, are here supported by an analysis of the Lamb shift using the same model.

    Commentary: It was in 1982 that the author decided to take early retirement from his professional patent career with IBM and was allowed for a period before retirement in May 1983 to work full time on developing his theory. IBM then provided financial support for the author’s retirement research project at the University of Southampton for a transitional period. Readers will see, therefore from the spate of scientific papers now listed that such full time efforts were rewarded by rapid progress in the development of the theory.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1983c]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 364]

    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento   Vol. 36, N. 11   12 Marzo 1983

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    The Lamb Shift for a Cavity-Resonant Electron.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Wincester, England

    (ricevuto il 6 Gennaio 1983)

    PACS. 12.20. – Electromagnetic and unified gauge fields.

    Summary. – The author’s recently reported anomalous–g-factor evaluations for the electron and muon, based on a model charge centred in a cavity resonating at the Compton frequency, are here supported by an analysis of the Lamb shift using the same model.

    It has recently been shown (1,2) that the anomalous g-factor of the electron and muon can be explained in terms of a cavity-resonant system. The method does not involve the very complex calculations found in quantum electrodynamic treatments and yet it does, by a simple classical style of analysis, give values of the g-factor in quite close accord with those observed. It is now the object of this paper to report progress in extending this same technique to the problem of the Lamb shift.

    The electron is deemed to be at the centre of a field cavity having an outer bounding radius R and an inner bounding radius r, the latter being slightly in excess of the classical radius of electron charge. A radial electrical wave resonance exists at frequency ν0 and propagation speed c, travelling to and fro between these cavity radii. Thus

    2(R − r)ν0 = c .(1)

    The radius r defines a spherical surface which reflects this radial oscillation and so may also provide a scattering cross-section πr2 for radiation intercepted from propagated electromagnetic waves which accelerate the electron.

    The inertia of the electron is determined (3) by the exchange of electric-field energy and electron kinetic energy in this process of interaction with intercepted waves, a conservation process in accord with E = Mc2. This requires there to be no radiation of electrical energy, apart from that which oscillates and does not escape from the resonant cavity. However, the acceleration of the electron does give rise to radiation due to [p. 365] magnetic action and so we may expect the scattered radiation of the wave energy to be that of only half the amount specified by the Larmor formula. Accordingly, the scattering cross-section of the electron is really only half that given by the Thomson-scattering cross-section (4):

    (8π/3)(e2/mc2)2 .(2)

    (1) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 32, 114 (1981).

    (2) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 481 (1982).

    (3) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 213 (1982).

    Here, e is the electron charge, m its mass and c is the speed of light in empty space. We can equate half of this expression to the area πr2 to find

    r = (2/√3)(e2/mc2) .(3)

    The value of ν0 is the Compton frequency of the electron, so that

    ν0 = mc2/h ,(4)

    where h is Planck’s constant. Thus, from (1), (3) and (4)

    R = (h/2mc)(1 + (4/√3)(e2/hc)) ,(5)

    or

    R = (h/2mc)(1 + (2/√3)(α/π)) .(6)

    This theory requires the anomalous g-factor of the electron to arise because the electron mass for linear motion includes energy outside the cavity radius R, whereas the electron mass for a so-called spin motion confined well within the bounds of the cavity radius does not include this external energy. The spin mass is less, with the result that the gyromagnetic ratio is affected so that the anomalous term a in the relation g = 2(1 + a) has the form

    a = mc2/(mc2 − e2/2R) − 1 .(7)

    Note that e2/2R is the electric-field energy of the electron charge e disposed outside the radius R.

    From (6), together with the substitution 2πe2/hc for the fine-structure constant α, we then see that (7) simplifies to

    a = 1/(2πα−1 − 1 + 4/√3) .(8)

    Putting α−1 as 137.036, this gives an anomalous component of the electron g-factor of 0.00115965, exactly in accord with the observed value to this level of accuracy.

