Crab Nebula (M1) — supernova remnant imaged by Herschel and Hubble Space Telescopes

Category: Papers & Publications

Peer-reviewed papers and publications by Harold Aspden

Crab Nebula (M1), supernova remnant · ESA/Herschel/PACS; NASA, ESA & A. Loll/J. Hester (Arizona State Univ.) · NASA Image Library ↗

  • 1982d

    1982d

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 33, pp. 237-239 (1982).

    A THEORY OF PION LIFETIME

    Commentary: This paper extends the principles of the earlier paper on neutron lifetime [1981b] to deal with the stability of the pion. The theory gives a theoretical value of the pion lifetime in perfect accord with that measured.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1982d]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 237]

    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento   Vol. 33, N. 8   20 Febbraio 1982

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    A Theory of Pion Lifetime.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 9 Dicembre 1981)

    In a recent letter (1) it was shown how the neutron lifetime of some (918 ± 14) s could be explained to an accuracy within these limits of error. The principles applied were those of the author’s lattice-structured vacuum theory (2,3). According to this theory, muon energy quanta, as a pair of migrant point charges, move at random within cubic cells of lattice dimension:

    d = 72πe2/mc2 ,(1)

    but with a characteristic frequency

    ν = mc2/h .(2)

    Earlier, the model has been applied in explaining and evaluating the muon lifetime, giving a result in very good accord with observation (4). Note that e is the electron charge, m is the electron mass, c is the speed of light and h is Planck’s constant.

    The author is now able to report how this theory applies to the decay processes of the pion. The theoretical lifetime is found to be in full accord with measurement.

    Let μ+ and μ− denote the positive and negative members of a muon pair, respectively. We regard the pion as having a spherical charge form, satisfying the basic Thomson formula used throughout the author’s work and therefore having a radius given by

    2e2/3Mc2 ,(3)

    where M is the pion mass. Our object is then simply to determine the probability that the migrant muon charges will come close enough to the pion charge to satisfy a critical condition which triggers instability. We take this to arise when the muon charge overlaps the pion charge as the muon spreads from a point to assume the form set by the Thomson formula. The migration of the muon charge involves a process of expansion and decay from its point form following its repeated recreation at random positions at [p. 238] the frequency ν. Until decay of the pion is triggered, we expect the combined energy of the pion, the muon and their mutual Coulomb interaction to be conserved. Then, to formulate the condition for pion decay, we consider a muon appearing as a point charge in the near vicinity of the pion and immediately adjusting to its spherical form set by (3), but with Mc2 reduced by the amount of interaction energy. If this puts the muon charge into touching or overlapping relationship with the pion charge, then there will be instantaneous decay. The lifetime of the pion is then determined by the chance of this event occurring.

    (1) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 31, 383 (1981).

    (2) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, 41, 423 (1972).

    (3) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Nuovo Cimento A, 30, 235 (1975).

    (4) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980), p. 146.

    Suppose the pion charge is positive and denoted e and let x represent its fixed radius. Let the muon μ+ appear at a distance y from the centre of the pion and adjust to a radius set by the Thomson formula (3). Instead of using mass energy Mc2, now write P and Q as the energies of the pion and muon, respectively, in terms of the electron mass energy mc2. Then the condition for instability, or touching relationship of the Thomson spheres, is simply

    (P + Q)mc2 = (2/3)(e2/x) + (2/3)(e2/(y − x)) + e2/y .(4)

    Note that y must be greater than x. For the negative muon μ− the above expression holds with the last term negative.

    We seek to solve (4) to determine y. Then, by the same principles as were applied previously (1), the pion lifetime τ+ attributable to the effect of the migrant μ+ is given by

    τ+ = (1/ν)(3d3/(4πy3)) ,(5)

    which, from (1), (2) and (3) is

    τ+ = 3(108πN)3h/4πmc2 ,(6)

    where

    Nmc2 = 2e2/3y .(7)

    To solve (4), first write

    Pmc2 = 2e2/3x .(8)

    Then cancel this term from both sides of eq. (4) and convert the equation, using (7) and (8), into the form

    Q = N(P/(P − N) + 3/2) .(9)

    This can be solved, since it is a quadratic equation in N2, to obtain

    3N = (Q + 5P/2) ± √(Q + 5P/2)2 − 6PQ(10)

    or, if we consider the negative-muon solution,

    3N = −(Q − P/2) ± √(Q − P/2)2 + 6PQ .(11)

    [p. 239]

    Since y is greater than x, we can only have solutions for which N is less than P. Also, N must be positive. Thus, (10) gives N = 72.3 and (11) gives N = 172, with P = 273 and Q = 207, the known masses of the pion and muon.

    The value of τ+ is then found, from (6), to be 2.85·10−8 s, since h/mc2 is 8.09·10−21 s. The value of the lifetime τ−, attributable to the negative muon, is also found to be 38.4·10−8 s. These two lifetimes combine according to the relationship

    1/τ = 1/τ+ + 1/τ− .(12)

    to give the mean value of lifetime τ. Thus, we may deduce a value of τ of 2.65·10−8 s.

    Supplementary to the decay effects of the muons, owing to their presence close to, but outside of, the pion charge sphere, there is the likely decay situation resulting from the change of the point charges appearing within the pion radius x. This is found by substituting P for N in (6) to obtain, for each muon, a further τ component value of 153·10−8 s. This modifies the theoretical pion lifetime to 2.61·10−8 s or 2.56·10−8 s, according to whether one or both of the muons are effective, on entry into the pion charge, in causing its decay.

    The measured lifetime of the pion is reported (5) as being (2.551 ± 0.026)·10−8 s and so we do have excellent accord between theory and observation.

    Further research is now needed to extend the theory to other fundamental particle lifetimes. The neutron lifetime of the order of 103 s was explained by exploiting the dual probability of both the μ+ and the μ− acting in concert on separate quark elements of the neutron. The muon lifetime of the order of 2·10−6 s was explained, as in the partial case above, by regarding the migrant muons μ+ and μ− as entering the charge body of the muon undergoing decay. In contrast, the pion decay has emerged as a lifetime of the order of 2.6·10−8 s by considering the proximity effect of μ+ and μ− in triggering pion decay. We must therefore ask why there is no such effect in relation to muon decay. One can only speculate on this pending the outcome of further analysis on other particles. Possibly, a migrant muon can only induce decay of a particle of like energy by creating a situation not compatible with the energy conservation law and breaching an energy threshold. This was the basis on which the muon decay was evaluated (4). In the meantime, it is submitted that the ease with which the earlier theory has found application in explaining the pion lifetime is a most encouraging feature, enhancing the credibility of the author’s theoretical method.

    (5) R. D. Hill: Condon and Odishaw Handbook of Physics (New York, N. Y., 1967), p. 9.

  • 1982c

    1982c

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 33, pp. 481-484 (1982).

    THE CORRELATION OF THE ANOMALOUS g-FACTORS OF THE ELECTRON AND MUON

    Abstract: The resonant-cavity model by which the author has recently explained the anomalous electron g-factor has an alternative resonant mode suited to a less stable particle. When this is analysed it is found to give a result in full accord with the g-factor of the muon.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1982c]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 481]

    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento   Vol. 33, N. 15   10 Aprile 1982

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    The Correlation of the Anomalous g-Factors of the Electron and Muon.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 19 Gennaio 1982)

    Summary. – The resonant-cavity model by which the author has recently explained the anomalous electron g-factor has an alternative resonant mode suited to a less stable particle. When this is analysed it is found to give a result in full accord with the g-factor of the muon.

    In a recent paper (1) it has been shown that the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron (the g-factor) can be explained in terms of a model of the electron as a sphere of charge centred in a resonant cavity of radius governed by the Compton wave-length λC. The electric energy of the field outside this resonant cavity was presumed to be decoupled from the electron mass energy for spin motion confined well within the resonant cavity, with the result that the mass difference between normal motion and spin gives the g-factor

    g = 2/(1 − δ) ,(1)

    where

    δmc2 = e2/(2R) .(2)

    Here, m is the mass of the electron, c is the speed of light in vacuo, R is the cavity radius and e is the electron charge.

    The parameter δ is simply the proportion of the electron mass energy located outside the resonant-cavity radius. There is an inner spherical surface of radius r within the cavity and resonance involves the two-way radial traversal of the distance R–r at the speed of light c and at the Compton frequency. R–r is, therefore, half the Compton wave-length λC = h/mc, h being Planck’s constant.

    Thus the δ value given by (2) can be written as (1 − r/R)α/2π, because e2/2(R − r) is e2mc/h or (e2/hc)mc2 and α, the fine-structure constant, is 2πe2/hc.

    (1) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 33, 213 (1982).

    [p. 482]

    Note, therefore, that for an ideal system for which r is zero we can use a value of δ of α/2π and, from (1), develop a power series for g given by

    ½g = 1 + (α/2π) + (α/2π)2 + (α/2π)3 + … .(3)

    It is conventional to present values for the g-factor as such a power series of α/π.

    To proceed, the contribution in the referenced paper (1) was in showing that the radius r of the inner surface absorbing incident radiation has a value given by √3 times the Thomson radius of the electron, that is √3 times 2e2/3mc2. This gives a g-factor of

    ½g = 1 + (α/2π) + (¼ − 3−½)(α/π)2 + (⅔ − 3−½ + ⅛)(α/π)3 … .(4)

    The measured value of α−1 is 137.036 and this gives a ½g value of 1.00115965 in close agreement with the observed value of 1.001159652. Even so, the accuracy to which the electron g-factor is measured and the corresponding accuracy of measurement of α−1 are such that we know eq. (4) is slightly discrepant. The author has been examining the scope for modifying eq. (4) by effects significant only at the order of the last term. One proposal is that there is a cosmological factor affecting the spin mass of the electron and the normal mass in different ways (2). An alternative approach which is looking quite promising is to trace the effects of energy radiation upon the radius r, using different acceleration parameters in the Larmor formula. These different parameters relate to the different masses of the spin and normal state. However, whatever the outcome of this research, the more important consideration is the viability of the theory when applied to the muon g-factor. Accordingly, in this paper we will address this issue.

    For the electron the theory suggests that when an incident electromagnetic wave causes acceleration and so induces radiation, this radiation is seemingly intercepted across a section of radius r and continuously accumulated in the cavity pending release and onward radiation in quanta. Indeed, as shown in ref. (1), it is the balance of the Larmor radiation and the energy being absorbed from the incident wave that determines the radiation cross-section πr2. Now, the electron is a very stable particle and this suggests that the resonance condition may be an optimum one and slightly different from that applicable to an unstable particle such as the muon.

    Accordingly, we will consider below the cavity resonance criteria of two charges, one complying with the electron model already discussed and another in which the resonance mode is more complex and involves a resonant interaction with the charge itself, as opposed to the simple resonance between the radiation-reflecting surfaces of radius r and R, respectively.

    In fig. 1 an element of radiation travelling at speed c is shown to enter the cavity radius R and then oscillate within the cavity before leaving. The figure is drawn as a time chart and shows the radiation path between the outer cavity radius R and the centre 0 of the charge. The radiation is trapped in the system for a resonant period. In the simple electron model we have seen that the electron g-factor results from a resonance mode involving oscillations along a path confined between R and r. The frequency, being that associated with the Compton wave-length, is a natural frequency associated with electron annihilation and creation. It is interesting, therefore, to give the electron some physical character matching this oscillation frequency. However, when we consider other particles, we need to imagine not only the frequency changing, but the mode of oscillation corresponding to a less optimum resonant state and characteristic of a short-lived system.

    (2) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 32, 114 (1981).