    For the muon the model requires the resonance to be on the inside wall of the inner [p. 366] cavity radius, so that the half–wave-length is R + r, rather than R − r. This involves writing the term 4/√3 in (8) with a minus sign and, upon evaluation, gives 0.00116589, also in exact accord with the anomalous term in the g-factor of the muon. The Compton frequency related to the muon mass has, of course, now appeared in the analysis.

    (4) E. U. Condon and H. Odishaw: Handbook of Physics (New York, N. Y., 1967), p. 7.

    The above summary of earlier work now sets the stage for the exploration of the Lamb shift. Here we are concerned with the effects of this external energy decoupled from the electron in the cavity. We will restrict attention in this preliminary enquiry to the specific problem of the electron in the hydrogen atom, exchanging states under conditions for which the only difference is that between an orbital motion and a linear oscillatory motion. This applies to the 22S½-to-22P½ transition.

    When an electron travels along a linear path all the energy contained within the cavity radius R moves with it at velocity V. However, the electron energy outside the cavity, for example at P in fig. 1, does not move at the velocity V. This latter energy is decoupled from the charge e and it can only transfer as if it were moving at velocity V by the process of being drawn radially into the cavity and ehected therefrom to a new forward position. Thus, in order to assure normal mass properties of the electron in linear motion, we have a hypothesis that this energy flow accounts for the extra momentum of the electron energy within the cavity to match that we would otherwise associate with the energy lying outside the cavity.

    Fig. 1. Energy flow lines drawn radially into the electron cavity and ejected forward, with point P outside the cavity and velocity V
    Fig. 1.

    This action is not manifested in any obvious way for linear motion because we assume that the whole energy is merely transported with the electron at the speed V. However, when the electron is in orbital motion there is then a discrepancy in the inertial properties. The additional momentum attributable to the external energy is like that of a fixed spherical bob on a pendulum. The energy in transit through the electron cavity has an additional angular momentum matching a velocity moment:

    (2/5)R2w(9)

    causing the electron in orbit of radius r0 to have its normal angular momentum mr02w supplemented by an amount

    (2/5)(Δ)mR2w ,(10)

    [p. 367]

    where w is the angular velocity of the electron in its orbit and Δ is the fraction of the electron’s mass energy that is in transit through the cavity corresponding to motion at w and needed to sustain the external-field energy balance.

    To find Δ, we let σ denote a uniform energy density inside the cavity having an additional velocity component by which it may sustain this balance. Then, in travelling a distance 2R, the total external energy e2/2R will have passed through a cross-sectional area of πr2. It follows that

    (πr2)(2R)(σ) = e2/2R(11)

    and the total energy in transit at the speed of the electron is ((4π/3)R3)σ or e2/3R or ⅔ of the external energy.

    Thus, since the external energy is approximately (α/2π)mc2, as may be deduced from (8), the quantity (Δ)w becomes

    (2/3)(α/2π)w .(12)

    Now, if the derivation of the Rydberg constant is traced, we find that it applies in association with a principal quantum number n and an azimuthal quantum number normally designed l, but here designated n0: Thus, whereas the energy state of a particular electron condition is normally stated to be hcR′/n2, where R′ is the Rydberg constant, we find that this includes a term hcR′/n02, provided n0 is not zero.

    For the 22S½ state the energy is therefore simply hcR′/n2, because n0 is zero. For the 22P½ state the energy is exactly the same if n0 is unity, the nominal value for this state, but if n0 differs from unity by δn0, we find that the energy hcR′/n2 is reduced by

    − δ(hcR′/n02) = (hcR′/n03)2 δn0 .(13)

    This accounts for the Lamb shift. As a frequency the shift becomes

    δν = 2cR′ δn0 ,(14)

    because n0 is unity. We know that δn0 is the angular momentum (10) when expressed in units of ħ/2π. Therefore, from (10), (12) and (14), we have

    δν = (8/15)cR′ αwmR2/h .(15)

    The value of w is known from the conventional Bohr theory to be

    w = 2πα2mc2/h ,(16)

    this being the angular velocity of an electron having angular momentum h/2π. R is known from (6) to be approximately h/2mc. Therefore, (16) reduces to the approximate expression

    δν = (4π/15) α3cR′.(17)

    [p. 368]

    The above formula is approximate to within about 1% of the true value. One reason is that R is slightly larger than h/mc as we see from (6). Also the external energy outside the cavity has been approximated as (α/2π)mc2 and it differs slightly from this, also from application of (6). Furthermore, a small correction factor involving a term in 2α is needed for reasons a little beyond the scope of this paper, which are the subject of continuing research. This is connected with the additional angular momentum needed by the electron when compensating a pair of interacting photon quanta, each such quantum needing an extra angular momentum α(h/2π). See the analysis in the author’s work elsewhere (5).