    [p. 483]

    In the case of the electron, imagine that the radiant energy trapped in the resonant state between R and r is very much greater than the normal quanta received from incident electromagnetic radiation and so tends to remain in the confined cavity between r and R. Now consider the alternative situation, where there is negligible energy trapped within the cavity and any incident radiation that is trapped for a limited time ranges over the whole space within the cavity. Our analysis then allows us to say that the radius r must still play a role because it is the parameter determining the cross-section related to Larmor radiation by the charge when accelerated. It cannot be transparent to radiation. It must be opaque to incident radiation. Hence, as fig. 1 shows, the incident ray is reflected at r. Then the ray must return, as otherwise the cavity model would have no role to play. Suppose now that the ray penetrates the surface at r. It travels to the centre 0 and is either reflected or passes directly through to reach again the surface at r. This surface, in providing a reflecting boundary, must absorb radiation momentum. Alternatively it must receive and reflect as much radiation on its inner and outer surfaces. Guided by the electron model, we presume that this surface at r can withstand the radiation pressure from inward momentum, because the electron charge is at the centre and is the seat of the mass-energy, but we will assume that any outward radiation acting on the inner surface at r has to be at least balanced by the same radiation acting on its outer surface. This sets the model in its optimum radiant mode. For least trapped energy, each ray of radiation must execute, on a statistical average, as many oscillations between R and r as between r and 0. This is the pattern of oscillation shown in the figure.

    Fig. 1. Time chart of a ray of radiation entering the cavity at R, reflecting between R, r and the centre 0, and leaving
    Fig. 1.

    To the extent that the logic of the above argument is valid, we can say that there is but one resonant mode applicable to the short-lived particle. The muon is the only lepton having properties analogous to those of the electron. It is short lived. Hence the resonance mode depicted in the figure should guide us to its g-factor.

    We see from the figure that, whereas the resonance distance for the electron was 2(R − r), the resonance distance for the muon is simply 2(R + r). The Compton frequency for the muon is higher in proportion to muon mass and this reduces R in inverse proportion. Therefore, if r were zero for the electron and the muon, both would have the same g-factor in accordance with eq. (3). However, r is finite. It may be shown that it too reduces in inverse proportion to mass because, in the same accelerating field, the balance of Larmor radiation across the cross-section of radius r puts r2 proportional to f2, where f is acceleration. Since f is inversely proportional to mass, we can say that the g-factor of the muon must be exactly the same as that the electron would have if R + r were substituted for R − r.

    It is routine to present (3) as a power series in α/π with coefficients expressed in terms of r/R and it is a simple matter then to show that a reversal in sign of r changes the g-factor equally about the median value given by eq. (3), subject to error of the order of (α/2π)2(r/R)2. This is an error of one part in 1011. This applies without any [p. 484] dependence upon the actual value of r, provided it is inversely proportional to mass and is small enough for the error term just mentioned to be insignificant.

    To find the value of the muon g-factor given by this theory, we simply take double eq. (3) and subtract the measured electron g-factor. Note that eq. (3) gives, with α−1 as 137.0360, the ½g value of 1.0011627602. Taking the measured electron ½g as 1.0011596522, we then deduce the muon ½g as 1.0011658682. This compares with the measured value (3) of 1.001165895(27).

    It is submitted that this cavity resonance theory for explaining the g-factor of the electron is greatly strengthened by the simple manner in which it has now proved adaptable to account for the g-factor of the less stable muon.

    However, quantum electrodynamics has proved so successful in accounting also for other phenomena that this alternative, yet somewhat complementary approach, must remain a tentative proposition pending further development. Such development would need to address the Lamb shift. The remarkable feature of the theory presented is its inherent simplicity and the ease with which accurate g-factors can be obtained. It is noted that the initial theory dealing with the electron g-factor model was first published in 1977 (4). At that time it was mentioned that there was a curious symmetry in the disposition of the electron and muon g-factors relative to the simple point charge expression presented in eq. (3). It is only now that this symmetry has been understood as being due to the supplementary resonant mode in the same basic model.

    (3) E. R. Cohen and B. N. Taylor: J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, 2, 663 (1973).

    (4) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 16, 401 (1977).

    H. Aspden
    10 Aprile 1982
    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento
    Serie 2, Vol. 33, pag. 481-484

  • 1982b

    1982b

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 33, pp. 213-216 (1982).

    ELECTRON FORM AND ANOMALOUS ENERGY RADIATION

    Abstract: This paper correlates data from g-factor measurements and energy radiation theory, both indicating that the electron has a characteristic radius from which radiation is
    reflected of 1.1547 times the classical radius e2/mc2. More important, the paper resolves an
    existing anomaly by reconciling the energy radiation property of the accelerated electron and the non-radiation hypothesis required to account for inertia according to the law E = Mc2.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1982b]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 213]

    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento   Vol. 33, N. 8   20 Febbraio 1982

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    Electron Form and Anomalous Energy Radiation.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 2 Dicembre 1981)

    Summary. – This paper correlates data from g-factor measurements and energy radiation theory, both indicating that the electron has a characteristic radius from which radiation is reflected of 1.1547 times the classical radius e2/mc2. More important, the paper resolves an existing anomaly by reconciling the energy radiation property of the accelerated electron and the nonradiation hypothesis required to account for inertia according to the law E = Mc2.

    In the 1911 edition of his treatise on the theory of electricity and magnetism Jeans (1) summarizes the classical treatment of energy radiation by the accelerated electron. He draws attention to the need for new theory (quantum theory) to meet certain anomalies and we now well know that electrons in atoms observe quantum rules which preclude continuous energy radiation. However, the emergence of quantum theory left open the question of whether, under certain circumstances, the classical analysis leading, for example, to the Larmor energy radiation formula is, in fact, still valid.

    It may well be true that the quantum interactions are characteristic of group behaviour in a well-populated electron environment but that where electrons stand in isolation the more classical treatment holds. This, at least, was the note on which Jeans (1) ended his treatise. Also, however, there was a more fundamental and evolving aspect of Jeans’ treatment of the accelerated electron. He demonstrated how the classical electron of charge e, radius a and mass m could satisfy the formula

    mc2 = 2e2/3a ,(1)

    c being the speed of light in vacuo. Then, retaining this expression and considering how energy increases with a decreasing as the electron accelerates to higher speeds, this energy being the work done in assuring this speed change, Jeans argued that «the electron can be held in equilibrium at all velocities, while its motion conforms to the conservation of energy». Clearly, this is an important concept, since it touches upon the basic nature of inertia. Jeans noted that the Larmor radiation had been neglected [p. 214] from the analysis, thereby overlooking the possibility that energy conservation and charge motion avoiding energy radiation were the key criteria in governing the inertial property of the electron.

    (1) Sir James Jeans: The Mathematical Theory of Electricity and Magnetism, 5th Ed. (Cambridge, 1966), p. 591.

    In recent years a great deal has been written about the classical problem of radiation by accelerated charge (2-5) with authors having different viewpoints on whether there is any energy radiation at all. This author in particular (6) has argued that the derivation of the Larmor formula, if applied to the locality of the electron charge, will indicate zero energy radiation of the electron manifests an inertial property in accordance with the formula E = mc2, where E is the electric energy of the electron. Thus, if there is energy radiation, this must come from the accelerating field in some less direct way than via the body of the electron charge. Although this basic conclusion was first put forward by the author (7) in 1958, it is only now, with the discovery of a remarkable correlation of theoretical electron properties, that the process by which energy may transfer from the accelerating field to the radiation field can be understood. This is the subject of this paper.

    The anomalous magnetic moment of the electron (the g-factor) can be explained (8,9) in terms of a model of the electron as a sphere centred in a resonant cavity of radius governed by the Compton wave-length. The electric energy of the field outside this resonant cavity was presumed to be decoupled from the electron mass energy for spin motion confined well within the resonant cavity, with the result that the mass difference between normal motion and spin gives the g-factor:

    g = 2/(1 − δ) ,(2)

    where

    δ = 1/(Δ + 2π/α) ,(3)

    where Δ is a dimensionless parameter set by the radius of a spherical form which is opaque to radiation. The value of Δ was determined in ref. (8) and is 4/3½.

    Equation (3) may easily be derived, because the radial spacing in the resonant cavity of the electron field is half the Compton wave-length or h/2mc. Let r denote the radius of the electron cross-section opaque to radiation. Then the overall radius of the resonant cavity is

    r + h/2mc .(4)

    The electron-field energy outside this cavity radius is e2/(2r + h/mc), which is the factor δ of mc2, that is the portion of the total electron energy that does not contribute to spin. Hence the g-factor 2/(1 − δ) requires a δ value of e2/(2rmc2 + hc/e2) or 1/(Δ + hc/e2), where mc2 is Δe2/2r. Thus, with α as 2πe2/hc, we obtain (3). Argument in ref. (8) gave r [p. 215] as 3½ times the J. J. Thomson electron radius a in formula (1). Hence Δ is 4/3½, as already noted. However, Δ can also be determined empirically from the measurement of the electron g-factor as 2(1.00115965) and α−1 as 137.036. From (2) and (3), these data give Δ as 2.31, in close accord with the value 4/3½ of 2.3094. Thus, empirically, the radius r in terms of the usual classical formula for electron radius e2/mc2 is half 2.3094, that is 1.1547, subject to an uncertainty of about two parts in one thousand as the evaluation of Δ is critically dependent upon the last significant digit in the measured values of the g-factor and α−1.

    (2) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980). See bibliography references in chapt. 4.

    (3) J. Aharoni: The Special Theory of Relativity, 2nd. Ed. (Oxford, 1965), p. 186 and 198.

    (4) B. DeWitt and R. W. Brehme: Ann. Phys. (N. Y.), 9, 220 (1960).

    (5) J. Kapusta: Nuovo Cimento B, 31, 225 (1976).

    (6) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 15, 631 (1976).

    (7) H. Aspden: Proc. IEEE C, 105, 359 (1958).

    (8) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 16, 401 (1977).

    (9) H. Aspden: Lett. Nuovo Cimento, 32, 117 (1981).

    The conclusion we reach is that there is empirical evidence showing that the electron presents a spherical surface of radius r which is opaque to radiation, where r is given by

    r = (2/3½)e2/mc2 .(5)

    Now, this same cross-section should obstruct an electromagnetic wave propagating past an isolated electron and we see a basis for explaining how energy conveyed by the wave is transferred to the radiating-field system of the electron. This is very important if one considers the electron charge hypothetically as a hollow charge sphere. We know that there is no field energy within the body of the sphere. Hence, if it is accelerated there can be no energy radiation sourced within the charge. If we analyse the action at the charge surface itself it is found by the analysis of ref. (6) that notion of the charge to comply with the law E = mc2 also means no energy radiation sourced at the charge surface. Yet, were we not to consider the interaction of the accelerating electric field in the analysis, we would find energy radiation in the form of electric field disturbance given by

    dE/dt = e2f2/3c3 ,(6)

    where t is the time and f is the acceleration. Note that it is usual to recognize that as the disturbance develops into an electromagnetic wave in moving away from the electron charge the energy is augmented by an equal amount of magnetic field energy, so doubling (6) to give the usual Larmor formula.

    This, then, sets the problem. We know that remote from the electron and the local accelerating field action there is the energy radiated in measure set by (6), but that none comes from the charge itself. Also, we know that the electron presents an opaque area of πr2 to a propagating electromagnetic wave which may cause electron acceleration. Can we relate the two aspects of this situation?

    Regard the wave as a plane polarized wave propagating in vacuum. This facilitates the analysis and allows us to regard the dielectric constant as unity in the system of units adopted. Let the wave be a simple periodic wave with no harmonics and have an electric field intensity of magnitude V0. Thus the energy density V02/8π is carried by the wave at speed c. The energy blocked by the electron and so absorbed for reradiation is then πr2 times V02c/8π or, simply, V02cr2/8. From (5) this is an energy absorption rate of

    dE/dt = V02e4/6m2c3 .(7)

    Note then that the electron is subject to an acceleration of amplitude proportional to V0. They are related by the factor e/m. The mean value of f2 is, as we know from analysis of periodic signals, precisely half of the square of the acceleration amplitude. [p. 216] Thus f2 is ½(e/m)2V02. Putting this in (7), we obtain the quite remarkable result that it is identical to (6). The energy supplied by the advancing wave causing electron acceleration is precisely the amount of energy that the author’s analysis (6) denied from being radiated from the charge sphere itself on the basis of the E = mc2 formula. This means that the conservative energy property of charge by which its motion is caused to satisfy E = mc2, thereby accounting for its inertia, does not deny the Larmor formula its role in energy radiation theory.