    A complete formula, allowing also for the mass correction of the atomic nucleus (mass M) and using the Rydberg constant for infinite mass can be written thus

    δν = (4π/15) α3R∞c (1 + 2α/(3½π)) (1/(1 + 2α)) (1 − m/M) .(18)

    Upon evaluation, putting R∞ as 109737 cm−1, α−1 as 137.036, m/M as 1/1836 and c as 2.99793·1010 cm/s, we find that (18) gives a Lamb shift of 1057.848 Mc/s, a value in good accord with the recent experimental value of 1057.845(9) Mc/s reported by Lundeen and Pipkin (6).

    This therefore provides a valuable heuristic account of the Lamb shift for this particular transition. This complements the author’s semi-classical treatment of the anomalous electron g-factor. Much now depends upon the development of this method to explain other transitions. Initial work on this looks quite promising. It is submitted, therefore, that this may provide an alternative avenue of exploration should the current problems in matching measurement of the Lamb shift with theoretical values derived from quantum electrodynamics remain unresolved.

    (5) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980), p. 98.

    (6) S. R. Lundeen and F. M. Pipkin: paper entitled Measurement of Lamb shift in hydrogen, presented at Second International Conference on Precision Measurement, NBS, USA, 8-12 June, 1981.

  • 1983b

    1983b

    The following is an item of Correspondence by H. Aspden published in Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 6, pp. 199-202 (1983).

    RELATIVITY AND ROTATION

    Commentary: My book ‘Physics Unified’ was published in 1980 and I found that it was ‘reviewed’ by Allen D. Allen in a contribution to Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 4, p. 579 (1981). Although my book was really about the electrodynamic foundation for the theory of gravitation and the factors governing the Planck constant, as well as accounting for particle creation, including the proton, Allen directed his commentary at the case I had argued against the Einstein’s theory of relativity. He asserted that it was not clear how the variability of the speed of light in rotating media argued against the theory of relativity.

    Now, those who fence to defend Einstein’s theory use two ‘swords’. If the topic is the speed of light, then that involves the first sword, the one termed ‘special’. Should one attack by a ‘rotary’ movement, then that sword is not used by the defendant, because it is only supposed to work for action involving non-accelerated situations. The other sword, that termed ‘general’, is designed to be used when the argument gets distorted by bringing in gravitational effects. These involve accelerated motion, but the defenders no longer use arguments based on the constant velocity of light. If its mathematical symbol c is brought into the argument, then that is regarded as a speed term that follows the curvature of ‘four-space’. ‘Four-space’ is not something in which one can make measurements. Otherwise, physicists would have a way of testing Einstein’s theory, without having to go through the usual process of making a measurement in ‘three-space’, then processing the data through what amounts to a computer program to convert its form, before writing the answer down on paper in the usual ‘three-space’ format. You see, Einstein’s theory is ‘tested’ by comparing measurement and theory, but only after there has been some ‘underhand’ doctoring of the data by that mysterious process invented by Dr. Einstein.

    This may well be getting off-track so far as the subject publication is concerned, but the fact is that scientists have ignored the effect of the Earth’s rotation in their laboratory testing of Einstein’s theory. It is possible to design an apparatus in which the speed of light can be measured for East-West and West-East travel, during a time interval in which the test apparatus is manipulated so as to be non-accelerated. One simply compensates for the acceleration attributable to Earth rotation and its orbital motion around the Sun and the virtually negligible effects of the cosmic motion of the solar system around the galactic centre.