    This is an interesting correlation, because there is a common indication, both from g-factor measurements and from the theory of electron inertia, that the electron has a cross-section opaque to radiation and of radius 3½ times the Thomson electron radius 2e2/3mc2. The logical interpretation is that the energy radiation attributable to accelerated charge is sourced in the waves which impact the electron and that the energy balance requires the electron to present a spherical surface at which this radiation can be presumed to be reflected.

    There are other implications from the analysis. One is that, although magnetic energy is carried along with a wave and can be absorbed with the electric energy, the acceleration of an electron does not generate magnetic disturbances in the immediate vicinity of the electron charge. Thus the electric energy radiated is the total energy radiated in this region, meaning that as the disturbance spreads over a larger range the energy is then shared with magnetic energy as the normal wave pattern develops in the radiation. This needs further study, but it conforms with a feature proposed elsewhere by the author (10) that the electromagnetic reference frame may have a lattice structure of dimensional order h/mc. This would imply that normal electromagnetic fields effects, even in a classically-based theory, are not to be expected in the immediate region of the electron charge, this being several hundred times smaller. This is also consistent with the proposition that electromagnetic reaction effects are associated with the mutual and collective behaviour of charge.

    Another aspect worth studying is the extent to which the nonquantum energy radiation process implied by Larmor radiation may manifest itslef in Nature. It may have relevance in rarefied regions where charges stand in isolation and so have significance in cosmology. So far as dense matter is concerned, one can understand why the electrons in an atom do not act in concert to assure overall radiation of energy, bearing in mind that they are regulated by the Schroedinger equation so as to belong to an integral unit comprising also the heavy atomic nucleus. This unit is electrically neutral overall and so no overall acceleration can occur. If, however, the atom is ionized, then, as with the electron in isolation, some energy radiation is to be expected. The phenomenon of Larmor radiation may, in the end, prove to be quite independent of the normal quantum processes by which energy is shed by electromagnetic waves in units associated with the photon.

    (10) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, 41, 423 (1972).

    H. Aspden
    20 Febbraio 1982
    Lettere al Nuovo Cimento
    Serie 2, Vol. 33, pag. 213-216

  • 1982a

    1982a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Wireless World, v. 88, pp. 37-39 (1982).

    THE ETHER – AN ASSESSMENT

    Commentary: This article is a very important component in the author’s efforts to convince physicists that they need to accept the existence of the aether. The article deals with the major problem confronting aether theory, namely the issue of its non-dispersion property. It is vital to keep in mind that any dynamic system has to have inertial balance. One simply cannot have waves as electric charge suffering lateral displacement as oscillations propagate through space and not have something that oscillates in counterbalance. Maxwell’s theory prescribes electric wave displacement but offers no inertial balance.

    In this article, the author reminds those who understand the physics of propagating signals along a long distance telegraph cable and Heaviside distortionless line solution. The counterpart in the aether is the response of the muon energy sea in providing the dynamic counterbalance. It is the same response that accounts for its adaptation to the Earth’s motion in a way that precludes sensing of linear motion by optical techniques.

    If the aether could distort electromagnetic waves that are being propagated through it then it must absorb energy and so retard the wave. On the other hand, there is a way in which what we see as empty space can obstruct an electromagnetic wave. This is by
    attempting to create matter in the form of protons. Matter, even if of transient existence, can affect the passage of a wave. Here, however, our dual wave response, which involves the aether lattice oscillations being kept in dynamic balance by a muon field, is affected because one wave is attenuated in amplitude more than the other. This means that there is a frequency distortion that corresponds with the loss of frequency with distance that is
    formulated as the Hubble constant. See [1984e]. The subject article was founded on this interpretation of the aether and it is therefore quite important in promulgating knowledge concerning the author’s theory.


  • 1981e

    1981e

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Physics Letters, v. 85A, pp. 411-414 (1981).

    LASER INTERFEROMETRY EXPERIMENTS ON LIGHT-SPEED ANISOTROPY

    Abstract: Although gas lasers provide highly coherent light sources useful in interferometry experiments, their application to the measurement of light-speed anisotropy can produce inconclusive results unless reflection effects at mirror surfaces are taken fully into account. A recent experiment by Brillet and Hall is discussed and shown to indicate a local anisotropy due solely to Earth rotation.

    Commentary: The author was here directing attention to the sensing the Earth’s west-east speed, as opposed to rotation, that was evident in the Brillet and Hall experiment. Though quoted as a test for Einstein’s theory, owing to the failure to sense motion through
    space at a cosmic speed, the sensing of actual speed, owing to linear motion relative to the inertial frame, invalidates the theory of relativity. The author later underlined the point made in this paper by the more extensive analysis presented in reference [1982e].


  • 1981d

    1981d

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in The Journal of Meteorology UK, v. 6, pp. 258-260 (1981).

    THE ENIGMA OF BALL LIGHTNING

    Commentary: This short paper discusses the phenomenon of ball lightning within aircraft and the reported sightings of luminous balls leaving the body of the aircraft and hovering on the wings. The author stresses that such evidence shows that the balls are not quasi-stable objects comprising nothing other than ionized air. There has to be an underlying energy medium in spin that develops an electric or magnetic attraction holding the bounding sphere to the wing.


  • 1981c

    1981c

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 32, pp. 114-116 (1981).