    Now, if anyone ever gets around to performing this laboratory experiment using modern laser technology and there is a difference, this has two consequences. Firstly, Einstein’s theory is disproved, because the speed of light is then not constant in a non-accelerated frame, and that ‘special’ sword is blunted so as to be of no use in defending Einstein’s theory. Secondly, the laboratory tests which do not compensate for acceleration but aim to measure anything connected with Einstein’s theory, but light speed in particular, would in some way depend upon Earth rotation. In attacking Einstein’s theory, I see no point in accepting that the two-sworded defender can play according to his own rules, when Nature has the governing hand in such an affray.

    My response to Allen in ‘Relativity and Rotation’ drew attention to certain experimental evidence and I now provide the following quotations from that response:

    “In a review of my book ‘Physics Unified’, Allen D. Allen, writing in Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 4, p. 579 (1981) says that it is not clear how the variability of the speed of light in rotating media argues against the theory of relativity. This lack of clarity may well be due to the fact that my primary argument in Chapter 3 of the book was directed to showing that the vacuum might have structure and that, if this structure rotated with the Earth or with other rotating objects, motion referenced on a non-rotating frame might be detected optically. I did say that if speed, as opposed to angular velocity, could be detected optically by reference to a non-rotating frame, the optical sensing being confined to the vacuum enclosed by the apparatus, then this would have dire consequences for the theory of relativity. I explain why below.”

    “Relativity does account for the optical sensing of relative motion in an inertial frame of parts of a rotating object and so the detection of the angular speed of that object. Thus, there was the Michelson-Gale experiment which evidenced Earth rotation in the interference patterns of light rays sent in opposite directions around a closed circuit. Also, there is the Sagnac experiment and the modern ring laser gyro, both of which show that light propagation can betray the rotation of the test apparatus. However, these concern angular speed measurement. The measurement of linear speed relative to a reference remote from and external to the test apparatus is quite another matter.”

    “If the West-East speed of a laboratory, owing to its rotation about the Earth’s axis (some 350 m/s at 40oN), shows up in speed-of-light anisotropy measurements confined within the laboratory, then it is submitted that this would clearly refute Einstein’s theory. Given such an experimental result, test apparatus otherwise fixed to the Earth and so constrained to share its acceleration, could, in principle, be replaced by similar apparatus caused to rotate once a day in the opposite sense and subjected to vertical acceleration of approximately 3 cm/s2 for test periods commensurate with the small time it takes for light to traverse an optical test circuit. Such an applied motion will ensure that the system is compensated to satisfy the zero acceleration requirement of Einstein’s hypothesis. Now, there is no logical way in which one can argue that the 350 m/s detection can be eliminated owing to these acceleration effects. On the contrary, the logic of relativity argues that the 350 m/s speed cannot be detected in either situation. The laws of physics and speed-of-light measurements have to be the same for systems in relative non-accelerated motion. If 350 m/s difference in light speed is sensed and this cannot be connected with gravitational acceleration at the Earth’s surface or the Earth’s centrifugal acceleration without dependence upon Earth radius, then Einstein’s theory stands disproved.”

    “All this can, of course, be dismissed as wishful thinking were it not for the fact that researchers persevere in experimental efforts to measure the cosmic speed anisotropy of light of several hundred km/s related to the sidereal frame and may well be stumbling over a detected anisotropy of a few hundred m/s in the Earth’s inertial frame. The latter should be the focus of attention.”

    “The author mentions the experiments of Townes at al. reported in Physical Review Letters, v. 1, p. 342 (1958) in his book, but more relevant today is an experiment reported by Brillet and Hall reported in Physical Review Letters, v. 42, p. 549 (1979). In this paper they claimed a null result which was 4000 times more sensitive than the best previous measurement of light-speed anisotropy in space. Yet, consider what they say. A genuine spatial anisotropy would be evidenced by a laser-frequency shift as a vector amplitude at twice the rotation frequency of the table on which the test laser was mounted. The experiment gave a relevant signal of 17 Hz (2×10-13 times the laser frequency) with approximately constant phase in the laboratory frame. For this reason it was classified as spurious and persistent but ignored because, when shifted by analysis over 12 and 24 hour periods, it gave no genuine indication of motion in the sidereal frame. The expected signal would indicate 1/2(v/c)2, where v is the speed anisotropy and c is the speed of light, the factor being related to the term 2×10-13 actually observed. This indicates an anisotropy in light speed of 190 m/s in the Earth frame, clearly an important result from the viewpoint of the comments above. It is noted that the author (H. Aspden) regards the Brillet and Hall experiment as needing interpretation to allow for anisotropy effects upon the angle of deflection at mirror surfaces moving relative to the light reference frame. These make the 190 m/s indication subject to adjustment and so leave the issue inconclusive. However, the experiment to verify that the 350 m/s motion of a laboratory can be detected seems viable. It is crucial to Einstein’s theory.”

    “Note that one is seeking to verify an anisotropy in light speed of the order of 10-6 the speed of light. Such a discrepancy between the speed of light, as measured East-West versus West-East, is of the same order as discrepancies now showing up in experiments comparing the speed of ultra-high energy photons and electrons. According to Einstein’s mass formula for high speed electrons, an 11 Gev electron should move at a speed within about 2 parts in 109 that of light. Yet, as Brown et al. (Physical Review Letters, v. 30, p. 763; 1973) found, 7 Gev photons and 11 Gev electrons are both discrepant in this respect. The relative velocity difference compared with visible light is of the order of one part in a million, being, for the 11 Gev electrons, (-1.3+/-2.7)x10-6 that of light. It is submitted that if the electron speed is referenced on a non-rotating frame centred on the Earth’s axis, then such discrepancies are to be expected. Yet, if a speed difference of 350 m/s shows up in such experiments, Einstein’s theory is surely in trouble.”

    “From this it would be correct to conclude that the author has come firmly to the position that, notwithstanding all the apparent successes of Einstein’s theory when tested against its key experimental criteria, it will fail once it is accepted that Earth rotation can be measured by optical speed-of-light tests. The author further believes that the evidence is before us but that we are so entranced by relativity that it is being overlooked and not probed in depth for its true significance. For example, suppose the Brillet and Hall experiment were performed at the North pole. Would the persistent and spurious signal then be non-existent? One may alternatively wonder how a signal can be both spurious and persistent, unless it is regarded as spurious because there is no explanation for it consistent with Einstein’s theory.”

    “These remarks were prompted by Allen D. Allen’s review of ‘Physics Unified’. This book is really an update of the author’s work, ‘Physics Without Einstein’. In 1969 there was far less evidence of a preferred cosmic frame of reference than there is today and Einstein’s theory seemed more secure. Yet, the author persisted in presenting his alternative perspective. One review by ‘Il Nuovo Cimento’ (v. 28B) is particularly apt:

    “From a close analysis of the grounds of this theory new physical concepts arise having a great theoretical potential. . . The book represents undoubtedly only a first step in the development of the theory and does not claim to give a complete description . . . Undoubtedly also for Aspden’s book it can be noted the lack of that formal polish which is characteristic of general relativity and which makes it so attractive. In fact, however, since the attempts to unify gravitational and electromagnetic phenomena led to incomplete results and since the physics of particles is unable to match with a satisfactory theory the multiplicity of experimental discoveries it seems appropriate to wonder whether we should take into serious consideration also possible alternatives to relativity. After all, it would be better to do it now that no experimental discovery has unquestionably contradicted the theory of relativity rather than in the future when, in front of the collapse (unlikely in the short term, but not impossible) of all the relativistic structure, it would be hard and slow to trace a new path out of the dust and ruins.” (End of review)

    “The Brillet and Hall experiment may be the forerunner of a conclusive test refuting Einstein’s theory. It was reported in 1979. If it is verified by further experiment that the linear speed of a laboratory can be sensed by enclosed optical measurement relative to the Earth’s inertial frame of reference, then Einstein’s theory stands refuted. Two experiments would then help in the quest to support ether theory. Firstly, the optical test apparatus by which to sense light speed anisotropy should be flown along a line of latitude of say 40oN to see if the speed of flight affects the basic 350 m/s indication. Secondly, the apparatus should be conveyed vertically (as by the space shuttle) to see how the 350 m/s measurement changes with altitude. In particular, it would be interesting to see whether it increases over an initial altitude of say 100 km and then decreases suddenly to zero outside a zone of Earth influence corresponding to a region of ether drag.”