    THE ANOMALOUS MAGNETIC MOMENT OF THE ELECTRON

    Commentary: This is one of many papers by which the author pursued the task of urging for acceptance of the author’s theory of the electron g-factor. When one mentions the anomalous electron g-factor to physicists they immediately think of QED and its remarkably
    precise confirmation of the physics of such great scientists as Dirac and Feynman. Yet their emphasis is on the divergence of that factor from the value 2.

    The underlying issue that matters to this author is the explanation of why ferromagnetic reaction measurements of the ratio of magnetic moment to angular momentum correspond to e/mc and not e/2mc of the electron. The scientific world at large is less concerned with this factor of 2, which is seen as a ‘spin’ property that is really quite
    vague, and relies heavily on the minor correction which alters 2 by a little more than one part in one thousand.

    The author, however, has had to take his factor-of-two reasoning [1978c], concerning the form and reacting properties of the electron, into that province dominated by QED and compete with the precision derivations of QED in the hope that physicists might listen to the case for believing in a half-field reacting aether environment that inherently gives basis for the g-factor of 2. This is essential if we are to understand how the aether can feed energy to us via its action is sustaining the quantized motion of atomic electrons in a polarized ferromagnet. The subject paper discusses how the author’s theory is a contender with QED at the level of 40 parts in 1012 for the anomalous component of the electron g-factor.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1981c]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 114]

    LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO   VOL. 32, N. 4   26 Settembre 1981

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    The Anomalous Magnetic Moment of the Electron.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd., Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 20 Luglio 1981)

    In 1975 the author (1) presented a heuristic method by which the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron could be evaluated. The model portrayed the electron as a spherical charge of finite radius determined by the J. J. Thomson classical formula and centred in a resonant cavity of radius governed by the Compton wave-length. The electric-field energy outside this resonant cavity was presumed to be decoupled from the electron mass energy for spin motion confined well within the resonant cavity with the result that the mass difference between normal motion and spin gives the –gfactor:

    g = 2/(1 − δ) ,(1)

    where

    δ = 1/(2πα−1 + 4/31/2) .(2)

    The expression 4/31/2 arises from the finite size of the electron. It would be zero for a point charge.

    The above formulation is extremely simple, as is the theory from which it is derived. The value of g can be derived directly from a knowledge of α−1, α being the fine-structure constant. Independently, in 1972 the author (2), collaborating with Dr. Eagles of the National Standard Laboratory in Australia, presented a method of deriving α−1 from first principles. The analysis involved a structured model of the vacuum state and accounted for the familiar E = hν radiation law. A critical determination of a odd integral ratio applicable to two fundamental particles required to give a minimum energy state gave uniquely the quantity 1843 and this appears in the value of α−1 presented in the paper. It also appears for the same physical reasons in a later paper (3) presenting a theoretical derivation of the proton-electron mass ratio. The formula [p. 115] for α−1 is

    (1) H. Aspden: Int. J. Theor. Phys., 16, 401 (1977).

    (2) H. Aspden and D. E. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, 41, 423 (1972).

    (3) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Nuovo Cimento A, 30, 235 (1975).

    α−1 = 108π(8/1843)1/6 .(3)

    This gives a value of α−1 of 137.0359148 and, although experimental data suggest that the true value of α−1 may be higher than this by up to one part per million, recent direct measurements of h/e2 by a new technique using quantized Hall resistance phenomena are indicating lower values. For example Braun, Staben and von Klitzing (4) measure α−1 as 137.03592 ± 0.00018.

    Encouraged by this the author has found it of interest to combine the theoretical value of the fine-structure constant and the theoretical value of the g-factor to obtain a purely theoretical value for this electron g quantity. The result obtained from eqs. (1), (2) and (3) is

    g = 2(1.001 159 646 913) .(4)

    Now, digressing a little into the field of cosmology, the author has been struck by the remarkable coincidence that the kinetic energy possessed by the Sun owing to its motion at a speed equal to the measured anisotropy of cosmic background radiation, some 390 km/s, is of precisely the same order as that available from the gravitational coalescence of dispersed matter in forming the Sun. The gravitational potential of the Sun is −2.3·1048 ergs. In contrast, the kinetic energy is 1.5·1048 ergs attributable to the Sun’s translational cosmic motion relative to the preferred frame of the cosmic background. Additionally the Sun has thermal energy derived internally from its nuclear sources. However, the coincidental connection between these two large energy quantities has led the author (5) to speculate on the hypothesis that the minimum energy state of any mass is that which ensures that at least its share of gravitational potential energy is retained by its kinetic behaviour.

    The above hypothesis is only tenable if we can discount gravitational interaction on a galactic scale, since the gravitational potential of the Sun’s interaction with the rest of the universe outweighs by far its self-interaction. Proceeding tentatively on this basis, it is suggested that a particle of mass m will share equally with other interacting mass, principally the masses of the Earth and the Sun for m on Earth, the mutual gravitational potential energy involving m.

    The relevant gravitational potential is given by

    G(Ms/Ra + Me/Re) ,(5)

    where G is the constant of gravitation 6.67·10−8, Ms is the solar mass 1.989·1033, Ra is the astronomical unit 1.496·1013, Me is the Earth mass 5.977·1027 and Re is the Earth radius 6.378·108, all in c.g.s. units. The potential given by (5) is 9.493·1012. Now unit mass will, by the hypothesis presented, have a residual kinetic energy of half this quantity and the mass-equivalent of this, found by dividing by c2, is 5.281·10−9. If this additional energy augments the normal electron mass but does not add to the spin mass, the result will be an increase in the g-factor by this gravitational factor 5.281·10−9. Multiplying (4) by this and adding to (4) gives

    g = 2(1.001 159 652 200) .(6)

    (4) E. Braun, E. Staben and K. von Klitzing: PTB-Mitt., 90, 350 (1980).

    (5) H. Aspden: Spec. Sci. Tech., 3, 114 (1980).

    [p. 116]

    When this is compared with the most recent experimental result for g reported by Van Dyck (6), we find the remarkable result that the comparison is perfect. The experimental value of the anomalous factor a = (g − 2)/2 is 1 159 652 200(40)·10−12 for the electron.

    The corresponding latest, but very preliminary QED value, reported at the recent conference on Precision Measurement and Fundamental Constants held at the U.S. National Bureau of Standards is 1 159 652 504(182). As its authors’ note (7), the discrepancy between QED theory and experiment for the electron g-factor is ten times as large as the experimental error of the basic measurement. The complexity of QED calculations is also bewildering, bearing in mind that calculation based on 891 Feynman diagrams was needed to derive the eighth-order QED contribution. Hence the simple derivation of the very accurate result presented in (6) does deserve consideration on its merits.

    Very probably the adoption of a favoured value for α will govern the situation. If α−1 were reduced below the value recommended by Williams and Olsen (8), this being 137.03563(15) and used in the above QED analysis, then this would imply further increase in the QED value and a greater departure between theory and experiment. Accordingly, in view of the very remarkable success of QED in its application to other quantities, one must except upward rather than downward revision of recommended α−1 values. However, should we see the favoured experimental value of α−1 diminish, then QED theory may be in difficulty and the heuristic treatment presented in this work may well justify closer scrutiny. Meanwhile, it is hoped that the reader will keep this alternative approach to QED in mind.

    (6) R. S. Van Dyck jr.: Bull. Am. Phys. Soc., 24, 758 (1979).

    (7) T. Kinoshita and W. B. Lindquist: paper submitted to Second International Conference on Precision Measurement and Fundamental Constants, National Bureau of Standards, U.S.A., June 8-12, 1981.

    (8) E. R. Williams and P. T. Olsen: Phys. Rev. Lett., 42, 1575 (1979).

  • 1981b

    1981b

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, v. 31, pp. 383-384 (1981).

    A THEORY OF NEUTRON LIFETIME

    Commentary: This is the first of a series of papers by which the author shows the power of the theory in explaining particle lifetime. The lifetime of the mu-meson is important to those who advocate Einstein’s theory and in the 1980 book ‘Physics Unified’ (p. 146) the author had shown how this lifetime could be deduced from his aether theory. That led on in that text to the explanation of how the lifetime changed when the mu-meson was in motion, without involving the mysterious ‘time dilation’ philosophy.

    By 1981 the author had advanced further to show how the same theory
    could explain neutron lifetime. The problem was that the measured neutron lifetime then reported was about 3% higher than the value established later. Indeed, the author was uncertain in 1981 as to which combination of nucleon energies was involved at the decay
    trigger threshold. This was clarified in the author’s main paper on the neutron [1986d] and it was gratifying to finding that the threshold condition was that of a proton-antiproton pair in the most
    likely of the possible combinations.


    To see the full text of this paper as presented in pdf format press: [1981b]


    Full text of the paper (transcribed from the PDF)

    Transcribed from the scanned pages of the printed paper. [p. N] marks where each printed page begins; figures are cut from the scans. The PDF above is the original.

    [p. 383]

    LETTERE AL NUOVO CIMENTO   VOL. 31, N. 11   11 Luglio 1981

    The author has obtained the permission of the copyright owner Societa Italiana di Fisica to publish this paper here in PDF format.

    A Theory of Neutron Lifetime.

    H. Aspden

    IBM United Kingdom Ltd, Hursley Laboratories – Winchester, England

    (ricevuto il 5 Maggio 1981)

    In an earlier letter (1) presenting a derivation of the fine-structure constant it was suggested that space may have properties associated with a characteristic cubic-cell volume of lattice dimension d = 72πe2/mec2, a characteristic frequency ν = mec2/h and a characteristic threshold energy quantum (here denoted Tmec2) which analysis gave as the combined energy of 1843 electrons. This led to a value of α−1 of

    108π(8/1843)1/6 = 137.035915 .(1)

    Above, e is the electron charge, me the electron mass, c the speed of light in vacuo and h is Planck’s constant. α is the fine-structure constant 2πe2/hc.

    The theory also indicated that space may well be populated by energy quanta, equivalent to having a muon pair in each cell. In 1975 this model, based on a theoretical evaluation of this double-muon energy quantum, was applied to the exact derivation of the proton/electron mass ratio (2). Recently, in 1980, by regarding these muon energy quanta as a pair of point charges migrating within a cell at random at the frequency ν, the model has found further application in explaining and evaluating the muon lifetime, also in very good accord with observation (3).

    In this letter it is shown how these basic ideas may also have relevance to the decay processes of the neutron.

    We regard the neutron as having two quarklike constituents, of charges −e and +e, respectively. The negative charge is deemed to be an electron and the positive-charge component, denoted N+, is taken to contain the residue of the neutron energy, denoted Nmec2, where N is of the order of 1838.

    Our object is simply to determine the probability that the migrant point charge muon pair will come close enough to these neutron constituents to satisfy the following two conditions simultaneously. Let μ denote the muon energy in terms of electron mass energy units and μ+, μ− denote the positive and negative members of the muon pair, respectively.

    Then firstly, μ+ must be close enough to the electron to create an unstable situation. As we may see from ref. (2), the electron has, according to the Thomson formula, a [p. 384] radius given by (2/3)e2/mec2 and we can suppose that the charge μ+ will, on entering the spherical volume associated with the electron charge, put the electron in a state conducive to escape from the neutron complex and therefore conducive to decay.

    (1) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Phys. Lett. A, 41, 423 (1972).

    (2) H. Aspden and D. M. Eagles: Nuovo Cimento A, 30, 235 (1975).

    (3) H. Aspden: Physics Unified (Southampton, 1980), p. 146.

    Secondly, simultaneously with the above condition, μ− must come close enough to N+, with total energy conserved, to trigger an increase of the energy of μ− to the threshold level Tmec2. Thus, at a separation distance x, we have

    (μ + N)mec2 = (T + N)mec2 − e2/x .(2)

    Here the negative Coulomb interaction energy component has been deployed to augment the energy of point charge. Alternatively, we could consider the situation where both the point charge and N+ are driven to the threshold limit

    (μ + N)mec2 = (T + T)mec2 − e2/y ,(3)

    where y is the critical separation distance.