    “Until experiments of this kind resolve the issue, we are left to theorize. The author has shown in ‘Physics Unified’ how Einstein’s General Relativity equation for the law of gravitation can be explained by energy propagation.” (End of quotations from ‘Relativity and Rotation’)

    Allen D. Allen also questioned the mathematics relied upon in deriving the non-relativistic version of that general law of gravitation, and this was also answered but a commentary on that is best incorporated in these Web pages along with the abstract of paper [1980b] on that subject, as published by the U.K. Institute of Physics. The relevant text of Physics Unified was a book version of the theory to be found in that very orthodox journal concerned with mathematical physics. It was thoroughly checked by several referees, in testimony of which there was an extensive review, because the referees needed some convincing. After all, here was a paper that argued a case in incontrovertible mathematics showing how easy it is to derive the Einstein General Relativity equation for motion under gravity, but by classical argument not involving relativistic principles.


  • 1983a

    1983a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Inst. Phys. Conf. Series No. 66: Session VI, Electrostatics 1983, Oxford, pp. 179-184 (1983).

    THE THUNDERBALL – AN ELECTROSTATIC PHENOMENON

    Abstract: A quasi-static electric displacement according to Maxwell’s theory is considered in a novel context, that of a forced radial electric strain centred on a source of energy. The resulting balancing charge displacement in enveloping matter may have transient stability and should exhibit ionization if gaseous. Potentially hazardous pockets of migrant electrostatic energy may well be created in the vicinity of electric discharges. Analysis shows the energy content to be within the range applicable to the thunderball, that is between 2×109
    J/m3 and 5×109 J/m3.

    Commentary: Although the thunderball phenomenon is a curiosity in science, the author has long regarded it as evidence of the ability to store energy in the aether in a form that is quite different from Maxwell wave displacement or storage by magnetic induction. Indeed, although the author did not realize it when the subject paper was written, this ‘aether spin’ feature manifested by the thunderball was destined to play an important role in future ‘free energy’ devices. Notable in this connection are the unipolar Faraday-disc-type generators, the N-machines which it seems can be used to pump energy from the vacuum medium, the electrostatic machine invented by Hyde and the Wimshurst-disc type machines that have been reported as functioning in a recluse community in Switzerland. Also, given that two aether spheres in counter-spin might, when brought into collision, release their energy spontaneously to shed heat, one may wonder if this occurs in ‘vortex turbine’ type machines which develop heat anomalously. The rotation one way of a tubular spiral rotor system through which water is pumped to progress clockwise and radially outwards to develop a jet which drives the rotor itself anti-clockwise does comprise two counter-rotating systems of matter closely intermeshed. If each entrains aether which shares that rotation in some measure one can envisage their shedding tiny spheres or vortices of aether in spin and counter-spin and so contemplate the occurrence of those collisions.


  • 1982h

    1982h

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Physics Letters, v. 92A, pp. 165-166 (1982).

    PROPOSED METHOD OF MEASURING FIRST-ORDER SPEED OF LIGHT ANISOTROPY

    Commentary: This paper does not contain the substantive section of the paper that passed referee scrutiny. The author made a serious error in amending the paper at the proof stage, thereby unfortunately excising a proposed test technique that, on reconsideration, should have been left unaltered. This paper, as published, was later challenged and the author did, of course, concede the error.


  • 1982g

    1982g

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Journal of Electrostatics, v. 13, pp. 71-80 (1982).

    CHARGE INDUCTION BY THERMAL RADIATION

    Abstract: It is argued that precision measurements which rely on the use of conductive housings for electrical screening may well be subject to spurious error owing to charge induction within the housing. If the momentum transfer processes associated with the
    absorption of thermal radiation act selectively upon electrons, a residual charge may be induced on surfaces internal to the housing and held in place by radiation pressure. The effects of such action upon the measurement of G is discussed in relation to anomalies
    reported in such experiments. The phenomenon is supported by the existence of the charge on the Earth’s surface. A method of testing for the presence of induced charge and eliminating its effects is indicated.