    To find the neutron lifetime, we now calculate the frequency at which these two conditions are met simultaneously, bearing in mind that μ− and μ+ occupy new random positions within a cell of volume d3, ν times per second. Evidently, the lifetime τ of the neutron for condition (2) is

    τ = (1/ν)(3d3/4πx3)(3d3/4πz3) ,(4)

    where z is the electron radius (3/2)e2/mec2. From (2) x is e2/(T − μ)mec2. Also, d = 72πe2/mec2 and ν = mec2/h. Thus τ becomes

    τ = (9/16π2)(1.5)3(72π)6(T − μ)3h/mec2 .(5)

    Upon evaluation ν−1 is 8.09·10−21 s and we have seen that T is 1843. μ is 207. These data give

    τ = 913 s .(6)

    Had we used alternative condition (3), then the T − μ term in (5) would be replaced by 2T − N − μ, with N as 1838. This gives a value

    τ = 921 s .(7)

    These alternative values compare with the observed neutron lifetime of (918 ± 14) s.

    Further research is now needed in order to develop this approach to neutron decay. We need, for example, to explain why, in (2), it is the muon point charge energy that adjusts with the interaction to the exclusion of N+, or why, in (3), its the muon point charge energy that adjusts first to the T threshold before N+ also adjusts to this same threshold. In choosing between (2) and (3) we must favour (3) because it is N+ that is to decay into a proton and this is more likely to occur if N+ is excited beyond a critical threshold. Also, there is need for more understanding of the process governing the other condition and the electron role in decay. These are matters which can perhaps be explored with some confidence in the light of the very close theoretical values of neutron decay time available from the technique presented.

  • 1981a

    1981a

    The following is a paper by H. Aspden published in Speculations in Science and Technology, v. 4, pp. 314-316 (1981).

    ATMOSPHERIC ELECTRIC FIELD INDUCTION

    Abstract: The origin of the Earth’s electric field is discussed and shown to be a consequence of the selective absorption of solar primary and secondary radiation by electrons in the
    substance of the Earth’s surface and atmosphere.

    Commentary: This paper reiterates the viewpoint expressed by the author on this subject in his 1972 book ‘Modern Aether Science’.


  • 1980e

    1980e

    The following is a reference to a book by H. Aspden published by Sabberton Publications in 1980.

    PHYSICS UNIFIED

    This book comprises 206 pages. It is an account, updated to the year 1980, of Dr. Aspden’s theory which is the subject of these web pages. However, being in book form it offers the reader a style of presentation, including the formal mathematics involved, not easily presented by the Internet facility.

    Its main thrust is to show how aether theory can provide the unification of gravitation and electromagnetism long sought by theoretical physicists.

    As with the author’s previous books it was published at a time when there had been a major step forward in the development of the theory.
    The 1980 landmark was the breakthrough in getting a paper [1980b] accepted for publication by the U.K. Institute of Physics, penetrating the resistance of their referee system, a paper which dared to say, indeed dared to show, that the Einstein formula for the anomalous perihelion advance of the planet Mercury could be derived by simple theory having classical foundation and not in any way being dependent upon the Einstein doctrine.

    That features in pp. 17-22 of the book. Acceptance of that paper plus some others at that time was a stimulus for writing this new work.

    The book overall is described on its back cover and the following is a summary:

    Perhaps the greatest challenge in 20th century physics is that of discovering how electromagnetism and gravitation can be embraced by a unified theory compatible with Einstein’s formulae for the energy-mass relationship, mass increase with speed and the rate of advance of a planet’s perihelion. In this work Dr. Aspden shows how this unification emerges from a straightforward analysis of energy deployment in particle interaction, confirming the intuitive prediction of Oliver Heaviside (1893) as later endorsed by Leon Brillouin (1970). However, an essential further step in Dr. Aspden’s thesis is the recognition that energy considerations are more fundamental than field concepts. A law of electrodynamics is derived which was, in fact, first suggested empirically by Maxwell and then discarded in favour of one deducible from his field equations.

    The unified theory based upon this new law of electrodynamics should have practical application since it can account for anomalies in the electron-ion energy transfer process currently observed in experiments relating to fusion power. Its appeal to the physicists will be the intriguing connection between the properties of elementary particles and the structured character of the vacuum medium, allowing exact theoretical evaluation of several fundamental physical constants.

    In its broader sense the work constitutes a general unification by providing a new insight into the processes of creation of the solar system. The event of the sun’s creation is shown to result from the onset of the gravitational state as the vacuum became ordered, a phenomenon analogous with the onset of the ferromagnetic state as a ferromagnetic crystal cools below the Curie temperature.

    Author’s note: July 15, 2002:

    This book is still in print but only in its hardback version. Less than one hundred copies remain to be sold. Anyone interested is urged to order a copy now, before stocks are exhausted, either from a bookseller or directly from the publishers: Sabberton Publications. E-Mail address: sabberton@energyscience.co.uk. For order information see www.energyscience.co.uk/books.htm

    A further note by the author:

    The reference to Clerk Maxwell above needs a little qualification. He did consider alternative formulations of the law of electrodynamics, several being consistent with empirical evidence. One of those laws, presented in quarternian formulation, had the form needed to conform with what was required by a law of gravitation. All the laws depended upon the uncertain factor Q, which could not be determined in Maxwell’s time owing to lack of further experimental evidence, not forthcoming until the Trouton-Noble experiment was reported in 1903. Maxwell opted for that factor Q being +1, whereas the factor -1 would have been the correct factor. It depends upon whether one accepts that an out-of-balance couple or an out-of-balance force exists in a general two-charge interaction situation. Sadly, Lorentz in 1904 and then Einstein in 1905 got into the act and, literally, messed things up! My role therefore has been my stalwart and voluntary effort to clean up the mess, but, again sadly, the physics community would rather drift along without paying attention to what I say and without even looking back to see if they have gone adrift in their blind acceptance of Einstein’s doctrines.


    Harold Aspden