    Commentary: The author’s interest in this theme has developed as a peripheral question when the author wrote his 1972 book ‘Modern Aether Science’. It was later, when the author was at a conference on precision measurements in Gaithersburg in U.S.A., organized by the National Bureau of Standards, that he became aware of anomalies in the certain measurements of the constant of
    gravitation G. These involved tests performed in Faraday cages at different levels in a deep mine, the test mass inside the cage being assumed to be grounded electrically. The author’s theory of gravitation was not able to explain the variations of G that were reported and so the test itself warranted scrutiny. Later, when the author was at the University of Southampton he performed experiments which verified the charge induction explanation of the subject paper. These experimental findings were presented at a conference organized by the U.K. Institute of Physics and held in Oxford, but because the results challenged orthodox belief as to the effectiveness of the Faraday cage, the paper was not included in the reported proceedings.

    Special Note: The following author’s note was prepared shortly after the paper had issued and was communicated by the author to recipients of the offprints of the paper.

    “My attention has been drawn to the early measurements of the effect of temperature upon G, for example by L. Southerns, [Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A78, pp. 392-403 (1906)] and P. E. Shaw & N. Davy [Proc. R. Soc. Lond., 102, pp. 46-47 (1922)]. The measured effects are far less than might seem to be indicated by my paper.

    The reason for this is that these experiments involve heating the apparatus by processes other than those involving incident radiation and then making the measurements with the gravitating body radiating energy at a higher temperature but absorbing incident radiation from an environment still at room temperature.

    It is only the radiation absorbed by the layer of atoms at the surface that results in the charge induction below the surface and, though displacing charge and perhaps being reflected from there, it does not account for any residual surface charge effect. If the
    body is heated there is transfer of heat to the surface atoms by conduction and any radiation from the layer of atoms at the surface is directed equally inwards and outwards and produces a balanced radiation reaction force on this surface layer and so induces no surface charge. Half the radiation goes inwards and asserts a radiation pressure on the atoms below the surface and so causes charge displacement but no residual surface charge induction.

    Experiments of the kind suggested on page 78 of the author’s paper aimed at verifying this phenomenon seem, therefore, warranted notwithstanding the early studies of temperature effects on G.”


  • 1982f

    1982f

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Proceedings of ICSTA (International Conference on Space-Time Absoluteness) (International Publishers – East-West), pp. 27-31 (1982).

    THE CASE AGAINST RELATIVITY – AN EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

    Commentary: The author here put the case that Relativity would stand disproved by the measurement of the West-East motion of 350 m/s at 40o latitude and discussed the evidence in support and in relation to aether theory.


  • 1982e

    1982e

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 5, pp. 421-431 (1982).

    MIRROR REFLECTION EFFECTS IN LIGHT SPEED ANISOTROPY TESTS

    Abstract: Light speed anisotropy experiments give unreliable results if account is not taken of the effects of anisotropy upon mirror reflections in lasers used in the tests. The deviation of ray paths when reflected by mirrors moving relative to the optical reference frame cannot be ignored. In particular, anomalous results are to be expected if curved mirrors are used and full account is not taken of all reflections at mirror surfaces. This is discussed by detailed reference to a recent important experiment reported by Brillet and Hall. Though finding a null anisotropy in light speed in the cosmic reference frame, they nevertheless noted a significant and persistent spurious signal indicative of anisotropy in the laboratory frame. This signal may be a measure of the laboratory’s West-East motion owing to Earth rotation relative to a light reference frame coincidental with the Earth’s inertial frame. This conclusion has a speculative aspect because it may impose some qualification upon the universal validity of the Principle of Relativity. Although the effect has been apparent in other laser experiments, specific experiments aimed at measuring the Earth’s West-East motion, as opposed to angular speed of rotation, have yet to be performed. It is submitted that such tests are of fundamental importance.